If it’s Soviet cartoon = propaganda If it’s western cartoon = a masterpiece that upholds the best of human rights under full democracy.

@DanteSimoncini

14 күн бұрын

I agree the Soviet Union was horrible.

@user-zr3qj3qk3u

13 күн бұрын

​@@DanteSimonciniyou lived in Soviet Union?

@DanteSimoncini

13 күн бұрын

@@user-zr3qj3qk3u No but it would still suck for someone like me.

@user-zr3qj3qk3u

13 күн бұрын

@@DanteSimoncini I study history and I know many people born and lived in USSR. They tell me a lot of positive things about it. I am realistic about this: Soviet Union wasn't perfect, but most people were kind of happy

@Sany113r

13 күн бұрын

​@@DanteSimoncinithen someone like you should grow up

You call it "propaganda". I call it "satire".

@CFYZ_GARBAGE

12 күн бұрын

сатира так же может быть пропагандой

@user-rm5dq8nt9g

11 күн бұрын

@@CFYZ_GARBAGE только у современных повесточников.

@CFYZ_GARBAGE

11 күн бұрын

@@user-rm5dq8nt9g угу только

@emanueledionisi9359

11 күн бұрын

The question for the Americans is simple, if it is made by them it is satire, if made by enemies chosen by the government it is propaganda

@EeAstronaut

11 күн бұрын

nah of course some random commie will defend it😂 Adam Dzoblaev in case if u don't know propaganda can be good too, (like health propaganda. Although Health Education would be better, but health propaganda is better than nothing.) but i don't suppose it's the case here though

Where is propaganda ?

@kwitshadie6539

13 күн бұрын

In Soviet logic, the Bull Dog and his owner were hoarding the wealth and the commoners protested in response. 🤔 In the end, this cartoon seems to describe in Uniparty in Congress today.

@Jerrymouse500

13 күн бұрын

Because it show that money > humanity, dog can control you if dog is billionaire

@XOFInfantryman

13 күн бұрын

​@@kwitshadie6539i thought Bulldog was an allegory for the British since that's the animal that's associated with the english

@kwitshadie6539

12 күн бұрын

@@XOFInfantryman Good to know, the British might be a factor considering the Bulldog. The Americans were involved with the space race in the 60’s so it was interesting that the creator made a reference to Soviet v NASA space race. 8:50 . 🤔😁 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sputnik_1

@digimaks

12 күн бұрын

Whenever West doesn't like something that is being said about it - that's being branded "propaganda". So convenient.

Самое ироничное, что Никита Михалков - сын Сергея Михалкова(сценариста этого мультфильма) в итоге стал таким же миллионером.

@iraptar1861

9 күн бұрын

Очень иронично. Михалковы всегда были приспособленцами к любому режиму.

@-still_water-

9 күн бұрын

Самое главное, что Михалков младший создаёт уже антисоветскую пропаганду )

@otherself7400

9 күн бұрын

Интересно

@scroogekvadmcduck2scroogek764

8 күн бұрын

Михалков напротив на Бесагоне выявляет всё это и показывает миру. Помог восстановить Великий Гимн и в отличии от вас помогает обществу. Добра

@SergeyLev-ud9bn

8 күн бұрын

Они жили при разных гос.строях все ж

this ain't propaganda, it just predicted the future.

@Vendigo13

11 күн бұрын

more like - predicted russia's future

@artemon4232

11 күн бұрын

@@Vendigo13 Capitalism rules almost the whole world, not just Russia

@user-cs1ct4xj1j

11 күн бұрын

Дело не в странах дело в людях Общество где цвет штанов не заставляет два раза пресидать обречён к краху

@Kenzi2731

11 күн бұрын

@@artemon4232 Are you stupid or what? Democratic and capitalist countries are diffrent things For example Germany Poland France UK and more is Social Democratic which means Socialism and Democracy Socialism is economical way where goverment gives u money for something like having children or because u were left by ur partner Capitalism means u need to work to have ur money and goverment will not give u anything Capitalist countries is China (communist-capitalist) Russia (authoritarian-capitalist) USA (democratic-socialist-capitalist) and a few more countries Almost all Europe is Social Democratic which means they are anti capitalist

@Kenzi2731

11 күн бұрын

@@Vendigo13 Pretty much no Russian economy goes up since the war because they created their own mcdonalds or their own guns and some of nations are buying it (arabic countries north korea and more) which makes Russia stronger Europe is going to be weak after Ukrainian war since they supported Ukraine with money and guns for like 2 years and still they can't make Ukraine win this war cuz Russia have unlimited lands people and guns After Ukrainian war the countries which will be stronger thanks to this war is: Iran Russia Saudi Arabia China USA (they are sending their old weapon to Ukraine so they are not losing money or weapons while Europe sends Ukraine modern weapons which is very expensive)

The scariest thing about Soviet propaganda is that it turned out to be true.😅

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

10 күн бұрын

Ага, также как Оруэлловский Скотный двор.

@user-qw9et5dw8d

10 күн бұрын

@@user-ly6pl5ot9m , "Скотный двор" - карикатура правильная, но описывает всё очень обобщённо.

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

10 күн бұрын

@@user-qw9et5dw8d А этот мультфильмец разве не карикатура? Впрочем, кажется в 90-х, в Нью-Йорке и в самом деле был такой случай что богатая дама оставила кучу денег своей собаке, лишь бы позлить родственничков. А вот в Конгресс ту псину не избирали.

@KaiserTwo

9 күн бұрын

all hail Jeff Bezos 💀🗿

@emskirchnerdrehstromprojek4270

8 күн бұрын

Talking about Obama, Bezos and Scholz?

If this is propaganda, then I fear what reality is

@sugatabhattacharya8787

10 күн бұрын

😂😂 wait a second isn't Trump the Republican candidate for president in the us.

@user-vw8np7cu3h

9 күн бұрын

@@sugatabhattacharya8787what?

@MdSel1

9 күн бұрын

i can tell you secret: propaganda its not a lie by default. any opinion told by any government called so.

@gnomechild3248

8 күн бұрын

​@@sugatabhattacharya8787rent free

@kwitshadie6539

8 күн бұрын

@@sugatabhattacharya8787 So is Biden whom is just as bad. We seriously need a blank slate of candidates; not just Cold-War era politicians.

Still Better than Modern day Disney Animated Films

@barismancosevdalisi

11 күн бұрын

Disney are terrible. I hate when some americans acting like disney characters.

@carkawalakhatulistiwa

10 күн бұрын

No rainbow warrior .aka captain marvel

@Gustavo-bm3ew

10 күн бұрын

True true.

@Infano_de_la_Nokto

8 күн бұрын

​@barismancosevdalisi Oh, f*ck. Yes, giperactive madman - it's fun, but, there are people who actually take their behavior pattern?! Wow. P.s. English - not my language,

@denisdenisov7623

7 күн бұрын

LOL

Guys the "bulldog" is a metaphor for a greedy nasty person. The meaning of the cartoon is that capital brings you to power even if you are a nasty person. It's NOT about leaving inheritance for your dog...

@ivansnob2360

5 күн бұрын

exactlly

@turplexx233

4 күн бұрын

Just like Churchill, British Bulldog.

@user-sb6us4qg2t

3 күн бұрын

Да? А я сразу Карла Лагерфельда вспомнил, который все свое состояние кошке оставил и других фриков. Ну и естественно, людей успешных успехов, где главное родиться в нужной семье, а капитал и связи тебя до поста презика доведут. Того же буша младшего или британских премьеров последних лет.

@wagnergauer9133

2 күн бұрын

And what brings you capital?

@user-zj4zz4un5z

20 сағат бұрын

@wagnergauer9133 looking at how millionaires in the cartoon bark when the peace is mentioned, they make money on war

This propaganda cartoon is 100% accurate...

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

You just called it a lie by calling it propaganda. Which this is bullshit

@DMlTREl

11 күн бұрын

Propaganda in past and documentary nowadays

@samfkt

9 күн бұрын

​@@DMlTRElyou two, learn the meaning of that word. It doesnt mean false or right, doesnt mean better or worse... .

@capivaraalien1466

5 күн бұрын

​@@samfktdon't think we can blame them. This the meaning in which the term is used.

Yeah, this actually happens on the regular. Heiress Gail Posner left $3 million in trust and her mansion to her 3 dogs, who were driven weekly in a gold Cadillac Escalade to the Pet Spa for the for the rest of their lives. Leona Helmsley left $12 million to her dog. Majel Rodenberry, widow of the creator of Star Trek left $4 million to her dogs. Michael Jackson left $2 million to his chimp, Bubbles. Miles Blackwell left $10 million to his pet hen, Gigoo. Etc.

@bennettbush3906

15 күн бұрын

Pretty stupid if you ask me.

@ironhell813

14 күн бұрын

They loved their animals as humans, but it showed they hated humans and had an unhealthy obsession with their pets.

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

I wouldn’t be surprised there zoophiles

@Lalondeist

13 күн бұрын

@@ironhell813 I don't know, I can kinda see their point. Ever meet a human you didn't like? Ever meet a dog, chicken, or chimpanzee you didn't like?

@bocha73

13 күн бұрын

​@@Lalondeistоднозначно да, встречал

The idiocy of capitalism - even a dog can become president if it has money. A worthy person can't.

@kitkat47chrysalis95

3 күн бұрын

a useless role with no power. the role of P is only to make speeches and announcements and take credit/blame for what the real power is doing.

@mishkaulitkin9476

Күн бұрын

Example: Joe Biden

@powerloomperson

Күн бұрын

@@mishkaulitkin9476example: literally every US president

@tovarich_mayor

Күн бұрын

Why? The worthy person just need get more money. Great people said - "If you homeless just buy a house."

@user-bt8js2cw7y

Күн бұрын

@@tovarich_mayor Your quote is brilliant as "If they have no bread, let them eat cake"

Watching this by myself in a dark room late at night was a surreal experience.

@RandomEmperor

23 күн бұрын

Same here

@justacat2

17 күн бұрын

u described me

@alexkatc59

11 күн бұрын

Did you spy me?

@Rudn4z_127

11 күн бұрын

i'm doing that rn

@pieskobi943

10 күн бұрын

Go watch "Jak Działa Jamniczek" and get a stroke.

Where is my promised propaganda? Only thing i see is reality

@orangecobraEU

11 күн бұрын

If you think it this mean you are a communist, you agree with communists ideas

@JohnG44

11 күн бұрын

Na it's propaganda soviet union collapsed on itself for a reason it had only a few rich while the rest worked.

@FIREH4

10 күн бұрын

​@@orangecobraEU не обязательно быть коммунистом, что-бы согласиться с чем-то, что предлагают коммунисты, у тебя детская логика, это и не удивительно, ты представитель типичного западаного червячка, который узнал новое слово, и теперь не знает куда его можно вставить.

@Wini_Dux

10 күн бұрын

​@@JohnG44 Boris yeltsin coup and destroyed URSS. Fact

@samfkt

9 күн бұрын

Propaganda doesnt mean truth or lie, good or bad...... cmon, learn the meaning of it.

Вполне справедливая карикатура на Америку тех времён, хотя и нельзя отрицать, что мультфильм пропагандистский. Но всё-таки в нём нет той ядовитой ненависти, которая сочится из речей того же Соловьёва, а агитация направлена не против людей или национальности, а против устройства капиталистического общества. Впрочем, ещё не было в истории человечества такого общества, в котором бы не было неравенства, глупости и собачей злобы.

@PartiZZZaNNN_original

13 күн бұрын

Но есть этапы которые позволяют сделать жизнь людей лучше. Как раньше людям казалось незыблемым право на владение другим человеком(рабство). Так и сейчас нам кажется незыблемым право владеть частной собственностью на средства производства.

@Chulya3546

13 күн бұрын

​​@@PartiZZZaNNN_originalпо истмату история человеческого социума движима общественно-экономическими противоречиями. Из самого простого: раб-хозяин, аристократ(феодал)-крестьянин, капиталист-рабочий. И разрешая эти противоречия общество и движется в развитии. Это абсолютно поверхностное объяснение, но по сей теме есть очень много информации в интернете и литературе

@PartiZZZaNNN_original

13 күн бұрын

@@Chulya3546 я с этим всем знаком, но людям надо проще. Не будут все интересоваться столь детально к сожалению, им и образы нужно подавать.

@Sniper_XPEHOB

12 күн бұрын

"Собачья злоба" - хорошо сказано, согласен 👍

@user-wm5yd4ip4p

12 күн бұрын

а первобытно-общинное?

Oh my god this rules, but how is it propaganda? This is like a stock cartoon plot in the west nowadays. Googling the premise I found two western films in the past ten years, Gunther's Millions and Millionaire Dog, along with a list of the top 10 biggest inheritances left to pets. It's interesting that this is the earliest iteration of that plot I know, though.

@KyleShiflet13666

8 ай бұрын

Because it was made by the soviets

@cheems4572

7 ай бұрын

yeah it isnt fully propaganda but it is a bit, I would assume its meant to display millionares as greedy and how money changes people?

@aminakhan703

7 ай бұрын

@@cheems4572 Propaganda isn't just anything that has a portrayal or makes a statement. That's all art.

@cheems4572

7 ай бұрын

@@aminakhan703 well yeah but being biased and trying to support a certain political party does Which I would say there’s small elements of that here, you just have to look a bit closer, the way they portray the millionaires, even if I agree that it can turn them into bad people Idk I’m not saying I disagree with you I don’t know where you got that, but I do believe it still has some elements in it that are propaganda like

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

Communism is all full of greed which is the funny thing.

7:53 casually nazi salutes*

@muthafuckawhatchusay

7 ай бұрын

He's among friends

@Nomadicti0n

24 күн бұрын

It's really accurate for nowdays

@user-jz8ze1jm6v

18 күн бұрын

But fascism often happened only where there was a threat of a socialist revolution (nationalization of the wealth of the oligarchs): Spain, Germany, Italy, Chile, Greece.

@artikult3591

17 күн бұрын

​@@user-jz8ze1jm6vFascism is the response of the propertied class to unrest among the lower class. For example, the Italian Blackshirts and German Nazis formed a rich class of industrialists from former Freikorps. In Italy, too, it was the industrialists who believed that isolationism and aggression towards their neighbors would lead to their enrichment, and they liked the views of Benito Mussolini. So the industrialists paid for the “March on Rome” and Mussolini’s rise to power. The same thing with Germany. Enterprises like Krupp, Henschel and others saw war as a way to get rich and make wealth for themselves, and Hitler was their protege

@user-el4fi3wq4q

16 күн бұрын

​@@user-jz8ze1jm6vAfter the Second World War, the fascists fled to a place where people didn't care who he really was, just to stay alive, those who covered for them did not care about the murders and genocide of civilians, they just wanted to marvel at someone else's grief and learn other people's secrets.

1963 => Propaganda 2004 => Reality

Propaganda are "Rambo" and "Rocky".

@201hastings

3 күн бұрын

Propaganda isn’t necessarily a good or bad thing you dunce. It’s propaganda in a historical sense. That’s like elementary school knowledge

@blanknickname

11 сағат бұрын

​@@201hastingsдурак твой папаша, пропаганда в Рокки и рэбмо это тупое очернение СССР Никаких знаний в этой пропаганде не содержится

Thank you for this Elon musk documentary

@Caero_

6 күн бұрын

I also interpreted it as Donald Trump.

@nekad2000

5 күн бұрын

Id say Bill Gates or Steve Jobs, but it could be any billionaire. Of course you know someone will take the low IQ route and say Trump.

Although this is propaganda, they aren't lying. The soviets did a brilliant job on this cartoon. They showcased something that actually happens and they made it like an old silly symphony.

@samfkt

9 күн бұрын

Propaganda never meant lying but also not telling truth...... has nothing to do with good or bad. The USA had propaganda about Japan in WW2, communism and cold war etc....

@CrossDix

9 күн бұрын

Propaganda is usually made to misslead someone on to a biased political opinion, there is nothing wrong with his statement. Propaganda is rarely any good because it never tells the whole truth.​@@samfkt

@T.Shurik

7 күн бұрын

Ну сценарий в виде стиха и правда неплохой сделали, но рисовка…лучше конечно в диснее.

@phantomcorsair8476

6 күн бұрын

@@T.Shurik Согласен, самое приятное то, что это правда. люди на самом деле дарят удачу своим питомцам. Не могу сказать, что виню их, но это глупо.

The author of the poem and the script, Sergei Mikhalkov, was an amazing person. he was able to write wonderful memorable poems for children (this is of course aimed at adults) and the anthems of the USSR and Russia

@vovahimself

9 күн бұрын

He was an amazing poet for sure. As for a person his legacy is kind of controversial.

@obi-wankenobi2644

8 күн бұрын

Мой друг пишу на русском надеюсь, что алгоритмы гугла тебе это переведут. Иронечное замечание, сын Сергея Михалкова стал в СССР и России ищвестным режиссером, несет по телевизору пооную ложь и оправдывает войнау в Украине

@mayakstudios7292

8 күн бұрын

@@obi-wankenobi2644 полную ложь несут шульман, гордон, Невзоров, фейгин и прочая шваль Ничего ироничного

@Mangoria360

8 күн бұрын

@@vovahimself nothing is controversial about Mikhalkov.

Where is the propaganda here? People like Dobbiecast History see propaganda everywhere. People like him will never say that American propaganda is propaganda. For people like him it’s true

@dobbiecasthistory1642

12 күн бұрын

Every government creates propaganda. My students are aware and they watch some in class.

@rje_ki4

12 күн бұрын

😅😅😅😅😅😊⁹

@Myko033

12 күн бұрын

Man everything Is politic It depend Who do It xd

@-KurbZik

11 күн бұрын

​@@dobbiecasthistory1642 . . . Dude. Y'know, in In the USSR, everything was "From the Authorities." I mean. Every project, every cartoon, movie, even Games, were considered to be made according to a State project. THAT IS, EVERYTHING. Even if in reality it is essentially a project of one person, a self-initiative, then it was probably out of habit that it was also considered to be a Government order. Your logic is weird, you know? Have you even tried to delve into this data? And then they wonder why it is that Americans are so disliked in Our works. Well, well.

@Treasure_hunter_21

10 күн бұрын

​@@-KurbZikas if there were no crackdowns on any decent be it socialists or students that didn't want to be sent to Vietnam

Нет, это реальность, которую они еще тогда угадали.

@theapplewaifu5395

13 күн бұрын

Ya ya fascista, ya

@Chulya3546

13 күн бұрын

Пропаганда - это распространение какой-либо идеи. Она может быть как жирной до отвращения, так и тонкой, что мы её даже не заметим. Тут мы видим нечто, близкое ко второму случаю. В любом случае мультфильм - класс

@user-vu6hn4ul2i

11 күн бұрын

Ага, мне особенно понравилось "рычать при слове "мир". Вот сейчас с лозунгов первомая странным образом пропало именно слово "мир". Или это - другое? 😂

@needforvkid

11 күн бұрын

@@user-vu6hn4ul2i не выйдет говорить "мир", когда идёт война

@user-vu6hn4ul2i

11 күн бұрын

@@needforvkid стоп. Сначала ты говоришь, что "рычать при слове мир - буквально собачья злоба" - это правда. Потом говоришь, что запрет слова "мир" - это другое, мол не надо путать, это не из-за собак у власти. Я правильно понял? 🤣

I gotta admid, the animation looks pretty good. 107 likes? I didn’t knew that was possible with me 97 more in just 4 days how possible?

@Sniper_XPEHOB

12 күн бұрын

Yeah. Propaganda or not, Animation is what the soviets exceeded at

@digimaks

12 күн бұрын

Why wouldn't it be a good animation? Soviet Union was literally a KINGDOM of various animation styles and huge number of cartoons! Some are for todlers, kids, youth, teens with deep meaning.And also adult cartoons (some are psychodelic and some downright disturbing).

@gludeusmaximus

8 күн бұрын

how about 200 haha

старуха миллионерша четко нарисована если посмотреть америеканские сериалы тех лет про жизнь богатеньких семей то в каждом есть такая старуха которая всем рулит

This is not propaganda, this is the truth

@reinhardt3090

7 күн бұрын

The words not mutually exclusive.

@user-bt8js2cw7y

7 күн бұрын

@@reinhardt3090 In the modern world, the word propaganda has a negative connotation

@reinhardt3090

7 күн бұрын

@@user-bt8js2cw7y Okay? The definition of the word is still the same.

@timothyblake3574

6 күн бұрын

The negative connotation of this word comes not from presenting a lie with the truth, but from double standards and diverting attention from the problems within. For example, in the USSR, until 1974, collective farm workers did not have passports or citizens could not travel abroad, as well as move to live in another city solely at their own request. Did at least one Soviet cartoon from the 1960s talk about this? No. They only distracted attention to the shortcomings of the United States, often exaggerating or highlighting only the truth that was beneficial to themselves. This is propaganda

@user-bt8js2cw7y

6 күн бұрын

@@timothyblake3574 This is a liberal lie about agricultural workers - in fact, they can move anywhere - for example, to the city, but there they must get a passport

After 8 years youtube be like: "time to put it in recomendation"

@dobbiecasthistory1642

8 күн бұрын

Wild how that happens. I throw this on my channel for my students years ago and in the last month half of Russia is getting it in their feed.

The Soviets must’ve had a Time Machine and based this cartoon on real life Karl Lagerfeld 😂

@gum0193

5 күн бұрын

в истории Англии Франции Испании Речт посполитой и даже в Российской империи были такие старухи) Михалков это написал потому что в социалистической России замыкание на деньгах высмеивалось в обществе. специфика в СССР была такая даже если у тебя были деньги ты не всегда и далеко не все мог себе позволить. например автомобиль или квартиру выдавало государство за выслугу лет. это как плюс так и минус - с одной стороны если ты усердно работал то ты мог к 30-33 годам иметь свою собственную квартиру абсолютно бесплатно. с другой стороны если ты умел зарабатывать деньги их наличие не гарантировало тебе возможность купить квартиру или автомобиль)

"propaganda"

@iskanderaga-ali3353

11 күн бұрын

Propaganda doesn't mean wrong you know

@samfkt

9 күн бұрын

Propaganda doesnt mean false or right, doesnt mean good or bad..... doest mean better or worse.

@Kamelskih

9 күн бұрын

Propaganda

@reinhardt3090

7 күн бұрын

Lots of extremely ignorant communists in these comments. You don't even know what propaganda means.

@Skooffy

7 күн бұрын

@@reinhardt3090 Don't cry, kid. I know what propaganda is, and I know that this term has neutral meaning. But in the minds of majority of people it considered as something bad. The point is simple: this is funny how almost any film/documentary/animation from USSR is considered as propaganda by westeners.

Communists may imagine this is how rich Americans behave, but really, poor and middle class Americans act the same way.

@imzjustplayin

2 ай бұрын

Is that because they shop on Temu?

@HERES_JAWNiE

Ай бұрын

People believe they are temporarily embarrassed millionaires. That plus the fact that we live in a service based economy where people think their Applebee's waiter is their own personal servant. I'd argue this is due to capitalist propaganda and extreme individualism

@briankleinschmidt3664

Ай бұрын

@@imzjustplayin No. we act like the people we are taught to admire. What is Temu?

@colonelcorn9500

16 күн бұрын

@@briankleinschmidt3664The peak of modern capitalism, where you can buy knock-off luxury goods made by Chinese kids while installing free bonus CCP spyware with every purchase!

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

16 күн бұрын

Hey Brian. Guy from what's left of Russia's here. Irony is, Ron Reagan with his Soviet jokes was right. Average working man in USSR, especially in 1930's lived worse than US unemployed during the Depression. And US middle class... oh, boyo, not that many high-tier CPSU members lived a life of middle class American WASP. A car, a home, regular BBQ's, avaliability to travel across the country and world, access to healthcare, education and amenities? That's rich. Them yanks don't value what they have, are they. P.S. Many of westerners, yanks and eurochaps, during the Depression went to USSR to build the "new bright tomorrow", sometimes out of socialist inspiration or due to offered work there. Some of them even took the Soviet citizenship. That didn't end well by greatest margin, with all these purges, tortures and mock trials in Stalin's USSR... the rest went back to their countries and told the tale how they lived there. I've read a story about the Western engineer complained about poor dinner he was served one day. Some lean meat, somewhat stale bread and tea. That's it? The translator girl cried. They've offered him *the best.*

WOW and now it become reality. Well done USA well done western country.

@WorldWorldCommunismAnimations

13 күн бұрын

Very true "In God we trust" More like "In Corruption we trust"

@dextercochran4916

10 күн бұрын

Yes, yes, comrades! You will hate Western capitalism! Or else!

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

10 күн бұрын

Just as Orwell's animal farm.

@thanhphongpham7482

10 күн бұрын

@@user-ly6pl5ot9m That how you see that Soviet is beyond any country in the world. Not like USA and the western country most of them are animal farm on may level.

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

10 күн бұрын

@@thanhphongpham7482 Not buying that any "oriental" or towelhead country are somewhat better than yankeeland or them melancholic EU fellas.

This the base

If we consider the term propaganda as the dissemination of information, then I do not see a problem, especially since it is true.

“Money will corrupt you… so we’ll make sure you never get any”

@mirziyodm

Күн бұрын

Not "any", but in form of profit from other peoples (hired workers) exploitation. Do you know that there were official non-capitalist millionaires in USSR?

This is the Ultra-Based True Propaganda!

@zaporizhacountryballanimator

10 күн бұрын

Typical communist kid:

@thischannel4326

7 күн бұрын

profile pic checks out

A million dollars isnt even that much money anymore

@classicalhollywood3254

2 ай бұрын

Stop acting like you’re rich.

@harrypjotr4987

Ай бұрын

exactly, not anymore. it was a lot more valuable back then so this means nothing.

@filosov

18 күн бұрын

It was in 1963

@user-fd9zu6yw8v

15 күн бұрын

Back when there was the gold standard...

14 күн бұрын

Back then most basic products cost cents. Now everything costs one dollar or higher; an example of how money has lost valor in a short amount of time.

Не сказал бы что это пропаганда. Первая сцена с получением наследства показывает, как капитал может поднять человека в статусе, при этом без наследства собака не получила смогла бы подняться, что отделяет всех других по признаку родословной, что правда в устоявшимся капитализме, где в основном уже люди с наследством новые олигархи. Сцена с повседневностью, а именно с полицейским показывает как влияет статус на исполнение полномочий. Он должен был арестовать его за предварение в общественном месте в ненадлежащем виде, но не сделал этого, ведь он богат. И к тому же показал, что он готов терпеть всё перед ним, даже его мочеиспусканием на него. Собака перестаёт узнавать других собак, что показыыает его отношение к простому Люду, он становится всё более безразличен к простакам. Когда он идёт в конгресс, показывается реальная ситуация, когда конгресс заполнен олигархами, меньшинством, решающий что делать с большинством, что противоречит идее демократии, власти большинства. Сейчас в Америке похожая ситуация, властью управляют меньшинста ЛГБТ, радикального феминизма и буржуи, решающие жизнь большинства - пролетариата.

@69dm

9 күн бұрын

какая Америка, мужик. Проснись. Советского Союза 30 лет уже нет

@kubikortLuma

9 күн бұрын

@@69dm всё новое - давно позабытое старое, проблемы, которые были во времена СССР, таки не решились, так причём тут то, что он развалился 30 лет назад?

@FerBes-sy9oc

8 күн бұрын

Все эти ЛГБТ активисты, феминистки, и прочие леваки спосируются из соц стран типа Китая. Например в случае БЛМ это уже доказано в суде. Так что проблема США в том, что они не понимают что такое коммунизм, и что коммунистов нужно уничтожить, пока коммунисты не уничтожили "капитализ, империализм и колониализм"

@TadpoleHappy

7 күн бұрын

Всегда мееьшинство правило

@FerBes-sy9oc

7 күн бұрын

Проблема в том что западных ЛГБТ, БЛМ, и иже с ними спонсирует Китай и прочие коммунисты

i got a 1984 audiobook ad on this

This cartoon shows America today precisely... How did they know?

Хороший мульт не вижу здесь пропаганды

@Chulya3546

13 күн бұрын

Ну она тут определённо есть, т.к. смысл мультфильма в том, чтобы донести до зрителя порочность кап. системы, но этот факт не делает его менее качественным

@Cosmic_Soldierboy38

13 күн бұрын

@@Chulya3546 тоже верно

@adekvatFCSM

8 күн бұрын

А капиталистическая система не порочна? Мне кажется это вы жертва пропаганды. У вас на глазах два капиталистических движения (неолиберализм и глобализм) ведут мир к пропасти, но вам "всё божья роса". Думаю что даже когда полетят ядерные ракеты вы всё так же будете утверждать будто так и надо. Капитализм поросенка и это факт.

"Propaganda was conceptualized as a form of influence designed to build social consensus." I do not see an attempt to influence/manipulate my opinion, but a validation of my experiences.

@nostradam96

6 күн бұрын

You have nothing to do with it. This is a cartoon for an internal audience. For a Soviet man, the story of the millionaire bulldog was ridiculous and funny.

@201hastings

3 күн бұрын

Don’t let all the loads your mom swallowed while pregnant with you make you mentally handicapped. It’s propaganda by definition and I know that makes you salty.

What a good movie, and nothing bad happens to him in the end! He is living his best life!

"...у них он научился рычать при слове мир"

Я хочу продолжение, хочу, чтобы про этого бульдога сделали мультипликационный сериал.

@user-wg5qx8jg5e

15 күн бұрын

Если доберусь до поста сценариста и смогу осуществить свои амбиции то сделаю, если меня не опередят:)

@STONE30man

13 күн бұрын

Хм некоторая проблема может быть в том что всех кто создавал этот мультфильм уже нет в живых

@user-rs4vx7kx2b

12 күн бұрын

Сценарист умер.

@user-jm3xl7rg5k

7 күн бұрын

Только не на Netflix -- а то бульдог будет нетрадиционной ориентации)))

This is awesome

Мы думали, что нам в СССР показывали пропаганду, а это оказалось чистой правдой...

So that's how Biden became a president... Huh, that explains everything. He barks so well, tho, sometimes I even can hear human words in it. Well, at least in this year. It kinda becomes rarer with time.

@FriarJoe66

8 күн бұрын

To claim that this is a representation of Biden when Trump’s life is objectively more similar to the plot of this short is such powerful cope lmao.

@tbqhwyf

7 күн бұрын

​@@FriarJoe66that's a false dichotomy. They can both be similar to the plot of the cartoon

@FriarJoe66

7 күн бұрын

@@tbqhwyf both be similar to this plot than the average American? Sure. But Trump fits the bill exponentially more than Biden does, it is disingenuous to claim otherwise.

@molot_hohlov

6 күн бұрын

> -Biden- > -Trump- *Douche and Turd* _fixed_

@hawk992

3 күн бұрын

It's the Trump story. Fits so well.

Since I'ma socialist, figure'd id see what propaganda to look out for

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

You just called your own bullshit a lie. You’re not a socialist till you start joining the groups.

@mooseears9849

10 күн бұрын

I applaud your commitment to human rights, but would not consider this propaganda. The elite are literally letting their pets inherit obscene amounts of money

@Hegemol900

6 күн бұрын

Since your an idiot who, after countless "failed" attempts, still somehow believes in a system that always dies, and always makes the lifes of its citicens worse, while complaining about the system that has not only survived, but spread and brought prosperity to the western world, you are obviously manipulated by the people who present a fake and not at all acurate picture of capitalism. I would really like to see you spend a day starving in your broken apartment, dressed in rags, the TV showing you stuff you can never afford, while parnoidly looking around the room for any cameras installes by the oh-so-great socialist leaders people, whom you are not allowed to critiscize, unless you want to be "reeduacted".

Надо ещё Золотую Антилопу на английский перевести.

@user-bb6pr1ui4p

6 күн бұрын

и сказку о рыбаке и рыбке

@ivansnob2360

5 күн бұрын

очень кстати когда 2024 объявили годом сноса доллара 😅

Guys! Propaganda literally means anything that influences someone's opinion on an ideology (in a good way) so chill!

@dobbiecasthistory1642

9 күн бұрын

Yeah. Donald Duck was propaganda in the States.

@Hegemol900

6 күн бұрын

We all know what people mean when they say "Propaganda". I dont care if their a secret original definition somewhere in a textbook you can pull out when its convinient. Propaganda is a biased and misleading way to manipulate people into beliving what you want them to belive. Thats what it means now, end of discussion.

@kitkat47chrysalis95

3 күн бұрын

@@dobbiecasthistory1642 everything is propaganda, we are surrounded by propaganda everywhere.

When you have inherit wealth you will have nothing to feel for the most average person

Simply put, in a capitalist society the poor learn and are propagandized to deify the rich man as a King. They learn that they are less than him and aspire to be him even though they can’t. His wealth is told to be founded by merit, but is actually founded on manipulation, luck, trickery and exploitation.

@Crimsonlee2XX

8 ай бұрын

I wouldn’t say that’s the case for every rich person. Example J.K Rowling the creator of Harry Potter books had an idea and made it big on that idea and capitalized on it, enriched by it. Whether you want to believe it or not billionaires like Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Bill Gates found an idea and capitalized on it, made whatever investments they needed to get where they are today. It’s very easy to have your idea that doesn’t gain much notoriety or not have the right networks or capital and be jealous of those who are more successful.

@smh9902

8 ай бұрын

You're either going to work for a capitalist or a dictator that owns everything and everyone as a slave. Choose.

@kimbanton4398

7 ай бұрын

​@@smh9902 That's literally what happens right now under capitalism with child labor in 3rd world nations where you work for less than 1 dollar an hour to produce commodities for our every day companies that we all love, like Amazon, Starbucks etc... And no, there's actually a 3rd option, which is: you're gonna have democracy in your workplace and own the company as part of a collective, as in worker co-ops, which is NOT working under somebody...

@smh9902

7 ай бұрын

@@kimbanton4398 But you can do that right now. Many companies are co-ops. No government intervention is required to do this. Capitalism allows co-ops to exist within it. Communism does not.

@brians7181

6 ай бұрын

you're too stupid and/or lazy to succeed in a capitalist society.

Propaganda??? This ain't propaganda, it's literally happen in real life lol XD *Sigh I miss Soviet Union

@zaporizhacountryballanimator

10 күн бұрын

Typical young soviet schoolboy fan

@FM-tn5pk

10 күн бұрын

​@@zaporizhacountryballanimatorYeah

@Wini_Dux

10 күн бұрын

Everybody miss 😢😢😢😢

@aokusazimniy8

9 күн бұрын

@@zaporizhacountryballanimator Who are u calling schoolboy?

8 anos depois* KZread: hmmm, ele claramente quer uma recomendação de propaganda comunista soviética..

Watched this 8 years ago, gets more accurate ig

Это что-то вроде аналогии на Черчилля?

@philipppaasch8929

16 күн бұрын

Я думаю да

@Bebrou66

15 күн бұрын

С чего бы?Скорее это аналогия на аристократию и "высшие классы".Черчилль был изначально богат, он не от наследства разбогател.

@---cock4449

13 күн бұрын

Причём тут Черчилль? Ему на голову не свалилось наследство от бабки. Черчилль был военным и всю жизнь посвятил войнам, а в мультфильме пёс гулял на широкую лапу, ни в чём себе не отказывая.

@blader_665b6

12 күн бұрын

​@@Bebrou66так разбогател или был богат?

@Bebrou66

11 күн бұрын

@@blader_665b6 согласен, формулировка странная, но он был из семьи аристократов, соответственно был богат с рождения

Я не смотрел его в детстве Но он очень ностальгичен

Везде пропаганда, есть пропаганда коммунизма и капитализма, я выбираю коммунизм!

@user-rm5dq8nt9g

11 күн бұрын

Так социализм - это тоже капитализм, в котором власть единственные капиталисты, которым принадлежит всё и все.

@crunchyandmagnificent5646

11 күн бұрын

@@user-rm5dq8nt9g Государственная монополия. Ты это услышал в видео и теперь повторяешь как попугай? Где тогда рыночек при социализме, где конкуренция за этот самый рынок? Где постоянное движение к повышению маржи профита? Где экспоненциально растущее неравенство между классами? Если уж на то пошло, где классовое расслоение общества?

@user-rm5dq8nt9g

10 күн бұрын

@@crunchyandmagnificent5646лол, могут ли рабы конкурировать с господином, будучи его собственностью? Само собой нет. За что боролись, как говорится.

@crunchyandmagnificent5646

10 күн бұрын

@@user-rm5dq8nt9g это тут при чем вообще? И где рабство? Оно с нами в одной комнате? А господин тоже?

@user-rm5dq8nt9g

10 күн бұрын

@@crunchyandmagnificent5646 ну, если вы там живёте при социализме, то да - в одной. А господин - это не ты.

Dog is the metaphor btw. It's still about the person

Ну в целом это пропаганда, но тут ничего расходящегося с реальностью не показали, аналогии что показаны в мультфильме действительно могут произойти, проблема в том, что дети которые посмотрят это, подумают что все богатые люди такие, в чем и заключается цель мультфильма. Так что это всё равно плохо. Тем не менее не стоит забывать что пропаганда велась и со стороны США и со стороны СССР

@grlg9991

17 күн бұрын

А с чего ты взял, что этот мультфильм для детей?

@user-lz1yw4fl2e

17 күн бұрын

Т.н. "богатые" разные бывают. Есть богатые экономически, а есть богатые финансово. Капитал это несомненно ко второму. Денежная масса не с неба берётся. В России это ещё и повязано с криминалом, тотальной коррупцией, захватом государственного банка-эмитента в 1991 году, так что не вижу ничего плохого в осуждении и тем более наказании преступников.

@user-td6rh6rj7r

16 күн бұрын

Вы, милый друг, это супругам Гейтсам расскажите, или Ротшильдам, пусть они за вас порадуются - это же надо такое незамутнённое сознание иметь.

@flurn3176

14 күн бұрын

Есть богатый плохой, а есть хороший! Этот богатый недоплачивает, а этот переплачивает! Этот задерживает зарплату, а другой 13 выплачивает! Этот не дает и спуску рабочим, а другой месяцами выходные раздает! Этот забивает на права рабочих, а другой их раздает! Это ведь так работает, верно? Трудись трудись и станешь ты богатым, будь как "хороший" капиталист! Только на деле средства у обоих одинаковые, просто один в медийной сфере преуспел (привет трампу, гейстсу, маску, джобсу), а другие как и по экономическим, так и политическим поражениям нет (ну тут ты и сам назвал всех наших капиталюг в злых). Смешно и тошно от вашего идеализма. Ни маск, ни гейтс будто бы не заставляли перерабатывать, будто бы не ущемляли в правах, недоплачивали рабочим, не играли с ними, будто с фишками. Нет, все проще: есть плохие, а есть хорошие.

@user-yr3rc8ef5h

13 күн бұрын

@@flurn3176 Хороших богатых людей нет в природе. Даже кому с неба падает случайно, быстро становятся скотами.

Looks like movie Knifes out; they were making that movie on using this soviet old cartoon. P.S. Everything in this "propaganda" is true.

@duart33

12 күн бұрын

propaganda doesn't necessarily mean it's not true, just that it is produced by a regime

It roasted both USSR and USA at the same time. Genius!

Video released in 2015 and Comments are soo fresh

Долой псов капитала!

@user-ly6pl5ot9m

16 күн бұрын

Ага, только избавимся от коммунистических свиней.

Did some youtuber make a video on this? Why are the comments suddenly flooded on this old ass vid

@dobbiecasthistory1642

8 күн бұрын

wondering the same thing. lol

@nitothefunkybunch6938

8 күн бұрын

@@dobbiecasthistory1642 all saying the same thing too

Зачем стабилизация изображения?! Этож мультик, здесь нету тряски))

@molot_hohlov

6 күн бұрын

причина тряски?

what year was this made? would be interesting to know

It’s ironic, this piece of propaganda actually makes capitalism look good not bad.

@OnCydig

11 ай бұрын

It did nothing of the sort for Soviet citizens at that time. Showing off the worst aspects of Western society: greed, materialism, hedonism, debauchery and government corruption. There's also a little nudge in there comparing Westerners to mindless dogs.

@shady8045

10 ай бұрын

how lol?

@jacobmoss6830

10 ай бұрын

@@shady8045 I mean the dog goes from being a dog to having lavish parties, political power and high board positions and he does this through inherited wealth. It's utterly hilarious.

@STBill

10 ай бұрын

@@jacobmoss6830 It's not funny for the people that such an unworthy "dog" is having this life.

@johnnyconsumer

10 ай бұрын

@@jacobmoss6830That’s….. not good. Your sense of what is “good” has been utterly warped by a capitalist system.

Where is the Propaganda and Lie?

7:58 lmao that heil was personal😅😅😅 sooo good

«Рычать при слове мир» - все поняли

Советы врали про коммунизм, но говорили чистую правду про капитализм.

@TadpoleHappy

7 күн бұрын

В итоге сами стали капиталюгами

7:53 There's a fricking n#tzi this this short 😅

@juanmccoy3066

4 ай бұрын

I think the idea for the propagandists to convey was that the capitalists cohort with the likes of nazis.

@Sanchongarr

16 күн бұрын

I think, that cartoon wad made at 30s, when this action wasn't related 2 monstric war crimes yet. At that time they thinked. that Hitler is just a joker.

@soficat7897

14 күн бұрын

​@@Sanchongarrнет, этот мультфильм был создан в 1963 году. На заставке был прописан год. Надеюсь, я правильно рассмотрела надпись. Цифры немного сливались некоторые) Возможно, они хотели такой пропагандой и США показать в плохом свете, и Нацистскую Германию - вот, смотрите, именно капитал их и довел до гибели. А еще он черный (P.S. я не знаю как в те года было с расизмом в СССР, но тут его поставили с нацизмом (поднятая рука) и капитализмом (когда была Холодная война между США и СССР))

@ilyasharin1976

13 күн бұрын

@@soficat7897 What, that's most likely the African dictators that were supported by the US. This has nothing to do with racism.

@Buto.7103

11 күн бұрын

"arent you convinced yet? See this nazi, nazis bad therefore gommunism good"

does anyone know what the song playing from approx. 5:21 - 6:42 is? shazam and other such apps have retuned no results.

@N_0ocha

9 күн бұрын

Это мелодия Михаила Александровича Мееровича. Скорее всего она была написана специально для мультфильма. Возможно, где-то в интернете она есть, но idk где именно

@610ball

9 күн бұрын

@@N_0ocha thank you for the composer's name! I'll try to find the song if it's online.

...this isnt propaganda? with this persons logic "Animal Farm" should also be propaganda, despite it being american...

6:28 quadrobicer 1963))

ну а что здесь не так?

The proletariat could never hope to be as loyal or righteous as a dog. Pearls are wasted before swine.

Taylor Swift with her cats. 😂

A poor person 's house costs now > ! 1 M . ? What a joke ! At the begining of that poor person's life it was $ 6,000 ?

@WIG34

10 ай бұрын

bro what?

@peanutsbuttissilent

2 ай бұрын

What you yapping about and also work on your english

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

You can buy a new home for around 300,000 where i live but didn’t forget about inflation and now money goes by Oil not gold anymore since 1971.

Accurate

Пропаганда - не пропаганда, в мультике всё правильно показано. Только это для любой страны свойственно, особенно для современной России.

4:45 уинстон черчилль?

Soviet people were lucky to receive an education in a country that clearly understood the threat of capital. Capitalism is the exploitation of labor, don't starve. Ultra-modern sl ave ry.

@ilyasharin1976

13 күн бұрын

GRISHAAAAA

@user-ty4ee9fi6c

9 күн бұрын

? Гриша¿‽

Looks like animated documentary.

In a world where the aristocats are the villains and Edgar is a poor exploited proletarian.

@ironhell813

14 күн бұрын

To be honest the aristocats was based on the great gatsby which is a great example of capitalism gone bad in and of itself. Ussr should have made a cartoon about how capitalism makes people stupid because it doesn’t value education just predatory paganism.

So they ripped off the Aristocats?

@user-kb2no8yg1o

13 күн бұрын

Soviets always was against aristocrats, not simple people. It was propaganda.

@digimaks

12 күн бұрын

Nothing to do with Aristocats. And looks like you have not understood the cartoon at all, or didnt watch the whole thing. It's about rich getting used to their inherited wealth that they did not get by hard work, adn start to abuse their powers, spilling it into global scale! The meaning of this cartoon is much deeper then you think.

why did the subtitle's like that

Vous voulez connaître le pire 😱 ?! Le fils du dessinateur de ce cartoon (Nikita Mikhalkov) est devenu ce millionaire que son père dénonçait sous le communisme. Il suffit de choisir son patron (Poutine) et il vous récompensera bien

Holy stromboli! Capitalism looks friggin awesome. I wonder if there's a form of capitalism where the people don't act like epileptic rag dolls...

@ironhell813

14 күн бұрын

The movie makes it look rediculous, like life is a game, it would have made an agrarian society like the ussr furious.

@classicalhollywood3254

14 күн бұрын

I agree

@ilyasharin1976

13 күн бұрын

You mad that this showed the very heart of Western society? Or must I remind you the constant drama that is involved with Hollywood and rich people?

@Lalondeist

13 күн бұрын

@@ilyasharin1976 ...after 9 months, another crybaby is born.

@classicalhollywood3254

13 күн бұрын

@@ilyasharin1976 well Hollywood supplies the best movies so fair enough.

Seeing Mykhalkov in the credits made me realize I have no idea who he is despite hearing about him so often growing up. Also, back then you'd probably pay money to watch these which are now on youtube, usually uploaded by the studios themselves just to earn enough and keep them afloat

“It is a life which has nothing to do with the profiteers; it scorns utterly their life and standards. It is bringing up a new generation to scorn these things also.” - American journalist Anna Louis Strong on pre-Stalin USSR, 1921-23

so this is where Garfield 2 took it's stroy

Make them love money in the West and hate money in the East

@Backupaccof2017acc

3 ай бұрын

Bruh

@gnightcore5352

Ай бұрын

Especially lack of money in the East 😂😂😂

@ironhell813

14 күн бұрын

But not lack of resources so they had to betray and invade their own allies like the us 🤣

@WorldWorldCommunismAnimations

13 күн бұрын

Complain about capitalism while the inflation rises. Soon America will no longer be the leading power and will be overtaken by china Communism did not work because the Russians did it wrong So don't brag about capitalism defeating communism. Brag about Joe Biden vs Donald Trump 😂

@XOFInfantryman

13 күн бұрын

​​@@ironhell813? Pipe down little bro Or do i have to bring up Prague Spring and other such events?

Забавно наблюдать когда многие американцы благодаря пропаганде ненавидят коммунизм. Но думают что изобрели велосипед, начиная работать на себя, без себственников и посредников. В этом и суть коммунизма.

@654g63

14 күн бұрын

Ещё забавней, видеть. Тупорылого крепостного, которого его коммунизм, лучше капитазма, но вот. Что интересно, только жрать вы раньше вы не могли)))

@reihlopjya8336

14 күн бұрын

увы но при ссср и собственником и посредником выступало государство земля давалась колхозам в пользование, а не владение а о частном промышленном производстве не могло быть и речи если вы в эту сторону клоните, конечно

@user-si3gc3mu7m

13 күн бұрын

В 1935 году советская власть передала землю колхозам в ВЕЧНОЕ пользование. В 13 томе сочинений Сталина,который охватывает период с 1928 по 1934 год написано и про хозрасчёт и про уравниловку. Если бы не госпереворота 1953 года. Паразитам понадобилось 40 лет что бы расшатать мощнейший фундамент народно-хозяйственного механизма заложенного Сталиным.

@zigoter2185

10 күн бұрын

ИП - это коммунизм? Смешно.

Карикатура Я не видел художественных произведений по-настоящему раскрывающих тему прибавочной стоимости

Все по факту

Still, propaganda isn't nessesarry something filled with intentional lies about something. It's a propagation of sirtain views. If you repost so thoughts i think are right thats also propaganda.