‘We don’t have to do it’: Bob Carr criticises Australia’s record immigration levels

Former New South Wales premier Bob Carr has criticised Australia’s record migration levels, saying we “don’t have to do it” to “guarantee Australia’s prosperity”.
Immigration to Australia has reached record numbers with more migrants arriving in January than ever before - 125,000 permanent and long-term arrivals.
“I’ve been trying to get Australia to understand that we do not need to have the highest rate of immigration, in proportion to our population, in the world,” Mr Carr told Sky News host Erin Molan.
“We’ve got third-world rates of immigration, and we don’t need it.
“Australians, especially those in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane … I just wonder why this is the only economic model we’ve got - to force feed population growth, to run the highest imaginable immigration intake, and to condemn our big cities to a relentless chase to keep up in terms of infrastructure.
“We don’t have to do it to guarantee Australia’s prosperity.”

Пікірлер: 783

  • @rickman2267
    @rickman22672 ай бұрын

    All migrants housed, thousands of Australians homeless or cant rent a place! Disgraceful.

  • @Genesis-007

    @Genesis-007

    2 ай бұрын

    We can only blame the sheep voting for thy wrong parties, One Nation will send them back given the opportunity

  • @thewastednukes

    @thewastednukes

    2 ай бұрын

    personal reresponsibility. Homeless aussies are just fucking stupid and dont know how to read. all these asian doctors and nurses are working hard and buyinmg property like good liberal voters do. its always the dumb poor aussies who compalin when they cant get ahead. take some responsibility.

  • @amz33894

    @amz33894

    2 ай бұрын

    @@Genesis-007 100% spot on. 4 people to a room with families living in parks as another youtuber commented. Meanwhile the average Politician, senior executive level public servant, magistrates and judges are on $9000+ a week. When will Australians say enough. When homeless encampments are a thing.

  • @Genesis-007

    @Genesis-007

    2 ай бұрын

    @@amz33894 more reasons to Vote for One Nation 👍

  • @amz33894

    @amz33894

    2 ай бұрын

    @@Genesis-007 Any political party who proposes a bill of rights in an anti freedom climate is surely worth a look.

  • @scottlewisparsons9551
    @scottlewisparsons95512 ай бұрын

    This is the first time that I have agreed with Bob Carr! The Albanese Labor government is not acting in the interests of Australians.

  • @georgekordis4268

    @georgekordis4268

    2 ай бұрын

    Neither of them are time to give united Australia party or one nation a go.

  • @scottlewisparsons9551

    @scottlewisparsons9551

    2 ай бұрын

    @@georgekordis4268 I agree!

  • @kjjviii1735

    @kjjviii1735

    2 ай бұрын

    All albo is doing is trying to fight off a recession at the expense of everyone else. Kicking the bucket down the road to create a bigger problem for someone else.

  • @Kelly-wf5ie

    @Kelly-wf5ie

    2 ай бұрын

    U 🤔 ?? Take a 👀 at the LAST 50++ years , notice ANY difference ?? Honestly , by now if ppl CANNOT see EXACTLY what ALL “ government “ has + continues to do to those whom PAY their WAGES etc.. they’re totally DELUSIONAL + need the straight jacket !! There is PLENTY of evidence/ proof that for the last 1/2 century ++ that NONE of these vermin ( politicians) are EVEN AUTHORISED TO HOLD OFFICE etc… NO WONDER the OZ people are SUFFERING, when they have people “ masquerading “ as Commonwealth Officials !!

  • @paulharrisonadventuregearm5457

    @paulharrisonadventuregearm5457

    2 ай бұрын

    Started with the Bloody LIBERALS!!!! Labour have just kept it going

  • @veronicabatteham9864
    @veronicabatteham98642 ай бұрын

    We don't have the infrastructure , why wreck a fantastic country 😡😡

  • @nocomment1683

    @nocomment1683

    2 ай бұрын

    I agree 100%

  • @thegallantsaint2034

    @thegallantsaint2034

    2 ай бұрын

    Albo doesn’t work for Australia. He is a globalist who sucks Schwab’s shlong

  • @derekthompson2868

    @derekthompson2868

    2 ай бұрын

    They've been wrecking it for decades!!

  • @S.Carrick

    @S.Carrick

    2 ай бұрын

    That's Sleazy the sneaks intention, to bring our once wonderful Australia to her knees, it suits his Communist agenda! 🤮🤮

  • @christinebell37

    @christinebell37

    2 ай бұрын

    I agree. And I came here as a highly skilled, highly educated, and highly experienced migrant who had to follow strict requirements to even be allowed to stay. I funded my way, secured a job in a month and I've never relied on Centrelink. But that was when immigration practices were actually true to the objectives of immigration policy

  • @edmundm2002
    @edmundm20022 ай бұрын

    Sadly, Australia is now run as a "fly by night company" and not a proud nation.

  • @user-ds2ej3wn8p

    @user-ds2ej3wn8p

    2 ай бұрын

    Sco Mo and Albo will give them a big bowl of curry as they arrive

  • @andyjay9346
    @andyjay93462 ай бұрын

    IT'S NOT JUST HOUSING * Water * Power Electricity * Food * Health Hospitals and the list goes on

  • @themoxcast

    @themoxcast

    2 ай бұрын

    Water should be the first 5 points on this list. Next drought, we're in real proper trouble.

  • @user-ds2ej3wn8p

    @user-ds2ej3wn8p

    2 ай бұрын

    But there will be more Indian lackys and they will work for half the wages of Aussies, the union jack must be replaced with the Indian flag and Indians should be on the banknotes not big ears!

  • @jonh9561
    @jonh95612 ай бұрын

    It's now taking me over two hours to get home from work each day and I live and work within Brisbane!

  • @Schwabian

    @Schwabian

    2 ай бұрын

    Same in melbo

  • @andydavies2582
    @andydavies25822 ай бұрын

    I actually thought Australia didn't have these problems ever coming to them like the UK. We are now f... and beyond fixable. 😢

  • @galacticnemesis366

    @galacticnemesis366

    2 ай бұрын

    Same problems just a little behind. Watch what happens in the UK and the US it’s like taking a peak into Australia’s future. Put Labor and the Greens last is key. Not just vote One Nation. Australians have to put Labor and the Greens last as well as put One Nation first. Educate your people and let the word spread. 😎👍👊🇦🇺

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    That;s because both nations are useless and whinge too much

  • @benjamindelfs2718

    @benjamindelfs2718

    2 ай бұрын

    We should of used the UK as an example of what not to follow. White British citizens are a minority now to Africans, Arabic’s and especially Pakistanis. There are whole towns and areas that belong to them. Google Islam in luton, England and you’ll see Australia’s future if we don’t stop it like France and Denmark are doing.

  • @jamesaustralian9829
    @jamesaustralian98292 ай бұрын

    Bob is one of the rare few that actually has some common sense

  • @user-mn6jz2sr5n
    @user-mn6jz2sr5n2 ай бұрын

    Dick Smith in previous decades mooted the idea of not exceeding 22 million in population to protect the way of life and also the environment whilst not squandering recourses at the same time securing a future for our unique Australian wildlife which is in dramatic decline. We don't need to follow the mistakes of the rest of the world by destroying what little of our great East coastline is left .

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    I think it may be too late already. They go on and on about green energy and protecting the environment while destroying it at lightning pace. The Koala which is a symbol of Australia is now an endangered species because of over development and loss of habitat as well as many were killed in the massive 2019 bushfires.🔥 🐨🌿

  • @antpoo

    @antpoo

    2 ай бұрын

    It’s clear he lost the big Australia debate and we are fast on our way to 50 million. Life getting miserable now I don’t bother to go do things because there are just too many other ppl. Big population is misery, No matter how much your bottom line improves.

  • @karlpartridge9546
    @karlpartridge95462 ай бұрын

    Number one reason for why over half of aussies canadians and kiwis are struggling. Way too many migrants from developing nations inequality, poverty and, homelessness has increased as more lower wage workers are allowed in not to mention decline of middle class our billionaires depend on these migrants for cheap easily manipulated lobour

  • @richardbrown9344

    @richardbrown9344

    2 ай бұрын

    Kalergi Plan, the covert scheme to destroy the west from within.

  • @karlpartridge9546
    @karlpartridge95462 ай бұрын

    India receives nearly 2 billion usd from australia in remittance money every year thats two billion that is not spent in aussie economy

  • @Ausman84204

    @Ausman84204

    2 ай бұрын

    The problem lies with Australian government, why allow so many people at once while citizens are struggling to make the ends meet?

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    you can solve this issue, migrate the complete families of those who are making the remittances

  • @Jin-oq2qu

    @Jin-oq2qu

    2 ай бұрын

    Everywhere I go, I see Indian people.

  • @chriswatson1698

    @chriswatson1698

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sometingwongwai9679 How is that a solution? They will all get old and in the meantime, they will compete with Australians for the use of urban land, infrastructure and public services.

  • @antpoo

    @antpoo

    2 ай бұрын

    Is that remittance so Modhi would allow the migration of millions of Sikhs? Which he doesn’t even want anyway.

  • @seaworldsocialartslecturer4160
    @seaworldsocialartslecturer41602 ай бұрын

    Australians are being played. Australia exported more gas than Qatar . Last year. But Australia only earned 2 billion in revenue while Qatar earned 78 billion. Wealth distribution.

  • @georgekordis4268

    @georgekordis4268

    2 ай бұрын

    And who's our major buyer you guessed it China so their keeping warm over their while people here can't afford to turn the heater on because their getting blatantly ripped off nice work government.

  • @fredericksmith7418

    @fredericksmith7418

    2 ай бұрын

    Chevron have a 50 year tax free gas from their Barrow Island reserves and gas plant because the price to build it blew out from 20 million to 60 to 70 million so they pay no tax plus it was built completely on a nature reserve. Their carbon capture has never worked from day one .

  • @fredericksmith7418

    @fredericksmith7418

    2 ай бұрын

    Sorry revised 60 to 70 billion not million so they have a long tax credit

  • @kenlydon1395

    @kenlydon1395

    2 ай бұрын

    No surprise ,the Yanks OWN Australia and are busy selling it to China or any other country needing resources. Time for Aussies to get mad and take back their country.,Nationalize ALL natural resources and then ask the people what they want and how much they want to export .@@fredericksmith7418

  • @jamesblackie4195
    @jamesblackie41952 ай бұрын

    Send the immigrants to the Canberra ACT if they want more people put another 100000 people there overnight see how there community runs.

  • @lyleessex4631

    @lyleessex4631

    2 ай бұрын

    Maybe they could be put up in parliament house

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    Already there mate, who do you think runs the cafe, restaurants, cleans public building at night (parliament house), cleaners, laborers

  • @richardcharlton8259

    @richardcharlton8259

    2 ай бұрын

    They are all ready here take a drive to the area of Gungahlin it’s like living in another country

  • @richardbemelen7287

    @richardbemelen7287

    2 ай бұрын

    They can all go live with Abul Rizvi, former deputy secretary of the department of immigration. He's the one who developed these mass immigration policies, as well as urging Howard and Costello to jack up the rate of immigration. The smug sod actually thinks his disastrous policies have benefited Australia. He lives in Canberra, so he doesn't have to deal with the consequences of his destructive policies.

  • @evabyrne-kr1fz

    @evabyrne-kr1fz

    2 ай бұрын

    I live in Canberra and i can say that i walked to the shops today and only saw three white people.

  • @brucejay1409
    @brucejay14092 ай бұрын

    Mr Carr is absolutely correct. Twenty years of excessive (mainly Third World) immigration into Australia has been a disaster. With the economy slipping into recession and homelessness rising on a daily basis, the whole nightmare has been a pointless sham. Most of Australia's foreign students come from dirt poor countries. They have no reason to go home. I doubt that a lot of them are finishing or barely even starting their studies. They're probably jumping ship, immediately, going straight into full time work.... and sending much/ most of their incomes back home. Australia is doomed. I left last year.. and now living in a much better environment elsewhere around the Pacific. Would never go back to Australia....it's a lost cause

  • @kirannnnnn

    @kirannnnnn

    2 ай бұрын

    The Colonisation has to end in Australia Without Natural resources Australia is a fifth world country

  • @vikingbulk8531

    @vikingbulk8531

    2 ай бұрын

    You're spot on. What's really sad is that so many of them openly tell you and laugh that they pick pointless degrees just to get a visa.

  • @briananderson7285

    @briananderson7285

    2 ай бұрын

    Vote One Nation, they have sensible immigration policy.

  • @rennmaxbeta

    @rennmaxbeta

    2 ай бұрын

    Which country did you move to, for future reference?

  • @markferguson7563

    @markferguson7563

    2 ай бұрын

    Attention: The Member for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, City of Sydney Councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Minister for Housing, Rose Jackson. On June 5, 2023, between 6pm - 7pm the federal MP for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, along with the City of Sydney councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Housing Minister, Rose Jackson, were invited by the community activist group, RedWatch, to address a meeting held at the Alexandia Town Hall, in Garden St, Alexandria, which was called: ‘The Federal Government’s Housing Policy’ As it transpired, these cretins spoke the usual drivel that always spills out of the mouths of politicians, whenever they are under pressure with having to front up, and answer the concerns of disgruntled constituents. Well, what a pitifully embarrassing scenario it was that evening to observe this trio having the temerity to, on the one hand, succor the stresses of local people who were under pressure, with either finding abodes to rent and, worse still, having to pay excessive rents. But, on the other hand, they all support large scale immigration intakes. Thus, mass immigration intakes is the irrefutable bane of the problem with why three is a critical shortage of properties to rent, and more so with exorbitant rents. The most glaringly acute aspect of the open-border programs existing within this inner-city zone of Sydney prevails with international students. Apropos to the number of international students in Australia from China, on Tuesday March 12, a friend of mine who runs a significant sized export business in Shanghai, told me (paraphrasing him) what someone from the consulate informed him of: ‘On March 3, the number of foreign students from China studying in Australia rose above the peak of 356,000 that were here in November 2019. By the end of April when universities are in full swing, the number of foreign students from China in Australia will exceed 380,000. Since October 2023, in the vicinity of 15,000 of these students from China have found lodgings within 6 kilometers of the consulate here in Camperdown.’ To put the 380,000 figure into perspective is to state that, the United States with a population THIRTEEN TIMES that of Australia, according to Prof. Victor Davis-Hanson is that, there are 350,000 students from China in the US. Therefore, what a gross insult it was for these cretins to have the impudence to front up at the meeting on June 5, and pretend to concerned with the plights of their Australians who are aggrieved with property shortages and excessive rents, when these grubs all support big immigration programs to propel GDP.

  • @hl5910
    @hl59102 ай бұрын

    Labor work for the w.e.f and not the Australian people. High immigration is the sign of a failing government that can't handle the economy.

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    Albanese is absolutely a Glo Ball who does the Biden of the WEF.

  • @amz33894
    @amz338942 ай бұрын

    Australia does not have entire industries that require a cheap labor force. Australia has no industries at all.

  • @KT-bb1tb

    @KT-bb1tb

    2 ай бұрын

    That was because of Labor's LIMA Agreement !

  • @amz33894

    @amz33894

    2 ай бұрын

    @@KT-bb1tb Exactly. Started giving 3rd word shit holes a start, now we're giving them everything.

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    @@KT-bb1tbwithout the LIMA agreement your inflation rate would be sitting around 800%

  • @galacticnemesis366

    @galacticnemesis366

    2 ай бұрын

    And it’s getting worse because what little manufacturing is left are heading over seas because of the cost of energy which is being pushed higher by their delusional push towards net zero. Put Labor and the Greens last is key. Not just vote One Nation. Australians have to put Labor and the Greens last as well as put One Nation first. Educate your people and let the word spread. 😎👍👊🇦🇺

  • @amz33894

    @amz33894

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sometingwongwai9679 LIMA was not the only contributing factor. Inflation is almost purely a currency debasement issue.

  • @karlpartridge9546
    @karlpartridge95462 ай бұрын

    Billionaires depend on low wage migrant workers to grow wealth

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    How? when there is a wage structure and all billionaire companies have to undergo an EBA

  • @elduderino7767

    @elduderino7767

    2 ай бұрын

    this is bigger than billionaires, far bigger, start at trillionaires and then maybe you'll get a bit warmer if billionaires had their way they'd abolish the minimum wage not ramp up mass immigration this is about homogenising populations - starting with the west

  • @bigrobsydney

    @bigrobsydney

    2 ай бұрын

    Thats just stupid. There is a minimum wage, set in Australia, by Australian authorities. Any individuals or organisations that deliberately underpay, are subject to criminal prosecution, again, by Australian authorities. Stop spouting crap.

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    If they weren't here people would pay more than minimum wage to get the job done.@@bigrobsydney

  • @Chad.H.
    @Chad.H.2 ай бұрын

    Vote one nation or independent, never vote the 4 major parties divide the power by voting minor parties

  • @dontbeasheeple5883

    @dontbeasheeple5883

    2 ай бұрын

    Until we get rid of the preferential voting system, we'll always be stuck with the ALP/LNP uniparty

  • @lyleessex4631

    @lyleessex4631

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@dontbeasheeple5883• well said i agree with you 💯%.

  • @lyleessex4631

    @lyleessex4631

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@dontbeasheeple5883 • well said i agree with you 💯%.

  • @thewastednukes

    @thewastednukes

    2 ай бұрын

    personal reresponsibility. Homeless aussies are just fucking stupid and dont know how to read. all these asian doctors and nurses are working hard and buyinmg property like good liberal voters do. its always the dumb poor aussies who compalin when they cant get ahead. take some responsibility.

  • @galacticnemesis366

    @galacticnemesis366

    2 ай бұрын

    @@dontbeasheeple5883 Put Labor and the Greens last is key. Not just vote One Nation. Australians have to put Labor and the Greens last as well as put One Nation first. Educate your people and let the word spread. 😎👍👊🇦🇺

  • @TheChivasRegal
    @TheChivasRegal2 ай бұрын

    Put immigration to a vote. Most people do not want this. But unfortunately we no longer live in a democracy.

  • @markferguson7563

    @markferguson7563

    2 ай бұрын

    Attention: The Member for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, City of Sydney Councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Minister for Housing, Rose Jackson. On June 5, 2023, between 6pm - 7pm the federal MP for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, along with the City of Sydney councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Housing Minister, Rose Jackson, were invited by the community activist group, RedWatch, to address a meeting held at the Alexandia Town Hall, in Garden St, Alexandria, which was called: ‘The Federal Government’s Housing Policy’ As it transpired, these cretins spoke the usual drivel that always spills out of the mouths of politicians, whenever they are under pressure with having to front up, and answer the concerns of disgruntled constituents. Well, what a pitifully embarrassing scenario it was that evening to observe this trio having the temerity to, on the one hand, succor the stresses of local people who were under pressure, with either finding abodes to rent and, worse still, having to pay excessive rents. But, on the other hand, they all support large scale immigration intakes. Thus, mass immigration intakes is the irrefutable bane of the problem with why three is a critical shortage of properties to rent, and more so with exorbitant rents. The most glaringly acute aspect of the open-border programs existing within this inner-city zone of Sydney prevails with international students. Apropos to the number of international students in Australia from China, on Tuesday March 12, a friend of mine who runs a significant sized export business in Shanghai, told me (paraphrasing him) what someone from the consulate informed him of: ‘On March 3, the number of foreign students from China studying in Australia rose above the peak of 356,000 that were here in November 2019. By the end of April when universities are in full swing, the number of foreign students from China in Australia will exceed 380,000. Since October 2023, in the vicinity of 15,000 of these students from China have found lodgings within 6 kilometers of the consulate here in Camperdown.’ To put the 380,000 figure into perspective is to state that, the United States with a population THIRTEEN TIMES that of Australia, according to Prof. Victor Davis-Hanson is that, there are 350,000 students from China in the US. Therefore, what a gross insult it was for these cretins to have the impudence to front up at the meeting on June 5, and pretend to concerned with the plights of their Australians who are aggrieved with property shortages and excessive rents, when these grubs all support big immigration programs to propel GDP.

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    The central and retail bankers want it. Australian banks’ mortgages are equivalent to 80 percent of the economy. The media gets the job of telling us they're all highly skilled workers.

  • @advancedsoul1511

    @advancedsoul1511

    2 ай бұрын

    I love your white women

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    because then you'd have smarter children.@@advancedsoul1511

  • @luke_rr4474
    @luke_rr44742 ай бұрын

    Another reason to get rid of this pathetic Labor government the worst in history.

  • @advancedsoul1511

    @advancedsoul1511

    2 ай бұрын

    I love your women

  • @thekingspin9846
    @thekingspin98462 ай бұрын

    Wonder how many Aussies traveled to India and China and said, if only Australia was more like this?

  • @Jin-oq2qu

    @Jin-oq2qu

    2 ай бұрын

    Migrants are mostly from. US, UK, NZ and India.

  • @ausforaus7617

    @ausforaus7617

    2 ай бұрын

    Most were probably Chinese or Indian born ....

  • @bigrobsydney

    @bigrobsydney

    2 ай бұрын

    You do realise that both those countries have economies that absolutely DWARF Australia's, right?

  • @markferguson7563

    @markferguson7563

    2 ай бұрын

    Attention: The Member for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, City of Sydney Councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Minister for Housing, Rose Jackson. On June 5, 2023, between 6pm - 7pm the federal MP for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, along with the City of Sydney councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Housing Minister, Rose Jackson, were invited by the community activist group, RedWatch, to address a meeting held at the Alexandia Town Hall, in Garden St, Alexandria, which was called: ‘The Federal Government’s Housing Policy’ As it transpired, these cretins spoke the usual drivel that always spills out of the mouths of politicians, whenever they are under pressure with having to front up, and answer the concerns of disgruntled constituents. Well, what a pitifully embarrassing scenario it was that evening to observe this trio having the temerity to, on the one hand, succor the stresses of local people who were under pressure, with either finding abodes to rent and, worse still, having to pay excessive rents. But, on the other hand, they all support large scale immigration intakes. Thus, mass immigration intakes is the irrefutable bane of the problem with why three is a critical shortage of properties to rent, and more so with exorbitant rents. The most glaringly acute aspect of the open-border programs existing within this inner-city zone of Sydney prevails with international students. Apropos to the number of international students in Australia from China, on Tuesday March 12, a friend of mine who runs a significant sized export business in Shanghai, told me (paraphrasing him) what someone from the consulate informed him of: ‘On March 3, the number of foreign students from China studying in Australia rose above the peak of 356,000 that were here in November 2019. By the end of April when universities are in full swing, the number of foreign students from China in Australia will exceed 380,000. Since October 2023, in the vicinity of 15,000 of these students from China have found lodgings within 6 kilometers of the consulate here in Camperdown.’ To put the 380,000 figure into perspective is to state that, the United States with a population THIRTEEN TIMES that of Australia, according to Prof. Victor Davis-Hanson is that, there are 350,000 students from China in the US. Therefore, what a gross insult it was for these cretins to have the impudence to front up at the meeting on June 5, and pretend to concerned with the plights of their Australians who are aggrieved with property shortages and excessive rents, when these grubs all support big immigration programs to propel GDP.

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    Well, they should stay there and be happy with their HUGE economies. We'll keep out HUGE backyards.@@bigrobsydney

  • @chriswatson1698
    @chriswatson16982 ай бұрын

    Australia was better in 2000.

  • @ausforaus7617
    @ausforaus76172 ай бұрын

    'OVER 100,000 MIGRANTS WELCOMED IN JANUARY' No they fking weren't!

  • @Eric-kn4yn

    @Eric-kn4yn

    2 ай бұрын

    100k that use to be annual intake in 2001

  • @chriswatson1698

    @chriswatson1698

    2 ай бұрын

    @@Eric-kn4yn During the 2nd half of the last century, which was only 24 years ago, the average intake was 70,000 pa.

  • @ritaa1359

    @ritaa1359

    2 ай бұрын

    Bro they were welcomed in the country from the start of 2021 and then the election happened the now pm brought in more just to have these problems

  • @KF-bj3ce
    @KF-bj3ce2 ай бұрын

    Bob Carr finally sees some sense, but what did he do? Nothing. Addition and acknowledged I have been informed that he was only the State Premier of NSW, However I still think that Labor is primarily driven by ideology, some of it very good but some of it so quaint which makes you think 'what the blazes are they doing now and so far outside the public thinking, and non inspiring and not trustworthy. One would have thought that a thinker like Bob Carr would have been able to do more. But then there is the left, the right and the middle of the Labor Party, fighting amongst each other no wonder that they are in such disarray with there thinking and planning. Labor talks about the environment but they never talk about the number of people that draw on it. It is a no brainer that Australia will struggle with the recent influx of immigrants and then they have the gall to reject nuclear power generation which could bring us significant amounts of energy for desalination, smelting and value added manufacturing.

  • @andysmoo3448

    @andysmoo3448

    2 ай бұрын

    He was a state premier. The federal govt is responsible for immigration policy. Carr spoke out several times when he was premier about the immigration being too high.

  • @KF-bj3ce

    @KF-bj3ce

    2 ай бұрын

    To@@andysmoo3448 Thanks for this.

  • @kanderson4417

    @kanderson4417

    2 ай бұрын

    To be fair Bob was a state Premier, he had no control over immigration. It's a federal thing. Vote out Labor and their open borders.

  • @fredericksmith7418

    @fredericksmith7418

    2 ай бұрын

    Labor will never reduce immigration or Liberal the economy would grind to a halt if they did

  • @chriswatson1698

    @chriswatson1698

    2 ай бұрын

    @@fredericksmith7418 Mass immigration has already caused the per person GDP to tank. A per capita recession IS a recession.

  • @daveevans4260
    @daveevans42602 ай бұрын

    but he did nothing to stop it and still does nothing as far as i see it your all traitors to Australia.

  • @evabyrne-kr1fz

    @evabyrne-kr1fz

    2 ай бұрын

    Fxxkin oath

  • @Kelly-wf5ie

    @Kelly-wf5ie

    2 ай бұрын

    NOBODY, I mean ALL those “ agencies “ WE pay for ( a service we NEVER get ) NONE of them have lifted a finger to STOP the INTENTIONAL DESTRUCTION + SABOTAGE OF THIS COUNTRY, NOT 1 !! So again I ask my fellow Aussie’s Y EXACTLY R WE PAYING ANY OF THESE VERMIN ANYTHING ????

  • @chrisnaude2929

    @chrisnaude2929

    2 ай бұрын

    *you're

  • @seriousmonkey5654

    @seriousmonkey5654

    2 ай бұрын

    Learn how to write a sentence.

  • @seanlander9321

    @seanlander9321

    2 ай бұрын

    If you don’t understand how strongly and how long Carr has opposed immigration then you don’t know much.

  • @russell_beddyoisken
    @russell_beddyoisken2 ай бұрын

    I think the most recent numbers are now 30% in Australia are overseas born. It's a push that's been noticeable for at least 50 years. Go back to the 1970's and promotional pop jingles like "I'm an Aussie Yes I am" hit the airwaves like a blitz. The idea was then, as it is now, that Australia is this kind of post-racial immigration nation. Multiculturalism was the buzz-term. Being Australian just meant having the necessary paperwork. It's no coincidence that "colonial" Aussies are taught to be ashamed of their history. It's more than just an "infrastructure" issue. Where else but the Western world does this go on?......

  • @karlpartridge9546

    @karlpartridge9546

    2 ай бұрын

    Try rolling Koreans Chinese or Japanese they should be multicultural and you would be ridiculed even indians hate african students in their universities

  • @anitacohen8753

    @anitacohen8753

    2 ай бұрын

    I remember going to work in South Australia during the 1960s. Most of the English who arrived on (subsidised) fares, said they left Britain as the blacks are now coming over! Britain is stuffed and Australia is soon to follow the same strategy!

  • @playlistofthegods

    @playlistofthegods

    2 ай бұрын

    They don't play spot the Chinese man in China. Spot the Aussie is becoming difficult in Sydney area, I was there last week, Shocking roads even though there are Tolls., Super congested.

  • @Low-Tide

    @Low-Tide

    2 ай бұрын

    The UKs current condition is what awaits us. There Is still a few countries with leadership that protects their country. Their people. Their national identity. Ours unfortunately have traded ours for money and woke ideologies. If the conflicts around the world escalate. We will see the results of the leaderships choices. You need pride in what you're fighting for. Hell, our own government won't even promote Australia Day anymore.

  • @georgekordis4268

    @georgekordis4268

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@Low-Tideletting all the current third world into the country was the start and end of this nation.

  • @fitzyholden1036
    @fitzyholden10362 ай бұрын

    Playing spot the Aussie has never been such a challenge.

  • @bigrobsydney

    @bigrobsydney

    2 ай бұрын

    Good thing you're not a racist then, eh? But then, what's your definition of an Aussie? Anyone that came here after invasion day count?

  • @Bushkaboo

    @Bushkaboo

    2 ай бұрын

    Absolutely correct. I hadn't been to Melbourne for 25 years. I'm part of a minority. Antiwhiteism at play. No Whites and no Aboriginals anywhere except homeless on the streets.

  • @Hannah-rl5lt

    @Hannah-rl5lt

    2 ай бұрын

    Go down the beach on Australia Day or NY...burkahs as far as the eye can see..disgusting

  • @ritaa1359

    @ritaa1359

    2 ай бұрын

    Bro literally but u can tell by the way they talk

  • @YesSir-ms3uk

    @YesSir-ms3uk

    2 ай бұрын

    Yeah but you meet a lot of people day today life that don’t have an Aussie accent

  • @colinfullford8630
    @colinfullford86302 ай бұрын

    Don't worry about the bloody housing issue, what about the cultural issue. I'm talking about the Australian culture, it's only a few hundred years old and it's at a risk of being swamped by many different cultures that are thousands of years old. It really will be the death of Australia as we know it.

  • @KT-bb1tb

    @KT-bb1tb

    2 ай бұрын

    Culture I think is the wrong Word......The Problem is Integration !

  • @iof1

    @iof1

    2 ай бұрын

    Spot on

  • @georgekordis4268

    @georgekordis4268

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@KT-bb1tb culture is the right one just the wrong cultures coming into the country when your importing third world what did you expect.

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    what no more Aussie Karen's, gee, that will be a huge loss

  • @rennmaxbeta

    @rennmaxbeta

    2 ай бұрын

    It'll be India 2 in 50 years

  • @thegallantsaint2034
    @thegallantsaint20342 ай бұрын

    Housing, Infrastructure, jobs, educational services are all under stress.

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    @user-rj2el1yg9ifrom what?? being utterly lazy to needing to work. define quality of life??

  • @ACDZ123
    @ACDZ1232 ай бұрын

    Perth is the most desirable city in Australia now ...English is still the first language in Perth 🇦🇺😜

  • @KT-bb1tb

    @KT-bb1tb

    2 ай бұрын

    It's Changing Far too Quickly !

  • @ACDZ123

    @ACDZ123

    2 ай бұрын

    @KT-bb1tb oh they definitely going to screw Perth up as well .. so far Perth has been left alone compared to Sydney and Melbourne..

  • @JohnsonCranium

    @JohnsonCranium

    2 ай бұрын

    Yeah your mandates on poisonous vaccines 💉 don’t make the place appealing TBH 😅

  • @ACDZ123

    @ACDZ123

    2 ай бұрын

    @JohnsonCranium I never took the jabby..Perth only had a few weeks of lockdowns..mandates arr the same in every state ...the border closure was the only thing WA was tough on ....now you were saying?

  • @JohnsonCranium

    @JohnsonCranium

    2 ай бұрын

    @@ACDZ123 re read what I wrote… that’s what I was saying… And I’ll add this Capital cities are zones for deadshit dumbarses… the same dumbos that follow orders without question. So please stay in ya retarded city and don’t venture out… All the rural folks are looking and laughing at you muppets. 🤣 Our coppers didn’t even follow the rules 🤣👍

  • @kanderson4417
    @kanderson44172 ай бұрын

    So where is Albo going to put these people? Always thought Carr was the worst state premier we ever had. But he is talking sense here.

  • @robert3987
    @robert39872 ай бұрын

    If Dutton seriously pushed for much lower immigration it would be an election winner.

  • @videowilliams

    @videowilliams

    2 ай бұрын

    Yes, you'd think one major party, desperate to win the next election, would blink on the mass immigration project which has never been supported by a majority of Australians, but thus far they'd rather go into opposition than cut it back.

  • @Hannah-rl5lt

    @Hannah-rl5lt

    2 ай бұрын

    Send them back and I'll vote

  • @edmurks236
    @edmurks2362 ай бұрын

    Bob Carr starting the bleeding obvious that even Blind Freddy can see.

  • @The_Stoic_PhilosopherSH
    @The_Stoic_PhilosopherSH2 ай бұрын

    We are really buggered now!

  • @reneperin8742
    @reneperin87422 ай бұрын

    Labor says they want to import professional people, well I have noticed most immigrants are taxi drivers, work in catering, work as carers and do no such professional work, they are taking jobs from Australian's

  • @Eric-kn4yn

    @Eric-kn4yn

    2 ай бұрын

    Old asian women no english in massage shops brothels every street corner

  • @MargaretCampbell583

    @MargaretCampbell583

    2 ай бұрын

    I have noticed a definite improvement in the quality of migrants though since Albanese has been in power

  • @TheMazinoz

    @TheMazinoz

    2 ай бұрын

    Their qualifications aren't recognised and they can't work as professionals!

  • @MLR884
    @MLR8842 ай бұрын

    If you’re wondering where it all began- it was Kevin 07 back when the GFC hit in 2008. He tripled the rates of immigration almost immediately. Everyone patted him on the back because he avoided a recession… but he didnt- he just shifted it. He relied on the mining industry that he vilified and he relied on unsustainable immigration to boost GDP. Aussie families have been going through a recession ever since thanks to the issues with too many people coming in. Subsequent governments have only increased immigration because they realised it was the easiest way to fudge the books and keep pretending we never had a recession when we’ve actually been in one of the longest recessions in history. Ever wondered how we can have an economic downturn but housing prices go up? It’s immigration. If you have too many people coming in, there is simply no way to meet the demand. The demand goes up, so does the cost because there aren’t enough houses to go around. Fewer people can build or buy so the rental demand increases, which drives the price up. That makes the economy slow down because people can’t afford to live, let alone splurge. So then the government INCREASES IMMIGRATION in order to give the economy another “boost” which just makes the problem worse.

  • @MargaretCampbell583

    @MargaretCampbell583

    2 ай бұрын

    No he did not Howard opened the floodgates but Post Howard Labor didn’t stop it

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    Australian banks’ mortgages are equivalent to 80 percent of the economy. It's always banking. Touch not the money business or risk a war.

  • @markgamble568
    @markgamble5682 ай бұрын

    Not only do we not need to do it, but we are going to regret it. Just look to England for the result of mass migration.

  • @smyleymk9821
    @smyleymk98212 ай бұрын

    MY FAMILY and I facing homelessness going for rentals competing with 20 or more people for a place, then you go to sydney , and its SPOT THE OZY , cos there are none , the whole city has been taken over.

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    Where are you? I have a house I may be renting out in future.

  • @smyleymk9821

    @smyleymk9821

    2 ай бұрын

    @@xx-vw9ep ,were in northen rivers, Ballina, lismore , around that area would be good, but would consider other.

  • @isomorph7954
    @isomorph79542 ай бұрын

    Immigration is not about economics, its all about social transformation, and under a diversity obsessed Labor government, wont abate anytime soon. Voters are apparently irrelevant and crazy must have some seriously powerful sponsors.

  • @playlistofthegods

    @playlistofthegods

    2 ай бұрын

    I wonder how many recent immigrant / New Australians Vote for Labour? May just be padding out the Labour voting base?

  • @sometingwongwai9679

    @sometingwongwai9679

    2 ай бұрын

    No its to lower the inflation so your home loans aren't at 30% and the country's bonds as being junk, This is mainly due to Aussies being so useless

  • @RD-ni7qe

    @RD-ni7qe

    2 ай бұрын

    If you think this is only Labor then you must have a very, very short memory.

  • @justmemimi7338

    @justmemimi7338

    2 ай бұрын

    Examine the policies of the WEF and UN. We need to expunge globalists from political office and the public service.

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    It's suicide.

  • @Forexfox99
    @Forexfox992 ай бұрын

    I did a tree change from Melbourne to South Australia, trying to escape the masses of congestion. At this rate of immigration, I have Mebe 5 years before they follow. Faaaaac.

  • @pilotandy1333

    @pilotandy1333

    2 ай бұрын

    Adelaide is changing quickly now, it wont be long until it has the same problems or worse.

  • @markferguson7563

    @markferguson7563

    2 ай бұрын

    Attention: The Member for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, City of Sydney Councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Minister for Housing, Rose Jackson. On June 5, 2023, between 6pm - 7pm the federal MP for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, along with the City of Sydney councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Housing Minister, Rose Jackson, were invited by the community activist group, RedWatch, to address a meeting held at the Alexandia Town Hall, in Garden St, Alexandria, which was called: ‘The Federal Government’s Housing Policy’ As it transpired, these cretins spoke the usual drivel that always spills out of the mouths of politicians, whenever they are under pressure with having to front up, and answer the concerns of disgruntled constituents. Well, what a pitifully embarrassing scenario it was that evening to observe this trio having the temerity to, on the one hand, succor the stresses of local people who were under pressure, with either finding abodes to rent and, worse still, having to pay excessive rents. But, on the other hand, they all support large scale immigration intakes. Thus, mass immigration intakes is the irrefutable bane of the problem with why three is a critical shortage of properties to rent, and more so with exorbitant rents. The most glaringly acute aspect of the open-border programs existing within this inner-city zone of Sydney prevails with international students. Apropos to the number of international students in Australia from China, on Tuesday March 12, a friend of mine who runs a significant sized export business in Shanghai, told me (paraphrasing him) what someone from the consulate informed him of: ‘On March 3, the number of foreign students from China studying in Australia rose above the peak of 356,000 that were here in November 2019. By the end of April when universities are in full swing, the number of foreign students from China in Australia will exceed 380,000. Since October 2023, in the vicinity of 15,000 of these students from China have found lodgings within 6 kilometers of the consulate here in Camperdown.’ To put the 380,000 figure into perspective is to state that, the United States with a population THIRTEEN TIMES that of Australia, according to Prof. Victor Davis-Hanson is that, there are 350,000 students from China in the US. Therefore, what a gross insult it was for these cretins to have the impudence to front up at the meeting on June 5, and pretend to concerned with the plights of their Australians who are aggrieved with property shortages and excessive rents, when these grubs all support big immigration programs to propel GDP.

  • @xpictos777

    @xpictos777

    2 ай бұрын

    I couldn’t even stand how busy Adelaide was getting (can’t believe I said that) I moved to the Barossa and love it, but I know the clock is ticking here too.

  • @davidvanderklauw
    @davidvanderklauw2 ай бұрын

    Bob Carr is terrible. He apparently realised the problem with high immigration. He said something about it "Sydney is full" but DID NOTHING. He was in a position of power and could have done something about it, and DID NOTHING. What could he have done as Premier of NSW? Plenty. Raise public transport fees to $100 per trip, but give a 90% discount to tourists with a passport, children, and to adult holders of a gold card. How to get a gold card? Live in the state for 10 years. That would stop them. What about driving licences? Make it a 10 year wait for get a driving test. 6 year old's who live in NSW can apply now and do their test in 10 years. Do not accept applications from out of state people. Do I need to go on?

  • @tomjones5338

    @tomjones5338

    2 ай бұрын

    He's being blackmailed he was named in the wood royal Commission unfortunately he's correct but wasn't allowed to do anything because they would've exposed him he would've face prison time or got the Epstein treatment

  • @richardbrown9344

    @richardbrown9344

    2 ай бұрын

    He knows exactly why this is happening and what is going on...

  • @elduderino7767

    @elduderino7767

    2 ай бұрын

    this is a federal issue, not a state issue speaking up about it is more important than ever 125k new permanent immigrants in just jan, thats 1.5m in a year, last year was a record at around 700k we are heading straight to the 3rd world

  • @MargaretCampbell583

    @MargaretCampbell583

    2 ай бұрын

    He was not in control of immigration, even for the short period he was foreign minister

  • @anitacohen8753
    @anitacohen87532 ай бұрын

    With Kevin Rudd there......did you expect something different?

  • @justinwolff1416

    @justinwolff1416

    2 ай бұрын

    Albanese makes Rudd appear almost human in comparison.

  • @nickstoic2944
    @nickstoic29442 ай бұрын

    Thank you for posting. With all respect towards all people from around the world, but it's so easy to see that just like in the US, the Labor government of Australia is creating this big mess fully aware of what is doing. Why this desperate sudden push for immigrants intake, net zero, voice and who knows what other policies? What's wrong with the government?

  • @royalrea2507
    @royalrea25072 ай бұрын

    We need quality not quanity

  • @chuckyaaa
    @chuckyaaa2 ай бұрын

    Agree And penny Wong should goto jail for funding UNWA

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    They just gave them a sh*tload more money!!!

  • @chrisdyson2833
    @chrisdyson28332 ай бұрын

    Ever been to Lismore? In 1 year the Australian immigration intake was literally 10 times the population of Lismore in the Northern rivers of NSW. But NO infrastructure was built to accommodate them. No housing, no additional health facilities, no more schools, no more transportation facilities, no more GPs, no more food production, no more domestic rubbish collection, etc etc etc. 10 more Lismores but not a single additional service to cater for them. Well done to the Albanese grubberment.

  • @john4flying
    @john4flying2 ай бұрын

    Don’t expect rational housing policy from our politicians who are almost all property investors

  • @justmemimi7338
    @justmemimi73382 ай бұрын

    The LNP really needs to step up and produce cohesive, alternative policies. I’ve not heard them critique mass immigration at all. We don’t want money from the federal government to accommodate mass immigration. ,We want our quality of life, and our culture. It’s terrifying how out of touch politicians have become. Thanks for your perspective, Bob.

  • @stuartthompson7102
    @stuartthompson71022 ай бұрын

    Bob says it how it is and no one in government is listening.

  • @thepanel2935
    @thepanel29352 ай бұрын

    "No benefit to the existing population" - classic comment. Those of us contending with the cost-of-living crisis in Sydney need to prepare ourselves because things will only get worse, not better.

  • @markferguson7563

    @markferguson7563

    2 ай бұрын

    Attention: The Member for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, City of Sydney Councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Minister for Housing, Rose Jackson. On June 5, 2023, between 6pm - 7pm the federal MP for Sydney, Tanya Plibersek, along with the City of Sydney councilor, Linda Scott, and the NSW Housing Minister, Rose Jackson, were invited by the community activist group, RedWatch, to address a meeting held at the Alexandia Town Hall, in Garden St, Alexandria, which was called: ‘The Federal Government’s Housing Policy’ As it transpired, these cretins spoke the usual drivel that always spills out of the mouths of politicians, whenever they are under pressure with having to front up, and answer the concerns of disgruntled constituents. Well, what a pitifully embarrassing scenario it was that evening to observe this trio having the temerity to, on the one hand, succor the stresses of local people who were under pressure, with either finding abodes to rent and, worse still, having to pay excessive rents. But, on the other hand, they all support large scale immigration intakes. Thus, mass immigration intakes is the irrefutable bane of the problem with why three is a critical shortage of properties to rent, and more so with exorbitant rents. The most glaringly acute aspect of the open-border programs existing within this inner-city zone of Sydney prevails with international students. Apropos to the number of international students in Australia from China, on Tuesday March 12, a friend of mine who runs a significant sized export business in Shanghai, told me (paraphrasing him) what someone from the consulate informed him of: ‘On March 3, the number of foreign students from China studying in Australia rose above the peak of 356,000 that were here in November 2019. By the end of April when universities are in full swing, the number of foreign students from China in Australia will exceed 380,000. Since October 2023, in the vicinity of 15,000 of these students from China have found lodgings within 6 kilometers of the consulate here in Camperdown.’ To put the 380,000 figure into perspective is to state that, the United States with a population THIRTEEN TIMES that of Australia, according to Prof. Victor Davis-Hanson is that, there are 350,000 students from China in the US. Therefore, what a gross insult it was for these cretins to have the impudence to front up at the meeting on June 5, and pretend to concerned with the plights of their Australians who are aggrieved with property shortages and excessive rents, when these grubs all support big immigration programs to propel GDP.

  • @B61Mod12
    @B61Mod122 ай бұрын

    Wow Bob Carr… very well said.

  • @asifulzead
    @asifulzead2 ай бұрын

    After covid labor is the worst disaster Australia has had

  • @BelloBudo007
    @BelloBudo0072 ай бұрын

    My concern is that once the numbers of 'new arrivals' outpace existing Australians, that control of the immigration situation will be completely lost and forever. Yet we keep pushing ahead with this crazy 'more of the same' idea.

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    It's all for the Central and retail bankers. We want a nice Australia, they want a big Australia. Australian banks’ mortgages are equivalent to 80 percent of the economy.

  • @VG-cz7yg
    @VG-cz7yg2 ай бұрын

    These immigrants are not living in cars or parks like an increasing number of Australians.

  • @MargaretCampbell583

    @MargaretCampbell583

    2 ай бұрын

    I have seen many migrants at inspections so they are having issues too

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    They can always go back to the relatives just like our children have to live with us because of sky-high property prices. @@MargaretCampbell583

  • @seanlander9321
    @seanlander93212 ай бұрын

    In Sydney, Australians have been replaced in most suburbs. Meanwhile what they built in a beautiful garden city is about to be legislated for demolition as unworthy by town planners, in favour of the hideous congestion of Asia. How is any of this vandalism an improvement?

  • @marylou3995
    @marylou39952 ай бұрын

    They are all on the world economic forum payroll

  • @galacticnemesis366
    @galacticnemesis3662 ай бұрын

    Put Labor and the Greens last is key. Not just vote One Nation. Australians have to put Labor and the Greens last as well as put One Nation first. Educate your people and let the word spread. 😎👍👊🇦🇺

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    I'm surprised nobody has started the stop immigration party. One nation won't do it.

  • @simonellerton1412
    @simonellerton14122 ай бұрын

    No matter what anyone says /you will be placed as racist for having an opinion...

  • @chriswatson1698
    @chriswatson16982 ай бұрын

    Planning is a case of taxing the existing population to pay for infrastructure for foreigners before they arrive.

  • @philliphunt1579
    @philliphunt15792 ай бұрын

    We have to have this mass immigration. The UN said so. Federal Government are told by the UN how many refo's we take in and where from.

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    It's "REPLACEMENT MIGRATION" and is written right on the WEF website. Yes, Labor is doing the Biden of the globalists.

  • @Schwabian
    @Schwabian2 ай бұрын

    Take a walk in Melbourne-you wonder what country your in- bring in qualified people not third world crap-

  • @ireneminzenmay4075
    @ireneminzenmay40752 ай бұрын

    What they have done is REVOLTING. I am so angry at Clare O Neel and Andrew Giles. And I was a labor supporter.They are disgusting

  • @SHA70
    @SHA702 ай бұрын

    Well aussies you voted for it. Enjoy!

  • @robertcoyte3243

    @robertcoyte3243

    2 ай бұрын

    Exactly the voters are to blame

  • @drazmarinic5991

    @drazmarinic5991

    2 ай бұрын

    Yep it wasn’t my vote though

  • @SGI999
    @SGI9992 ай бұрын

    Go tell it on the mountain and everywhere please Bob. Spread the message.

  • @woobykal68
    @woobykal682 ай бұрын

    the great replacement.

  • @ninaclemente5944
    @ninaclemente59442 ай бұрын

    The ALP has Kevin Rudd!!!! Enough said!

  • @karlpartridge9546
    @karlpartridge95462 ай бұрын

    When there is a shortage of workers people get paid more they spend more and economy benefits ALL when there are plenty of workers wages stagnate people have less to spend but a handful of billionaires profit from low wages

  • @KT-bb1tb

    @KT-bb1tb

    2 ай бұрын

    Ya, Living in a Fantasy Land ! It's NOT Working !

  • @PeterC245
    @PeterC2452 ай бұрын

    This is the only plan. These current criminally, incompetent clowns , have to prevent a recession,

  • @chrisdickinson7949
    @chrisdickinson79492 ай бұрын

    The vast majority of Australians DO understand we don't need mass immigration, Bob should explain it to our Politicians that wont listen to OUR wishes for the future of Australia !

  • @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    @user-ch5vr2hv4f

    2 ай бұрын

    The bankers run the show. The politicians and media sell it to us.

  • @user-en9jk8rf8v
    @user-en9jk8rf8v2 ай бұрын

    I thought he was dead

  • @billybobb7252

    @billybobb7252

    2 ай бұрын

    Nah that was his wife. She dropped dead recently.

  • @taniabriscoe6493

    @taniabriscoe6493

    2 ай бұрын

    Who Bob Carr? I remember when he attended bohemian Grove back in the day. Boasted that he rubbed shoulders with the others .

  • @user-mm5ot2tc4l

    @user-mm5ot2tc4l

    2 ай бұрын

    They get them out of storage.

  • @Margaret-bo3pv

    @Margaret-bo3pv

    2 ай бұрын

    😂😂😂

  • @user-en9jk8rf8v

    @user-en9jk8rf8v

    2 ай бұрын

    @@user-mm5ot2tc4l 😂 like the South Americans on all Saints day, 😁

  • @terenceosullivan7846
    @terenceosullivan78462 ай бұрын

    This is the only sensible thing Carr has said in his lifetime. Yet Bernard Salt, Shane Oliver and their are silent. The only benefit they cite is “ diversity of food.” How shallow and vacuous

  • @seanyuke3249
    @seanyuke32492 ай бұрын

    Tower developments, and pop up ghettos on every second 10 acre block that used to be in the bush.

  • @Coops777
    @Coops7772 ай бұрын

    Nice to see Bob coming on board with some common sense

  • @lizann3058
    @lizann30582 ай бұрын

    Too little, too late...

  • @Kelly-wf5ie
    @Kelly-wf5ie2 ай бұрын

    The RBA has already ADMITTED that the Treasurer CAN direct them to invest in infrastructure to help with housing etc… + that in turn would help the economy in a MASSIVE WAY !! So the ?? IS, Y HASN’T HE ?? All 1 needs to do is read about their future on the WEF , WHO UN etc.. websites, in which NO LIVING Aussie has a CONTRACT WITH, PERIOD !!

  • @MrRatclima
    @MrRatclima2 ай бұрын

    Centralized govt. + an politically uneducated and apathetic populace is a bad combination.

  • @ireneminzenmay4075
    @ireneminzenmay40752 ай бұрын

    Clair O Neil is putting people in tents, all she cares about is putting on her signature red lippy 💄💄💄💄

  • @jjsc4396
    @jjsc43962 ай бұрын

    "Serious" ...."with (specific) numbers".....mate, that hasn't come from an Australian politicians pie-hole in the past 30 years 🙄

  • @indoman8887
    @indoman88872 ай бұрын

    It is openly admitted that the only reason the Australian economy has grown for several years now is because of mass immigration, Covid time being the exception. The Treasurer has stated that the large budget surplus last year was due to high commodity prices, in particular iron ore and this year will be substantially lower because of the decrease in the iron ore price. To address these issues, the answer of the bureaucrats in Canberra is to bring in more migrants, in the hope they will keep GDP growth positive. This whole situation is not going to end well, starting with social cohesion, as we have seen since the start of the Israel Palestine war, and the various demonstrations that are occurring. There seems to be more loyalty to country of origin, not Australia.

  • @adventuremike9264
    @adventuremike92642 ай бұрын

    Strong economics must be delinked from population growth.

  • @videowilliams
    @videowilliams2 ай бұрын

    My hero. One of them anyway. He has always been strong on this topic including when he was the Premier in Sydney, and I filmed him speaking much like this at a 2009 book launch, posting the video ("Bob Carr on Overloading Australia") on the SPAnsw (Sustainable Population Australia) channel.

  • @Larry-Livermore
    @Larry-Livermore2 ай бұрын

    Australia is not a dumping ground for failed states.

  • @lovechineseforever9434
    @lovechineseforever94342 ай бұрын

    WHAT?? WHO IS GOING TO DO THE WORK TO PAY TAXES, MATE? AUSTRALIA IS FULL OF BLUDGERS

  • @Leftyintollerable
    @Leftyintollerable2 ай бұрын

    Don't remember Bob being the P.M of Australia Sky News?

  • @NoName-qv8ko
    @NoName-qv8ko2 ай бұрын

    Bob Carr the best PM Australia never had.

  • @jordanhanson316
    @jordanhanson3162 ай бұрын

    I just wrote a letter to Albanese’s office on this exact problem, not that it will help, but our healthcare is already completely under staffed. Our people are sacrificing a sustainable system for one that is much much worse, just so the rich corporates can meet their KPI’s. It’s disgusting.

  • @henryshen5445
    @henryshen54452 ай бұрын

    It really bothers me when I see school kids on an excursion in Sydney and none of the kids are white! And I’m Asian.

  • @Mark-td5ux
    @Mark-td5ux2 ай бұрын

    Once the lucky county now overun by foreign hordes.

  • @louisebb4183
    @louisebb41832 ай бұрын

    You would think that they learned from UK ? But Australian labor leaders think they are smarter 😂

  • @xx-vw9ep

    @xx-vw9ep

    2 ай бұрын

    The Labor party are globalists and are in on it doing what THE WEF wants them to i.e. REPLACEMENT MIGRATION.

  • @susanc4622
    @susanc46222 ай бұрын

    “Australians to understand “??? It’s not the average person, it’s the politicians.

  • @rumpelstiltskin6252
    @rumpelstiltskin62522 ай бұрын

    yeh but it sure secures a lot of votes. migration need to be seperated from goverment

  • @lesliewiddowson6909
    @lesliewiddowson69092 ай бұрын

    The States need to do what Texas did and say no more

  • @RealRoknRollr3108
    @RealRoknRollr31082 ай бұрын

    Cmon now, we obviously desperately need more delivery drivers. And who's going to work in the petrol stations? Aussies? Dont be stupid. And tai restaurants, I have to walk 5 cm before finding a nearby tai joint, we need more of them

  • @Eric-kn4yn

    @Eric-kn4yn

    2 ай бұрын

    Asian massage shops brothels old asian females no english every street corner

  • @monsel97
    @monsel972 ай бұрын

    We don't have any housing. WTF.

  • @Pedroaghyu
    @Pedroaghyu2 ай бұрын

    Self inflicted problems, when voters are not paying attention and this is what happens, every democracy has the government they deserve

  • @michaelmccormack2460
    @michaelmccormack24602 ай бұрын

    The problem is there’s too many marginal seats in Sydney Melbourne and Brisbane they won’t have any foresight to get people to move out of Sydney setting up industries because all they’re concerned about is keeping marginal seats right and keeping infrastructure up to them instead of saying righto we need to expand populations around the place what if they moved a lot of people out of Sydney I wouldn’t need all these big infrastructures so how about have some big foresight and start encouraging industries to move out of the bigger cities and then you’ll be surprised how much we don’t have to spend on infrastructure in the big major cities while the regionals centres don’t get nowhere near the funding is what these big major cities do and the people live in those big cities can’t afford to live in there at allSo I have some foresight and move them out of the cities for next generation

  • @dylangriffiths5284
    @dylangriffiths52842 ай бұрын

    Quick!! Get the gum leaves out!! Let’s welcome them to country!!! 😂😂😂

  • @user-yv8cu6st2n
    @user-yv8cu6st2n2 ай бұрын

    This labour government is last.

  • @MargaretCampbell583
    @MargaretCampbell5832 ай бұрын

    Oh No.

  • @Pseudonemonics
    @Pseudonemonics2 ай бұрын

    As per every other country, this will be the end of Australia as you know it