Grade this Giants mock draft! A, B, C, D or F

@NYGiantsTV

Ай бұрын

Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account and use code CHATSPORTS for $20 off your first purchase! Check out gametime.co for last minute tickets.

@iamlegend8153

Ай бұрын

C-

@etc7898

Ай бұрын

B-

@anthonyrazza1344

Ай бұрын

C +

@anthonyrazza1344

Ай бұрын

C+

Please don’t trade up, don’t trade away the entire future for a mid-QB

@judewhite4401

Ай бұрын

Exactly. If you trade up for a quarterback, you’re fucked for a long time.

@melissalynn7608

Ай бұрын

Facts. We have way to many holes to trade picks away to move yp. If we trade back and get a elite reciever and get get picks for moving back and get a mid qb in the second or third ill be happy. But we need the draft capital from moving back to draft lineman and new rb1

@BigBlueBen

Ай бұрын

Yup I’m not the biggest fan of Daniel’s or maye. Do hope we trade up for Marvin Harrison I want us to make a splash after saquon went to Philly

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

@@BigBlueBen trading up for a wr when we have a shit roster and can still get an elite wr prospects if we stay put makes zero sense

@BigBlueBen

Ай бұрын

@@bradleybarber293 Marvin Harrison is a special player and we really gotta try something different. We’ve had 10 years of poverty drafting the way u want us to

MPJ at 47 that’s a steal for us

@Lyfe2Shortz

Ай бұрын

He’s first round lock

@sbelbey

Ай бұрын

He won't be there at 47

@FigAristotle

Ай бұрын

He's definitely not dropping that low

@pokemoore5550

Ай бұрын

Gosh y’all can’t read I said “MPJ at 47 is a steal” …. Meaning if it happens it’s a steal never said it will happen

@WIllyEnHenry

Ай бұрын

I Soo Agree he Going to be a Sleeper in this Draft Everyone Is Over Looking hom

There are a couple Brandon Jacobs types in this draft i would pick over the running back from usc

I agree can never have too many O-Linemen or Pass rushers !!!

Sarnistal cb from Michigan should be on our radar !!

Would not pick Penix…he is left handed and our star tackle is a Left Tackle. Take one of the top WRs.

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

What? He took a wr in the first 😂

@fernandoruiz4120

Ай бұрын

Who tf is going to throw the ball

@jameshollister8294

Ай бұрын

They can't I guess I would because the giants need to keep swinging

@isaacm6265

Ай бұрын

Great point I didn’t even consider

NO TRADES.. let the GM do his JOB

@just908blaze1

Ай бұрын

Idk he’s been suspect so far in regards to drafting.

@sonnycheeba4536

Ай бұрын

@@just908blaze1 exactly so DO NOT trade away players.. develop them.. New Oline coach can fix his blunder

@ayyubjackson1769

Ай бұрын

​@@just908blaze1no be hasn't

@just908blaze1

Ай бұрын

@@ayyubjackson1769 banks is the only good draft pick so far lol

First like love what you are doing keep up the good work

I’m trading down and maybe twice. Every mock draft I do with trading down.. our draft comes out amazing

If they seriously think MPJ will fall to them in round 2 they should get Odunze with the 6th pick. they will already have chemistry and know eachother.... worked for Burrow/Chase and Hurts/ Smith

@jameshollister8294

Ай бұрын

Agree

@ReadRideClimb

Ай бұрын

Odunze either way. We already have speed. We need a superstar.

Nabers if MHJ is not there at 6. Don’t trade up because the two and Odunze are all extremely similar with upside

The scenario you presented, I am drafting Malik Nabors. Great Player.

Canton for a man that’s never played a down in the NFL is crazy

Nabers 6th

@T2Pgaming

Ай бұрын

I think the chargers are going to take him I think we’re getting Rome odunze

I don't understand how giants can take any WR when they don't have a QB to get him the ball... Penix won't be there in the 2nd round btw.

@FigAristotle

Ай бұрын

The QB was never the problem. The problem was the offensive line. Daniel Jones took us to the playoffs with the worst receiving corp and worst offensive line in the year ago. Or did we forget already?

If we MHJ or Nabers at 6 and penix in the second round I would be the happiest fan

Some thing you have to consider, is, it’s going to cost more for the Vikings to trade up then us from 6. So why wouldn’t a team want the max haul to trade down? That puts us in a disadvantage

No trade up! In fact I would be inclined to trade down for additional draft picks....If Shoen is any good at building, we will see it.

Do not trade up FOR ANY REASON. We need a player like Nabers or odunze at 6. 2nd round we take best position available again and in the 3rd round we take a corner like Carson out of wake forest. Lots of good corners in the 3rd round. Round 4 get a playmaker like a Bucky Irving possibly.

Nabers is a no brainer at 6

What do you have us giving up to trade up? We only have 6 picks.

New York Giants need to make the right decisions in the 2024 NFL Draft.

The first 3 make sense. I think bottom 3 picks we got defense only. Need to draft a safety, corner and DL

MHJ should be the #1 NYGs target if Williams and Maye goes first. The other QBs are meh, and I prefer to have a good base of a team before going out to spend on a QB this time. Sick of seeing QBs being ruined in the NFL because of ill preparation of team before hand.

Stay put at 6 & draft the best receiver at 6.

If it has to be like this, I'll take it. I think the Gints need to get creative to squeeze some good talent outta this draft.

Trade down for picks 11and 23 you can get a very good wr and maybe get penix as well

That's the only reason I will take dunze over naber because you could pair the two teammates together they have chemistry with throwing and catching back shoulder passes I think it will work

If MHJr or Naber aren’t available at 6 trade back get more picks and fill our holes ! WR, CB,RB,OL,LB, Draft a QB in the late round if you desire to draft a QB !! If we don’t fix the main problem WR-1,CB, OL, and RB in this draft then idk what we are building. We need another TE bcs this Waller guy can’t decide whether he wants to retire or not. That tells me he doesn’t want to grind anymore!!!

Don't trade up. Nabers is the pick. Don't F this up. NYG

Bud if we get Penix at 47 I’ll cry in happiness

For me naber with 6 pic, get a cb at pic 41. Definitely would like us to draft Jordan travis third round being a FSU fan as well as Giants fan would be fiyyaaa

Maye is best QB in draft, I agree.

Hell ya I'll do it to trade up

Who would you pick with the #6 pick in the NFL Draft?

I would do it like this lol bear with me 😂 RD -1 WR Nabers or Harrison .. Rd-2 Corner or DT that slips maybe. Rd -3 O- Line depth or LB. RD-4 RB. Later Rounds I go for depth or a hopeful sleeper lol

@ThUnDeRThUnDeR125

Ай бұрын

Bare

Maybe Penix is day 2 candidate but the demand for QB will push him to rd 1

Schoen better SPRINT to the podium if Penix is their at 47....I would say if he's their at 32 they should trade up to get the extra year of team control but at 47?? 1000000% you take the gamble

REALLLLLL ONEEEEEEE

I’m not to the Giants pick yet and I think you’ve been slamming a few cold ones buddy! Lol. I love your takes, but the Giants have TOO many problems to trade up for anyone! I’m concerned the Joe/Brian can’t evaluate the ability spot or any other. Banks & JMS appear to be solid, KT’s numbers are a little misleading, not gonna discuss Evan at all. But not many of our picks the last 2 years have exceeded expectations. We need as many picks as possible until we get it right

Rome

They should take RB Will Shipley from Clemson. He can fly, which they need cuz Singleton is on slow side with 4.6+ 40yd dash. Look what Achane did for Dolphins before getting hurt.

Maye would be a perfect fit

Sign O'Dell and draft Nabers. O'Dell can still help. Wandale, O'Dell and Nabers would be 🔥 Best CB in rd 2

Nabers this year and get an elite qb prospect next year or two

Go JJ top 4 pick lets do it Denver. FYI taking the best WR available. Not trading back.

If both top QB’s are gone @6 would you take the TE from Georgia?

Nabers or Odunze. I prefer Odunze because he’s a bigger prototypical X wr with 50/50s and a huge red zone target but both are studs.

I'm sorry marshall ,I know you are a huge Giants fan and so was I....I got a feeling they will F**k up their draft pix

@user-dr4mv9wm9r

Ай бұрын

If you say you were a GIANTS fan then you were never a real fan….. because Giants fans complain but always remain loyal…🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵

I would of went TE in the ladder rounds, We need a CATCHING TE Too!!!

@jameshollister8294

Ай бұрын

Exactly you agree we really need a trade down

@just908blaze1

Ай бұрын

Use bellinger more. Problem solved.

@iamlegend8153

Ай бұрын

@@just908blaze1 does not solve the problem but I do agree he's capable of being the guy but I say he's still #2. If Waller comes back obviously he's #1.

@americanmade1979

Ай бұрын

I like the idea too, but this TE class after Bowers and dude from Texas is weak... big drop off in talent... but who knows, we don't find out who's gonna be great and who's gonna suck until years later sometimes.

We need wide receiver

I think it's not good for the Giants to draft a QB in this years draft. They have to many holes in the offense. O-Line is a mystery, probably better than last year but still far away from being decent and we got no receivers (a lot of depth but no true seperator and no true WR1). Grabbing Nabers and maybe Neal gets better, a QB next year comes in a much better situation. Look and Young and Stroud. Stroud had a solid WR-core (yes, it was a mystery) and a good O-Line, young didn't have either and they already calling him a bust. I love maye and i'd love to get him, but you give up. We should build a Team that's QB ready before we draft one. Sorry if my english isn't the best. Greetings from Germany/Bavaria.

No way in HELL should the Giants give away their next two (25/26) first-round picks to trade up.

Idk 3-11 plus 23 in a first round pick next year sound better to me 😂

No trades we only got 6 picks

Id trade back to maybe 11 if its still there and get bowers or odunze if either is still there.

I think the Giants should draft tight end dallin holker from Colorado State

I would trade our 3rd pick for a chance at Penix

If we can get nabers at 6, there's 0 reason to trade up.

We don't have the draft capital to be trading up. Plus it would screw up our future drafts to do so. Hell no to a trade up!!

A+

I like that bc if jones plays like shit we can always go for a qb next year especially since a lot of teams this year are in desperate need of a qb why depleat are draft picks when we can build a team ready for a star qb this would complete are wr room next we need to hit a running back and see if we need more OL and TE’a that’s just the offense defense needs more depth in the secondary and more starting material before we can really work on a DL men to play next to sexy dexy

I love Nabers at six this offense needs play makers . Moving up to pick a QB is going to cost you . If you don’t have to move up I would do it if you love a guy . Drafting a QB is always a coin flip anyway.

Giants are not trading up for a quarterback in the top 4. The Chargers are taking a wide receiver. They don’t have any now.

I've been wrong more than I've been right about our team. Your extrapolation is pinpoin. Salute raw, see you at the parade

Pennix?? 2nd rd??? We have one CB on this ream...

Giants should not move up for drake Maye!

Can't imagine having a QB that needs a clean pocket. What a liability, especially for the Giants. But what do I know ? Lol

Skip penix and get a safety 2nd and get a RB in 3rd not 4th get Bucky Irving or the kid from Wisconsin

Nabers

Don't trade the 6th pick

I’m not trading for a chance at JJ or Maye

Nyet on Penix - a 24-year old QB with an injury history? Besides, we don't know if we have a RT that will keep him from being killed.

It’s still way too early for this I know it fills in the time I still think we take the QB

Yes Michael pennick's second round all day everyday on a Sunday

@just908blaze1

Ай бұрын

Definitely won’t be there tho smh

Only qb worth moving up for is Jayden Daniel's.

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

Not even close to being true

@mikevota2236

Ай бұрын

You 💯 will see he's got most talent out of all the qbs in draft

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

@@mikevota2236 again not even close to being true 😂 played behind an elite oline and with the best wr duo haha neither Maye or Williams had either and still played just as good

@mikevota2236

Ай бұрын

@bradleybarber293 Your bugging 😒 maye is a project, and Usc qb way overrated. LSU is stacked with Nfl ready players as is USC squad.

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

@@mikevota2236 Maye is not a project what are you talking about 😂 dudes been a top 5 QB for 2 years now and will be a top 3 pick. Nobody is calling him a project

Odunze then Penix

Idk 😶

The Giants are moving up in the draft for quarterback. Nobody has better than a six pack to offer.

@jameshollister8294

Ай бұрын

Moving is a bad idea

I like HAYNES

Or we just draft Nabers and get immediate production

Michael Pennix

So why the Giants can’t do that? WTF

Im not moving up for the 4th or 5th best qb. Fuck that.

@bradleybarber293

Ай бұрын

He didn't move up?

I’d draft Joe Alt at 6.

Nabers will have a better career than Harrison unless he gets injured badly.

nabers no doubt

Giants reaching got them into the bad decision with Daniel Criminal Jones. (Stole a contract and didn't deserve it). Best agent of the century. Danny Criminal has not played a full season ever.

I hate these mock drafts it will be what it will be not a mock draft well know soon enough

I would take dunze at six

Malique, NAbERS

N we need help at db

Horrible mock.... if this would be the Giants draft "haul" Id be pissed. I like Nabers, but not more than Odunze. I hope it goes QB, WR/DB, DB/WR. There's potential and a good chance to get 3 great players in those positions in the first 3 rounds.... positions of need. Not opposed to drafting a DL or OL in the 3rd either if they are a "steal" in the eyes of the Giants.

Jaylen Daniels

You are wrong about moving up and taking a QB. WR_TE_CB_S. That is the priority. When you say these things about moving up it is from my point of view foolish. WR WR WRN and then TE At #6 I am going Brock Bowers or Joe alt. Then I am coming up into the first to make an attempt at the other one.

McCarthy i would not touch anywhere before late second round.. he is over rated. might as well wait for get Milton. I prefere Nabar vs harrison because he is a big receiver and a big receiver is better

Don't take Penix. Too many injuries.

No Penix has an injury history plus he left handed.

You can't 'will' a WR to the Giants. It's common knowledge that the Giants are in a rebuilding phase with some promising pieces in place. Enter JJ, the future of the team. This is DJ's final year in NY, and the Giants' current strategy suggests a potential trade for a WR1 with a proven veteran.

@juliusjean-baptiste924

Ай бұрын

It’s not a will, it’s a desperate need they haven’t filled in 6 years before DJ was even drafted. It can help a WB greatly having a #1 guy which DJ never had in his career.

@Boogiesu12

Ай бұрын

@@juliusjean-baptiste924 - It's a will when the most important position needs to be addressed and they are clearing cap space to sign a WR1. He can't will a first-round receiver when it's evident they are headed in a different direction. And rightfully so since it will clear up huge cap space next year to further solidify the team. JJ should be the rightful pick not a luxury they are going to address anyway through a trade.

@juliusjean-baptiste924

Ай бұрын

@@Boogiesu12 honestly we don’t even know if they are or if they can afford to. As a team at the top of the draft they’re just doing their due diligence as they should. But staying at 6, likely lands them their WR1. If they want a QB, They’re going to have to move up and I don’t see the Pats trading down cuz they need a QB themselves in the worst way considering the division and conference they play in and unless they’re getting 4 firsts, I don’t see it. The Vikings for sure are moving up to 4 at least & the broncos or the raiders could too and what are the Giants going to do? Get into a bidding war with the Vikings over the 4th best qb? Mortgage the future giving up a godfather x2 offer? Giants aren’t in position to mortgage 3-4 first round picks which will be what it takes to move up to get one especially when they’re not a consistent winning team. The Vikings with a QB are a playoff contender and are in a position to do so where it won’t really affect them.

@Boogiesu12

Ай бұрын

@@juliusjean-baptiste924 - so easy to debunk this, honestly we don't know they are sitting at 6. End of the discussion, you build your franchise with a QB. DJ is not the future