Bobby Charlton fantastic player for Utd and England, scored the 2-0 goals against Portugal to put England into the 1966 World Cup final, then another 2 to beat Benfica in the 1968 European Cup Final, to me the best of the very best.

George Best was in my opinion the greatest footballer ever!

@WalesTheTrueBritons

Жыл бұрын

No! Top 10 British player for sure. He isn’t even the Best British player. John Charles and Bobby Charlton are above Best.

@kevingill648

Жыл бұрын

@@WalesTheTrueBritons I said... In my opinion.

ROY KEANE ONE OF THE GREATEST ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS IN THE United team should have been in the top 10

@stevemartin7798

Жыл бұрын

Attacking hardly great all round midfielder but attacking no.

I wish david beckam and roy Keane could have made the list. However, none of the players you have mentioned in this list can be dropped. Thats the predicament when it comes to deciding on the best Man Utd players. There have been too many of them

@Ian-bq7gp

Жыл бұрын

Giggs isnt fit to lace the boots of George Best. He could ghost past players in a packed penalty box. Charlton and Ronaldo were great and Edwards ive never seen but he was by all accounys amazing. Best for Northern Ireland v Russia he was amazing, also v spain and of course in european cup final with the gteat Eusebio in the opposition. I saw him at fulham and he was well past his best and was still showing a touch ive never seen since. It was like the ball was slave to georges wishes. Its the one game i was so happy i went to. That was nearly 50 years ago but the atmosphere and excitement and buzz at craven cottage that day has never been surpassed. RIP George you was a legend not only for football but the girls all knew you performed like a rabbit even after a night out clubbing. My partner was hitch hiking across Iran on her way to Kabul and when the driver said country she said british and the iranian soldier said George Best. He really was the first superstar and the first player to earn £1000 a week but he would fill up stadiums. A great memory maybe im biassed as Ronaldo is a genius but for sheer skill i believe only Georgie had it all but by the early 1970s he was drinking maybe to cope with all the adulation and awful paparazzi.

@dilobillson8675

Жыл бұрын

@@Ian-bq7gpTwo different levels of greatness Best was given a short gift for 5 years, Giggs was given a gift that kept getting better over time worked, choice is not hard to to say who's the greater unless we put it in catorgery.

@Ian-bq7gp

Жыл бұрын

Dilo best as you said was only 5 years at his peak and yes Giggs was over 20 years but it was levels. The ball of leather in bests era weighed a ton especially when the leather became saturated but despite this i cannot agree that any player ive seen before or since had the ball control and genius of Best. Its sad he wasnt in todays era. He would have been like mohammed Ali of football.

@hrishikeshchanekar9846

Жыл бұрын

@@Ian-bq7gp Would you regard George Best's ball control and dribbling skills superior to Messi's and Maradona's?

Duncan Edwards 1. George Best 2. Denis Law 3. Bobby Charlton 4. Then pick six from the rest

@lawmantheonetrueking3739

Жыл бұрын

My Dad saw Duncan and said he was unbelievable. He would have been England’s Captain in ‘62 and most likely Moore would have not got the armband off him. Utd would have given the great Real Madrid team a real run. Real dominated the European Cup from 56-60. Utd were just hitting their stride in ‘58 when tragedy struck. We could have won quite a few ECs before ‘68 but sadly the team was almost destroyed. Sir Matt rebuilt the team and with Denis and George joining Bobby (3 Ballon D’or winners) we rose up again. Then came

@lawmantheonetrueking3739

Жыл бұрын

Then came Sir Alex and we dominated again. Now it’s the time of Erik and we hope the good times will come back again.

@raybrooking8084

15 күн бұрын

Very very true sir.

Sorry, but this list has to contain the name of Duncan Edwards, to omit his name is an insult to all those who tragically lost their lives in the Munich Air Disaster.

In my opinion, Roy Keane should have been on the list. He is probably the best captain for Man United as well as PL. He was the captain on the field that maximised the performances of all players in the team. He was also the one who inspired Man United to beat Juventus in the semi final of the Champion League. While Paul Scholes dictated the play, it was Roy who was the machine of the team. Roy and Paul, together with David and Ryan, formed probably the best ever midfield in Man United and the PL. if I were the one to remove one player on the list to give way to Roy, I would take out C Ronaldo, no disrespect to him. C Ronaldo only reached his peak after he left Man United while the rest of the top 10 plus Roy reached their peak in Man United. Above is just my personal opinion. The extreme difficulty in picking the top 10 greatest players for the team only indicates how great a team Man United were, are and will be…..

good list

The man who made me love this club was David Beckham.

Eric will alway's be Eric to recent supporter's but if you are including time played & goal's, why no Tommy Taylor? He made 166 appearances & scored 112 goals for the club compared to Eric who played 143 times & only scored 64 goals, both over 5 year's. I know the argument's about Eric's contribution to the team's developmemt, but Tommy's goal return & the mobilty he gave the forward line was sensational, especially up against real hard men in the opposition defences & what they were allowed to get away with! Duncan is out on his own! Not being in this list is mind boggling. People don't know this but it became known later via Sir Matt that Real Madrid tried to sign Edward's, Charlton & Taylor!

@davidr1138

Жыл бұрын

Duncan Edwards and Tommy Taylor are really good calls. But so would be Roy Keane. And probably David Beckham and Nemanja Vidic too.

@bakerk2047

Жыл бұрын

@@davidr1138 You have a point of course, but my comment's were to at least open people's eye's to the beginning's of the club's development under Sir Matt & put it out there were some real very special player's who should be on this list.

@dilobillson8675

Жыл бұрын

Respectfully what did Tommy and Duncan win title wise?

@Smiler_Fangirl619

Жыл бұрын

@@davidr1138 I loved Nemanja Vidic. Class player.

@johnhassett4001

Жыл бұрын

If Bobby Charlton said Duncan Edwards was the greatest, then your argument about trophies is meaningless. Duncan was 21 when he died and respected by all

Duncan Edwards? The greatest Manchester United player, ask Bobby Charlton. I was on the tour of Old Trafford many years ago, the guide was a life long supporter and employee of the club. We were sat in the dug out and he enquired if we had any questions? Following the ones about the ground etc I asked in his time with the club considering how many great players had been there who did he consider the best, without pause the reply; "Duncan Edwards"

Man United supporters are born with a gift of class once a United always a United we will never support any other Team we are born winner performance is temporary class is permanent

Great team great player's

Why do these lists always always always forget the Busby Babes? Yes, Sir Bobby was one of them, but he wasn't the only one. Remember Mighty Duncan, Tommy Taylor, Eddie Colman, Roger Byrne, etc. They may have been lost in Munich, but they should never be forgotten.

David degea must be included in the list

I like the list and approve of the final name, Scholes is the name that all the big players/managers said they feared going against. Vidic for me would be in there.

Jaap Stam and Vidic top defender - surely Backam cannot ever be ignored ? !!!

Denis Irwin. Absolute class player.

@shandorunia

Жыл бұрын

Yeh Irwin was world class in a quiet never put a foot wrong kinda way.

@lennykelly9952

Жыл бұрын

Johnny Carey was also a United player my dad said way better than Irwin and he said the brummie Duncan Edwards should be there as well we’re Chelsea fans but be honest when players are good their good.

@geraldwalsh6489

Жыл бұрын

I may be from Ireland,but i definitely feel Busby babe Duncan Edwards should be on that list. Eventho i cannot stand Roy Keane,perhaps he should be there too.By the way,my fave player anywhere of all time is Bobby Charlton,whose autograph i have TWICE!

Andy Cole and Dwight York are also worth mentioning as part of the legends of Manchester united..

Am satisfied with the list

You missed Roy Keane - the heart of Man Utd

@howardchambers9679

Жыл бұрын

Who would you have replaced to fit Keano in?

@espenkaligrebrof9682

Жыл бұрын

@@howardchambers9679 Denis Law. He won two league titles, one FA cup and the European cup. Keane won the league seven times, the FA cup four times and also the European cup. + Denis Law went to City. Would never make my list

@dazediss6629

Жыл бұрын

@@espenkaligrebrof9682 Denis won the Balon D’or

@espenkaligrebrof9682

Жыл бұрын

@@dazediss6629 So did Fabio Cannavaro. He was never the best player in the world

@anthonygeraghty4304

Жыл бұрын

The balon dor was a joke until 1995 I’m not saying that players who won it before then didn’t deserve it but it was only awarded to players from who originated from Europe. Only European players won the award till then any players playing in Europe but from Brazil Argentina etc weren’t considered. Why do you think maradona never won it. To answer your question I’d take smichel out but I’d rate Keane over probably half of them

I agree with all your choices, but I wish you could have included Duncan Edwards. Also, find a way to pronounce these legends' names properly.

I missed Roy Keane

@kwizeragodie7200

Жыл бұрын

Beckham, RudVanNestrooy, and Roy Keane should be on this

No Keane ,most successful captain in United history

My fav is dwight yorke

Muito bom

No feature like this that omits Duncan Edwards is worth considering.

roy keane . david beckham. ole gunner solekar

Ryan Giggs should be on that list, his exploits in midfield, and in front of the net, plus that amazing goal v Arsenal (you know the 1), have earned him a place in MUFC folklore, and you know it! David Beckham, even without the infamous halfway line goal. The Calypso Twins (Andrew Cole and Dwight Yorke): goal machines, both of them! I could be here all night!

Keane should be in with Schmeichel missing out

How do you exclude Duncan Edwards from this list?

@kurtme9685

Жыл бұрын

He so sadly died at 21…he may have become better than all of them but very difficult to put him in there with so few games

@danielhughes3677

Жыл бұрын

You don't really he's a Legend

@dilobillson8675

Жыл бұрын

Wins

@allsportstv7837

Жыл бұрын

​@@kurtme9685 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😊

@allsportstv7837

Жыл бұрын

​@@kurtme9685 😅😅😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😊😅

Where id DUNCAN EDWARDS

@jameshill2806

Жыл бұрын

That is a tricky one m8, he was 18 sadly when he passed., barely started his career. My Dad and Uncle say he was the best they ever saw unfortunately he didn't get his chance :(

@kevinhempstead2359

Жыл бұрын

@@jameshill2806 he was 21 not 18 and played more games for Utd, then king Eric, over the roughly the same length of time, so not that tricky, was simply the best.. would have surpassed everyone, but will have to downgrade down to; one of the greats

@bobsnedden3080

Жыл бұрын

@@kevinhempstead2359 Yes he was a United giant. We will never know how much more that team could have become,and England in Duncan's case

@stevenmutumbu2860

Жыл бұрын

Where is Roy Keane ..alot are missing

@adeyemiilugbuhi6230

Жыл бұрын

He died too young

My favourite player was Jimmy Greenhoff

Best , Law , Charlton , Robson , Keane , Scholes , Edwards , Schmeichel , Ronaldo , Irwin

@johnwoolveridge699

Жыл бұрын

In no particular order barring George Best who is the greatest player ever to play in England

At 1 minute 15 seconds he said we had Can Toe Nar . Lol

I have to agree. Giggs has to be Uniteds most decorated.

Beckham should be there.

George Best is my man

Ryan Giggs definitely worthy of his spot, The all time Greatest assist makers in Top English football, with the second at Manchester United being over 150 behind. Not a very nice person of the field by all accounts, but one can’t argue his quality on the field.

not only do i think bobby Charlton the greatest United player but Englands greatest player, BTW Platini said of Cantona that he's a great player in a small pond, which i agree with especially when you see his performances against great european teams

Whoever produced this video should have found a better narrator, someone who can pronounce players names and clubs correctly.

BEST EDWARDS & CHARLTON are the first 3 names...period

Ryan Giggs Welsh Man

This is a joke, right? I'm a City fan, ffs, and even I can tell you that Duncan Edwards is not only the greatest United player of all time, he's the greatest player full stop. It's Edwards, Best, Charlton, Law and then you can argue about the rest.

Manchester United has been around for too long and is too big, too great and too successful a club to have a greatest players list of only 10 players! Perhaps a number such as 25 might be more appropriate.

I would add Maguire and Phil Jones to the list 🤣

@brendanmulvey8731

Жыл бұрын

Totally agree with you and don't forget Eric Djemba-Djemba. 😉

@leeeastwood6368

Жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣

@bobsnedden3080

Жыл бұрын

you are Joking! Never Maguire or Jones There are better defenders left out that would be in the list.

@leeeastwood6368

Жыл бұрын

@@bobsnedden3080, humour!

@bobsnedden3080

Жыл бұрын

@@leeeastwood6368 Well there are people who believe Maguire is a God , but not me now we have the best Manager at the moment,who is boxing above any expectations with the squad he has. But it's difficult to gauge humour or a child like thinking.😂

ManU is the greatest English Team in the UK.

@WalesTheTrueBritons

Жыл бұрын

? You mean the greatest English team in England! The Uk = England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

What is the FA Super Cup? What is the Man Utd main team? Does it mean the First Team.

The top 10 1 Duncan Edwards 2 Bobby Charlton 3 Denis Law 4 George Best 5 Bryan Robson 6 Ryan Giggs 7 Eric Cantona 8 Paul Scholes 9 Christiano Ronaldo 10 Johnny Carey

@Darko_Boi

Жыл бұрын

i know if it was an all time (like after you left the club too) cr7 would won lol (NOT HATING ON ANYONE HERE!!)

Where do you late Ryan Giggs

Of course you did not include any defenders. WHY?

Great list

Is there any defender?

I can’t exclude anyone listed, but VanDerSar, Vidic, Keano, Becks, Ferdinand, Irwin, Bruce, Ruud, Sparky…. All deserve honorable mention.

Duncan Edwards??

It's pronounced Can to nar not Can toner

It isn’t Benficker, it’s Benfeeker

Can tone A. Don't trust anything with so many errors

Are you aware of the number of People who became Utd Fans, because of Beckham! He won them the Treble. (Best player that Season) Come on!

WOWWWWWW breathless

Duncan Edwards or Roy Keane

Pele, good... Maradona, better.... George...????????

I want to see Greenwood playing again for ManU. I need him badly agsin

Obviously this is just the video makers opinion and he’s wrong on at least three. Roy Keane was the most successful captain united ever had and in my opinion the best captain united ever had. 13 years there 7 premier leagues 4 fa cups champions league continental cup winner and player of the year in 2008 if you are basing your choices on success you are well off the mark. Think you need to look at your choices again

Roy Keane before Robbo all day long

Edwards was the king of them all.

WTF is the FA Super Cup?

@commiebastard3633

Жыл бұрын

Does he mean the Charity Shield ?

Beckham blows

It's sad to see Gigs now. He's not celebrated enough just coz of his stupid life choices

@riposte1960

Жыл бұрын

He would have been knighted if he hadn't fucked up his family life

Schmichel G Neville Ferdinand Vidic Evra Ronaldo charlton Scholes Giggs Best Law Sir Alex Ferguson

A TITLE, is the league, get it right please! 🤬

No Keane weaker team

Ffs learn how to say the name of the greatest united player ever. Eric Cantona not Contona also why is that virus Ronaldo in this?

Roy Keane was better than Brian Robson Paul Scholes Steven Gerrard Frank Lampard but then again he is not English that's why he's not in the top 10 greatest united players Roy Keane was the driving Force behind United the dogs on the street would tell you that Keane never looks for credit he would tell you that's my job so give you the credit he deserves Alex Ferguson himself said it was an honour to have managed such a player that's why I say if he had been English he would have been God

@johnconnolly8334

Жыл бұрын

Gigs is welch'law is a scot'best n irish' Schmeichel is Danish there is no Duncan edwards' Dennis Violet Stan Pearson or William Billy wieland.

@shaka7594

Жыл бұрын

Sorry..keane was great but he was no robson

@michaelharty3539

Жыл бұрын

@@shaka7594 where are you from England

Ryan giggs should be stripped of this title.. he is not a good human being... with his fame & money he could easily have many beautiful women but he opted for his brother's wife & having an affair for so many years.

No Edwards no Keane no sence

Well put together however there should have been eleven one of the games most professional players was left out. A fantastic ambassador no nonsense Denise Irwin

Charlton Best Law Cantona Scholes Edwards Robson Keane Beckham Schmeichel

Keano...Becks... belong on this list

Harry Gregg

KEANO KEANO

The big miss for me is Duncan Edwards.