Bill Pentz is the holy grail when it comes to explaining what is needed for effective dust collection!

Loved every 52 minutes of it! In the world of two minute popcorn, and instant everything, do you know how easy it is to skip videos or fast forward? For me to sit still and be completely entertained by 52 minute video, it's pretty amazing.

I like the idea of making each handle from a different wood, so when they are in the holders you can identify the one you want without having to think about it

Looking like a kid at Christmas with the excitement of getting back in the shop! :) Thanks for all the videos/updates while you've been recovering....Hi from Virginia!

The new DC layout looks really efficient. Not very many long runs or branch lines. I picked up a big grizzly air cleaner from a local guy that was shutting down his shop. Just like you I've noticed that making sure I let it run frequently makes a huge difference in air quality. Can't wait to see the new video on Sunday, you seem super excited about it!

Lathe work produces some of the finest dust you can make, especially when sanding. I suggest you make a hood to place behind the lathe while you work that hooks up to your dust collection system or shop vac. Or at least an adapter so you can place the hose of your shop vac directly behind the piece you're turning. Love the videos. Love the projects. Your channel is definitely one of the ones I look forward to watching each week.

@darylwalker266

7 жыл бұрын

Definitely birds eye maple. Definitely.

Birdseye Maple. Also welcome back, missed your projects.

Was great to see the excitement in your face about getting back in the shop doing some woodworking! I know you don't want to hear it BUT because of your sinuses, cut a hole in the outside wall, build a shed (like April did) and put your DC out there or at least run the exhaust and filters out there. No need to go expensive crazy on the filters and all the other stuff you might try to add! You (of all people) can "easily" patch the hole when (and if) you sell the house. BTW, the piping for your DC looks good, however that will limit how much you can change machines around in the future (haha). Since we are on the subject, Yes you are a creature of change, so I'm wondering when you will move the miter station/cabinet to another wall (just kidding). Happy woodworking my friend!

Maple with the grey ring, I think walnut won't provide enough contrast.

It'll be great to see you back at it in the shop building your next project, just remember the mask👍🏻

Have a great week. Best wishes from Jan In Norway

I have been holding my breath in anticipation of you getting back in the shop, can't wait to see what you come up with next. Glad you are nearly back. Take care of those sinuses.

Can't wait to see you back at it! It is a pleasure watching your videos and seeing your excitement and passion. Great job Jay! 🇨🇦

I have sinus issues as well and I always run my dust collector in my garage shop when ever a tool is running. I put in an Oneida V3000 with spiral ducting that I bought from a local plumbing supply store, and blast gates from Lee Valley. Everything fit together perfectly and the dust collector pulls around 1000 cfm at the tool (measured with a digital anemometer) with one blast gate open at a time. More than enough to keep everything virtually dust free.

Osage orange ("Bodark!"). It's hard as a rock, only available in handle sized pieces, and very, very southern :)

Talk about itchy fingers!… not long now mate and the smell of woodwork comes to a shop near you 😊😉

I am currently overhauling my dust collection system too. Just ordered a Clearvue CV1800 and will finally be running ductwork rather than moving the DC from tool to tool. I'll be going with 6" ductwork, trying to decide between PVC and snaplock. The pricing seems to be similar. EDIT: Duh, should have watched the whole video. Looks like you're looking at a Clearvue too.

Those ferrels will look terrific. Great Idea on your part. If you want to look at some chisels that are off the beaten track you might want to look at the IBC chisels. They come apart so you can easily make handles for them but also the entire back is flat all the way up to the screw that holds it all together. Your idea will work on them also.

I think the Birdseye would definitely be a nicer contrast to the custom collar you had made. We sure can tell you're dying to get back in the shop and get Hands-On!!

Hey Jay, glad you had a speedy recovery. Regarding the timer on the air filter, I might suggest a couple of oscillating fans that start when the filter comes on but only run for an hour or so. I think they would stir up the surface dust to be collected and make a huge difference with the air quality. Looking forward to Sunday's mystery video.

Thanks for the video and all the great content that you produce. I am very much looking forward to having you back in the shop but even more so to know that you are healing well. Have a great one.

Glad your glad about working again, looking forward to what's next. Those custom rings look great, looking forward to that video.

Can't wait to see the chisels. I think both species will look great, but I think the maple will give much better contrast to the rings.

Good to have ya back, what about a chisel predominantly walnut with a bird's eye maple strip thru it? just an idea. have a good day

Glad your feeling better and getting back in the shop!

Glad to see you're getting back to work. One thing, don't forget the lathe. Lots of dust when you do the finish sanding. Oh yeah, Maple. Same reason as Jeremy Gunkel.

I like walnut quite a bit. I just used walnut splines in a cedar tea box I made for my wife, I really like the finished color of the walnut.

Walnut if the choice is between the two. Have you ever used wenge? I bet handles made from that would look sweet.

As I mentioned on your IG feed, I'll be watching your war on dust intently, as I am now dealing with a pretty severe dust allergy that is keeping me out of the shop. I don't have a dust collector yet but I do use the Grizzly air filter/cleaner (hangs from the ceiling). I love it's timer feature. I could use a tool, make a cloud of dust then go inside while it runs on the timer, come back out a bit later and the air would be MUCH cleaner. Like everyone else, excited to see you back in the shop soon, too!

Jay's getting artsy!! Can't wait.

Nice video Jay. You can really tell that you're looking forward to getting back to work in the shop. So are we :)

Very cool rings and i like the idea of the maple for the chisel handles also the sketchup model of the new dust control set up looks like a huge improvement

Glad to hear you are almost back to 100%!

and about the dust collection. Go for 6" pipe alle the way. It wil improve your cfm at the machine a lot.

larger dust collector - I bought the Penn State 5HP, but it's stationary and it's been a bear setting it up in my garage/shop. I know the JDS cyclones are also excellent, similar in price/performance, and *mobile*.

laminate the walnut and maple so you get a dark stripe or a light stripe.

Go with Birdseye maple it will look sweet with the gunmetal feral. Great to see you so recharged and ready to go. Looking forward to seeing the next video.

If the chisels are to be primarily hand pushed or LIGHTLY tapped then just about anything would work. If you expect some moderate to heavy mallet use I'd go for something harder and heavier than either walnut or BE maple. Someone mentioned senge. The pieces of wenge I've got here are super hard. Almost metal like. And yes, they would look fantastic as chisel handles. The hickory would/should be good as well. Anything that is harder and hard to split would be excellent. For my own dust collection system I focused on both CFM as well as proper machine setup to ensure a good air velocity at the dust producing areas. For example on your miter saw station you've got the nice box already. But some heavy vinyl curtains that hang part way down or around the edges that can close up the opening a little will greatly aid with getting a good velocity across the opening to draw back in any dust that is moving out into the shop. CFM is only good if it is used to produce good FPS of the airflow to pull the dust away.

Glad to see you back in the shop Jay. I like the design of the chisel handles and I love Walnut, but I would be afraid the black rings with your logo might disappear against the brown handle of Walnut. Birds eye Maple all the way! Have a great week.

You should have a look at David Stanton's channel. He uses three types of dust collection - high pressure - high volume - and air filtration. It is always amazing how little dust he produces.

Cool stuff Jay, looking forward to everything especially those chisels!

Have you thought about a horizontal lamination of the two species? Not sure if the strength of a lamminated handle would be sufficient.

Why not both? Glue up some alternating walnut/maple blanks on a diagonal. You'll get a really neat look when turned. Like the edges of those "scrapwood" jewelry boxes that Kevin (krtwood) made 6 months ago.

Before you go to bed put on respirator and walk around shop with air line blowing down all horizontal surfaces the over night filter will capture even more.

My 2 cents would be for the walnut, for me it is lighter (weight) and I tend to choke up on the blade of the chisel and the more weight on the handle end of things gets tiring on the thumb. I know it seems like a small thing but I was using mine for an extended time the other day and actually thought to my self "i wish this was lighter". Oh, and I like walnut. Great videos keep up the good work!!

good to hear your gonna make dust/shavings now. looking forward to your video and projects. walnut, walnut, walnut. I am a huge figured maple fan but for tool handles walnut is my favorite. Mix it up for our benefit?

Jay build a little shed outside of your garage and put your dust collector (and maybe the air compressor) in it. I Know you said you don't want a hole in your garage - but think about it. You can ask April in the podcast :) Regards

I'm a walnut fan for this!

Those rings are awesome! I think they'd look best with a lighter wood.

Love your enthusiasm Jay and my vote is Bird's Eye Maple. Be Well!

Rings look great jay ! You should sell em 😃😃👍👍 maple has my vote should look great with those rings.

Nice looking rings Jay. Rather than choosing between walnut or maple how about a laminated handle? I would use maple for center and walnut for the outsides. The maple would give you better strength and the walnut would give you some cool contrast.

Bird's Eye Maple, I think would give you more energy transfer into the workpiece. Walnut might dampen a bit, but hey, what do I know? My favorite chisel has a poplar handle. Do what you want :)

I would say walnut, or do half and half if you have an even number of chisels

Walnut wil look great. Maple will be to light of a color and make the gunmetal ring color stand out to much. Walnut and gunmetal wil look very stylish

Birdseye maple would contrast the rings nicely.

Maple, Those rings are Awesome

I'll throw my vote in for the maple. I think it'll look better with the ring color.

Jay, I have seen hundreds of walnut handles but I don't think I have ever seen any bird's eye maple handles. I'd go with the maple.

It's gotta be birdseye maple. Go for the contrast to show off the ferrules. Hurry back Jay

Fuck that dust up, Jay. Get some. War is hell.

Hello Jay, Any chance you could do a video on how you Sharpen your Plane Blades and chisels? That would be really helpful, Thank You.

I'll be looking forward to your DC videos! I'm just setting up my shop, and I have asthma/lung issues, so this is a biggy for me.

I would go with two tones of those woods. If you can't make up your mind why not have both lol.

I like Maple for handles

I'd go with Bird's Eye Maple. Walnut will be too dark and the ring won't show up as well. Just my humble opinion... It'll be good to see you in the shop making sawdust.

Walnut for sure!!!

Cool video! I like it

I think maple with walnut accents would look nice, but a glue lamination may not have the strength and durability you want. You could always make a solid maple handle and inlay a touch of walnut, I guess. If you want a single, solid piece, though, hickory sounds like a winner.

Both woods!

Go maple. Give the rings the contrast they deserve.

Hickory handles!

@JayBates2

7 жыл бұрын

!!!!! Why did I not think of that!! Hmmm....

@ryanlangan1060

7 жыл бұрын

Second on Hickory

@WesleyAring

7 жыл бұрын

Make it three!

@simonhopkins3867

7 жыл бұрын

nothing like a nice piece of hickory.

@mjj1587

7 жыл бұрын

I agree with Hickory! Should hold up well - I buy all hickory drum sticks and they seem to last the best for me!

Pentz has great info, but not everyone needs that level of collection. If you know some of his history (it is tricky to find on his site, but it is there) He has had lung problems since childhood, so it is not surprising that he had issues working with exotic woods. I wear a P100 respirator 99% of the time in the shop. It made a huge difference for me. It is a pain, but I don't have the luxury of being able to afford thousands on an "Ideal" dust collection system.

It's clear that you're a Detroit Redwings fan, let's hear a little hockey talk every now and then

I think you could do walnut with a strip of bird's eye maple in the center.

@ElectricFlow

7 жыл бұрын

Or maybe the other way around..mainly maple with a strip of walnut.

I would mix the two woods, two maple and rest walnut.

What are you intentions for your current dust collector if/when you upgrade? I'll be in the market for one. Regarding the tool handles, what do you think of a bird's eye maple/walnut sandwich?

@JayBates2

7 жыл бұрын

I have a friend in need of an upgrade so I'm giving it to him.

I say birds eye maple to contrast the ferrel and chisel.

whatever has the straightest grain! Also, something that you won't be afraid of hitting! I think just strait grain hickory or maple. Walnut is to soft even if you are hitting straight end grain.

if it's not to late try laminating half walnut half maple

Nice watch

One of the best ways to reduce fine dust is to exhaust the collection system to the outside -

Birdseye maple. Or Hickory...like I saw suggested in another comment. I think you need the contrast...the walnut would not be enough contrast with the gunmetal.

normally i think walnut is nice on handles bu ti think the maple might contrast more with the black logo things (forgot the name) - look forward to seeing you back in the shop!

He liked it so he is going to put a ring on it...XD

Birdseye. Walnut is not strong enough for a chisel handle.

How about extracting dust and chips outside? There's no magic dust collector nor filter that can do such a good job.

Cool video. It's fun to see you get excited about your work.

birdseye maple for sure!!

Walnut handles. I think it will look better with less contrast.

Maple for the handles.

Have you considered a Birds Eye and Walnut lamination for the chisel handle?

Hiya, you should be super pumped about that video it's incredible. I worked on thousands of tv programs and yours is broadcast quality for content and production. My only comment and it's not a #should do, is mic yourself up please.

@JayBates2

7 жыл бұрын

Yup. Only had one mic though. Looking to get another when the budget has room.

Use maple and what about some kind of dust collection at the lathe

Did I see a We-Watch on your wrist? I have one and love it!!!

Hi Jay, Walnut for me, the contrast between the wood and the ring should be great. The maple is just toooo white

I plan to do the 2 stage harbor freight dust collector with a wynn filter. I plan to make it on a mobile cart to move to the work area. I have a small basement shop and everything is mobile. also plan to grab a cheaper jet style hanging filter for around $300. curious on your thoughts on this. setup.

birdseye maple for the win!

Birdseye will be harder.

Thanks for the VLOG Jay, what is your new camera?