To be honest, Raesah Khan was just an MP without any appointment. Even if she lied, well, just sacked her and case closed. For TCJ and Iswaran, they are heavy weights from the government. Not only they should uphold higher standards than a normal MP, they should come under more stringent and intense scrutiny for any missteps. Don't you think so?

@johnchua9387

11 ай бұрын

Such double standard. Aren't she and the other two PAP members of parliament all elected by the people? Not having an appointment does not mean you do not hold a high standard in parliament. Every elected member should be held accountable for any wrongdoings regardless of parties.

@leonenarwani7258

11 ай бұрын

That's what the point is about , when raesah khan brought up her fren who was sexually harassed, shanmugan was the first to jump and ask her details for clarification,but now the same happening with pap , they are saying it's a sensitive matter and we should give them time while ,those are the selective standards, I mean it doesn't have to do with anyone being in pap or etc ,

@johnchua9387

11 ай бұрын

@leonenarwani7258 The same can be said to Pritam Singh when Raesah Khan told him that she was rape. Pritam Singh gave the excuse that he wanted to give her time to disclose to her family first, sighting it was a sensitive matter. Like I said in my reply, regardless of which party line, the elected members of parliament should be held accountable for any wrongdoings expeditiously.

@mothershipsg The context of this video is incomplete, as you only showed the first half of the exchange between Shanmugam and Pritam with regards to the Raesah Khan incident. You should also include the second half of their exchange, in particular when Pritam replied that Shanmugam was improper to take an "inductive leap" and went for the "jugular" against the WP. You should include the second half of their exchange with regards to the Raesah incident, so as not to mislead the viewers.

@september9646

11 ай бұрын

Because MS salary is not come from OP.

@cnachopchopnewsagency

11 ай бұрын

Do not forget that mothership advisor is George Yeo, PAP ex-minister

@hiroyukishinichi9873

11 ай бұрын

Slap to Prata Singh's face, reeled off word-for-word him wanting to put on record during COP that Khan was R*aped Gud to refresh people's memory of this Prata Singh trying to cover up Khan's lie until no choice but to lie to the public and COP and throw Khan under the bus and insinuate that she is mental.

Omg this is so frustrating. Pritam and PM were debating abt apples and Shan comes in with a smoke screen and talks abt oranges!

@say2davidlow

11 ай бұрын

wife accused husband for not being faith after got caught, husband then dragged up old story and counter accuse wife was not virgin...and merry going round...

@willyhuang4026

11 ай бұрын

​@@say2davidlow😆😆😆

The handling of these two cases presents a glaring disparity. The WP leaders were rigorously scrutinized and interrogated for their two-month delay in managing Raeesah Khan’s issue. In contrast, PM Lee’s three-year concealment of Tan Chuan-Jin’s affair raises serious questions about transparency and accountability, especially considering that both MPs continued their political roles despite the PM’s knowledge of the affair. Suppose the COP investigation was necessary for WP leaders following Khan’s resignation. Should there not be a similar inquiry into the PAP’s handling of Tan Chuan-Jin’s case, to clarify who knew about the affair, when and whether there was a deliberate attempt to cover up the affair to the Parliament and general public?

@paullim9754

11 ай бұрын

The glaring disparity clearly stated in your user name. But for technicality, COP was dealing with an issue of lying in parliament, they don't deal with issue of an affair.

@infinitelight465

11 ай бұрын

@@paullim9754, having adultery under wrap is worse than lying not only to parliament, to PM and to the citizens.

@stickymoney

11 ай бұрын

@@paullim9754 isn't having an affair with another member of the parliament that persisted under the nose of the PM AND not declaring these facts to the parliament a subset of lying?

@hiroyukishinichi9873

11 ай бұрын

@@paullim9754nice one, slapped a big {Biased} label on his face soundly

@mohamadromzee7394

11 ай бұрын

​@@stickymoney So you are also saying WP also lied because they did not disclose their own similar affairs in parliament?

Isnt adultery the worse form of lying and deceit???

@metoothanks3973

11 ай бұрын

something that shanmugam did in the past 😂

@sumasa

11 ай бұрын

If you can keep such lies to your family, lying to your fellow countrymen is a habit

Everyone can see it’s off the point and distraction from the main issue.

Somebody's mistake why try to frame somebody else must be punished. If she lies, she should be punished.

Typical pap double standard. Shan stop snaking around pls, you have no moral authority after ridout.

What's is the outcome of the rideout bangalo house investigation.

PS is saying that WP needed to be sensitive in treating RK case just as LHL was sensitive in treating the TCJ issue. Families who are innocent are involved. That is why there was “delay” for action. Therefore there shouldnt be double standards, one for WP and one for PAP.

Sad...😭😭😭.....sad......😭😭😭.....sad.....😭😭😭.....for those lower income and no income and jobless.

Sylvia Lim “First, it seems to me that the furore about the use of Trace Together data could have been avoided if the government had been clear from the start that the police would be using its powers to access the data. Instead, blanket assurances were given by several Ministers that the TT data would only be used for contact tracing in COVID-19 cases. These blanket assurances were given from at least mid-2020. Minister Vivian Balakrishnan told the House last month that he had forgotten about the Criminal Procedure Code when he gave his assurances, and had sleepless nights thereafter. But the bigger question is: for all these months, why did no one in the government step forward to correct the misrepresentation that Trace Together was fully ring-fenced for COVID tracing?”

Mothership you gave a short clip without the context. Shanmugam threw a smoke bomb about PS not caring about sensitivity when the nuances of what PS was talking about prior was slightly different. The second part of this painfully dragged out segment showed PS rebutting back Shanmugam for good. Pls dont mislead the audience here.

Some how after the Ridout affair, I felt my respect to K Shan eroded at least by 40%

@franciscody9622

11 ай бұрын

What was it before it got "eroded" 40%?

@RudyTruly

11 ай бұрын

@@franciscody9622 80%...he compared himself to Goh Keng Swee Mr Hon but he forgotten the situation then

@hiroyukishinichi9873

11 ай бұрын

Some how after the Ridout affair, I felt my respect to K Shan enhanced at least by 40%....what's there not to like: 1. pay rent to the country to help further spruce up and look after dilapidated heritage buildings (SLA's job to maintain in the first place anyway) and eradicate mosquito breeding area 2. most importantly, the whole process was verified by CPIB to be aboveboard and clean

@RudyTruly

11 ай бұрын

@@hiroyukishinichi9873 everyone is free to kiss ass and lick ass correct?

@jslam1232

11 ай бұрын

@@hiroyukishinichi9873Yes you are right! He’s such an amazing minister! We should increase his salary and give him more mistresses!

Mr. Singh lied then.

Why is he wearing 2 watch? Strange..

@franciscody9622

11 ай бұрын

One is a health monitor.

Imagine if the parliament is filled with 40% of opposition MP, we will have many debates, it will be very interesting !

@chaneruthi6004

10 ай бұрын

Hope in 2025

Part 2 please?

True

Classic pap strats, dodging and pointing fingers, none of the pap members even faced scrutiny that Pritam faced.

Regarding the ridout matter, I read in the papers and news VB saying that there were snakes and termites in the unused black & white bungalow..did you took any pictures or the contractor took any photos of snakes or termites b4 the renovation???🤔

@franciscody9622

11 ай бұрын

Likely true.

@willyhuang4026

11 ай бұрын

Any ghost story ?

Mothership why didn't you show the exchange right up to the end when PS responded ... Bias ... why cut off here

Lying can be pardon....that is nature for humanbeing.But Raesah been sacked or ask to be self resign. Unlike minister who scandal,curruption.After get caught,thrre no other way but to resign.😮

Both ministers should provide the full picture of their property holdings, investments and transactions by disclosing full details of the properties they own in Singapore and abroad, if any, and how much they earn from renting them out. This will confirm the motive(s) for renting the Ridout properties from SLA. Openness and transparency are required from politicians or VTO.

@hiroyukishinichi9873

11 ай бұрын

🤣🤣🤣Put aside how obtuse and ridiculous your suggestion sounds like, in that case, ALL public servants and ALL MPs (including WP, PSP and all) must provide full picture of their assets too since they ALL receive pay from the country

I think many can recognised who is missing the point.

Pritam looks shaken. This is bad news for WP

@jarrenloke2120

11 ай бұрын

RK Leon and Nicole are all being crucified by their own leader..This is bad for WP

@CC-dx6bc

9 ай бұрын

He was jealous of Leon

Shiny object ... smoke ...

the question is why did shemhoins the workers party,and then lied in parliament 😍

Check all Singaporen record all not in order struggling by this government

Fantastic points by Shanmugam

utter rubbish. parliament use for dodging at weaker opposition.

They bring up Khan cause they got nothing better to bring up

Hes trying to throw a red herring...horrible person Shan!

Pritam 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

I respect Shan a lot until after watching this debate, really dis........ I better don't say much lest I got a letter scare....

PS being investigated for lying based on the claim by a confirmed liar. What a joke!

Robbeeeeers where got admeeet!

ahh the ridout snake in all its glory.

Yeah right! Coming from someone with the Ridout affair baggage on his head.

Pritam singh, being the leader of WP, is currently being probed by the police for lying under oath. This guy has serious problems relating to responsibility, reliability and morality. 🤣🤣 The facts surrounding the raeesah case is enough to send the whole WP team to the grave.

@ethanang3527

11 ай бұрын

Tan Chuan Jin case? S Isarwan case?! Answer that one please Ridout one also. If you cannot answer that, you are really hopeless.

@hiroyukishinichi9873

11 ай бұрын

@@ethanang3527 TCJ equals out with Leon P Nic S Iswaran case not even done with investigation. WP has AHTC and Khan, easy. Ridout was a witch hunt that came up with nothing in the end (CPIB cleared). Joke.

@mitsubishilancer727

11 ай бұрын

@anziar3038 lets send anziar to the grave first

@kellyjs9137

11 ай бұрын

Pritam Singh being probed by the Commitee of Privileges whereby the dishonourable the ex-speaker of parliament TCJ; * presided the Committee of Privileges * using vulgar “F>>king populist” during parliamentary session * committed indecent marital affair with fellow senior MP This GUY HAS EVEN SERIOUS PROBLEMS RELATING TO RESPONSIBILITY, RELIABILITY NOT ONLY MORALITY BUT EMBARRASSMENT TO PAP. where international news/tv making a joke out of it. The facts surrounding raesah khan “sexsual rape” sensitivity was not shown by PAP but instead WP was being hounded…Don’t you think this is double standard shown by the ruling party? How is Pritam Singh conduct & behaviour as what you claimed to be??? How grave is WP compared to PAP??? PAP is getting messy with all the previous affair committed by Michael Palmer with own CC staff, before the Iswaran arrest by CPIB, Singaporeans were dished out by Keppel O&M officials (not names) taking bribes..

@BeachBoi1000

11 ай бұрын

Because WP is so used to find fault with PAP they didn’t reflect on their own behaviour and get carried away with their increased popularity.

Singaporeans taken for a ride for TOO LONG

Ridout rats.. 😂

@MTMT-wm2dq

11 ай бұрын

110%

Well done Law Minister. PAP truly hold high standard.

Shan completely missing the point. 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

Mothership trying to mislead by not showing full exchange... shameful..

throwing smoke bombs by highlighting the use of rape, and then insisting on LO bringing up mental issue on a supposedly young lady just shows the beyond facts and intention behavioural patterns which we've all seen, year after year.

Despite what Raesha saga ..MHA actually setup unit to handle sexually based crime...hence there must be some truth ...PAP, continue this trajectory..you will lose the house eventually.

What if we are to include all the extramarital affairs of the PAP parliamentarians and the perceived corruption and emerging scandals at the institutional level of our public institutions, agencies and statutory boards? Should PM Lee blame the bad advice given to him by his pool of advisers on the use of money politics to entice mediocre to join his 4G PAP, or should he blame himself for his own failure?

@franciscody9622

11 ай бұрын

The PAP candid selection process is no longer working properly. Remember the Ivan Lim saga which PAP promised to revert to but have not done so. Why,?

A leopard will not change it spot.. Irritating

Shanmuggam bochor.

Put it simply, double standard?

Please leave my son alone !!! Why got cover-up?

That is a falsehood against WP he didn’t covered the lie BS

KS is losing some marbles upstairs. so completely off point. time to start mentoring new blood

@elsieyong703

11 ай бұрын

Some people use something that look like a,watch to monitor their blood pressure. Is SM wearing one such device?

WP shame 👎👎👎👎👎