The Blue Beetle Plays MTG Lord of the Rings | Xolo Maridueña | Game Knights 62 | Magic Commander
Ойындар
This video is sponsored by Wizards of the Coast. Become a Patron to support our content, receive awesome rewards, join our exclusive community and more! / commandzone
--------
Show Notes:
The Game Knights are going to Isengard, and they’re bringing a superhero! Xolo Maridueña (DC’s Blue Beetle) joins his Cobra Kai co-star Jacob Bertrand to face Jimmy and JLK on the fields of Middle Earth. Wielding legends from the new Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth set, these four heroes will do battle from the dark depths of Mordor to the glistening peaks of Minas Tirith. Don’t be fooled by their small size, this clash will be as epic as the War of the Ring itself!
It’s Theoden vs. Sauron vs. Samwise vs. Bombadil
Only One May Rule Them All!
----------
Order The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth Product Now!
magic.wizards.com/en/products...
----------
HELLOFRESH:
Try out America’s #1 Meal Kit! Go to www.hellofresh.com/knights16 and use code knights16 to get 16 free meals, plus free shipping!
STAMPS:
Get a 4-week trial, free postage, and a digital scale at www.stamps.com/knights. Thanks to Stamps.com for sponsoring the show!
FRAMEAMAJIGS:
Frameamajigs are the perfect framing solution for your collectible cards. Make your pledge on Kickstarter by June 28th at www.kickstarter.com/projects/...
----------
CARD KINGDOM:
Support our channel and get all of your cards in one fast and convenient package: www.cardkingdom.com/command
ULTRAPRO:
Keep your cards and game pieces protected with the best game accessories products in the business: ultrapro.com/command
Be sure to enter the giveaway at the end of the episode for a chance to win free MTG product and UltraPro swag! Get your entry in before winners are announced on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram on the evening of Wednesday, April 26th 2023.
ARCHIDEKT:
Discover, build, catalog, and playtest on Archidekt, the deck-building website that makes it easy to brew brand new lists or manage your old favorites. Go to www.archidekt.com/commandzone to get started today!
--------
Where to find our guests online:
Xolo Maridueña:
Twitter: @Xolo_Mariduena
IG: @Xolo_Mariduena
Jacob Bertrand:
Twitter: @jb_mixmatch
IG: @thejacobbertrand
TikTok: @jacob.bertrand
----------
Deck Lists:
Jimmy’s Samwise Gamgee Deck: www.archidekt.com/decks/47480...
JLK’s Tom Bombandil Deck: www.archidekt.com/decks/47482...
Xolo’s Theoden, King of Rohan Deck: www.archidekt.com/decks/47493...
Jacob’s Sauron, the Dark Lord Deck: www.archidekt.com/decks/47492...
--------
Credits:
Directed by: Josh Murphy
Executive Producer: Josh Lee Kwai
Co-Producer: Jimmy Wong
Lead Editor: Josh Murphy
Edited by: Manson Leung
Lead VFX: Sam Waldow
VFX Artist: Evan Limberger
Production Design: Ladee Danger
Environment Design: Evan Limberger & Sam Waldow
Post Production Supervisor: Jake Boss
Assistant Editor: Arthur Meadowcroft
Director of Photography: Jon Salmon
Gaffer: Jamie Sutor
Key Grip: Steven Escoboza
Production Sound: Jim Funicelli
Sound Mix: Josh Murphy
Theme Music: Post Malone
Judge: Jamie Block
Writers: Jordan Pridgen & Jamie Block
Production Assistant: Gabriel Pozos, Eric Lem, Arthur Meadowcroft
Tolkien Narration: Tim R.
--------
Follow us on Twitter!
@commandcast
@jfwong
@JoshLeeKwai
@wachelreeks
Follow us on Facebook:
/ commandcast
Follow us on Instagram:
@CommandCast
Email us:
commandzonecast@gmail.com
--------
What life total app do we use?
LIFELINKER:
Lifelinker is the premium Life Counter app for Magic: the Gathering - available for FREE on the Apple and Android App Stores now! Download Lifelinker today - available on Android and IOS platforms.
--------
Commander/EDH Official Rules, Banlist, FAQ, and more: mtgcommander.net
#magicthegathering #mtg #commander #mtgcommander #edh #gameknights #commandzone #lotr
Пікірлер: 1 500
Xolo: ‘Let’s go to combat’ Table: ‘You’ve already gone to combat’ Xolo: ‘I have once, but what about second combat?’
@TheMedievalMassacre
11 ай бұрын
This comment wins! XD
@obadijahparks
11 ай бұрын
Tasteful.... like the tears of their enemies.
@joshuaaronniquay5868
11 ай бұрын
What about the second breakfast?
@solomonaddariodavies8974
11 ай бұрын
Shouldnt jimmy have taken something like 24 damage from Thalia's lieutenant because of double strike?
@kevinwilliams5427
11 ай бұрын
this comment gets a chef kiss lol
“And I’ll deal with Josh later” a mistake many game knights guest have made
@joonatuominen7844
11 ай бұрын
Just forgets he has first strike so the death touch shouldnt matter
@joonatuominen7844
11 ай бұрын
Nvm, nissa had first strike also
@raiderdevellian5752
11 ай бұрын
1st rule of command zone....... You kill Josh 1st chance you get. Jimmy always kills himself
@joshuaaronniquay5868
11 ай бұрын
Josh is always a threat no matter the board state. I love every interactions he brings to the table.
@lehandroz
11 ай бұрын
It's basically how the script goes, as always. Jimmy always gets the short end of the stick.
FYI I ran 36 lands and 12 pieces of ramp in my deck - sometimes you just get unlucky with land drops. If someone else wants to calculate the likelihood of me missing a land drop after drawing so many cards, please feel free to do so. But need I remind you... t's a feature, not a bug people!!!! -jimmy
@Natedogg2
11 ай бұрын
Also, keep in mind that Jacob drew a bunch of cards with Rhystic Study and still managed to miss land drops. Sometimes, it just happens.
@SpellingBeeWiner
11 ай бұрын
Hahaha gotta love the proactive defense! Honestly I just liked seeing you run a deck with some incremental life gain so you don't die by accident the instant people think you're the threat!
@brisingr0962
11 ай бұрын
“Sometimes unlucky”. It’s not luck. It is the curse
@hotdachsbun
11 ай бұрын
I can't believe they all committed to shrinking themselves to be hobbits for one episode. That's dedication to the cause. Great game. Great production.
@bigblind6422
11 ай бұрын
I think deck builders are over valuing mana rocks and dorks over playing more lands. Yes, the ceiling is high when you can continue to hit your land drops and get ahead on mana, but many times in game if you miss that next land drop, then that other ramp piece was effectively a land. However rocks/dorks are easy to remove and they usually happen to get caught up by sweepers, putting you behind.
"I missed a land drop, so long as it doesn't become a pattern. I'll be fine" Famous last words before the drought.
@loganshaw4527
11 ай бұрын
The fool temping fate to be funny again.
@TheIhplodur
9 күн бұрын
Jimmy Missing a land drop is alraedy a pattern.😂
The table being excited about jimmy top decking a land is the most genuine casual commander interaction I have ever seen
@joshshin6819
11 ай бұрын
Jimmy I swear never mulligans on 2 land hands so him drawing a land is such a given 😂❤
@frisbeez1775
11 ай бұрын
Our group has a rule where if you miss a land drop 3 times in a row, you get a table rampant growth. We want people to play and missing land drops doesn't allow that.
@joshuaaronniquay5868
11 ай бұрын
@@frisbeez1775nice rule zero. I don’t like going against someone who missed land drop cuz I like to see them trying to stop me with all their ressources
@dylanmahoney4889
11 ай бұрын
Our play group idea the same thing
@Dragonspirit223
8 ай бұрын
@@frisbeez1775 I'm stealing this
Sam wise, Gandalf, and Treebeard defeat Sauron and then the rest of middle Earth turn on them. Incredible
@brogangoogerstaff
11 ай бұрын
That's what happened in the books right?
@1SI69
11 ай бұрын
@@brogangoogerstaff Each single word of it
@fernandozavaletabustos205
11 ай бұрын
A classic Fallout plot twist!
Jimmy missing land drops isn’t a curse - it's TRADITION!
@catbookworm6438
11 ай бұрын
Perhaps even... Historic!
@scottricks1676
11 ай бұрын
It’s a life style!
@user-fp2mv2qu6d
11 ай бұрын
THE TRUTH
"Xolo isn't the threat anymore" - Josh, before watching Xolo play Horn of Gondor the very next turn.
@josecampos9717
5 ай бұрын
Can someone please tell me how on earth when they started their decks were huge and an hour later their decks look exactly the same like please someone tell me why!??
@dispozablehero9829
5 ай бұрын
@@josecampos9717 because theres 99 cards in there. Theres no conspiracy going on
@josecampos9717
5 ай бұрын
@@dispozablehero9829 it still looks like the same deck after an hour lol that’s all I’m saying and they played a lot of cards
The giant table and chairs is too hilarious 😂😂
@joshshin6819
11 ай бұрын
Gotta love that LOTR throw back ❤😂
@jmeistergaming7399
11 ай бұрын
There decks are taller than they are
@xtremesonik2672
11 ай бұрын
6:41mins in, already a cool idea about the size of the players. This channel thinks of everything. Awesome guys!
This was an amazing game. An entire hour before someone got taken down, no one got screwed, everyone's deck got to shine, lots of deals, lots of ups and downs, it could have been anyone's game at any point. That's how it should be.
I love Jacob. Such an expressive, charismatic guy
@livleeson1705
11 ай бұрын
He’s so chill I love him!
@gareth4009
11 ай бұрын
Right? I feel like no one hates him. So fun and enthusiastic
Jacob drew 14 cards with Rhystic Study - for 2 mana cuz of the nightscape
@kamikirbits7708
11 ай бұрын
and he still died first
@brandonmarshall2370
11 ай бұрын
@kamikirbits7708 that's why he died first*
@kamikirbits7708
11 ай бұрын
@@brandonmarshall2370 both are correct. He died first because of the cards he got but also those 14 cards didn't help him stay alive and he still died.
In case anyone, like me, is wondering, they did errata old Amass cards to be Amass Zombies, and as part of the effect they turn the Army into a Zombie. So he is right that they work with the new Amass cards.
@Yontanian
11 ай бұрын
I was so confused when this happened. Reading the card did not explain the card.
@erikohman2294
11 ай бұрын
Thanks! I did wonder.
@yellowmaster52
11 ай бұрын
@nzjcooke reading the card (and errata), explains the card.
@AustinWestbro
11 ай бұрын
I thought that was so cool! Had no idea til now!
@nuclearphish8051
11 ай бұрын
That's really annoying actually. The old Amass would've worked with the new one just fine without the errata, right?
Having Goldberry in a Tom bombadil deck is such a flavor win
@howardjones1388
11 ай бұрын
Its almost like she was made to help Tom Bom
@fenixmeaney6170
11 ай бұрын
@@mfmageiwatch she looks fine, what's wrong with it?
@thelasttrueblade6684
11 ай бұрын
@@mfmageiwatchI'm not a LotR fan but honestly I think the art is excellent. Besides, fat bottomed girls they make the rocking world go round. And who's gonna disagree with Queen?
@howardjones1388
8 ай бұрын
@@thelasttrueblade6684 yeah buddy!
On Jimmy's Overwhelming Stampede, Jacob had a Sauron trigger, he could have sacrificed his tapped Orc Army to scry and create another Army token untapped to block, and as Josh played a spell to flicker Jimmy's token, Jacob's Army token would have been a 2/2 so he could have survived that turn.
@yoda9240
11 ай бұрын
You're right! I thought of the sack to have an untapped army, but didn't think it would save him. I forgot that Josh cast a spell so it would have been large enough to leave him at 1. Too bad he didn't know that Josh would cast that spell.
@Kindaichi83
11 ай бұрын
If he remembered the trigger and created another army token, then jimmy would just swing at him with an additional creature or assign the creatures differently.
@yoda9240
11 ай бұрын
@@Kindaichi83 Jimmy didn't know Josh had a blink spell, I doubt he would have changed his attack.
@Kindaichi83
11 ай бұрын
@@yoda9240 i'm referring to the trigger from Jimmy's overwhelming stampede. If Jacob had remembered that and sacrificed his current army token to create a new untapped one, Jimmy would have attacked differently to ensure lethal damage. Anyway, Josh blink spell actually wouldn't have mattered as he only cast it after blockers were assigned.
@yoda9240
11 ай бұрын
@@Kindaichi83 The way Jimmy attacked, it still would have killed Jacob if he had 1 more power on the board, he needed 2 more power to survive, therefore Jimmy may not have attacked differently. If Jacob blocked with everything and Josh casts his spell after blockers are declared then Jacob's army still gets buffed and Jacob then has enough toughness among his blockers to live. That is what we are talking about.
Jimmy saying, “it’s a feature not a bug” had me laughing out loud 😂
Kinda bummed that Jimmy didn't have the win after the Stampede, but it was a very fun episode to watch. The flavor of the LOTR cards fit almost perfectly with MTG
This is my 1st magic set, and im building my 1st magic commander deck around Sauron, The Dark Lord! Thanks to yall, The Professer, and MTG Arena for getting me into the game! Had a blast at a prerelease event last weekend!
@mibbzx1493
11 ай бұрын
You’ll enjoy it so much, you’ll be building more than one deck
@theholychirch3924
11 ай бұрын
@mibbzx1493 already working on a scry/+1+1 elf deck too 😭🤣
@theholychirch3924
11 ай бұрын
@dontatmetillyouvebeenoutside I will! It seems pretty efficient if you can get the card draw on top of the scry, I guess I'm more worried about sustaining long enough to get the counters up high enough to win. Maybe adding some indestructible like Mithril Coat will help. The main combo I'm trying for is getting "Elrond, Master of Helaing" (commander) and "Arwen Undomiel" capatlizing with "SeedBorn Muse" as my win conditon. I found a great engine to add in is Fathom Mage, Shortcut to Mushrooms is a good engine using The Rings Card draw if u can tempt it high enough, Raise of Palisade seems like it'll be great removal. I'm going to experiment with "Three Rings for the Elven Kings" trying to copy counters and scry with that.
@theholychirch3924
11 ай бұрын
@@dontatmetillyouvebeenoutside oh reliquary Tower or something like that, that gives no hand size, helps mw feel more confident throwing heavy card draw in there
@LeonJohnson-yi3hg
11 ай бұрын
That’s such a cool card have fun!
got to meet and play with both jacob and xolo when they were shooting cobra kai near my gamestore. Both really awesome dudes
1:08:50 jimmy giving josh the win by pointing out an ability he can activate. You are the best jimmy
Cobra Kai x LOTR is the crossover I didn’t know I needed 😂
@randommindz6782
11 ай бұрын
and DC (Blue Beatle)
Barely a few minutes into this episodes, and you can tell the passion put into it. The editing, animations, voice work make this one of my favorite episodes! Well done command zone crew!
I think Jimmy's decks are either light on lands, or all his lands are very heavy( they settle to the bottom of the deck).
Josh destroying Jimmy's guardian project while there was a rhystic study on board is exactly why he gets so much flak from the community 😂
@Words-of-encouragement.-.
10 ай бұрын
Yeah, but for all the cards that Jacob was drawing with that Rhystic Study, he never really did anything amazing with it. At no point did he TRULY become a real problem.
@UltimateLoaf
4 ай бұрын
Guardian Project is likely to draw more cards, since no one can pay to stop the draw (unless they remove it).
Jimmy missing land drops is a staple of the show at this point 😂
@luemece
11 ай бұрын
And not only in this show, wherever he goes...we like Jimmy for that...he keeps it real.
so glad to see these two back and on the same episode! can’t wait to watch
@very_grey
11 ай бұрын
Jacob plays at Flesh and Blood events too. I played against him and it didn't dawn onto me until halfway through our game lol.
Can't wait to to see Xolo as Blue Beetle! He is the perfect casting!
49:15 Gotta love Xolo sneaking a peak lol
Xolo such a good guy for not knocking jimmy out with mother of runes on the Thalia lieutenant
As long as I don’t miss any more land drops, the Jimmy Wong story.
Used to play magic with a a few of my friends in school and haven't touched it much since then. Having found this channel made me get Magic arena and been having so much fun learning the game again. I love seeing how everyone always uses a completely different deck play style to show off all the intricacies the new sets introduce. Keep up the good work lads :)
The "players are halfling" effects is such a great idea. Very well done. 11/10 Bonus point for big chairs.
Absolutely GORGEOUS episode lads. Still in the beginning but the narration during the commanders is excellent. Thanks for the effort you guys put in. Everytime I’m wondering what you guys are up to with the slower upload schedule I’m immediately reminded by the next video.
It’s so ‘enchanting’ to see these ‘legendary’ ‘humans’ ‘sacrifice’ time out of their day to provide us entertainment. Bless you all
So hyped to see Xolo and Jacob again, them being nerds and just cool dudes got me to watch Cobra Kai
Haven't watched a full game knights episode in a while, this one is so fun to watch.
Josh playing five color isnt a suprise😅😂 Nice new table ✌️
oh my god the chairs LOL
That was one of the swingiest Game Knights in a while! Everyone got a chance to show off what their decks was capable of and the decks were very flavorful with their additions.
i only got into mtg this last year and got into commander less than a week ago and this channel has made learning more about commander and all the different mechanics and cards such a fun experience. keep up the amazing content you guys you make such a positive impact for new players like me.
It's always fun with Xolo or Jacob, but they're *both* here this time! I love this set; there's so much new stuff, and all of the reprints tie in with the flavor and the mechanics soooo well! I hope a lot of will go down in price sooner rather than later, but excited to at least get my hands on a few of these cards. Now I need to get Treebeard into my abzan life gain deck...
Jimmy: oh wait you could move it to 3 now right? Josh: that’s true, the 3rd one is… oh *quack* This actually sent me💀
honestly your guys' videos are SO good. the quality combine with the friendly feeling like a place to chill is unprecedented. you guys are 10/10 keep it up
dear command zone team, this whole video was just awesome. the hosts, the guests, the setdesign and all those hundred+ little animations when cards were played or effects took place: perfect and it was so easy to follow the whole match with these inbetween explanations i was just looking for a lord of the rings mtg video and im realy happy i stumbled uppon this one keep up the good work :)
I’m not even through the commander intros and this is already my favorite episode. The editing and effects are so good
@priorityholder
11 ай бұрын
They really do a great job putting these together, such good production value. I wonder how many people were introduced to Magic because of them?
@miclowgunman1987
11 ай бұрын
I swear it is Hamish Parkinson from VLDL reading the book quotes.
This video is one of the best put together things I’ve seen! Loved all the LotR scenes!
This was an absolutely incredible game. Super swingy everyone got to show off their decks and it kept me guessing till the end. Love it!
Amazing video once again. You guys got me into Magic three years ago and I’ve made so many friends along the way because of it! Stay awesome.
The animations are beyond amazing!!!! Great job team
The height difference between josh and xolos decks at the end 😂
Production, game play, animation, effects, and the people in the table. Everything about this is amazing!
The way Jimmy looks at the camera with disgust! Lol😂 14:17
This game was awesome 👏🏾 LOTR cards fit so well in Magic, I feel bad for Jimmy’s Land drop Curse 😅 Next time. Love the animations and art work. Amazing Game 👍🏽 Love the mats.
Ladee danger killed it with this set
@jeffreylong1478
11 ай бұрын
Agreed, looks sweet 👍
@AnthonyKusanagi101
10 ай бұрын
Ill keep my Yuriko and my Surrack and Goreclaw decks thank you
No idea about series and stuff, but Yay, Xolo is back! The guy who played my favorite commander 2 years ago! 🎉🐶
Broooo, I've listened to every single Lone Lobos episode, I've been sooo excited about seeing both of these madlads duke it out at the same time here!!! Also, Jacob's Gandalf-feint was Amazing!!
I have no idea if it's been asked yet. But how do you get those land mats? Those are amazing 😍
@Lance_Hobbies
11 ай бұрын
must be from ultra pro. not so sure though. but most of their access are from ultra pro
Fun episode. Xolo and Jacob are great guests.
This was wild! Loved it, thanks for the great content!
So excited to watch this one. 2 of my favorite guests
"As long as this doesn't become a pattern" - James Wong *6 year long montage of Jimbo missing land drops begins to run*
Super Fun Episode! Really enjoy Xolo and Jacob on the show.
This was the most fun I’ve ever had watching magic, thank you command zone!!
Awesome to see both these guests at the same time! Love that Jacob's become a regular at commander tables
Love those playmats!!!!! I wonder if theirs more to put together to create the whole map for LOTR.
Oh look the players didn't realise that Josh was the biggest threat. Again. 😂
the amount of fun had at this table is amazing to watch
Love the approach on the decks and the power level, as always you guys are the best
This is the first time I've actually been interested in purchasing the playmats they have but it looks they aren't available anywhere? 👀
@lic4444
11 ай бұрын
I also need to know how to get these playmats!
@code_talkergaming1551
11 ай бұрын
It doesn't look like UltraPro. I've been looking, post a link if anyone finds them.
Great episode. Very fun back and forth.
Didn't know the Cobra Kai guys were into MTG, cool crossover! Good editing and just enough explanations in there during the plays (with a bit of pausing to read card text) to understand all the synergies popping off, lots of fun (and swings) when multiple players involved.
Low-key had a crush on Xolo ever since his last appearance. Lets go!
@babyblue4288
11 ай бұрын
Don’t we all
"Xolo and Jimmy are the threats." meanwhile Jacob draws a billion cards off of rhystic study.
I've never played or bought Magic but man do I love watching these! And I just realized I've heard Jimmy's voice in Dungeons and Daddies!
I just started watching this channel yesterday when i learned CGB had been on here. Ive loved both episodes ive watched so far you all definitely gained a lifetime fan! ❤❤
Not even 6mins in and I know it's going to be one of the best game knights videos ever
Josh and jimmy are back!? Let’s go!!
I really loved this game. Shows what we already know, the people you play with make the game. Thanks for making this great show 🎉
THRAXIMUNDAR! already best commandzone vid ever
I had convinced myself that Elijah would be playing in this episode, even if I knew that this was never going to happen. Still kinda sad.
I keep checking UltraPro, hoping those map playmats will appear 😭
This was an amazing episode. The decks were awesome, the plays were excellent and above all else…Tom won, proving that he’s one of the strongest characters in Middle-Earth. It was also great to see Xolo and Jacob in the same episodes.
Watching this late just getting into magic and lotr and you guys are helping me do it yalls channel is very cool , love xolo he was great as Blue Beatles totally underatted movie
who did those voiceovers for the commander intros?! great stuff
Where did they get those playmats?? They look really good!
Thank you for another great video!
What a great game! Tom is quickly becoming one of my favorite cards in the set, the Sagas always have great flavor and art is it's really fun to build a deck around them.
Brilliant set! Are the mats custom?
Jacob is always highly entertaining, fun fun game!
Xolo And Jacob are some of my fav Game Knights guests. Really awesome to see them here for this sweet lore set.
1:11:00-1:12:00 was peak commander 😭😭😭 I love the “I knew that he knew that I knew” energy
I didn't think that Amassing with Gleaming Overseer causes the Orc Army to also become zombies as well????
@sirpandaachoo
11 ай бұрын
It doesn’t. It just says add a counter to target army.
@1ntegrator
11 ай бұрын
No it does! The mechanic Amass has been erratat such that they army gains the respective type
@TheRandomeDud3
11 ай бұрын
@@1ntegrator ah ok. That makes sense. Thank you
Why is Aragorn ad King Theoden black-face?
@Johnitus69
7 ай бұрын
Pandering for BSG score
Learned MTG on Thursday. Was prompted to watch this and am so excited to dive in deeper. Thanks dudes!
Yes!!! Was waiting for this!! So glad the guests are Jacob and Xolo too!
Finally, a game where no matter what wins, as long as Josh loses I'm happy!
@fluffyrinsu4879
11 ай бұрын
But he won
@joshuabarnett88
11 ай бұрын
Yeah I posted that at the beginning and came back to cry
@alexsmythe6815
11 ай бұрын
Josh won what are you talking about
@joshuabarnett88
11 ай бұрын
@@alexsmythe6815 it's almost like the r reply I posted before yours explains it
@gentrywymer3583
11 ай бұрын
Why does everyone hate on Josh so much??? I don't really understand he seems like a cool dude.
This set is such a desecration of Tolkiens work
@Argusthecat
11 ай бұрын
Really? Why? Like, it's just art of classic characters. It's not like they're declaring new canon for Middle Earth.
@thezerowulf2046
11 ай бұрын
@Argusthecat from Tolkien himself. "In principle, I object as I strongly as is possible to the "translation" of the nomenclature at all (even by a competent person). I wonder why a translator should think himself called on or entitled to do any such thing. That this is an "imaginary" world does not give him any right to remodel it according to his fancy, even if he could in a few months create a new coherent structure which it took me years to work out. I presume that if I had presented the Hobbits as speaking Italian, Russian, Chinese, or what you will he would have left the names alone. Or, if I had pretended that 'the Shire' was some fictitious Loamshire of actual England. Yet actually in an imaginary country and period as this one, coherently made, the nomenclature is a more important element than in an 'historocal' novel. But, of course, if we drop the 'fiction' of long ago. "The Shire" is based on a rural England and not any other country in the world - least perhaps of any in Europe or Holland, which is topographical wholly dissimilar. The topology of The Shire, to take the first list, is a 'parody' of that of rural England, in much the same sense as are its inhabitants: they go together and are meant to. After all the book is English, and by an Englishman, and presumably even those who wish it's narrative and dialogue turned into an idiom that they would understand, will not ask of a translator that he should deliberately attempt to destroy the local colour."
@Orfeh9999
11 ай бұрын
@@thezerowulf2046 which translated nomenclature are you alluding to?
@Argusthecat
11 ай бұрын
@@thezerowulf2046 ...This is Tolkien complaining about the Dutch translation of his book. This has nothing to do with artistic interpretation, this is his personal beef with one single translators language choices.
@thezerowulf2046
11 ай бұрын
@@Argusthecat I guess you missed the part about him saying "that this is an imaginary world does not give him a right to remodel it as he fancies"...
I love the editing for this episode!
This made me interested in learning how to play MTG ! Amazing work !!
Wow a game where Josh wins? That is some crazy unusual occurrence! Definitely doesn't seem contrived at all.