If Talking Giants like an O-lineman, you know he's good...

@rjharrold2907

Ай бұрын

Stance change first

@yepdontcarebud

Ай бұрын

I mean they've whiffed on quite a few

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

​@@yepdontcarebud And you haven't.

@MrHumble22

Ай бұрын

He like Evan Neal & Josh Ezeudu ..

@rjharrold2907

Ай бұрын

@@cooldude7821 Everyone misses. That's the point. Learning lessons about educated guessing

babe wake up, Talkin Giants 2024 mock draft is up

A 370 lb lineman next to Dexter would be fun

Love it Bobby. Bring these Giants fans back down to earth who want the latest pro day QB at 6. If top 3 QBs are gone, the pick is Nabers.

Nabers and Haynes is my dream realistic scenario

@user-cu6sd3iz7r

Ай бұрын

HOW MANY FUCKING O-LINEMEN ARE YOU WHACKED IN THE HEAD....STOP WE NEED DB HELP IMMEDIATELY EVERYWHERE WITH A 2ND YEAR STUD YET INEXPERIENCED CORNER!

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

​@@user-cu6sd3iz7r 2nd year stud. Think you got whacked in the head.

Yesss Christian Haynes is my favorite OL in this draft!

@robertpalatsky5017

Ай бұрын

I doubt he falls to the second round, or atleast that far.PRobably would need to trade up to get him, or trade down in the first, accumulate more draft capital and take him in the first round, not that I would trade back from 6. I'd take Nabers too.

I doubt Theo Johnson would be available in RD5 but if he was, home run pick

We got a bunch of o- line guys already . 6 free agents 😢 we need corners

@jbkalways9039

Ай бұрын

we got bare minimum signings. like numerically the least amount offensive linemen we couldve gotten lol

@Thagomizer-U235

Ай бұрын

They signed 3 guards in fa and a tackle that will win starting guard spot if Neal miraculously wins Tackle. We need an outside cb opposite Banks.

T’Vondre Sweat next to Dexter Lawrence would be hysterical. Nobody is running the football on us

Yes, I would be very happy with your picks!

Excellent pic I love it. And then we draft defense and lots of it

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

Let me take a guess on why you love this draft Donna.

I know you don’t do trades but based off personnel attending pro days and needs: 1st round: trade back for Michael penix (hope to get another 2nd round and an extra 4th round) 2nd round: explosive sleeper WR (maybe Adonai Mitchell) 3rd round: TE (ben Sinnott) 4th round (via trade for Michael penix trade): LG Zak Zinter 4th round: DT (hopefully sweat) Other picks I need to evaluate but hoping and praying our 1st round - 4th round picks end up like this

You can't go wrong drafting an LSU WR. I'm still having nightmares about the other UConn draft pick, Matt Peart.

@davidzucca2910

Ай бұрын

Just think Will Beatty and hopefully everything will be okay.

@Thagomizer-U235

Ай бұрын

U r letting a 3rd rnd bust give u nightmares? What is Neal doing to u?

@davidburks4657

Ай бұрын

@@davidzucca2910 thanks, I forgot about Beatty.

@davidburks4657

Ай бұрын

@@Thagomizer-U235 I still have hope. Burns will get him right.

I say we get odunze and penix

@MrBruceWolf

Ай бұрын

That's my nightmare draft. Solid but unspectacular possession reciever and a backup QB 🤮

You’ll be glad you did

Let’s go New York Giants

I’d be THRILLED with sweat. Let him work with Patterson and alongside Dex and he will blossom. Watched him for years at Texas and he is awesome. Would love to see him become a giant!

Awesome video.

Took Theo Johnson in my Giants madden franchise kids a stud 😂

Love the first two picks. Want a cb and rb somewhere.

@DannyUrena-mf3yk

Ай бұрын

RB is important

I normally don't watch mock drafts but it's talking Giants, Im glad I did

Would be really happy with a draft like this.

Really like your picks. Hope the team does as good as you did.

Would take a CB like Lassiter over the OG in round 2 but otherwise I love this and think it’s realistic. Love the Theo Johnson pick.

It all starts with OL. Nice job.

2nd round will either be a Qb, Db or Wr

I want to get S Cole Bishop and RB Will Shipley with the 3rd and 4th round picks too

Nice love the OG pick

I would love a huge run-stopper in the 3rd. Big need that is not being discussed much.

I'd love to see your top 3 options for each rounds 2-7. It's so hard to guess, but I know your eval is deep for the draft. Seems like better chance to 'nail pick' with your best array of picks. Keep up the great work!

I’d swap T’Vondre Sweat with Kris Jenkins and I don’t think Theo Johnson falls that far if he does that’s an absolute steal but I just see him going either late 3rd or early 4th

Tbh i dont see the chargers passing on nabers,so our pick is most likely odunze

I'd be happy with those choices.

I like your picks

Getting sweat might officially make the Giants D-line the best in the NFL on paper.

Great work and thanks Bobby, Exciting time of year for sure. My favorite NACCA division one basketball program, UCONN, Huskies still has men and women going. My favorite NCAA division 1 hockey team Quinnipiac Bobcats are in the frozen 4. And of course the NFL draft coming up.

@KTF0

Ай бұрын

Where TF is Quinnipiac? Sounds like a Harry Potter location

Theo Johnson... Check it...other than Miami, and Clemson.. I love Penn St. Players... I'm all in.

I don’t understand Daniel Jones might not make passed week 6.

I don’t see Theo Johnson being there in Round 5 for the Giants. But if he is, I agree that we should snatch him up.

I agree with the #2 pick👍👌💯

nice draft

This guy Xavier Legette is unreal. 6’1 225lbs with agility, long speed, acceleration before AND after the catch. Great hands, physical and my guy, if you just look at his lower-body during plays and highlights…he’s truly gifted!

Would love any combination of these players to be drafted by the Giants. If Christian Haynes can be as good as you say, I love the outlook of our OL if you got Thomas at LT, Runyan at LG, an improved JMS at C, Christian Haynes at RG, and then whoever the best RT is out of Eluemunor or Neal (probably Eluemunor lol).

CB2 is more of a need than back up OL and safety

By round three you need a DB and Odunze is the pick in round1.He finds the ball like no one else.

It seems like nobody is worried about our corner spot i feel like it's one of our biggest weaknesses

They can't keep wasting high draft picks on the offensive line, they just don't know how to eval them. Would rather them draft OL in later rounds lol

LFG!!

Good stuff, love the Nabers pick, health provided he's a superstar in the making. I like him more than Harrison. If the TE falls in our lap that's a gift!

Could move up and get a QB...

Doubt sweat will fall that far but would love it

I know u don’t do trades in mock but I wouldn’t hate moving down with Vikings. Take a OT or CB then go WR with 2nd first.

I have a feeling CB will be the 2nd or 3rd pick for us.

Love it but any reason to not go after a corner?

surprised you didnt have a cb for that last pick

Not gonna lie, I'd hate this draft. The 3rd round pick would especially be a head scratcher.

WE SHOULD TRADE DOWN FROM #70 & GET AN EXTRA PICK BACK....TAKE NUBIN OR RAKESTRAW WITH PICK #47 FOR SURE ENOUGH

I don't think Sweat will be available in the third but I love the pick if he is

I can’t believe T’Vondre was there at 70

Personally I’m taking Odunze at 6. 6’3, has that leader personality type and strong work ethic. Yeah Nabers might be the better prospect rn, but I can see Odunze having a Hines Ward type career.

@JesseGMan7

Ай бұрын

Also I’m trading up for Fatanu if he’s there in 20’s. Trade our 2nd round and next years.

@JesseGMan7

Ай бұрын

Those are the 2 guys I love in this draft. Maye too but I doubt that’s realistic.

My only fear with Nabers is how much will it cost to keep him. By the time his rookie contract 😮ends, a top 5 wideout could be worth 40 million.

Bobby --- I appreciate your investment of time to thoroughly think about this mock! Well done! I agree with you assessment of JJ McCarthy --- he is just an average guy being propped up by a great team that cheated by stealing signs. He is not worth a top 10 pick! Only thing I believe you're missing in your mock is a developmental QB. I believe the Giants are going to use their pick @ 70 to draft someone like Spencer Rattler and give him time to absorb the pro game under Daboll.

Give me Odunze with the 6th pick

Honestly I really want a QB however it’s not the end of the world, if we don’t take one hopefully we’ll be in a position to take Carson Beck next draft

We have young talent on the Dline..I would put a DB with the 3rd pick..Is Haines THAT good?I like the position pick with OL 2nd round..just not sure with Haines..

Good work but I gotta find a CB somewhere in the early rds. After Banks we have really nothing at CB

Hi

We need Defense Defense Defense. Let’s make it scary For every team that comes into our stadium.

What's the plan then if we don't draft a CB? We need somebody.

What about corner? We should get one in the 2nd or 3rd round because it’s one of our biggest needs

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

Still have free agency.

One G is enough.

If I'm going safety I would take Cole Bishop. He may not be there at 4th rd.

It's a good draft, except for the last pick. We can get better value with a WR with return skills. Theo won't be there in the 5th round, late 3rd/4th round pick.

This draft would get Schoen and Daboll fired good job

@grundeeno5790

Ай бұрын

exactly, it's horrendous

Big money bug money no wammys

Building around daniel Jones again woohoo! Can’t wait to start up the GM/HC hiring process when the season flops again

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

Always a chance he isn't ready to start the season.

U can tell Bobby is a big dude lmao always wanna put major focus on guards & super slow run stuffing DTackles 🤣🤣🤣

Love the Nabers pick and that is where this draft loses me. I like Christian Haynes but I would prefer another WR or another weapon here if not here then in round 3 the Giants need to draft 2 WRs and a RB in this draft. This offense was historically bad last year and this draft does nothing to fix that. Adding Nabers is nice but it more or less makes up for Saquon leaving. Last year the offense had 1 weapon Saquon after FA and this draft they still have 1 Weapon Nabers. I would like to see the Giants add WR Nabers, WR Tez Walker and RB Isaac Guerendo then possibly Joe Milton if he is there in round 6 that would allow for Haynes in the 2nd and a DB in the 4th or you go DB in the 2nd and O line depth in the 4th.

Christian Haynes, nice... But what if Kitchens is there❓The U...😊.... Unlikely, but possible... Kitchens has been growing on me... I actually think he's better that Nubin.

I’d be happy with this draft.

Bobby’s favorite Phish show?

Realistically someone is going to take Theo Johnson by the end of the 3rd. He's stupid low on mock draft engines. I was a little shocked you didn't take a RB late. I like Marshawn Lloyd (USC) but there are going to be a couple of guys there late.

Picking Sweat to me is a great example of why bpa process is the way to go. If he truly is the most valuable player on the board take him. He can give Dex rest on early downs a lot, both guys can play both spots and nobody wants to have to run on that mass and power. Allows us to play lighter on the back half if they want to situationally too

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

BPA sounds fantastic if your GM is capable of identifying who the BPA's are.

@rjharrold2907

Ай бұрын

@cooldude7821 I agree with that. But then that's a gm problem not a philosophy problem. I like Schoen, great process but we'll see what happens. I also think the smart tough dependable has to have a limit as well

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

​@@rjharrold2907 Not sure Schoen has done neither a great or terrible job.

This would be a great draft.. personally I’d like to invest in a RB around RD4, if someone like Jaylen Wright falls to late 3rd could be a huge get, Singletary would be best deployed as a committee back.

@user-nf8il8wo5x

Ай бұрын

Braelon Allen

Where are all the outraged Michigan fans calling you an idiot for not being high on McCarthy? They can smell JJ negativity like a shark in water. Good video Bobby

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

This is a mock. JJ was 27-1 & bought Michigan a championship. Why in the hell would anyone be negative about anything that man does. Daniel Jones. Now that's negativity.

@punkrockdad86

Ай бұрын

@@cooldude7821 he's really overrated by you guys...gonna be funny when hes a career backup.

Give me Nabers

@kooljoe35

Ай бұрын

No, give me a quarterback I’m sick and tired of Giants fans want to draft the wide receiver when we have no quarterback. Stop with this nonsense and stop with this crazy talk. You’re all crazy.

@grundeeno5790

Ай бұрын

@@kooljoe35 yep, we have the dumbest fanbase in the sport. look at the comments praising these picks. All it does it get the coaching staff fired by next year because they have no QB

Aside from no corner this would be an excellent draft for the G men great stuff Bobby 🫡

@TalkinGiants

Ай бұрын

Ya went in wanting a CB but just never liked the guys available. Still have a bunch of write ups to do as well

With that draft we will only win 4 games

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

I take it your draft is better.

@intel_da_developer4791

Ай бұрын

You have to invest in drafting a QB. You count on DJ being healthy this upcoming season.

A safety in 4th rd??? Bro, look for a CB in the 2nd and OG third..

Joe alt at 5? Chargers need a wr and might take nabers from us

Not 1 but 2 OLinemen.......that might be a little bias lol. Drew Lock to Nabers 😂

@BigDashKnows

Ай бұрын

Love Haynes though

No CB ?

If Neal is moved inside to Guard, while Eluemunor is the RT, then there is no longer any need for Guard. Love getting Nabers, and after that, we need DT to replace Leo, an ILB to challenge McFadden and a CB to replace Jackson.

@travisdalessandro58

Ай бұрын

You can neve have too many OL, especially young ones. What if Neal sucks at guard? What if there's an injury? I'm cool with loading up on OL.

@spencerweiss6337

Ай бұрын

@@travisdalessandro58 in which case I’d really like them to just draft Joe Alt as much as I love Odunze

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

​@@spencerweiss6337 At pick #6. Definitely not happening.

I don't care how fast they run or how high they jump, let's draft some good football players

Too many guards… and not a fan of Sweat pick

Offense will be horrible 😢😢

Haynes isn't a 2nd round pick

Is it just me or is getting another cornerback the biggest Giants need outside of getting a #1 WR?

@cooldude7821

Ай бұрын

One can argue QB is always the biggest need. CB is probably just B4 or after QB.

other than zay flowers 2023 didnt turn out to b a gr8 mock....js

Enough Drafting O.linemen. Giant's needs WR. Another T,E. Draft another Corner and Safety and RB. 6 Picks right,,?