If it was homeless people "getting everything" instead of immigrants, she'd be on TV ranting and raving about how unfair it is that hardworking people get nothing. There would ALWAYS be something. She's a harbinger of human sorrow

@connie7025

10 ай бұрын

Yep they don’t care about homeless people only when they provide a talking point

@feargach2107

10 ай бұрын

"If she was..." .Why not confine your comments to what she actually says. This entire item does little or nothing to further the debate. Time for me to unsubscribe from Novara as I believe in rights for migrants and this lob-sided name calling doesn't help.

@markwelch3564

10 ай бұрын

​@@feargach2107but this is what she said, about ten years ago

@tomritchie3408

10 ай бұрын

nail on head.

@Rejoin_2023

10 ай бұрын

Yep, the Tories have had 13 years to care about the homeless, and their situation has got worse just as it has for all of us.

Setting refugees against homeless people is utterly vile.

@biggusdickus5216

10 ай бұрын

Why's it all blokes if they're refugees then

@leehenry5764

10 ай бұрын

But they do nothing for homeless and everything for immigrants

@mikecook1537

10 ай бұрын

Is it not the case?

@chloebidwell228

10 ай бұрын

@@biggusdickus5216going to need more than just anecdotal evidence/opinion to back up that claim.

@ChristopherFynn001

10 ай бұрын

It is deliberate ~ and unfortunately works.

I have a colleague that hates people claiming benefits, even though he himself claimed benefits 10 years ago. I keep bringing this up and he just says "well I picked myself up and got a job" and I just respond with "no, you moved back in with your mum and spent the next 5 years without a job getting money from her, some people can't do that", and his response is "well, that's a them problem then isn't it. They should have parents". I don't understand.

@kumstuke

10 ай бұрын

Sounds like dead brain gammon case here, I'm afraid

@readikus

10 ай бұрын

I believe it’s called projection

@crotchet1586

10 ай бұрын

Conservative brains are literally different to liberals Article ''Conservative and Liberal Brains Might Have Some Real Differences''

@stephenroche5107

10 ай бұрын

Nice one👍

@johnfitzpatrick3197

10 ай бұрын

He is an ignoramus, but keep expising his hypicrisy!

What I find astonishing is that her partner is from Bulgaria and she was devastated when he couldn’t return to his home country during lockdown to see his mother. One rule for her and one for us. Her partner has a stronger stomach than I do, I could not stomach her opinions.

@alfsmith4936

10 ай бұрын

She's probably not allowed to voice her opinions at home and that's why she comes out with such hateful rubbish in public.

@ronantv

10 ай бұрын

He's actually Bosnian and apparently met in 1991. This would lead one to presume he may have come to Britain as a refugee at the time of the war in the Balkans. Would be nice for someone to ask her.

@lauralee9482

10 ай бұрын

@@ronantv even worst. 🤦‍♀️

@gordonaliasme1104

10 ай бұрын

Her pillow talk is asking him for details of any atrocities that he saw...☠️

Michael says he is sad about this. I can absolutely see where he is coming from here. I'm 74 and this divide and rule stuff has been going on my whole life. I remember when having a colour TV was weaponised against the poor (this later became the "flatscreen" TV argument), I have heard people object to people having "fish and chips" when they could boil up a pan of rotting vegetables. That it's being used against migrants is no surprise as Dalia says. Just seen an article in the "i" about Professor Alice Roberts where she doubts if we are any more civilised than people living in the middle ages. She almost certainly has a point.

@safirahmed

10 ай бұрын

​@@cujimmi Fish and chips comment was about the previously low prices in past years. People now complain about benefit claimants using smartphones and believe smartphones are a luxury when smartphones with internet access are an essential requirement by most benefit claimants to access benefits and use Universal Credit.

@nilsalmquist802

10 ай бұрын

@@safirahmed Indeed. Internet access is essential for applying for jobs and proving that you are actively seeking work. It certainly isn't a 'luxury' that the usual bigots such as this Malone woman would like us to believe.

@safirahmed

10 ай бұрын

@@nilsalmquist802 It's why I supported free broadband policy in the 2019 Labour manifesto.

@abigailweir7287

10 ай бұрын

​@safirahmed And the Tory BBC called it "Broadband Communism".

@safirahmed

10 ай бұрын

@@abigailweir7287 Yes they did and now they are thinking about the possibility of replacing the TV Licence fee with a tax on broadband.

So Michelle from Dorset has been homeless for twelve years and unable to get any help or support. The so called 'migrant crisis' has been an issue only in recent years. What were the Tory government doing when Michelle became homeless? What has the government done for the increase in homelessness over the past twelve years? The homeless were blamed for their own hardship, just like migrants are blamed for political point scoring. The issue sits with this government and the media that promotes their agenda against the vulnerable.

@everettscott4745

10 ай бұрын

Absolutely excellent insight. Well highlighted.

@matthewwatt2295

10 ай бұрын

​@@catscan2022The government isn't making an active decision to give migrants a better deal than the homeless - they are required by international and UK law to consider all asylum applications and house the applicant during that time if necessary. The home office are doing such a poor job to process their asylum applications (which may be rejected anyway) that we have a backlog of asylum seekers whose applications haven't been processed yet. The tories have created a problem for themselves by gutting the civil service departments that are supposed to be handling the applications and then they blame the migrants for the government's incompetence.

@Alun49

10 ай бұрын

@@catscan2022 Firstly we have to recognise that the government is not interested in finding solutions for things like homelessness. This is seen as an unnecessary waste of money. In regards to refugees, there are requirements under international law. Therefore, the government provides the most basic solution, but also uses this as a dogwhistle drawing attention to the money being spent and the need for draconian solutions, because, of course "this is not fair to the British People." Now they have an issue which can be used to distract the electorate from the governments disastrous track record, and pretend that they are having to solve a problem that they are actually parly responsible for. Thus voters, falling for the perceived threat, will tend to vote for the Tories. The ultimate aim is to present any social policy as against the interests of the British People and thus scrap right left and centre all the provisions they can for social welfare. The money thus saved, can then be siphoned off into government business contracts and thus to the profit of the wealthy classes. This is what fascists have always done. Pretend they are on the side of working people, and then trick them into screwing themselves. It works like a treat.

@whateverisavailabley

10 ай бұрын

​@@catscan2022because the governments.friends are making money from housing them.

@alfsmith4936

10 ай бұрын

​@@catscan2022What makes you think any more money would be spent on the homeless, if there were no immigrants? I think the people complaining now would be calling them "scroungers" and complaining about paying tax to keep the lazy comfortable, if they were all housed and given a comfortable life.

Like they have done anything for the homeless anyway but to pitch them again migrants is a new low.

@dj_cakes

10 ай бұрын

I don't understand why Right wingers have a need to make sure others suffer. Like, if they see migrants coming to the country, fleeing war or poor conditions or whatever reason, it is an absolute must that they be treated like shit when they get here. It is unacceptable that they should be treated kindly. Where does this come from? I dont understand this mentality.

@b00ts4ndc4ts

10 ай бұрын

@@dj_cakes this is how they keep the spot light off of them by having a Jeremy Kyle style of light the fire, throw on some fuel and while they fight it out, they don't become the target. Taxing the rich should be what we should be talking about. But don't let anyone tell you, that you are wrong for having compassion ✌️

@brianbarham2277

10 ай бұрын

Spot on@@b00ts4ndc4ts

Women ranting about having to live with her elderly mother and how awful it is. Disgusting lack of gratitude to her mother.

@patcampton7163

10 ай бұрын

So she wasn't homeless then, she could live with a relative.

The Tories create and maintain the costly immigration policies. If the Tories had simply built houses, funded the NHS properly, provided legal routes in from the countries that have none and invested in integration support then we wouldn’t be discussing this. Instead they decided to create an unnecessary issue and use these people as scapegoats. They do the same with the NHS, the benefit system etc. It’s intentional incompetence and it’s a strategy they are using to gain excuses to scrap good policies.

@shushanto

10 ай бұрын

Exactly right. It is ALL deliberate. Why is NO-ONE in the media (including the BBC) pointing this out? Labour MPs aren't doing it either. It's like they don't know how to talk properly. They keep making mealy-mouthed critcisms of "Tory Failures". It's not a failure, it's a deliberate strategy to destroy the country and pretend it's someone else's fault, while they hand taxpayer money over to the big CEOs. They'll probably get million pound jobs with them when they leave government.

@dj_cakes

10 ай бұрын

Create a problem, blame someone else for it, promise to fix it (but never get round to it)

@howardosborne8647

10 ай бұрын

Create division and disharmony is a very old tactic of distraction from the REAL issues ailing our society......typical of the Tory mindset,though.

@Camille_Anderson

10 ай бұрын

It would be nice of the British people had brand new houses, access to better health care and respect too.

@Areflection4

10 ай бұрын

You have succiently named the Tory government and their supporters.

Jeremy Vine is toxic. He pretends to be this nice cuddly guy who's 'just asking questions' on his radio and TV show but he knows exactly what he is doing

@M2Mil7er

10 ай бұрын

It's the proto-fash daytime TV to get the stay at home mums into it.

Carol doing well is inversely related to the state of this country. She is so obviously awful that it shows people's minds have rotted to take her in any way serious.

@bobsmithy9024

10 ай бұрын

4:51 This is probably not really true. All migrants are allowed to leave the hotel so that means they can work on the black market. Cash in hand work. The idea asylum seeker can leave the hotel but do nothing every day is silly and naive. We're all being gaslighted.

@hillydog

10 ай бұрын

What makes you think people people take her seriously?

@pseudonayme7717

10 ай бұрын

@@hillydogThe fact that she still has a job.

Well said Dalia, Malone is a nasty piece of work….split to rule indeed 😡

I can't stand Jeremy Vine and his awful show (it is a practically uncritical platform for Carol Maloney and her ilk)! Bring back Matthew Wright 😁

@alfsmith4936

10 ай бұрын

It's terrible isn't it? Whenever anybody blames the Conservative party for anything, he says "alright", like things are going too far and changes the subject. Storm Huntley is even worse. She pretends not to have an opinion but will happily go along with the far right, over centerists and lefties, when it's pushed on her by someone like Malone and says "some people might say (insert something fascist)" when nobody suggests something nasty enough. I used to like Alex Conran but even he lets things slide when they need calling out lately.

@sparkyjackson8479

10 ай бұрын

I was thinking it was a bit lobsided. No sitting on the fence there!

That woman at the start shouting "they stay in 4 star luxurious hotels" she can shout it all she wants, it doesn't make it true. Its truly disgusting the way the uk has become.

@annemoncrieff3875

10 ай бұрын

The way little engkand has become. STOP SAYING UK AND/OR BRITISH. IT IS ALL ON THE ENGLISH. We Scots r not like this.

@alzo1sgood

10 ай бұрын

@@annemoncrieff3875 I agree with you. It is embarrassing being ruled by that mob.

@Ellenad369

10 ай бұрын

Wakeup your country has betrayed you, your precious Queen and Ministers committed high treason they abolished the Uk and its laws back in the seventies,the United Kingdom has been a police state owned and controlled by N…Europe.

@domfjbrown75

10 ай бұрын

Not all English, thanks...

@Themystergamerr

10 ай бұрын

It makes me want to cry actually, the unjust inequality in this country 😔

A four star hotel is only a four star hotel when all the amenities like 24 hour room service, concierge service, daily maid and linen service, etc, are all operational. Cramming several people into a room without any of those amenities is not in any way a life of luxury for anyone.

@SamoIsKing

10 ай бұрын

This is the key point that people either arent aware of or are deliberately ignoring. As soon as a hotel starts being used for housing asylum seekers its not longer a 4* hotel.

@leehenry5764

10 ай бұрын

Luxury compared to the streets clown

@peterzapp2091

10 ай бұрын

Run down and empty hotels, because owners no longer can recruit staff from Europe, cost increased, tourists stay away from Ecoli-infected beaches and from unfriendly immigration officers.

@keldsleepnot7961

10 ай бұрын

@@leehenry5764 yet the vast majority of people living on the streets wouldn't begrudge them in the slightest. And you're avoiding the complex mental health needs of many of the homeless that lead them to turn down any offered help! Asylum seekers and homelessness are two very different problems that requires very different answers! Which you would understand if you ever actually bothered to find out what life is like for the homeless!

@leehenry5764

10 ай бұрын

@@keldsleepnot7961 Illegals are not asylum seekers, stop confusing the 2.

Absolutely Dalia, i remember Carol Malone shovelling her rubbish on that issue years ago-i can’t believe people are still falling for this brainless narrative

@Ellenad369

10 ай бұрын

Never mind the Presenters you should be more concerned about the illegals taking over your homes,which will happen because it was planned long ago,why do think all our services have been underfunded and failing,why do you think the NHS was sold off years ago.

@jimlyon7276

10 ай бұрын

I think that the best solution for us is that Carol Malone goes on Anger Management Courses- LOTS of them!

I remember her blaming France for us having to have our passports stamped after we left the EU, accusing the French of vindictiveness. She surely knew that, as we were no longer EU citizens, we were not entitled to the rights of other EU citizens.

@jackdeegan3617

10 ай бұрын

She also said that the EU was being vindictive when it implemented the etias visa program for British people, despite the fact that Britain was involved in starting the process back in April 2016 and that another 60+ countries were also placed in the same program at the same time as Britain.

@e.u.sheridan9727

10 ай бұрын

I like the stamps in my passport.

@patcampton7163

10 ай бұрын

I have to have my passport stamped when I go to Norway now. It felt like the 60s all over again 😊

Dare I suggest that "Michelle of Dorset" voted for the very party which put her and others in their position. As for Malone's hand-wringing about the homeless, if it wasn't for the asylum seekers, she would be attacking the homeless instead.

@craigsmith7457

10 ай бұрын

She was attacking people on benefits 10 years ago!

@patcampton7163

10 ай бұрын

I think Michelle of Dorset should be given a place on the barge. Let's see if she takes it?

Yeah the argument homeless people get nothing..... Pretty confident that if we had 0 asylum seekers the same people would be arguing that homeless people should get nothing. So that argument from her is complete bs.

Can't stand the woman! If the asylum seekers weren't here she'd be up in arms if there was government help for the homeless. It beggars belief that the tories have been in power for 13 years but it's not their fault 😠😠😠

I take it that Carol has been campaigning for homeless people and bringing up their plight for years. Im sure she has been.

@hayleyelizabeth717

10 ай бұрын

Haha Of course she has...😠😔 Awful woman

@PORRRIDGE_GUN

10 ай бұрын

In her right wing mind, she has.

@Themystergamerr

10 ай бұрын

Yeah, she's gone on hunger strike for them and everything 😂😂

@PORRRIDGE_GUN

10 ай бұрын

Well she skipped lunch a couple of times and went shopping at Harvey Nicks...@@Themystergamerr

@inspectortanzi

10 ай бұрын

She's been deafening in her silence.

Even were the government to put refugees into 4 star hotels, they certainly wouldn't be given 4 star treatment that's for sure. A single room for one would no doubt be used to accommodate four if not six people, and they certainly wouldn't get room service, nor a 4 star breakfast, that much I know.

Someone should remind Carole Malone that she is married to an immigrant 😂😂

@mnky75

10 ай бұрын

And Farage!

@KW-ro5ow

10 ай бұрын

I didn't know that, to be fair though I avoid her like the plague whenever she is wheeled out on telly.

@jake751

10 ай бұрын

Is he blind and hard of hearing?

@Drmerlin604

10 ай бұрын

The reason why people like Malone and Farage are married to immigrants is that there are certain unpleasant jobs that we British refuse to do.

@alfsmith4936

10 ай бұрын

Ahh but they're the "right sort of immigrant".. "The right sort" means "wealthy".

Put them up in Buckingham Palace We are paying the royal parasites enough for rooms, if they decline let the royals pay the bedroom tax..that should fund malones 4star hotels.

@nilsalmquist802

10 ай бұрын

I think we should just move the royals out in to the '4-star' hotels that Malone thinks are so luxurious. I'm sure they wouldn't mind.

Malone said in an express article yesterday that migrants were being housed in 5 star hotels,here she says 4 star. She can lie without question on the express but knew she left herself open to being called out if she repeated it on a panel on tv

@markwelch3564

10 ай бұрын

Even where the building was a four star hotel in the past, it doesn't stay four star once you've closed the fancy restaurant and the pool and the gym Even more so once you've stuffed two people into a single room

@tonybullion2537

10 ай бұрын

Once the hotel has been expropriated by the Home Office for use as immigrant accommodation it ceases to be classed as an hotel, luxury or otherwise. They become HMO’s (Homes of Multiple Occupancy) and the limits of numbers of occupants to a room exceed those of the former hotel. More beds can be put in the room, more occupants, even if they are complete strangers, can be crammed in, and the toilet/bathroom facilities are not improved or altered to cover the additional use! This Malone person quoting 4 Star hotels isn’t just being disingenuous but is, actually, lying through her teeth!

@KW-ro5ow

10 ай бұрын

She's done this before. Claiming illegal immigrants get free cars 🤣

That Jeremy Vine show caller is baffling. "I have struggled with homelessness in the past and I never got adequate help for it by our government" Paraphrasing, in the same breath: "How dare these homeless people get inadequate help from our government, they dont deserve it!" Can they not see what they're advocating for?

@deanolium

10 ай бұрын

Because the way they see it is that they are more deserving of help with the view that migrants and refugees should be at the bottom of the pile underneath the "native" population. So it's more trying to say "if someone is getting help, it better be me first rather than those people". The thing is that they're not realising that if someone waved a magic wand and there weren't any refugees or homeless migrants, it doesn't mean that the Govt would then start helping them. They don't seem to realise that the Government would rather they didn't exist as well.

@alfsmith4936

10 ай бұрын

She's been led right down the garden path hasn't she? The Cons have been in power for 13 years, she's been homeless for 12 and she blames immigrants. Oh well.. At least she pays road tax.

@BambiTrout

10 ай бұрын

It's the bitter attitude of "if I couldn't have it, then NO ONE can". The Tories feed off of this kind of selfishness and pride in suffering.

The caller proclaiming “there’s no money”, meanwhile record breaking profits and millionaires are laughing all the way to the bank. Tax the rich and fix the country.

Malone doesn't change. I'm not sure how any woman becomes so warped and vicious. She just hates and hates and hates. This depthless well of gleeful cruelty toward, always, the disadvantaged in society is stomach churning.

how is she so angry and how can people be so angry at asylum seekers? racism really is a failure of the human mind

@keirmitchell5560

10 ай бұрын

how many you got living with you?

@avoidconfusion

10 ай бұрын

@@keirmitchell5560 what's that got to do with anything?

@Tao_Tology

10 ай бұрын

She operates the same way Katie Hopkins does: it pays to be 'outraged' and say right wing things.

@RightDenied

10 ай бұрын

People are angry because natives are homeless. Suffering, struggling to pay bills to live. We have elderly that have to choose between heating or eating. That is why people decry immigration, especially illegal. Not your racism claim. That said, those that know, know that it isn't immigration alone that is the cause, but it is a corrupt government with no interest in helping its citizens and gross misuse of public funds, they use illegal immigration to deflect their crimes. However, that still doesn't invalidate peoples concern with spending money on illegals when we have issues at home. Ever heard of putting on your own oxygen mask before helping others? We are in no position to save the world, we can't even help ourselves.

@keldsleepnot7961

10 ай бұрын

@@keirmitchell5560 why how many homeless have you got living with you?

This country is so messed up, I just got back after 13 years overseas, very depressing. We all say since Brexit but actually I was already disgusted when I left in 2009. Best wishes to you all. 🙏

@07Flash11MRC

10 ай бұрын

Sure, but Brexit made a lot of things even worse or at least more openly / visibly bad.

@alistairrobinson3865

10 ай бұрын

@@07Flash11MRC yeah 100% agree just meant it was already on its way / bubbling under the surface

@janetmalcolm6191

10 ай бұрын

Actually it wasn't messed up 13 years ago to be honest but after Cameron and Osborne the rot set in. Austerity that has never ended for one. Stagnating wages was another. The decline has been so very obvious over these years and blaming Covid, Ukraine and goodness knows what else doesn't really cut it! You are right when you say depressing and the people are possibly getting depressed with it all.

@rodspence5105

10 ай бұрын

Nice comment alistair i got back in 2021 from living abroad and have the same view as you

The state of our media is so depressing. 😢 Thank you Novara for being compassionate.

Why, if the Tories are promising to reduce the number of asylum seekers being processed in quick time, has a hotel been given a 10 year contract to house asylum seekers? Could it be that the intention is NOT to reduce the numbers of asylum seekers waiting to be processed? Or, if the Tories ARE serious about reducing numbers of asylum seekers being put up in hotels, could the taxpayer be left with paying a 10 year bill for an empty hotel? Seriously the contract should be reviewed annually and reissued or denied depending on the service given. It would be interesting to know if any Tory donors are connected to these hotels.

Sadly this woman appears to have never learned that there's a difference between want and need. Everyone should get what they need.

@ryanfraser167

10 ай бұрын

You don't get to decide what ppl need neither does the state, that' happens in Russia, Cuba, north Korea, china.😊

@grimdolo918

10 ай бұрын

@@ryanfraser167 Please feel free to point out where I said I did?

@07Flash11MRC

10 ай бұрын

@@ryanfraser167 "You don't get to decide what ppl need neither does the state": Really, lmfao? You do realize that we are forced and coerced into doing a job just to get what we "need", which is just basic human rights like water, food, a small roof over our head and time with our loved ones. Don't speak of other countries when you've never even lived outside of your country's borders.

@M2Mil7er

10 ай бұрын

@@ryanfraser167 Is ignorance as bliss as they say it is?

4 star hotels ? Is she serious. Absolute lie and she knows it

They keep lying. 10 seconds of Googling get you the real info: New research from Shelter shows at least 271,000 people are recorded as homeless in England, including 123,000 children. Shelter’s detailed analysis of official homelessness figures and responses to a Freedom of Information request shows that one in 208 people in England are without a home. Of these, 2,400 people are sleeping rough on any given night, 15,000 people are in hostels or supported accommodation and nearly 250,000 are living in temporary accommodation - most of whom are families.

What makes me depressed and angry is Carol Malone´s stupidity. She should go on a luxury holiday for a few months with these lucky people

@michaelbaines6731

10 ай бұрын

Great idea.

Carole Malone should be challenged to go and live in a hotal under the exact conditions of the migrants for three months. If things are as luxurious as she claims, this shouldn't be a problem.

@jimmyrich4675

10 ай бұрын

I'd love to see this, make my year😂😂😂😂

Imagine living a life all wrapped up in hate and jealously like Carol Malonely

@iskrajackal9049

10 ай бұрын

Malonely 🤣 rofl

@alastairwallace6153

10 ай бұрын

KAREN malone.

@somecontrol268

10 ай бұрын

Yes but she makes a decent living from it. It is beyond me how anyone can even listen to her voice never mind her opinions.

Back in the 90s I remember there was a similar hysteria about ‘single mums’. Apparently they were bleeding the country dry with their Council flats and free holidays to Ibiza and flat screen TVs. All paid for by the ‘hard working tax payer’.

@patcampton7163

10 ай бұрын

Yes I was a single mum after divorce in the 90s. I remember it well.

Malone..Irish surname..seems fairly despicable for anyone to forget their past and where they're from and then in turn to punch down on migrants like this. So grim. Keep highlighting this stuff Novara. The media is the main problem

@peterswires8439

10 ай бұрын

Likewise Leo McKinstry.

@davidpryle3935

10 ай бұрын

You’re stretching it a bit there, talking about her surname. Her ancestors could have moved to England when all of Ireland was part of the United Kingdom. Indeed her ancestors could have been from the north of Ireland, which is still part of the United Kingdom. Not really any different to someone moving from Cornwall to Kent.

@reganovich

10 ай бұрын

@@davidpryle3935 🤣 you don't even know your own history nevermind Irish history

@davidpryle3935

10 ай бұрын

@@reganovich Well, you seem to have a problem with history and geography. Would you care to point out to me anything I said, that was inaccurate.

@reganovich

10 ай бұрын

@@davidpryle3935 bog leat

Malone is the worst type of two faced hack going.when she wrote for the Sunday people she wrote a piece running down Jill Dando the week before she was murdered and then tried to backtrack on what she'd said the week after.

The gall of them pretending they care about the homeless

Carole Malone doing her weekly audition to become a concentration camp guard.

Daughter of a proud Durham miner. I bet he’s turning in his grave.

It's a old joke about the banker, the homeless person and the asylum seeker having a cup of tea. There are 20 biscuits on a plate, the banker takes 19 biscuits and says to the homeless person:"That asylum seeker's trying to nick your biscuit." It's funny, because it's true. With Malone as the banker. And it's not funny anymore. Because it's true.

I am a Malone,and she is a disgrace to the family name.

10 years ago Carol was saying prisons were like a bloody Butlins camp.

I watched most of this debate on C5. She constantly cut across and interrupted the other person and JV was powerless to stop her.

You’re right it’s depressing. The caller’s no doubt genuine problems, and the issues faced in this country, are down to government policy yet they have convinced her that it is the fault of migrants, that it is an either / or - either she gets the support she needs OR the migrant gets the support they need, when in reality both the caller AND the migrant should get the support they need. Sad.

@zuzanazuscinova5209

10 ай бұрын

How can the state possibly afford to provide all this support without bankrupting itself?

@annabelgalt4616

10 ай бұрын

Yes the limited resources fallacy. Or the how can we help everyone or pay for everything limited debate. Money had been found for corruption from PPE etc it can always be found when needed. The gov can just ask the Bank of England to print more money. Like they did during covid. There is plenty of money in this country. It's called Capitalism its wealth and power is stored at that top bit of the triangle, whilst the lower people are divided fighting over the illusion of scraps.

@kieranb7047

10 ай бұрын

Genuinely interested when I ask this. How would you give both what they need?

@markwelch3564

10 ай бұрын

​@@kieranb7047we're one of the richest countries in the world. How can we _not_ afford the basics?

@ryanfraser167

10 ай бұрын

You pay for it all then, don't expect me or others to ..

Isn't it funny how the right-wing will reach for the "what about our homeless?" argument as some kind of excuse for what we're doing, but never ever usually mention it. In fact, the stay quiet about it usually. Homelessness has risen year on year since 2010, never heard Malone talk/report about it in that time.

@Leon-lt5gv

10 ай бұрын

👍

I had a shocking conversation with my friend a few weeks ago. The subject of politics does come up up occasionally and I often say we need to put a stop to austerity and he always disagrees with me despite being on minimum wage and struggling himself. It turns out he didn't even know it means cuts and under funding of public services. He thought it was some kind of pride in being British thing. Unbelievable. Maybe independent media needs to spell out what Tory policies actually are instead of using a broad term like austerity.

@jimlyon7276

10 ай бұрын

Next best thing? - I'll point you in the right direction. While I don't care for how Amazon abuse their workers - inc. criminal negligence up to the point of manslaughter, I'll still use their customer reviews- So look up "The Capital Order: How Economists Invented Austerity and Paved the Way to Fascism by Clara E. Mattei - Basically "austerity" is a near 100 year old act of right wing class warfare - deep sigh ! ! !

The more we talk about this issue,,,, we seriously need to acknowledge the main problem,,, and that’s our HOMEOFFICE ,,,, this government department has made a virtue out of ineptitude.

Just because of the disgusting way we treat our homeless, and other vulnerable people, that doesn't make it right to treat other vulnerable people this badly. Surely the issue here is how badly we treat the homeless, not how well we treat refugees

@jondrizzle4554

10 ай бұрын

They're illegal immigrants Not asylum seekers

@av4661

10 ай бұрын

Amen.

The government has failed the homeless as well. It’s not a competition between the worst off people in the uk

Perpetuating trauma. Can you image how this experience is going to affect the thousends of children in this situation, being vilified by nasty people like her. Awful stuff.

Isn't this just admiting the govenments double failure... process asylum seekers & find accomadation for the homless.

Someone needs to sue Carole or complain to OFCOM. She's talking crap.

Will Carol be opening her home for the homeless she is so passionate about?

Look at the profits being generated by some of the companies providing these "hotels" , no one mentions how much is being creamed off

"It's true! And the proof is..........I've written an article saying it's true!" I think I might have spotted a flaw.

Tub thumping racists on daytime TV is the normal thing now. The Tories policies working, blame the immigrants. Blame the junior doctors etc.

@basfinnis

10 ай бұрын

​@@cujimmiShe's a racist and tells lies constantly, NHS, doctors, migrants. That's OK with some people obviously?

It’s starting to get really depressing watching the mass media in the uk. It’s creeping further to the right every week.

@johnmclaughlin7455

10 ай бұрын

The mass media has been there for years,

@oldishandwoke-ish1181

10 ай бұрын

Anticipate private security on the streets and morning broadcasts of the national anthem anytime soon.

@pwhite8107

10 ай бұрын

The reason for people thinking more right wing thoughts is due to the left being so radical and irrational .

@paulroberts7544

10 ай бұрын

That's because the British public have ALWAYS been conservative. The public view hasn't changed. All that's happening is mainstream media and institutions are veering sharply to the left, thus incrdeasing the demand for right wing media. When you say it's creeping FURTHER to the right - what is your definition of 'right wing'? Right wing typically means small state, low taxes. But 'the right' also stands for individual sovereignty, conservative values and national identity. All very British values. A lot of people don't are about politics until it starts veering in a direction they don't like. People AREN'T becoming more right wing. They're speaking out against the swerve to the authoritarian left and towards globalism. Traditionaly, we've been willing to fight and die to defend ourselves against communism AND fascism (essentially botht the same thing).

@Probabilityislife

10 ай бұрын

@@paulroberts7544We are all fu**** At 18 I saw and was followed home by extraterrestrial spacecraft with my Gf. What’s coming is the end of the human race. Not because of extraterrestrials but our behaviour as a whole. War, mass migration, economic collapse it’s all coming on a scale never seen before.

Presumably Malone believes it's also Michelle's fault for being homeless and not taking personal responsibility for her finances.

I expect she does loads to help homeless people NOT

Forced to live with your mum is not the same as 'being homeless for 12 years'. Having said that, she should have affordable housing on offer, and it's not asylum seekers fault that this is not available.

I teach ESOL and many of my students are refugees and/or asylum seekers. The sad truth is that things don't necessarily improve radically once their claim is accepted. The poor accommodation they have previously been living in is often removed with nothing prepared for them to move into. I've known of families whose applications have been accepted then being moved from one place to another at the drop of a hat. British people don't know very much about these people and the disinformation on the television is utterly depressing. Thanks Novara Media for trying to redress the balance.

@annemoncrieff3875

10 ай бұрын

Stop saying british, it is the little english. Leave Scotland and NI out of it. Not sure where Welsh stand as they've been under little english rule for so long I think they act like they little englander now.

@worldaccordingtodunk

10 ай бұрын

Once they have Refugee Status they can live and work anywhere in the UK they want.

@Delred1

10 ай бұрын

Work? WHAT work? WHERE ?

What do these people do for homeless people? Nothing, What do they do to tackle the homeless situation? Nothing, What do they do to stop this government destabilizing over countries causing mass immigration? Nothing. Its not on, Its not on.

Some of the really racist and really nasty things that people are saying now on threads supporting Lee Anderson has absolutely shocked me. As someone born and brought up here in the UK I never realised to the extent how when people join a racist bandwagon all these people seem to lose all human decency. The foul stuff that comes out of their mouths has truly been shocking for me. As a young child growing up in East London in the 80’s I experienced this intense hate then and this brings back those horrible feelings. What is worse is the drawbridge mentality of non white people making comments about immigrants. In my opinion they are worse. Just because they are safe here now they don’t care about other “brown skinned people” disgusting!!

Of course, the Express is famed for speaking out about the plight of the homeless...

Carol Malone is a veteran down puncher.

This government are completely desperate and without morals....this is ALL the Tories doing! Carol Malone is the queen of what they call in the US...a Karen 😭

I saw Jenrick being interviewed on LBC whilst he wore earphones, and it reminded me of Nuremberg.

Does Malone hold the same views about the 88,000 immigrants from Hong Kong,the 10,000 granted visas to work on the landed gentries farms or the foreign students (paying above the odds)at universities. Like Trump,she speaks to the uneducated.

At some point, 5-10 years ago, a group of people sat around a table and agreed a strategy to slow processing of immigrants down to a trickle and then use them as meat for the working class. They know that the more they miss treat people, the more they strip our society, they can just shine a light on the immigrants and nobody will question what’s happening. And the owners of all these crappy hotels which were screwed because of things like Air B&B and Teams/zoom will be more than happy to have a long term contract

The whole ‘get two extreme personalities to argue’ on morning tv has become exhausting.

In other clips they say poverty in Britain is the British poor's own fault. Hence I don't believe in the newly expressed compassion for the British poor. It's just the opportunity to add a xenophobic twist.

We have become hateful. I am ashamed.

@oldishandwoke-ish1181

10 ай бұрын

The mean-spirited have always been among us. This government has enabled them.

@janetmalcolm6191

10 ай бұрын

No Tory rhetoric is hateful. Their ideas are not everyone's....but the media makes out it is.

@peternelson7048

10 ай бұрын

​@@janetmalcolm6191The reason that fascists push the nationalist agenda is because it's easy to convince the average person that foreigners are to blame for the state of the country that the fascists inevitably cause with their corruption.

The Tories made the choice to make the poor even poorer and homeless. The asylum seekers did make the poor poorer, that is down to the nasty party.

So many problems that just cant be fixed, only thing we can do is to give the upper classes a chance to prosper. Hunger, homelessness, healthcare are just to hard to deal with. Says every right winger in the world. The sheer gall of this lady calling refugees "entitled" boggles the mind.

the sooner we allow asylum seekers to work like they do in Germany, Sweden, Australia but to name a few, the better all around for everybody considered.

@Tao_Tology

10 ай бұрын

-asylum seekers- refugees

@djdrogs

10 ай бұрын

What's the difference?@@Tao_Tology

The clear implication is that without boat crossings there would be plenty of help for the homeless, boat crossing are a new thing, a few years ago there were hardly any, a couple of hundred a year. we didn't sort out homelessness then or in the previous years. During Covid we provided the least we could get away with.

There's a hotel up the road from me that houses asylum seekers, it looks really run down, like it's not been renovated for about 25 years. It has 3.7 on google hotel reviews, so certainly not 4 star! And it's out of town way away from any amenities. In any case, this whole barge nonsense is a piece of performance art to satisfy Angry From Clacton that these immigrants aren't having a nice time. (Incidently, the hotel I mentioned says their contract with the Home Office is ongoing until 2024.)

Carol Malone should be prosecuted for lying hate crimes.

Imagine a country under collapse due to misinformation and diversion about desperate people on boats. Not one of them oblivious that trillions are lost, food is going to soon disappear, while they go on and on about people on boats which has no relevance to the economy other than they could help us with there skills. A country like that is destined to collapse. But do not worry if you lose your job you can line up in the Jobcentre where they've made it into a second stage of hell. Welcome.

In the 19th Century, workhouses were designed and operated to discourage all but the most destitute from seeking admission. The food was inferior to prison food. Same attitude!

@normanchristie4524

10 ай бұрын

George Orwell's books on being down and out in Paris and the English workhouse system in the 1930s are still worth reading to understand how these economic systems worked.

When did Carol Malone ever give a f**k about homeless people?!

@07Flash11MRC

10 ай бұрын

When it serves her false narrative to fear-monger about immigrants and distract from the real issues the working class is facing.

Maybe what it tell us is that the Govt only does what it is obliged to by law. They have to help asylum seekers, but they don't have the same legal obligation to the homeless. What we need is law that entitles the homeless to proper support.

The awful spiteful Carole Malone. Calls all people economic migrants. Many, many people are seeking asylum due to fleeing war and persicution. But even if economic migrants not fair to report like this! But should be saying homeless should be helped condemning government over appauling treatment of homeless. But don't see her doing that.

@TristanBanks

10 ай бұрын

Besides using them to virtue signal, they don't care about homeless except to humiliate and punish them.

Yeah, like she gives a F about homeless people.

Sadly hostile views to migrants and those on low incomes and benefits are widespread in Britain. If they were only held by die-hard Conservatives this would be dispiriting but not much of an electoral issue because those voters would always support the Tories; unfortunately many actual or potential Labour voters hold the same attitudes and this is why the Labour vote is at risk from this kind of rhetoric. Clearly right-wing politicians and media fuel these feelings but such attitudes are very deep-rooted and existed long before mass media or a mass electorate. Divide and rule is certainly an approach favoured by those in power but maybe this hostility has deeper roots in people trying to make themselves feel better by scapegoating those lower than them rather than directing their anger at the real architects of their troubles above them.

This pitting class against class Tory line is decades old. It is very interesting how the caller basically outlines clearly how and why she is in her economic predicament while drawing the false conclusion that it's all about migrants.

I used to think she actually had some brains; one of the very very few times I have been totally and absolutely wrong 🤬

@MissyGail4eva

10 ай бұрын

Upon that insightful logic, how can you be so certain? About being wrong only a "very, very few times"? (Allowing for the additional comma, just _one_ more time.) jk 😅

Jeremy Vine's awful program truly is the spiritually home of 'I'm not racist but'

Another excellent episode of Novara Media. Your voice and analysis is sorely needed and deserves wide support, not only moral, but financial too. I suppport NM's journalism financially and I encourage everyone to do the same.

If Carol thinks immigrants are living a 'luxurious' lifestyle at the taxpayer's expense, why doesn't she tear up her passport and get on a dinghy from Bolougne-Sur-Mer?

Yeah! And the Daily Express has always stood up for the homeless, hasn't it? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Are people entitled to FOOD BANKS? Bet the Tories would love to abolish them too. And they caused them.

In terms of staff. The staff are probably stressed, over worked and underpaid. The asylum seekers are frustrated, badly fed and provided for with little hope. Both are in the same cramped conditions. It’s unsurprising bad behaviour happens

@oystercatcher943

10 ай бұрын

There is never an excuse for bad behaviour though and especially the worst behaviour later on in the video

The rotten policies of divide and concur.

@joekeyes2534

10 ай бұрын

That's the Communist mantra isn't it.

Carol Malone doesn't want homeless people to be fed and houses either. What a hypocrite.