It's crazy to think how complicated this whole thing is and was

@chairmansam312

7 ай бұрын

The British were very intelligent

@sammymcfone8281

7 ай бұрын

Because the vile Germans simply will not stop their villainous empire building. Love from the peace loving, nothing to do with this UK.

@On1Zuk4-Sensei

7 ай бұрын

No. Things are complicated today. Not so then. There is a CLEAR pattern which repeats itself here in this story, concering the origins, the root causes of the conflict today (that has become ,indeed I repeat, VERY complicated) Can you tell what it is ?

@sammymcfone8281

7 ай бұрын

@@On1Zuk4-Sensei the Germans? No! The bloody French. The French?

@nkristianschmidt

6 ай бұрын

The Arabs and friends got 99.7 pct of the Middle East but could not accept the immigrants from the 0.3 pct that is Israel. The solution to today's problems is that the Middle Eastern countries take their felllows in as immigrants same as Israel took millions from the Arab countries and the rest of the World. But, alas, 99.7 pct is not enough for them. And they sure as H do not want their fellows as immigrants. That would solve too many problems for Israel and perhaps generate some for themselves.

Surely this one will be received with less controversy than the first one /s

@wizard680

7 ай бұрын

Lol

@sammymcfone8281

7 ай бұрын

​@@wizard680Because the vile Germans simply will not stop their villainous empire building. Love from the peace loving, nothing to do with this UK.

This video was timed well

@sammymcfone8281

7 ай бұрын

Because the vile Germans simply will not stop their villainous empire building. Love from the peace loving, nothing to do with this UK.

@eliebechara3811

6 ай бұрын

I mean the conflict has been going on forever 😅

@TheMrPeteChannel

5 ай бұрын

​@@eliebechara3811it will never end.

@wizzyno1566

2 ай бұрын

​@@eliebechara3811thats not the point.

seeing how complicated this issue is I cannot see any way how there can ever be peace in this region, generational hate will keep this fire lit.

@nkristianschmidt

6 ай бұрын

The Arabs and friends got 99.7 pct of the Middle East after ww1 and ww2 but could not accept the immigrants from the 0.3 pct that is Israel. The solution to today's problems is that the Middle Eastern countries take their felllows in as immigrants same as Israel took millions from the Arab countries and the rest of the World. But, alas, 99.7 pct is not enough for them. And they sure as H do not want their fellows as immigrants. That would solve too many problems for Israel and perhaps generate some for themselves.

@MM-yl9gn

6 ай бұрын

Israel needs to buck the west and play on the middle east not calling for refugees while grilling the west for importation of syrian refugee exploitation of cheap labour since all the world revolves around Israel and the jews, right? Mkay

Will watch it later, commenting and liking for the algorithm

My Lord this video was amazing. I'm searching (hoping) for a Part 3.

Once again it’s still better than the original since it’s longer

@sammymcfone8281

7 ай бұрын

Yes!! Because the vile Germans simply will not stop their villainous empire building. Love from the peace loving, nothing to do with this UK.

Man that German Jew voice sounds great I wonder if he has other terrible accents

@brianhall8588

6 ай бұрын

Doesn’t sound German at all.

@CivilWarWeekByWeek

6 ай бұрын

@@brianhall8588 Correct I said it in english

@brianhall8588

6 ай бұрын

@@CivilWarWeekByWeek it still didn’t sound like a German person speaking English. Go visit Germany

Use my code CASUAL to get $5 off your delicious, high protein Magic Spoon cereal by clicking this link: sponsr.is/magicspoon_casual Also, this video is a remake of one I made released a few weeks ago, but it's 30 minutes longer. Enjoy.

@TeddyBelcher4kultrawide

7 ай бұрын

Do you have a problem spelling out Montenegro

This is the best series, now you should get lots of views

Thank you for a thorough history. This topic needs this sort of care, and you did an excellent job.

Eagerly waiting for part 3.

Great vids keep em coming

@joeshyafunds

6 ай бұрын

less shoulder shrugs tho

Why is bearded Ryan Gosling in the thumbnail?

Excellent production....

Outstanding information, thank you.

Good video

WOW, good info.

2:02 Not only Women. It was also vice-versa and it was usually only technical marriage. Someone in the family of my great grandparents was married to a women, but they didn't actually were married or even were close friends. Of course, they soon divorced.

@user-sh3cf7kd6e

7 ай бұрын

Also, they weren't da mn "settlers". They were immigrants and refugees that had no other place in the world to go to.

@donovanlocust1106

7 ай бұрын

​@@user-sh3cf7kd6eshh they hate the truth

@TheTruth-ko9ov

6 ай бұрын

user-sh3cf7kd6e It's not their land.. and why the hell Palestine should be responsible of what was happening to the jews in the Europe!!!! What was happening to jews in Europe shouldn't be an excuse to occupy Palestine and expelling its people. So Palestinians didn't do anything to the jews who were living in Palestine and they also didn't do any harm to jews who were escaping from Europe.. but to double their population and trying to get everything for them was a turning point and they have all rights to be against what was happening..

@donovanlocust1106

6 ай бұрын

@@TheTruth-ko9ov except the Palestinians worked with the Nazis so....

@fantastichound

6 ай бұрын

​@@donovanlocust1106yes a little tiny issue there

You're gonna have to make whole new video after today

Great timing.

47:37 MISTAKE DETECTED! AMIN'S TOP QUOTE SAYS "IT'S" WHILE IT SHOULD BE "ITS"! UNACCEPTABLE Jk, great vid. Enjoyed the extra content throughly. This series is very relevant to me as an Israeli.

@cameraman502

6 ай бұрын

Literally unwatchable

Of course, the uploads to Playeur aren't going through on the videos that are most likely to get pulled from KZread...

I don’t know how anyone could watch this and still not understand the plight of the Jews…

Very good coverage of a period that is usually glossed over in a sentence or two about the history of the conflict. Side comment about the format: the stock video clips that pop up during the narration are really jarring and annoying. They have nothing to do with the topic, time-frame or the people involved in the story. People who are interested in a deep dive into complex topics like this really don't need the irrelevant eye candy to stay interested in what you have to say.

@chrisscotney4124

6 ай бұрын

Or the continuously playing ads every 5 minutes they spoil the flow

Yummy factual representation

looking good man

Wow Grant. Impressive work. There is nothing good about this horrific nightmare of October 7th and aftermath but at least it caused me to find your incredible work. Thank you for providing a resource for people to understand more than just slogans and chants. Blessings to you.

Nothing bloody changes.

Who did that fantastic Churchill impression?

Is part 3 coming?

I think a lot of Amin al-Hussein's mentality, is actually why there's never been a Palestinian state, and probably never will be. It's a mentality of a revolutionary, not the leader of a nation-state. You can tell from his conversations with Arab diplomats and British diplomats that he doesn't have any idea what he's doing or talking about, and he's completely incompetent for the position that he has on a global stage. He wants strikes, battles, to speak recklessly and talk endlessly about conspiracy theories, while all the responsibilities of feeding his people, engaging in diplomacy, signing treaties, and ensuring stability and progress for his people is outsourced to other leaders in other countries. Same was done with Arafat, and the same is done today in Gaza, and to a lesser extent the West Bank. The leaders are of course wealthy, even Abbas has a net worth of over 100 million, but of course he pails in comparison to the OGs in Gaza who run Hamas and are sitting on billions, while the United Nations, the West and even Israel actually feed their people and help fund them so they can keep having kids, so they can play around like Jacobins in the 21st century. It's also a testament to how much our Enlightenment/Liberalism thinking really pisses off people who are devoted to Political Islam and the desire for an Arabic/Islamic Empire. The more we give them money, the more we take care of their people, the more it reminds them that their old ways, no longer work in the modern world, and how if they actually want to "take care of their people" they have to risk it coming at the expense of their religion, just like the West had to sacrifice the primacy of Faith, to have an Industrial and Scientific civilization.

@DB-nl4qd

4 ай бұрын

Well said 👏 Israel is an amazing case story it is literally the only indigenous people of the land that came back to rule back the land. And jews are not only part of a religion they are also an ethnic group as it is not easy to convert to Judaism, as it is not like other religions that you need to read a few lines more or less. To be fair like you say the Palestenian leaders also don't really want a state. They want something they won't get and then they aren't really after peace.

@fleebertreatise1063

16 күн бұрын

Today, one of the most popular Palestinians is Marwan Barghouthi He’s currently in prison and probably won’t ever be released, but when polled Palestinians rate him higher than Hamas. Here’s more info about him (the quote below) I think it’s important to remember that when your in the position that Palestinians are in, some of the best leaders will either be imprisoned or killed by Israel, or by other Palestinians. When you have a conflict like this that is the center of your political, historical, and ideological existence, the cream of the crop of leaders will probably join up and use violence. Kind of like if a person grew up around many gangs. A more extreme nationalist version of that. “Marwan Barghouti. One of the most popular Palestinian leaders, Barghouti is currently serving multiple life terms in an Israeli prison. He briefly challenged Abbas for the PA presidency, which caused alarm among some Israeli and U.S. officials: Barghouti eventually withdrew from the race and supported Abbas. Born in Ramallah, he became active in the Fatah movement at age 15. He was arrested and sent to Israeli prison, where he learned Hebrew. After his release, he earned bachelor’s and master’s degrees at Bir Zeit University in the West Bank.” “One of the leaders of the first intifada against Israel in 1987, he was arrested and deported to Jordan, where he lived for seven years. He was elected to the Palestinian Legislative Council in 1996 and earned the respect of the Palestinian street by criticizing corruption among PA officials and human-rights abuses by the Palestinian security services. During the second intifada, Barghouti worked with the al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade, a division of the Tanzim militia associated with Fatah that conducts violent attacks against Israeli civilians. Israeli soldiers arrested Barghouti in 2002; he was convicted of four counts of murder in an Israeli court and sentenced to five life terms in prison.”

@fleebertreatise1063

16 күн бұрын

Also, never say never. There are other leaders. Violent leadership and activities have to be delegitimized though. That is a tough process IMO, but is possible. Iran isn’t helping the situation, but does put give Palestinians allies. If military force is used as leverage instead of in active fighting, possibly that leads to some form of deal. “Ahmed Qurei (Abu Ala). Qurei, the PA prime minister, is an Arafat loyalist and a member of the Fatah old guard. Like Abbas, he is thought to be a more moderate and pragmatic leader than Arafat was, although he has had little success implementing Abbas’ reforms. Qurei trained as a banker and succeeded Abbas as PA prime minister in 2003. Born in Jerusalem, Qurei joined Fatah in the 1960s and came to prominence in the mid-1970s, when he headed the group’s economic wing in Lebanon. He designed a key Palestinian development plan, which was presented to a World Bank aid conference in 1993 and became the cornerstone of the Palestinian development strategy. Qurei also headed the Palestinian Legislative Council, was instrumental in the Oslo negotiation process, and helped design the Palestinian Economic Council for Development and Reconstruction. After the parliament-recommended shakeup October 3, Qurei will keep his post, but must name a new cabinet within two weeks.” “Mohammed Dahlan. A former head of the Palestinian Security Forces (PSF) in Gaza, Dahlan was minister of civil affairs in Abbas’ cabinet. Dahlan is seen as a member of Fatah’s younger “new guard,” but some critics say he and his peers lack the national stature and credibility to negotiate with the Israelis. Born in a Gaza refugee camp, Dahlan was a founder of the Fatah Youth Association in 1981. Arrested eleven times by Israel, he was deported in 1987 and made his way to PLO headquarters in Tunis; from there, he continued to orchestrate street protests in the West Bank and Gaza, earning Arafat’s trust. When Arafat and his fellow Fatah partisans returned to Palestinian territories under the terms of the Oslo Accords in 1994, Dahlan was made Gaza’s security chief. Civil-rights advocates criticized his tactics as head of the Gaza security forces, accusing him of using the PSF to harass and intimidate Arafat’s political enemies. While he is generally popular with younger members of Fatah, his periodic arrests of Palestinian militants-demanded by Israel and the United States-have been deeply unpopular on the Palestinian street. A critic of Arafat who both participated in and suffered from PA infighting, Dahlan resigned as security chief in June 2002, but returned to serve as interior minister in Abbas’ short-lived 2003 cabinet.”

That video of the bandits, wow they had quite modern weapons, no wonder they got their way

What great timing

As some who is admittedly uneducated on this history i appreciate these video. Cheers

This is very complicated. I cannot say which side is right. 😮😮😮

During this period, Stalin was interested in 1936, but was bogging down running the Great Purge (Ежовщина).

Thank you sir, your videos are unreal

Will there be part 3?

@CasualHistorian

7 ай бұрын

It probably will happen, but how soon it happens depends on how well part 2 does.

@adalhussain558

7 ай бұрын

​@@CasualHistorianpart 2 was great 😊

@Geizer52

6 ай бұрын

Your work is absolutely phenomenal. I encourage you to keep on. Because of the depth and vastness of what you cover, please do NOT judge whether or not to continue this series, by simple YT or monetary standards. This is the kind of work that will eventually be used in classrooms, up to and including post graduate research. In time, with your intellect, and the help of other professionals, you might even be able to create materials that could be incorporated for use in middle school, or basically tailored to various audiences. But now is the TIME to keep assembling ALL your research. With gratitude from one of the elders of Zion….

@RabidMullet

6 ай бұрын

@@CasualHistorian Your content is amazing. Please don't leave us hanging...

It's Golda Meir, not Golda Mayor.

Great video. Not sure why you use recent footage and modern type footage tho.

There's a decent chance ben gurion could have been talking about independent arab communists

Convenient timing 🤔🧐🤔

This is important history. Makes it understandable that it is a problem without a solution. But, a compromise is possible if both sides are determined to change the design of Israel.

When putting the map of the mandate on screen you have a map of modern Israel. I'm wondering if the Golan Heights included were actually part of the mandate

@y.l7455

Ай бұрын

They actually were at some time in the history of the Mandate but then were given to Syria.

Eu gosto.dessas imagens antigas.

Ironic give the recent events.

I stopped when he said the thankless job of the british and french, 0:42 . Truly a casual historian.

I truly hope you continue this story, its the first time I really had to hear objectively all events. Thank you so much. I also would like to ask something. We keep hearing about the arab majority for millenia. However I came across the book "Palestina ex Monumtis Veteribus Illustrata" from 1695 describing something completely different, namely Jewish and Christian being the majority in a desolated land. Plus beduins. It would mean a lot to know the facts also earlier to understand the claims of the arab palestinians.

@henrykanning245

6 ай бұрын

You mean the Arab civilians who were massacred, forced onto trucks, then banned from ever returning to their homes? To somehow view this conflict “Objectively” you need to ignore the clear disparity in power between Jews and Palestinians. To somehow view Israel as a victim to have to ignore the reality that Israel has committed far more violence than the Palestinians have.

@12w3hji123456789

6 ай бұрын

@@henrykanning245 hundreds of thousands of Jews in the arab nations also where expelled or had to flee. They where in most cases reduced to close to zero jews left. While in Israel there lives 2 million arabs.

@Jozaam-21

6 ай бұрын

@@henrykanning245 Lol 😂 Always try to find an excuse as usual, is that not what the Roman, the Muslim conquerors and other kingdoms did to the Jews in the first place?

@henrykanning245

6 ай бұрын

@@Jozaam-21 It’s not an excuse it’s not being ok with ethnic cleansing and Genocide. Anti-Semitism should be a lesson against trying to liquidate entire populations yet here you are defending a state trying to remove its indigenous population to make room for western settlers.

@El_Jefe_Maestro

6 ай бұрын

You seem to not understand that most "Arabs" arent actually Arabians, they are culturally ARABIZED locals. There are genetic studies showing Palestinian Arabs share more DNA with Middle Eastern Jews and ancient Bronze Age Levant samples like Canaanites than European Jews do. Palestinan Arabs are simply pagans and Jews that converted to Christianity and Islam and became Arabized over the centuries due to various conquerors passing through.

Where is part 1?

The reason for Arab rejection of Israel is: 1. A pride thing. This is big in their culture. 2. Its location within "dar al Islam," a region of the world formerly belonging to imperial Islam (caliphate). For dhimmis to self-determine there is an "insult." 3. Self-determination being a more Western thing in the first place.

@theguyshadows

6 ай бұрын

More of a thing in Western countries, but Britain still denied the Palestinians the right to self-determination. What great Western value! Selectively applied.

@anthonymorris5084

6 ай бұрын

@@theguyshadows The "Palestinians" are Arab. The British and French created the sovereign independent nations of Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, and Jordan, all Arab and all sitting right on top of Palestine. You're welcome.

@El_Jefe_Maestro

6 ай бұрын

​@@anthonymorris5084You seem to not understand that most "Arabs" arent actually Arabians, they are culturally ARABIZED locals. There are genetic studies showing Palestinian Arabs share more DNA with Middle Eastern Jews and ancient Bronze Age Levant samples like Canaanites than European Jews do. Palestinan Arabs are simply pagans and Jews that converted to Christianity and Islam and became Arabized over the centuries due to various conquerors passing through

@y.l7455

Ай бұрын

@@theguyshadows Britain created Jordan and gave the fate of the other part of the Mandate to the UN which gave the Arabs the option to create another Arab state along side with the Jewish one. The Arabs refused and attacked Israel, for 18 years occupied the territories that the UN gave them to form a palestine state to begin with but didn't establish one.

Man, amin al-husseini sounds like ilham aliyev here. 1:07:52

@ananmuadi31

7 ай бұрын

He just admitted that he's a colonial settler here, and that the arab cause is a colonial cause.

@ananmuadi31

7 ай бұрын

But sooner or later, like how the Jews returned to Jerusalem after being ethnically cleansed by the british-arab created state named jorda, the Armenians will return to Artsakh.

@Matt-bl4bu

7 ай бұрын

@@ananmuadi31 Maybe better to forget about contested land. Lives are more impotant.

@ananmuadi31

7 ай бұрын

​​@@Matt-bl4buTell that to the Armenians of Artsakh and the Cypriots. I dare you.

@Matt-bl4bu

7 ай бұрын

@@ananmuadi31 Armenians evacuated, so they must agree with me, for now at least..

this because it was mainly black after 57:00 ? o7 keep up the good work

@CasualHistorian

7 ай бұрын

Yeah. Something weird happened while exporting the original. It's fixed now.

Well a certain Englishman was there to deal with the early Palestinian Arab insurgents.

Excellent Doc!

October 11, 2023 and its probably as bad as it's ever been.

One correction: Hitler assumed dictatorial power after the death of President Hindenburg, not Ludendorff.

Crazy how one side has money and knowledge the other side is jealous and violent and we this as a conflict of equals.

You asked if anyone knows what involvement the Soviets had in these riots to comment and let you know. Here I am. I am very familiar with this topic. I know. 😊 I am letting you know I know. Are you happy ?

This was posted before the October 7th attack by Hamas?

@CasualHistorian

4 ай бұрын

Yup

@ellengeller4832

4 ай бұрын

Was it a prescient posting? It seems mindbogglingly apt now. The Palestinians live in a fantasy world. I bet they secretly enjoy having benefitted from proximity to Jews, but they keep that to themselves. It has made their unexceptional lives quite exceptionsl. @@CasualHistorian

@everettduncan7543

4 күн бұрын

​@@CasualHistorian Only a week before the attack, and just months after protests against Hamas in Gaza

7:50 he is refering to local communist movement, in the 1930s communist was popular globaly..

Okay but can we agree on the fact that it’s incorrect to pronounce Nablus “nab-LOOS”?

@y.l7455

Ай бұрын

The sound of "u" in "Nablus" is like the sound of double "o" and not like the sound of a in "apple" or u in "up" so I can't agree with you. Beside, the original name of the city is Shechem.

@elcalich33sehead

Ай бұрын

@@y.l7455 the city’s best kept secret.

I only watched the beginning, will watch the rest later, but a tip (from someone who doesn't have any experience in YT) I have for you is to try to make the first seconds more interesting, this video started quiet bland and I assume that newcomers who don't know the channel are very likely to stop watching because of it (though this is part 2, so it's probably not that important in this specific video)

How fitting: A "Syreals" company as a sponsor. * badumm tshhkk *

Well I don’t know much but I do know that the Soviets were more on the side of the Arabs throughout later much of the conflict, and the Americans and west were on the side of Israel!

When it came to the Soviet view directed by Stalin in the 1930's, the Soviets tended to lean pro-Jewish including their quick recognition of Israel in 1948 later on. Still, there was an antisemitic issue among Slavic peoples which caused difficulties as well. Things in Moscow were bogged down in the 1930's due to Stalin's bloody purges which killed roughly 7 million. Consequently, Soviet policy was rather skewered.

At 7min Ben Gurion is referring to Communist Jews in Eastern/Western Europe who loved their communist positions in the government and the wealth of their status in Western Germany which led them to look past the horrors of the Pogoroms and death the Communist and Facist regimes of Europe were waging on the majority of Jews all over Europe. You must’ve not went to Synagogue or Yeshiva for grade school to not be able to make these distinctions. The Communist loving Jews in Russia were just as horrible to other Jews than the Czar they claimed to be against for it was them that killed more Jews under their rulership than the Czar Empire ever did.

magic spoon looks ugly as hell, i'd rather eat the cardboard box than that slop

The conflict has been the same from beginning, nurtured by the Muslim governments in the region.

This needs more views, I didn't know much until the current violence in Israel so I started doing some research. I saw Vox's youtube "How The Palestinians were expelled from their homes", and I sympathize with the innocent Palestinians for losing their homes/lands through violence, but it's good to know what led up to it. Yes the Palestinians resorted to violence , but the complete ethnic cleansing of 62% of Palestinians who had lived there for centuries was not right either. Its the Palestinian population that continually loses out due to Zionists policies of forcing Palestinians out of their homes and getting killed by Israeli police in the West bank or shared cities.

@hoidoei941

6 ай бұрын

It’s not about numbers like it is a game of victimhood. It’s about being civilized enough to forgive eachother like e.g. the IRA did. Like The relations of USA between Japan or Europa towards Germany after WW2 etc. It’s about reason over emotion benefiting together(from which the Palestinians certainly did when Israeli brought modern agricultural methods, advanced irrigation systems creating highly fertile area’s from before utter useless soil especially compared to Palestinian primitive tech..) They could have had everything (…)

@dplameras

6 ай бұрын

The only way the west changes is through moving public opinion. The Palestinians are still being oppressed, their homes are literally being stolen after 70 years of living in that home and Jewish settlers moving in. Palestinians are getting arrested and for simplifying posting the Koran in social media or talking about their oppression, they don't have the right to vote and they are the majority population in Palestine-Israel combined. The far right government is unjust and the Palestinians need justice. And that propaganda you heard about the land being turned into an oasis by the Jews is one that Zionists have fed the population for decades. The land is a land of milk and honey and always has been.

@michellec1866

6 ай бұрын

You can see what’s kind people of Palestinians were, in later episodes on Lebanon wars. Hopeless violence

@saarze

6 ай бұрын

The vox video is complete misinformation from beginning to end, basically Arab nationalist propaganda. The Mufti would definitely approve. The truth was far more complex than the one sided narrative the Arabs like to sell, and hopefully you will see that on the next parts of this series, as these topics are beyond the scope of a KZread comment.

@anthonymorris5084

6 ай бұрын

Your characterization is a fallacy. Nobody was "expelled". What Vox failed to inform you was that when Israel became a nation, from a unanimous UN vote from member states, 5 Arab nations invaded with the stated goal of wiping Israel off the map. This conflict caused refugee crisis, as all wars do, as countless thousands fled the violence. Thousands of Jews were immediately expelled from Arab nations and fled to Israel. If "Palestinians" were expelled, how do you explain the 2 million Arab Israelis currently living in Israel as full citizens?

"their leaders"

Please don’t say “anyways” just say anyway.

Firstly Palestine was a geopolitical entity and was never a State or a nationality under British Mandate, it was seen a base to protect British interests in the Middle East. The Arabs who lived there were the same tribes as those in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. The British protected Jewish Kibbutz from the 1920s when the first Arab attacks took place, later the British trained and arming Jewish "Night Squads" that later became the Haganah. The British brought in extra troops and crushed the Arab Revolt 1936-39. This program like many forgets the good works the British did 1920-1945. Maybe to justify the Jewish terror campaign 1945-48 were the Jews began murdering the British who had protected them?

@El_Jefe_Maestro

6 ай бұрын

most "Arabs" arent actually Arabians, they are culturally ARABIZED locals. There are genetic studies showing Palestinian Arabs share more DNA with Middle Eastern Jews and ancient Bronze Age Levant samples like Canaanites than European Jews do. Palestinan Arabs are simply pagans and Jews that converted to Christianity and Islam and became Arabized over the centuries due to various conquerors passing through

I’m actually more interested in ancient history from 3000 years ago when both peoples lived in the land beside each other. It’s pretty clear that the British screwed things up as they did in India, Pakistan and many other regions of the globe.

@fantastichound

6 ай бұрын

There was no both peoples living side by side 3000 years back, those call palestinians today are arabs, arrived in the area after the collapse of the Roman empire.

@kimepp2216

6 ай бұрын

There were no Muslims or Christians 3000 years ago. Those faiths had yet to be invented.

@fantastichound

6 ай бұрын

@@kimepp2216 there were Hebrews with a well founded religion.

@kimepp2216

6 ай бұрын

@@fantastichound you are correct.

@anthonymorris5084

6 ай бұрын

How did the British "screw things up"? Every single ruler of this territory for the last 2000 years, arrived with a sword and slaughtered the incumbent power who arrived with a sword as well in the same manner. The British and French defeated the Ottoman empire in WW1 and were the last rulers of this territory. The British and French unlike every single conqueror before them, created the independent, sovereign nations of Egypt, Syria, Lebanon and Jordan and then left. You're welcome. Everybody loves to blame someone else for their self induced problems.

Came from all around to benefit from a jewish society

Syrian socialist

The same reasons the Native Americans did.

@ShnoogleMan

7 ай бұрын

The Jews weren’t pushing out the Arabs at the time the way the Euros were doing to the natives.

@kevinstfort

7 ай бұрын

@@ShnoogleManthey still pushed them out though. And now they are breaking their treaties (as we did with the Natives) with the illegal settlements.

@ShnoogleMan

7 ай бұрын

@@kevinstfort Yeah, after being faced with numerous massacres.

@DB-nl4qd

4 ай бұрын

Actually the jews are the native Americans in that land in a different format.

Ooohhh so close arabs! Better luck next time

“Why is it that on June 4th 1967 I was a Jordanian and overnight I became a Palestinian?” “We did not particularly mind Jordanian rule. The teaching of the destruction of Israel was a definite part of the curriculum, but we considered ourselves Jordanian until the Jews returned to Jerusalem. Then all of the sudden we were Palestinians - they removed the star from the Jordanian flag and all at once we had a Palestinian flag”. “When I finally realized the lies and myths I was taught, it is my duty as a righteous person to speak out”. This declaration by a true "Palestinian" should have some significance for a sincerely neutral observer. Indeed, there is no such a thing like a Palestinian people, or a Palestinian culture, or a Palestinian language, or a Palestinian history. There has never been any Palestinian state, neither any Palestinian archaeological find nor coinage

@anthonymorris5084

6 ай бұрын

Well said. The "Palestinian" was invented by the Left to validate their antisemitism. They created a fictious marginalized group to give them an excuse to attack Israel.

@El_Jefe_Maestro

6 ай бұрын

You seem to not understand that most "Arabs" arent actually Arabians, they are culturally ARABIZED locals. There are genetic studies showing Palestinian Arabs share more DNA with Middle Eastern Jews and ancient Bronze Age Levant samples like Canaanites than European Jews do. Palestinan Arabs are simply pagans and Jews that converted to Christianity and Islam and became Arabized over the centuries due to various conquerors passing through

Please stop using the expression 'English' interchangeably with 'British'...it would be even hetter to use the term the 'UK'. These terms mean very different things.

I could CRY listening to this. My sympathies are with ISRAEL.

Hey this might actually count as original research. Shame! Shame!

Alternate title: The Palestinians are Revolting.

so the mufti was right i guess but he wasnt powerful or cunning enough to make deals

❤🇮🇱 IZRAÄÄL 🇮🇱❤

They divided the Land of God.... at their whim and interests.... it was the Land of God..!!!!

England... England, what a disappointment with England...how they despised the People of God...!!!!

You are putting Golan with the Palestine mandate and this is simply false. It was part of the Republic of Syria since the treaty of independence in 1936. It is still internationally recognized as a Syrian territory occupied by Israel

@CasualHistorian

7 ай бұрын

The map portions of the video were made with an After Effects plugin called "Geolayers3" which takes border data from a number of different sources, and it's Israeli borders include the Golans. There are other map data sources Geolayers3 can access that would give Israel borders more closely accurate to 1936, but that same data source makes the rest of the Middle East look far less accurate. All of the new map segments in the video, however, have the Mandate's accurate borders. If you are still complaining about this, I don't think you've actually watched the video. Within the context of this video, showing the mandate possessing the Golans was a limitation of the tools I used, not a political statement.

@yurig2530

7 ай бұрын

US recognizes is as a part of Israel.

@mwolkove

7 ай бұрын

The Syrians placed a bet against Israel when they decided to push the Jews into the sea. They used the high ground provided by the Golan to attack Israel, and they lost the war. It would've been fine if they'd won though, right? They would've given all the land back to the Jews afterward, because they were just kidding?

@user-sh3cf7kd6e

7 ай бұрын

​@@suleyman8696 Rabin, nor any other Israeli would agree to this without a de facto guarantee of security. Not only no Syrian government so far would've actually even want to enforce it, but also, Syria itself always has been very unstable. It at least would've Israeli military presence. Without it, the north Israeli population would be at a great risk. And that small piece if land is useless for Syria/ns. Unless you are a nationalist.

@user-sh3cf7kd6e

7 ай бұрын

​@@suleyman8696 That's the only reason annexed it at the first place. Because of topography and security alone.

Skipped history in the university ? Never been a palestinian country or people !

@user-sh3cf7kd6e

7 ай бұрын

​@@thecityissleeping You are both right. Their national identity began to really crystallize in the late 50's and they declared independence only in 1984.

@cosimodirondo972

7 ай бұрын

@@thecityissleeping In the main, Arabs only began calling themselves "Palestinians" in the 1960s for political expediency. United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181 (Partition Resolution) of 1947 never refers to the Arabs as "Palestinians," but simply as "Arabs." The first time that body calls the Arabs "Palestinians" is 1970 with UNGA Resolution 2628 (November 4, 1970). Before this, the United Nations referred to the Arabs as "inhabitants," "the population," or "the Arab civilian population." Not once did it use the term "Palestinians."

@El_Jefe_Maestro

6 ай бұрын

​@@cosimodirondo972You seem to not understand that most "Arabs" arent actually Arabians, they are culturally ARABIZED locals. There are genetic studies showing Palestinian Arabs share more DNA with Middle Eastern Jews and ancient Bronze Age Levant samples like Canaanites than European Jews do. Palestinan Arabs are simply pagans and Jews that converted to Christianity and Islam and became Arabized over the centuries due to various conquerors passing through

What i have learned is this Israel/Palestine fight is a way bigger tangled mess then i though. It all goes back to God kicking His Jewish people out and promised to bring them back ×2. The bible is so accurate and every word is true. Especially when it comes to God and His promised people. Their story is already written. If i was Arab, i would read the bible to learn Jewish history. What the Bible says cant be stopped by any man. The words written are until the end.

@michaelbeasley2710

7 ай бұрын

Greetings melissalarson2569 - here is a slight correction to your comment; the Bible is about The Israelites who are Hebrews and are not Jewish; we are Israelites which means that We Are the Sons and Daughters of Jacob, who, is also called Israel. Being "Jewish" primarily means to be converted to the religion and lifestyle of Pharasaical-Rabbinic [or orthodox] Judaism from a former religion and lifestyle. The name Judah, Judea / Yahudah , Yahudea; is the origin of the word "Jew", which does not appear in the OT until after the Book of Second Kings. By the time of the coming of Messiah, the Israelites who returned from Babylon were called Jews because the Southern Kingdom which was the Tribes of Judah, Benjamin and Levi, were taken into captivity in Babylon for 70yrs; and the region we returned to was also called Judea [ which is renamed to Palestine after the final destruction of Jerusalem by the Roman Empire in 70 A.D.]. Judah is the fourth son of Jacob; and the fourth tribe of the 12 Tribes of Isarel. When someone is referred to as an "ite" that means they are a son , daughter, child' or descendant of the person or people group being spoken about. Jacob himself is the son of Isaac, the son of Abraham. The very first Israel-ite is Reuben. The Israel-ites in the Bible are not the Israelis [the jewish community] of today; We are a different group altogether. I hope this brings a level of clarity and understanding to your study of the Bible. Be Blessed with open eyes, open ears and a spirit of humility. Shaloam Sister😊

@DZ-yk2ew

6 ай бұрын

Nah, Paul just made up this whole argument to rationalize how could god be faithful and yet his chosen people had rejected him. And because he made that argument two thousand years ago, Christians want to restore Israel for the sake of bringing about the end of the world. Religion is the problem in this whole story. If people would give up their delusions and be sensible, this would be far less complicated.

The British promised nationhood to the Arabs in 1915. The Balfour Declaration, which promised the Zionists the land, didn't happen until 1917. The first Jewish colony was established in 1882, and the first resistance to those settlements was in 1921. Further revolts against the Zionists ensued as a direct result of the loss of Arab land, from 1936 to 39. You obviously omitted these details for a reason.

@OakAsmr

5 ай бұрын

Oh shoot bro I didn’t realize that you were going back, but if you’re gonna do that you gotta go all the way back pal! No worries I got this, I’ll skip until after the Islamist conquest because before it’s not relevant to the current conflict, because no Italian or Greek claims Israel. In 638 CE Israel was considered from the Byzantine Empire by the Islamic Empire, Jews made up the majority of the population, then the Arabia people colonized this land and refused to allow the Jews back to the Temple mount, did a little cultural cleansing and then held the land. Damn, and then Jews were slowly expelled due to the poor governance and obviously the oppression inherent with Islam, however there never was 0 Jews in Israel. It’s almost as if the Jews returned and threw off their oppressor’s chains in 1948. Arabs lost their colony, the difference between a Jordanian and a Palestinian is legitimately almost not existent, it’s mostly just food, which was taken from the native people (read Jews). So the historical context means the Arabs should make like the white people in Africa (except the south) and go back to their countries. You lose you leave. I’d be more sympathetic if Arabs didn’t keep killing Jews for being Jews, but it’s clear the only acceptable Arab solution is the final solution, so maybe if that’s what they want then they should leave. Sorry, don’t attempt genocide and maybe Arabs would have had the negotiation power with the west to actually keep their land. Again I’d be way more sympathetic if (by polling data) the majority of the population wasn’t in favor of genocide.

@ericpalmer3588

5 ай бұрын

This is in part 1

@jawadmaniaci91

4 ай бұрын

@@OakAsmr You are an ignorant bigot and almost everything you said is factually incorrect. For one Jews ceased to be a majority in Palestine in around the fourth century. Over 200 years before Islam! By the fourth century Christians became the majority in that area it’s well documented by historians. Also, Jerusalem was depopulated of Jews by the Byzantines before the Muslims conquest. As a matter of fact, the Muslims invited the Jews to come back and live in Jerusalem. When the Muslims took over, they did not replace the native population. The Palestinians are overwhelmingly descended from the Canaanites. Genetic studies and G25 calculations based on ancient DNA samples have shown they share 60% to 80% of their genome with the bronze age Canaanites. Under international law refugees have a right to return, so if you don’t leave you don’t lose. I know this bothers you, but all human beings actually have rights not just Jews!

@y.l7455

Ай бұрын

@@jawadmaniaci91 Under International Law refugee status is not passed by the father through generations but that not seems to bother you either. Don't start a geocidal war against the Jews and then cry when you lost it.

@y.l7455

Ай бұрын

The attacks on Jews in 1920, and the massacres of 1921 and 1929 didn't happen because any "loss of Arab land". The Jews before 1920s didn't attack any Arabs and legally bought all the lands they settled in and developed them. You obviously omitted these details for a reason.

😁😁😂😂🤣😂🤣😂♥️♥️♥️😜😜🤣😜👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Where is part 1?