The problem isn't the screens or buttons. It's the user experience. If you put feature used very often in a place that you have to click, 3/4 times to reach - that's bad UX. If you have buttons upon buttons to dial in every little thing creating this ugly cluster of buttons and switches that are hard to pick up on - that's bad UX. If a car brings excellent UX, be with buttons or screens, people wouldn't complain so much.
@AI.Overlord.X2 минут бұрын
The people who say they prefer buttons, drive old cars and cant afford newer ones with screens. They use the button excuse so people dont find out that theyre poor. They want everyone to think they drive an old car out of preference.
@vipermoon_2 минут бұрын
Who is this person you're talking about? Doug? Are there really people taking it that far? The thing you said at the end about what you do want real buttons for, that is what I hear the vast majority of car enthusiasts asking for
@hbrent902 минут бұрын
Even airplanes have and are making a tremendous revolution. Small planes now can be retrofitted with glass cockpits that largely get rid of all buttons in favor of screens. Below is a link about the evolution of 737 cockpits, which tell the same story. kzread.info/dash/bejne/dmiip5uOm5TKis4.html
@FernandoTRA3 минут бұрын
Would much rather have an extended cab with regular sized bed than 4 doors and a small bed.
@alfher49964 минут бұрын
To expensive not thanks
@thebananaclub5 минут бұрын
Relying on a screen for all functions is also not the way. Screens are less reliable than buttons and certain functions should be limited to buttons. Screens could break or get dead zones. The cost of a new screen or headunit will be thousands. Climate controls, radio, seats, and windows should be left to buttons. Any extra applications could be on a screen.
@nbaumg6 минут бұрын
this was such a pointless video. you made up a bad argument no one was making to argue against.
@stepladder32577 минут бұрын
i like me a good screen with carplay with assist cameras, but pls don't make climate controls touch screen
@yeahitskimmel7 минут бұрын
Screens AND buttons, not or. Can't have enough buttons for all the settings in the menus but it would be cool if we got user programmable hot keys you'd set like FM stations
@TheNoerdy7 минут бұрын
Naw screw this. I feel like driving a car that looks like a cockpit is cool. There is a reason why planes don't use touch screens...
@AI.Overlord.X8 минут бұрын
Screens > buttons And that's why Tesla is the best car ever made.
@milhousemeets63438 минут бұрын
Tesla has voice commands, so whatever you need can be done through voice command or it’ll take you to the screen where it can be adjusted.
@thndr_546810 минут бұрын
Arguing that cars without screens would look like a pilot's cabin is so stupid. You've reviewed cars from the 90s haven't you? Do those cars have button all the way back on the roof? Did you just forget every other car you've reviewed? This is such a dumb video that misses the entire point.
@blackeye333612 минут бұрын
Yea but some cars like the new mustang dont need a huge touch screen ruins the look and vibe some do
@FernandoTRA12 минут бұрын
The built-in compressor does not use bed space. It's inside the wall space. It is an excellent feature that I would have loved when I worked at the ranch.
@dl527012 минут бұрын
justr drove a 1993 BMW 850Ci in Argentina. Such an amazingly cool car. Always loved the E31. Suspension's best left in S mode, in K there is a lot of body roll. Automatic is a bit lazy, but that's a 30 year old we're talking about, There is an 850CSi here as well, I will try it later...
@djmaciiii13 минут бұрын
The new base model jeep 2 door wrangler, has a 12" screen. It did not need it last year, but I guess it needs it this year. It also looks stupid.
@MQZ1713 минут бұрын
Gears selection should always be physical, thats it.
@adrianwilliamson686114 минут бұрын
There are too too too many 'features'...that is the problem. I think Doug cant see the forest because of the trees.
@00dfm0014 минут бұрын
I actually hate the Tesla extreme minimalism.
@jorgecabrera708814 минут бұрын
only the real enthusiasts will understand
@killacamfoo14 минут бұрын
Insanely dangerous fad.
@Dougie196915 минут бұрын
I just took a dump I'm selling it for a hundred grand It's one of a kind Only one like it in the world Follow me for more entrepreneur skills PS Demuro did you seriously just give this a 9 in cool factor ??? How disappointing and just......WOW
@FernandoTRA16 минут бұрын
The exhaust pipe under the rear axle? Maybe that's something new.
@jeinarsantos612516 минут бұрын
Me with my '97 base model Corolla watching this: "Yeah......okay" 🙃
@sputumtube16 минут бұрын
Is there an argument to say that screens are unsafe? Distracting whilst on the move? Would you watch Judge Judy (etc) while driving? Not so different is it? They also look awful. That clip of the Tesla interior was inescapably dull. Also, what if the screen fails? You then lose every function the vehicle has to offer!
@imobimnbago17 минут бұрын
Most people arent asking to make the horn sound selector a button. They just want basic controls to have buttons. It seems you went out of your way on this one to argue against a position no one is acutally taking.
@billgaber428218 минут бұрын
Consider that many people are wearing gloves/mittens when they get into the vehicle. Also, switches are moving parts so they fail both mechanically and electrically.
@crktritual19 минут бұрын
Chad Buttons vs virgin screen
@85priesty20 минут бұрын
Why is it illegal to use your phone, when it's more difficult to use a touch screen in a car. It's cheaper to make screens. Than physical buttons... the screens are good for the "features" but the traditional things, like air-conditioning and audio controls should be buttons... Edit: Turns out I'm on the same page as Doug. But I stiĺl don't understand that it is getting to the point that there's no difference between using your phone and trying to navigate through screens. Admittedly, I love the fact that I can dial phone numbers with the enormous number of buttons in my 15 year old Volvo...compared to the new Hyundai EV...it's probably just me hurtling towards 40, but it's fun...even though the Bluetooth is horrendous. But it has a CD player, amazing sound and the best seats ever, when the transmission dies as it definitely will... I'll remove the seats and turn them into a lounge suite...haha,
@firemanjeff91121 минут бұрын
There is nothing wrong with wanting a mostly analog car. But I guess Doug gets to decide the "proper" button to screen ratio. As for me, I like a back up camera and GPS. I have no other use for a screen or any of the features inside of it.
@douglasquaid254821 минут бұрын
Regular people are stupid, so that means touchscreens are stupid. Case closed.
@Akumobrotha22 минут бұрын
This trend will go away. Just like four bangers in trucks. Electric will go away. 5 years and we will be back to normal. But the screens will stay
@macxgeek22 минут бұрын
Absolutely ridiculous! At the very least, incorporate the touch screen into the dash. So many new cars have it sticking up above the dash, looks so stupid
@SolarZ6823 минут бұрын
screens are cheaper? Yes. Will auto makers decrease the prices of cars Because screens are cheaper ?No. Idiotic take and who TF wants all buttons no screens ? litteraly nobody thinks that nobody said that ever
@dhalsim-123 минут бұрын
They should ease off with screens because the majority of features on modern cars are unneeded toys. They might be interesting to play with for a week or so but after that who bothers? Most people in reality only use the climate controls and the stereo 95% of the time. A clever car manufacturer would be looking to simplify cars/ engines and make them easier to work on. They'd be tapping into a large market of people who'd like that.
@mrsharps23 минут бұрын
‘… and you probably buy used anyway!’ Shots fired.
@andrewb32524 минут бұрын
My 22 Civic Si has exactly 10 buttons and looks clean and uncluttered. This is the correct amount.
@Andrew-zv4fm25 минут бұрын
I think Doug is just about wrong on every point he made. Ok, heated and ventilated seats and HVAC systems need to be adjusted all the time and physical buttons are necessary. As for everything she mentioned, that could all be done with a knob and a touch pad. The issue with screens: It depends on where the screen is placed. If it easily falls to hand then that is great. If it doesn't fall to your hand then that is an issue. Look at the Model Y and look at the new C-Class. The Model Y I have to reach to use the screen and with the C-Class I don't. The best system of physical buttons and screen was with BMW and Mercedes. The screen falls to your eye level and you use a knob or touch pad to adjust the radio. Even if the C and S Class's you need to look down at the screen to see what you are doing with the HVAC system or what station you are listening to. The auto industry gave us screens without asking us. Like I said, Doug is wrong.
@jacobjackson492832 минут бұрын
Insane how many people clearly didn't watch the video
@Lumber_Jack32 минут бұрын
The CEOs of Palm, Nokia, Blackberry, Motorola, etc all said the iPhone was doomed because it only had a touchscreen and did away with a hardware keyboard. Didn't work out too well for those guys...
@eastern_ocelot33 минут бұрын
Is this a real video/argument, this is not a serious discussion, a health combination of screens and buttons is wanted.
@a9entjones34 минут бұрын
I love Uncle Doug's Rocking Chair
@undreal739834 минут бұрын
I hope that trophy says "DADDY DOUG" on it
@truthserum531034 минут бұрын
Doug's the kinda guy to control his wife and kids thru a screen.
@barrettpickett560335 минут бұрын
This model I always loved the moon roof translucent feature. Those are magic cup holders. The rims I would see if you could upgrade. It is a shame they didn't give a moon roof up front. On the newer maybachs they don't have the wood for the tables which is a shame. I don't think you can change the rear entertainment system which is sad. One great feature is people not being in awe and it being one of those hidden gems. And listening to the people riding in it they all love it.
@M3NS35 минут бұрын
I miss my Radio Preset Buttons as well as basic AC Buttons. I went from a 2020 BMW X7 to a 2024 X7, I could not be more disappointed. I miss the Buttons, the PRND, The user friendly interior, they also removed the comfort lock/unlock from the rear doors, removed the Start/stop switch. And worst of all I bought the X7 M60 for the power, I dont want the hybrid. My old X7 will go down as my favorite family car I ever owned or was ever Made.
@wpdjs62636 минут бұрын
Buttons are better
@mattcelder37 минут бұрын
Doug the type of guy to make up button extremists that don’t exist to have fake arguments with for the first 9:00 of the video
Пікірлер
The problem isn't the screens or buttons. It's the user experience. If you put feature used very often in a place that you have to click, 3/4 times to reach - that's bad UX. If you have buttons upon buttons to dial in every little thing creating this ugly cluster of buttons and switches that are hard to pick up on - that's bad UX. If a car brings excellent UX, be with buttons or screens, people wouldn't complain so much.
The people who say they prefer buttons, drive old cars and cant afford newer ones with screens. They use the button excuse so people dont find out that theyre poor. They want everyone to think they drive an old car out of preference.
Who is this person you're talking about? Doug? Are there really people taking it that far? The thing you said at the end about what you do want real buttons for, that is what I hear the vast majority of car enthusiasts asking for
Even airplanes have and are making a tremendous revolution. Small planes now can be retrofitted with glass cockpits that largely get rid of all buttons in favor of screens. Below is a link about the evolution of 737 cockpits, which tell the same story. kzread.info/dash/bejne/dmiip5uOm5TKis4.html
Would much rather have an extended cab with regular sized bed than 4 doors and a small bed.
To expensive not thanks
Relying on a screen for all functions is also not the way. Screens are less reliable than buttons and certain functions should be limited to buttons. Screens could break or get dead zones. The cost of a new screen or headunit will be thousands. Climate controls, radio, seats, and windows should be left to buttons. Any extra applications could be on a screen.
this was such a pointless video. you made up a bad argument no one was making to argue against.
i like me a good screen with carplay with assist cameras, but pls don't make climate controls touch screen
Screens AND buttons, not or. Can't have enough buttons for all the settings in the menus but it would be cool if we got user programmable hot keys you'd set like FM stations
Naw screw this. I feel like driving a car that looks like a cockpit is cool. There is a reason why planes don't use touch screens...
Screens > buttons And that's why Tesla is the best car ever made.
Tesla has voice commands, so whatever you need can be done through voice command or it’ll take you to the screen where it can be adjusted.
Arguing that cars without screens would look like a pilot's cabin is so stupid. You've reviewed cars from the 90s haven't you? Do those cars have button all the way back on the roof? Did you just forget every other car you've reviewed? This is such a dumb video that misses the entire point.
Yea but some cars like the new mustang dont need a huge touch screen ruins the look and vibe some do
The built-in compressor does not use bed space. It's inside the wall space. It is an excellent feature that I would have loved when I worked at the ranch.
justr drove a 1993 BMW 850Ci in Argentina. Such an amazingly cool car. Always loved the E31. Suspension's best left in S mode, in K there is a lot of body roll. Automatic is a bit lazy, but that's a 30 year old we're talking about, There is an 850CSi here as well, I will try it later...
The new base model jeep 2 door wrangler, has a 12" screen. It did not need it last year, but I guess it needs it this year. It also looks stupid.
Gears selection should always be physical, thats it.
There are too too too many 'features'...that is the problem. I think Doug cant see the forest because of the trees.
I actually hate the Tesla extreme minimalism.
only the real enthusiasts will understand
Insanely dangerous fad.
I just took a dump I'm selling it for a hundred grand It's one of a kind Only one like it in the world Follow me for more entrepreneur skills PS Demuro did you seriously just give this a 9 in cool factor ??? How disappointing and just......WOW
The exhaust pipe under the rear axle? Maybe that's something new.
Me with my '97 base model Corolla watching this: "Yeah......okay" 🙃
Is there an argument to say that screens are unsafe? Distracting whilst on the move? Would you watch Judge Judy (etc) while driving? Not so different is it? They also look awful. That clip of the Tesla interior was inescapably dull. Also, what if the screen fails? You then lose every function the vehicle has to offer!
Most people arent asking to make the horn sound selector a button. They just want basic controls to have buttons. It seems you went out of your way on this one to argue against a position no one is acutally taking.
Consider that many people are wearing gloves/mittens when they get into the vehicle. Also, switches are moving parts so they fail both mechanically and electrically.
Chad Buttons vs virgin screen
Why is it illegal to use your phone, when it's more difficult to use a touch screen in a car. It's cheaper to make screens. Than physical buttons... the screens are good for the "features" but the traditional things, like air-conditioning and audio controls should be buttons... Edit: Turns out I'm on the same page as Doug. But I stiĺl don't understand that it is getting to the point that there's no difference between using your phone and trying to navigate through screens. Admittedly, I love the fact that I can dial phone numbers with the enormous number of buttons in my 15 year old Volvo...compared to the new Hyundai EV...it's probably just me hurtling towards 40, but it's fun...even though the Bluetooth is horrendous. But it has a CD player, amazing sound and the best seats ever, when the transmission dies as it definitely will... I'll remove the seats and turn them into a lounge suite...haha,
There is nothing wrong with wanting a mostly analog car. But I guess Doug gets to decide the "proper" button to screen ratio. As for me, I like a back up camera and GPS. I have no other use for a screen or any of the features inside of it.
Regular people are stupid, so that means touchscreens are stupid. Case closed.
This trend will go away. Just like four bangers in trucks. Electric will go away. 5 years and we will be back to normal. But the screens will stay
Absolutely ridiculous! At the very least, incorporate the touch screen into the dash. So many new cars have it sticking up above the dash, looks so stupid
screens are cheaper? Yes. Will auto makers decrease the prices of cars Because screens are cheaper ?No. Idiotic take and who TF wants all buttons no screens ? litteraly nobody thinks that nobody said that ever
They should ease off with screens because the majority of features on modern cars are unneeded toys. They might be interesting to play with for a week or so but after that who bothers? Most people in reality only use the climate controls and the stereo 95% of the time. A clever car manufacturer would be looking to simplify cars/ engines and make them easier to work on. They'd be tapping into a large market of people who'd like that.
‘… and you probably buy used anyway!’ Shots fired.
My 22 Civic Si has exactly 10 buttons and looks clean and uncluttered. This is the correct amount.
I think Doug is just about wrong on every point he made. Ok, heated and ventilated seats and HVAC systems need to be adjusted all the time and physical buttons are necessary. As for everything she mentioned, that could all be done with a knob and a touch pad. The issue with screens: It depends on where the screen is placed. If it easily falls to hand then that is great. If it doesn't fall to your hand then that is an issue. Look at the Model Y and look at the new C-Class. The Model Y I have to reach to use the screen and with the C-Class I don't. The best system of physical buttons and screen was with BMW and Mercedes. The screen falls to your eye level and you use a knob or touch pad to adjust the radio. Even if the C and S Class's you need to look down at the screen to see what you are doing with the HVAC system or what station you are listening to. The auto industry gave us screens without asking us. Like I said, Doug is wrong.
Insane how many people clearly didn't watch the video
The CEOs of Palm, Nokia, Blackberry, Motorola, etc all said the iPhone was doomed because it only had a touchscreen and did away with a hardware keyboard. Didn't work out too well for those guys...
Is this a real video/argument, this is not a serious discussion, a health combination of screens and buttons is wanted.
I love Uncle Doug's Rocking Chair
I hope that trophy says "DADDY DOUG" on it
Doug's the kinda guy to control his wife and kids thru a screen.
This model I always loved the moon roof translucent feature. Those are magic cup holders. The rims I would see if you could upgrade. It is a shame they didn't give a moon roof up front. On the newer maybachs they don't have the wood for the tables which is a shame. I don't think you can change the rear entertainment system which is sad. One great feature is people not being in awe and it being one of those hidden gems. And listening to the people riding in it they all love it.
I miss my Radio Preset Buttons as well as basic AC Buttons. I went from a 2020 BMW X7 to a 2024 X7, I could not be more disappointed. I miss the Buttons, the PRND, The user friendly interior, they also removed the comfort lock/unlock from the rear doors, removed the Start/stop switch. And worst of all I bought the X7 M60 for the power, I dont want the hybrid. My old X7 will go down as my favorite family car I ever owned or was ever Made.
Buttons are better
Doug the type of guy to make up button extremists that don’t exist to have fake arguments with for the first 9:00 of the video