Why would we talk in colonizer language? Disgusting
@itsmesoleh067 сағат бұрын
Dutch is stingy, not like british, they taught the countries they colonized their language but dutch didnt. But im proud of it, we dont need it anyways.
@Mhuda6913 сағат бұрын
because for 3.5 centuries there have been sporadic and continuous wars in various regions in Indonesia. The people fought with any weapons, including bamboo which was made sharp to be thrust into the Dutch troops. At that time, many Dutch and Allied soldiers died from being stabbed by sharpened bamboo sticks. resistance made antipathetic people use Dutch.
@linauni5552Күн бұрын
am sorry,,my grandma was speaking dutch...but she didn't teach to her child or grand child,,cause we have so many language in our country to speak so we dicided to speak our motjer tounge language ,,,its mean indonesia language
@joshuad4772Күн бұрын
As an indonesian, dutch is an ASS language. I always wished we were colonized by germans cuz german is an actual useful language😭
@anrashid473 күн бұрын
Nobody has apologized for their stupid ancestral mistakes. Now they pay for it lah when China becomes RULER of THE WORLD !!!
@anrashid473 күн бұрын
I just want to live to see uk and dutchland, portugal and spain be colonies of China !!! Hail President Xi !!!!
@devi0273 күн бұрын
It should be a good thing, because Bahasa Indonesia (formal) itself can be confusing sometimes even for us Indonesians lol
@vinnyMancini965 күн бұрын
Thank you Aztecs 🇲🇽🇮🇹💪
@fizarputra81825 күн бұрын
De facto Indonesia had been independent in August 17th 1945
@nedzadbadnjevic68856 күн бұрын
The Dutch crimes in Indonesia is not forgotten.
@parashit21816 күн бұрын
8:43 In 1910, Balai Pustaka is the first ever institution who standardize Malay. Despite the language exist for more than 1000 years prior, it never had any standard. Balai Pustaka's Malay was transform into Indonesian (Bahasa Indonesia) in 1927. But, most of Malay in Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei are still using Balai Pustaka's Malay as the refference. Because it based on "Higher Malay" which is more polite and constructive than the original Folk's Malay.
@Ririn9506 күн бұрын
Ga penting menggunakan bahasa penjajah biadab seperti belanda yang sudah menyengsarakan rakyat Indonesia. Apalagi bangsa Indonesia sudah memiliki bahasa kebanggaannya sendiri yaitu bahasa Indonesia.
@greendragonspirit16466 күн бұрын
Britain really is the worst, they don't do their nonsense these days only because they can't get away with it. The British treasure their drug dealing queen Victoria, not realising that she was trash.
@_louvadeusa_6 күн бұрын
I don't know much about the topic, so seeing that opium addiction is still a current epidemic was a little jarring (almost felt anachronistic). Maybe it's my own western bias but it feels like an understated problem that I never hear much about. Great video!
@boba0176 күн бұрын
my grandpa speak Dutch 🇳🇱 and my son half dutch but he can't speak Dutch cuz his daddy never speak dutch to him
@HYDRONORTHWESTTECHNOLOGI-jf1yf6 күн бұрын
The collective Western imperialist dishonest leadership anticidences is the problem of most development in the World.
@raniermoura38256 күн бұрын
I had no idea that that happened. Very interesting and educational video!
@ridwanmanurung27158 күн бұрын
As Indonesian, we are proud Bahasa Indonesia ❤ 🇮🇩
@angelicalovelynda87489 күн бұрын
The question is: Why we have to? 💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻 NAH
@jimmynova989 күн бұрын
To call Britain a small regional power and China one of the most powerful countries in the world is laughably ignorant on the topic. Britain colonized numerous countries and large swathes of several continents at this point. Britain had already colonized the new world. While China controlled little more than the land we would call China today and few neighboring territories. Also you make it sound as if the British colonized Indian with this goal in mind, and completely fail to mention that it had already been colonized by the Portuguese before them. And I’ve barely started the video……..
@joshandgrenade9 күн бұрын
China had 30% of the world's population and a similar amount of GDP at the turn of the 18th century. The Qing Dynasty from 1700-1800 was the most prosperous period China had ever felt, relative to the rest of the world. It was incredibly powerful, and it saw itself as the center of the world (right or not). The "New World" was irrelevant compared to China, until the mid 1800s at the earliest. Portugal's domain over India was limited to a few coastal cities like Goa and Daman; it was nothing compared to the vast swathes of territory in Bengal at the British East India Company ended up taking in the 1750s-1790s. Britain had lots of fantastic advantages underpinning it, but as of the early 19th century had not really proven itself globally beyond regional European matters. Britain has a really good marketing team. It was a competitive player, but paled in comparison to China with tis 100s of millions of people (until it started industrialising, and then the events of the video happened). Anyway, the Opium Wars were shocking. China had no big reasons to expect they couldn't stop the British, but they underestimated technology.
@jimmynova989 күн бұрын
I brought up the new world, as well as all of the other British colonies, to refute the videos claim that it was a regional power. They were one of the only countries that resemble what we would call a world power today. I do agree with you that China was populous and had a large economy. But that doesn’t directly equate to power. They were a regional power at best, with little actual influence over other countries beyond the economic.
@dougspray71609 күн бұрын
The British should go down on their knees and beg Chinas forgiveness for this despicable opium trade of their ancestors. A crime sgainst humanity comparable with the Atlantic Slave Trade, The Holycaust, The present war in Gaza, The Japanese in Manchuria, etc
@artus19810 күн бұрын
The f' in Europeans normalize colonization ! Look at the pattern - they colonized entire planet and act like nothing happened - cognitive dissonance
@tomjerry-qh3ou10 күн бұрын
There is an interesting fact that when Lin confiscated opium from British merchants, they were British government property. [ Lin finally demanded that the British merchants surrender all their opium to the local authorities, which the British superintendent of trade, Charles Elliot, did after giving the British opium merchants guarantees that they would be compensated by the government for their lost property. When Lin Zexu started to destroy the confi scated opium in May 1839, he was therefore destroying British government property, which would provide the British with an excuse to demand compensation under the threat of war. ] From Pär Kristoffer Cassel - Grounds of Judgment
@garumeg11 күн бұрын
Holy crap, the Mists of Pandaria soundtrack in the background really made it hard to concentrate on the awesome narration due to sheer nostalgia. Anyway, fantastic video!
@c_o_r_y11 күн бұрын
Caffeine is as much a narcotic as opium. That’s not a judgement-in the basic sense of psychoactive substances. Anti-drug enforcement is always focused on the supply side, but never stops to ask what the drug is doing for the user. For 18th century china, it only took combining the harsh reality of 18th century life anywhere with a several millennia old culture of prioritizing group survival and harmony over individual welfare. Today China is still battling with large swaths of social disengagement, they’re just not hopped up on dope. This is why they cracked down on video games. The EIC lucked out by finding a market, but to say exploited really washes over cultural forces and robs people of their agency.
@mutantryeff11 күн бұрын
I've been consuming 'Purple Voodoo' at ~$50 for 200g cake.
@mutantryeff11 күн бұрын
China has no problem shipping pre-cursors for Fentynal to the west.
@zl438410 күн бұрын
你们不如先管一管乱开药的医生，真打算大力度禁芬太尼的话中国又不可能再过来打一场芬太尼战争
@dragonwukong910 күн бұрын
China is not responsible for your pathetic laws. Don't mix up purposeefully sending drugs by the British drug lords vs American companies buying fentanyl to promote opiods for their own profits.
@mutantryeff11 күн бұрын
The USA makes it profits off of war.
@user-yy9hk9od9u11 күн бұрын
Lots of opium and African slaves were sold in the name of the queen.
@victorcastillo471811 күн бұрын
Loved it, very good! 👍🏽
@stargazer5911 күн бұрын
Great video!
@anangs12011 күн бұрын
Correction : Indonesia became independent on August 17, 1945 !! The Proclamation of Indonesian Independence was read by Soekarno, accompanied by Mohammad Hatta, at Jakarta. Indonesia declared its independence shortly before Japan's surrender, but it required four years of sometimes brutal fighting, intermittent negotiations (Indonesia War of Independence) , and UN mediation before the Netherlands agreed to transfer sovereignty in 1949.
@babanggagah438912 күн бұрын
Kami, bangsa Indonesia, menjunjung tinggi bahasa persatuan, Bahasa Indonesia
@robertbaldwin577112 күн бұрын
Inonesia's elite spoke Dutch. Now they speak English. To unite the country Bahasa Indonesian was introduced.
@MakIyen12 күн бұрын
Many better languages in Indonesia. Why speaking Dutch? Only 2 b able 2 talk 2 few people.. n not d great ones.
@Cuppa-oc4yf13 күн бұрын
This was such a well made video. Voice over is peaceful and in pretentious, imagery is lovely, background music is not overwhelming and the information is delivered in a well constructed narrative. Well done, and thank you.
@them2wheels11617 күн бұрын
Mengapa kita perlu mempelajari Bahasa musuh yang tidak berguna?
@Dailysista18 күн бұрын
Apakah harus bersyukur ? Aapun alesannya jadi Indo gak terlalu ke-branding as Dutch colony ? 😮
@Eureka7.20 күн бұрын
Pembelokan sejarah yg sempurna
@tonychen192520 күн бұрын
It was colonized for no more than 150 years .see google . Dutch did not want the prople to be clever .. only elite Indonesia can enrolled into dutch school ..
@lunassr721220 күн бұрын
because the Dutch self is Change language they sayyed is Dutch language 1945 not function 40 years ago after '80(niece Queen Beatrix self sayyed that)
@Akuanakmamahdanpapah21 күн бұрын
when i was kid i realize that, how dutch occupied our country for hundred years but we can't speak dutch😅
@IronDroid92521 күн бұрын
They do actually, Recent generations just don't usually learn dutch like their Grandparents did since We already have our own language
@user-cn2gl5ct5g22 күн бұрын
FYI, Indonesian independence is 17th August 1945, not 1949. So that could be seen that Dutch has been doing war crime for 4 years but they denied it b'cos they dont wanna seen as perpetrators of war crimes as they do military aggression after Indonesian independency proclamation twice.
@Mamay_vessa22 күн бұрын
Indonesia dont speak dutch but so many languange similar .... we also sleep with guling like dutch.. we also eat some food similar with dutch foood. Dutch food,languange and life 30 % stilll live in indonesia ... in middle indonesia
@Savannah1922 күн бұрын
Good for them 👏👏
@TheBigLeChowski23 күн бұрын
Props to the usage of FTL music, love that game
@joaodejason993723 күн бұрын
differ from those in philippines..due to colonization. the country change the name of country, change their religion from islam to catholic..change their pwoples name to spain name... we' re indonesian proud to our culture... we're moslem but our name and culture still exist
@juliomandiaga961223 күн бұрын
From Jose Rizal in his novel El Filibusterismo, 1891 One and all you forget that while a people preserves its language, it preserves the marks of its liberty, as a man preserves his independence while he holds to his own way of thinking. Language is the thought of the peoples. Luckily, your independence is assured; human passions are looking out for that!”
Пікірлер
Why would we talk in colonizer language? Disgusting
Dutch is stingy, not like british, they taught the countries they colonized their language but dutch didnt. But im proud of it, we dont need it anyways.
because for 3.5 centuries there have been sporadic and continuous wars in various regions in Indonesia. The people fought with any weapons, including bamboo which was made sharp to be thrust into the Dutch troops. At that time, many Dutch and Allied soldiers died from being stabbed by sharpened bamboo sticks. resistance made antipathetic people use Dutch.
am sorry,,my grandma was speaking dutch...but she didn't teach to her child or grand child,,cause we have so many language in our country to speak so we dicided to speak our motjer tounge language ,,,its mean indonesia language
As an indonesian, dutch is an ASS language. I always wished we were colonized by germans cuz german is an actual useful language😭
Nobody has apologized for their stupid ancestral mistakes. Now they pay for it lah when China becomes RULER of THE WORLD !!!
I just want to live to see uk and dutchland, portugal and spain be colonies of China !!! Hail President Xi !!!!
It should be a good thing, because Bahasa Indonesia (formal) itself can be confusing sometimes even for us Indonesians lol
Thank you Aztecs 🇲🇽🇮🇹💪
De facto Indonesia had been independent in August 17th 1945
The Dutch crimes in Indonesia is not forgotten.
8:43 In 1910, Balai Pustaka is the first ever institution who standardize Malay. Despite the language exist for more than 1000 years prior, it never had any standard. Balai Pustaka's Malay was transform into Indonesian (Bahasa Indonesia) in 1927. But, most of Malay in Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei are still using Balai Pustaka's Malay as the refference. Because it based on "Higher Malay" which is more polite and constructive than the original Folk's Malay.
Ga penting menggunakan bahasa penjajah biadab seperti belanda yang sudah menyengsarakan rakyat Indonesia. Apalagi bangsa Indonesia sudah memiliki bahasa kebanggaannya sendiri yaitu bahasa Indonesia.
Britain really is the worst, they don't do their nonsense these days only because they can't get away with it. The British treasure their drug dealing queen Victoria, not realising that she was trash.
I don't know much about the topic, so seeing that opium addiction is still a current epidemic was a little jarring (almost felt anachronistic). Maybe it's my own western bias but it feels like an understated problem that I never hear much about. Great video!
my grandpa speak Dutch 🇳🇱 and my son half dutch but he can't speak Dutch cuz his daddy never speak dutch to him
The collective Western imperialist dishonest leadership anticidences is the problem of most development in the World.
I had no idea that that happened. Very interesting and educational video!
As Indonesian, we are proud Bahasa Indonesia ❤ 🇮🇩
The question is: Why we have to? 💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻 NAH
To call Britain a small regional power and China one of the most powerful countries in the world is laughably ignorant on the topic. Britain colonized numerous countries and large swathes of several continents at this point. Britain had already colonized the new world. While China controlled little more than the land we would call China today and few neighboring territories. Also you make it sound as if the British colonized Indian with this goal in mind, and completely fail to mention that it had already been colonized by the Portuguese before them. And I’ve barely started the video……..
China had 30% of the world's population and a similar amount of GDP at the turn of the 18th century. The Qing Dynasty from 1700-1800 was the most prosperous period China had ever felt, relative to the rest of the world. It was incredibly powerful, and it saw itself as the center of the world (right or not). The "New World" was irrelevant compared to China, until the mid 1800s at the earliest. Portugal's domain over India was limited to a few coastal cities like Goa and Daman; it was nothing compared to the vast swathes of territory in Bengal at the British East India Company ended up taking in the 1750s-1790s. Britain had lots of fantastic advantages underpinning it, but as of the early 19th century had not really proven itself globally beyond regional European matters. Britain has a really good marketing team. It was a competitive player, but paled in comparison to China with tis 100s of millions of people (until it started industrialising, and then the events of the video happened). Anyway, the Opium Wars were shocking. China had no big reasons to expect they couldn't stop the British, but they underestimated technology.
I brought up the new world, as well as all of the other British colonies, to refute the videos claim that it was a regional power. They were one of the only countries that resemble what we would call a world power today. I do agree with you that China was populous and had a large economy. But that doesn’t directly equate to power. They were a regional power at best, with little actual influence over other countries beyond the economic.
The British should go down on their knees and beg Chinas forgiveness for this despicable opium trade of their ancestors. A crime sgainst humanity comparable with the Atlantic Slave Trade, The Holycaust, The present war in Gaza, The Japanese in Manchuria, etc
The f' in Europeans normalize colonization ! Look at the pattern - they colonized entire planet and act like nothing happened - cognitive dissonance
There is an interesting fact that when Lin confiscated opium from British merchants, they were British government property. [ Lin finally demanded that the British merchants surrender all their opium to the local authorities, which the British superintendent of trade, Charles Elliot, did after giving the British opium merchants guarantees that they would be compensated by the government for their lost property. When Lin Zexu started to destroy the confi scated opium in May 1839, he was therefore destroying British government property, which would provide the British with an excuse to demand compensation under the threat of war. ] From Pär Kristoffer Cassel - Grounds of Judgment
Holy crap, the Mists of Pandaria soundtrack in the background really made it hard to concentrate on the awesome narration due to sheer nostalgia. Anyway, fantastic video!
Caffeine is as much a narcotic as opium. That’s not a judgement-in the basic sense of psychoactive substances. Anti-drug enforcement is always focused on the supply side, but never stops to ask what the drug is doing for the user. For 18th century china, it only took combining the harsh reality of 18th century life anywhere with a several millennia old culture of prioritizing group survival and harmony over individual welfare. Today China is still battling with large swaths of social disengagement, they’re just not hopped up on dope. This is why they cracked down on video games. The EIC lucked out by finding a market, but to say exploited really washes over cultural forces and robs people of their agency.
I've been consuming 'Purple Voodoo' at ~$50 for 200g cake.
China has no problem shipping pre-cursors for Fentynal to the west.
你们不如先管一管乱开药的医生，真打算大力度禁芬太尼的话中国又不可能再过来打一场芬太尼战争
China is not responsible for your pathetic laws. Don't mix up purposeefully sending drugs by the British drug lords vs American companies buying fentanyl to promote opiods for their own profits.
The USA makes it profits off of war.
Lots of opium and African slaves were sold in the name of the queen.
Loved it, very good! 👍🏽
Great video!
Correction : Indonesia became independent on August 17, 1945 !! The Proclamation of Indonesian Independence was read by Soekarno, accompanied by Mohammad Hatta, at Jakarta. Indonesia declared its independence shortly before Japan's surrender, but it required four years of sometimes brutal fighting, intermittent negotiations (Indonesia War of Independence) , and UN mediation before the Netherlands agreed to transfer sovereignty in 1949.
Kami, bangsa Indonesia, menjunjung tinggi bahasa persatuan, Bahasa Indonesia
Inonesia's elite spoke Dutch. Now they speak English. To unite the country Bahasa Indonesian was introduced.
Many better languages in Indonesia. Why speaking Dutch? Only 2 b able 2 talk 2 few people.. n not d great ones.
This was such a well made video. Voice over is peaceful and in pretentious, imagery is lovely, background music is not overwhelming and the information is delivered in a well constructed narrative. Well done, and thank you.
Mengapa kita perlu mempelajari Bahasa musuh yang tidak berguna?
Apakah harus bersyukur ? Aapun alesannya jadi Indo gak terlalu ke-branding as Dutch colony ? 😮
Pembelokan sejarah yg sempurna
It was colonized for no more than 150 years .see google . Dutch did not want the prople to be clever .. only elite Indonesia can enrolled into dutch school ..
because the Dutch self is Change language they sayyed is Dutch language 1945 not function 40 years ago after '80(niece Queen Beatrix self sayyed that)
when i was kid i realize that, how dutch occupied our country for hundred years but we can't speak dutch😅
They do actually, Recent generations just don't usually learn dutch like their Grandparents did since We already have our own language
FYI, Indonesian independence is 17th August 1945, not 1949. So that could be seen that Dutch has been doing war crime for 4 years but they denied it b'cos they dont wanna seen as perpetrators of war crimes as they do military aggression after Indonesian independency proclamation twice.
Indonesia dont speak dutch but so many languange similar .... we also sleep with guling like dutch.. we also eat some food similar with dutch foood. Dutch food,languange and life 30 % stilll live in indonesia ... in middle indonesia
Good for them 👏👏
Props to the usage of FTL music, love that game
differ from those in philippines..due to colonization. the country change the name of country, change their religion from islam to catholic..change their pwoples name to spain name... we' re indonesian proud to our culture... we're moslem but our name and culture still exist
From Jose Rizal in his novel El Filibusterismo, 1891 One and all you forget that while a people preserves its language, it preserves the marks of its liberty, as a man preserves his independence while he holds to his own way of thinking. Language is the thought of the peoples. Luckily, your independence is assured; human passions are looking out for that!”