U have to wonder about these political academics! How ignorant is the Bell academic? Get ur noses out of what's being preached to u at uni and go out and look at these Bradshaw's paintings. open ur minds up!
@davidaugustynek23103 күн бұрын
Sung from the perspective of a white man claiming to be a wandjina?
@narellefriar25883 күн бұрын
Sad to see it has intensified in the past 14 years.
@rcflier532Ай бұрын
What evidence He has?
@sevic333Ай бұрын
Superb
@grointastic4242Ай бұрын
We were part of Indonesia and obviously they were on the land too. Oh and the Dutch found Australia way before the English too
@georgewelch99782 ай бұрын
This 'Bradshaw Art' doesn't resemble anything like all the other aboriginal art, in fact It looks very African. In the rocky hills and mountains in Zimbabwe there is any amount of ancient rock art with striking similarities to this.
@nunyasmith32812 ай бұрын
Aboriginals have always been very rudimentary in whatever they did including art. They didn't even create dot painting that they love to exploit as their own. For them to create such artistic paintings is unlikely.
@brogabrerian2 ай бұрын
African Watusi
@clarechiarizia18202 ай бұрын
As he says - follow the money..... .the Incas disappeared completely. Nobody disputes that?
@MungoManic3 ай бұрын
Such a great dude. His ideas may not be completely accurate but he did more to document and analyze these paintings than any human alive. Love his attitude and commitment to truth-finding. I'm going to make a video soon about these paintings and will be sure to highlight him
@petermartin48073 ай бұрын
Should have took an elder and got permission
@northislandguy4 ай бұрын
There’s an episode on Bush Tucker Man and Les said that the Indigenous disregard the paintings calling it “rubbish paintings”
@michaelbutler15575 ай бұрын
Do some reading in Mungo Man, Ancient skeletal remains that appear different in character ie. height, appearance.
@mysteryexchange41926 ай бұрын
Love the Message. Songs gonna be stuck in my head all day now 😳 I'm not sure how to feel about that. Strangely it's kinda catchy.🤷♂
@trevorfitzgerald49966 ай бұрын
Mother of the devil
@stenkarasin20916 ай бұрын
Who paintedthem? Who created the midden at Mungo?
@brianwillerton86596 ай бұрын
He has his own fantasies, as an artisan on the American continent, I can't imagine all the art across this country would be the same, there were different cultures on that Australian Continent long before closed minded Brits got there, he needs to do more history with the Aboriginies on the Island before coming up with suppositions on his own.
@alisatour21986 ай бұрын
What a load shit" i can see clearly with head designs are definitely belong to Aboriginal. Most our deep scared culture isnt knowing to most waknere out there, this rock art is definitely done by blackfellas
@antithesespistopheles81127 ай бұрын
Here’s the thing, aboriginal average iq is…62. That should be the end of any dispute.
@zurackdempsey82608 ай бұрын
These comments make me sick as an indigenous man (Aboriginal/Torrest strait islander) we been here since megafauna, since Sahul, since the beginning of creation
@zakblackhawk2048 ай бұрын
Love the views of the kids, notbad.jpg.
@user-cm9xz8mf9m8 ай бұрын
Carbon dating.
@imaginimage62078 ай бұрын
theese are Indonesian
@JohnCole-qv1fd8 ай бұрын
God don't let the voice elites see these they'll get them painted over
@sammyjones35008 ай бұрын
That aboriginal at 6:35 seems full of shit.
@lukemacmillan40308 ай бұрын
Couldn't be more obvious to even the casual viewer that they are completely different and look more African. Embarrassing academics on here. My 5 year old could tell the difference.
@davidruse32428 ай бұрын
maybe it was done by the Papuans who were here first..
@itookallthenames8 ай бұрын
Bradshaw
@brianholloway14518 ай бұрын
Well I watched a magnificent documentary on ABC National Geographic and it showed the custodians of the artwork going round and touching up the artwork and they said and I quote. If we didn't go round and touch the artwork up they wouldn't be here. Interesting and yet no one said anything. And what about erosion if we take erosion into affect we would know that none of these rocks would be there. But the custodians of this ancient rock art have been touching up the paintings for years. And they showed us on camera how they did it amazing. So when you say these are 20 30. 40 50,000 years old. Is quite amazing because on the National Geographic Abc show tells a completely different story by the people who look after the indigenous people of Australia. And the other place in Western Australia where there's magnificent fossils. They are saying now if we don't put a shelter over them they will be gone within 10 to 15 years. That's amazing since they said they've been there for over 20 million years. And now they're saying that it's possible that they can disappear within 15. Because of erosion. In actual fact one of the greatest naturalist was John Gould and he said it is a miracle we still have the fossil record at the present rate of erosion. He knew the maths didn't add up. Because if you only take 5 million use the fossil record would've been wiped out at least three times at the present rate of a erosion. And at the back of Tamworth they have a dam that was made and it was supposed to be there for another thousand years because they built it where the granite was and is. But they didn't realise that the granite was disintegrating enormously fast and now the dam is completely fall right up to the top and now cows eat the grass where the water should be. So if we take away assumptions and theories it's amazing what you have left
@lisilucyinski94558 ай бұрын
Chaffee or split rock dam?
@brianholloway14518 ай бұрын
It's not Chaffey and it's not split Rock dam. It's actually at the back of Tamworth on the range. It's about 100 feet tall and we dug by hand and the concrete was mix by hand it was one of the very first and very very old dam@@lisilucyinski9455
@tonybuckley9508 ай бұрын
Anyone who has attended university knows Academia is full of pet theories, superstitions, infighting. Most breakthroughs relying on new evidence were fought against as heresies. Nobody liked the established order being upset.
@cohort0755 ай бұрын
It made me laugh when listening to the two women “academics”, probably never saw a Bradshaw in person, let alone travel across the Kimberly ranges as many times as Graham had.
@JohnBrennan-pt9kg8 ай бұрын
OK have your myths, but that does not mean your myth gets to block science and reality
@madchad48058 ай бұрын
There is a Bradshaw gallery near me. It’s unbelievable hand prints at the top of a cliff face.
@richardrobinson16518 ай бұрын
So much garbage in this comments section. The only truth is right here. Who created this artwork???Not Bradshaw.
@davidderby4368 ай бұрын
Alright, alright, l give up. It was me.
@georgeseymour29538 ай бұрын
The Australian Aboriginals and leftist, corrupt archaeologists have stolen 60 000 years of history and a sophisticated very old culture that created the so-called Bradshaw Rock-art pictures in Kimbrley, NW Australia. Thay claim the aboriginals, egy even today stone-age people, have 64 000 years of history in Australia. In comparison, the Syeleta - Solutre stone age cultutre took 20 000 years to develop modern technology, to land on the Moon. The present-day Aboriginals have really had a history of 4 200 years in Australia. Genetic tests on 2000 Aboriginals throughout Australia have showed convincingly that the present-day Aboriginals migrated 4200 years ago from the South of India together with the domesticated ancestral dogs of dingos. Since the Bradshaw pieces of rock-art are at least 17 000 years old, by absolute dating, they cannot possibly be the work of the Gwoin Aboriginal people, or any other aboriginal tribe.
@dinosshed8 ай бұрын
It's a matter of those who are seeking factual evidence and those who seek to make shit up.
@frankiefallzonie12038 ай бұрын
I’ll be honest, that “aboriginal” guy looks like he’s making up what he’s talking about
@christianskey49158 ай бұрын
Aboriginals are slaves from the Egypt in Queensland mountains there's story's of little blue people lived in rain forest that were story's I was told buy old timers
@TheFluffyDuck8 ай бұрын
Africa lots of hominids, Europe lots of hominids, Asia, lots of hominids, India lots of hominids, South America one migrations lots of cultures. Australia only one group of people, ever. Dont ask questions!
@keithad64858 ай бұрын
I don't see Walsh as remotely racist in the way he is shown in this video, he is simply trying to figure out the origin with a very open mind without agenda except his search for the truth. Racism tag is trotted out so often, it has lost its original mean. When I hear of someone called a racist, it makes me think that person has his or her own agenda and will not tolerate dissent from their own view and wants to shut down the heretic but without reasoned argument to support their view.
@keithad64858 ай бұрын
In India in the 1990s, I have heard Indian tribal members talking in their language and was struck by how much it sounds like listening to Aussie blackfella talk, even the nasal tone. I wondered at the time if this is where Aussie blackfella originally came from. If yes, perhaps these blackfellas, when they came to Australia, were the dominating culture over these Bradshaw painters and the Bradshaw painters died out or were wiped out. I add this is only conjecture on my part.
@Billy-jn6te8 ай бұрын
Australian Aboriginals closest relative is the indigenous Indian and Pakistani people.
@keithad64858 ай бұрын
I find this a concept easy to accept. Be interesting to do a DNA analysis of Indian tribes and Aussue blackfellas.. Aussie Blackfella came from somewhere, could not have magically appeared here in Australia, could not have come out of 'thin air', @@Billy-jn6te
@therealbmaphill8 ай бұрын
Sanitized that is the problem...He is spot on.
@petersimpson61108 ай бұрын
Dot painting was invented in 1971 by Geoffrey Bardon who then taught the style to aborigines. There are NO dot paintings ever found in ANY caves.
@HouseholdDog8 ай бұрын
My friends don't believe it so I don't either. Ladies and gentlemen... SCIENCE!
@HouseholdDog8 ай бұрын
The profession of Archaeology in Australia is completely swamped by politics. I would 100% trust a local historical society over anything a University Archaeologist/Historian says. I remember researching the WW2 riots that occurred in Melbourne. One historian said the authorities covered it up. One quick look at the papers, through trove, and it was on page 3 of the papers. Which is the next best page next to page 1.
@petersimpson61108 ай бұрын
Totally agree, the Government has covered up HEAPS of things for their own reasons, and they also have been rigging EVERY election since 1947, Fed, state and local, its all about to come out courtesy of the military.
@petersimpson61108 ай бұрын
The 'Welcome to Country' Ceremony was invented in 1976 by Ernie Dingo and Richard Walley to welcome Maori performers. There is no Aboriginal word for a 'Welcome To Country' like the Maori's Haka. How can it be an 'ancient Ceremony' if there is no word for it. How could someone say "Who's going to perform the Welcome to Country ceremony"? The 'Acknowledgement of Country' was invented in the 1990s. The 'Smoking' Ceremony is, also, a recent invention. There is NO film or video evidence of any of these ceremonies at important events such as royal tours, the 1956 Olympics, etc, prior to the 1970s and 1990s.
@DonHavjuan8 ай бұрын
Spoiler: they're not 20k years old, they're about 12k years old, and they appear to have been painted by someone other than current "Aboriginal" people, who are, not in fact aboriginal at all - they're more recent arrivals. The original inhabitants of Australia are long gone. Daily reminder: the dingo has only been here 3400 years and isn't native either. The famous woomera is also relatively recent, at about the same age, brought to Australia with a wave of migration.
@MungoManic3 ай бұрын
Yep recent dating attempts put them around ~12 kya. There are some cultural connections between the Bradshaw culture and historical tribes but many differences. Culturally, the bradshaw people remind me more of Papuan tribes in the Fly river area. I agree the woomera is relatively recent but it appears towards the end of the Bradshaw era
@PurpleGold.8 ай бұрын
@26:58 That lady really buys into this ethereal, nebulous concept of the spirit realm creating this work of art, but is furiously opposed to any investigation that this may be a product of a race other than the Aboriginal one, which only serves to expose her for having an agenda. She was quick to argue (did you see the anger in her eyes, trying to intimidate the interviewer?) that no one could ever possibly prove his theory as it will only ever be speculation, yet she explains it away with all that spiritual claptrap, as if it’s fact. Yet even she wouldn’t even really be able to understand the specifics of the spiritual significance. Just another case of the Emperor’s New Clothes because some people just can’t handle the truth.
@cohort0755 ай бұрын
She, I bet had never seen a Bradshaw in person, only in pictures, probably taken by Graham himself.
@susancurran31609 ай бұрын
Sure they arenot aliens
@earthworld10009 ай бұрын
Archeology is not a science but a number count of the living today and money pushed into players hands will consimate the marriage. The women from England never looks at the camera when she speaks and looks all over the place as very nervous, will she resign when she is found wrong ?
Пікірлер
U have to wonder about these political academics! How ignorant is the Bell academic? Get ur noses out of what's being preached to u at uni and go out and look at these Bradshaw's paintings. open ur minds up!
Sung from the perspective of a white man claiming to be a wandjina?
Sad to see it has intensified in the past 14 years.
What evidence He has?
Superb
We were part of Indonesia and obviously they were on the land too. Oh and the Dutch found Australia way before the English too
This 'Bradshaw Art' doesn't resemble anything like all the other aboriginal art, in fact It looks very African. In the rocky hills and mountains in Zimbabwe there is any amount of ancient rock art with striking similarities to this.
Aboriginals have always been very rudimentary in whatever they did including art. They didn't even create dot painting that they love to exploit as their own. For them to create such artistic paintings is unlikely.
African Watusi
As he says - follow the money..... .the Incas disappeared completely. Nobody disputes that?
Such a great dude. His ideas may not be completely accurate but he did more to document and analyze these paintings than any human alive. Love his attitude and commitment to truth-finding. I'm going to make a video soon about these paintings and will be sure to highlight him
Should have took an elder and got permission
There’s an episode on Bush Tucker Man and Les said that the Indigenous disregard the paintings calling it “rubbish paintings”
Do some reading in Mungo Man, Ancient skeletal remains that appear different in character ie. height, appearance.
Love the Message. Songs gonna be stuck in my head all day now 😳 I'm not sure how to feel about that. Strangely it's kinda catchy.🤷♂
Mother of the devil
Who paintedthem? Who created the midden at Mungo?
He has his own fantasies, as an artisan on the American continent, I can't imagine all the art across this country would be the same, there were different cultures on that Australian Continent long before closed minded Brits got there, he needs to do more history with the Aboriginies on the Island before coming up with suppositions on his own.
What a load shit" i can see clearly with head designs are definitely belong to Aboriginal. Most our deep scared culture isnt knowing to most waknere out there, this rock art is definitely done by blackfellas
Here’s the thing, aboriginal average iq is…62. That should be the end of any dispute.
These comments make me sick as an indigenous man (Aboriginal/Torrest strait islander) we been here since megafauna, since Sahul, since the beginning of creation
Love the views of the kids, notbad.jpg.
Carbon dating.
theese are Indonesian
God don't let the voice elites see these they'll get them painted over
That aboriginal at 6:35 seems full of shit.
Couldn't be more obvious to even the casual viewer that they are completely different and look more African. Embarrassing academics on here. My 5 year old could tell the difference.
maybe it was done by the Papuans who were here first..
Bradshaw
Well I watched a magnificent documentary on ABC National Geographic and it showed the custodians of the artwork going round and touching up the artwork and they said and I quote. If we didn't go round and touch the artwork up they wouldn't be here. Interesting and yet no one said anything. And what about erosion if we take erosion into affect we would know that none of these rocks would be there. But the custodians of this ancient rock art have been touching up the paintings for years. And they showed us on camera how they did it amazing. So when you say these are 20 30. 40 50,000 years old. Is quite amazing because on the National Geographic Abc show tells a completely different story by the people who look after the indigenous people of Australia. And the other place in Western Australia where there's magnificent fossils. They are saying now if we don't put a shelter over them they will be gone within 10 to 15 years. That's amazing since they said they've been there for over 20 million years. And now they're saying that it's possible that they can disappear within 15. Because of erosion. In actual fact one of the greatest naturalist was John Gould and he said it is a miracle we still have the fossil record at the present rate of erosion. He knew the maths didn't add up. Because if you only take 5 million use the fossil record would've been wiped out at least three times at the present rate of a erosion. And at the back of Tamworth they have a dam that was made and it was supposed to be there for another thousand years because they built it where the granite was and is. But they didn't realise that the granite was disintegrating enormously fast and now the dam is completely fall right up to the top and now cows eat the grass where the water should be. So if we take away assumptions and theories it's amazing what you have left
Chaffee or split rock dam?
It's not Chaffey and it's not split Rock dam. It's actually at the back of Tamworth on the range. It's about 100 feet tall and we dug by hand and the concrete was mix by hand it was one of the very first and very very old dam@@lisilucyinski9455
Anyone who has attended university knows Academia is full of pet theories, superstitions, infighting. Most breakthroughs relying on new evidence were fought against as heresies. Nobody liked the established order being upset.
It made me laugh when listening to the two women “academics”, probably never saw a Bradshaw in person, let alone travel across the Kimberly ranges as many times as Graham had.
OK have your myths, but that does not mean your myth gets to block science and reality
There is a Bradshaw gallery near me. It’s unbelievable hand prints at the top of a cliff face.
So much garbage in this comments section. The only truth is right here. Who created this artwork???Not Bradshaw.
Alright, alright, l give up. It was me.
The Australian Aboriginals and leftist, corrupt archaeologists have stolen 60 000 years of history and a sophisticated very old culture that created the so-called Bradshaw Rock-art pictures in Kimbrley, NW Australia. Thay claim the aboriginals, egy even today stone-age people, have 64 000 years of history in Australia. In comparison, the Syeleta - Solutre stone age cultutre took 20 000 years to develop modern technology, to land on the Moon. The present-day Aboriginals have really had a history of 4 200 years in Australia. Genetic tests on 2000 Aboriginals throughout Australia have showed convincingly that the present-day Aboriginals migrated 4200 years ago from the South of India together with the domesticated ancestral dogs of dingos. Since the Bradshaw pieces of rock-art are at least 17 000 years old, by absolute dating, they cannot possibly be the work of the Gwoin Aboriginal people, or any other aboriginal tribe.
It's a matter of those who are seeking factual evidence and those who seek to make shit up.
I’ll be honest, that “aboriginal” guy looks like he’s making up what he’s talking about
Aboriginals are slaves from the Egypt in Queensland mountains there's story's of little blue people lived in rain forest that were story's I was told buy old timers
Africa lots of hominids, Europe lots of hominids, Asia, lots of hominids, India lots of hominids, South America one migrations lots of cultures. Australia only one group of people, ever. Dont ask questions!
I don't see Walsh as remotely racist in the way he is shown in this video, he is simply trying to figure out the origin with a very open mind without agenda except his search for the truth. Racism tag is trotted out so often, it has lost its original mean. When I hear of someone called a racist, it makes me think that person has his or her own agenda and will not tolerate dissent from their own view and wants to shut down the heretic but without reasoned argument to support their view.
In India in the 1990s, I have heard Indian tribal members talking in their language and was struck by how much it sounds like listening to Aussie blackfella talk, even the nasal tone. I wondered at the time if this is where Aussie blackfella originally came from. If yes, perhaps these blackfellas, when they came to Australia, were the dominating culture over these Bradshaw painters and the Bradshaw painters died out or were wiped out. I add this is only conjecture on my part.
Australian Aboriginals closest relative is the indigenous Indian and Pakistani people.
I find this a concept easy to accept. Be interesting to do a DNA analysis of Indian tribes and Aussue blackfellas.. Aussie Blackfella came from somewhere, could not have magically appeared here in Australia, could not have come out of 'thin air', @@Billy-jn6te
Sanitized that is the problem...He is spot on.
Dot painting was invented in 1971 by Geoffrey Bardon who then taught the style to aborigines. There are NO dot paintings ever found in ANY caves.
My friends don't believe it so I don't either. Ladies and gentlemen... SCIENCE!
The profession of Archaeology in Australia is completely swamped by politics. I would 100% trust a local historical society over anything a University Archaeologist/Historian says. I remember researching the WW2 riots that occurred in Melbourne. One historian said the authorities covered it up. One quick look at the papers, through trove, and it was on page 3 of the papers. Which is the next best page next to page 1.
Totally agree, the Government has covered up HEAPS of things for their own reasons, and they also have been rigging EVERY election since 1947, Fed, state and local, its all about to come out courtesy of the military.
The 'Welcome to Country' Ceremony was invented in 1976 by Ernie Dingo and Richard Walley to welcome Maori performers. There is no Aboriginal word for a 'Welcome To Country' like the Maori's Haka. How can it be an 'ancient Ceremony' if there is no word for it. How could someone say "Who's going to perform the Welcome to Country ceremony"? The 'Acknowledgement of Country' was invented in the 1990s. The 'Smoking' Ceremony is, also, a recent invention. There is NO film or video evidence of any of these ceremonies at important events such as royal tours, the 1956 Olympics, etc, prior to the 1970s and 1990s.
Spoiler: they're not 20k years old, they're about 12k years old, and they appear to have been painted by someone other than current "Aboriginal" people, who are, not in fact aboriginal at all - they're more recent arrivals. The original inhabitants of Australia are long gone. Daily reminder: the dingo has only been here 3400 years and isn't native either. The famous woomera is also relatively recent, at about the same age, brought to Australia with a wave of migration.
Yep recent dating attempts put them around ~12 kya. There are some cultural connections between the Bradshaw culture and historical tribes but many differences. Culturally, the bradshaw people remind me more of Papuan tribes in the Fly river area. I agree the woomera is relatively recent but it appears towards the end of the Bradshaw era
@26:58 That lady really buys into this ethereal, nebulous concept of the spirit realm creating this work of art, but is furiously opposed to any investigation that this may be a product of a race other than the Aboriginal one, which only serves to expose her for having an agenda. She was quick to argue (did you see the anger in her eyes, trying to intimidate the interviewer?) that no one could ever possibly prove his theory as it will only ever be speculation, yet she explains it away with all that spiritual claptrap, as if it’s fact. Yet even she wouldn’t even really be able to understand the specifics of the spiritual significance. Just another case of the Emperor’s New Clothes because some people just can’t handle the truth.
She, I bet had never seen a Bradshaw in person, only in pictures, probably taken by Graham himself.
Sure they arenot aliens
Archeology is not a science but a number count of the living today and money pushed into players hands will consimate the marriage. The women from England never looks at the camera when she speaks and looks all over the place as very nervous, will she resign when she is found wrong ?