That's actually an informative video thank you!

@atbing2425

18 күн бұрын

No, thank you!

Very interesting and very useful! Thank you very much!

@atbing2425

15 күн бұрын

Thank you

Wow an amazing video thank you 🙏

@atbing2425

17 күн бұрын

Thanks man

Top tier video.

man you deserve more subscribers this is really cool ngl

@atbing2425

19 күн бұрын

Thanks man

@dsp6373

10 күн бұрын

Why won’t you lie? You usually do. Why not this time?

Thanks for this video. Please note that /x/ is a *velar* fricative, not an uvular sound as you say.

@atbing2425

16 күн бұрын

Well from what I have seen it's sort of variable. So you are right that you could interpret both in Hebrew and Arabic alike that these fricatives are velar. I chose to represent them as uvular simply from my experience as a native Hebrew speaker.

I don't know where you got the facts for this video but some claims about the Palestinian dialect are either wrong, outdated or apply only to bedouins. For example, it's not the case that Palestinian dialect uses t instead of th often. That's something more associated with Gulf Arabs and Lebanese.

Good video, information seems legit, even if your pronunciation of certain sounds is just a little bit off 😅

@atbing2425

7 күн бұрын

Thanks, Yeah it's definitely not easy

Well done

I love them ❤️💙🖤🤍💚

תודה רבה

Thanks ... i wanted to find sth like this 🤍❤️

Thank God arabic pharyngealized consonants are not like in the old arabic.... it would be objectively the hardest language to learn💀

There is no such thing as (hebrew language). jews after living with the Canaanites, they learned their language/dialect. After that they massacred the Canaanites and changed the name of the Canaanite language/dialect into hebrew. In the book history of Israel by Martin Noth on p. 24 the author says: When the Israelite tribes arrived, however, they still found that the language spoken was the Semitic 'Canaanite', and, like many earlier immigrants, they and their relations adopted this language in place of the probably Aramaic dialect they had spoken previously. This is why you see images in which there is an arrow drawn from Canaanite to hebrew. It basically means that hebrew is derived/stolen from Canaanite. Btw, i'm talking about old hebrew. As for modern hebrew. it's not even the same as old hebrew. It's basically an amalgamation of multiple languages.

@IsmailShields

Күн бұрын

They copied the language and called it Hebrew. However, Canaanites continued to live and evolve. Hebrew became a d3@d language

you keep on propagating nonsense like parts. There is proof that ancient languages in the Arabian peninsula used the sound P. Actually, all proof is against that but there is a tendency in western academia to force Greek and Persian linguistic trials to old Arabic although both said languages came to be in the first thousand BC while old Arabic dates to before the second thousand Bc, There is no Semitic designation in real historical studies, this is a Biblical term that has nothing to do with the region's people and genealogy. Hence, your termed photo semitic is nothing but a failed recycling of Jewish fallacies.

@mew11two

11 күн бұрын

The least delusional Arab

@victor_rybin

6 күн бұрын

you wrote it too complicated, what exactly is the jewish fallasies, and what's your correction? you say ancient Arabic used the sound "P"? and Arabic wasn't influenced by Greek and Persian, but instead all languages came from Arabic?

@saadhamid6226

6 күн бұрын

@@victor_rybin The Jewish fallacies are numerous from claiming to be chosen people to Jacob wrestling God to the ground and forcing him to grant Palestine to the Jews to their alleged knowledge of the genealogy of people and this is the particular point I make. Semites and other designations of races is a proven fallacy based on scientific historical and biological findings. On the second point Arabs and since ancient times conserved their language and its phonetic, syntactical and morphological traits so the letter ب was consistently pronounced as a B sound never a P sound as ignorant western linguist claim. They argue that since ancient Greek had an alteration between the P sound representing original B sound in addition to P shifting to an F sound (ph) in Greek and because this phenomenon permitted through Hebrew and Ancient Egyptian then the same must have occurred to Arabic. They ignore that the Arab world ( in its overwhelming majority) never fell under Greek rule and that Arabic retained its fixed phonetic nature. As for the age of Arabic it dates to before the 2 thousand BC according to scores of Thamoudic graphites and inscriptions. So yes it long predates both Greek and Hebrew.

There is no such thing as Palestinian Arabic. The only indigenous words in "Palestinian Arabic" are in Hebrew.

@IsmailShields

Күн бұрын

What?

@IsmailShields

Күн бұрын

There's no such thing as Hebrew. It's just the ancient Canaanite language

@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700

Күн бұрын

There is, in fact, a distinct dialect of Arabic spoken in Palestine no matter how you try and spin it, and there has been for centuries.

@makevet6531

4 сағат бұрын

@@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700 Give me ONE "Palestinian" word - common..

Herbew is a dead dialict of Arabic, that died out hence that is why Yemeni jews can read the Turah and other books written 1400 after Moses PBUH. The new invention os a mix of yiddish, arabic and latin thank you very much.

@dsp6373

15 күн бұрын

Hebrew isn’t even on the same branch as Arabic. Hebrew and Aramaic are on the same branch. Hebrew and Phoenician are dialects of Canaanite. If Hebrew were a dialect of Arabic, that would mean that Phoenician is also a dialect of Arabic, but that’s not true either. There vowels and consonant changes found in Hebrew clearly give away that it is not descended from Arabic, not Arabic is descended from Hebrew. Both, however, are descended of an earlier language that passed through several stages before they even became Hebrew and Arabic.

@shankybob2850

14 күн бұрын

What Bullshit! The linguistic structure of Biblical Hebrew is ENOUGH evidence to prove that not only did all other ancient languages originate from Hebrew itself after separation incident at the Tower of Babel but also that Hebrew was the first language created by God and it was used to create the universe hence Adam & Eve also spoke it! Stop bullshitting people! Your Arabic came much later!

@ramamit5201

14 күн бұрын

BS

@mew11two

11 күн бұрын

No it is not, stop it

@sigmasabra862

11 күн бұрын

What a bunch of crap.

Jordanian Arabic* "palestine" is not a real thing. Do Phoenician and Hebrew or Aramaic and Hebrew next time.

@victor_rybin

6 күн бұрын

Palestine is a real region, same as Mesopotamia, Caucasus, etc. Maybe you're in a wrong place for political controvercies

@IsmailShields

Күн бұрын

Jordanian and Palestinian dialects are different

@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700

Күн бұрын

Palestinian Arabic objectively is a real thing, and you cannot deny that no matter which side of ethnic cleansing you support. Your denial of such a dialect is further proof that what you are doing is ethnic cleansing.

@victor_rybin

Күн бұрын

​@@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700 i don't think Israelis commit ethnic cleansing, and that their denial of Palestinian culture proves their malintent. Israelis just propagate the correct idea that Palestinians are random Arabs, and that the Palestinian identity was created as a weapon against Israel. but Israelis overdo it, often denying _"Palestine"_ as a region, or _"Palestinian something"_ as a thing

@victor_rybin

Күн бұрын

@@leseuletuniqueufcassesilte5700 i don't think Israelis commit ethniс сleаnsing, and that their denial of Palestinian culture proves their mаlintеnt. Israelis just propagate the correct idea that Palestinians are random Arabs, and that the Palestinian identity was created as a wеapоn against Israel. but Israelis overdo it, often denying _"Palestine"_ as a region, or _"Palestinian something"_ as a thing