the thing with mario maker is that all of those mario games share a lot of similarities just with different graphics, mario kart on the other hand has very complex scenarios and would need a lot of things to even remotely do something similar to the actual MK

Жыл бұрын

The modding community shows quite well how extremely difficult it is to make a good track. 99% of custom tracks are absolute grabage, boring to play at best. There are a few masterpieces, but those are the very rare exeptions. The flood of catastrophic mario maker levels is already immense and the good levels are scarce. And there it is exponentially easier to create good levels. Those track makers are a cool idea, but not feasible in practice in a way that we would expect. All games that featured them never offered good custom made tracks. The only thing those tracks were good for, are quick time trial sessions against other ghost players, but not for a real race session like we woulc expect on Mario Kart. All the good mario kart custom tracks were made using highly complicated developer tools and software, with features that a stage builder designed for 3 year olds could never offer or even compare to. Not that making racing tracks by consumers is impossible, but making good ones definitely is with the limitations the software would need to have to make a good, beginner friendly user experience. I see it just like you.

@fbm6573

Жыл бұрын

@ I completely agree. With seeing how much trash was made in Mario maker, which is much easier than a Maria kart maker would be, there’d be about 1,000 bad tracks for one single good track. It’s just not a good idea

@Miles4Daze

Жыл бұрын

I think it would work like LittleBIGPlanet Karting where you can make a track with a tool and go up, down, and sideways.

@JamesTDG

Жыл бұрын

Exactly, it's too intricate to be an imitator of smm. We all saw how complicated the sm64 maker fan project was. It's likely going to be a simple track creator like with existing ones rather than what was initially in mind.

@JamesTDG

Жыл бұрын

@@fbm6573 that's an understatement. Track design is far more difficult, it's gonna be at least 1 good for every 50k bad ones, and remember, this estimate is a floor, not a ceiling for how bad this ratio can become

I had this idea for a long while, and I’m so glad that other people are realizing this great idea!! 🏎️🏎️🏁

@nintendohub64

Жыл бұрын

I’ve thought about mariomakers for many game series the whole idea has so much potential

@balls.gaming.

Жыл бұрын

@@nintendohub64 true, you could make any track you want with any style. I honestly think this would be better than Mario Maker 3.

@nintendohub64

Жыл бұрын

@@balls.gaming. yeah I’d take MARIOKART maker over Mariomaker 3 anyday

@balls.gaming.

Жыл бұрын

@@nintendohub64 if Nintendo doesn’t release this I’m going to be sad.

@EthanCole2009

Жыл бұрын

Same

Nintendo, hire this man.

@TheSpeedfoever

Жыл бұрын

Well he has to tweet at them and then go to their HQ for an interview and has to be lucky to get in

@Bluebewychannel

Жыл бұрын

@@TheSpeedfoever yeah and Nintendo probably won’t hire him bc he’s a yt anyways

@dylanmatiashernandezv.2195

Жыл бұрын

Im a worker from nintendo and hes hired

@wildcat9036

Жыл бұрын

Yes

@faclonx6275

Жыл бұрын

@@dylanmatiashernandezv.2195 there no way you work for Nintendo

I want to hire Nin10doland because he's speaking FACTS

LittleBigPlanet Karting had a track creator mode as well, and I think this idea could adopt the system that that game used.

@_RK_800_

Жыл бұрын

Agreed

@giddygoon73

Жыл бұрын

That's what I was going to say-

@m1d45r3x

Жыл бұрын

I love little big planet karting | and the 3 original games as well alongside a big adventure

@BrickShorts8118

Жыл бұрын

@@m1d45r3x man is speaking fax

@motizz69420

Жыл бұрын

@@m1d45r3x saaaame i had all games on the ps3

if this game ever comes out, i can't wait to see all the impossible kaizo levels people are gonna throw at Dashie

Awesome game idea! I’m excited to race on Unfair Kaizo tracks! And recreate Racing games tracks.

@pixelthecat7752

Жыл бұрын

Don't get excited

Trackmania is a huge success. Also fans were making Mario levels, Nintendo saw the market -- and we got Super Mario Maker games. Hopefully something like that is already in the works.

@JamesTDG

Жыл бұрын

Sadly Nintendo's creation didn't have nearly enough features the fan made ones have, like Smashy for example is already adding more features in a shorter time than Nintendo.

We need this now

Really like some ideas here so i thought i'd share some of my own: Track Templates: Several original mariokart tracks can be used to showcase how different aspects work, for example mushroom gorge could be one so people learn about how to use mushrooms in tracks ect More themes: I feel like some themes were missed out, especially city tracks like Tour tracks or Moonview highway or mushroom city, as well as beach tracks that arent based on underwater Item modes: I feel like for certain things there should be an item that you can place that switches you, like the SMB2 mushroom or SML flower. Some of these could include: double dash (automatically picks the character's partner), Mariokart Wii Wheeling on bikes, Old drifting from games like MKDD and MKDS, etc. I feel this would be less prominent in the retro themes but good in the 3D theme

The amount of coconut mall levels people would make…

@ericgrasso3066

Жыл бұрын

Coconut Mall 2, 3, etc, or people would probably make extremely insane and chaotic versions of Coconut Mall...

@valeriebreidenstein8362

Жыл бұрын

@@ericgrasso3066 Like they did with Luigi Circuit from Mario Kart Wii. Still funny trying to beat the track with too many pipes on the road 🤣

Dudes literally got a full library of ideas

For the track building elements, I say they should take a piece out of LBP Karting’s book and allow the player to unroll the road and be able to chance the roads shape and size as you go, being able to widen the track in certain spots, make them more narrow, Curl them inward to make a half pipe, Divide the paths into a split path, Add and Remove Guard Rails to preferred sides of the track, Add Bumps in the certain of the track to trick off of and in the 8 Deluxe Style, be able to use the triggers to warp the track to different angles or create side walls to use the antigravity on. Then when you have a lay out, you can decorate the track with background terrain, Setpieces, and obstacles, you could also be able to place different types of textures on the ground that have different properties, like Dirt, Grass, Sand and Pools of Water, Lava, Poison or Quicksand.

Mario Kart Tour shows how a Mario Kart Maker would work. I don’t care if it’s a top down maker, I don’t care if it’s limited at first, *JUST PLEASE GIVE US ONE AT SOME POINT.* I get it, the RC one exists, but who has the space in their home? With pets and people with apartments it’s very difficult to use the real life maker. Please Nintendo, as someone who spends *hours* in maker games. Please give us one at some point.

I don’t feel like this would ever realistically happen because of fear it would cannibalize the sales of Nintendo’s futures Mario karts. Similar to what Mario maker did to the 2D Mario games. Nintendo would logically want to keep Mario kart around because it’s always a game guaranteed to make Nintendo lots of sales

Infinite Mario Kart tracks, making my favourite video game of all time even more infinitely replayable than it already is? Dude I would pop off so hard if they announced this. Imagine an announcement trailer where it just looks like a regular race and then all the racers hit a wall and then the Mario Maker tools pop up. That would get some killer reactions. I love this concept you’ve made and with a bit of Nintendo magic I think this could be something really special.

@jaegertw2

Жыл бұрын

FakeFantum was the best player me

I really hope Nintendo sees this and gets the hint

Wooooah amazing idea! 🤯

I’ve wanted this for SO LONG, Nintendo PLEASE watch this!

I really thought about this concept and think it is smart to start much more limited. Just have the different selectable themes be the themes you have in SNES Mario Kart and omit any SNES track of being a retro track. Also only to have it in the style of the current game (so MK8/9). Other than that you could be very free with everything like placing water, lava, anti-gravity, paragliding, cannons, enemies, pipes, oil slips etc etc

Even before Mario Maker came out, I wanted this really bad. I wanted an official way to make custom tracks without having to use blender on CTGP. If they made this, I would spend all my money.

@ricardopratt5190

Жыл бұрын

So you had 1000 billion dollars and thats how much it cost would gou buy it I know I would they basically running my pockets

@Z64sports

Жыл бұрын

Does that mean you're buying all the copies?

That would be INSANE if that were to happen! I would be down for that!

Might wanna save something this big and spectacular like this for our 40th anniversary, which is in 2 years

It wont work since they did planned to have a channel based on the idea in the Wii when Mario Kart Wii was revealed or something like that but it was scrapped due to either time constraints OR to much memory because of the 3D models and the Item customization is the closest maker we ever going to get in a Mario Kart title.

Another theme we need: City theme. Several Mario Kart tracks take place in a city, most notably New York Minute.

@valeriebreidenstein8362

Жыл бұрын

True. And there are so many city tracks, which are really cool but hard to play. Mushroom City, Moonview Highway, to name two. Making your own would be really cool.

YES!! I’ve been thinking about this since 2015

I think that your themes were cool, but imagine a custom theme with all the assets! And customers sprites! Obviously, these would need extra moderation, but it would be so cool!

This would probelly be the best mario game ever. It would be fun seeing dashiegames trying to beat the hardest possible courses

I don’t think anyone realizes how hard making a track editor like this actually be intuitive would be

I feel like we don’t have enough risk reward Items. SO! Mini mushroom - Shrinks the player but gives them a speed boost. Storm Cloud - Returns from wii Big Bomb - A much bigger Bob-omb that you can set down and activate it when you want, if it hits you big spin out.

@courage1363

Жыл бұрын

Technically we already have one called the Giga Bob omb in Tour.

been begging for this for years

if nintendo would make a mario kart maker for PC, then an official game on switch were you could upload the games you make - a community would come together and make a awesome game

Seeing this idea become publicly wanted gives me hope!

ive been wanting this for a while

One of the best game idea I've ever heard!

From a game dev's perspective, it's really unlikely they'd decide to do this unfortunately due to the sheer complexity of a full on 3D map editor (with decent optimization & good visuals) compared to a 2D tile based one 😮‍💨

ive had this idea for like 10 years. rly want it

That would be so great

I like the idea, but I feel like it would be too complicated having all the decorations, and if anything, it will look worse than the tracks that we have for the booster courses

@mr.derpyface558

Жыл бұрын

It could (to a lesser extent) have the décor automatically generated like with Mario maker.

I was thinking about this idea

I just think Mario Kart 9 will come with an editor. Is the only thing the franchise needs to add to the already perfect formula.

this would be better then mk9. Making own tracks would be crazy, We could also mae super cool long tracks it would be fun to unlock certain assets for tracks or design every day until you played 31 days a bit like mario maker on the wii u but longer and it would be fun seeing what new track parts you get every day

“What if we had a Mariokart maker?” Bro that’s what I’ve been saying since Mario maker 2 came out

super nice video ❤️‍🔥

this is actualy amazing the actual mario kart 9 fan makers

I LOVE that custom trophy idea.

This is a epic idea I wish it existed

I NEVER THOUGHT OF THIS OH MY GOD!!! this would literally be awesome I'd really like to build A track that's good for steering wheels if ur gonna be using one because I'm gonna order one

Yeah! I love this idea! 0:01 I hope Nintendo is going to do it!!!!!!!!!!

Awesome video

These are all interesting ideas and I liked the video as well as subscribed to your channel. Here are my thoughts for each category: Styles: I would like to see a Mario Kart DS style included and would prefer it over Mario Kart Super Circuit if I had to choose. I would also like to see Mario Kart Double Dash, but I understand it might be a bit more difficult and they likely won't be able to include styles from every game. Themes: I agree but I would also like to see a little bit more such as a city/highway theme and a mountain theme. Alternatively, maybe mountains, cars, skyscrapers, etc. are all things that can be added to any theme in track design. Track Design: I agree. I would like to see a lot of custom options such as how long or short the course can be, its shape and the amount of laps such as 1 big lap, 3 laps, 5 or 7. Enemies: I agree. There are so many options here. Objects: I agree. Of course coins and item boxes can be added onto the track as well. Items: Classics such as red shells, green shells, bananas and mushrooms should definitely be included as well as more powerful items such as the invincibility star, lightning bolt, golden mushroom and bullet bill. While more controversial, the blue shell should also be an option. I would also like to be able to customize what items can be received in which places players are in. For example, I would like to be able to choose whether players can receive a lightning bolt from 8th-12th place, 7th-12th place, 6th-12th place, etc. A bit off topic but relating to this, I would also like to be able to race other racers, CPUs or race and personally control multiple characters at once in the tracks I create, and be able to choose how many racers there are in a race such as 8 or 12. Characters: I would like to be able to customize the roster of how many characters and which ones I would like to include in my courses from a variety of options. Of course, Mario, Luigi, Peach, Toad, Yoshi, Bowser, Donkey Kong, Wario and Koopa Troopa are a given for just about every Mario Kart game. Other characters that I feel should definitely be included are Waluigi, Bowser Jr., Koopa Troopa, Shy Guy, Daisy, Birdo, Baby Mario, Baby Luigi, Toadette and Dry Bones. I would also like to be able to customize between different colors of Yoshis, Shy Guys, etc. More characters I would like to see included as options are Rosalina, Diddy Kong, Wiggler, Dry Bowser, Nokis, Piantas, King Boo, Funky Kong, Dixie Kong, Baby Peach, Baby Daisy, R.O.B., Magikoopa, Petey Pirahna and the Koopalings. Toadsworth is another character that would be cool to include as well. Weather/Time of Day: I completely agree! This needs to be included. Online: I strongly agree, this would make the game a lot more fun. Conclusion: I really hope Nintendo makes a Mario Kart Maker. It would very possibly be the most enjoyable game Nintendo ever makes, or at least one of the most enjoyable. In order for this to work however there has to be a lot of different elements included like the ones you mentioned in your video. I hope it won't be missing a lot like in Super Mario Maker 1 or Super Mario Maker for the 3DS.

I was talking about this with my brother a few days ago! These are my ideas: STYLES: Super Mario Kart, Mario Kart: Double Dash, Mario Kart Wii and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe. THEMES: The same you said on the video. ITEMS: depends of the game, each style would have its own items. ENEMIES: Goombas, chain chomps, piranha plants, monty moles, cars on the city theme, oil stains, that worm from the desert which name I forgot, and obviously, Shy Guys. INTERACTIVE AND DECORATIVE STUFF: Trees, light poles, walls, holes, ramps, outdoors, pipes, cones, rocks, mushrooms (and some derivatives) and arrows. TYPES OF TRACK: Ground, asphalt (the only type that would accept cars), bridge, wood, rainbow, indoor floors, and rainbow. ALSO: Possibility of making battle tracks; The online mode you said on the video; Number of laps/sectored track is proportional to the track's length. THESE ARE MY 2 CENTS FOR A POTENTIAL MARIO KART MAKER!!

I’ve had this idea for 6 years!

When I was a kid, there was some sort of mario lego track builder toy. You could just snap pieces together. They could make something similar if they (Hopefully) make a Mario Kart Maker.

I can already see the Mario kart troll levels😂

While this all sounds great, I think one big thing about Mario Kart is how varied and unique set pieces, themes and music are. Maybe to go along with the track creator, you could have a modeling tool to create certain pieces and customize your track to what you envision. You could really detail your set pieces and change colours, add textures, etc. Along with this, it might be cool to be able to combine themes, like a city and beach for Coconut Mall or a mountain and plains for Shroom Ridge. Finally it would be awesome to be able to create your own music, or use existing music, with a simple music editor, GarageBand style. These are the things that really make the good tracks, and it would be a great change from just generic grass, desert, and snow themes

Yeah, me and my brother have wanted this, mostly me lol!

Nintendo should have made this, and it was a long time since we want a track editor. I remember Modnation Racers, which is an underrated game, and it makes me wish we can create our own tracks. Couple of the fact that many videos show custom tracks in such games. Nintendo, do it! It’s a long wanted game that we want!

Bro, me and my brother thought of a super Mario kart maker for like 4 months now I’ve been praying Nintendo listens to this video!!!!!!

I have an idea maybe like a playtest button that makes you go through a camera run through of the track also maybe have a line that shows the path and a setting to toggle the line.

Good job 👍 😮

Great idea send this to Nintendo dude

The last few days your on my start page but without that i wiuld have found your channel

Amazing

finally someone thinks of something im thinking of

Very interesting.

What we really need is a Mario GTA Type game. Getting in and out your Kart and exploring Maps and taking down Bosses collection things

Me: Mario Kart Live: Home Circuit exists! Everybody else: What's that

mario kart maker we need this bro

Me before sub demand: Gaming! Me after sub demand with king goomba: Gaming, WITH GUN!

Happy new year!!!

theres one theme im surprised you didnt mention, which is a mountain theme, like Wuhu Mountain Loop (aka Maka Wuhu), but i guess you could combine that with the other themes

What would be even better is making an official custom track dlc, similar to ctgp, maybe they could add that once they are done with the booster course pass

I remember wanting Mario Kart 8 to have a level editor. I also used to play around with a Super Mario Kart track editor called EpicEdit, removing walls to cheat and making Rainbow Road's purple tiles pink so it looked more like the Mario Kart 7 version. I even contacted and got replies back from the author!

Modnation racers, you just explained Modnation racers.

little big planet karting was so fun for this reason

great vid personally I think this will happen

saludos nin10donald... esa idea también la eh pensado igual la idea de un Mario Maker 3d... tenemos la misma forma de pensar y eso me agrada mucho... saludos desde México

I think Nintendo aims their games towards more younger audiences, so they would probably have to simplify a lot of the stuff you’ve mentioned in this video

I’m thinking that it can also be playable offline, with friends, family, or CPUs, overall, this is a great idea!

Would be amazing

If this comes out we’ll get a lot of Little Timmy levels. I mean, just look at GBA BC3 RT

I think it would be cool if you could choose a song for your track and there would be every track song ever.

I have never thought about this, but this is genius. But if this were to happen, I'd hope they wouldn't forget about Battle mode. Also, for the upload criteria, maybe it'd have an automatic checkpoint system that you can mess with manually if you want, as well as making an out-of-bounds area where Lakitu drags you back. Also, each course would need to be completed in each CC for it to be available in said CC. You could upload in only one CC, but that'd mean that it'd only be available in said CC. So if I made a course and completed it in 50 CC to upload, I can't play in 200 CC until I clear the course in that CC.

Yeah, good ideas an all, but this is literally impossible. But if somehow they do it I'll be super happy haha

I would be down for a Mario Kart Maker I love games that let you be creative

A City theme would be nice like you could add Cars and trucks and degsine them how you want

Hurry up and hire him for Mario _____ maker games

Given a long, long time of development, I think this could work

If we get this I hope that Nintendo changes rainbow roads to ruins because thwomp ruins is iconic

The fact that Nintendo hasn't made a Mariokart Maker yet baffles me.

Why have they never done this yet? Maybe they could even add double dash elements

I dreamed of this

You could also add different track music from past Mario games!

You deserve to have a developer position in Nintendo

I would take this as the next Mario Kart game over 9! 🏎️

Home Circuit crying out loud in the shadow realm

This man

We need this as the next game

I am full of ideas if it ever came to fruition. It reminds me a lot of LittleBigPlanet Karting and Modnation Racers and I really enjoyed those two games out of the PS3 which I don't really care about PlayStation after that point. Also... Nin10doland... what world do you live in where Mario Kart Super Circuit is called Mario Kart *Super Sircuit* . Ha ha ha!