4:21 Mistake in the Scots. It should be 'haun', not 'hand'. The pronunciation of the vowel sound is closer to Frisian, Danish and Faroese.
@jackdubz4247 Жыл бұрын
This video reminds me of my favourite bit of Scots: it's a braw bricht moonlit nicht the nicht.
@Dirt-McGerk Жыл бұрын
Few corrections for frisian Earth = Ierde Sun = Sinne Hand = Hân
@superbrainil
Жыл бұрын
There are several Frisian dialects, so I might have used a different one. Alternatively, I can be wrong
@Dirt-McGerk
Жыл бұрын
@@superbrainilRight, I guess I've been a bit too quick with my comment. But to be fair a lot of eastern dialects are near extinct, whereas West Frisian is very much alive still
@lafamilleerre7733 Жыл бұрын
Je me pose la question : le proto-germanique est-il influencé parfois par l'ancien latin ? Exemple : huis, house, haus, hus, hoys... Ostium : porte extérieur d'une maison, et par extension, maison. En français : huis, huisserie, huis-clos... Day : latin dies ? Mouse, maus : en latin musa. En français, langue d'origine latine, des mots d'origine germanique existent : helmet, helm, qui donnent "heaume" (casque) et peut-être vase (terre au fond de l'eau) : water, wasser, vaser (yiddish) ? Qui pourrait répondre ?
@kingrednax6000
Жыл бұрын
La raison de ces similitudes est que les langues romanes et les langues germaniques proviennent toutes du proto-indo-européen.
@chriswatson7965
Жыл бұрын
Proto-Germanic is older than Latin. No connection between house and ostium. The French huis is derived from ostium and possibly influenced by the German huus. Day and Latin dies have different origins, but it is possible that the Latin dies influenced the changing of Germanic dag to English day. Mouse and musa have the same origin in proto-indo-european
@tiburciusvanderleeuwen6697
Жыл бұрын
The ancient Franks spoke a Germanic language, Frankonic and Old-Frankonic. Possibly many words in the French language come from this ancient Germanic language of the ancient Franks.
@SpiritmanProductions
Жыл бұрын
@@chriswatson7965 You could well be right regarding dag -> day, but I wonder if it could instead have been influenced by the same thing that caused the Dutch adjective-forming suffix -ig to translate to -y in English. For instance, Dutch has 'handig', 'grappig', and 'ruizig' where English has 'handy', 'funny', and 'noisy'.
@simontenkate9601
9 ай бұрын
@@tiburciusvanderleeuwen6697 like the word for water: l'eau, aa ( a little stream, small river ), å.
@MagnsATK98 Жыл бұрын
Appreciate the Nynorsk version of Norwegian!
@troelspeterroland6998 Жыл бұрын
The reason why the word for 'sun' ends in l in some Indo-European languages (e.g. The North Germanic ones), and in n in others (e.g. the West Germanic ones) is that this word was apparently irregular in Proto-Indo-European so the stem ended in l in some cases and in n in others, just as you specify with the two variants of the Proto-Germanic form. This is also the case for 'water' by the way. Here the stem alternates between ending in r in some cases, which is preserved in the West Germanic forms, and in n in others, which is preserved in the North Germanic forms. So the Proto-Germanic form would have had two variants as well, *watôr-/*waten-
@Pachupp85 Жыл бұрын
Germans brought helmets to Poland. Confirmed.
@BoerChris Жыл бұрын
Icelandic for 'fire' is 'eld'.
@Divig
Жыл бұрын
In swedish we say 'eld' as well, but we do use 'fyr' sometimes. ("Ta fyr" = something is starting to take fire, "fyrbåk" = precursor to a lighthouse) Is it the same in icelandic?
@BoerChris
Жыл бұрын
@@Divig I made a small error; fire is 'eldur' Masculine nominative). To catch fire is 'fara að loga'. Beacon (your fyrbak) is 'leiðarljós'.
@HD-dq9kr Жыл бұрын
In Icelandic sól means sun, sunna isn’t used in daily speech as it’s more poetic. But it’s a female name and also in the word sunnudagur (Sunday). Eldur means fire, fúr isn’t used at all in Icelandic.
@gardist Жыл бұрын
Why didn't you include Luxembourgish?
@karshmellow3021
Жыл бұрын
Luxembourgish is technically just a Low German dialect, but historically Luxembourg was separate from Germany which is why they technically have their own language. Edit: I was oversimplifying a lot but yeah, what they said below.
@jensschroder8214
Жыл бұрын
@@karshmellow3021 No, Luxemburg is not Low German. It's Moselle Franconian dialect German.
@honkytonk4465
Жыл бұрын
@@karshmellow3021 no it's a middle german dialect
@diegopendinorodriguez4829 Жыл бұрын
I need to know the origins of english language.
@user-ec8vd3sf4s10 ай бұрын
why is the map of South Africa joined
@superbrainil
9 ай бұрын
It's for Afrikaans. It is a language that's descended from Dutch that's spoken in there
@user-xz9mc9ui4c Жыл бұрын
Короче верхне немецкий самый не германский из всех языков.
@Dannydanny545 Жыл бұрын
Before the rani the Germanic tribes spoke in monosyllables and dwelt above the trees
Пікірлер: 27
4:21 Mistake in the Scots. It should be 'haun', not 'hand'. The pronunciation of the vowel sound is closer to Frisian, Danish and Faroese.
This video reminds me of my favourite bit of Scots: it's a braw bricht moonlit nicht the nicht.
Few corrections for frisian Earth = Ierde Sun = Sinne Hand = Hân
@superbrainil
Жыл бұрын
There are several Frisian dialects, so I might have used a different one. Alternatively, I can be wrong
@Dirt-McGerk
Жыл бұрын
@@superbrainilRight, I guess I've been a bit too quick with my comment. But to be fair a lot of eastern dialects are near extinct, whereas West Frisian is very much alive still
Je me pose la question : le proto-germanique est-il influencé parfois par l'ancien latin ? Exemple : huis, house, haus, hus, hoys... Ostium : porte extérieur d'une maison, et par extension, maison. En français : huis, huisserie, huis-clos... Day : latin dies ? Mouse, maus : en latin musa. En français, langue d'origine latine, des mots d'origine germanique existent : helmet, helm, qui donnent "heaume" (casque) et peut-être vase (terre au fond de l'eau) : water, wasser, vaser (yiddish) ? Qui pourrait répondre ?
@kingrednax6000
Жыл бұрын
La raison de ces similitudes est que les langues romanes et les langues germaniques proviennent toutes du proto-indo-européen.
@chriswatson7965
Жыл бұрын
Proto-Germanic is older than Latin. No connection between house and ostium. The French huis is derived from ostium and possibly influenced by the German huus. Day and Latin dies have different origins, but it is possible that the Latin dies influenced the changing of Germanic dag to English day. Mouse and musa have the same origin in proto-indo-european
@tiburciusvanderleeuwen6697
Жыл бұрын
The ancient Franks spoke a Germanic language, Frankonic and Old-Frankonic. Possibly many words in the French language come from this ancient Germanic language of the ancient Franks.
@SpiritmanProductions
Жыл бұрын
@@chriswatson7965 You could well be right regarding dag -> day, but I wonder if it could instead have been influenced by the same thing that caused the Dutch adjective-forming suffix -ig to translate to -y in English. For instance, Dutch has 'handig', 'grappig', and 'ruizig' where English has 'handy', 'funny', and 'noisy'.
@simontenkate9601
9 ай бұрын
@@tiburciusvanderleeuwen6697 like the word for water: l'eau, aa ( a little stream, small river ), å.
Appreciate the Nynorsk version of Norwegian!
The reason why the word for 'sun' ends in l in some Indo-European languages (e.g. The North Germanic ones), and in n in others (e.g. the West Germanic ones) is that this word was apparently irregular in Proto-Indo-European so the stem ended in l in some cases and in n in others, just as you specify with the two variants of the Proto-Germanic form. This is also the case for 'water' by the way. Here the stem alternates between ending in r in some cases, which is preserved in the West Germanic forms, and in n in others, which is preserved in the North Germanic forms. So the Proto-Germanic form would have had two variants as well, *watôr-/*waten-
Germans brought helmets to Poland. Confirmed.
Icelandic for 'fire' is 'eld'.
@Divig
Жыл бұрын
In swedish we say 'eld' as well, but we do use 'fyr' sometimes. ("Ta fyr" = something is starting to take fire, "fyrbåk" = precursor to a lighthouse) Is it the same in icelandic?
@BoerChris
Жыл бұрын
@@Divig I made a small error; fire is 'eldur' Masculine nominative). To catch fire is 'fara að loga'. Beacon (your fyrbak) is 'leiðarljós'.
In Icelandic sól means sun, sunna isn’t used in daily speech as it’s more poetic. But it’s a female name and also in the word sunnudagur (Sunday). Eldur means fire, fúr isn’t used at all in Icelandic.
Why didn't you include Luxembourgish?
@karshmellow3021
Жыл бұрын
Luxembourgish is technically just a Low German dialect, but historically Luxembourg was separate from Germany which is why they technically have their own language. Edit: I was oversimplifying a lot but yeah, what they said below.
@jensschroder8214
Жыл бұрын
@@karshmellow3021 No, Luxemburg is not Low German. It's Moselle Franconian dialect German.
@honkytonk4465
Жыл бұрын
@@karshmellow3021 no it's a middle german dialect
I need to know the origins of english language.
why is the map of South Africa joined
@superbrainil
9 ай бұрын
It's for Afrikaans. It is a language that's descended from Dutch that's spoken in there
Короче верхне немецкий самый не германский из всех языков.
Before the rani the Germanic tribes spoke in monosyllables and dwelt above the trees