so much info was left out

A) Why were there an Arab majority region in this area? Because of the Ottoman empire! The amazing Ottoman empire, the modern Islamic empire, ruled over millions of square kilometers, for hundreds of years. Before them there were Greeks, Romans, Byzantines, and even the civilization of Mesopotamia. But an Independent land of Palestine? The term "Palestine" was used by these ancient empires to describe this region, but there was never a "Palestinian" state, nor "Palestinian" people nor "Palestinian" culture. There were just inhabitants of empires, that moved around (you can even check it out! The ancient people living in this area from the time the Roman empire ruled this land are not the same people that lived in this area in the time of the Ottoman empire). B) "A war started in 1947". While the Israelis accepted the UN's proposition, the Arabs living in this regions declined and didn't even want to talk to UN representatives. After the UN's declaration, The Arabs living in this state started attacking Israeli villages, and called to all the neighboring nations to "throw the Jews into the sea". But somehow, the tiny Israeli state won. Frankly, Israel, by reasonable thinking, should have been destroyed. But it didn't! Stop talking like the entire story is one sided. You are deluding everyone. Nice graphics though.

@quoteschannel5040

8 ай бұрын

Study well little knowledge is dangerous

You forgot to say that the Jews agreed but the arab's didnt.

@knoriy

8 жыл бұрын

+Shalev Dahan Did you forget that it was their land to begin with, you wouldn't expect America to give a peace of their land away.

@sjbubbly

8 жыл бұрын

+Kari Noriy It was neither of their land to begin with, you know how many times that worthless strip of land has been reconquered and borders rehashed prior to this sensationalized bull s***? None of them can in good conscience make the claim "I was here first". And even if we were to entertain this childish notion of "first come first serve", it doesn't mean the land will be best utilized to help humanity by either party. Humanity has bigger problems coming down the pipe that WILL take precedence over this trivial crap and if they don't settle the hell down and "play nice", they're going to be scratched off this earth. When crisis faces humanity and leisure is becoming more scarce with increasing demand for survival, you better believe the most burdensome groups will be the first to go. Like it or not, they're surviving off the tolerant nature of the rest of the world and survival tends to wear thin the patience required for that.

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

@@knoriy correct

@t0misin

3 жыл бұрын

@@knoriy it was a British land. The brits divided it equally among them, the Jews agreed, the Arabs didn't

@algorithm.engineering

3 жыл бұрын

@@knoriy It was never their land There wasn't any Palestinian coin/king Before the current situation the British rule the region, before them the ottomans, before them the mamluks, before them the crusaders, before them Arabs who came from the region turkey and Saudia, before them the Byzantiuns, before them the Israelis who ruled the region for more then thousand years. The identity of the Palestinians started to be created in the 19th century at the time the jews started to reclaim the land. This land called Palestine by the Romans 800 years before the arab conquest and the creation of Islam!

The way it works is when you conquer an area you own that area and do what you want with it.

That noise in the back makes it hard to listen to, good bye.

Jordan has been an independent kingdom since 1946 The Emirate of Transjordan established in April 1921 And before that it was Palestine. So if Israel is Palestine, Jordan is also Palestine.

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

We are all arabs so it doesnt really matter

@lscottschlager2147

3 жыл бұрын

Most theologians agree that in God's covenant with Abraham, the land God was giving to the Hebrew nation was roughly what we now call Israel and Jordan. The city of Jericho sits West of the Jordan river but when Moses led the Hebrew people out of Egypt, he led them to the Jordan river where they crossed over and settled in Canaan which was mostly East of the Jordan river.

@Sp3ll633

3 жыл бұрын

True. Mandate Palestine also included parts of Jordan.

Her last statement was interesting: "A state that was once historical Palestine". However the fact that the same entire area was PREVIOUSLY once the state of historical Israel, is not mentioned.

@gregorywinch688

9 ай бұрын

It only was it historically Israel but there are texts dating as far back as 500 BC stating it as such. From Dan to Be'er Shiva ( Beersheba) this land belongs to the Israelites.

@spudinho1

9 ай бұрын

@@gregorywinch688 So presumably New York State belongs to the indigenous American Indians?

@ignorantarewatermelons

8 ай бұрын

correct! ... "historical palestine" started only in 19th century ... "historical israel" for more than 3000 years already.

@gnosis8142

8 ай бұрын

There is another critical way that the statement that Israel now is the majority of Palestine, is false ― Jordan is ~80% of Palestine. Israel is currently a fifth\20% of the previous Palestine land. So if you want to give the Palestinians a proper size land to live on, where they already lived ― you can easily fix it. And it won't even be fair to the Jews. P.S. to OP ― there were many things that weren't mentioned in this video :-D.

@keifer7813

8 ай бұрын

So really the land belongs to no one. It's just your turn. Yo these lands are sounding like my ex....

This is so biased.........

No mention of occupation by Egypt and Jordan - very balanced!

@simmydafinessa8017

3 жыл бұрын

True, but even the most radical palestine sympathizer doesn't want that. They want the area judenfrei, they've been wanting that for a long time. They forget the fact we were subjected to dhimmi status and not allowed to our holiest sites! If there is a "free palestine", Iran, Syria, or Jordan will take the opportunity to colonize it or turn it into another Iranian proxy state and what will happen to all the israeli cities and villages will make what happened in Gaza look like the morning dew. But what can you expect from marxist ideologues who base their existence on pipe dreams of taking over Jerusalem. Heh as if!

@ahurali5185

2 жыл бұрын

I don't get it, Palestine was just an Ottoman Territory before the British Invasion, in other words there was no nation or country of Palestine

Where is Narnia? You can't find Narnia on a map. So, you mean Palestine and Narnia are the same?

You completely left out Jordan. The land that was captured from the Turks wasn't called Palestine, it was named that by the British in 1917.

@wheelie642

9 ай бұрын

This video is an ignorant view of the country.

@ignorantarewatermelons

8 ай бұрын

they had so many missed narratives.... if comleted, it would turn out that israel belongs to israel.

you say israel kicked out 700k "palestinian" refugees then why there are still arabs in israel who enjoy full rights even after the 1948 war

@albertobarrera2961

3 жыл бұрын

You are so dumb, i was taught not to insult or berate the weak and ignorant. I will spare you, genuinely have pitty for people like you.

It's very difficult to learn with bongos in the background.

@devoraarram4836

5 жыл бұрын

It's very difficult to learn when only half of the truth is told and most of the facts aren't even mentioned in order to make the "Palestinians" look better and the Israelis look bad.

Historical all the way back to 1913? What a joke.

Hard to swallow the truth? People still confuse between who rules/occupies/colonize a land, and the nation who actually lives there. When the Middle East was under the rule of the Ottomans for over 800 years it didn't become the land of the Turks, same thing when the English came along (not only to Palestine, but also Jordan, Iraq and Egypt) the and remained Arab (Jewish, Christian and Muslim all together). And so, bringing a bunch of European zionist Jews in under British sponsorship doesn't change ethnic right of the people who LIVE THERE. Saying anything except that is like saying colonized India was inhibited by the British just because they ruled over it. The actual difference here is that this particular occupation happened at a time when the world had supposedly developed international laws (which it broke) which in turn should be overthrown and occupiers should go back to their original lands (given that the threat on Jews in Europe has be eradicated).

@omricabaza

2 ай бұрын

King solomon built the first temple in Jerusalem 3000 years ago. 1300 years ago Muslims barged in. So understand please that we jews/zionsts belong to Israel since forever. Its our eternal land. Palestinians are just visitors. Plus palestine is just a name given by kind Hadrian to erase jewish presence nothing more than that. Palestine never existed. JUDEA DID! YOU CAN'T ERASE TRUTH NOR ITS HISTORY. SO KISS OUR ISRAELI ASSES FOR LETTING YOU STAY UPON OUR SACRED LAND. YOU'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO BE HERE AFTER ALL

I love how this history started only 100 years ago because it’s politically inconvenient to discuss who had the land first and what kingdoms were established beforehand

Tell me how the country is called Palestine first?

Video left out the fact that Transjordan was given to the Palis in 1948. that is the Pali homeland. the Peace loving pals moved to Jordan and tried to murder their king and they were all kicked out of Jordan. Some of these pals live in Gaza, which was given to them for "PEACE" in 2005. Wheres the peace, Pals?? there is none b/c you dont want it

@NoChecker

2 жыл бұрын

Who is pals

@mahamedali7147

2 жыл бұрын

What peace when israelis stole their land, the whole land is entitled to palestine, Free palestine 🇵🇸

@Bill-sj4fw

3 ай бұрын

And I can literally write a book on everything you've left out. This is a quick video relax

thnx it helped a lot

In 1947 the Arabs REJECTED the partition proposed by the United Nations. She just says "That didn't happen" omitting that fact.

@robertcampbell6042

10 жыл бұрын

Not only rejected it but the various Arab League attacked Israel so they could divide up the land among themselves and screw the Palestinians.

@Sarafara7

10 жыл бұрын

Do you know why they REJECTED the partition plan? Because no one comes to a country and says "I'll take more than 50% of your land and you're going to have to deal with it." Then, begins massacring the natives. It's just not common sense. Got it?

@Sarafara7

10 жыл бұрын

Robert Campbell Hmmm, that's not how it happened. :)

@Jordanicolass

10 жыл бұрын

Alaanot3ala: They didn't make the partition, it was the UN who made the partition, and the countries of the world voted. Those lands were part of the Ottoman Empire and passed to British hands after WW1. The British were the ones who divided the Ottoman Empire lands and they promised a piece of land to the Jews through the Balfour Declaration. The British however didn't wanna make the Arabs mad because they were their main source of oil. That's why they passed the hot potato to the UN. Now in 1948 Israel was not even close to have the army they have now. The Arabs and Israel were pretty equal militarily back then. When you say slaughter the population that's quite amusing. It was a civil war and there were casualties on both sides. Israel was attacked by 7 Arab countries and everybody thought they were over, no one came to their rescue, and by every ones surprise they defeated the Arabs. Your point is actually the real problem of the issue. The problem is not land because even if you get half of it you won't be happy. Land is the scapegoat. The ultimate goal is to completely eradicate Jewish presence. And you pretty much expect the Jews to just sit back and let you do it? Ridiculous!

@jns6320

10 жыл бұрын

Robert Campbell 1. So everyone BUT the Palestinians decided how the land was to divided? 2. In 1948 Israel had the dominant military. Even with combined Arab strength, the Israelis had greater manpower and weapons. The Arabs were divided, had poor communication, little ammunition and were divided internally. When the arms shipment from Czechoslovakia arrived, Israeli victory was assured.

Deceitful video with one-sided agenda, no mentioning that every war started with Arab aggression on Israel, and every territory gain was after a defensive victory, this is important

@ehabuossef8026

2 жыл бұрын

If i came in your home and kicked you out of your room and told you this is my room now go and live in other room You will think I'm joking but I'm not you try to punch me but i stop you and kill your brother And took now the living room and the room then you tried to attack me again and i stopped you and killed another one of your family again untill you had only 1 room in the entire house and none wants to hear that this house is yours but think you are a guest because i given them some fake contracts and etc to show this house was for my grandpas for 582837374882 years ago and that means it now belong to me You asked the help of your neighbors but he shot them and buried them in the garden alive and you still can hear them screaming from down the dirt and you cant do anything I think this doesnt need explanation at all.

i didnt got who start those wars?

@coolranch-ez4tu

3 жыл бұрын

Britain

Can you do one on Middle Earth next?

@maryamjxydbfb

3 жыл бұрын

tf is middle earth? do you mean middle east? or the fantasy land of the hobbit and lord of the rings

@aaronmeyer9618

3 жыл бұрын

Maryam Mokhbat the fantasy land

@mohommedameenahmed2099

3 жыл бұрын

Q

You only have power over people so long as you don't take everything away from them. But when you've robbed a man of everything, he's no longer in your power - he's free again - Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

Isn't this the story of Jacob and Esau?

Can't understand most because the audio is way too loud

Why can't you make an infographic explaining from 70 AD?

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

Ill explain it to you from canaanites till the ottoman empire and till today kingdom of israel and judea collapsed after king david and solomon died the babylonians destroyed it and your comment was from 1 year ago i can explain more but idk if you still have this account

@akanksha7028

3 жыл бұрын

@@samer.a say say...

This is Swiss Cheese Journalism. That's when you attempt to present your opinions as facts. After you have formed the opinion you intend to use, you look at historical facts and cull only those points that may lend an ounce of credibility to your hypothesis and what you're left with is a story that's so full of holes it looks like a piece of Swiss Cheese. And this poor girl doesn't even do a good job at that because the few points of history she mentions she deliberately twists, and clumsely fabricates. This girl isn't even a good liar.

@lscottschlager2147

3 жыл бұрын

@gavin's friend not new to me however the level of antisemetism is at an all time high and there is an entire generation of young Arabs that hate Jews and the Israeli government and they don't even know why. So much easier to just accept whatever these pathological liars tell them then to do a little research and figure things out for themselves. I watched today's top pathological liar, Dr. Karmi, on an Arab produced television show, look directly into the camera and state that the Balfour Declaration dictates that the Arabs leave Palestine to make room for a Zionist State. That statement is going to become a universal truth because few people are going to take the time to read 3 or 4 paragraphs and realize how incidious this woman is. That is why every single remark uttered by anyone - regardless of how cavalier it may be spoken - must be challenged. We cannot give these people 1 more inch - not 1 more grain of sand.

Hitler had a brighter idea than Balfour because his initial idea was to migrate them to Madagascar… at least there was no one in Madagascar. The latter is just the same as what Netanyahu, sharon, golda meir etc… is doing to Palestinians today… but the agony & mental torture of it going on for years and years of seeing other people taking over your land making it into an open prison is probably worse.

Wouldn't the Arabs be Saudi Arabia? Not Palestine

Wow I’m a neutral but this segment feels entirely pro-Palestine There’s always two sides of a story… this sounds way one sided

To begin with, this is one of the most twisted videos I've seen in quite a while and to be honest I understand why some people here chose to believe it, after all having no job or school leaves you bored and you just have to show your enthusiasm towards "humanity". Okay so before I begin I assume all the pro-'palastinians' or whatever you name yourself also keep protesting against what is STILL going on in Syria, Aritrey, Sudan, Poland and etc, 'coz like the song says you are "all about humane 'bout humane" right? Okay so, the woman says the 'plan never happend' referring to the U.Ns' plan regarding the 2 state country, well it didn't happen because the arabs denied it on the sight of it, that happend 2 more times on later dates, he/she continued to lie on and on about the villages destroyed in the "war that broke out" well, you know, when 4 countries, come on 1 and the 1 country wins, obviously they won't sit and wait for the villagers who by the way also helped in the war to do it again, so they simply demolished the traitors house and took what's rightfully NOBODY's! as no agreement was signed and the british left! It was UNCLAIMED LAND, so to conclude, spare me of correcting all of the twisted vids and just spread my word.

Israel’s sovereignty, its territorial integrity and political independence were agreed upon when Israel Declared its Sovereignty and was subsequently recognised as Israel requested to be recognised, in accord with the partition plan, Res 181 borders. The words are:* “acknowledgement of”. When Israel declared its Sovereign extent as being defined by the partition plan, Res 181 borders, it acknowledged what lay outside of the borders recommended by Res 181 were not it’s own. The International Community of States agreed and acknowledged that this was territory Sovereign to Israel, in doing so acknowledging what was not Israeli Sovereign territory, outside the borders of the State of Israel.

I have seen a map of Palestine what encompasses Syria. Once the River to the Sea is accomplished are you going after Syria?

There is No Palestine

So much was left out.

The jews agreed to the UN 181 Suggestion while the Arabs did not The Arabs started a war 1 day after the British army left the region. In this war the "naqba" occurred - hundreds of thousands of Arabs fled - It is a very sad thing but unfortunately this is a typical thing which happens in any war(I don't trying to justify it at all). In this war(which the Arabs started) 1 % of the jews in the region died! Half million of the local Arabs fled/expelled - What do you think would happen to the jews if the Arabs won? The Palestinians didn't even try to offer any peace suggestion while the Israelis made dozens of offers The Palestinians didn't miss any opportunity to miss an opportunity!

I understand that you have to obey the Qatari government. But you could be less biased, or pretend that you are not biased.

id love to listen but its hard to focus over this annoying music

That land whose name Palestine by Greece why named philastina land of philastins greece people not arab

@shainazion4073

2 жыл бұрын

The Greeks called the land as Palestine because of the Jews. The word in Greek of "palasteis" means "the wrestler" because Jacob wrestled with God, it became the land of the people who wrestled with God. Any other questions??

A lot was skipped when 1948 was mentioned who allowed Israel to form when uk left?

@user-qd4tf8dt7b

9 ай бұрын

i might be wrong but there's a civil war right after, most muslim left the area. The Jews 'won' and I think 'UN' is the one recognized Israel. Again, I'm not sure, I read from a lot of different source.

@bbaff8622

8 ай бұрын

Was not really a civil war. Some 8 arab armies attacked Israel to wipe them out.

That's because the "Palestians" refused to acknowledge the state of ISrael or the right of the Jews to have a state.

@maryamjxydbfb

3 жыл бұрын

they have no right to take someone else's country just because they dont have one

You said at the end Israel had imposed itself on the region known as Palestine? So Palestine did exist before Israel was created. Is that what you are saying?

So basically, what you're saying is that "Palestine" was "occupied" by the Ottomans aka Turkey (1486-1917), then it was "occupied" by the British (1917-1948), then it was "occupied" by Jordan (1948-1967), and now it's "occupied" by Israel (since 1967). So basically, you're saying Palestine never existed and doesn't exist? Got it, thanks.

@thekingisback4720

8 жыл бұрын

That is what she said I totally agree.

@thekingisback4720

8 жыл бұрын

sami mastouri a lot of your statements are not exactly accurate. And your comment made no point.

@thekingisback4720

8 жыл бұрын

sami mastouri and what do you mean extermination of millions. In the last 4 years the assad regime has killed more people than israel has killed in all of her wars combined.

@thekingisback4720

8 жыл бұрын

+sami mastouri no israel is a state maybe the people are invaders but there is nothing you can do about, 8,000,000 people are not going to move out of their home so you can debate it all you want but you are not moving 8,000,000 people.

@o0da7om0o

7 жыл бұрын

Aaron hahaha that whats Jewish trying to explain.. dude, Palestine has never either been occupied by Jordan or ottoman .. Israelis have no land .. they steal our land .. we gonna take it back at the end

before the British mandate it was controlled by the Ottoman. empire before that Byzantine empire before that the Roman empire before that the nation that was conquered time and time again was called judea. the Greeks Conquered judea and before them they Assyrians conquered northern judea and the Babylonians conquered all for judea no where in history does a empire,nation,country was called Palestine only was it re named Palestine by the Romans! also btw the Zionist immigrants wanted to name the new Jewish state Palestine so i wonder if what Arabs would call themselves then would they say there Israelis? ?

The annoying background drums are louder than your voice.

This video leaves out a lot, a whole lot of history. It only goes back to 1917. Wow, very misleading!

0:39 The nakba?? Your pronunciation of the word is very bad. 🌚 النكبة 🌚 اعرف وربي نطقهم سيئ وش الناكباا؟؟؟

@shainazion4073

2 жыл бұрын

Please watch the video, *"How we really became refugees, 13 Palestinians tell their personal stories"*

Leaving out key facts to distort reality? "War broke out un 1948..." well tell me why that was? Historical Palestine - what is that? The history of Palestine dates back way before there was EVER a national identity called Palestinian. Make this video a minute longer and incorporate a few of the essential details, then I'll pay closer attention.

Try in nernia...

This round of fighting was sparked over a dispute over land in East Jerusalem. The short version of this dispute is Jews buying the land while the Ottoman Empire ruled the area, however during 1948 (Israeli Independence War), the Jordanian Arab Legion has conquered East Jerusalem and deported all Jews living there, and giving their properties for the fleeing Palestinians to live there. Fast forward to 1967 (Six Day War), Israel has liberated all of Jerusalem. Jews that owned those properties sued after the current occupants refused to pay rent, and as the land wasn’t theirs, lower circuit court has ordered their eviction until blocked by the Supreme Court following riots by the Palestinians. Said riots have spilled into the Al Aqsa Mosque, Islam’s third holiest site, in which they assaulted police officers with stones, firework launchers and pepper spray. It was also accompanied by an attempted lynching of a Jewish driver

There is no palestine

@hargajasapembuatanwebsite8879

7 жыл бұрын

ds There is no Israel, but State of Israel

@ds-ts2ml

7 жыл бұрын

Harga Jasa Pembuatan Website Long live the STATE of Israel!!!!!!!!!!!

Where was pallistine? You still never showed us.

In Jordan

@amalomar4382

3 жыл бұрын

nah Jordan for Jordanians Palestine ( the country that has been stolen by Israelis )for palastinian (the native people for that country)

Who did the ottomans conquered it from

Ehhh Historical palestine on the map also included Transjordan so Historical palestine is takes up most of Israel and Jordan

@TheJakeybonz

9 жыл бұрын

+Tropicadero oh right and also theres no historical palestine.

@Tropicadero

9 жыл бұрын

+TheJakeybonz Yeah Palestine was just a region not a state

What happened if britishers do not invade the world ?

PEOPLE ON COMMENT SECTION TALKING LIKE THEY know better than PALESTINIAN themselves :)

@evy2432

3 жыл бұрын

Palestinians don't even know the meaning of their own name - "Palestine"! LMAO

According to history juw never had a land & they will never get !

@roachman8744

9 жыл бұрын

According to history you have never picked up a book

@yacinelayri

9 жыл бұрын

I have read somme but not match history & According to your comment you have never read or listen abut truth , what really happened to juw !

@izyphotos001

9 жыл бұрын

#yacine you should read some history books - Jews have been in the Israel area for over 3000 years. How long ARABS have been there? PALESTINE? PALESTINIANS? Just a make up name for the region that the british gave so they don't have to call it ISRAEL. Learn history!!!

@musmohdnor539

6 жыл бұрын

yes

@fourtess6602

5 жыл бұрын

@@izyphotos001 Hmm the Romans gave that name after the Philistines who were invaders of land and israels biggest enemy at the time.

*When I hear my country is in danger, it really hurts me. I hope God some day will help us.*

@tatsumakimojo5502

4 жыл бұрын

Sali Badr you country is not in danger, it s at war. Maybe it’s time to concede and make peace.

@user-zw1k

Жыл бұрын

Same

@djpaulcfunkeddub3951

9 ай бұрын

@@tatsumakimojo5502 Concede what? You concede! Cont!

@wcc4269

9 ай бұрын

This the same dude who will sob to the US to stop all this lmfao@@djpaulcfunkeddub3951

@ily_sm1073

9 ай бұрын

@@tatsumakimojo5502it’s not ur place you’ve comed from literally nowhere!!! israel is not a country it’s just a group of people !!!!!!!!!! Occupied Israel!!

hmmm...i wonder why there where no Palestinian state in the west bank and Gaza from 48 to 67?...hmmm

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

Damn 4 years ago i wouldve explained but your probably dead

In your mind

This left out a lot of facts.

So why is this "Where Is Palestine" video not showing all of what was considered Palestine? Just there area that is in conflict with the Jews... Shame Shame Shame

History: F

yes ... being palestinian means that you live in palestine ... there were the palestinians of arab descent ... and ... the palestinian jews ... both are "palestinians".

this isn't true

Palestine is not exist now....I search but I can't found only Israel is shown in map

1000

Funny how the jews seem to have not read the torah where it states that they are in exile n God has banned them from having a state... most jews believing that there state will not be created until there messiah comes funny how looking into your faith can resolve this whole conflict

Gaza prison without electricity, water and food is subject to extermination

Palestinians gave their own land for money 💰

@shainazion4073

2 жыл бұрын

In the 1945 British Land Survey, the Palestinian farmers only owned 3.3% of the land.

I am amazed as to how can some people be so misled. Firstly, the war of 1948 was sparked by the Arabs (the Jews agreed to the preposition, unlike what was implied by the narrator, that both sides didn't like the plan) and so Israel had the right to occupy some land. Later in 1967, Israel indeed start the war but only against Syria and Egypt, Jordan decided to attack and so Israel took over the West bank. Throughout all this time, Israel NEVER forcefully evacuated any Arabs, they all left on their own. Ask the 1.7 million Arabs who live in Israel and receive equal rights to other Jews. To sum up, This video is strongly very anti-Israeli like every other video made by AJ+

Historical Palestine?

Before 1917

What music is that? Also who's the voice actress?

Who are the Palestinians?

Yeah when you say "War Broke out"...common. Every country around Israel attacked it Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Egypt with the goal of annihilating Isarel and driving the Jews into the sea. Did you know that when Germany lost their AGGRESSIVE war in 1945, they lost 20% of land AND were forced to take in about 20,000,000 Germans living outside of Germany? What happens when you lose a war of aggression, you usually lose land. Yes Israel is bigger today than it was in 1947 but like the other youtube user stated, the Arabs REJECTED the Partition rendering it non binding and ATTACKED the newly formed State thereby causing a "war of aggression" Don't forget, there already is a Palestinian Majority in a place called JORDAN which is ruled by foreigners that have no claim to any land anywhere. Also it's not a "separation wall" - it's a security fence that saved THOUSANDS of lives because Palestinians unlike Jews value death and honour more than life and peace. If it was truly about separation then Israel would separate areas in Haifa, Jaffa and other areas where about 20% of it's citizens are PALESTINIANS! (which of course is a made up nationality, it's like saying Americans who live in California are Californians which is true for the State but it's not their nationality) These Palestinians are "Arabs" and lived in the "Ottoman empire" and if they wanted to have a State, from 48-67 they were ruled by Egypt and Jordan, why didn't they create one?

True History📖 👍 Friends 😢😭😭

The Ottomans did not call that region Palestine they called it Southern Syria

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

All arabs lived there so it didnt really matter the name you shouldve stayed in europe and thats it

so wrong, omg this person doesnt know history...

@samer.a

4 жыл бұрын

Better than you

🌼

So Palestine was Turkish. So Palestinians are Turkish. So being a Palestinian is like being a Texan but disregarding The United states... in a way. So Palestine was never a country, just an area of the ottoman empire. But History Clearly proves that Jews were there before the Ottoman empire. So once that collapsed, Jews got their land back and the Left over Turkish muslims got angry about the fact the Jews came back home. Got it. Thanks for the video update =-)

@daniel4740

9 ай бұрын

Facts

@NolaCross-lr8zr

4 ай бұрын

FICTION!

@NolaCross-lr8zr

4 ай бұрын

FICTION! ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE, WE HAVE 10 LOST TRIBES. THEY ARE SCATTERED ABROAD. ONLY 2 REMAINED: BENJAMIN AND JUDAH. SO WHERE DID THE REST OF THE JEWS COME FROM?!? THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS EUROPEAN JEWS! AND THEY AREN'T WHITE! IF JUDAH WAS ONE OF THE LOST TRIBES, WE WOULDN'T HAVE JESUS! AND THOSE PEOPLE IN GAZA ARE JEWS, NOT TURKS! AND REVELATIONS 2:9 TALKS ABOUT FALSE JEWS AND HOW HELL IS WAITING FOR THEM. YOU ALL HAD BETTER READ YOUR BIBLES!

Emm what about telling what really happened in 1948? A 1 day old country of Israel was attacked by the Arab league army's and won the war of independence so yeah if you mess with the bull you get the horns! The only one to blame for the only one to so call "Nakba" is the Arab league. The "Balfour Declaration" are you joking? If it had happened there would not have been a genocide for the Jew in world war 2, just 5 years after the declaration of 1917 that call Israel the rightful home of the Jews in 1922 the White Paper has limit the migration of Jews to Israel and by 1939 the second white paper limit Jews migration to 10k a year! And a total of 75k between 1940~1944 (a time were 6milion Jews murdered by Nazis) but you just "forgot all of this" Keep this in mind the use of "Palestinians" as a detention of people was not in use until the creation of the state of Israel and mainly after 1967 at Arab states never wanted to create a state for the "Palestinians" in the land of British mandate Palestine it would have been added to Egypt / Jordan and Syria. And yet with all that one of the best places in the world for a Palestine to live in , is within the state of Israel as an Israeli citizen where he or she can get any education he wish vote for the government , get government found health care work where ever he wish think freely say what's on his mind and achieve his or her dream. Can they do it in the web bank? Gaza strip ? Jordan? Or maybe peaceful Syria? Probably not but in Israel they can.

@Musak66

10 жыл бұрын

nobody forgot the NAZI REGIME and 95% of the world do not support the nazi regime and its also important that you israel people should stop justifying more than 500 civilian kills to less than 40 soldiers kills as what you people called "israel have the right to defend itself" cruel and foolish please mind my language, you should stop been ignorant of what your government is doing to the external masses and make your personal research before the EVIL YOU SENT COMES BACK TO HUNT YOU.

@dolevabelson7925

10 жыл бұрын

Boss Ross Of course I don’t mind your language on the contrary your entitled to have your own opinion and I embrace it that what so lovely about democracy, and hear that! Israeli Palestinians express their main to freely. Can the Palestinians in Gaza say that too? Sure if they wanna be killed right after that by Hamas followers see what happen to the lost once who opposed Hamas in the battle of Gaza in 2007 Fatah followers were thrown from the 16h floor of Gaza billings. Blind by my government that just funny tell did you know that Israel agreed to 3 … 3 ceasefires requested by Hamas the UN guess who broke them? If you would have truly care about the people of Gaza your would have YELL! #freeGazafromHamas 13k rocks where fire from Gaza in the last few years each cost 800$ that worth over a Billion $ , 60 tunnels dredged into Israel were found cost over 2m$ each that’s equal to 75% of Israel government fund for healthcare so please if you wish to see death support Hamas if you wish to see a new down for Gaza support the disarm of Hamas and the rise of Fatah.

They said they were ethnically cleansed by the Israelis? Where were you crying during the ottoman Empire and the British mandate? Didn't you but hurt cry at those times? Lol I guess arabz will be arabz...

Here is logic to those without it. Palestinians never existed.. the word Palestine came from the Romans during the Roman Empire who named Palestine after Philistine, which happened to be a Greek island. Philistine in Hebrew means invader. They invaded Canaan, which was given to the Jews. Simply put, there was no such thing as Palestine or Palestinians before Roman Empire. So, its SO ironic how Palestinians claim Israel invaded Palestine when facts prove otherwise. So when Palestinians proudly call themselves Palestinians, they are basically saying "We are invaders" and when people say "support Palestine" they are saying support invaders. Its funny since Palestinians are not allowed to become citizen in Egypt, Syria, Jordan or Lebanon. What God promised to Israel, no hate filled muslim will take. What more proof does one need? Israel smashed 6 Arab nations in 3 different wars.

Wow, this piece is a text book example of what propaganda looks like.

@mozartips

3 жыл бұрын

Only people with no brain cells would think like you.

Next we eill hear about the nakba where israel moved a bunch of palestinians out if israel BECAUSE israel had just gotten invaded by 8 or so arab nations.

In 1948 the Zionists established a sovereign Jewish state in the heart of Palestine - this led to the immediate expulsion of around 750,000 Palestinians, along with the destruction of their towns and villages. 75 years on and the Zionist state is further away from peace than ever, locked into an unending cycle of violence and counter-violence, and with virtually no significant support other than the USA, for whom Israel is a convenient client state. Under Netanyahu the government has drifted increasingly towards a militaristic theocracy [not unlike Iran] and the current horrors in Gaza show that the IDF are the new Nazis, murdering women and children on an industrial scale.. And to those who won't speak out, remember - "silence is compliance".

War in Sudan - no protests. War in Ukraine - no protests. War in Afghanistan - no protests. War in Central African Republic - no protests. War in Ethiopia - no protests. War in Libya - no protests. War in Mali - no protests. War in Somalia - no protests. War in South Sudan - no protests. War in Syria - no protests. War in Burkina Faso - no protests. War in Nigeria - no protests. War in Benin - no protests. War in Togo - no protests. War in Algeria - no protests. War in Tunisia - no protests. War in Chad - no protests. War in Yemen - no protests. 1,200 people massacred in Israel on Oct. 7 - no protests. Israel defends itself from terror attacks - massive protests

Under Ottoman rule, the inhabitants of Palestine were Ottoman subjects constituting a sector of the larger 'Ottoman people'. To acquire Palestinian nationality at its first inception, one was required to hold status as an Ottoman citizen under the Ottoman Nationality Law, 1869. When Palestine was legally separated from Turkey on July 24 1923, Ottoman citizens who resided in the territory of Palestine became ipso-facto'Palestinian citizens'. This being confirmed by the Palestinian Citizenship Order which was enacted by the British in 1925.Hence it is imperative to view Ottoman nationality as it formed the basis of Palestinian nationality in accordance with international law.

@ignorantarewatermelons

8 ай бұрын

therefore , it shows that "palestinians" may not be indigenous to palestine ... there were the "palestinians" of arab descent ...and "palestinians" of jewish descent.

@JsJdv

8 ай бұрын

What does that have to do with the fact that Palestinians were the ones living in Palestine and being driven off by settlers forced upon them by western powers? It's easy to ignore the situation on the ground, doesn't it?

It seems most people here commenting have limited historical eyesight. You keep referring to it as the land of the Palestinians, when it was actually the land of the Jews - given and promised by God himself. However the Jews were taken from the land, evacuated the land, and so the area came under the control of the Ottoman Empire. The land name was then changed to Palestine. Why do some of you not acknowledge that it is also known by the name: the land of Israel? Way before the area was RENAMED by other rulers to Palestine (a version of the name Philistia) I don't say this to imply that Jews NOW have the right to reoccupy the land - that's up for debate. Jesus said their Temple (hence Jerusalem ) was abandoned to them for their lack of faith and disobedience to the true God. In other words, no more divine favor and protection from their enemies. A truth we see down to this day. Because of these facts, I stay neutral as to WHO really has a right to the land.

Why lie about everything ?

If they actually said why the two state solution didn't happen I might have taken what they said later seriously, but they wouldn't dare criticizing the Palestinians.

@sue3519

3 жыл бұрын

didn’t happen because Israel refuses it keeps stealing Palestinian land and build internationally illegal settlements

@carolgaribay

Жыл бұрын

I'll take over half of your house and see if you agree to my terms and conditions. I'll harass you, terrorize you, displace you, continue to take over room after room... The big neighborhood bully will promise to give me sovereignty some day, but that will never happen. You'll be seen as the stubborn one, unwilling to cooperate. Your family will be either maimed, killed or be thrown in jail for trying to defend the little dark room I've confined you to.

So basically it never existed.

Lol saying 1948 a war broke, and not saying its the arab nations who started it as well as in 1967 the six days war. what a misleading information in one video, I am amazed.

@vavom8999

7 жыл бұрын

terroism? there was a deal in which several arab nations didnt like and started a war. they lost the war and israel gained land beacuse of it

I would like to know how I am Palestine but my Dad is Israel

AJ+ = Al Jazeera

2024

#notmybusiness