This scene feels so real. When the two soldiers win the close quarter firefight and then stop to eat amidst the battle it really shows you how starved/deprived they are - especially since that drive manifested in the middle of combat with heaps of adrenaline running through their bodies.

@Rambonii

Жыл бұрын

The trench was my least favorite part it seemed so stuipid to think that Kapp could survive doing his corner move recieving 3 shots that missed while standing still

@warbossgrotsmasha23

Жыл бұрын

i'm surprised they haven't went full cannibal mode with all that freshly killed meat around

@IamPatrickStar

Жыл бұрын

@@warbossgrotsmasha23 well granted, they’re covered with mud for being in the trenches for days weeks or months

@starsiegeRoks

Жыл бұрын

​​@@Rambonii it's harder than you think to aim a single-shot bolt-action rifle when your hands are shaking from fear and adrenaline. It's pretty much the entire reason we started inventing sub-machine guns and later Assault Rifles. Plus, it's a movie. Sometimes directors and writers and actors make decisions that are seen as mistakes (or mistakes seen as decisions).

@emperorconstantine1.361

Жыл бұрын

@@starsiegeRoksthe real mistake I think, unless Katt’s rifle seriously malfuncted, was after he shot, the bolt handle was upright! Holy shit!

this feels so real. hollywood would put some epic music over it

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

And give it a heroic high note ending.

@Holret

Жыл бұрын

and the main character wouldnt have a helmet on or anything to obstruct his facial features.

@internetstrangerstrangerofweb

Жыл бұрын

You can’t really criticize the Hollywood music part when honestly- the soundtrack in this movie leaves ALOT to be desired. It’s just this one electronic tone that makes it sound like some video game. The movie is great don’t get me wrong- but music’s role in conveying suspense, seriousness, etc. wasn’t utilized to its fullest extent here.

@-qj6ps

Жыл бұрын

@@internetstrangerstrangerofweb I agree the soundtrack was the worst part of this film. I really hate anachronistic music in movies

@mauriciobalderas3314

Жыл бұрын

Good thing this is a German movie

Wow the close combat in this scene is so gritty and real. The chaos, the smoke, artillery, the confusion, the soldiers shooting and stabbing each other at close range, checking around every corner for enemies. It truly does justice to what the troops on the ground must've seen 100+ years ago. However, no movie can portray the true horrors of war unless you've actually experienced it.

@lordlopikong6940

Жыл бұрын

You'll be disgusted and reluctant. But you'll never know the the biggest experience war can give, And that is fear

@lautermannsgrab1668

Жыл бұрын

Also Finger weg vom Krieg!

@Xyz_xyz712

Жыл бұрын

Imagine being one of the first soldiers to see a fucking tank for the first time man... I can’t imagine what went thru their heads at that time . WW1 ,WW2 and the whole Serbian hate with Bosnians in the 90s 3 of the worst wars I’ve read about

@lautermannsgrab1668

Жыл бұрын

@@Xyz_xyz712 Tja. Das war das traumatische Ur-Erlebnis des deutschen Militärs im Ersten Weltkrieg. "Der Feind hat ziemlich durchschlagkräftige Panzer an der Front, wir haben nur ein paar unbrauchbare Prototypen irgendwo in der Etappe." Das beobachtete auch der Gefreite Hitler. Er schwor sich, dass das in einem späteren Krieg nie mehr so laufen darf. An die Macht gelangt, rüstete er bald die deutsche Panzerwaffe auf. Diese war in der ersten Hälfte des Zweiten Weltkrieges die stärkste der Welt. Bis heute kann man sich die deutsche Besessenheit bzgl. dieser Waffengattung so erklären.

@user-qx7dr9hz1d

Жыл бұрын

Except for the infinite ammo hack Tjaden and Kat had

1:56 Every other movie would have the protagonist do one final blow or still have enemy desperately fighting back, but this film stops midway and shows a bloody hand move into frame begging for comfort. Every death in this film has impact and shows that these were people with lives, they aren't just plot devices.

@LopThighsLol

Жыл бұрын

The worst part in my eyes, is that the soldier is near silent. He's in too much pain and fear to even process crying out. It's gritty stuff.

@jaikee9477

Жыл бұрын

That little shot showing the face of that dying young French soldier was a masterstroke. You're not killing another anonymous body in a uniform, you are killing a WHOLE life full of hopes dreams, plans, wife, family, kids, relatives WIPED OUT like that.

@safe-keeper1042

Жыл бұрын

For real.

@metalbeaver6294

11 ай бұрын

Disagree, I've seen this plenty of times

@Sean-Johnson

8 ай бұрын

@@metalbeaver6294 What other movies did this, if I may ask?

So cool to actually see what happens when the soldiers actually reach the enemy trench, most movies never bother to depict it

@irishsaturday7577

Жыл бұрын

Normally the soldier we follow doesn't make it that far.

@whoknowswhocares885

Жыл бұрын

Mostly because the war tactics consisted of generals ordering their men to charge at machine gun fire.

@cattholic8257

Жыл бұрын

Probably because they barely made it to the trench most of the time

@AngloSaxonWheatFarmer

Жыл бұрын

Yeah because either theese raids succeeded amazingly or failed horribly, usually the latter

@user-yy7hn3zj5y

Жыл бұрын

К сожалению этого никто не знает, в живых мало кто остается после таких атак.

1:58 gets me the most, he's just another kid and is begging for mercy after being brutally attacked. The other guy that shot him put him out of his misery...

@Basedlocation

Жыл бұрын

How to make french toast 101

@ecervantesramirez

Жыл бұрын

@@Basedlocation that’s so messed up 😂😂😂

Felt so bad for the dude at 2:00 it’s probably true for most soldiers when they are fighting someone and feel bad before killing them and empathizing with the enemy

@pliskenx51mm83

Жыл бұрын

War is hell, he looked down and saw the enemy he was killing was another man around his age, 18 to 20ish maybe, basically a kid with his whole life ahead of him and just like that hes dead.

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

@@pliskenx51mm83 and killed badly at that.

@pliskenx51mm83

Жыл бұрын

@@johnnyringo3871 at least it was a headshot that killed him in the end

@Layerlol

Жыл бұрын

@@pliskenx51mm83 Yeah, The kid was given a mercy kill

@Layerlol

Жыл бұрын

The worst part about it all is that you lose your life in those trenches and the battle just keep going on, nobody cares or even remembers your name, just another Soldier dead on the battlefield

That’s how my dad got to school

@Gameprojordan

Жыл бұрын

No man's land? More like no man's hill! both ways! In the snow!

@madmatt1414

Жыл бұрын

show some respect.

@Layerlol

Жыл бұрын

Nah chill with this comment.. Respect.

@yehohnathanherrera1779

Жыл бұрын

Distasteful comment.

@TheMylittletony

Жыл бұрын

uphill both ways!

2:13 onwards is arguably one of my favourite fight scenes from any military movie

@IMN602

Жыл бұрын

Those slow bolt action rifles made things interesting lol

@tgs12495

Жыл бұрын

Dynamic duo

@ricklopez8431

Жыл бұрын

​@IMN602 When it's a G98 vs Lebel 1886, I think the G98 had the advantage since the Lebel was older and had to be reloaded individually through the side.

@michaelmilian4336

Жыл бұрын

Best squad in the lobby

@BrycetheHaloLord

Жыл бұрын

@@ricklopez8431 The lebel had a tube magazine.

1:38 I can't imagine how painful that had to be

@Eusoik

8 ай бұрын

Yup, one thing that scared me the most about the Great War is being stabbed by a bayonet, I can't imagine how painful that must be.

@WalkingTaco187

6 ай бұрын

​@@Eusoikimagine that this dude actually killed Paul 1:41

Damn the attention to detail in this scene is pretty damn good. When that explosion went off and the soldier in front of Paul fell over you can actually see his jaw very faintly getting hurdled into the air before Paul even knows his face got blown off.

@Courierman6

Жыл бұрын

HOLY SHIT

@SOC675

Жыл бұрын

Time?

@olegslapins8156

Жыл бұрын

When I was a kid I read that particular part(about the jaw) from the book. Closed it and never touched it again.

@internetstrangerstrangerofweb

Жыл бұрын

Ironic. He used his voice to convince countless men to gleefully march to their deaths, and in the end he lost the ability to speak. Just like Robespierre.

@SOC675

Жыл бұрын

@@internetstrangerstrangerofweb poetic

2:13, 2:26 This is why the Submachine gun was invented

The shot ar 0:38 is in my opinion is one of the best I've seen in a war film. The horde of Germans coming out of the smoke about 100 yards away and the Hotchkiss gun crew trying desperately to stop them. Spooky stuff.

@sachab3854

Жыл бұрын

It's like something you'd see out of a horror movie

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

@@sachab3854 I think you could argue that this *IS* a horror movie.

@dimidas2580

Жыл бұрын

It’s hell on Earth

@Hankeshon

Жыл бұрын

its heartbreaking too because you can hear the cries of pain or shock of them being mowed down in the distance.

@tgs12495

Жыл бұрын

Especially with the red mist

I woulda taken that dead officers pistol ( 0:26 ) in a trench fight where everyone is using bolt action rifles, an auto-loading pistol that you can get multiple shots off with quickly comes in handy big time. In the same time it’d take him to get two shots off with the Mauser, he could have gotten at least 4-5 shots off with the pistol and in a trench fight where you’re facing multiple enemies who are really close to you, that can really make the difference between you either getting shot/bayoneted/bludgeoned or making it back out of that trench alive…

@TheVampyr

11 ай бұрын

Only German officers, nco’s, and Stormtroop units (towards the end of WWI) were issued sidearms. If Paul took that Luger, and some officer or nco caught him with that, he would have been shot for looting. If it wasn’t issued to you, it’s not yours. German’s are sticklers for the rules.

0:42 Looks like the smoke on the battle field is turning red from the blood splatter.

@Bmt791

Жыл бұрын

That little detail just sums up the insanity of this

1:25 that was a full on mercy killing, even if Paul didnt intend it to be a mercy killing and was killing out of percieved necessity to survive, he actually saved that dude from dying of either blood loss, or if he was "lucky" enough to find a medical tent, guaranteed infection.

@user-cf3ld8nl6x

3 күн бұрын

Согласен. Да, в те времена антибиотиков небыло еще... и о витаминах не знали. Т.ч. тогда шанс умереть от сепсиса был очень велик. Считай любое ранение в тело - смерть.

Such good detail in this scene. Around 40 or so seconds in, you can see about 4 or 5 soldiers catch a burst of machine gun fire and drop in unison. Small detail 👌

@antonkrieg3708

Жыл бұрын

Right before Paul splashes into the water. Yep I caught that too.

My favorite combat sequence in this movie

At 1:27, the French soldier on the ground has both his legs blown off and very briefly begs for his life before Paul shoots him. It’s so ruthless and emphasizes just how inhumane of a war this really was.

@3VVK

11 ай бұрын

Is there humane war?

@Courierman6

11 ай бұрын

all in all Paul probably did him a favor. Had he not shot him that dude would have had an agonizing death

@Sean-Johnson

9 ай бұрын

@@Courierman6 Or if he was lucky to find a medical tent, guaranteed infection.

This was a fabulous movie

2:22 the rifle shoots while the bolt is open.

2:19 the Gewher 98 is the perfect rifle for home defense. Works perfectly in a “hallway” type area 😂

@theodorebennett7938

Жыл бұрын

Ain't nothin better to clear a room with than the old G98. 😀😂

@mulkanmulkan5620

Жыл бұрын

@@theodorebennett7938 you don't need shoot twice to make somebody dead

@GranitWall

Жыл бұрын

They didnt have a better gun at that time.

@jaybeeonyt

Жыл бұрын

​​​@@GranitWall K98 Az carbine's existed which were better for use within trenches due to their smaller size.

19th century tactics vs. 20th century weapons. Nuts.

You can tell Kat and Tjaden had fought along side each other quite a bit

J'ai rarement vu un film de guerre qui semble à ce point réaliste. J'ai conservé une relique de mon arrière grand-père sur lequel il a gravé ses "souvenirs terribles" de ce conflit, 1915-1917. Pauvres hommes.

@Maxijuno

6 ай бұрын

Oui mais nous la suisse ont a été neutre les deux conflits

this movie needs to win some serious awards this year. Personally i hoped for the best sound award but winning the best cinematography and score awards is a huge success !

@DonDDimma

7 ай бұрын

I believe it won an oscar

First entry point of embarkment:- trinidad drifting Second Point All quiet on western front

The fact that the Germans managed to push through is terrifying. Just the amount of death that occurs on each side is gut-wrenching. Suddenly the Germans stopped getting gunned down and started overrunning the French- it is total chaos at each point.

Parents: awww, he’s playing with his little legos 😊 Our imagination: 1:25

My grandfather William, was there. He was born in 1887, italian front, Alpini Fiamme Verdi. He runned on those battlefields. Rip. MV

This was the most intense war movie I`ve ever seen...

I just read the book... And I cried sometimes of feeling meaningless and that this horror is so near.

1:27 Probably did that fellow a favor.

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, if he were to survive losing both legs back then, he would be going home to find a complete lack of compassion for his circumstances as well as his sacrifice. People were very cruel back then.

@keyabrade1861

Жыл бұрын

@@johnnyringo3871 Indeed: most people, as far as I know, think that people haven't necessarily become less cruel since then, it's probably true that they have. The relatively poor diets, rampant smoking, much less-advanced medical and food preparation technology, somewhat less-advanced sanitation, less common vaccines, lack of modern understanding of mental illnesses, and prevalence of arsenic, lead, asbestos, radium, and leaded gasoline back then almost certainly meant that many more people back then were mentally fucked-up and took it out on others than there are today. It's just that, today, we can see it all due to social/mass media, which means that mental illnesses and sociopathic people _seem_ to be more common.

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

@@keyabrade1861 back then in England and Germany (I can't speak for France) lots of businesses wouldn't hire veterans (wounded or not) and there was next to nothing in terms of veterans benefits. They served their purpose and now the people want them out of the way.

The French Solider Paul shoots at 1:26 was scared shitless knowing he was going to die.. I can't even imagine being in a situation like that knowing you're about to lose your life from a shot to the face

@therant311

Жыл бұрын

Well, he had no legs

@Layerlol

Жыл бұрын

@@therant311 I'm aware of that but some people would still want to keep their lives despite the fact, you can hear the subtle fear in his subtle scream before that bullet went through his face

@HITBnn

11 ай бұрын

Why did he shoot him tho ?

@Layerlol

11 ай бұрын

@@HITBnn Because he was the enemy, Unfortunately in war good men die

@depositenmeamibcp

4 ай бұрын

@@HITBnn That man would have been killed by infection due to open wounds and shrapnel caused by the explosion that blew off his legs

It’s like they’re on a different planet

Dude used an anti-tank grenade on grunts in the trenches. No wonder he ran out of cover so quickly after the explosion, and no wonder theres so many soldiers missing legs when he does. Shits powerful

Close combat with bolt actions is a form of anxiety i dont want.

the actors must have had so much fun lol

@WalkingTaco187

6 ай бұрын

No because in the interviews they said they felt real fear with the acting because their set were real trenches

We have taken objective butter

although the french beg for mercy to not kill them if they are injured in combat, it is a high chance that they won't make it, the trench is muddy as hell, the qualities there can easily get the wound infected. the man at 2:00 looks too wounded to even continue, even if he was able to figt, the wounds would most likely get infected, even more likely since this was a raid and their wounds wont be treated unless the trench is captured in five minutes. if you say "omg germans are so bad they literally shot a man begging to not kill them!" in the midst of the confusion, everyone that isn't one of your comrades is shot, and there is no time to stop and think about this, you have to believe around every corner, is a man with a rifle aiming to you, and you can't stop to think otherwise one might just pop out and nail you on the spot.

@Hankeshon

Жыл бұрын

well said

@Stupidfaes

Жыл бұрын

British commonwealth troops executed wounded quite often too. After this war the Hague convention was made, which brought about the laws of war

@SokarVision

10 күн бұрын

Lets just say that a soldier with an infected wound somehow does make it out alive and makes it to a medical tent. They'll still suffer from the pain of amputation just to ''Recover'' and die later on another battlefield. Also anyone yapping about people being killed in a literal WAR needs to just stfu

@user-cf3ld8nl6x

3 күн бұрын

@@SokarVision Вы забыли что тогда антибиотиков небыло.... Вы книгу кстати не читали? Так вот, там их друг умер от простого ранения в ногу.

Ww1 was hell on earth for soldiers

I'm just glad you all can see my POV when playing on St. Quentin Scar with no-hud...

2:22- th bolt is not even closed yet

saw tis movie yesterday, it was actually pretty good..

The scariest part about this, is that this is arguably the least fucked up scene in the movie, and is relatively tame compared to the horrors described in the book.

I saw this in the cinima instead of on Netflix for free and it was the best decision I ever made. The entire ordeal was just deafening

I once got my hands on a ww1 iron cross 2nd class. Only the thought it had actually seen something like that gave me goosebumps.

Hats down to the camera man

I think this movie made me appreciate the veterans of ww1 even more, do you know what kinda of balls it takes for you to run into fire with a gun that reloads for 2 mins. Going up against a tank and lmg with just a rifle. You really earned your stripes coming home from that.

@Celestial1000

7 ай бұрын

Who cares about stripes and medals ???

@TransoceanicOutreach

6 ай бұрын

9/10 soldiers in WW1 never saw the enemy unless they were prisoners of war.

In war, there's no time for words.

I think this movie shows a good representation of what war is like. but you can never depict war unless you have experience

1:26 the enemy was already heavily wounded and hold his hand up begging for mercy.

The German Attack, also known as the German Offensive, was a significant military operation conducted by the German Empire during World War I. It specifically refers to the series of attacks launched by the Germans on the Western Front in 1918. After years of stalemate and trench warfare, the German High Command planned a major offensive in an attempt to break the deadlock. The operation was called Operation Michael and began on March 21, 1918. The German Attack aimed to achieve a decisive victory by launching a massive assault on the British and French forces, hoping to drive them back and force them to surrender. The offensive was initially successful, catching the Allies off guard and pushing them back several kilometers. However, the German advance eventually slowed down due to logistical issues and overstretched supply lines. The Allied forces regrouped, and with the arrival of American troops, they were able to mount a successful defense. The Battle of Amiens, which took place from August 8 to 11, 1918, marked a turning point in the German Offensive. The Allies launched a surprise attack, employing innovative tactics such as the use of tanks and aircraft. The battle resulted in a significant loss for the Germans, and their offensive momentum was halted. The German Attack and subsequent battles, depicted in Erich Maria Remarque's novel "All Quiet on the Western Front," highlight the brutal realities of warfare. The novel portrays the experiences of German soldiers on the Western Front, capturing the horrors, futility, and dehumanizing effects of war. Overall, the German Attack was a critical phase of World War I, but despite initial success, it ultimately failed to achieve its objectives. The German offensive was eventually pushed back, leading to the eventual Allied victory and the end of the war.

Everybody dies in the war The main character: yall dead

1:16

@WhyMySisterkeepdoingthis

Жыл бұрын

Dude show some respect for him

I watched this movie two nights ago, while this version takes place in 1917 - it deserves all 7 Oscars it's nominated for - all on a 20 million dollar budget. iPhone cameras and Samsung ones - just a guess, cut down on production costs.

My hype for the track meet lol

I wonder what Schofield was up to during this.. Sad Fact: Blake is already dead from the stabbing of the German pilot during this time.

@Courierman6

Жыл бұрын

Scofield is probably dead from the Spanish flu after he put his hand in that dead germen when crossing no man's land

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

Probably also KIA. It's the logical deduction, or severely wounded.

@Layerlol

Жыл бұрын

@@johnnyringo3871 Maybe illness got him from the wound he had on his hand too especially when he accidentally put it inside the dead solider

@nepnepguythegreatestofall6032

Жыл бұрын

Part of me thinks that all WW1 movies are somehow connected into this one giant cinematic universe. War Horse, 1917, All Quiet on the Western Front, Gallipoli, The Light Horsemen, The Trench, Beneath Hill 60, etc. Nonsense it is, but it makes me laugh just thinking about it

@mcsquilliams7044

11 ай бұрын

Dr who showed up and took him to australia under the name ned kelly

The Actors are brilliant.

Impresionante.

Jesus I've watched this scene a hundred times but I didn't realize until just now that when he turns his platoon leader over after he goes down you can hear him still barely alive choking on his blood. I always thought he just got instantly taken out by the explosion.

How Paul was hesitant to finish the French soldier really showed how they’re still human but in desperate times humans can turn to animals.

This didn’t actually happen all the time, there were places where there were no offensives for years, and even if there was an attack, mostly not even one soldier made it to the enemy trench. But it’s a damn f. Good movie

@Iwanwahid1969

Жыл бұрын

i cant imagine it happening all the time since the number of casualties that can occur in a single wave is ridiculously high.

@nextube_owner

Жыл бұрын

Yeah that’s right there were barely any soldiers who managed to cross no man’s land

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

@@Iwanwahid1969 there is a phrase commonly used to describe the French soldiers, but realistically it can also describe British, German, Russian, Austrian and especially Italian soldiers; "they were lions under the command of donkeys." The men of every army were gallant and determined to succeed. Their officers by contrast (especially the senior officers) were mostly clout chasers, trying to score political or career points off the backs of their men by launching often hopeless offensives or refusing to allow their men to retreat in the face of unstoppable attacks. But that's just how "Important" people conduct themselves.

@fCyka

Жыл бұрын

@@Iwanwahid1969 search for the numbers on the western front theyre surreal hundreds dying on both sides

@BoPrivateFC

Жыл бұрын

nah, that's a common view of trench warfare but a generally incorrect one. taking the first few trench lines wasn't the hardest part of an attack, holding them against enemy counterattacks was. no man's land provided cover for attacking soldiers (who generally did not sprint at machine guns, but moved from cover to cover in squads and used suppressing fire), but it was extremely difficult to move supplies and heavy weapons up through the mud. meanwhile, the defenders had prepared supply routes (communication trenches and railways), artillery dug-in out of the enemy's range, and a bunch of other advantages to retake the lost trenches.

2:44 Jesus, this poor French soldier still be killed even he begged for mercy in German Language

@uncle7215

Жыл бұрын

He wasn’t speaking German. He said in french “Putain, putain, Non!” (Fuck, fuck, no!)

@Hankeshon

Жыл бұрын

@@uncle7215 i thought he said "bitte, bitte" in german as if that was the only german he knew and then said "non" in his own language before getting shot

@uncle7215

Жыл бұрын

@@Hankeshon no, as a French i can confirm that he definitely says Putain

@Hankeshon

Жыл бұрын

@@uncle7215 thats still really sad

@plantpreyer2135

Жыл бұрын

no he spoke french

2:22 My man fires with an open bolt and unchambered round.

@aoimidori1237

Жыл бұрын

Quick rechambering shot lol

I find it a bit weird when that guy :18 died when a artillery hit like a bit away from him but when artillery hit Paul right at his feet all that happened was he got flown into the air and he was fine.

@Courierman6

Жыл бұрын

Well you see paul had plot armor witch makes you invincible FOR A WHILE

@guardianangel7047

Жыл бұрын

@Paul Baumer lol thanks for replying, Mr. Paul Baumer himself.

@Hankeshon

Жыл бұрын

it was a dud shell. it hit the dirt and sent earth flying up with tremendous force but the shrapnel mustve not exploded. they said 30 percent of shells in ww1 were duds.

@carlosandleon

Жыл бұрын

Paul was probably hit by a mortar, not an artillery shell

@tobeslmao

15 күн бұрын

It was a dud

Question, what was the deal with the German soldier with the Luger, was he an NCO or something, I have a full uniform but also have a Luger and Luger holster and would like to know what rank or whatever that soldier was

My dad traveled to Ohio to the western front to ww2 to north dokata to United States to home to school

Paul could've saved Hitler's life, probably not, but like imagine how crazy that would be.

@thelordofthelostbraincells

Ай бұрын

Isn't that what a real soldier said? I remember seeing something about how a ww1 soldier saved this "random man" only to realize years later that man he saved was the man would would start the seconds world war. That's crazy to think of what kinda person can become an absolute monster

@JosephSvigos

Ай бұрын

I don’t know if you’re talking about what I’m about to say but, I remember hearing about a WW1 British soldier who was about to shoot Hitler, but he couldn’t do it since he’d already killed so many people.

This was Hitlers origin story

@wsam.1984

Жыл бұрын

Except there was no mention of hitler in this movie and not even anything mentioned about him the entire movie. But people like you only remember ww1 as "hitlers origin story"

@RytheCodplayer

Жыл бұрын

Hitler actually said that WW1 was “the best time of his life” should give a pretty clear picture of how psychotic he was

@cattholic8257

Жыл бұрын

@@wsam.1984 would you like some extra salt to rub in those wounds

@pliskenx51mm83

Жыл бұрын

@@wsam.1984 Well one can't deny that Hitler, did indeed, participate and fight in WW1. That doesn't make all of WW1 about Hitler, but its also silly and inaccurate to forget or over look that Hitler was in WW1.

@azukiants

Жыл бұрын

@@wsam.1984 he means that by that this was ww1, and that hitler fought in it and went through it like the actors portraying the film, only idiots see ww1 as hitlers origin story.

So many men being mowed down at once and pink cloud formed from all the blood in the air.

I wonder how much friendly fire there was. Exhausted, sleep deprived, and extremely stressed.

2:24 why did the soldier pull his comrade back as if to say " ill go first" I get that soldiers will take turns of "going first" but why in this scene ? Im thinking its because the french soldier was trying to lure them into an ambush and the first soldier never relised ? Thoughts anyone ?

It was like John wick 1916

@wsam.1984

Жыл бұрын

Except there was no flashy music, super human abilities and Paul didn't kill over 20 "bad guys" in a row.

The officer leading the assault who gets his face blown off, was that this films adaptation of the LT. from the 1979 rendition?

This video got 3 thousand likes. In ww1 thousands of lives would have to be lost each day. That means everybody who liked would probably lose their lives if they fought in ww1

Love this interpretation of the show. Just wish the music was more… fitting for the time period. Would’ve added more weight.

@-qj6ps

Жыл бұрын

100% agree. Anachronistic music ruins the mood.

@germenman

Жыл бұрын

Nah it just sucked get some actual fuckin taste🤣🤣🤣

Makeup department on this movie was something else

damn this movie was freaking good

@germenman

Жыл бұрын

Nah it sucked your opionion is trash

@gorebox_guy

Жыл бұрын

@@germenman it's an anti war flim bruh

@gorebox_guy

Жыл бұрын

@@germenman so you German and get offended this movie is by Germans bro it's not mean to be hate on Germans is an anti war flim

The Germans revised their tactics. The Soviets tried this again 25 years later, often without guns.

Imagine, running out in the cold of the battlefield, from the trenches into No Man’s Land. Feet feeling wet and soggy, running forward across uneven scared land. Others collapsing from the endless fray of fire from the opposition. Moving with the rifle, taking the aim into the nothingness that might hit something in the sheer chaos, getting up and moving. Mud in the boots, tired with adrenaline, diving into the opposition’s trench to bring them down with the bayonet if you don’t get it yourself. To somehow make the run back across No Man’s Land with the company of men who did their duty to. To escape the possible bullet with your name on it as you run back into your trench from the long haul across. Happy to live until you turn back, and see the repeat. The opposition doing the same. As the Allied machine gun posts start firing. The Allies are on the defensive, the opposition is on the offensive. If you live through this day, there is tomorrow. But as you take aim at the one man running across the scared desolate land of No Man’s Land, you sight in as the front of German men run closer, Allied machine guns on overtime pushing the fray of bullets towards of front of men. Not one man from either side actually WANTS to be out there, rather just taking the orders, from the leaders, for most aren’t doing the “dirty work”. -Absolute respect to the men who survived who survived to tell the tale. From either side, pre-WW2. This was carnage to the most extreme no modern action movie can capture, yet this was truly real as well as surreal. Yet, what is happening in the modern battlefields of Europe in Ukraine with Russia right now in 2023, this has become the Chapter 3 of humanity’s World Wars. World War 1 was Chapter 1 110+ years ago, the American Civil War was just the Prologue. God help us. 🇺🇸

@ameyagnihotri1117

6 ай бұрын

Great comment. I want to say that both sides should came together and decide that no more frontal assaults. The frontal assaults are simply mass suicides and nothing else.

So much adrenaline and blood pumping, but they're so hungry that they stop everything just to eat in peace

the lack of semi automatic or even automatic weapons in that time..., making assaulting trench a ridiculous task to do

imagine surviving a charge through no man's land only to get killed by a guy with a shovel or whacked in the head with a truncheon

*Me On My School During Section Wars*

This movie is actually banned in germany

Ninguna película, ninguna (quizá se salva stoortruppen 1917, realizada en 1934) muestra realmente como era un verdadero asalto. En realidad, la masa de alambradas tenía docenas de metros de espesor, delante de las trincheras de primera línea; entre esas enormes masas, había estrechos pasillos libres para poder salir de la trinchera para atacar. Por eso, cualquier ataque contra una trinchera, iba precedido de gigantescos bombardeos de artillería, que no eran para aniquilar a los defensores (ocultos en los refugios subterráneos) sino para destruir esa masa de alambradas. Una vez destruidas, el terreno cercano a las trincheras era un paisaje lleno de embudos y cráteres; el asalto siempre iba precedido por tiro de artillería propia, esta vez de cobertura. Es decir, la artillería disparaba salvas de humo, unos 300 metros por delante de los atacantes, y a medida que avanzaban. Esto impedía que los defensores los vieran, y se disparaba a ciegas. En cabeza siempre iban zapadores de asalto; su misión era volar los restos de alambradas que quedasen, con pértigas explosivas, que introducían bajo las alambradas y que al explotar, dejaban un pasillo libre. Los zapadores ponían marcas para conducir al rebaño humano de infantes por esos pasillos, evitando cráteres y alambradas. A 50 metros de la trinchera, todos los atacantes preparaban granadas y sin dejar de correr las arrojaban: eran cientos de granadas a la vez, sobre la trinchera. Los defensores disparaban completamente a ciegas, por el humo de cobertura; solo a 100 metros, y detenidos por los embudos del suelo y los restos de alambradas, se hacían visibles los atacantes, y solo tenían el tiempo en que los atacantes cubrían 50 metros más, para abatirlos, porque luego les caía esa lluvia de granadas. Por supuesto, la artillería propia, cerrando las trincheras por delante, y los disparos masivos a ciegas, derribaban a gran número de atacantes, pero sin precisión, solo por saturación de fuego. En realidad, era más duro y salvaje que en el cine, pero esa falta de visibilidad impediría rodar buenas escenas, y se falsea.

@pixulasuelta

Жыл бұрын

La película sólo fue hecha como a fin de entretener he informar no como un documental

intense battle scene and good movie. yesterday it won best international film in the oscars 2023, but compared to the older versions, i dont like some of the changes they made.

@germenman

Жыл бұрын

How did you like such a shtty movie you need get better taste

@EnkaMexi

Жыл бұрын

@@germenman Like what movie?

@germenman

Жыл бұрын

@@EnkaMexi 2022 aqontwf

@EnkaMexi

Жыл бұрын

@@germenman aqontwf? i dont know that movie

All these people just living the moment...no walking zombies on their phone, no facebook, no instagram....this feels so real.

1:41 this part is kinda sad bc its underated and no one talks about

@warstoriesinkino

6 ай бұрын

Thank you for your interest, please subscribe to the channel too 🙂

@khangphan4863

5 ай бұрын

Yes, it demonstrated that War made Paul from an innocent boy become a killer , he is no longer afraid of killing ppl ( but after that scene ,he regrets killing a French soldier .)

When you're parents tell you how they got to school back in their day.

The only way this wasnt real enough is that the gun fire and artillery isnt heavy enough with enough people just exploding. But only because you probably couldnt hear or see what was happening.

CQB before CQB

For Germany to have won first instead of invading France, Germany should have invaded Russia first and only protect the border with France using trenches for that there Germany It could move forward in Russia as it would take a long time for Russia to move its troops months go by and Germany dominates more and more territories in the Russian empire Then after having defeated Russia, then yes, Germany could focus all its forces on France, another thing that should have changed is that the Hungarian stars should have given that territory to For Italy, I think, yes, Germany would be able to win a partnership treaty, so Germany would annex several territories, it would take 1/3 of Africa, it would take several territories in France would annex Belgium colony Lithuania Estonia Latvia Poland Belarus Ukraine and Finland would become German-influenced vassal states Now austria hungary would annex serbia and montenegro but actually using their hungarian was in a dire situation i bet they would last until the 30's until the empire fell to the ottomans Azerbaijan Armenia Georgia It would become a vassal of the Roman Empire in addition to taking almost the entire Middle East and that's all Russia was most screwed in this war, which basically lost a lot of territories to Germany And for the Ottoman Empire the United Kingdom was also going to get screwed together with France they should pay very high reparations to Germany we would probably see an independent India soon in the 30's and an independent India would probably roll a second column from Paris in France after the great depression and the German empire being the greatest world power the United States with the Its big defeat would be more isolationist along with the Russian empire too, tomorrow it would help in the Russian civil war and probably the whites would win because the German empire and there were the Bolsheviks as a risk to the empire and yes the empire of Brazil was going to come back

@jesontjowari9723

Жыл бұрын

That was the plan and.... Russia actually defeated by Germany in WW1. The problem was that all of Germany's allies (Austria, Ottomans, etc.) were losing.

you cut the scene off at the best part where they start munching on all that food.

WWI

This was my favorite part of the movie watching two friends go in and surviving with eatch other to think they’d would have Ben dead along time ago if it for them staying together

I know all soldiers promised to come back home with they're family 🙁

@johnnyringo3871

Жыл бұрын

"The War will be over by Christmas..."

Move name

How to make french toast 101