The only major differences are the smoothness and the fact that your robot still moves around with bent knees. But overall... The choreography is the same.

@merxellus1456

Ай бұрын

Wat u expect.. Boston spent all their resources and years of development on it.. This company just copy the moves from a Makeshift robot which is still a newbie and is an under development robot. Plus they r right.. Any robotics Company would prolly be able to do this with just a few programming.

@martinpalm7859

Ай бұрын

@@merxellus1456 I never argued against those points. I am pointing out and comparing the current results. This bot can do better, but overall it's good.

@theneonbop

Ай бұрын

The robot looks good, but I've seen a lot of good robots and have yet to see any with the apparent agility or software quality of ones from Boston Dynamics (although ETH Zurich is getting close)

@jryde421

Ай бұрын

And speed

@erdenebayar8723

Ай бұрын

Hell nah what you do? Have you ever made anything like that and made company for this field? I bet you don’t and complain about others work? Disgusting 🤮

I don't think they thought it was difficult to do either. They did it cause it looks uncanny and grabs the viewers attention.

@capnk443

Ай бұрын

It's the most efficient way to stand up, if us organics had 360 degree joints we would stand up this way too

@lukewei

Ай бұрын

Correct, because if you've noticed, lots of other robotic companies were showing off how human like their creations are, and this is basically their statement, hey, im not sure you noticed, but robots are robots. Hence the walk away, rather than the wave and hello.

It is the fact that the boston dynamics one looks so much smoother, you can also notice how the robot is using a hopping technique to stabilise itself, which the boston dynamics one doesn't.

@dylandreisbach1986

Ай бұрын

Yeah it’s not necessarily the hardware, it’s the software. They have been perfecting bipedal movement for decades and this new platform will help them continue that. The way Atlas could jump around and carry things. That’s where the real advancements are.

@aussiekai

Ай бұрын

@@dylandreisbach1986 yeah, plus the point of the new robot is that it is fully mechanical, the previous Atlas accomplished it’s fine movements using hydraulics and they believed this was their next step forward. Due to mechanical components bring cheaper to produce and easy to maintain, compared to hydraulics which has several breaking points.

@inadad8878

Ай бұрын

@@aussiekai I like you try to downplay this very impressive robot

@aussiekai

Ай бұрын

@@inadad8878 Woah, I believe you are misundanding my point, whilst it would be fun to make this myself, the point I was making is that the purpose of Boston Dynamics robot was misunderstood. I'm just saying that they failed to understand what they were comparing to and trying to recreate.

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

@@inadad8878 by itself, this robot would be impressive, but this video wasn’t posted simply to show off this robot. this video was posted to show that this robot can do what the new Atlas does. They invited the comparison, and by comparison, this robot is not impressive.

who said its difficult? difficult is the smoothness and speed

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

...and the, "wait, is that REALLY a robot? Or is this CGI? Or is there somehow somebody in a robot suit there??" factor. It's kind of hard to believe the life-like movements. My brain screams that it's not possible, yet there it is.

holy shit its v2 from ultrakill

@CallsignAegis

Ай бұрын

yes

@Ahena994

Ай бұрын

Now we make them fight while playing the cyber grind in the background

@Spubbily01

Ай бұрын

​@@Ahena994 I wish I had the influence in the world to make this a reality

@v1_ultrakill_real

Ай бұрын

V0.2

I think what’s impressive is the agility & ability of Atlas to withstand error; Atlas is far more stable & less likely to fall over, because of this its range of abilities are also much greater. Still, this robot is more impressive than most.

yeah it's easy to copy ideas, what's hard is to come up with them in the first place.

@Lightning---K.

Ай бұрын

It is called backwards engineering 😅

@inadad8878

Ай бұрын

you have 1 month to copy this. something tells me you couldn't with all of the money in the world!

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

@@inadad8878so what? They never claimed they could. They aren’t the ones trying to say that what Boston dynamics did was easy.

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

Ideas are actually a dime a dozen. Ideas are super cheap. What's difficult is execution and implementation and follow through and eventually seeing that the idea was actually a good one. For example, a lot of Elon Musk's ideas weren't his at all, they were rejected by NASA back in the 1960s, such as the 'idea' of landing a rocket through controlled descent so it could be re-used. NASA rejected this as it was impractical and costly compared to just dropping the booster in the ocean and retrieving it, and it critically would have meant limiting the payloads they could send into space as some of that payload would have to be earmarked for fuel for landing the rocket. So Musk slapped his name on the unused impractical idea, talked it up with a ton of propaganda, dumped Billions into the project, and got it to work. It's not that it wasn't going to work; it's that it would have been too costly and complicated and less efficient compared to just dumping things in the ocean using parachutes. And his journey with this 'idea' has proven out exactly these criticisms. In the end, NASA was right to avoid such gimmicks. Unfortunately they have lost quite a bit of their funding, and their minds, and they are now working with Elon, using tech that they rejected 60 years ago.... Artemis is F'd in the Eh.

blud literally woke up and said "fuck it, lets start a robotic company". hope you succeed bro.

So impressive that you guys made this in less than a week since the atlas robots came out 😮

@user-bp3yz5hy5n

Ай бұрын

Cuz Boston dynamics actually put time and effort into making a walking robot, unlike these guys who steal their programming

@robn2497

Ай бұрын

@@user-bp3yz5hy5nalso "isnt actually difficult" because you copied it.

@ryangonzales7716

Ай бұрын

@@user-bp3yz5hy5n steal their programming? you have no idea what you're talking about lol

@user-bp3yz5hy5n

Ай бұрын

@@ryangonzales7716 I’m talking about their robot learning to walk, Boston dynamics actually put time and effort into programming their robot and it took them years to do, unlike these guys who appear to only take days apparently

@Rodrigo-jd2wg

Ай бұрын

@@user-bp3yz5hy5n maybe they are better and faster and it takes them way less time, boston dynamycs is overrated

Everyone seems to be fixated on the physical robot... That's not the hard part.... The impressive part of the Boston Dynamics robot is that it went through so much simulated pretraining.... Eventually the robot was physically built and someone said get up, then it thought, what is the most efficient way to go from the pose I am in to the pose I want to be in without falling over.... That's the impressive part. I do like your project and think it's impressive in itself. Good work! The fact that your robot has this extended range of motion is fantastic.

@YourComputerExpert

Ай бұрын

Is this actually true, though?

@massacrestarts1673

Ай бұрын

​@YourComputerExpert from what I understand, all of the movements of the previous Atlas were choreographed.

@SubBass100

Ай бұрын

@@massacrestarts1673 you are correct, previous Atlas, dancing around, was choreographed. Things like balancing on uneven terrain was still improvised based on realtime sensors. Their new bot, according to the release, uses many many previously simulated motions in virtual environments to better understand how to get from point a to point b in the most efficient way without becoming unstable.

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

@@massacrestarts1673 yes it was choreographed. As in, they hired a choreographer, the same, same as a dance troop would. That determined what actions the robots would take, but the robots still had to figure out how to maintain stability while going through those actions

You guys forgot to put the hockey stick at the background.

the impressiveness of atlas is that it doesn't look geriatric, but more like a person missing a few bones than a machine.

I would argue that good engineering is deceptively simple, but getting to that place where one can distill an idea down to its simplest form can take decades of practice.

its NOT difficult, you are right. but its how eerily smooth the movements are that make it so popular

The difference is that other robot did it like it was nothing..

It is indeed impressive but it's not the movement that make's it insane but how much effort they put into it so it's perfectly uncanny, unatural but also very smooth

That's what makes the new Atlas so great for mass production. Its body plan and means of movement are simple and easier to wrap our heads around than a complex and intricate hydraulic system. The smoother movement of the official Atlas just comes down to really good computer programming and probably some higher end components

Wow in so little time you made something damn similar to BD million dollars new "atlas"

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

Except it’s not similar at all. It’s extremely clunky and cannot walk straight tall and smooth like atlas.

The main thing is that it ain't something a human can do, thus it's shocking

honestly, that is the point of the new Atlas, making state of the art use of OFF THE SHELF parts❤❤, also NVIDIA is going to make bi-pedal bot building in garage trivial, as same as it happened with drones, from helicopter models barely flying with help of human intuition... to pretty much any flight characteristics drones made out of boredom, literally build out of junk, flying on open source model.

Cute! Let’s see your robot out maneuver retired Atlas? 😂😂

not booster robotics but booster animation!

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

What?? It's not animated. Obviously. What's wrong with you?

Don't think anyone claimed that it's difficult. It's just that other companies haven't done it before.

Yeah but yours looked like it was struggling, theirs looked like a Dark Souls boss cut scene. (You win BTW)

intention complexity, how does the robot choose to use its inertia to get more natural human motion

I still love robots and if this doesnt cost 1,000,000 to make id put one in my business cus i lift heavy shit all the time

If it's not that difficult then why didn't you make that thing before Boston dynamics did? Instead you made it afterwards and of a lesser quality.

Budget is the only difference

If this is a student project, great job! If you're trying to actually sell a robot that can't stand still like it's 1992, then uh...

Nowhere near Boston Dynamics movement quality, but this still looks good! Some people are saying it's CGI, but I don't really care if it is or it isn't, because I can't tell. If it's CG, then I'm excited to see some awesome renders. If it isn't, then I'm excited to see more developments in robotics!

The reason the Boston Dynamics one looks so cool is the proportions, the lines, and the almost human way it moves -- minus that bizarre contortionist thing it does. It's like a droid from Star Wars. Ignore the motor sounds and put some clothes on it and we may not even realize it isn't human. A new kind of Turing Test, I say! If a robot walks around in full coverings/costume, can you tell it's a robot and not a human? We can look at those "Big Foot" videos and see that it is obviously a human in a costume based on the way it moves. I think we are leaving the realm where that was once true of robots. Your robot looks great guys! Just not as big a budget, apparently. I think these fluid movements and contoured humanoid bodies are going to be an absolute requirement going forward, unless it's purely utilitarian and meant for the commercial / defense sectors only. Right now Boston Dynamics has that category in the bag and I want to see some other companies pull it off at least as well as BD. Good luck to you, guys! You could get one of the BD robots at some point, and choreograph a fight between it and this one, so that yours wins. Like, have it snap the limbs of the BD one with its strength or something, we would all enjoy that.

I think we should be encouraging companies like this to keep pushing forward rather than bashing them in the comments. But I suppose they brought it upon themselves by trying to compare themselves to Boston dynamics rather than saying they were given inspiration and trying to do better.

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

Exactly. They could’ve simply made the title “we put our robot through the same motions as the new Atlas” and it would’ve been hey, cool! Instead, they tried to downplay Boston Dynamics achievements by saying it’s not that difficult, and then put out a video demonstrating that while their robot might be able to go through similar motions, it is nowhere near capable of the movement that Atlas has.

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

@@valerierodger Yeah, they could have framed it better. Some explanation would be cool too, about what went into it, what the robot has to do to execute it, and why it's an important thing for them to achieve. When it's presented as more of a challenge to BD it kind of comes off weak.

Not quite.

wow the leg direction change is interesting, who are you? Booster Robotics, why have I only heard of you now? more videos please,

Plus the fact this is sped up, whilst theirs is not.

can you talk about who you are, background, history, do you sell this robot you have created to others?

Brother ate the devil fruit

스스로 발전해라. 남을 깎아내린다고 네가 성공하는게 아니야.

Is it a better way to stand up for this bot?

Вот это пранк от Бостер Роботикс)) Быстро взяли и сделали.

Is its body a PC case? XD

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

The difference is budget....

Sure but yours doesnt look like it wants to destroy all human yet.

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

That's EXACTLY the feeling I got from the new Atlas! I was like, "Whoa. Now here's a robot that can kill all humans! Somebody give that machine a machine gun!"

Nothing is „that difficult“ when you‘re the second

People don’t know how advanced and futuristic tech we work on in the labs, a lot of “cool” stuff is just a lot of time away from research that these guys need to put into, to create a presentation! Boston dynamics is good at making that…

And it’s doing all that while dancing chacha 😂

That's kinda of the point, isn't it? Its the more efficient/easy way for the robot to get up compared to how a human would do it.

@user-fr7yt8xe2w

Ай бұрын

Человек все еще круче, человек может вставать прыжком отталкиваясь руками из за головы))

@mister_r447

Ай бұрын

@@user-fr7yt8xe2w IDK, this contortion stuff is pretty cool aswell, tho that might just be for its novelty.

Great work :)

"goblin " robot

THEIR MAKING V2

Good good, this is exactly what boston Dynamics want. To make other companies strive to do better

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

I'm pretty sure that Boston Dynamics would rather just stay at the head of the pack.... They have to keep going harder because the pace of development in the industry is so insane. It used to be that robot dogs were just Boston Dynamics Spot, but now there are a bunch of companies making them. That is sure to follow with Atlas. So the BD team is always thinking of how to outdo themselves, because if they can't stay ahead they will eventually get overshadowed and left behind by someone else. BD wants to be the Apple of the robotics world. Other companies have quite the hill to climb to keep up with them.

Guys, I’m pretty sure Booster is aware they can’t match up to Boston Dynamics. They were trying to see if they can match the weird movement and successfully did it. Fast.

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

No, they didn’t match the movement. They replicated some of the motions.

@uBreeze

Ай бұрын

@@valerierodger motion (noun): the action or process of moving or being moved. Are you just trying to be spiteful? Would you like to make an attempt at it?

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

@@uBreeze I agree that it's not exactly a match. Did the robot stand up in the same general way? Yeah. Did it make it look so easy that it's uncanny and gives us all Terminator vibes? No. There's still much to be desired. The bent knees and constant mechanical marching kind of kill the effect. With some work, maybe they can really achieve the same feat. I hope they can. But so far it's just not on the same level.

@uBreeze

Ай бұрын

@@johnsmithe4656 Again, I doubt they were trying to match Boston Dynamics.

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

@@uBreeze I dunno man, first you said they were trying to match it, then someone said they didn't match, then you said they did, now you're saying they weren't trying to match the BD version.... so I don't know what to tell you. Color me confused.

When are the two gonna fight?

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

This is what inquiring minds WANT TO KNOW! Show us some Jiu Jitsu between robots, put a whole new spin on that Battle Bots show.

Why did you build it using an x-box 😭😭😭

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

Budget!

Atlas be having a dad bod

AMAZING

is it open source?🤔

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

but its creepy

That looks nothing like it

nice CGI looking ahh thing, @Corridorcrew will have a fun time looking at this

@simobomb6475

Ай бұрын

If it mooves smooth its cgi

@JelloBeanzer

Ай бұрын

I'm honestly not sure if it's CGI or not, but I admit that I'm excited at the possibility of Corridor Crew making a video dissecting this video.

Yes. Fluidity does.

Nice CGI

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

Where?

Ok now make it freerun before Boston Dynamics dose.

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

I'm wondering how long it will take before we have actual robotic Light Infantry. Running/jumping/clearing obstacle courses will mean we're really, really close. I give it 5-10 years. Just imagine if robots did our fighting for us, we wouldn't have to spend the lives of our young people to stave off an adversary. To the contrary, our adversary, should they choose to attack us, would have to fight against and die to robots. Needless to say, whoever achieves this tech first, including the AI aspects of it, would easily be able to dominate the whole world. Light Infantry bots are the holy grail of military tech. And they're coming!

no one said it was difficult. It's just creepy af.

Its the fact u didnt think of it first

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

No it isn't.

@3sc4p1sm

Ай бұрын

@@johnsmithe4656 yep.

please add more imperfection to your texture

The Atlas 2 is CGI right?

@dabbingraccoons6416

Ай бұрын

No?

@valerierodger

Ай бұрын

No

Bender would kick this thing’s ass

@johnsmithe4656

Ай бұрын

Sure, but the new BD Atlas can bite Bender's shiny metal @$$$$$$.

Booster Robotics, I talked to someone at Boston Dynamics about working for them and they responded that in order to work for them I had to buy a robot for $50k. That's unreasonable. Is there any chance you might hire me?

why can't you just get the shadow right 😢😢😢😢😢

WHY?

What???, you guys just popped up out of nothing..

Everyone knows Niel Armstrong first man on the moon. And nobody know who been there after him

@Wy_WyTheWizard

Ай бұрын

ok?

V2

Obviously an animation, but great work mimicking the movements in animation. The single shadow with multiple light sources is a giveaway.

If you had put this video out with a title like “we decided to replicate the movements of the new atlas with our robot”, my reaction would’ve been: hey, cool. That’s awesome! But instead, you phrased your title in a way that both downplays the achievement of Boston Dynamics and invites comparisons between your robot and Atlas. Bad idea. If the movement of the new atlas isn’t difficult, why can’t your robot move as smoothly and efficiently? Why can’t it walk and stand as straight as the new Atlas? Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you can do it well. The striking thing in the video introducing the new Atlas wasn’t really the moves that it made, it was the manner in which it made them. Your robot doesn’t move anything like Atlas, so it’s not very convincing to hear you say that the movement of Atlas is not difficult. Your robot can replicate some of the motions of Atlas, but not it’s movement.

Moves like Donald Trump.

Bostor > Boston 🎉

good work but your video title is going to give you many negative comments.

Simulation😁

looks like CGI to me..

the metals are too clean, obviously 3d animation, and how the camera shake and how the video is taken is definitely for 3d animation

@Simons_Animatronics

Ай бұрын

Your stupidity is unhinged

Too bad boston dynamics is already own by a Korean company.

Quite funny reading the comments. People don’t see that this is obvious 3D animation)) and of rather mediocre quality. floor textures are lol))

Goofy ahhh try

Really good render and animation guys but this moment gave it away 0:08. Its a suddent stop without any movement from intertia.

I hate this type of movement its not looks like humanoid its like a bending machine

"If it's possible, then it can be done!" Hmm, yes, the floor here is made out of floor.

2nd

wow a copy

So janky

早送りしてるでしょう。動きが遅いです。

I'm confused, did Boston Dynamics say that it's difficult. Did they imply in anyway that no one else can do it? Than why phrase the conversation like Boston Dynamics is trying to have an unnecessary competitive agenda. I am genuinely happy that your robot has accomplished the same functionality, now go create something new instead of showing the world that you can do similar moves as others. Taking swipes at the market leader is a very old tactic to get attention. Believe me, it's not a good look. Stay original and create your own benchmarks and you will be respected for it.

@christdimiyoka890

Ай бұрын

Unitree is the leader.

@christdimiyoka890

Ай бұрын

Astribot is better than Boston

This is a bad take guys

Fake .

coooooooooolll))