You are right, they use backing tracks (playing and singing by them) and in fact they have never hidden it

@hipoman8087

5 ай бұрын

True. The drummer contrite.

It boggles my mind that people will claim that The Warning don't use backing tracks on some songs when they've talked on many occasions about using Ableton software to manage and play backing tracks. It's not a secret, they don't try and hide it, and have never claimed to not use backing tracks. They do play a lot of stuff without backing tracks, and the backing tracks they do use are minimal/subtle, but they absolutely use them. And you're right that Pau is a hell of a singer. While I firmly believe that Dany is the better singer overall (more high range being the biggest difference), there's something about Pau's tone when singing that just grabs your heart and rips it out of your chest. If you want to check out a different (and older) Warning concert that doesn't get blocked, I can highly recommend the entire Lunario CDMX concert on their official channel. It's the entire Queen of the Murder Scene concept album (which is AMAZING) and a few of their other popular originals.

@Nolimitcam._

6 ай бұрын

Yes the ladies always say that they do use them and it’s nothing wrong with that🤘

@ronhall5395

6 ай бұрын

Yes, they have always used some backing tracks. Just watch the 2nd TEDX . Clearly during the Survive song, A piano is playing in the back during the jam session at the end of the song. Yes, the echo effect on Wrong is a track.

@batallasdeshorts4149

6 ай бұрын

@@g.garcia7151 I totally agree, but sometimes people think that some vocals are backing tracks, so people deny it, and some interpret that this is why they are denied using tracks generally, when they were specifically referring to those tracks.

@genboyer

6 ай бұрын

And perhaps most important is that they have always recorded their own backing tracks, not some studio musician.

@stephenb4703

5 ай бұрын

MOST of what they do is only minimally helped by backing tracks. It fills in small gaps.

The echo is a backing track to mimic what is on the studio version.

Yep, They use Ableton live (as you mentioned the laptop is next to Pau) it has the click track for their in ear monitors as well as additional tracks as needed for each song, although you'll find it's mostly subtle in it's implementation. The song More is a bit more blatant as there is a keyboard/synth sound (edited; I've been corrected, the effect is done with guitar!) with the Ale's bass during the intro. The tracks used are still played/sung by the band (they're also classically trained pianists), but as you say, as a three piece they occasionally need to use some additional 'padding' or sounds that are on the studio version but were dubbed on by them additionally to their chosen instruments. Good reaction - a thumbs up from me! TWA⚡UK

@Dave_Marks

6 ай бұрын

Not true. The effects in More are all done with guitars. There is no synth or keyboards. TW and the producer have said this.

@Wishi13

6 ай бұрын

@@Dave_Marks I stand corrected! Thanks 👍

@rexwave4624

6 ай бұрын

The response “Wrong” appears to be a backing track.

@ronhall5395

6 ай бұрын

Not to cause controversy, but the synth sounds in MORE, are Dany's guitar effects done as a backing track.She is very proud of those backing tracks. No keyboard was used.

@Wishi13

6 ай бұрын

@@ronhall5395 Yea, the first reply already stated the same thing, but thanks for the info.

Check out Pau's rig rundown - she talks about using Ableton software - they have access to all of their studio tracks with it - they can blend in any. track they want. Here are a couple videos of Pau talking about it: kzread.info/dash/bejne/Z62m25eDYaeblcY.html kzread.info/dash/bejne/on2jj5eBpMWfqqQ.html It's why they sound bigger than a traditional rock trio. What I hear mostly when listening to them are extra guitar parts and backing vocals. When a guitarist plays a solo and the rhythm guitar drops out, it can sound very empty, so you usually hear a rhythm guitar when Dany plays a solo. Personally, I think this is the best way to go for them. Why bring other musicians on stage when they can use tracks that they wrote and played themselves?

Yes, Pau's laptop runs both click and stems. Pau does all the triggers for start and stop of the Ableton (she talks about the START pedal on her left, and STOP pedal on her right in the most recent rig rundown video). Their use of supporting tracks is complementary to the songs not mandatory for. I have seen them when that backing track dies or does not get triggered correctly, and they keep right on playing. Bands have been doing this since the 70s (the Who with Baba O-Riley) and the 80s (Rush with Amiee Mann's voice on Time Stand Still). I have no problem with it being used in a supporting role like they do, especially since they play all the parts themselves.

@luisaguila7367

6 ай бұрын

Thanks for your clear explanation. I was starting to explain the same with the laptop, the click, the pedal and so on. Nice reaction. 23 is one of the most impressive songs with Pau singing and drumming in a masterclass way. Perforned in some concerts, not a regular song in the setlist. I had the opportunity to be in Monterrey concert last year and the song was included. Blow away my mind and feelings. Lucky me to be there and the song was included. Long life to the good Rock. Long life to TW and DPA. I'm 59 and rocker listener since looong time ago. I love this band and recognize their talents. God bless you!

The thing with The Warning is, they are so good with pitch and timing that they can actually use all these samples live. And they are also masters in producing those bits. So there subtle use of backing tracks is an expression of their greatness.🤘

Dany uses a Kemper board that also has extra guitar effects for each song too! The girls did a Gear Masters tour showing all the equipment they use And Dany goes thru her guitars her petal board strings and all the other stuff she uses.

No one can tell someone their opinion is wrong. However in saying that, the degree of difficulty and talent required to pull off what Pau is doing in 23 is off the charts. Her vocals are studio level quality…while pounding the drums!

@gaminjunctiontv5534

6 ай бұрын

They do use back tracks to fill out the sound. After all they are a 3 piece. Paula covers this in her gear rundown presented by Digital Tour Bus.

@davekimball3610

6 ай бұрын

Never mind that she's pulling that off at what, 7000 feet in altitude or whatever CDMX sits at.

@williamburkholder769

6 ай бұрын

@@davekimball3610 7300' or so, yes, or about 3/4 of normal atmospheric pressure. Fitness required... Pau is in beast mode here.

@kencadby6586

6 ай бұрын

And that means 3/4 oxygen per breath. :) @@williamburkholder769

They do use backing tracks and also click tracks in their in-ears and make no secret of it, in fact there are a couple interviews in which they go to some length explaining how it works. But it is always subtle. And they are very well rehearsed, as I once attended their performance at Poinfest in St. Louis and only learned later that from a vlog that their click track wasn't working. I had not noticed any difference.

With some bands, you get the feeling that they use tracks to hide their lack of talent. With The Warning, the tracks clearly enhance their performance and their talent is in full display. Great review!

They def use tracks on Ableton. They add piano, guitar and other embellishments to some of their live tracks. More has a synth part. This Hell You Call a Dream has an entire intro part. I don't know why people get weird about playback tracks. Its still played and written by them. It is part of the sound they want.

@charliebald1079

5 ай бұрын

People are weird

@viktorstagnetti7491

5 ай бұрын

I think it's because a lot of people assume that backing tracks are only used by shitty bands/artists to mask their issues. In this case, I'd say it enhances their performance. Naturally, fans first instinct is to defend their band.

@jamesanderson5268

5 ай бұрын

Survive has a piano backing track.

@smward87

5 ай бұрын

Yeah 99.99% of bands and musical artists use backing tracks and samples during their live performances. They're there to put on a show just as much as they are to showcase their talent don't forget. So that means filling out the sound to enhance the live playing with backing tracks.

@ben-jam-in6941

4 ай бұрын

I never had the pleasure of having samples mixed in live but it would have made some things harder playing rock styles of music .. For example if after the second chorus but before the last verse the second has a shorter lead break than the big take us out lead at the end. But this time my lead guitar player has evoked his inner Duane Allman and did a jam band length lead and came out of it in a position where we need to let every thing go around another time and then begin that verse. Im making my observation more complicated to explain than need be. Anyway if you hit a button that plays these samples before you or the lead guitarist knows he’s gonna feel it and play a longer lead you couldn’t signal the samples like you would the drummer to just wait one more time around those chord changes and then bring it down for the verse. I guess Im accustomed to being able to improvise in a very natural way that 98% of the crowd will never know happened anyway.

Hi. TW were always honest about it, yes, they use some tracks, usually some keyboard or piano sound, or even some rhythm guitar, and on occasions, like this, some effect ir voices. where it becomes clear is in enter sandman, that Alessia Cara's voice is added to theirs. There are even several videos of Pau on KZread explaining how he is responsible for launching the tracks from his midi pedals. It's no secret and it adds a lot to what they do live. without failing to say that everything that is sound has been recorded by them for the tracks, that is, in one way or another they do it. Great reaction. Viva The Warning! ⚡🤘⚡🤘⚡🤘

Nice Reaction! They all three did like a rig rundown by a channel called Gear Masters recently and Pau talks about the laptop and how she starts and stops the backing tracks, so I don't know why people don't think they're using them. It's not like they're trying to hide it. "The Warnings Paulina Villarreal Gear Masters" Since you're a guitar player you might like Dany's too. She LOVES her PRS.

@scottinokc

6 ай бұрын

Came here to recommend Pau's Gear Masters video, you beat me to it 👍🏻

It never ceases to amaze me how Pau can sing so well while playing the drums and, as always, Ale doing a great job on the bass and Dany on the second voice and guitar. On the other hand, as Pau often says, at the end of the day preferences in music are just opinions.

Watch Pau’s rig run down. They’ve always been open about using stems and Pau talks about using Ableton. The area you point out is pulled right from the released track. Including elements that fill in secondary or atmospheric parts is pretty well known. Watch some live acoustic stuff and you’ll see just how great they are unplugged. Talent is talent and always shines through.

This band does not do any bad songs, so when some body asks me which song I like the most, I say any of the good ones. I can´t chose because every song is great! The Warning is a gift to the World by the Rock God. I love this son, and I love it more every time I hear it. It´s so beautiful and the clarity of Paus voice is mesmerizing! Thank you for the reaction.

@warrenmccann9156

6 ай бұрын

Could not have said it better. This is an amazing song sung by an amazing singer. They are a gift to the world and a National Treasure for Mexico. Trust me I was at the Pepsi Center in October and I can tell you Mexican people would go to war for these girls.

Pau is running Ableton Live on the lap top next to her kit. She has the whole show programmed with backing tracks and effects. The lighting and video screens are also programmed into that lap top.

Do a live . . Maybe do Queen of the Murder Scene from start to finish . . . Its a concept album . . Play it here start to finish . . . Covers 2 things . .you wanting to hear a whole album and also gives you content . . Lol . Great reaction . . 🍻🇳🇿

Just got done binge watching all your TW reactions for the first time. I know you get a ton of suggestions on what to do next, but here is my 2 cents. I like it that you throw in the early covers every few reactions. The one you absolutely need to do next is their cover of Metallica's Atlas Rise live at The Whiskey. There is another version of it done in The Cave at their house that is outstanding, but the live version is mind blowing. And you have said a few times you plan to dive in to a full album offline. If you do this with QOTMS, it's a slam dunk choice to do it by watching the live performance of the whole album at the Lunario. Look forward to your next reaction.

Beautiful Song, Great Performance

Yes, the echo sounds on Wrong and Gone are indeed a “track”. They use backing vocal tracks on other songs as well such as Alessia Cara’s vocals on ES and some of the binary code in Error and I’m sure there’s other examples. The majority of what TW use are sound effects, ie sirens, screams and other inocuos sounds. They also have songs with keyboard parts that they no longer play onstage or never have. There are songs with splashes of a 2nd guitar to fill out Dany’s sound. Even with all the effects that Dany can use through her Kemper she can’t play 2 different sets of notes simultaneously. Tracking/stems are very much used by a majority of touring bands these days, it’s not a secret or taboo. The distinction is when some bands rely on them for a majority of their sound. If any of TWA caught the NA leg of the Error Tour with Plush and Holy Wars did you wonder where the bass sound was coming from during the Holy Wars set? There was only the lead singer, guitarist and drummer onstage. How often are we finding out lately that some of what we consider “legacy” bands have been using tracks for entire segments of their shows for years? There are a lot of modern bands, The Warning included, that use tracks to enhance the show not to be the show and there seem to be others that can’t function without tracks.

They do use backing tracks. Due to harsh experience, the computer with the click track/ backing vocal/ backgound video etc crashing to the stage and the lid closing mid song during a live show, there is nothing on the computer that will keep them from giving a full performance.

Thanks for the reaction Gary! No problems here with anything you said, we all have to have favorites and non-favorites. But I have never found a song by them that I really disliked!! 😊⚡️

@warrenmccann9156

6 ай бұрын

I like their music so much I can't decide which song I like least. But I like evolve the most because the lyrics are prescient to my in a really personal way. Which is another really great thing about this band. Their lyrics actually say something. They have meaning.

2:01 You can clearly hear rhythm guitar during her lead part. Anyone denying their use of tracks is simply not paying attention. You have to in order to deliver a perfect show. And Dany uses octave effect a lot to make a big sound.

The warning is completely open and up front about using Abelton tracks. All of the tracks with the exception of Alessia Caras voice in Enter Sandman is recorded by the girls. If there's an instrument or voice in the track it's almost always still them. With a 3 piece it's necessary to fill out the sound.

Pau is awesome I love her vocals and Dany backing while playing that slide portion was pretty cool. ⚡🔥Ale is always there in the background keeping it all together.⚡ I really like this song and take no offense that you prefer other songs more so do I. Thank you for reacting to TW appreciate your opinion. 🤘 Dany said if there's a backing track they have produce it an example is the piano in Survive or the screams in QOTMS. 👍 Pau does a rundown and explains the computer and how they work it in. 🤘⚡🔥

I know "23" isn't one of The Warning's bigger hits, but I absolutely love it.The emotional content in Pau's voice is devastating. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, of course, so if "23" isn't your favorite, that's fair.

@rsdempster

6 ай бұрын

23 from Teatro Metropolitan was my most watched video for 2023. I'm a sucker for power ballads.

@batallasdeshorts4149

6 ай бұрын

Los conciertos no serían lo mismo son canciones como 23, son lo que hacen que sean dinamicos, es necesario que hayan canciones relajadas.

@adrianszczygiel6385

6 ай бұрын

Same here. 23 was the first song I heard from them and it totally blew my mind. The deeper I dug into their music the more I fell in love with it. They are awesome :D

Ellas mismas han dicho en tutoriales que usan pistas de acompañamiento eso no es un secreto, solo cuando la canción lo requiere, muchos grupos lo hacen y más cuando son tres, pero lo que importa es que son ellas mismas las que tocan, cantan y escriben sus canciones, son increíbles músicos, las admiro mucho por ser tan talentosas y buenas en todo lo que hacen, mi grupo preferido sin lugar a dudas, DPA 💯🤟

@SDsailor7

6 ай бұрын

La musica de los backing tracks son ellas cantando y tocando.

Luv your reactions! I, for one, really appreciate your keen awareness of the myriad aural components of a performance. Looking forward to your next vid. 👊⚡️

They talk about it a bunch of times in behind the scenes stuff, in one Dany is like “it’s still all us, it’s not we can’t play it”. They have also said Dany and Ale play multiple parts at the same time.

Such as amazing song and performance. Dany's guitar parts are great, and of course - Pau kills it, no surprise there. Pau does heartbreakjust as well as she pounds those drums. To see something like this on a whole other level ceck out Revenant from this same show, The girls each recentlly did individual rundowns of their gear for the channel Digital Tour Bus. Great little five minute vids that you might enjoy - they give a nice glimpse into both their gear and their personalities.

I totally understand the fascination with the production, but I just need the excellent end result! 🤩

Yes, there’s so many great concerts by them. Dakota bar is the go-to for their 1st album timeframe. Lunario is the debut of their full 2nd album & they are on🔥. Foro DiDi is from the same timeframe but added their then newest single ‘Narcisista’ (& is perhaps the ultimate version of it). ‘Dust to Dust’ gets an extended bass intro & an equipment failure leads to a magical a cappella version of ‘Crimson Queen’. There’s great stuff from the Whiskey a gogo including a rendition of ‘Atlas Rise’. & plenty more.

They are 100% using backing tracks, which they have video's going over how they use them. Great reaction.

Every band uses backing tracks ,these add to the songs or we wouldn’t have all the good music we have .

The sounds you hear in the background: It's exactly the same as on the cd. It runs with the click track and possibly other things from the laptop of Pau. When the laptop should stop it hardly would have any influence on the song because it is quite low in volume. Everything you hear from the laptop is made by the girls so you always hear the sisters on a concert and that is what they want.

I think you’re right that the “Oh,oh,oh” echoing in the background is on a backing track. I’m not sure if Pau is triggering it with her midi pedal; I suspect it is just synchronized with the click track they are playing to (which she does initiate). 👍😎

There is no doubt that, generally, they use a backing track. Enter Sandman still has some Alessia Cara vocals. Alessia Cara isn’t there. Now, yeah, you can debate if a specific thing is backing or not, but they have backing tracks, no debate.

I know that the favourite song of Dany is Comfortably Numb and i see, i think there is some remeniscences in this song. Long life to TW I propose "The end" at lunario when Ale was 13...omg

@iNsTaNtpUdDiNhEaD

6 ай бұрын

I'm pretty sure Dany's favorite song is "The Sound of Music" from the musical of the same name.

@juanloverboy9254

6 ай бұрын

@@iNsTaNtpUdDiNhEaD No, She said that in an interview. She said when she listened this song and the guitar solo final she was in schock. That's was she said. ;-) Allison Hagendorf interview. 49:00

Dany's kemper sounds great. The stereo double is fantastic.

There is a fan cam of this performance [sorry i do not have the link}. You can here the audience sing the delay

I recently watched a gear breakdown of Pau's drum kit and she has peddles which she uses in conjunction with her lap top and left foot. Take care

Mi grupo preferido sin lugar a dudas, mi admiración desde hace tiempo y Pau increíble tocando y cantando. Yo estoy con ellas hasta el l final, conozco su historia y se el talento que tienen las tres. 🤟💯

in almost a year i have found that there are different components of each song that drills into me..More is not a "favorite", the VMA version is, to me, So much more powerful than the studio effort. i appreciate that the ladies meticulously craft each song to be the best it can be,..

!!!The Warning = 100% 🔥¡¡¡ Greetings from Argentina

They use a backing track and a click on live performances. Whoever said they don't, does not know what they are talking about. Paulina launches the stems and clicks from an Ableton software suite on a computer next to her kit through a Roland midi pedal. The first thing they did when they recorded the Error album in 2020 was laydown the backing tracks. For those of you who don't know see this video: The Warning's Paulina Villarreal Vélez - GEAR MASTERS Ep. 475 At about the six minute mark she points this out.

I do like this song.

That is a sound effect that is part of their backing track- not a voice but electronic sound. They have backing tracks on most of their songs these days but usually not vocal (except Alessia Cara for Enter Sandman).

@phishfan

6 ай бұрын

Thanks!!

Yes, they use backing tracks in a some of their songs. Pau has talked about it and shown her setup. She runs Ableton Live with the click track and the stems. She has 2 dedicated pedals to start and stop the song.. she doesn't trigger individual sounds. Sometimes for ambience, like sound effects.. a couple of songs there are rhythm parts while Dany plays lead. In Survive which starts out with piano played live, they play a piano backing track later in the song.. Enter Sandman, has a an Alessia Cara backing vocal track.. I'm not sure who has denied it.. it's very clear they use them. Most reactors just say "oh I hear a ...", not sure why you seem obsessed with them though. lol Check out her Gear Review video kzread.info/dash/bejne/on2jj5eBpMWfqqQ.html

Thank you. Yes, that is a track of Pau in the background that you hear. TWA

They have been very transparent about the use of track and stems. They have always said that the tracks help fill out the sound, but you have to be prepared to play with out them and they have had to play with out them several time due to computer issues and other equipment. Music is art and hits people differently it is ok not to like something as much as some one else as long as everyone respects each others options. Enjoying the video's you are doing keep up the honest option's.

My favorite song is the one I'm listening to🤘

Yes you are correct. They talk about using stems and click tracks in most of their songs. Pau uses ableton software and controls all of it through her midi pedals. Check out her lates gear masters video. She covers it. BTW your opinion on this song is fine. That’s why I watch reactions. Nice reaction. Enjoy your opinions and reactions.

Yeah, that echo is surely a track. Those that say TW does not use tracks are uninformed. Great song, nonetheless.

Great analysis. Thanks

Pau is amazing 🥁👩‍🎤🔥

You are correct! That's why Pau has the lap top,,if they say they don't they clearly know nothing about this band!

Excellent my friend

@phishfan

6 ай бұрын

Thank you! Cheers!!

Pau has talked many times about using Ableton Live for click tracks and additional sounds when playing live. They make no attempt to disguise what they are doing.

Nice reaction! Yes, the girls have said it many times, they do use tracks and Pau is the one who triggers everything from her laptop. You can watch Pau's gear rundown video from DTB where she explains it. Keep the reactions coming. 👍

Like your honesty. There’s a video where the drummer shows exactly what equipment she uses. She points out something she uses the laptop with foot pedals. You’ll know what it is. I have no complaints with minor amounts of filler. I’d say they do almost all of their show live. Nice catch on that. But I’ve got to say it was a darker stage so it was hard to tell if maybe one was at a mic. ❤❤❤

Backpacking vocal is all times with the click. When daddy's playing the lead you can hear power cords in the background as well

That quiet vocal you speak of is on the recorded version and there you hear it's meant for a special echo thing. Which makes sense when you hear it played live.

The voices or echoes that are heard in the background. They are choruses of own voices previously recorded and coming from Pau's computer. There are sounds that they record and are part of their songs. They explain a little about that in VLOG #25 (previously exclusive on Patreon) .

*23* , like many of their songs, is left open to interpretation... some have speculated the title is for the year "2023" while others have thought it references someone's age... i was not sure but have come to see it as being about the year "2023" because that's when Pau turned 21 years old... the lyrics "barely old enough to drink" are fitting in many locales where 21 is the drinking age... in DPA/TW's home area, the drinking age is 18, IIRC... anyway, this is certainly a song about caring deeply for someone from afar, holding back, and then realizing that, in the future, they will meet that someone again... how they will handle their feelings and memories and what may possibly happen... then again, while it sounds personal, maybe this song is about something they might have read or seen in a movie or TV show... after all, their song *Amour* comes from a 15 second clip of a scene in the movie "Ratatouille"... that scene has the camera looking through a hole in the wooden floor... there are two characters down there having a fight... maybe a lover's quarrel? i don't remember... anyway, they are arguing, they suddenly hug each other, and it is done; end clip... there's also their song *Wildfire* which was inspired by "The Hunger Games" movies... i think at least the 2nd one titled "Catching Fire"... DPA/TW have drawn inspiration from a lot of places... IRL, books, movies, games, etc 😹 this song has brought tears to many eyes... while being a powerful drummer, Pau is also a fantastic and very emotive singer... i don't go a day without hearing DPA/TW... they possess both, my heart and soul... TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA

A thing with this show, as I understand it, the audio is from night 2, and the video is from both nights, so sometimes things like Dany's strumming look out of synch to the sound that's coming out of the guitar. Recommend Pau's drumming masterclass. Very informative and there's a subtitled version. I agree with you on 23. It's good, but it doesn't super excite me. Ugh and Dull Knives are still my favourites.

You are right it is a track.

You are not wrong about tracks. The band has never tried to hide it. They are very upfront about the fact they are a 3 piece and cannot physically do everything in a live setting. That said, I think the are a great example of the perfect use of tracks. It is subtle and only enhances what they are playing. Without the tracks their performance doesn't really suffer. I think the most glaring use I have ever seen was 'Z' performed at Teatro. The rhythm guitar clearly kicks in while Dani is still finishing her blistering guitar solo. The official audio plays that way, but the 'live session' video there is no rhythm guitar until after the solo finishes. It is also ok not to be a big fan of some of the songs. I still think they haven't written a bad song yet, but there are some I don't care to listen to very often. And The Warning is very reactor friendly. They know how it works. The more people spread the word, the better it becomes for them. Also, they were independent up until this last album, so all the old songs have no management company patrolling them.

Who cares! What an awesome song and group! Awesome Band, Awesome Beautiful Ladies!

The audience did a lot of singing along at this concert, but I think you're correct in your analysis. The repeated background vocal seems to be on the click track laptop. Pau uses Ableton to run EVERYTHING. I think whether you like or don't like the song depends upon your personal past and whether you relate to the spirit of the lyrics. It takes me way back to my youth and rips my heart out every time. I totally relate. Pau is a real empath, with the ability to take a 15-second movie clip and turn it into poetic lyrics. Her cover of Radiohead's *Creep* is probably my favorite version of that song.

"23" while not your fav, is def. one of mine. I know you still like it so no knock on you. I know these use backing tracks which is not a secret, takes nothing away from how great they are. Looking forward to more reactions from you.

@phishfan

5 ай бұрын

Thanks for the comments!!

Yes they often have some backtracks, some effects or added instruments

The thing about The Warning and backing tracks at a live concert....if the computer or the track misfires, or crashes, most in the audience won't know it happened. To give the audience a 'best sound possible' is their goal, so sirens, gunfire, and screeching tires are tracked in. Nightwish relies on The London Philharmonic to get the amazing full sound they produce in live concerts. Hard to take TLP on tour, so....back tracks. Both bands are great, but during a power outage, I'f rather be with The Warning.

The band makes no secret about how they will use tracks when they deem necessary. In a recent gear run down on digital tour bus Pau shows the midi pedals she uses to activate and deactivate the tracks they use. Tis is a clip from a longer interview--in the clip they answer a question about backing tracks and thier philosophy on using them kzread.info/dash/bejne/fYN828avmK7WXco.htmlsi=VZvBlZDgxP3Enxhf

💯%TWA🤟🎶☮️

I don't know why anyone would say they don't use backing tracks, they 100% do. There are videos of Pau showing how her laptop works to trigger the click and backing tracks. I think it super cool how it all works! I would say, you use the term "sample". I personally use that term for something different than backing tracks, but I'm not a musician and could be wrong. I thought they were different, so that might be why some people say they don't use them. Idk? Just my thoughts. Thanks for the reaction!

They definitely trigger things and use a click. They talk about it in many videos. And yes there is an echo playing from the back.

The is a gear video that shows Pau’s gear set up, they have a MacBook there running Ableton for when they use tracks, there are foot switches just to the left of her HH pedal that she uses to trigger the tracks.

The warning forever

Yes that is correct that was a backing track.

Yes the echo is a track

Yeah, as per other comments, incredible song, but this would have been recommended for you because of the incredible showcasing talent that is Pau.

They definitely use backing tracks, it's not a secret. Pau talks about it on her masterclass here in KZread. You can also learn more about their setup at the channel "Digital Tour Bus", they mentioned backing tracks on those videos too: Pau's: Gear Masters Ep 475 Ale's: Gear Masters Ep 473 Dany's: Gear Masters Ep 471

My friend The Warning "Atlas Rise" Metallica cover LIVE in Whisky a go go plis

On her gear video she shows the laptop

yes it is a backing track for the echo .

Some tracks going on but sounds great.

Something I have not heard any one comment on yet ,it seems to me that since this was such an important show and they wanted the most professional,fullest sound possible as it was an official release by the band,they used every available backing track possible, including rhythm guitar parts, to sound as much like the recorded versions as possible. Please correct me if I'm wrong. This is not a criticism by any means. When I see them live in person or watch a fan video, they sound more basic and raw,mainly Dany's guitar,with no rhythm tracks,but still full.

If you get a chance look at the Gear Masters videos of the girls and it explains a lot how they create their sound. ie Dany has a synth that adds a lower tone to her guitar since she is playing lead and rhythm at the same time. The Gear Masters look at Pau, she explains the Ableton laptop next to her and what she uses it for....

Others have mentioned this as well and referred to it a delay/echo effect.

Sometimes the three are missing another member. But it doesn't make sense because you don't need another member to write the songs. With today's income you don't pay anyone just to play anymore. Added to this is the close relationship between the three. Another member would always be a foreign body.

Pau said that multiple times, what's the problem? This don't influence their great performance! 😉😍

There use of backing tracks is minimal. In the last 2 or 3 years the computer died and know one new it. It happened at least 5 or 6 times only die hard fans knew. One of the times was opening for GnR they would not let them do a sound check the commuter would not work and they still killed it. Many say there is a guitar backing track, lately I have seen a few reactors get it right, Dany uses her pedal board to split her guitar into stero with one side on a delay with a different tone so it sounds like 2 guitars playing

Pau is nominated for best rock drummer of 2023 and the winner will be announced on the Drumeo youtube channel on January 25 2024 So if you voted for her that's great. I voted for her because i believe she deserves the honor.

Pau una maestra de la composición y enorme interprete con su voz ronca y desgarrada ,23, Pau es un genio del nuevo rock

Yep, a little backing track magic. Dany's backing vocals are pretty cool, too, but she doesn't do all of it. I love this song and this performance, but then again, it's Pau, and the passion she transmits is just other-worldly to me.

That's not a secret they use backing tracks :) With only 3 of them it would be impossible to play all of this. But on the other hand - they record everything by themselves, they play and sing their parts live and the backing tracks are only for support. Results are incredible so nobody should have anything against that, especially that many of the greatest bands in history also used that method. 23 - one of my favs from The Warning by the way :) Thanks for a great reaction video, spot on as always! :)

@tonycook1624

6 ай бұрын

The laptop on the stand on the left side of the drummer is used as the trigger for the fill-in samples they use

Consider watching the The Warning's Alejandra Villarreal Vélez - GEAR MASTERS Ep. 473 and The Warning's Daniela Villarreal Vélez - GEAR MASTERS Ep. 471 and The Warning's Paulina Villarreal Vélez - GEAR MASTERS Ep. 475

If you do an entire album i suggest Queen of the Murder Scene. Its a concept album they made when they were all still teenagers, so all the songs go together.