The two I love are 1. Does Australia have free speech is in the new citizenship test AND the answer is not NO! OOPS 2. Everyone sites Australia has signed Human Rights treaties etc.. BUT no-one ever reads the fine print down the bottom that states Australia only abides by these treaties etc within the boundaries of The Australian Constitution!!!! Ergo NO FREE SPEECH!!!! Ooops sorry The High Court does agree that we have an IMPLIED right to "political communication" unless of course you're a public servant, work for a charity etc etc etc
@jjsc333411 күн бұрын
Nothing is real
@ericknudten727216 күн бұрын
Amusing Ourselves to Death is one of the core books I always go back to
@garypatterson285720 күн бұрын
"Artificial Intelligence" is an idiot. There is no understanding of what a "dog" is, just some weighted variables in images tagged with the keyword "dog." It's not intelligence in any workable sense, it's just a keyword swarm attached to a data cloud. It's like a blind idiot shouting a name every time it's prodded with a stick. There's no thought there, just reaction. There's no intelligence there, just a blind process drawing images when prodded with keywords. This isn't "art." It can't be. If an AI is trained on only its own output, it will generate noise. Nothing more, nothing less. Just random gibberish that means nothing, forever and ever. A human given no input will generate childish imagery at first, but refine it over time to something artistic. "AI" is an idiot generation machine, producing only copies of what it has been given, unable to produce anything original or even interesting. Until an AI can describe a dog and argue what is or is not a dog, it cannot be intelligent. It's just an idiot shouting "DOG" when you ask it to draw a dog.
@bmodoryx20 күн бұрын
While I don't disagree, I've yet to encounter a single definition for "Art"
@NathanLorenzana21 күн бұрын
This is misleading, due to ignorance or purposefully. There is a huge difference between images generated ONLY through text, and artwork assisted with AI. Both use AI, but the method varies greatly. This is causing confusion and hypes up AI to a level that it will never be able to achieve, because applied arts is problem solving and art is about an experience translated into a medium. Images generated with text is a roll of the dice, and assuming this random element is somewhat a threat is not founded in reality. Be careful. Plus, a quick search here in KZread demonstrates that people wanting to make money with AI art is the biggest challenge of all, not because it's AI, but because the business of art itself is a tough one to break into AND sustain in the long term. Every one of those videos have people making less than $30 profit in their experiments. Do your homework.
@blu12gaming4421 күн бұрын
Have you ever considered the possibility that artists can't directly interact with generative AI because it's still very new??? Before Photoshop, Blender, Maya, etc. universities were still working on particular algorithms to get things to just work, and didn't yet implement user friendly GUIs and tools. Instead of bemoaning the death of art as we know it (because it isn't): you should focus on pushing the need for interactivity/user-input for AI-based tools, which will inevitably happen anyway because prompts can only go so far.
@Ryftrr21 күн бұрын
You're completely missing the point of what generative AI does. With software tools like the ones you named, the creative process and generation of the work's composition is still left in the hands of the human behind the machine. With generative AI models, the human creative process is ditched completely and all that's considered is the end result. Rather than the human mind portraying one's unique perception of the world through creative expression, a lifeless machine shows the user what it thinks they want to see based on a prompt. Two entirely different topics here
@theothertonydutch20 күн бұрын
Mate. AI-art plagiarizes all other art.
@purplemicrodot5821 күн бұрын
So agree. An A.I. image is no more art than a dog's pawprint.
@divinethrash420621 күн бұрын
That’s still natural and made organically
@Ryftrr21 күн бұрын
@@divinethrash4206right, so even the dog's pawprint is more "art" than what a generative AI spits out. The Humanities are humanities no longer when the party responsible is not human.
@1jotun13621 күн бұрын
Butlerian Jihad
@SteveWeas21 күн бұрын
Is this essay AI generated?
@joshuakrook121 күн бұрын
No, but that would be funny. The examples are from AI images but the text is normal.
@purplemicrodot5821 күн бұрын
That's a hilariously relevant question. 🤣
Ай бұрын
lovely game
@_tho_max_Ай бұрын
The story and character have striking similarities with “The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone” by Tennessee Williams
@_mvr1981_Ай бұрын
Hypothetical future, or the real world outside the matrix? Maybe we are living inside one of those towers. Connected and dreaming.
@LogCoulson92 ай бұрын
I starte watching his work with the young pope expecting just a satirical and cynical take on the papacy and religion. I ended the show in tears and blown away by the beauty and heart in it
@user-rf1wp3sb2i2 ай бұрын
I've come to notice a pattern in videos that critique the negative effects of tech and social media--the frequent use of footage depicting young girls dancing, or doing makeup and taking selfies, as representative of the negative effects of the medium While there are reasonable interpretations to be made from this (tech platforms are shallow, hedonistic, equate appearance with worth, push unrealistic standards, give people body-image issues etc.), I think the use of these visual motifs, especially when taking into account their frequency, ultimately comes off as more reactionary, shifting blame for social ills onto women The film critic Roger Ebert once described Film as not an intellectual or logical medium, but an emotional one. That is, the immediate impact of the visuals is what sinks in most for the audience. Satirical films like Fight Club or American Psycho are notorious for being misinterpreted and having their characters idolized, and Ebert would say that the audience could not be faulted for taking things at face value. The images argue for themselves. Talking about the numbing, oppressive nature of tech over footage of young women dancing ultimately appeals to the same instincts behind the Salem witch trials-inspiring a punitive stance towards the harmless expressions of young women, in place of the real causes. While the true culprits and those with power-tech execs, legislators, and such-appear inaccessible to the average person, young women are everywhere as an easy vector for ire and resent, and many online movements harboring these misplaced grievances have sprung up
@kieran_forster_artist2 ай бұрын
Brilliant. Scarily reminiscent of my pre medicine, pre psychiatry life that was much more amenable to the pursuit of art seriously. The idea of Peter Pan syndrome bc of a desire to write a novel is beyond stupid. It’s profoundly sad.
@kieran_forster_artist2 ай бұрын
Brilliant short summary of this living genius! So happy to hear another Australian seeing his truth
@StephenLyons-tl8ie2 ай бұрын
Just a note; The letter "T" in certain words should not be replaced by the letter "D".
@stephenelkington49713 ай бұрын
Friedman said 'Government's don't have responsibilities - people have responsibilities'. Citizens of advanced societies in the West think that there government has a responsibility to organise the defence of their nations, to provide them with access to healthcare [even if not directly provided by the state] and to provide their children with an education. We also expect governments to invest in the infrastructure - roads, rail, water, sewage, energy provision [we expect the government to keep the lights on !]. I think the citizens are better judges of the situation than Friedman. Under Thatcher and her successors governments have sought to renege on their responsibilities with fairly disastrous results. Filthy beaches, rivers, expensive unreliable trains a collapsing health service have been the actual experiences under 'free market' policies. The promised 'shangri-la' has proved utterly illusory.
@barryloughran36323 ай бұрын
the sun doesnt Rise or Set, it's a fixed Star. The world Turns.
@mishmohd3 ай бұрын
well what do you expect one to do, accept their lot in life? the sanctimony of the elites has been forever shattered, and now more than ever they withhold and gatekeeper knowledge and culture. What am I supposed to do? Curtsy and sing their praises? the cult of achievement society is brute forcing upward class movement. At some point, one must see the world as it is not as it ought to be.
@TalbotDeKlerk-co1ej4 ай бұрын
Thank you my broer dankie.
@mostafa-re7fm4 ай бұрын
I'm a law PhD student. I would be thankful if you could introduce me to some resources about this subject.
@joshuakrook14 ай бұрын
You can start with my PhD :) newintrigue.com/2021/09/07/towards-a-new-law-school-curriculum-in-australia-full-text-pdf/
@mostafa-re7fm4 ай бұрын
@@joshuakrook1 tnks but it is related to legal education 🤣
@flynnjaman4 ай бұрын
Quite fond of the cut to mom’s spaghetti 🍝 to represent loneliness, foreign lands & the surreal
@joshuakrook14 ай бұрын
Murakami has several chapters of his character just cooking spaghetti haha.
@flynnjaman4 ай бұрын
@@joshuakrook1 it was only after I had written this comment that I finished listening & heard the you insinuate what you mentioned above.
@flynnjaman4 ай бұрын
I just purchased NW, I is my first HM novel
@SterileNeutrino4 ай бұрын
Worlds explored since the coof circus: The one of Death Stranding (dead and empty but also beautiful and haunting), the one of Horizon Zero Dawn (alive and complex), the one of Vandermeer's Borne (3 books, hostile in every aspect), the one of Simon Stalenhag (memories of a past that doesn't exist).
@TreeLuvBurdpu4 ай бұрын
Why do you use technology to shame others for using technology? Does that make you feel better about yourself? Better than others?
@LONDONFIELDS20015 ай бұрын
BCH is absolutely fundamental right now. Fundamental.
@blueyedmule5 ай бұрын
Gary Vaynerchuck does NOT approve.
@NY_Mountain_Man5 ай бұрын
I forgot about this concept. Thank you.
@BradConroy_guitar5 ай бұрын
Great video. This book made a huge impact on me in the early 2000's.
@duannehaughton48935 ай бұрын
Great video, thank you. Wished it was longer, but if it was, it would have been bombarded with more interrupting advertisements probably…
@joshuakrook15 ай бұрын
Good point :)
@NJGuy19734 ай бұрын
@@joshuakrook1 The most important passage in "Amusing Ourselves To Death": "What would you think of my book if I suddenly paused and wrote a few words on behalf of United Airlines or Chase Manhattan Bank? You would rightly think I had no respect for you, and certainly no respect for the subject." Postman then continued: "We expect books and even movies to maintain consistency of tone and continuity of content. But we're no longer struck dumb, as any sane person would be, when a newscaster, having just declared that nuclear war is inevitable, goes on to say he will be right back after this word from Burger King."
@NotBanned_6 ай бұрын
“The furies are at home in the mirror; it is their address. Even the clearest water, if deep enough can drown.”
@kenrickbaughman9926 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing 🙏. Simon definitely has an 3rd eye view of life. Im an 22 year Professional Tattooist and Artist. I think Simon S is probably has some of THE best visuals, imagery and futuristic way of how humans are addicted to technology.
@Embassy_of_Jupiter6 ай бұрын
I don't think the aura of mystery necessarily has to disappear when you translate such art to cinema. It's just a shitty adaption. And also mass market cinematography makes this almost impossible. You would need long static scenic shots like in Stalker (1971) or Blade Runner 2049, but then people complain that it's boring. Imagine that feeling of chilling on a hill with some friends in quiet contemplation on a warm autumn evening watching the sunset with zero stress, listening to the leaves rustling in the wind. Or taking a walk in a quiet snowy night through some deep fresh snow in a quaint little village. You can't capture that feeling with a 2 second shot. 😂 Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, Dorohedoro, Cowboy Bebop, Ergo Proxy, Kill la Kill and Girls Last Tour, I think, are all anime that perfectly capture the feeling behind the art. It is certainly possible. It's just extremely rare, requiring exceptional talent.
@jjmars91606 ай бұрын
I recently, a month or two ago, happened to stumble across these amazing paintings. After a little research I started to follow Stalenhag creations and storyline. Like Mr. Spock would say, " totally fascinating ".
@caronalain6 ай бұрын
Thanks Joshua. I studied personally with Neil Postman. He was a great man. Although ultimately provocative, he was quite conscious of his « transgressions », which at that time were a national sport among hard thinkers ( artists, composers, writers) catching new human truths, as well as old eternal ones. Neil Postman was a nice person and a good human being.
@rmschindler1446 ай бұрын
Made me cry.
@BenjaminSteber6 ай бұрын
2:40 - Shout out to Bridgeport, CT.
@chilledtea66146 ай бұрын
I had no idea they made it into an Amazon series! Wow!
@NineInchTyrone6 ай бұрын
Where are the windmills ?
@NineInchTyrone6 ай бұрын
MODERAN
@Saint_Svadhisthana_Sahasrara_16 ай бұрын
Actually, Orwell & Huxley were both right.
@ZephyrusAsmodeus7 ай бұрын
1909.. that's remarkable insight into the human-machine condition for so long ago
@RLReagan7 ай бұрын
You have a great narration voice. Not British but a fairly distinctive N American. I think most prefer your dialect as authoritative. There’s a show where the British Captain guy speaks American because it’s a space luxury cruise ship and supposed to give him a more comforting, professional manner. Funny how it used to be the other way. Altho thinking about it I guess I’d want my spaceship cruise captain to be American for some weird reason.
@joshuakrook122 күн бұрын
Australian, although spent so much time in the UK that maybe it muddled it a bit haha
@prof.puggle16317 ай бұрын
lil beauty
@ocin79177 ай бұрын
Is that a kiwi accent??
@joshuakrook17 ай бұрын
aussie but close haha
@kmg36587 ай бұрын
🙂
@gwynkrook32837 ай бұрын
Hello Josh. I found this incredible. I love the way you understand Japanese culture hear. Did they invent haiku, hope so. is right. I love the way you see the difference between eastern culture men and women. A protagonist sounds like a narcissist evil. In this day and age men like you and Aidan are far more convious. I love history this is what I learnt from your short movie. Books are beautiful to read. I love opening up the eyes of the mind in a novel. Lesbian I'm not at all but I'm going to try find the movie on bee. I relate to the Indian culture and do yoga as a daily practice. I read Amy Tan the valley of amazement. It's an easy read on what Chinese woman go through pursue it. It's really a quick read. I love the way civilisation has helped society to learn from the past progression is awesome. I love the way you say we need to dance. I love psytrance and plan on doing film crew work and helping Aidan do sound crew work at big parties and concerts. You so good looking. This was absolutely amazing to watch
@domm13417 ай бұрын
Thanks for making this video. I think that, no matter how hard we try, we cannot be complete in ourselves. The passage of time sees to that.
Пікірлер
The two I love are 1. Does Australia have free speech is in the new citizenship test AND the answer is not NO! OOPS 2. Everyone sites Australia has signed Human Rights treaties etc.. BUT no-one ever reads the fine print down the bottom that states Australia only abides by these treaties etc within the boundaries of The Australian Constitution!!!! Ergo NO FREE SPEECH!!!! Ooops sorry The High Court does agree that we have an IMPLIED right to "political communication" unless of course you're a public servant, work for a charity etc etc etc
Nothing is real
Amusing Ourselves to Death is one of the core books I always go back to
"Artificial Intelligence" is an idiot. There is no understanding of what a "dog" is, just some weighted variables in images tagged with the keyword "dog." It's not intelligence in any workable sense, it's just a keyword swarm attached to a data cloud. It's like a blind idiot shouting a name every time it's prodded with a stick. There's no thought there, just reaction. There's no intelligence there, just a blind process drawing images when prodded with keywords. This isn't "art." It can't be. If an AI is trained on only its own output, it will generate noise. Nothing more, nothing less. Just random gibberish that means nothing, forever and ever. A human given no input will generate childish imagery at first, but refine it over time to something artistic. "AI" is an idiot generation machine, producing only copies of what it has been given, unable to produce anything original or even interesting. Until an AI can describe a dog and argue what is or is not a dog, it cannot be intelligent. It's just an idiot shouting "DOG" when you ask it to draw a dog.
While I don't disagree, I've yet to encounter a single definition for "Art"
This is misleading, due to ignorance or purposefully. There is a huge difference between images generated ONLY through text, and artwork assisted with AI. Both use AI, but the method varies greatly. This is causing confusion and hypes up AI to a level that it will never be able to achieve, because applied arts is problem solving and art is about an experience translated into a medium. Images generated with text is a roll of the dice, and assuming this random element is somewhat a threat is not founded in reality. Be careful. Plus, a quick search here in KZread demonstrates that people wanting to make money with AI art is the biggest challenge of all, not because it's AI, but because the business of art itself is a tough one to break into AND sustain in the long term. Every one of those videos have people making less than $30 profit in their experiments. Do your homework.
Have you ever considered the possibility that artists can't directly interact with generative AI because it's still very new??? Before Photoshop, Blender, Maya, etc. universities were still working on particular algorithms to get things to just work, and didn't yet implement user friendly GUIs and tools. Instead of bemoaning the death of art as we know it (because it isn't): you should focus on pushing the need for interactivity/user-input for AI-based tools, which will inevitably happen anyway because prompts can only go so far.
You're completely missing the point of what generative AI does. With software tools like the ones you named, the creative process and generation of the work's composition is still left in the hands of the human behind the machine. With generative AI models, the human creative process is ditched completely and all that's considered is the end result. Rather than the human mind portraying one's unique perception of the world through creative expression, a lifeless machine shows the user what it thinks they want to see based on a prompt. Two entirely different topics here
Mate. AI-art plagiarizes all other art.
So agree. An A.I. image is no more art than a dog's pawprint.
That’s still natural and made organically
@@divinethrash4206right, so even the dog's pawprint is more "art" than what a generative AI spits out. The Humanities are humanities no longer when the party responsible is not human.
Butlerian Jihad
Is this essay AI generated?
No, but that would be funny. The examples are from AI images but the text is normal.
That's a hilariously relevant question. 🤣
lovely game
The story and character have striking similarities with “The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone” by Tennessee Williams
Hypothetical future, or the real world outside the matrix? Maybe we are living inside one of those towers. Connected and dreaming.
I starte watching his work with the young pope expecting just a satirical and cynical take on the papacy and religion. I ended the show in tears and blown away by the beauty and heart in it
I've come to notice a pattern in videos that critique the negative effects of tech and social media--the frequent use of footage depicting young girls dancing, or doing makeup and taking selfies, as representative of the negative effects of the medium While there are reasonable interpretations to be made from this (tech platforms are shallow, hedonistic, equate appearance with worth, push unrealistic standards, give people body-image issues etc.), I think the use of these visual motifs, especially when taking into account their frequency, ultimately comes off as more reactionary, shifting blame for social ills onto women The film critic Roger Ebert once described Film as not an intellectual or logical medium, but an emotional one. That is, the immediate impact of the visuals is what sinks in most for the audience. Satirical films like Fight Club or American Psycho are notorious for being misinterpreted and having their characters idolized, and Ebert would say that the audience could not be faulted for taking things at face value. The images argue for themselves. Talking about the numbing, oppressive nature of tech over footage of young women dancing ultimately appeals to the same instincts behind the Salem witch trials-inspiring a punitive stance towards the harmless expressions of young women, in place of the real causes. While the true culprits and those with power-tech execs, legislators, and such-appear inaccessible to the average person, young women are everywhere as an easy vector for ire and resent, and many online movements harboring these misplaced grievances have sprung up
Brilliant. Scarily reminiscent of my pre medicine, pre psychiatry life that was much more amenable to the pursuit of art seriously. The idea of Peter Pan syndrome bc of a desire to write a novel is beyond stupid. It’s profoundly sad.
Brilliant short summary of this living genius! So happy to hear another Australian seeing his truth
Just a note; The letter "T" in certain words should not be replaced by the letter "D".
Friedman said 'Government's don't have responsibilities - people have responsibilities'. Citizens of advanced societies in the West think that there government has a responsibility to organise the defence of their nations, to provide them with access to healthcare [even if not directly provided by the state] and to provide their children with an education. We also expect governments to invest in the infrastructure - roads, rail, water, sewage, energy provision [we expect the government to keep the lights on !]. I think the citizens are better judges of the situation than Friedman. Under Thatcher and her successors governments have sought to renege on their responsibilities with fairly disastrous results. Filthy beaches, rivers, expensive unreliable trains a collapsing health service have been the actual experiences under 'free market' policies. The promised 'shangri-la' has proved utterly illusory.
the sun doesnt Rise or Set, it's a fixed Star. The world Turns.
well what do you expect one to do, accept their lot in life? the sanctimony of the elites has been forever shattered, and now more than ever they withhold and gatekeeper knowledge and culture. What am I supposed to do? Curtsy and sing their praises? the cult of achievement society is brute forcing upward class movement. At some point, one must see the world as it is not as it ought to be.
Thank you my broer dankie.
I'm a law PhD student. I would be thankful if you could introduce me to some resources about this subject.
You can start with my PhD :) newintrigue.com/2021/09/07/towards-a-new-law-school-curriculum-in-australia-full-text-pdf/
@@joshuakrook1 tnks but it is related to legal education 🤣
Quite fond of the cut to mom’s spaghetti 🍝 to represent loneliness, foreign lands & the surreal
Murakami has several chapters of his character just cooking spaghetti haha.
@@joshuakrook1 it was only after I had written this comment that I finished listening & heard the you insinuate what you mentioned above.
I just purchased NW, I is my first HM novel
Worlds explored since the coof circus: The one of Death Stranding (dead and empty but also beautiful and haunting), the one of Horizon Zero Dawn (alive and complex), the one of Vandermeer's Borne (3 books, hostile in every aspect), the one of Simon Stalenhag (memories of a past that doesn't exist).
Why do you use technology to shame others for using technology? Does that make you feel better about yourself? Better than others?
BCH is absolutely fundamental right now. Fundamental.
Gary Vaynerchuck does NOT approve.
I forgot about this concept. Thank you.
Great video. This book made a huge impact on me in the early 2000's.
Great video, thank you. Wished it was longer, but if it was, it would have been bombarded with more interrupting advertisements probably…
Good point :)
@@joshuakrook1 The most important passage in "Amusing Ourselves To Death": "What would you think of my book if I suddenly paused and wrote a few words on behalf of United Airlines or Chase Manhattan Bank? You would rightly think I had no respect for you, and certainly no respect for the subject." Postman then continued: "We expect books and even movies to maintain consistency of tone and continuity of content. But we're no longer struck dumb, as any sane person would be, when a newscaster, having just declared that nuclear war is inevitable, goes on to say he will be right back after this word from Burger King."
“The furies are at home in the mirror; it is their address. Even the clearest water, if deep enough can drown.”
Thanks for sharing 🙏. Simon definitely has an 3rd eye view of life. Im an 22 year Professional Tattooist and Artist. I think Simon S is probably has some of THE best visuals, imagery and futuristic way of how humans are addicted to technology.
I don't think the aura of mystery necessarily has to disappear when you translate such art to cinema. It's just a shitty adaption. And also mass market cinematography makes this almost impossible. You would need long static scenic shots like in Stalker (1971) or Blade Runner 2049, but then people complain that it's boring. Imagine that feeling of chilling on a hill with some friends in quiet contemplation on a warm autumn evening watching the sunset with zero stress, listening to the leaves rustling in the wind. Or taking a walk in a quiet snowy night through some deep fresh snow in a quaint little village. You can't capture that feeling with a 2 second shot. 😂 Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, Dorohedoro, Cowboy Bebop, Ergo Proxy, Kill la Kill and Girls Last Tour, I think, are all anime that perfectly capture the feeling behind the art. It is certainly possible. It's just extremely rare, requiring exceptional talent.
I recently, a month or two ago, happened to stumble across these amazing paintings. After a little research I started to follow Stalenhag creations and storyline. Like Mr. Spock would say, " totally fascinating ".
Thanks Joshua. I studied personally with Neil Postman. He was a great man. Although ultimately provocative, he was quite conscious of his « transgressions », which at that time were a national sport among hard thinkers ( artists, composers, writers) catching new human truths, as well as old eternal ones. Neil Postman was a nice person and a good human being.
Made me cry.
2:40 - Shout out to Bridgeport, CT.
I had no idea they made it into an Amazon series! Wow!
Where are the windmills ?
MODERAN
Actually, Orwell & Huxley were both right.
1909.. that's remarkable insight into the human-machine condition for so long ago
You have a great narration voice. Not British but a fairly distinctive N American. I think most prefer your dialect as authoritative. There’s a show where the British Captain guy speaks American because it’s a space luxury cruise ship and supposed to give him a more comforting, professional manner. Funny how it used to be the other way. Altho thinking about it I guess I’d want my spaceship cruise captain to be American for some weird reason.
Australian, although spent so much time in the UK that maybe it muddled it a bit haha
lil beauty
Is that a kiwi accent??
aussie but close haha
🙂
Hello Josh. I found this incredible. I love the way you understand Japanese culture hear. Did they invent haiku, hope so. is right. I love the way you see the difference between eastern culture men and women. A protagonist sounds like a narcissist evil. In this day and age men like you and Aidan are far more convious. I love history this is what I learnt from your short movie. Books are beautiful to read. I love opening up the eyes of the mind in a novel. Lesbian I'm not at all but I'm going to try find the movie on bee. I relate to the Indian culture and do yoga as a daily practice. I read Amy Tan the valley of amazement. It's an easy read on what Chinese woman go through pursue it. It's really a quick read. I love the way civilisation has helped society to learn from the past progression is awesome. I love the way you say we need to dance. I love psytrance and plan on doing film crew work and helping Aidan do sound crew work at big parties and concerts. You so good looking. This was absolutely amazing to watch
Thanks for making this video. I think that, no matter how hard we try, we cannot be complete in ourselves. The passage of time sees to that.