As advance as they proud themselves to be, they are as primitive as our " midevil Era "
@CasTro-ex6zi17 минут бұрын
So we are unisolarans?
@isaganipalanca880330 минут бұрын
I was quite skeptical of this production at first, the initial visuals conveying a totally lunatic, cheap and nasty "Hogwarts" and "Harry Potter" feel, testament to the writers' obvious ignorance if not downright disrespect the source material (witches? Ahhh! = let's default to the Wizarding World - that's what people know and want!), in addition to an "Empress Natalya" who was never in the books and the advancement of the younger, hotter sister (a minor character at best!), Tula Harkonnen, as lead, over the Atreides, Raquella Berto-Anirul and Valya Harkonnen of the book, owing to greater eye candy potential... I mean, there was this visual of a generic Victorian haunted house/British boarding school building on a Scottish moor making the rounds, completely ignoring the fact that the sisterhood originated in a seaside cliff/grotto on the tropical jungle planet Rossak... But the departures of writers, showrunners and actors from the project as well as the success of the Villeneuve films must have worked wonders in eliminating the most absurd and egregious inaccuracies born of stupidity and laziness and superficial grasp of the original works, let alone canon. At least it now displays the stylish look of the Villeneuve Dune with heavy Foundation vibes (on a smaller budget) which has done a world of good. I will watch this, as opposed to hate-watch. I am also gratified that the reverend mothers at this point were cast with rather plain but expressive women and not vapid sex-pots (that came later actually, in the Muad'dib timeline, which is why I didn't like the austerely good-looking Rebecca Ferguson as much in the Jessica role as more book-accurately ravishing hothouse-beauty, Francesca Annis of the Lynch movie, as, let's face it, the Bene gesserit consorts of the later empire were literal overpowered honey traps). I am suspending my judgement as of now.
@user-lm8xe9cn8z41 минут бұрын
Toon would work, movie floop
@chancellorpalpatine4035Сағат бұрын
I maintain the movies are often the woes part of Star Wars. Books, comics, and shows are more interesting in general.
@ansaz14Сағат бұрын
Speak for yourself. I rooted for the humans to the bitter end or last bite, whichever came first.
@BleuCzechСағат бұрын
Some thoughts How long of a stable period does it take to create a sophon? How is it better for the San-Ti to go through the expense of destroying, then occupating earth vs. finding a suitable home on any of the nearby stars?
@yogagalactica99942 сағат бұрын
Great mic. Love your videos. I’d recommend moving the mic arm so it’s not in frame.
@mishjone2 сағат бұрын
Well heater Lucas got idea for Star Wars from Dune. And copied alot of things from Dune. So of course it would seem like space game of thrones
@mishjone2 сағат бұрын
It just a teaser way too early to form a narrative of the whole movie
@shaddouida34472 сағат бұрын
3 Body Problem Season 2 Update 3 Body Problem Season 3 Update
@CYI3ERPUNK2 сағат бұрын
“Highly organized commercial products are guaranteed to produce nothing new/original/unique/interesting.” - some guy named after a mouse shaped moon thingy , probably
@TheMrdatruth3 сағат бұрын
Nice story telling thx, but wtf, how a sophon didnt can help the traitors to build Terminator like AI Bots to kill humans, or transfer the knowlege from the Santis to the Traitors...
@pandycious3 сағат бұрын
So hard to get through this video. Too much negativity. Also Quinn just keeps repeating over & over & over & over & over again how it looks too much like the Dune films (duh) & House of the Dragon. So tedious. We get it, move on. Stop repeating your self.
@margaretjohnson62593 сағат бұрын
very good.
@Tattletale973 сағат бұрын
Dune Messiah is going to piss off soo many Muslim~
@dylangullberg73834 сағат бұрын
I haven’t read the Sisterhood book. Does any of this footage seem like it was pulled from the details in the book? I’m surprised you didn’t do much of a breakdown/comparison.
@kikidevine6945 сағат бұрын
Emily Watson? That's a hard yes, already. The harkonens were disgraced because one of them disobeyed orders which would have won a battle, but resulted in the deaths of millions.
@BleuCzech5 сағат бұрын
Quinn, thanks for your wonderful work in SyFi. Who once said "The problem with science fiction is that it is much too unimaginative". Now that we know season 2 is a go, do you think Netflix will wrap the story up with all that still needs to happen or gamble for a third?
@johnrex71086 сағат бұрын
Well, The Culture sounds like hellscape. What is the point in being a good person when it is merely enforced through constant observation and punishment (through drones and AI), and genetic modification making you comply on a physical level with the expected norms of society? There's no choice there, only submission.
@eauchellassariangcl99946 сағат бұрын
Begin with all these allegations I am supposed to accept? Says who? Sorry. Will check this out again another time. But ofcourse. Peace.
@V1NC3NTG7 сағат бұрын
I've never read the books. But way before the series came out I watched all your videos. It made enjoying the show that much more interesting because I had so much backstory from you ahead of time. Thanks for your content.
@br7693t8 сағат бұрын
"there are good things"...still waiting to hear one that's not couched in criticism. Just don't watch the show, it's simple.
@ocularorb40218 сағат бұрын
2:12:41 bizarre audio mixing
@ocularorb40218 сағат бұрын
....on a lunchbreak? do british people have longer lunch breaks because no way im finishing a spearhead game in 30 minutes
@AlexisLK8 сағат бұрын
You were right, HBO is expanding the Dune universe on screen with series and if it's successful it's just the beginning
@DuBoisatl8 сағат бұрын
Literally had a boner so the moment I saw Dune….
@yoooo7909 сағат бұрын
We as a people are not ready.
@RegularRegs9 сағат бұрын
Just imagine them trying to do a smart baby in film again. Last time I saw it was in Twilight's last movie and WOOF ... bad CGI lol. It was horrifying. Imagine adding speech to that. Yikes.
@heyhiheythere52439 сағат бұрын
So there is no stimuli in eternity if so then the brain would not eat itself but grow unchecked u would come back a god not broken by the laws of physics good story tho but in reality its what our live now do eventually we will die the same way these people do if we r lucky some might get murdered or eatn or accidents happen but this is the goal of life to die wiyh white hair starin into space completely checked out lol
@heyhiheythere52439 сағат бұрын
Praise Jesus 😂
@lucyrobinson28149 сағат бұрын
SURELY...looking like DV Dune is a GOOD THING? Biggest franchise in a while now launched...world a bit gaga for it...GoT S8 failure... We NEED a transition piece...like this...hook noobs...but hold the initial hands of long term fans. Space Game of Thrones...is PRECISELY what this needs to be...to start with. It's that simple. Do love you Quinn...but the levels of Dune gatekeeping going on with this reaction to the trailer is a bit silly. If it had veered far from looking like DV work...no doubt there would be just the same reaction but moaning doesn't look DV like enough. Can't win. This is the Dune for the meantime. With high expectation...and low expectation. Brian a writer...so...yeah... Space GoT...just Go With It ❤
@zCopyCatz10 сағат бұрын
Probably way too much drama for my liking, honestly was hoping for a Children of Dune remake.
@CousinSlowhands12 сағат бұрын
lovecraft wasn't flawed, you have the flaw, /hate
@stevengordon214512 сағат бұрын
In your statements brother...you hit apon a problem the television & movie industry always suffers... Everything is judged by what came before. For the lens to shift it takes great caution or throw caution to the wind. ... I'm holding off all judgement until I've watched the entire series.
@johnnybwrexter982813 сағат бұрын
So I'd it doesn't reference anything from the books and as new characters. Cool judge on own merits.
@GenerationBright13 сағат бұрын
I'm gonna say, before I watch this review, that I thought the first season was very good. It genuinely made me cry on episode 7 multiple times. This being said, a lot of the harder science fiction discussions were just not there & parts of the show, especially in the first 2 episodes, felt very preachy. I'm hesitantly optimistic that the parts of the show that really worked - the interpersonal plots & performances, will continue to work in the next season. But I don't think for a second the extremely weird science fiction elements the rest of the stuff & the third book explore will be properly represented due to the show runners (iykyk) & the need for mass appeal (Netflix mandate).
@san.r.913913 сағат бұрын
"The universe is entirely mathematics" My OCD: Statement = True
@Chuckf6614 сағат бұрын
Petition to require Quinn to read all the great Sci Fi works because DAMN he's good!
@elizabethwilde114315 сағат бұрын
It'd be cool af if they told the stories from the scattering and what the honered maters were running from.
@RozWBrazel15 сағат бұрын
I intend to read this, then Arrival(formerly Stories of Your Life and Others) as a palate cleanser.
@sergio764417 сағат бұрын
Where is the Fedora! I am confused???
@Hal-Embers17 сағат бұрын
But if the resetters lower themselves to 0 dimensions before they set the rest of existance into 1st dimension wont they theoretically reach the 10th dimension before us and only for like a few nano seconds before the universe reaches the 9th on its own?
@richard246195617 сағат бұрын
"He did this while singing." 😂
@timothymorgan117517 сағат бұрын
I am going to see this,but my only concern is how in DUNE PART 1&2 The Spaceing Guild had no impact at all,And the way the movie made it seem that the Sisterhood was the greatest power in the Galaxy. I am getting the same vibe here.
@timothykalamaros295417 сағат бұрын
Harlingen disgrace came from Butlerian jihad incident
@gmiller416518 сағат бұрын
If you want another scifi work that’ll give you an existential crisis, I highly recommend reading Blindsight by Peter Watts, if you haven’t read it. It’s one of the more internally distressing reads I’ve had and wish it would be adapted as a short TV series.
@georgegach718 сағат бұрын
This is not Villeneuve. Same color grading and set pieces at best.
@korvusknull144718 сағат бұрын
I don't think it's ten thousand years before, it is just the narration talking about the founding of the system. I believe it takes place closer to the books.
@TimothyWhiteowl18 сағат бұрын
around 10,000 years prior to the events of DUNE is when the spice made it's way into the empire so, it may have been the first attempts at using the spice liquor for the transformation.
@kikidevine6945 сағат бұрын
And the Guild was pretty much set up during the BJ, same time as the Bene Gesserit
Пікірлер
As advance as they proud themselves to be, they are as primitive as our " midevil Era "
So we are unisolarans?
I was quite skeptical of this production at first, the initial visuals conveying a totally lunatic, cheap and nasty "Hogwarts" and "Harry Potter" feel, testament to the writers' obvious ignorance if not downright disrespect the source material (witches? Ahhh! = let's default to the Wizarding World - that's what people know and want!), in addition to an "Empress Natalya" who was never in the books and the advancement of the younger, hotter sister (a minor character at best!), Tula Harkonnen, as lead, over the Atreides, Raquella Berto-Anirul and Valya Harkonnen of the book, owing to greater eye candy potential... I mean, there was this visual of a generic Victorian haunted house/British boarding school building on a Scottish moor making the rounds, completely ignoring the fact that the sisterhood originated in a seaside cliff/grotto on the tropical jungle planet Rossak... But the departures of writers, showrunners and actors from the project as well as the success of the Villeneuve films must have worked wonders in eliminating the most absurd and egregious inaccuracies born of stupidity and laziness and superficial grasp of the original works, let alone canon. At least it now displays the stylish look of the Villeneuve Dune with heavy Foundation vibes (on a smaller budget) which has done a world of good. I will watch this, as opposed to hate-watch. I am also gratified that the reverend mothers at this point were cast with rather plain but expressive women and not vapid sex-pots (that came later actually, in the Muad'dib timeline, which is why I didn't like the austerely good-looking Rebecca Ferguson as much in the Jessica role as more book-accurately ravishing hothouse-beauty, Francesca Annis of the Lynch movie, as, let's face it, the Bene gesserit consorts of the later empire were literal overpowered honey traps). I am suspending my judgement as of now.
Toon would work, movie floop
I maintain the movies are often the woes part of Star Wars. Books, comics, and shows are more interesting in general.
Speak for yourself. I rooted for the humans to the bitter end or last bite, whichever came first.
Some thoughts How long of a stable period does it take to create a sophon? How is it better for the San-Ti to go through the expense of destroying, then occupating earth vs. finding a suitable home on any of the nearby stars?
Great mic. Love your videos. I’d recommend moving the mic arm so it’s not in frame.
Well heater Lucas got idea for Star Wars from Dune. And copied alot of things from Dune. So of course it would seem like space game of thrones
It just a teaser way too early to form a narrative of the whole movie
3 Body Problem Season 2 Update 3 Body Problem Season 3 Update
“Highly organized commercial products are guaranteed to produce nothing new/original/unique/interesting.” - some guy named after a mouse shaped moon thingy , probably
Nice story telling thx, but wtf, how a sophon didnt can help the traitors to build Terminator like AI Bots to kill humans, or transfer the knowlege from the Santis to the Traitors...
So hard to get through this video. Too much negativity. Also Quinn just keeps repeating over & over & over & over & over again how it looks too much like the Dune films (duh) & House of the Dragon. So tedious. We get it, move on. Stop repeating your self.
very good.
Dune Messiah is going to piss off soo many Muslim~
I haven’t read the Sisterhood book. Does any of this footage seem like it was pulled from the details in the book? I’m surprised you didn’t do much of a breakdown/comparison.
Emily Watson? That's a hard yes, already. The harkonens were disgraced because one of them disobeyed orders which would have won a battle, but resulted in the deaths of millions.
Quinn, thanks for your wonderful work in SyFi. Who once said "The problem with science fiction is that it is much too unimaginative". Now that we know season 2 is a go, do you think Netflix will wrap the story up with all that still needs to happen or gamble for a third?
Well, The Culture sounds like hellscape. What is the point in being a good person when it is merely enforced through constant observation and punishment (through drones and AI), and genetic modification making you comply on a physical level with the expected norms of society? There's no choice there, only submission.
Begin with all these allegations I am supposed to accept? Says who? Sorry. Will check this out again another time. But ofcourse. Peace.
I've never read the books. But way before the series came out I watched all your videos. It made enjoying the show that much more interesting because I had so much backstory from you ahead of time. Thanks for your content.
"there are good things"...still waiting to hear one that's not couched in criticism. Just don't watch the show, it's simple.
2:12:41 bizarre audio mixing
....on a lunchbreak? do british people have longer lunch breaks because no way im finishing a spearhead game in 30 minutes
You were right, HBO is expanding the Dune universe on screen with series and if it's successful it's just the beginning
Literally had a boner so the moment I saw Dune….
We as a people are not ready.
Just imagine them trying to do a smart baby in film again. Last time I saw it was in Twilight's last movie and WOOF ... bad CGI lol. It was horrifying. Imagine adding speech to that. Yikes.
So there is no stimuli in eternity if so then the brain would not eat itself but grow unchecked u would come back a god not broken by the laws of physics good story tho but in reality its what our live now do eventually we will die the same way these people do if we r lucky some might get murdered or eatn or accidents happen but this is the goal of life to die wiyh white hair starin into space completely checked out lol
Praise Jesus 😂
SURELY...looking like DV Dune is a GOOD THING? Biggest franchise in a while now launched...world a bit gaga for it...GoT S8 failure... We NEED a transition piece...like this...hook noobs...but hold the initial hands of long term fans. Space Game of Thrones...is PRECISELY what this needs to be...to start with. It's that simple. Do love you Quinn...but the levels of Dune gatekeeping going on with this reaction to the trailer is a bit silly. If it had veered far from looking like DV work...no doubt there would be just the same reaction but moaning doesn't look DV like enough. Can't win. This is the Dune for the meantime. With high expectation...and low expectation. Brian a writer...so...yeah... Space GoT...just Go With It ❤
Probably way too much drama for my liking, honestly was hoping for a Children of Dune remake.
lovecraft wasn't flawed, you have the flaw, /hate
In your statements brother...you hit apon a problem the television & movie industry always suffers... Everything is judged by what came before. For the lens to shift it takes great caution or throw caution to the wind. ... I'm holding off all judgement until I've watched the entire series.
So I'd it doesn't reference anything from the books and as new characters. Cool judge on own merits.
I'm gonna say, before I watch this review, that I thought the first season was very good. It genuinely made me cry on episode 7 multiple times. This being said, a lot of the harder science fiction discussions were just not there & parts of the show, especially in the first 2 episodes, felt very preachy. I'm hesitantly optimistic that the parts of the show that really worked - the interpersonal plots & performances, will continue to work in the next season. But I don't think for a second the extremely weird science fiction elements the rest of the stuff & the third book explore will be properly represented due to the show runners (iykyk) & the need for mass appeal (Netflix mandate).
"The universe is entirely mathematics" My OCD: Statement = True
Petition to require Quinn to read all the great Sci Fi works because DAMN he's good!
It'd be cool af if they told the stories from the scattering and what the honered maters were running from.
I intend to read this, then Arrival(formerly Stories of Your Life and Others) as a palate cleanser.
Where is the Fedora! I am confused???
But if the resetters lower themselves to 0 dimensions before they set the rest of existance into 1st dimension wont they theoretically reach the 10th dimension before us and only for like a few nano seconds before the universe reaches the 9th on its own?
"He did this while singing." 😂
I am going to see this,but my only concern is how in DUNE PART 1&2 The Spaceing Guild had no impact at all,And the way the movie made it seem that the Sisterhood was the greatest power in the Galaxy. I am getting the same vibe here.
Harlingen disgrace came from Butlerian jihad incident
If you want another scifi work that’ll give you an existential crisis, I highly recommend reading Blindsight by Peter Watts, if you haven’t read it. It’s one of the more internally distressing reads I’ve had and wish it would be adapted as a short TV series.
This is not Villeneuve. Same color grading and set pieces at best.
I don't think it's ten thousand years before, it is just the narration talking about the founding of the system. I believe it takes place closer to the books.
around 10,000 years prior to the events of DUNE is when the spice made it's way into the empire so, it may have been the first attempts at using the spice liquor for the transformation.
And the Guild was pretty much set up during the BJ, same time as the Bene Gesserit