Пікірлер

• 
  @CricketTheHivewing22 сағат бұрын

  Actually crazy how much nonsense and random hate bro’s getting from people who do not understand the concept / study of linguistics; amazing video, keep it up!

• 
  @atbing242518 сағат бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @enes752_Science_of_Kingdom2 күн бұрын

  A very good video!

• 
  @atbing24252 күн бұрын

  Thank you

• 
  @snrnsjd2 күн бұрын

  Once again, third view

• 
  @snrnsjd2 күн бұрын

  Third view

• 
  @paolofrassine71402 күн бұрын

  Superb! Thanks

• 
  @atbing24252 күн бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @user-dz2hr2nd8l2 күн бұрын

  That's yiddish, not hebrew.

• 
  @HeisenbergsUncertainty3 күн бұрын

  Free Palestine from occupation 🇵🇸✌️

• 
  @andred76843 күн бұрын

  Free the world of the religion of peace ☠

• 
  @HeisenbergsUncertainty3 күн бұрын

  ​@@andred7684 it's not something about one certain religion. Christians as well as orthodox Jews are also suffering from these right extremist Israelis.

• 
  @joliteal1Күн бұрын

  Free culture of languajes out of politics

• 
  @jawad97577 сағат бұрын

  ​@@andred7684 does it make you feel good about yourself to be dismissive of the deaths of so many people, do you feel proud? You clown.

• 
  @amityanukaСағат бұрын

  Free the land of the jews from Arab colonialism no matter what you want to call it Palestine , Israel Judia or Canaan.

• 
  @barakbarkan71723 күн бұрын

  Yeah more like a mental pain, not a physical pain

• 
  @DanielM-tu8xn4 күн бұрын

  I swear to god people in the commend are spewing the most ridiculous claims I have ever heard, as if Arabic was the only language ever existing in the middle east

• 
  @nathanielmartins59304 күн бұрын

  Well, there are people who pretend that Israel was the only civilisation to exist in the levant. Crazy people exist on both sides.

• 
  @atbing24254 күн бұрын

  kzread.info/dash/bejne/Y4qZspahY7G5krw.htmlsi=Rhdcm-8BRgBfAsbs Only language in the world

• 
  @DanielM-tu8xn4 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 you got it wrong, it's the only language in the universe

• 
  @nathanielmartins59304 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 That video is full of Pseudo-science.

• 
  @atbing24254 күн бұрын

  You don't say

• 
  @Rodin995 күн бұрын

  yes, interesting..

• 
  @atbing24254 күн бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @hagalhagal99895 күн бұрын

  At 1.42 it's not as if Paul decided. There was a debate and the Apostles agreed with Paul. At 2.58 the chart is a bit misleading. It makes it appear that all these schools of thought had the same adherents. But the truth is that few disagreed from what later came to be the Nicean Creed.

• 
  @shira58875 күн бұрын

  thank you so much! it explains so many things!

• 
  @atbing24255 күн бұрын

  תודה אני ישראלי דרך אגב את לא חייבת אנגלית

• 
  @hagalhagal99895 күн бұрын

  I think you will find this series by Thomas Alexander on how Islam began interesting. The series is based on the work done by Inarah. kzread.info/dash/bejne/oY6rtNGfcaiphsY.html You may also want to check out these channels: Pfander Films, Islamic Origins and Odon LaFontaine.

• 
  @jagatdeuri32615 күн бұрын

  As a Deori language speaker, its the Eastern most bodo-garo langauge ( like a bridge between bodo-garo and tani) we can see tani influence in my mother tongue which make it very distinct from other bodo-garo languages lile boro, dimasa, etc

• 
  @user-by7mp4sc6z6 күн бұрын

  The Altaic thing is fake.

• 
  @atbing24256 күн бұрын

  Since I made the video I have changed my mind, yes you are probably right.

• 
  @Mister69K7 күн бұрын

  bravo!

• 
  @atbing24257 күн бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @AimAdolfAim7 күн бұрын

  Linguistik? Ich war verwirrt, als ich mir das ansah

• 
  @atbing24257 күн бұрын

  Ja

• 
  @pierreabbat61577 күн бұрын

  Speaking of Ghazzah, I haven't heard anyone on the news who isn't a Semite pronounce Rafaḥ right.

• 
  @atbing24257 күн бұрын

  I'm assuming your point is that Jews aren't Semites apparently

• 
  @pierreabbat61577 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 No, both Arabs and Israelis would pronounce the final consonant, but a lot of people drop it.

• 
  @atbing24257 күн бұрын

  Lol sorry

• 
  @atbing24257 күн бұрын

  I'm just so used to these annoying people

• 
  @0MVR_06 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 you need to disarm

• 
  @teehee40967 күн бұрын

  Please fix your thumbnail my guy.

• 
  @greypsyche52558 күн бұрын

  5:50, Arabic has sh ش though, or is that different?

• 
  @atbing24258 күн бұрын

  I'm sorry I didn't understand the question

• 
  @0MVR_06 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 Arabic asparations are separate and distinguishable.

• 
  @Yousef770779 күн бұрын

  What is the goal of this video? Pardon me but I’m very confused. Is there a reason you can’t pronounce Arabic words correctly? Your pronunciation was not very good. So I’m really confused by the purpose of this video if you are struggling to speak the languages. Perhaps focus on languages you’re more knowledgeable on? Maybe then the information can be more accurate. Good day.

• 
  @Joe17298 күн бұрын

  he's not pronouncing Arabic like a native for the same reason he's not pronouncing English words like a native?? Like why is this so hard for you

• 
  @amj.composer9 күн бұрын

  I've never seen anyone analyze sound shifts for non-IE langs, super cool and thanks for sharing!! I REALLY wanna learn Arabic but I'm literally terrified of its difficulty

• 
  @atbing24259 күн бұрын

  Thanks. Just learn Arabic; it's about progress, don't worry if you face challenges along the way.

• 
  @user-yp2sc1cy1n7 күн бұрын

  It's like an ocean, if you think of sharks and rpgue waves you won't enjoy yourself. If you swim, frolick, dive and let it carry you, you'll enjoy it.

• 
  @arrivederciheheeeeee580911 күн бұрын

  Totally respectful comment sections here

• 
  @atbing242511 күн бұрын

  For sure lol

• 
  @arrivederciheheeeeee580911 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 wowie youre active

• 
  @atbing242511 күн бұрын

  Well I get notified about every comment

• 
  @Omar2473712 күн бұрын

  I have a question please where is the place of origin of the proto uralic people in europe or in asia and can you explain more for me

• 
  @atbing242512 күн бұрын

  Don't know for sure, around the Urals, at the edge of eastern Europe.

• 
  @Omar2473712 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 so they originate in european side right?

• 
  @atbing242512 күн бұрын

  Probably

• 
  @mohamejd12 күн бұрын

  How ironic

• 
  @mcp61312 күн бұрын

  I always love these type of videos, and its cool to finally see one that is for a semetic language and not an indo european one

• 
  @atbing242512 күн бұрын

  Thanks

• 
  @Yahya-sb1yo5 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425I would love to see one comparing semetic ones to other Afro asiatics, like Berber languags

• 
  @atbing24255 күн бұрын

  @@Yahya-sb1yo i would love to, There isn't a lot of information on the topic, but I'll see what I can do.

• 
  @phufadangbluered554413 күн бұрын

  Free Free Jerusalem 💀

• 
  @yosuf568613 күн бұрын

  Are you Persian?

• 
  @atbing242513 күн бұрын

  Israeli

• 
  @yosuf568613 күн бұрын

  @@atbing2425 LOL

• 
  @calebbrown70255 күн бұрын

  @@yosuf5686that’s not funny

• 
  @yosuf56865 күн бұрын

  @@calebbrown7025 It's not funny if he's Israeli...yes But the funny thing is that he is Persian and pretends to be an Israeli

• 
  @calebbrown70255 күн бұрын

  @@yosuf5686 oh okay. I was confused

• 
  @cl961513 күн бұрын

  One way that you can tell a group of people are colonizers is how far their language spreads. Think of English, Spanish, and French being spoken in places besides Europe. The same standard should be held for Arabs but sadly too many people have become complacent with the erasure of indigenous Middle Eastern cultures.

• 
  @Nawaf_-13 күн бұрын

  Israilte Hebrew is not hebrew at all. it sounds like a Foreigner trying to pronounce Arabic

• 
  @atbing242513 күн бұрын

  "Modern Hebrew is not Hebrew because it doesn't sound like Arabic"

• 
  @cl961513 күн бұрын

  The Arabic word for Jerusalem “Al-Quds” is a direct appropriation of the Hebrew word for the “Holy House.” In Hebrew being “Bayit HaMiqdash” or בית המקדש״.” Enough pretending like the Arabic version is just as legitimate. It is the definition of a colonial name. Think of how the American colonists named their states after mispronunciations or Anglicized versions of native words (Illinois, Mississippi, Kansas, Michigan, etc.) It is the same thing and it should not seen as anything different. It also occurred in other places as well. For example, Hebron (חברון) for which the Arabic name is “al-Khalil” meaning “the friend.” Funnily enough that’s exactly what it means in Hebrew too! This is the hallmark of colonial expansion.

• 
  @arrivederciheheeeeee580911 күн бұрын

  I mean, the old Arabic name for Jerusalem was literally bait Al maqdis and that was around when the Romans were occupying the holy land. It's more likely the Arabs adapted the name from the Jews who were in the region.

• 
  @mahmoudbts61885 күн бұрын

  The arabic word for jerusalem "al qudus" is simply a reduction for "bait al maqdis" (the holy house/place). The full name of the city using bait al maqdis would be "madinat beit al maqdis" but the name "bait al maqdis" usually means the area taht al aqsa mosque and the church of sepulchre are in. So the word "bait" was deleted (since it means "the house" so people thought it means the holy places themselves), and by using simple arabic grammar rules we can see that "madinat (city) maqdis" isnt gramattically correct so they removed the mem letter so "maqdis" became "qudis". For the name of the city hebron. Yes indeed the word khallil means "friend" in arabic but it also means helper or servent and bunch of other meanings. And actually the full name of the city is "madinat khalil al-rahman" which means "city of the friend/servant of al rahman (the most merciful aka god)" and by the server of god it refers to abraham which was believed to live in that city.

• 
  @cl96155 күн бұрын

  @@mahmoudbts6188Thank you for the more in depth explanation. I think my point still stands though.

• 
  @kfurgie9992 күн бұрын

  Why are we arguing about naming conventions when thousands of children are being killed

• 
  @yaseensharawi803413 күн бұрын

  No I don’t want the end because European want to get rid of the immigrants The British will find the solution for the immigrants problem and will make a new promise and will send them here because you know before the first palastinan homsipian has been in the Land there was a niuandartal or homoeractes immigrants before them

• 
  @yaseensharawi803413 күн бұрын

  And the Canaanite are not the ancestors of the modern Israeli they are the ancestors of modern day palastinan and Lebanese the modern Israeli except for mzrahi are for most part of Italian descendants

• 
  @yaseensharawi803413 күн бұрын

  The Canaanite is extinct language The savages (hapwuro) that come from arba valley and destroyed them and make them worship the god of war Yhowa the savages haprow destroyed everything And now savages that came from behind the sea say they are there children Savages European

• 
  @eminqarayev-fg8kp15 күн бұрын

  Rica Ediryorum Bu Videonu Endirini ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️🙏⬇️🙏⬇️🙏⬇️

• 
  @ricardo82shadow12315 күн бұрын

  Where are geez and Akkadian in that family tree language?😂😂😂

• 
  @user-jf1ou8jm8h16 күн бұрын

  There is no such thing as (hebrew language). jews after living with the Canaanites, they learned their language/dialect. After that they massacred the Canaanites and changed the name of the Canaanite language/dialect into hebrew. In the book history of Israel by Martin Noth on p. 24 the author says: When the Israelite tribes arrived, however, they still found that the language spoken was the Semitic 'Canaanite', and, like many earlier immigrants, they and their relations adopted this language in place of the probably Aramaic dialect they had spoken previously. This is why you see images in which there is an arrow drawn from Canaanite to hebrew. It basically means that hebrew is derived/stolen from Canaanite. Btw, i'm talking about old hebrew. As for modern hebrew. it's not even the same as old hebrew. It's basically an amalgamation of multiple languages.

• 
  @FreePhilistine.GoliathLives2415 күн бұрын

  They copied the language and called it Hebrew. However, Canaanites continued to live and evolve. Hebrew became a d3@d language

• 
  @cl961513 күн бұрын

  According to the archeological record, (and not the Biblical record as I assume you’re taking) Israelites emerged as a group from within the Canaanites. This means that the Israelites were originally Canaanites but then became unique mostly because of their monolatry. So what I’m trying to say is that the language spoken by the Israelites (ancient Jews) was in fact a Canaanite language. Hebrew comes from the Canaanite branch of the semitic language family.

• 
  @cl961513 күн бұрын

  As for your take on Modern Hebrew, I would love to hear what you think the other languages that comprise Hebrew are. The fact of the matter is that modern Hebrew is incredibly similar to ancient Hebrew differing only really in syntax, and of course, vocabulary. Since Hebrew was only used liturgically for thousands of years many words for modern concepts had to be developed. These words were either developed by extrapolating from existing Hebrew root words or from other similar languages like Arabic. Your assessment that modern Hebrew is merely an “amalgamation of other languages” is far from the truth.

• 
  @Esoterica-Arabic13 күн бұрын

  Exactly. There is no such thing as 'Hebrew'. It had always been called, for the majority of its history as a spoken language, 'Canaanite'. Steal the land, Steal the language, claim someone else ancestry, claim falafel is yours, claim Hummus is yours, claim our Levantine music as yours. On top of that, 'Jewish History' is all fabricated and made up of thin air. All these 'archeological findings' are propaganda, exaggerated, and clearly mislabeled (if one delves into a serious academic research regarding this matter) & conflated with the Canaanite archetypes found all over the Levant. The whole thing is a mythology advertised as history.

• 
  @user-jf1ou8jm8h13 күн бұрын

  @@cl9615 Ok jew, how can you determine that israelites emerged as a group from within the Canaanites by relying on archeological record? Answer: you can’t.m, unless there is an ancient scroll that says (israelites emerged from Canaanites) and that doesn’t exist. Canaanites/Phoencians are Arabs. The definition of Arab is (a person that is originally from Arabia/Arabian peninsula). Canaanites/Phoenicians were from Bahrain. Bahrain is part of Arabia/Arabian peninsula. This means that Canaanites/Phoenicians are Arabs by definition. Proof: In the book Geography by Strabo translated by Hans Claude Hamilton and William Falconer in book XVI chapter 3 section 4 the author says: On sailing further, there are other islands, Tyre and Aradus, which have temples resembling those of the Phoenicians. The inhabitants of these islands (if we are to believe them) say that the islands and cities bearing the same name as those of the Phoenicians are their own colonies. William Falconer says in the margin: Besides the islands Tyre and Aradus, there existed even in the time of Alexander, and near the present Cape Gherd, a city called Sidon or Sidodona, which was visited by Nearchus, as may be seen in his Periplus. The Phoenician inhabitants of these places appear to have afterwards removed to the western side of the Persian Gulf, and to the islands Bahrain, to which they gave the names Tylos, or Tyre, and Aradus. The latter name still exists; it was from this place that the Phoenicians moved, to establish themselves on the shores of the Mediterranean, and transferred the name of Sidon, their ancient capital, and those of Tyre and Aradus, to the new cities which they there founded. Gossellin.

• 
  @thediaxd374716 күн бұрын

  Thank God arabic pharyngealized consonants are not like in the old arabic.... it would be objectively the hardest language to learn💀

• 
  @user-nx4jc1mj9w17 күн бұрын

  Semitism is separate from African and Asian languages and from injustice to include them with those languages.

• 
  @williammatthewwalker814517 күн бұрын

  Well done

• 
  @makevet653118 күн бұрын

  There is no such thing as Palestinian Arabic. The only indigenous words in "Palestinian Arabic" are in Hebrew.

• 
  @FreePhilistine.GoliathLives2415 күн бұрын

  What?

• 
  @FreePhilistine.GoliathLives2415 күн бұрын

  There's no such thing as Hebrew. It's just the ancient Canaanite language

• 
  @leseuletuniqueufcassesilte570015 күн бұрын

  There is, in fact, a distinct dialect of Arabic spoken in Palestine no matter how you try and spin it, and there has been for centuries.

• 
  @makevet653114 күн бұрын

  @@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700 Give me ONE "Palestinian" word - common..

• 
  @0MVR_06 күн бұрын

  bait

• 
  @tradingintroverts19 күн бұрын

  Proudly Bantu from Akwa ibom in Nigeria

• 
  @affanshikoh506919 күн бұрын

  תודה רבה

• 
  @samiqala654319 күн бұрын

  Why you compare the language of quran with the language of children killer.

• 
  @ThatBernie21 күн бұрын

  Good video, information seems legit, even if your pronunciation of certain sounds is just a little bit off 😅

• 
  @atbing242521 күн бұрын

  Thanks, Yeah it's definitely not easy

• 
  @rashid864622 күн бұрын

  I don't know where you got the facts for this video but some claims about the Palestinian dialect are either wrong, outdated or apply only to bedouins. For example, it's not the case that Palestinian dialect uses t instead of th often. That's something more associated with Gulf Arabs and Lebanese.

• 
  @ryuko4478Күн бұрын

  Arabic speaker that grew up with Palestinians here: Most Urban Palestinians from cities like Al-Quds, Jenin, Ramalla, etc. even from cities that were conquered by Israel lost the th and dh sounds. But Rural Palestinians and Bedouin Palestinians didn't lose it. Due to a lot of people from rural areas moving into the city it is now common to hear th and dh in Palestinian cities, but turning them into t and d like in talate for 3 and tum/tom for garlic is common. Also Gulf Arabic NEVER loses th and dh, I have no idea where the hell you made that one up.

• 
  @mayanlogos9225 күн бұрын

  Thanks ... i wanted to find sth like this 🤍❤️

• 
  @mayanlogos9225 күн бұрын

  I love them ❤️💙🖤🤍💚

• 
  @user-qd8pl6es8f26 күн бұрын

  Altai language theory is such a hopeless false Western idea. When will we be finally over that pseudo-theory.

• 
  @AthanasiosJapan28 күн бұрын

  Very interesting and very useful! Thank you very much!

• 
  @atbing242528 күн бұрын

  Thank you