Story of the Subcontinent with Dr. Ishtiaq: kzread.info/dash/bejne/l6WY1pKtgpy5e8o.html

@raviinder6406

9 ай бұрын

Abbas bhai , Jaranwala tehsil ke Banga me Shaheed Bhagat Singh paida hua tha . Usski likhi , boli baaton par show bhi ho jaye tu bahut asha hoga .🙏

@user-lv2cr1nh4u

9 ай бұрын

Jnnah is the hero of India/indians.Had there been no Jinnah today entire india would have become a beggar bankrupt terror state.Every indian should sing this song E JINNAH TERA INDIA/INDIANS PE EHSAN HAI EHSAN.

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

@ahmedhaseeb3367

9 ай бұрын

اسلا م علیکم عبا س آپ کا بیا نیا کیا ھے پا کستا ن کو ختم ھو جا نا چھے اور بھا رت کے سا تھ مل جا نا چھیے یا کچھ اور

@gigachad_6862

9 ай бұрын

Very good discussion !!

My grandfather got land in Indian Punjab due to abolishment of zamindari system. Rule was One jodi Ox can ploug 25 acre land so who ever had 1 jodi OX gets 25 acre land. My grandfather had 4 Jodi Ox so he get 100 acre but majority got 25 acre land in our area. The zamindar had 5000 + acre land😅 that he had to transfer 😅 Now my all cousins r millionaires local level politicians, businesses, most of us have master degrees few r Mphil and Phds. We r also in India UK canada Usa and Australia too. If zamindari system would be in India. I would be working under zamindar while taking care of his horses and buffalos😅

@Gappasappa

9 ай бұрын

Add the natural entrepreneurship of the Punjabi 😂😂

@maneesh77

9 ай бұрын

Not just the economic development, but the distribution of land and reforms had a strong hand in strengthening Democracy in India. It greatly reduced the powers of the local "influencers" of the time, made people be invested in the development in the area and country and made people realize that they had the control of their affairs.

@yasirawan1069

9 ай бұрын

یہی۔ چیز پاکستان میں بھی ہو جاتی کاش

@Pinto_555

9 ай бұрын

great post...but the abolition was not carried to the full extent. We still have the Rajahs and Nawabs still holding on to their titles and vast wealth. This is unacceptable. The Pataudis for example who are pure entertainers these days are kowtowed as Nawabs. These Nawabs took full advantage of Partition. The ones that would not inherit much left for Pakistan and acquired responsible titles, which the families of nawabs of Rampur, Pataudi and dozens of others did. Hence, we have Gen Insfandyar Ali Khan as chief of ISI, and before him Gen Yakub Khan and Pak c in ci while the Mansur Ali Khans stayed back with full titles and wealth. The abolition was half baked in my opinion.

@gigachad_6862

7 ай бұрын

@@Pinto_555 Even Sikh king descendents have bns of dollars property in Indian punjab. All kings property had to be taken in custody of Government of India but as at that time India was dependent on British so they had to provide concessions to these 500 royal families. Yet majority of big landlords had to give away big chunk of land to the working class so it was a good decision. Most of these royals r loosing or had already lost their wealth and living in depression. Yet few had survived who had political connections or who went into hotel industry and business.

Issue of minority will never get resolved in India even after partition if full population exchange will not take place. - B R Ambedkar

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@srinivaskumar232

9 ай бұрын

True

@Striker-jg9kv

9 ай бұрын

Arey toh rape jihad me convert hue begairat behaya mughaliya musalminas ka halala kar karke ghazwa i hind ka sapna kaise poora honga , inshallah mashallah 72 hijabi musalminas ka dalla Allah tallah 😂😂😂

@hshankar592

9 ай бұрын

True

@blackrockorange

9 ай бұрын

Dr Ambedkar knew a lot more than Moulana.

Muslim politics is gangster way of politics.- B R Ambedkar/Pakistan or The Partition of India

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@Striker-jg9kv

9 ай бұрын

​@@md.shaghilsubhani.1639why rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool, why not read about what br Ambedkar jad to day about ur 6 year old 72 hijabi musalminas ka dalla Randi-allah tallah 😂😂😂

@Striker-jg9kv

9 ай бұрын

​@@md.shaghilsubhani.1639abey randikhana madrassa me apni islam se bhari ghazi haji namazi aashiq gay rasool pichwada shake shake it karke apne gando mulla ko khush karne wale ganduudin namazi, kabhi marwane ki jagah apna quraand bhi padh le jisko tere asli abba jija ambedkar ne tumhare abbu ki salwari laudadaar oichwade me ghusa kar gaali di thi

@Striker-jg9kv

9 ай бұрын

Arab Turk Irani Afghans ki teri begairat behaya ghasti halala chudai ki deewani converted musalmina ammi khala behen se hue rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool Muslim salwari hijde​@@md.shaghilsubhani.1639😂😂😂

@ShamshersSingh

9 ай бұрын

@@md.shaghilsubhani.1639 or islaam ko ek terrorist religion Jo sirf inshaanityat ka ktal ker ke dusro ko kafir kafir ghardan kaate h ... Or aaj puri duniya islaam pe thok rhai h Hindu God ki uper koi thook nahi rha h Whai islaam or Mohammed ko sab Gali De rhai h ...hala jihaadi atankwadi madras chap pthar baaj

You mentioned one 22 years old Muslim cleric was killed but you deliberately did not mention that 6 Hindus were killed before that in current Mewat riots.

@Redninja-ui9yp

9 ай бұрын

Ese hi toh Pakistan bna hai

@sanjaychoudhary6822

8 ай бұрын

Right

@hammadraza9255

8 ай бұрын

"Beghairati" on it's peak. You people are either dumb or ignorant, Where is mewat and where is gurgaon !!! Did that imam kill people !!!?

@r.k3261

8 ай бұрын

Pappu bajrangi monu Manesar yaad hai andhbhakto

@explorer7913

3 ай бұрын

RSS terrorist organisation kaun pal raha hai tum lindu log

I am also making a prediction here that if muslims keep on behaving like this they are soon going to face severe problems in Europe and America .Hindu muslim tension in India is not Pakistan specific but due to same muslim attitude with which they are so fixated world wide.

@dharmascan

9 ай бұрын

Prediction. Bariya!

@snathan3198

9 ай бұрын

They can't live with anyone including themselves.

@sarabjitbaidwan9658

9 ай бұрын

Right

@mukundha7621

9 ай бұрын

Islam is theocratic the problem is most Muslims deny these

@Pork393

9 ай бұрын

Muslims r not liked anywhere in the world! Asky why?

With the spread of social media, the Hindus have started understanding the muslims philosophy, teachings and doctrines. The Muslims called it Hindu nationalism . Now they have understood about the partition of India with the two nation theory and guilty persons of partition, so what is wrong with it .

@Gappasappa

9 ай бұрын

Hindus are an open minded society 👍👍

@snathan3198

9 ай бұрын

this fellow literally wants the appeasement policy of Khangress party to continue. He is the modern day Jinnah. He loves the barbaric invaders and justifies Jazia. He is no friend of Hindus or Bharat.

@samiazaffar7096

9 ай бұрын

I have got some Hindu friends and they really don’t know much about Islam. They don’t mix up with them in India. N ow they have started understanding Islam.

@majorconfucius3937

9 ай бұрын

Very well said

@AKumar-co7oe

9 ай бұрын

@@samiazaffar7096 Now that Hindus are understanding just how violent and hateful islam is towards non-muslims, hindus are being called 'radicals'.

I'm #RSS youth City Head of Chhattisgarh(INDIA) and my Friend circle has been mostly consisting Muslims and we all pity and laugh at #Pakistani muslims when they point at RSS for every Chaos happening in their Artificial nation😂

@KF-786

9 ай бұрын

Listen to Ravish Kumar to learn the reality of Muslims in India. Stop your propaganda.

@hunk3891

9 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂 zimmi ka Matlab jaante ho? Puchlena

@herosingh1765

9 ай бұрын

@@hunk3891 Mithun chakrabati 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣

@hunk3891

9 ай бұрын

@@herosingh1765 uske hisab se😂😂

@ramizkhan4405

9 ай бұрын

@@hunk3891Zimmii nahi hota zammi hota hai chutye

This is another amazing gem by Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed.

@a2d2charlie13

9 ай бұрын

paaji...science hu akbar

@rajendrawandhare9114

9 ай бұрын

Haris bhai, he said 1 cleric was killed, but he didn't mentioned in same Incident in Haryana 5 Hindus were shot or stone pelted to death.

@hshankar592

9 ай бұрын

True

@rahulsharmavds1781

9 ай бұрын

Kya haal hai haris bhai ☺ Kese hain aap

@Rishi6901

9 ай бұрын

Mujhe sahi me nhi lgta tha Pakistan me pdha hua koi Profesoor aisi soch rakh sakta. He's truely gem for Pakistan. Baaki jo faltu k scholar jo apna DNA define krti rhti phle bs unko hi dekha tha. We want a reaction video on some clips of this podcast.

Malana Azad is worthy of abuse. He sent the list of all Moghul creations to be included in the list of world heritage sites. But the world heritage council had to persuade him to include, Ajanta, Ellora & many other antiquities of Indian heritage for inclusion. These sites were completely ignored & suffered heavy damage because very little staff was appointed to defend them. It was only after early 80's that the government took steps to secure these heritage sites.

@atulkumar-pr4yo

9 ай бұрын

He remained education minister for almost 10 years after independence.

@romeshkumarsharma2563

9 ай бұрын

You will not see 8th century in our history because Qasim , and Arabi general had invaded Sindh and defeated Raja Dahir in 3rd attempt , and converted a lot of Sindi Hindus. Because Maulana was educated minister and so he skipped it.

@Shaktisingh84599

9 ай бұрын

Bhai baad main khoji gyi thi ye caves😅

@sitarampradhan8488

9 ай бұрын

​@@Shaktisingh84599gain knowledge. Those caves are discovered by British.

@romeshkumarsharma2563

9 ай бұрын

@@Shaktisingh84599 Ji haan. Modi ne ki thi khoj.

Hindus are accommodating but not fools. They have realized that Pakistan will never give up their anti India stance and Muslims will ne ver give up their fundamentalism. Hence, many Hindus are reacting to that realization now.

@induchopra3014

9 ай бұрын

We dont want friendship now. Too late. Enemy should be defeated.

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

@user-lv2cr1nh4u

9 ай бұрын

Rogue state of Pakistan/napakistan feels that through its nuisance value it can blackmail India. Indians should just avoid this rogue state and move on.

@mukundha7621

9 ай бұрын

​@@user-lv2cr1nh4u you never avoid a problem you solve them

جناح صاحب کے متعلق اگر تفصیل سے اتنی معلومات قوم کو دیں جاتیں تو شاید حالات مختلف ھوتے اس میں کوئی شک نہیں کہ پاکستان ایک ناکام ریاست ھے یا ناکامی کے آخری کنارے پر ھے

@ksaeed1000

8 ай бұрын

کیا تفصیلات معلوم ہونی چاہیئے تھی بتائیے ؟

@MrSalahshamsi

8 ай бұрын

جنرل ایوب مردہ باشد

Maulana Azad remained Education minister for almost 10 years. But in educational carriculam, he inserted more chapters on Mugal rulers and their culture and Architecture. He included less chapter on great indian civilisation and rulers and indian culture and tradition. The present Govt is balancing not deleting anything what is alreday in carriculam. There is a false propaganda that History is being changed.

@nsdhillon59

9 ай бұрын

The Convention was adopted by the General Conference of UNESCO on 16 November 1972. The World Heritage Convention formally takes effect upon ratification by the first 20 States. Parties. My question, where does Maulana Azad come in to the equation?

@RavindraSingh-pn9zn

9 ай бұрын

ye in jihadiyo ka narative hota hai... ye $ale bc one sided he baat kare ge hamesha... abhi christian ke church jala diya islam ne...

I m not for hindu rashtra but hindus live with each other's in peace. When they say hindu rashtra they mean civilization more than anything Don't compare jehadism with Hindu's.

@bikramsen9952

9 ай бұрын

Upper castes live in peace with the Shudra ? Really ?

@decodedecode162

9 ай бұрын

@@bikramsen9952 yes we live in peace. Nontouchability has vanished publically although existing insome villages but up to their kitchen.And let me tell u that Chandergupta maurya,Nanda rulers shivaji and many others were shudra according to modern day classification.Nanda rulers were teli Chandergupta was paeckok breeder shivaji came from a shephered background.There are plenty of other such exapmles.History writing is more a tool of propaganda than reality. If u want to debate with me on this issue I m ready to explain to u many nuances one by one.

@RavindraSingh-pn9zn

9 ай бұрын

@@decodedecode162 ye in jihadiyo ka narative hota hai... ye $ale bc one sided he baat kare ge hamesha... abhi christian ke church jala diya islam ne...

@ramanharish1327

9 ай бұрын

​@@bikramsen9952i am dalit, my friends all are upper caste . Even do lunch in their homes . It is slowly vanishing, still in undeveloped rural area might be discrimination. Everyone racing to survive in modern world , where is time to this stuff. Education is key bro. It gives respect.

@akshayingale9682

9 ай бұрын

​@@decodedecode162🤣🤣🤣

While referring to gujrat riots , Please do mention what started gujrat riots - Godhara Train Burning .

@induchopra3014

9 ай бұрын

All Muslims hide that. They don't want to even acknowledge it ever happened. They skip it, whenever gujrat is mentioned

@chemistryguru0007

9 ай бұрын

Both are doing altaqaiya kyunki one sided baat krte he ye nhi btayenge every dnge started by muslims

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@romeshkumarsharma2563

9 ай бұрын

Why ? Dr. Ishteaq after all has Muslim genes.

@kafka1343

9 ай бұрын

@@chemistryguru0007 meanwhile the true history said by br ambedkar If Hindu Raj does become a fact, it will, no doubt be the greatest calamity for this country. No matter what the Hindus say, Hinduism is a menace to liberty, equality and fraternity. It is incompatible with democracy. Hindu Raj must be prevented at any cost.”

Partition minus the massacres and riots was a blessing in disguise for the Hindus of India imagine 40 crores iihadis and fundamentalists clamoring for sharia

@jineshjillsgeorge

9 ай бұрын

That's two nation theory....which means your mentality is exactly the same as those who divided Hindustan.

If Hindus has to continue the continuity of it's 10,000 year old flourishing Civilization, then Islam has to be thrown out of Indian Subcontinent.

I would say Maulana Azad understood human psychology very well.

@Timakiwala

9 ай бұрын

Moulana Abdul Kalam Azad never gone to school,, स्कूल गया नही,, he only learn Quran and islamic ideas in Madrasa.. But muslim Nehru made him first Indian Education Minister... horrible yar.. अनपढ आदमी शिक्षामंत्री???? He has changed complete Indian history into Islamic history....... From 1947 , Congress made maximum Muslim Education Ministers>>moulana Azad,, Humayun Kabir,,mc Chagla,, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed,,Nurul Hasan becaus Congress was Pro -Muslim, Nehru from Gyasuddin Gazi family brother of Abdullah of Kashmir... These both people > not told the fact.. Azad was antiHindu.

@vs9324

9 ай бұрын

@@Timakiwala The brainwashing of bhakts is legendary and you exemplify it.

@JJ-xo3bc

9 ай бұрын

@@Timakiwala what are you on about? Azad was visionary you just cant see it smh

@divyanshusingh2145

9 ай бұрын

Visionary for muslims , not for hindus !@@JJ-xo3bc

Brilliant podcast .. watching from India

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

Jinnah was an Astute Advocate and a Cunning Politician -lacking Morality. Excellent discourse.Very enlightening.👏👏👏

@jogeshwarkumar226

9 ай бұрын

He was characterless too as he ran away with the minor daughter of his friend and client and used his legal skills to marry her lateron. He never cared about his wife afterwards as he was too busy with fanatics muslims to divide india. Now the country he got is paying for its sins and you can see its condition with your own eyes.

@user-lv2cr1nh4u

9 ай бұрын

Jnnah is the hero of India/indians.Had there been no Jinnah today entire india would have become a beggar bankrupt terror state.Every indian should sing this song E JINNAH TERA INDIA/INDIANS PE EHSAN HAI EHSAN.

@vivekpatil007

9 ай бұрын

@@user-lv2cr1nh4u Nope not at all. Leaders of that era were likely to have made better plans to control sea lanes.

@KingKong-lb3vh

9 ай бұрын

@@user-lv2cr1nh4u Alag mulk banane ke natahij: La ilaha par bana tha.........LEKIN (afsos), MAQBOOZA PAKISTAN ban gaya - do qaumi nazariat muqammal naakaam........APNE HI mard e momin, sadiq ur ameen, mard e mujahid giraye nasheman pe bijliyan..... wahid islami mulk

@hunk3891

9 ай бұрын

Jinnah was a Muslim.

Superbly conducted by Abbas Haider sahab. Questions and answers between interviewer and interviewee were both non-prejudiced. First time I have sat and listened to Dr. Istiaq Ahmed sahab. Thank you for the education. So difficult to find such respectful, refined and scholarly discussions between 2 persons who may not entirely agree with each other's views but respectfully hear each other without needling each other. Being an Indian living in India, i too say that India is witnessing a political reaction to years of one part of the family(that too the larger proportion) being treated in a step-motherly fashion and being largely ignored . And, that those who term themselves as "minority" have abused the hospitality of those whom they claim are the "majority". This action and reaction was something waiting to happen and India shall have to live through this natural process of upheaval and learn its own lessons the hard way, if it refuses to learn from history. Regards from India.

When he was in india he done an Interview with "The Lallantop", an Indian KZread channel, that was just amazing, all of you can also watch that, love from India🇮🇳❤

Azad is a real Indian patriot who also had a scientific temper and a true educationist taking education of Indians to a higher levels.

@divyanshusingh2145

9 ай бұрын

Ohh yeah , now i know how all that dis informed history i'm taught in NCERT books , "Maulana" taking over Education system is like jihadis managing an army - ohh wait - Pakistan is a clear specimen of this thought !

@RR-pc7yv

8 ай бұрын

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Mahatma Gandhi promised Maulana Azad that Partition would be over my dead body. Maulana being closed to Mahatma Gandhi believed him in toto. The partition hurt Maulana Azad deeply…. Indian state cannot have Hinduism as religion since religion has never been a unifying forces since time immorial. And Dr. Ahmed is right: India has accommodated all and it will continue to do so, which is My firm belief !!!

@bhadshakhanaa

6 ай бұрын

The trio of terror treachery treason. Ghandi ze appeaser nehru ze compromiser jinna ze instigator common denominator with all 3 the Indian masses of 47 or before failed to understand the deal behind close doors to break up Hindustan with lord Mountbatten and ze British Establishment. Rest is rewritten as history or selective narrative but historia is set in stone.

Doctor sahab is not only one of the great historian but also possess balanced mindset to filter views based on past, present and future...respect from IN🇮🇳

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@ayazmir8760

7 ай бұрын

Excatly

You are a great asset of the Indian subcontinent. Very learned , progressive and realistic thinker and analyser of the history of the Indian subcontinent .

جسونت سنگھ نے اپنی کتاب جناح میں مولانا آزاد کی تقریر کا مفصل حوالہ دیا ہے۔ اُن کے بارہ میں کم از کم یہ کہنا درست ہو گا He was the one who could peep into the future.

As always truth always speaks. Thank you both of you to make this possible. Great job

@Timakiwala

9 ай бұрын

Moulana Abdul Kalam Azad never gone to school,, स्कूल गया नही,, he only learn Quran and islamic ideas in Madrasa.. But muslim Nehru made him first Indian Education Minister... horrible yar.. अनपढ आदमी शिक्षामंत्री???? He has changed complete Indian history into Islamic history....... From 1947 , Congress made maximum Muslim Education Ministers>>moulana Azad,, Humayun Kabir,,mc Chagla,, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed,,Nurul Hasan becaus Congress was Pro -Muslim, Nehru from Gyasuddin Gazi family brother of Abdullah of Kashmir... These both people > not told the fact.. Azad was antiHindu.

No doubt in the fact " State secular hi honi chahiye" Great line

@user-lv2cr1nh4u

9 ай бұрын

State becomes secular when the constitution is secular.india will remain always secular whether BJP or any other party comes to power because constitution of India is secular. vice versa case rogue state of Pakistan/napakistan can never be secular and a big disaster is awaiting rogue state of Pakistan/napakistan.

@mayankindian3750

9 ай бұрын

​@@user-lv2cr1nh4u bhai ucc laao secular country me religion based laws Nahi hone chahiye

@shobhitdagur1086

9 ай бұрын

Name a secular nation like India

@mayankindian3750

9 ай бұрын

@@shobhitdagur1086 ha jha me muslims ko waqf board property or pta nahi kya kya rakhne ki azaadi di hui hai state secular hai to uska religion based kaam koi nahi hoga

@ayushbhadauria2899

9 ай бұрын

@@mayankindian3750 Can't agree more but I envisage u are pro UCC cause of rational mind and not just because it seems anti sharia or anti momins

Professor saab is truthful in his opinions👍🏻

Jinnah was in the favor of a united India, all the way up until when Congress rejected the Cabinet Mission Plan of 1946. Ironically, Molana Azad (a member of Congress) wanted Congress to accept it, but he was sidelined! Ultimately Nehru and Gandhi were just as responsible for separation.

We were lucky to have Azad in India and new generation is coming to like each other in two countries

Muslims are not a nation in political sense. The Muslims are a religious community and the Muslims belong to different nations. Arab Muslims, Iranian Muslims, Indian Muslims and Turkish Muslims hail from different nations.

@hunk3891

9 ай бұрын

Kya drama hai. 😂

Can’t agree more with Dr Saab statement at @25:00 Most of the violence against muslims that u see in india is reactionary, been piling up for last so many years. Hindus are not violent in nature unlike Muslims, it’s just that they have got their voice post 2014.

Mr. Haidar, please be informed, just as you discuss persecution of Muslims in India, Indian Hindus discuss what is done to Hindus in Pakistan. It has become normal in Pakistan. In every few days we hear news of that minor Hindu girl is abducted, converted and then married to a Muslim man. We hear Hindu men and women are lynched on charges of blasphemy. Reaction is inevitable.

Great job Abbas!!! 👏👏👏 Your listening abilities & patience are unmatched. Keep up the good work & continue searching for the truth. Nothing but truth! And More & more of Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed please so that our nation comes to terms with the truth. 🙏🙏🙏

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

Pakistaan ka Banna hi tarikh ki sabse badi bhool thi.🤨🤨

Abbas Bhai .... gurgaon me imam ko bina kisi reason maara ???? Main ggn se hi hu ..nuh me musalmano ne hindu mandir par attack karke 3 Hindus ko mara tha.....phir hinduo ne reaction Kiya .....pls Puri research kare.....aam Pakistani wala mindset ki ( Muslims hamesha ache hote hai aur hindu hamesha kharab hote hai ) mat rakhe ......

@naveenraina9909

9 ай бұрын

Abbas this revealed your moral bankruptcy

@indiantiger6313

9 ай бұрын

It is islamic tactics. they will discuss retaliation as the main cause of agression. 😂

A.K. Azad had no knowledge of future (an absolute domain of Allah SWT). But he knew History of this region and the people and could draw conclusion. He was aware of the history of Syed Ahmad & Syed Ismail (Shaheedain), cause of their Shahadat and the role played by the people of this region! He knew they are Untrustworthy!

How a muslim who believes in Dawah to convert everyone to Islam can wish and advice only Hindu motherland to be become Darul Islam... today's Hindu is not foolish like ancestors who welcomed outsiders and forced to be slaves...

Love from India ❤❤❤❤

@rajendrawandhare9114

9 ай бұрын

Geetaji he selectively qouts 1 cleric died in Haryana but 5 Hindus were died?this selectivenes of misinformation can lead to more distrust.

@rajendrawandhare9114

9 ай бұрын

Also died

@milindranade5427

9 ай бұрын

@@rajendrawandhare9114 zimmi mentality is incurable

Paxtan has appointed with wife of yasin malik with the intention of improving relations with India 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Madhya Pradesh is the one of the richest state in India. Madhya pradesh means food basket of India. One of the best infrastructure of India exists in Madhya pradesh.

Maulana azad didn't wanted this side of sindhu to be hindu majority in other words wow he is genius toasting bread from both side in reality favouring islam only.

Very good conversation between two scholars . All points raised by Moulana Abdul Kalam Azad have got one insight into future of Pakistan stems from the fact that Muslim leaders of undivided India were still evolving in grasping 20th century philosophies for a modren nation state . Independence came when the leadership was underprepared to handle a State with its problems . When fuedalism needed to be replaced by ascending social democratic values for creating a welfare state ., instead the elite perpetuated their hegemony politically and never allowed modern reforms . Rest is history .

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed sahib , Abbas Haidar bhai Adaab Sat Sri Akaal🙏 Hamesha ki tarah hi bahut hi shaandaar 👍👍🙏

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

What a thoughtful and thought provoking interview. Time to celebrate the truth and honesty!

The reading/book list of Molana Azad would be a goldmine.

Amazing scholarship and honest and objective to a fault ! Thank you so much sir for giving us a lesson in true history

@sarabjitbaidwan9658

9 ай бұрын

Sickular mindset is very dangerous

Please invite Ali Usman Qasmi whose book 'Muslims against the Muslim League' is a classic 👌👌

Our establishment and our parliament should be compelled to follow what Dr. Ishtiaq says. He is a true preacher.

Here in Bangladesh,the then east Pakistan we created Pakistan under the slogan” zamindari khatam koro, Pakistan qaim koro”.

Sardar patel was a visionary in indian politics 🎉 🎆

I come to your videos to learn history and past, but I always learn much more than that. Big salute to you for broadening my horizon of knowledge. You're like a big brother ❤️

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@chandrakantbhandurge9320

9 ай бұрын

Thank U Ishtiyak Ahamad Sir, we love ❤️ U Sir.

@Timakiwala

9 ай бұрын

Moulana Abdul Kalam Azad never gone to school,, स्कूल गया नही,, he only learn Quran and islamic ideas in Madrasa.. But muslim Nehru made him first Indian Education Minister... horrible yar.. अनपढ आदमी शिक्षामंत्री???? He has changed complete Indian history into Islamic history....... From 1947 , Congress made maximum Muslim Education Ministers>>moulana Azad,, Humayun Kabir,,mc Chagla,, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed,,Nurul Hasan becaus Congress was Pro -Muslim, Nehru from Gyasuddin Gazi family brother of Abdullah of Kashmir... These both people > not told the fact.. Azad was antiHindu.

Last part, Mr Ahmed blamed Cia for encouraging 20000 madarsas . He doesnot mention any pakistani blame. Surprising!!!!

Most candid talk and analysis by Dr. Felt like a classroom, all his videos will remain a legacy and hopefully become a turning point for his country.

Ishtiaq Sir, has really put things in proper perspective 👍🏼

Haider himself is a devout Muslim and wants Muslim supremacy but wants a "secular" (minority appeasing) government in India - This helps me decide to vote for BJP ! And to top it all up , he is just a convert that doesn't know his own identity Lol

Thank you Dr Saheb for being the conscience of the Indian sub continent. And thank you Junaid for bringing this wonderful discussion to us!

@nicolasflamel3489

8 ай бұрын

We have had conscience as a people since 20000 years, don't know about your desert cult.

Jabtak Muslim minority hote hain unka islam peaceful or progressive hota hai, jaise hi Islam majority ban jat hai unka Islam shariya ban jat hai. Gair muslim kafir or Musalman jihadi banjata hai

26:37 these forcefully Converts never discuss islamic communalism in india post partition of 1947. These forcefully converts never discuss the "un accommodative" nature of Islam and Muslim. They think about islamic interests, islamic gains. 😂

Critical thinking aate hi Islam khatam...100%.....

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@NewYork0110J

9 ай бұрын

Bro is it true for muslims earth is hell and 72 hoors palace is jannat.

@mukundha7621

9 ай бұрын

​@@NewYork0110JThey even have hadith world is great for non-Muslims while hell for beleivers

@ankurantil6137

8 ай бұрын

​​@@md.shaghilsubhani.1639 gadhey pe baith kar jannat me Jana..... Aur chand ko aadha tod dene se to behtar hai 😂

Dr. Ishtihaq Sir, really appreciate you for standing strongly with truth, and being neutral , it really needs great courage . Resprct Sir. !

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

@rajendrawandhare9114

9 ай бұрын

How this anchor not say that 5 Hindus were also killed in Haryana By muslim mob.This type of selective qouts does not gives credibility to discussin.

@user-lv2cr1nh4u

9 ай бұрын

@@rajendrawandhare9114 What else can you expect from the anchor of a rogue terror state called pakistan/napakistan.

India has never been a majoritian state. Indians are accomodative & on freindly terms with any one who is non aggressive, even animals! Dr. Ishtiaq must know this before doubting & advising RSS.

Before Islamic conquest Boundaries of Bharatvarsh started from Hindukush Range on the west and on its peak was expanded to Bali , Indonesia to Angkor Vat, Combodia in the East, Islam divided Bharatvarsh and Hindu Rashtra will unite it.

Hats off to maulana azad for his foresight but thankful to jinnah for sticking to his agenda.

Brilliant analysis. Very interesting and informative

بہترین موضوع ❤ بہترین سوالات ❤ بہترین مہمان ❤

I am surprised, how can a person predict accurately 😮

Ishtiak Ahmed is great conjurer too much knowledge I have ever seen

India main 11 November main "National Education Day" Celebration kortey hain abul kalam azad ji ki honour k liye

Why he kept aside 30 pages of autobiography till 30 years after his death. In those pages he was blaming Nehru for the partition.

@romeshkumarsharma2563

9 ай бұрын

He had no formal education but born and studied in Madrasa in Saudi Arabia. He was against the partition merely to keep all the Muslims together to put more pressure on Hindus and not for any other reason.

@indiantiger6313

9 ай бұрын

Yeah, he was a pan islamist believed on Ummah concepts. He wanted United muslim so that they could achieve islamic goals easily. He and all muslim always thought that BHARAT belongs to us(momin) but we belong to islam not Bharat. That is the reason every muslim reject Bharatiyaness as kufr/kafirana things and always create ARABISED version to justify they don't belong to this land and have separate identity.

17:54 universal, moral, ethical principles of Islam. 😂 is se bada joke duniya me kuchh ho sakta h kya?

Patel was exactly right to go for partition if you ask me. Britishers wanted a land for them, they got it. India has its own rich history and culture and its own type of secular values. And if Muslims don't want to relate to it then this should be it.

This gentle old man reminds me great humans in punjabi culture that are now nowhere to be seen or heard.

@romeshkumarsharma2563

9 ай бұрын

Please visit Chadta Punjab once and stay with me in my village , and you will find a lot of such persons.

@AbbasHaider Great stream as before with doctor ishtiaq sahab he is a true valuable scholar who paints an objectively clear picture about the history of Pakistan 🇵🇰 In contrast a stream with Dr ayesha jalal is also needed as both the scholars have a difference of opinion on the matter of historicity of Pakistan I hope you heed my suggestion many thanks to you and your esteemed guests. Best of luck 🤞

@Timakiwala

9 ай бұрын

Moulana Abdul Kalam Azad never gone to school,, स्कूल गया नही,, he only learn Quran and islamic ideas in Madrasa.. But muslim Nehru made him first Indian Education Minister... horrible yar.. अनपढ आदमी शिक्षामंत्री???? He has changed complete Indian history into Islamic history....... From 1947 , Congress made maximum Muslim Education Ministers>>moulana Azad,, Humayun Kabir,,mc Chagla,, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed,,Nurul Hasan becaus Congress was Pro -Muslim, Nehru from Gyasuddin Gazi family brother of Abdullah of Kashmir... These both people > not told the fact.. Azad was antiHindu.

Indian State is secular from 10,000 years and will remain secular for next 10,000 year ,but Indian Subcontinent was Hindu Rashtra and will remain Hindu Rashtra, the Islam only has hardly a century left of its lifespan in the Subcontinent.

@harshnaik6989

9 ай бұрын

The term Hindutva came from foreigners, there is nothing like Hinduisms exists. Foreigners clubs every teaching of India under a term Hinduism because they don't understand the dept of it. In ancient India the most followed teaching were of Carvaka's (they were Atheist and rejected Vedas and Gods and they were inventor of concept of Dharma), Just like that there were many teachings in India which rejects Gods, Vedas or Geeta etc... like Aajivika's, Vaisheshika, Nyaya's, Carvaka's, Buddha, Jains etc... but we gave them all the title of Rishi Muni Infact there are multiple teachings in India, and we accommodate all. India kingdoms never had the concept of having an official religion of state. So why would people who follows Charvak's, Nyaya's, Buddas, Jains, Aajivika's, Tribals beliefs want to be under any religion? or accept Veda or Geeta or gods? The term Hinduisms itself is foreigners and why would we accept that? The only thing that makes sense is India should be the land of Dharma (Dharma means Law in English) and India is already a country which hold Rule of Law as supreme Law, so we Indian are naturally an Dharmic Nation. I hope you got the Ans brother.

Wonderful discussion. Abbas Haider had brilliant questions and full marks for researching and posing insightful questiosn.Without a doubt, Abbas is the most learned of all the youtubers on the history of India and Pakistan

Did you know Bollywood actor Amir Khan is Azads great grand nephew... hence Amir khan named younger son Azad...

Thank god.. Even Liberal Muslims are not aware of what is happening or what happened... I hope Muslims and liberal muslims keep doing what they are currently... Bless you liberal muslims.... Imam e Hind.... Lord Ram? Really... Good keep doing what you are doing... Even Dr Ishtiyaq Ahmed is at a question mark.... Thank god.

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

@abhaynath5833

9 ай бұрын

Liberal Muslim is oxymoron. The moment a person becomes liberal, other Muslim declare him as Kaffir.

Maulana Azad Istiaq saheb ko batane gaye the kya ki unki Islam ki interpretation universal hai ki theological, kya bongi maari hai 😂😂😂

@HimanshuShukla0802

9 ай бұрын

Some Dark Real facts of Maulana Azad's life & movements:- (1) Azad never went to school .He was home-schooled and self-taught . His works is translation of Qur'an and he also wrote "India wins freedom" (almost half) which was completed by Karim Chagla. (2) Azad created a party known as Hizbullah (Army of Allah) in 1913. With this, he inspired the greatest Pan islamists leader Maulana Maududi, the revivalist leader of Jamaat-E-Islami who has even inspired the Al Qaeda chief Ayman Al Jawahiri and Muslims brotherhood Sayed Qutub too. By the way , Today everyone knows that Hizbollah is a famous internationally recognised Shia terrorist organization operating from Lebanon. (3) So why Azad joined Congress?? The answer is that Since Azad didn't get the needed response from the Ulema, disappointed he joined Congress in 1920. So Maulana Abul Kalam Azad now became a Gandhi supporter but being a pure Islamist, he came into the public limelight after emerging as the leader of the Khilafat movement. He wanted to harness Islamic unity and protect the Caliphate. Azad was the Sataunch Proponents of Imperialism of Turkish Caliph so he started a movement with his Pan Islamists Devbandi Ali brothers which is known as "Khilafat movement" . On the other hand Arabs were fighting thier freedom movement against imperialism even Turks themselves didn't want Caliphate. (3) So Muslims like Abul Kalam Azad and the then Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind president Ahmad Hussain Madani opposed Pakistan Why ? Only because they felt that Partition would affect Muslim domination in the sub-continent and Muslims would heavily lose. Plus they tried to extract a heavy price from the Congress for their patriotism in the name of minority protection. As Congress president in 1945, Azad even went to the extent of agreeing to a proposal of rotating Indian headship. It meant India would have a Hindu and then a Muslim head of State and army chief by turns. So, eventually, Gandhi and Nehru made Congress hostage to ‘Hindu-Muslim unity at any cost’ which Jinnah skillfully exploited and got more concessions from the Congress to establish parity in numbers between Hindu and Muslim representation. (4) Azad not only focused on promoting Mughal-inspired history but also tried his best to Islamicize education and further the unity amongst the Muslims against Hindus. (5) Azad had no position among pan Indian muslim community after 1940. It was almost Zero in Punjab , Sindh , NWFP, Balochistan , Bengal to South India.Even he was unable to win his seat too. Particularly , Muslim League used call him "Agent of Hindus" or "Slave of Mushriqeens". (6) Was Maulana Azad a Secular guy ? His speech delivered on 27th Oct 1914 in Kolkata, showed his true face ; "All relationships in the world can break down but this relationship can never be severed. It is possible a father turns against his son, not impossible that a mother separates her child from her lap, it is possible that one brother becomes the enemy of other brother But the relationship that a Chinese Muslim has with an African Muslim, an Arab bedouin has with the Tatar shepherd, and which binds in one soul a neo-Muslim of India with the right-descendant Qureshi of Mecca, there is no power on earth to break it, to cut off this chain." (7) Despite their obvious differences, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad went to pay his respect to the founder of Pakistan, Muhammad Ali Jinnah and prayed at his grave in the year 1953.

Brilliant analysis by Dr Istiaq Ahmed based on honesty and judicious logic.😊

@MohitKarnik

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad new that Muslims can only enslave human beings but Hindus can give livelihoods grasp Science and implement modern technology unlike the Madrasa going Muslims. That is why today Pakistanis are slaves of the Pak Army and its Elites who collude against their common citizens by turning them into a heard of Bigoted Psycotic Supremacist and irrational sheep who will slaughter their own mothers if they were told to do so by their Fundemetalist Mullas on order of their Millitary masters. The Genocidal tendency of a Pakistani has one command structure from General to Mulla and the crowd goes wild. In UK EU and AUSTRALIA its the Mulla who incites the hit on the Kafirs. Gustakh E Rasool ki eik hi sazza Sar tan se juda Sir tan se Judaa! Jai Hind 🙏 Jai Bharat 🙏

Excellent Host and Brilliant Dr. Ishtiaq Sb. Thought provoking discussion. May we all get the ability and acumen to see the sociopolitical crisis of Pakistan like Dr. Ishtiaq Sb.

Rasool can never be Avtar for Sanatanis...Our Avtars are not invaders,converters,Khatnabaaz,AuratBaaz,9 saal se NIKAH,AURAT KI KHAREEDFROKHT,BAHU PAR KAMUK HONA AUR NIKAH KARNA.LOOGO KE TEMPLES AND IDOLS TODNA.

@indiantiger6313

9 ай бұрын

One way traffic h uski theory. Kitni asani se ye bol dia ki Hindus, muhhamad ko avtar man ne ko tayar the Lekin muslim should always say "Allah ke siwa koi IBADAT ki layak nahin. Ye Ram ko IMAM bana kar Islam aur muslim ko enlightened tag kar ke bechne ki koshish karta h. Lekin me agar Allah ko RAM BHAKT bol dun to yahi istiaq Ahmed jihadi jaise behave karega. 😂

this hindu extremism is reaction for sure , theologically hindus are accommodating, hindu will go to temple gurudwara masjid and church without hesitation, cuz we don't have any theological crisis cuz we believe every religion god leads to same high conscience, i also worry that hindu shouldn't be like them or react like them in reaction,

@induchopra3014

9 ай бұрын

Why hindus go? Its wrong. This leads to confusion in hindus.

@avinashmishra7735

9 ай бұрын

Maulana Azad ko is baat ka zyada dukh nahi tha ki Pakistan Indus Civilization ki chhati par ek Islamic mulk bnega. Maulana ko is baat ka zyada dukh tha ki kahi is k reaction me Hindustan me Hindutva na aa jaaye. A secular Muslim is a hypocrite muslim. He/she is actually a soft jihadi who comes in defense of islamic fundamentals at the cost of throwing hard jihadis under the bus. That's what this Ishtiaq Ahmed or Maulana Azad kind of people do. They can throw the whole ummah just to defend Islam from criticism. Remember, all muslims moderate or extreme have same dream of converting the whole world. They all use democracy and diversity to kill democracy and diversity in their own ways. It's just a matter of demography. See how this Istiaq is crying to realize Muslims divided in 3 countries. "No problem in Islamic fundamentals, it is just fundamentalists who are interpreting it wrong" is like saying Muhammad was perfectly right in everything he did but those why try to follow him are not. Hindutva (Hindu reaction) will show the world how to deal with Islam with mutual respect to minimize the overall harm of human cvilizations

@indiantiger6313

9 ай бұрын

Tolerance paradox.

Not agreed with Ishtiak that after becoming Hindu Rashtra it will divide. No immediately after becoming Hindu Rashtra it's solution will be implemented.

In Pakistan there were around 20% non Muslims in 1947 now there are only around 3% left. In India there were around 9 or 10% Muslims now there are around 15%. Why? But Hindus are non secular. Wah wah. What fantastic logic

Great analysis by Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed Sir , his logical approach and the core values of Hindus has always been accommodative.

@salimalvi5178

9 ай бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/lZ6iscOqdrOXd8Y.html

@Pork393

9 ай бұрын

Dont forget, Dr Ahmed always defends Islam & normalises the demolishing of temples by saying, ok the temples were demolished, but temples were also built! Is this the argument? On one hand he says Islam is martial but doesn't say it is a violent ideology! Despite destruction over 1400 yrs he still says Islam is peaceful? Its an oxymoron! Looks like Dr Ahmed is confused about Islam! He know he can't criticise Islam! So he keeps beating around the bush!

It’s always enlightening to hear Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed. Best wishes for Dr. sb 🎉. Abbas Haider you are doing excellent work. Love to see you keep growing 🙏

Ramlal : mera betaa Jumbo Jet udaa saqta hai. Abdullah: mera betaa poora Airport udaa saqta hai. 😅😅😅😅

Watched movie Jinnah thirty years ago,role of Jinnah was given to Christopher Lee by English director

Maulana Abdul Kalam had no role in creating IITs other than just inaugurating it. If Muslims were so farsighted then why education system in Pakistan is in this condition. "With the recommendations of the Sarkar committee in view and on the basis of blueprint made by L. S. Chandrakant, Biman Sen, and Sir J. C. Ghosh, the first Indian Institute of Technology was born in May, 1950 at the site of Hijli Detention Camp in Kharagpur, a town in eastern India. Initially the IIT started functioning from 5, Esplanade East, Calcutta (now Kolkata) and shifted to Hijli in September, 1950 when Sir J. C. Ghosh offered the place as a ready made place for the IIT. The present name 'Indian Institute of Technology' was adopted before the formal inauguration of the institute on 18 August 1951, by Maulana Abul Kalam "

@sarabjitbaidwan9658

9 ай бұрын

Absolutely

@bittoochatterjee2661

9 ай бұрын

FINALLY ONE NORTH INDIAN / HINDI BHASI ACCEPTING IT WAS ONLY AND ONLY DUE TO BENGALI'S EFFORTS 🌹🌹❤❤😍😍😊😊 INDIA IS THIS PLACE AS OF TODAY . NO IIT NO SUNDAR PICHAI NADALA KEJRIWAL 😁😁🤣🤣😂😂 PROUD TO BE A BENGALI

@kafka1343

9 ай бұрын

Understanding the fundamental role education plays in the development of the nation, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad as the Chairman of Central Advisory Board of Education, gave impetus to Adult Education and Literacy. Not only did he lay emphasis on elementary education but also propogated diversification of secondary education and vocational training. Lol maulana was the reason that right to education to every child under 14 yr old was introduced by him lol

@divyanshusingh2145

9 ай бұрын

Ohh yeah , now i know how all that dis informed history i'm taught in NCERT books , "Maulana" taking over Education system is like jihadis managing an army - ohh wait - Pakistan is a clear specimen of this thought !@@kafka1343

@jagdeepsandhu9659

4 ай бұрын

​@@bittoochatterjee2661every body knows , acknowledges Bengali contribution , why do 😊you wallow in self pity ?

Pakistani should at least read few books about Hinduism before commenting and comparing Hinduism and it's philosophy with Islam

@indiantiger6313

9 ай бұрын

It doesn't matter if they will read or not. The fundamental doctrine will remain constant that is "Kafir is villian and oppressor" because he/she doesn't worship 7th asmani kafirmisia fictional character ola-o-uber and reject all other as false gods. 😂

@karolbagh3793

9 ай бұрын

@@indiantiger6313 Jai Hindu Rashtra 🛕🛕🛕

@harshnaik6989

9 ай бұрын

@@karolbagh3793 The term Hindutva came from foreigners, there is nothing like Hinduisms exists. Foreigners clubs every teaching of India under a term Hinduism because they don't understand the dept of it. In ancient India the most followed teaching were of Carvaka's (they were Atheist and rejected Vedas and Gods and they were inventor of concept of Dharma), Just like that there were many teachings in India which rejects Gods, Vedas or Geeta etc... like Aajivika's, Vaisheshika, Nyaya's, Carvaka's, Buddha, Jains etc... but we gave them all the title of Rishi Muni Infact there are multiple teachings in India, and we accommodate all. India kingdoms never had the concept of having an official religion of state. So why would people who follows Charvak's, Nyaya's, Buddas, Jains, Aajivika's, Tribals beliefs want to be under any religion? or accept Veda or Geeta or gods? The term Hinduisms itself is foreigners and why would we accept that? The only thing that makes sense is India should be the land of Dharma (Dharma means Law in English) and India is already a country which hold Rule of Law as supreme Law, so we Indian are naturally an Dharmic Nation. I hope you got the Ans brother.

Dr. Shab Hat's off for you you are really enlightened person you may live long I respect your opinion

Dr . Sir ko sunna hsmesha accha lagta hai from india

Don’t worry……we will remove secular word from our constitution…….dr Ambedkar was against this word…..pm Indira Gandhi did this change during emergency without any discussion in parliament…..we are naturally inclusive…..whole world is like family to us…..one English word will not define our society…..majority of Indians don’t know about this complicated English word in our constitution manual…..so no confusion 🎉

@salimalvi5178

9 ай бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/lZ6iscOqdrOXd8Y.html

@sarabjitbaidwan9658

9 ай бұрын

Absolutely

@harshnaik6989

9 ай бұрын

The term Hindutva came from foreigners, there is nothing like Hinduisms exists. Foreigners clubs every teaching of India under a term Hinduism because they don't understand the dept of it. In ancient India the most followed teaching were of Carvaka's (they were Atheist and rejected Vedas and Gods and they were inventor of concept of Dharma), Just like that there were many teachings in India which rejects Gods, Vedas or Geeta etc... like Aajivika's, Vaisheshika, Nyaya's, Carvaka's, Buddha, Jains etc... but we gave them all the title of Rishi Muni Infact there are multiple teachings in India, and we accommodate all. India kingdoms never had the concept of having an official religion of state. So why would people who follows Charvak's, Nyaya's, Buddas, Jains, Aajivika's, Tribals beliefs want to be under any religion? or accept Veda or Geeta or gods? The term Hinduisms itself is foreigners and why would we accept that? The only thing that makes sense is India should be the land of Dharma (Dharma means Law in English) and India is already a country which hold Rule of Law as supreme Law, so we Indian are naturally an Dharmic Nation. I hope you got the Ans brother.

I am a critic of Ishtiaq Ahmed’s duplicity and jaundiced attitude towards Hindus, but Abbas bhai, you are a great interviewer and your poise as well as your style of speech, posing questions is worth admiring. You will go places for sure with your intrinsic talent and better grooming.

Eye opening and very interesting.most of us don't know the actual history including myself.we should have good friendly relationship with India for the greater good.peace for all and hatred for none.

Dear Abbas, Pls remember that what happened in Gujarat was also a reaction by Hindus. It was a Muslim Mob that burnt down a train at Godhra which was carrying Hindu pilgrims on 27th Feb, 2002. 59 Hindus including women and children were burn alive. A "Minority" that claims to be victims here has always been initiating aggression against the peaceful Hindu Majority. And Muslims like you conveniently skip this part. Why would the Hindus not respond. In fact the Hindus don't respond as much as they should because we were always taught that all religions are equal even by our religious Hindu clergy. Islam on the other hand indoctrinates Muslims with hatred towards every Non-Muslims(Kaafirs) especialy Mushriks like the Hindus. Maulvis of India are no different from Maulvis of Pakistan.

Excellent interview with a secular humanitarian Muslim Pakistani Prof.....Thank you Prof. ......God ( Creator ) bless you with good health & strength to light up your country with knowledge .💙💙