You are both correct. For the main lyrics, Dany does a high register harmony and then switches to the lower register harmony for the chorus. The harmonies produced by these sisters brings out a fullness to their songs that other groups can't match.

@RobertLindabury

5 ай бұрын

Absolutely this! Many people miss it but Pau starts out lower with Dany doing the higher harmonies and then when Pau swaps to the higher register, Dany swaps immediately to the lower harmonies. It's so awesome! And, a lot of people seem to miss Pau's very special to her vibrato throughout this song. And all her emotional breathy moments really give the feels.

@alvasquez2931

4 ай бұрын

Yep

Paulina really deserves respect for doing what she does as an artist.

@CarlD70

5 ай бұрын

Absolutely, most multi- talented Drummer/vocalists currently residing on our planet. Thanks for visiting earth Pau.

@krash66

5 ай бұрын

@@CarlD70 I am convinced they are 3 Alien Unicorns from the planet Rocktopia, here to save Earth from crappy music. LOL

Paulina Villarreal, our Drumeo Rock Drummer of the Year for 2023! Flawless vocals while drumming, a very rare and special talent!

@SDsailor7

5 ай бұрын

Don't forget best up and coming drummer of 2023 two awards in the same year. And more to come her way for sure.

@genboyer

5 ай бұрын

My hope is that next year she will celebrate her 23rd Birthday at the Grammys!

Pau has said this in the past: Dany has the highest range, Ale’ had the lowest range, and Pau had the widest range. This enables Pau to harmonize with Dany at the high end and Ale’ on the low end. All low ends belong to Ale’. The best example of this is in the song Choke. I’ve seen them live six times, and when Ale sings her low solo, the crowd goes wild every single time. ⚠️⚡️🤘🏽

@WaldoKitty

5 ай бұрын

wildest or widest? ;)

@braddentrujillo2050

5 ай бұрын

@@WaldoKitty good catch, I fixed it. Although Pau is the “wildest” when playing her instrument, her singing range is far from wild. 😂⚡️🤘🏽

@JohnMacleod-wo3ou

5 ай бұрын

Dany has the largest range according to Bendeth, but Pau has full ess to her voice that fools people. She is able to put an emotion in her voice that is unmatched. Pau makes you cry.

@braddentrujillo2050

5 ай бұрын

@@JohnMacleod-wo3ou I just repeated what Pau stated with Dany and Ale sitting next to her nodding in agreement.

@genboyer

5 ай бұрын

But let's not forget the Ale sings a mean falsetto on some harmonies!

PAU is my musical hero.. Top of the list of favorites artists... Dany & Ale are top of list in their own way. But Pau is built different. She has 3 brains and she uses them all at the same time. Sometimes Ale goes high , they trade off... It's hard to tell sometimes.. The echo is a track or echo effects. I'm trying to figure it out too... 🤘🎶☮️

Such a sad but beautiful song! She is so Pau-r-ful, whether singing or pounding those drums!! 10/10

Wow. I can't believe she's playing the drums and singing. So talented

These Ladies are absolutely AMAZING!!! Love this song. Pau is an incredible artist... this is Talent overload at the highest level. Thanks guys for another wonderful Warning reaction. ⚡⚡⚡⚡

There is a higher harmony early, then it switches to the lower harmony. I think Dany does both. Pau and Dany seamlessly harmonize. It's really something to behold. There are a lot of different styles on display at the Teatro Metropolitan concert. The energy is constant.

@paulf4650

5 ай бұрын

Dany and Pau do that frequently, swap the high and low harmonies in live performances. I agree, it is something to behold!

Man I love the guitarwork in this song, never mentioned enough

Your wife is correct about the higher register harmony going on toward the beginning... starting around 2:48 And then later she switches to the lower register harmony that you pointed out.

Pau is an awesome drummer, singer, songwriter and person!! Absolutely EPIC live performance! Awesome Dany's sliding riffs! Great Ale's bass lines! Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡

The concert they did at liceo in 2015, will take you back to the 80's

Paulina is unique. The Lyrics of 23 are intense and beauty. Is hard to believe that she sings the entire song. But she does. And she is so young! We see many reactors trying to be technicals or "musicians" on reviews and loose the passion and joy of the song. Ok. The girls are talented and a prodigy of music. But they are artists and love to sing and play. The Warning is the hole thing and more. JUst enjoy! We are so lucky!

👍👍Awesome performance!! 🖖❤

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Yes!

Always enjoy your reactions! Yes, Dany harmonizes first an octave above Pau, earlier in the song, and later an octave lower. Incredible range, and Pau's performance is just otherworldly, yet again!

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

They are so good! Thank you!

it seems like the echo is the track that they used from the album. When I play the two back-to-back, I hear the same tone and everything. as for the vocals, I believe it’s just Dany and Pau.

First part there is a higher harmony, I didn't pick up if it is Dany or Ale, in the second part Dany does the lower one. EDIT: "Fast forward to 23..." A higher harmony, pretty sure it's Dany.

@ericlenouy8756

5 ай бұрын

Yep, Dany doing the higher in the first part, then switching to the lower

Sounds like your little thunder rooster there wants to hear some more from The Warning.

*23 Backstory:* The Warning did two nights at Teatro Metropolitan (Friday & Monday). This video was from the first night. But I'm not sure about the audio. Since on the second night. Ale's bass teacher, Pablo Gonzalez, stood next to his pupil also playing a bass guitar on the song 23. Yet, his name appears on the credits at the conclusion. We only see him during the closing credits on stage with everyone else. Pablo Gonzalez was the man who suggested these girls to each write a song by themselves. Then write a song together. That project became *Escape the Mind* EP. Dany wrote *Eternal Love. * Ale wrong *Take Me Down.* Pau wrote *Fade Away* & *Escape the Mind.* The band wrote *Free Falling.*

Very cool Pau's a killer. TW are incredible so much fun to watch. Thank you great reaction. 🤘🔥⚡

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Love reacting to them.

Rock superstars!! So many of their songs should be #1 hits, including this one.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

From what we have heard. We can agree

The echo is a track (it sounds like it was pulled from the studio album). This is one of my favorite tracks on the album (Error).

Pau and Dany switch harmonies. When Pau is in her upper register, Dany is in her lower, and vice versa. The two have different timbers and under tones to their voices.

Danny does both, at 2:47 is when she is doing the higher voice, then at 3:09 she starts doing the lower voice.

Break my heart for all I care, as long as I get, to be there.

Al bebe tambien le gusta paulina y the warning y esta reaccionando.... un fan mas que se une a las filas de the warning !!! 👏👏👏

It is amazing to see the skill on display here.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

💯💯

!!!The Warning = 100% 🔥¡¡¡ Greetings from Argentina

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Hello!

Excellent my friends!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(It’s Pau) (or Pow!😂)

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

POW!💥

@randymarple9830

5 ай бұрын

@@ThunderRooster Fix your description from PAO to Pau. Unless PAO means something else. Paulina= Pau(for short)not PAO. Nice reaction though.

@randymarple9830

5 ай бұрын

Ahhhhh, I see you changed it !!

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

@@randymarple9830 it was an error. I fixed it already. 😁

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

@@randymarple9830 no worries!

I continue to be impressed with Pau beating her kit like it owes her money while singing flawlessly at the same time! Also, this concert took place in Mexico City @ 7300' above sea level!! Regarding the "echo" vocal, I am fairly certain it is a track.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Wow!

23 is another magical song,, nice reaction

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Thank you!

Dany is doing the higher harmony. There is an echo in the click track.

@scrantsj

5 ай бұрын

I think she switches between the high and low harmony during the song.

There is definitely a higher background part in the first half

There is an echo response in the high harmony which is part of the track.

23 ,un tema de amor toxico triste y profundo,bellamente interpretado por Pau con su voz desgarrada que te mueve el sentimiento,Pau es un maestro de la composición e interpretación ,Pau es un músico completo,un genio

Pau's song No doubt but, if you really focus on Dany as well, it's almost a Duet.! ⚡✌️🤟⚠️⚡ Rock On TW Army ⚡✌️🤟⚠️⚡

You are both correct, at first Dany does the higher notes then she switches to a lower note. Good ear 🌽👂 😁 great reaction as always 😊

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Thanks!

Mi Voz favorita del Rock de absolutamente todos los tiempos, tengo 49 años y vaya que he escuchado mucha música, nada como Pau.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

That’s awesome

Thats the first time I've seen someone mention Jen Ledger from SKILLET, when talking about Paulina. I wonder if they've ever listened to SKILLET and if Paulina has takin inspiration from her for her ability to sing while drumming. Although I've never seen Jen sing an entire song while drumming.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

I’m not sure. I haven’t listened to them in so long.

Yes, it does sound like a backing track of a falsetto (doesn't sound like Ale's falsetto though).

*23* *23* , like many of their songs, is left open to interpretation... some have speculated the title is for the year "2023" while others have thought it references someone's age... i was not sure but have come to see it as being about the year "2023" because that's when Pau turned 21 years old... the lyrics "barely old enough to drink" are fitting in many locales where 21 is the drinking age... in DPA/TW's home area, the drinking age is 18, IIRC... anyway, this is certainly a song about caring deeply for someone from afar, holding back, and then realizing that, in the future, they will meet that someone again... how they will handle their feelings and memories and what may possibly happen... then again, while it sounds personal, maybe this song is about something they might have read or seen in a movie or TV show... after all, their song *Amour* comes from a 15 second clip of a scene in the movie _"Ratatouille"_ ... that scene has the camera looking through a hole in the wooden floor... there are two characters down there having a fight... maybe a lover's quarrel? i don't remember... anyway, they are arguing, they suddenly hug each other, and it is done; end clip... there's also their song *Wildfire* which was inspired by _"The Hunger Games"_ movies... i think at least the 2nd one titled _"Catching Fire"_ ... DPA/TW have drawn inspiration from a lot of places... IRL, books, movies, games, etc 😹 this song has brought tears to many eyes... while being a powerful drummer, Pau is also a fantastic and very emotive singer... i don't go a day without hearing DPA/TW... they possess both, my heart and soul... TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA

Dany sang the high harmony in the early part of the song and the longer harmony in the last half of the song.

There is a polling for them at LOUDER rock song of the week. Sadly they are losing, please go vote.

@Emanon905

5 ай бұрын

It's unfortunate that The Warning is losing to such a mediocre song in the poll. Who knew that Goths would come out to vote? They're just edging out The Warning. Search "Louder Rock Song of the Week" to vote!

⚡THE WARNING⚡ 🤘

23 sort of represents Pau can legally drink anywhere. Because she turned 21 in 20 23

Dany started off with a higher harmony, then switched into a lower harmony later.

Dany will fluctuate from high falsetto in the 1st verse to lower harmony in the 2nd.

Queens of Rock! Survive, a song from their younger yrs. Do you recognize something in that song?

@ThunderRooster

4 ай бұрын

I’ll add it!

I think the baby wants to be in the video, too.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

You may be right lol

I just realized, you are filming in an Rv. Kitchen slideout behind you.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Yes we are! We have been traveling the country for over a year now.

The few times I have heard Ale as an adult. I think she may be the lower register you are hearing.

I understand that all three ladies exercise on treadmills and sing while they are running. Pau use to get winded playing so hard and singing but no longer.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

SMART!

You should check out the Ukrainian girl band “The Sixters” new song “Feels” they rock. They also just dropped a ballad but you should check out the Rock.

Hi. Can you please react to legendary Russian rock band Kino song Calm night? It's rock music masterpiece! You will be surprised so great music you never heard. Lot of bloggers from different countries really like this band and song. Now really interesting your reaction too. From album "Last hero".

⚡️TWA⚡️

My friends... The Warning and Michael Starr LIVE/ Highway to Hell please

Pau is built for ballads. Check out her solo piano cover of Creep by Radiohead. It's better than the original.

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Ohhh that would be sweet!

2:53 the head voice in back vocal is from Ale. Take a look at the video, Ale sings the lowest and highest notes ;) kzread.info/dash/bejne/ip6YlpN9lLWsY8Y.html&ab_channel=TheWarning

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Ohhhh

🤘🤘

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

🤘🏻🤘🏻

RE-UPLOAD?

rabbit hole

Pau actually has a higher vocal range than Dany.

Ale is the low voice

Dani higher

Oh shut up you talk dribble

Spelled her 3 letter name wrong?😮go far away dude

@ThunderRooster

5 ай бұрын

Thanks for pointing it out. It is corrected. Thanks for stopping by.