Western is better than boss, but speed should not be in the cards, when plowing, take your time and be safe, a few seconds will not matter, it's always the great job you do, and best job.

notice that on the trip blade test the boss plow was going way faster than western

@sunxil3534

10 жыл бұрын

agree, and do you notice that western hardly trip but jump up when hit the obstruction, which means that if you plow with western in normal speed, your teeth will tell you the truth when hitting obstacle

@fixt100

10 жыл бұрын

even the speed test was biassed considering the boss has rams triple the size and strength of the western(hmm wonder which ones will last for a decade and which ones will start to leak and fail because they are under built)

@justinteal495

6 жыл бұрын

4 years late but let's not forget to mention the age gap between the two trucks

So basically this is an advert for Western Plow. Biased load of crap which is basically saying don't buy a boss plow they are crap, buy a western they are amazing.

as a former western plow dealer, it was very frustrating to sell a plow, or even worse, a customer would have say a western plow on a 2003 GMC THAT WAS STILL IN GOOD SHAP, BUT THE TRUCK WAS TIRED, SO HE BUYS A 2009 GMC, WELL THE WESTERN PLOW THE WAY THEY ARE MADE TODAY is some cases you could buy a 2200$ conversion kit to work on the newer 2009, but most times you don't have that option, witch means buying a whole new 7000$ plow now, not like back in the day were you could take a western plow take it off a 1980 ford f250 and in a few hours have it up and running on a 1985 ford f150 and out plowing, not the case any more, so if you change trucks, be ready to be cash grab in the market when you replace the truck, as you will be buying a whole new plow, not just a mod to the hook up on the truck, I would never put a plow on a new truck, there not built to take it, if you plow a lot be ready for a front end re-build after every winter, never mind your box bolts all stretched out and raddling

I've had both and am 100% convinced that when I went to Boss 9'2" Power Vee after having Westerns, there was no going back - not even with Westerns attempt to compete. I can plow lots to "military specs", to all corners, stacking as high and able to push back as far as I need without needing to load my bobcat up and bring with me to clear corners. Boss is BOSS - that's why it's called THE BOSS! :-)

@catfish3562

7 ай бұрын

bs

I still prefer boss I have less problems with boss and these trucks aren't even the same they don't travel the same speed either

BOSS PLOW ARE THE WAY TO GO!

boss plow all the way

Using a full trip plow against a trip edge is literally apples to oranges comparison, they should’ve used a Boss DXT blade against that Western

I have Boss 9.2 and love it ..

Boss all the way

I have owned Fisher v - plows for over 11 years and was very satisfied. I just purchased a new Fisher extreme v2 and am very dissatisfied with how noisy the blade is. The blade clatters so loudly that it caused a few of my tenants to come out of their homes enquiring about the noise. I called the manufacture and they suggested felt or silicone between the ribs and face board. If anyone else has had the same problem, and you have fixed it, please share your solution with me. Other than that, the plow works great; however, if I had known about this problem, I would have purchased a Boss or Meyers. Probably a Meyers, because of the 5 year warranty and that the face board is welded to the ribs, would eliminate the loud clatter. Sorry Fisher, hopefully engineering can get this right. Other than that, you have always had a great product. Larry

This helped me make a decision . I will leave my truck home and put a Pronovost PXPL snowblower on my tractor .

I think it all boils down to who visits the welder most.

I use a boss blade every time i move snow. It seems to me that everything they were saying about the western is true about the boss. The boss has almost all the features that he said it didnt

I’ve used both western and boss I like them both they are top notch plows the boss it’s bit more complicated to take off and put it in the western it takes less than a minute. I’ve used western for the last 8 years it never let me down the only thing went bad on it in 8 years was the controller I just bought another truck with western mvp3 plow I absolutely love it

I've had my Boss V for 14 years and just today one spring broke. Pretty damn good! I always love how they "stack em up" against each other with huge bias! Cool!!! If I'd have watched this video before buying my plow I'd have bought 3 Westerns!!!! LOL!!!! My dad had a Western on his pickup a long time ago and it was a pile of shit. Maybe they're better now but my Dad cussing at his still lingers in my mind.

@MBTAMoreRailfan

4 жыл бұрын

Erik Lund it’s a biased vid with a lot of fake stuff.

I had a old curtis plow on my old truck, and people can say what they want about those plows, but that plow was a BEAST.. The only issue I had with the plow was getting any service parts for it, as the dealership network is almost non existent. I got a newer truck, and went with a western plow. This is my third year with it, and most likely my last year with it. Upon installing it, I went through two light modules. I got a good one, FINALLY, then ran the plow. This year, I mounted it, and it raised and froze. The controller went into a security lock mode, and ran to my nearest dealer, about 45 minutes away so they could use a master controller on it to free it up, put mine back on it and it worked for a whole 15 minutes. As soon as I got it home, it went into a communication error mode, and wouldn't function. I called that dealer back and was told that the plow module NEVER GOES BAD, but I should diagnose it myself! Basically making me feel that because I do some minor residential usage with it, that i'm not as important as any of their commercial accounts! I can not diagnose it myself without the test harness, or I can cut wires and try to jump the plug, or borrow another controller to narrow it down. Two snow storms later, and after contacting the western plow main headquarters, that dealership got me in, and they were able to diagnose it after 3 hours finding that the module was bad! WTF?? On a 3 year old plow, one year of which we had no snow!!!! GARBAGE!!! I shouldn't have had to replace the plow module so soon! After this season is over, I plan on pulling the entire setup off my truck and selling it all. Looking at a BOSS or Meyers. Screw fisher and western!

@DynoDieselWagon

Жыл бұрын

Curtis jUnK

This guy isn't biased at all, but western does have cool features, but IMO I think boss is just built better, snow plow mechanic says boss a better buy due to fewer break downs, I guess western has a electrical box that if any problem with it you have to replace the entire box which is a lot of money, overall it's all in your own perspective, they both make ya money!

Get the Boss!

WESTERN IS THE BEST,,,cost more work better,,all i will ever run,,

I run a Western but this just shows how good both are. The fact that they are nitpicking things on the Boss that really don't matter shows they are fairly equal. I've used a Boss plenty of times and they are great plows and probably will be my next one if this Western ever wears out.

This vid is 3 seasons old. BOSS have a wider range of models and features now. Including a trip-edge combined with their trip-blade system.

the snow Dogg is often overlooked and I think it's every bit as good...it's on the heavier side, but you can't beat the no maintenance required of the stainless...

This guy has no idea how the Boss V Controller works. It accomplishes all the same things with less buttons

@King-tw1vi

3 жыл бұрын

He’s also comparing a larger boss plow to a smaller western which obviously the western is going to move faster it’s not as large.

@roberttaylor8261

Жыл бұрын

I have a Boss Vplow an got a Joystick make a big difference on speed of use! I tried handheld an seams always hitting control buttons where the stick does 2 moves at once!

@roberttaylor8261

Жыл бұрын

Typacal Guy doing video to sell a Differant product! Both plows are good but both have good an bad!

"Our product may not be as good, but at least we have good lawyers" But clearly this test is quite angled in favour of the winning party.

in milwaukee area we see alot of western plows but up north we see alot of boss, it depends where you live

It's all about preference really. Boss plows are better for professional plowers I see that a lot in my state. When your first learning to plow and get your feel western v plows are a must to start with once you get your feel in sell that western and invest in the boss straight blade.

Any of you boss guys run the HTX-V? Looking at one for my 1/2 ton Trailboss. 5400 installed. Any issues ?

The hydraulic speed is actually adjustable on the Boss Snowplows. You can set the speed to go faster or slower. Really lame video by Western. I guess when you have an inferior product all you can do is lie about the competition.

Yeah that Boss trip blade set up cost my friend a lot of money when it didn't trip in the v position... Wrecked the front end of the truck and the plow. I like fisher plows the best

You can adjust the speed on the Boss it can move a lot quicker than that western but I guess western didn't show that because they have an inferior product

@masonh2538

8 жыл бұрын

Hahahahaha no western doesn't need to be adjusted. If I had to adjust my plow right after I bought it I'd be pissed

@Jasha333

7 жыл бұрын

Tim Dion everything gets adjusted when it's initially installed, no matter the brand. if you don't like the speed that your dealer adjusted your hydro pump at, just have them change it. this video is extremely biased towards western if you havnt noticed already..

Guys I will go with western because I hav have had one and it's true

there favoring western .. but boss in a better built plow, western just goes off of there more options, but they do not last as long as a boss, and the boss controles are better just like Jeremy Whitmore said,, less buttons is faster ,, you dont have to switch modes, witch takes longer ... boss is just a better build and long lasting plow

Also when they do the trip blade test what if the boss blade is not in float. When they do the speed blade test the boss blade looks bigger.so they would just make it look bigger

What about the aluminum pump in the western vs the cast Iron in the boss

false if you push both of the right buttons on the boss plow it will bring the left win forwards and the right back vise versa so it will work as a straight blade

I can say from experience the western plow is a lot easier to run and it is faster then the boss plow Iv ran bout for a number of years

Thank you for your unbiased opinion. This comparison really shows the pros and cons to each brand.

this guy dont know what hes talking about. BOSS is all ill ever run. and you can move the wings in a straight blade motion. and the down presser is better for scraping and also can put it in float. BOSS all the way hands down.

obviously this guy has never commercially plowed snow. BOSS is built stronger and is faster like i got time for my wings to move.

And all plow manufacturers have their down falls no plow is unbreakable.!! So having knowledge and tools on hand to fix these issues is a must before jumping in a truck and plowing. If not at least have a reliable source for when the time comes that plow breaks. Because they ALL will.

My boss bought 3 of these plows. Now waiting for snow.

You know what proves which is better? What real world contractors are using. Aside from the western wideout, all I see on the trucks of those who do this for a living, is BOSS plows. I personally love my Fisher 7'6", but I'd get a BOSS plow if I wanted to make a living off plowing.

Its funny because boss offers trip edge as well

The boss is faster. If you use the remote as designed.

Look at the speed of the boss vs western. Of course the Boss is going to respond harshly. It's going faster than the western!!! I call BS Western!!!!

I have Western straight blades at work. I camt stamd them. Parking lots, winding hilly roadways. Bike paths. Cant use a straight blade. Is also like to add the Western throws snow in your "face" (windscreen) with the slightest gust of wind.

I'll stick with my boss plows

hay I love westerns plow sow I'm going with western and I'm only 8 year old I want a plow truck

@user-xc1qc

4 жыл бұрын

well now your 12 and you still cant drive

Two completely different trucks!!!! Different suspension systems!!!

BOSS all day.

I'll stick with my boss plow.

Im a total Boss guy, have a whole fleet of Boss plows. Look at how complicated the western controller is vs the boss smart touch controller. I live in Milwaukee and still wouldnt ever buy a Western even though theyre made a few miles from my shop.

I've ran them all over the years. I'll stick with Snow-Ex. Much like the western as they're both DD subsidiaries ... except it's better.

Boss hands down I had a western. I run boss now. Lots of labor. Attaching brackets removing brackets for ground clearance. If the western settles in soft or frozen ground melt. Mounting isn't easy at all. It's harder. As for theft . Why they to remember a code. I can just unplug my controller. Good luck if you want to take my plow. Unless you have a controller on you. Boss is heavier then western. That's important on commercial jobs. Scrapping a parking lot to bare pavement. To salt for the hospital. Bring any western you want. I'll bet you 500 I can stack snow higher. And push your piles back more

Looks like the operator of the Boss plow is making it go slow. I'll stick with The Boss.

I didnt know the snow plow industries customers were facing such a hard time with theft......

This is very funny because the western is exact same as the Fisher extreme v

sure sounds like western is paying u lol id still buy a boss hate the chain i like the hydraulics for back blading pressure.

Bunch of goofs... BOSS everyday all day

Boss is and has always been the better plow. I only have a western now because that's what my grandfather wanted when he owned the business. When it comes time to buy a new plow it will be a boss! The comparison of the controllers was a complete bunch of bs. If you push in the middle of the top buttons you get scoop and middle of the bottom buttons you get vee same as middle of the left both wings operate to give you left angle and same for the other side. There's nothing better or worse about one control over the other because they all have the exact same functions. I guess one better benefit would be that boss does it with only 5 switches so it's less parts to wear out.

i bought a western straight plow in 1995 not only did i just sell it in feb,2017 the young man is still using it, i never ever had any problems with it, i did just buy a sno-way and have had nothing but problems with bran new sno-way plow,, im really pissed i tried to save 800 or so dollars and i have spent over 14 hours trying to get sno-way to figure out how to get electrical correct for lights on a 2016 chevy silverado LT, penny wise and dollar stupid ,

Alternative title: Western employee trashing the #1 plow manufacturer in the United States

All ill say is look at the construction of a BOSS and look at that of a western. The western only has a pin where the two sides pivot about and the boss has a whole center. you tell me whats more durable. a pin or a weldment

I will keep my boss vxt with wings.

I'm a fisher man, Rockland maine.

This is just a western schill ad, and the speed test, the boss has way more articulation so its obviously gunna take longer, the western has very short strokes. You can short chain a boss, just carry 4 ft of chain in the emergency box. And have you ever hooked up a western by yourself? "Easy hook system " dont forget the 8 pins needed lol

and I live the disclaimers! !! what does that say... "We at western Lie and Steal out ideas, and Edit the commercials to make us look good" sad.. truly sad

someone here has never run a boss controller. Boss controller hands down is the better controller

the first plow I ever used was a fisher and it was the greatest thing since the invention of the wheel. damn thing was older than I was but it was damn good. if I was smart back then I would have pulled it off the old jimmy and found another truck but at the time both the truck and plow was 28 years old and the truck was literally falling apart around the plow. now I have a piece of shit Meyer and this thing sucks out loud. ALL but 2 of the factory welds have broken on it and it is so unreliable I have hung it up for the winter (thankfully I only plow my renter, my sisters, there kids and myself) because of the extreme unreliable nature of the Meyer I have now I did not do any "for hire" jobs this year. so now I'm in the market for a new plow to go on my recently purchased suburban and I don't feel like driving 100 miles one way to the nearest fisher dealer so I'm looking at western (witch is the sister company to fisher) and I have looked at boss plows. I like the chain system for one big reason. In case shit goes wrong I can chain it up and get it home. I've been plowing for a long time and I have learned a lot but the important one is no matter what plow and truck combo you have if it can go wrong it will go wrong and it will never happen 1 pm Monday a block from NAPA. it will happen 20 miles out of town at 8 pm. a guy could ratchet strap the plow up but I have had those fail too. I haven't made my final choice but those are my 2 top picks. western has the chain system witch I love but the dealer is 30 miles away. the only advantage boss has for me is the dealer is 5 miles away. western has twice the warranty boss is offering so I'm leaning toward western. but still weighing the decision.

This is a pathetic comparison it's way to biased to get the actual truth on both plows.

It's all about the blizzard power plow. Just saying. Bigger faster cleaner better looking.

boss

how moch is cost this plow

Boss is better than western it can do the same things they just might not be as big and expensive

What BS. My Boss plow is 22 years old and works great, see if that Western will last that long

@ethanrobison9886

3 жыл бұрын

We used to own a Wester v plow (then again we were the second owner of the truck and plow) that plow didn’t sit straight, it was a 3 man job to hook up the plow, and it was always in the shop

All the boss owners sitting around with the time to hate on this video when all the hustlers running western are out making the big bucks

Get an Arctic Vplow, it blows all of these plows right off the road.

Funny how they say that the test trucks are comparatable but in all reality one is a early 90s and the other is a 2006 I dont consider 12 years difference to be similar.

The newer one lmaooo

he also implies the boss cant stack high as the western, B.S. I stack it just as high as anyother plow with my Power V-XT

Watching this video makes me laugh.... they pick the small boss plow, they say it doesnt trip in the scoop mode or v mode when i know they do. and you can order the trip edge for the boss. Dont forget that boss stands behind their plows 20 times better than any other company.

Ill take a fisher any day of the week

I have personal experience with both brands. My first V-plow blade was a Western and I liked it.....BUT I bought a new truck later, so bought another Western V Plow (BIG MISTAKE!!!). Here's what changed....I found out later, WESTERN COPIED BOSS'S DESIGN FOR BLADE TRIP ACTION ON MY EARLIER PLOW (that's why my first Western worked so well---it was a Boss design). BOSS TOOK WESTERN TO COURT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT AND WON!!...so WESTERN COULD NO LONGER USE BOSS'S TRIP DESIGN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So, after losing in court, WESTERN REDESIGNED THEIR PLOW WITH THE VERY POOR "TRIP EDGE SYSTEM". The trip edge system allows only the bottom 6 inches of the blade to trip and the rest of the plow stays put.....THIS SOUNDS GOOD ON PAPER, BUT WESTERN'S DESIGN DOES NOT WORK!! So...when I bought a 2nd Western, it had the "TRIP EDGE SYSTEM". YOU WILL NOT BELIEVE THIS....IN THE NORMAL PROCESS OF PUSHING SNOW, THE WESTERN "TRIP EDGE SYSTEM" WILL INDEED TRIP, EVEN THOUGH YOU HAVEN'T STRUCK AN OBSTACLE!! So, you'll be pushing snow and the WEIGHT of the snow (NOT AN OBSTACLE), WILL TRIP THE BLADE. With the bottom 6 inches of your blade tripped, snow builds up under the front of your truck and you are soon stuck. I contacted WESTERN many times about this, since it was under warranty and was told it was working AS DESIGNED!!! SO AFTER HAVING THIS WESTERN FOR 2 MONTHS....I TRADED IT FOR A BOSS POWER V AND HAVE HAD ZERO PROBLEMS. (I lost $750 in the trade, but it was worth it). WESTERN IS A SLEAZY COMPANY....THEY STOLE BOSS'S DESIGN AND THEY GOT CAUGHT. THEY TREATED ME LIKE DIRT AS A CUSTOMER.... EVERYTHING IN THIS VIDEO IS A FLAT OUT LIE!!! DO NOT PURCHASE WESTERN....I COULD GO INTO DETAIL ABOUT THE OTHER LIES IN THIS VIDEO, BUT THE BIGGEST IS THE "TRIP EDGE ISSUE". I LOVE MY BOSS POWER V AND HAVE HAD IT FOR 7 YEARS NOW...ZERO PROBLEMS! FEEL FREE TO ASK QUESTIONS ON THIS KZread, I WILL TRY TO RESPOND. THANK!

@michaelkey3915

2 жыл бұрын

That doesn't happen. it only trips when hitting an obstacle. i've plowed with a trip edge western for years now and never a single issue. clearly you were doing something wrong or had it assembled incorrectly or something of the sort. It will NOT trip just from the weight of the snow. what a joke.

oh so this is a commercial, not a real test.... GO SNO WAY!

@briant3403

7 жыл бұрын

sno way cant even get their own electrical harness to work on a bran new truck after 14 hours losers

@eddiecunninghamlll9684

6 жыл бұрын

M Maida I've seemed to snow ways in 30 years up here in Buffalo, they'll never be a market here for them unfortunately

@monarchlandcare8683

5 жыл бұрын

I've got a snoway 29 and boss super duty. I'll take my snoway over the boss, I actually have to fight my dad for that truck. It is so much quieter and smoother than our boss. And it has down preassure. That's just us though. Our boss is still damn good. This is definitely promoting westerns plows.

Hit a curb that is higher than what your trip edge protects. See how that goes and report back

@4:38 they are wrong....you can press either both right or both left and the plow angles in the respective direction...you dont have to press bottons diagonally like shown...pretty biased video

Im partial to my Curtis plow........

Good thing western let's you change plows from a vplow to a straight blade by just switching out my control, oh wait I can't, who's the BOSS

@trumpetman1984

2 жыл бұрын

This is 3 years late, but even 3 and more years ago you could use the BOSS v controller and run a straight blade. AND you can run a straight v blade with a straight blade controller but will only be able to use it in the straight blade configuration. I know this because we have 3 BOSS plows. 2 v blades and 1 straight. I needed a backup controller one night when out but only had an extra straight controller in one truck. That was able to get me through the night when I could get the correct controller and the other fixed

They say the springs last the life of the plow...which is 1 season

lol, this was not an advertisement for western I promise

unless you do eleventeen driveways a day, how are they cost effective they cost more than 2 of my trucks and I plow miles of driveways.

There is only one plow everyone should buy it’s not a straight blade and it’s not a V plow it’s the (boss EXT) and like boss says you get a true 10 feet when compared to your competitors just over 9 feet that would be western… Just like boss says it’s a parking lot plow… I have one and I have been plowing for 34 years and as far as I’m concerned it’s the best plow ever made!!!

Western plows are obviously the best just don't buy it from Trux Outfitter in Ithaca New York

Gee I wonder if this review was bias or not.. and they also compared a XT plow Not a DXT the better model. To the "top notch western"

@daytonrd17

6 жыл бұрын

With actual knowledge of the system. I work for Boss Snowplow and manufacture their products.

Goddamn laywers

Western on the bump test jumped higher than boss. Ant the anti theft sucks someone can just pull the pin and it's off. that is why boss is better

Watch the comparison I thought, SHIT! My Boss plow is being installed tomorrow morning. Did I make a bad decision? I think this comparison is really an ad for Western.

You’re wrong about the straight blade control on the boss. If you hold down both buttons on the left the blades will straight blade to the left same to the right. The fewer buttons the better. Read the damn owners manual!