The reason the Boston Dynamics one looks so cool is the proportions, the lines, and the almost human way it moves -- minus that bizarre contortionist thing it does. It's like a droid from Star Wars. Ignore the motor sounds and put some clothes on it and we may not even realize it isn't human. A new kind of Turing Test, I say! If a robot walks around in full coverings/costume, can you tell it's a robot and not a human? We can look at those "Big Foot" videos and see that it is obviously a human in a costume based on the way it moves. I think we are leaving the realm where that was once true of robots. Your robot looks great guys! Just not as big a budget, apparently. I think these fluid movements and contoured humanoid bodies are going to be an absolute requirement going forward, unless it's purely utilitarian and meant for the commercial / defense sectors only. Right now Boston Dynamics has that category in the bag and I want to see some other companies pull it off at least as well as BD. Good luck to you, guys! You could get one of the BD robots at some point, and choreograph a fight between it and this one, so that yours wins. Like, have it snap the limbs of the BD one with its strength or something, we would all enjoy that.
@Memmo-9Ай бұрын
Fake .
@aidanmatthewgalea7761Ай бұрын
the impressiveness of atlas is that it doesn't look geriatric, but more like a person missing a few bones than a machine.
@C0ttageCheesАй бұрын
Great work :)
@notecat7785Ай бұрын
blud literally woke up and said "fuck it, lets start a robotic company". hope you succeed bro.
@noleftturnsАй бұрын
The Tesla & BDs Terminator is already dead - stick a fork in it. Why? The wrong robot for the wrong task. Elon & BD have this crazy idea that his Terminator will take the jobs from union workers who will stop paying taxes and go on welfare and everyone will be happy Hello - Taking jobs from humans is a stupid idea and will never happen Laws will be passed to restrain them from getting near human beings So, what is the right robot for the right job? Apple sounds like they know - an appliance for the home. Just like the iPhone is an appliance - it was never invented to take jobs from humans just to make life better for them If you want to see what the Apple robot might be - lookup evoBOT It has: no hands no feet no head no torso no pullies and cables It can move at 40 MPH can climb stairs can climb and descent 35-degree snowy mountains can carry 220 pounds can lift 143 pounds runs for 8 hours on a small battery pack that is switchable weighs 88 pounds and can easily be put into the backseat of your car a titanium foldable version could be carry-on luggage taken to a work site it uses its weight to move and not motors It uses 360-degree vision - it sees everything around it all the time. It uses LIDAR - it can operate in total darkness, blinding snowstorms, torrential rain, hail, and fog with no problem. It uses four brushless motors and no pullies or wires of any kind It uses its weight to move even on ice or up snowy mountains - the power to the wheels is only needed when its weight isn't enough to overcome resistance. It uses internal reaction wheels to turn so that it can turn on ice with no problem That's a totally different way for humans to use a robot to assist them and not replace them.
@jonathanchampagne7683Ай бұрын
Booster Robotics, I talked to someone at Boston Dynamics about working for them and they responded that in order to work for them I had to buy a robot for $50k. That's unreasonable. Is there any chance you might hire me?
@joelmulderАй бұрын
This is a bad take guys
@gwenmcgarry528Ай бұрын
The main thing is that it ain't something a human can do, thus it's shocking
@julianstoller5883Ай бұрын
Where can I learn more about Booster Robotics, as of this comment I can't find any website or LinkedIn page.
@orpheuscreativeco9236Ай бұрын
I would argue that good engineering is deceptively simple, but getting to that place where one can distill an idea down to its simplest form can take decades of practice.
@wstoker84Ай бұрын
Budget is the only difference
@noblebuild2550Ай бұрын
intention complexity, how does the robot choose to use its inertia to get more natural human motion
@bxxxxxxxxxxxxАй бұрын
Nothing is „that difficult“ when you‘re the second
@valerierodgerАй бұрын
If you had put this video out with a title like “we decided to replicate the movements of the new atlas with our robot”, my reaction would’ve been: hey, cool. That’s awesome! But instead, you phrased your title in a way that both downplays the achievement of Boston Dynamics and invites comparisons between your robot and Atlas. Bad idea. If the movement of the new atlas isn’t difficult, why can’t your robot move as smoothly and efficiently? Why can’t it walk and stand as straight as the new Atlas? Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you can do it well. The striking thing in the video introducing the new Atlas wasn’t really the moves that it made, it was the manner in which it made them. Your robot doesn’t move anything like Atlas, so it’s not very convincing to hear you say that the movement of Atlas is not difficult. Your robot can replicate some of the motions of Atlas, but not it’s movement.
@nyvdrtngrydАй бұрын
but its creepy
@shadowuniferАй бұрын
Yeah but yours looked like it was struggling, theirs looked like a Dark Souls boss cut scene. (You win BTW)
@hyperspamАй бұрын
Is it a better way to stand up for this bot?
@uBreezeАй бұрын
Guys, I’m pretty sure Booster is aware they can’t match up to Boston Dynamics. They were trying to see if they can match the weird movement and successfully did it. Fast.
@valerierodgerАй бұрын
No, they didn’t match the movement. They replicated some of the motions.
@uBreezeАй бұрын
@@valerierodger motion (noun): the action or process of moving or being moved. Are you just trying to be spiteful? Would you like to make an attempt at it?
@johnsmithe4656Ай бұрын
@@uBreeze I agree that it's not exactly a match. Did the robot stand up in the same general way? Yeah. Did it make it look so easy that it's uncanny and gives us all Terminator vibes? No. There's still much to be desired. The bent knees and constant mechanical marching kind of kill the effect. With some work, maybe they can really achieve the same feat. I hope they can. But so far it's just not on the same level.
@uBreezeАй бұрын
@@johnsmithe4656 Again, I doubt they were trying to match Boston Dynamics.
@johnsmithe4656Ай бұрын
@@uBreeze I dunno man, first you said they were trying to match it, then someone said they didn't match, then you said they did, now you're saying they weren't trying to match the BD version.... so I don't know what to tell you. Color me confused.
@ArcmoveАй бұрын
Quite funny reading the comments. People don’t see that this is obvious 3D animation)) and of rather mediocre quality. floor textures are lol))
@generalrubbish9513Ай бұрын
"If it's possible, then it can be done!" Hmm, yes, the floor here is made out of floor.
@ahabkapitanyАй бұрын
no one said it was difficult. It's just creepy af.
@orlandojam8Ай бұрын
Bostor > Boston 🎉
@guy_kisserАй бұрын
Plus the fact this is sped up, whilst theirs is not.
@user-jr1jx2ed6fАй бұрын
wow a copy
@fritzeph6550Ай бұрын
Too bad boston dynamics is already own by a Korean company.
@MrNeonz-fk2kyАй бұрын
I think what’s impressive is the agility & ability of Atlas to withstand error; Atlas is far more stable & less likely to fall over, because of this its range of abilities are also much greater. Still, this robot is more impressive than most.
@rylenstuffsv2Ай бұрын
It is indeed impressive but it's not the movement that make's it insane but how much effort they put into it so it's perfectly uncanny, unatural but also very smooth
@FredfredfredfredfredfredfredАй бұрын
Bender would kick this thing’s ass
@johnsmithe4656Ай бұрын
Sure, but the new BD Atlas can bite Bender's shiny metal @$$$$$$.
@user-fr7yt8xe2wАй бұрын
Вот это пранк от Бостер Роботикс)) Быстро взяли и сделали.
@Fury_BlackWolfАй бұрын
If it's not that difficult then why didn't you make that thing before Boston dynamics did? Instead you made it afterwards and of a lesser quality.
@JelloBeanzerАй бұрын
Nowhere near Boston Dynamics movement quality, but this still looks good! Some people are saying it's CGI, but I don't really care if it is or it isn't, because I can't tell. If it's CG, then I'm excited to see some awesome renders. If it isn't, then I'm excited to see more developments in robotics!
@obercanober4182Ай бұрын
I still love robots and if this doesnt cost 1,000,000 to make id put one in my business cus i lift heavy shit all the time
@UsertlolАй бұрын
The difference is that other robot did it like it was nothing..
@waterpannАй бұрын
THEIR MAKING V2
@TitoBobbyPhАй бұрын
And it’s doing all that while dancing chacha 😂
@pepdronrealАй бұрын
who said its difficult? difficult is the smoothness and speed
@johnsmithe4656Ай бұрын
...and the, "wait, is that REALLY a robot? Or is this CGI? Or is there somehow somebody in a robot suit there??" factor. It's kind of hard to believe the life-like movements. My brain screams that it's not possible, yet there it is.
@WingofTechАй бұрын
Is its body a PC case? XD
@johnsmithe4656Ай бұрын
The difference is budget....
@justinsmith2227Ай бұрын
Brother ate the devil fruit
@azeraniАй бұрын
You guys forgot to put the hockey stick at the background.
@mister_r447Ай бұрын
That's kinda of the point, isn't it? Its the more efficient/easy way for the robot to get up compared to how a human would do it.
@user-fr7yt8xe2wАй бұрын
Человек все еще круче, человек может вставать прыжком отталкиваясь руками из за головы))
@mister_r447Ай бұрын
@@user-fr7yt8xe2w IDK, this contortion stuff is pretty cool aswell, tho that might just be for its novelty.
@Timothy_PearmanАй бұрын
its NOT difficult, you are right. but its how eerily smooth the movements are that make it so popular
@Chuck.1715Ай бұрын
honestly, that is the point of the new Atlas, making state of the art use of OFF THE SHELF parts❤❤, also NVIDIA is going to make bi-pedal bot building in garage trivial, as same as it happened with drones, from helicopter models barely flying with help of human intuition... to pretty much any flight characteristics drones made out of boredom, literally build out of junk, flying on open source model.
@Cyan37Ай бұрын
Don't think anyone claimed that it's difficult. It's just that other companies haven't done it before.
@caesarcandra5438Ай бұрын
please add more imperfection to your texture
@lukalukin4177Ай бұрын
Everyone knows Niel Armstrong first man on the moon. And nobody know who been there after him
Пікірлер
wow the leg direction change is interesting, who are you? Booster Robotics, why have I only heard of you now? more videos please,
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
The reason the Boston Dynamics one looks so cool is the proportions, the lines, and the almost human way it moves -- minus that bizarre contortionist thing it does. It's like a droid from Star Wars. Ignore the motor sounds and put some clothes on it and we may not even realize it isn't human. A new kind of Turing Test, I say! If a robot walks around in full coverings/costume, can you tell it's a robot and not a human? We can look at those "Big Foot" videos and see that it is obviously a human in a costume based on the way it moves. I think we are leaving the realm where that was once true of robots. Your robot looks great guys! Just not as big a budget, apparently. I think these fluid movements and contoured humanoid bodies are going to be an absolute requirement going forward, unless it's purely utilitarian and meant for the commercial / defense sectors only. Right now Boston Dynamics has that category in the bag and I want to see some other companies pull it off at least as well as BD. Good luck to you, guys! You could get one of the BD robots at some point, and choreograph a fight between it and this one, so that yours wins. Like, have it snap the limbs of the BD one with its strength or something, we would all enjoy that.
Fake .
the impressiveness of atlas is that it doesn't look geriatric, but more like a person missing a few bones than a machine.
Great work :)
blud literally woke up and said "fuck it, lets start a robotic company". hope you succeed bro.
The Tesla & BDs Terminator is already dead - stick a fork in it. Why? The wrong robot for the wrong task. Elon & BD have this crazy idea that his Terminator will take the jobs from union workers who will stop paying taxes and go on welfare and everyone will be happy Hello - Taking jobs from humans is a stupid idea and will never happen Laws will be passed to restrain them from getting near human beings So, what is the right robot for the right job? Apple sounds like they know - an appliance for the home. Just like the iPhone is an appliance - it was never invented to take jobs from humans just to make life better for them If you want to see what the Apple robot might be - lookup evoBOT It has: no hands no feet no head no torso no pullies and cables It can move at 40 MPH can climb stairs can climb and descent 35-degree snowy mountains can carry 220 pounds can lift 143 pounds runs for 8 hours on a small battery pack that is switchable weighs 88 pounds and can easily be put into the backseat of your car a titanium foldable version could be carry-on luggage taken to a work site it uses its weight to move and not motors It uses 360-degree vision - it sees everything around it all the time. It uses LIDAR - it can operate in total darkness, blinding snowstorms, torrential rain, hail, and fog with no problem. It uses four brushless motors and no pullies or wires of any kind It uses its weight to move even on ice or up snowy mountains - the power to the wheels is only needed when its weight isn't enough to overcome resistance. It uses internal reaction wheels to turn so that it can turn on ice with no problem That's a totally different way for humans to use a robot to assist them and not replace them.
Booster Robotics, I talked to someone at Boston Dynamics about working for them and they responded that in order to work for them I had to buy a robot for $50k. That's unreasonable. Is there any chance you might hire me?
This is a bad take guys
The main thing is that it ain't something a human can do, thus it's shocking
Where can I learn more about Booster Robotics, as of this comment I can't find any website or LinkedIn page.
I would argue that good engineering is deceptively simple, but getting to that place where one can distill an idea down to its simplest form can take decades of practice.
Budget is the only difference
intention complexity, how does the robot choose to use its inertia to get more natural human motion
Nothing is „that difficult“ when you‘re the second
If you had put this video out with a title like “we decided to replicate the movements of the new atlas with our robot”, my reaction would’ve been: hey, cool. That’s awesome! But instead, you phrased your title in a way that both downplays the achievement of Boston Dynamics and invites comparisons between your robot and Atlas. Bad idea. If the movement of the new atlas isn’t difficult, why can’t your robot move as smoothly and efficiently? Why can’t it walk and stand as straight as the new Atlas? Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you can do it well. The striking thing in the video introducing the new Atlas wasn’t really the moves that it made, it was the manner in which it made them. Your robot doesn’t move anything like Atlas, so it’s not very convincing to hear you say that the movement of Atlas is not difficult. Your robot can replicate some of the motions of Atlas, but not it’s movement.
but its creepy
Yeah but yours looked like it was struggling, theirs looked like a Dark Souls boss cut scene. (You win BTW)
Is it a better way to stand up for this bot?
Guys, I’m pretty sure Booster is aware they can’t match up to Boston Dynamics. They were trying to see if they can match the weird movement and successfully did it. Fast.
No, they didn’t match the movement. They replicated some of the motions.
@@valerierodger motion (noun): the action or process of moving or being moved. Are you just trying to be spiteful? Would you like to make an attempt at it?
@@uBreeze I agree that it's not exactly a match. Did the robot stand up in the same general way? Yeah. Did it make it look so easy that it's uncanny and gives us all Terminator vibes? No. There's still much to be desired. The bent knees and constant mechanical marching kind of kill the effect. With some work, maybe they can really achieve the same feat. I hope they can. But so far it's just not on the same level.
@@johnsmithe4656 Again, I doubt they were trying to match Boston Dynamics.
@@uBreeze I dunno man, first you said they were trying to match it, then someone said they didn't match, then you said they did, now you're saying they weren't trying to match the BD version.... so I don't know what to tell you. Color me confused.
Quite funny reading the comments. People don’t see that this is obvious 3D animation)) and of rather mediocre quality. floor textures are lol))
"If it's possible, then it can be done!" Hmm, yes, the floor here is made out of floor.
no one said it was difficult. It's just creepy af.
Bostor > Boston 🎉
Plus the fact this is sped up, whilst theirs is not.
wow a copy
Too bad boston dynamics is already own by a Korean company.
I think what’s impressive is the agility & ability of Atlas to withstand error; Atlas is far more stable & less likely to fall over, because of this its range of abilities are also much greater. Still, this robot is more impressive than most.
It is indeed impressive but it's not the movement that make's it insane but how much effort they put into it so it's perfectly uncanny, unatural but also very smooth
Bender would kick this thing’s ass
Sure, but the new BD Atlas can bite Bender's shiny metal @$$$$$$.
Вот это пранк от Бостер Роботикс)) Быстро взяли и сделали.
If it's not that difficult then why didn't you make that thing before Boston dynamics did? Instead you made it afterwards and of a lesser quality.
Nowhere near Boston Dynamics movement quality, but this still looks good! Some people are saying it's CGI, but I don't really care if it is or it isn't, because I can't tell. If it's CG, then I'm excited to see some awesome renders. If it isn't, then I'm excited to see more developments in robotics!
I still love robots and if this doesnt cost 1,000,000 to make id put one in my business cus i lift heavy shit all the time
The difference is that other robot did it like it was nothing..
THEIR MAKING V2
And it’s doing all that while dancing chacha 😂
who said its difficult? difficult is the smoothness and speed
...and the, "wait, is that REALLY a robot? Or is this CGI? Or is there somehow somebody in a robot suit there??" factor. It's kind of hard to believe the life-like movements. My brain screams that it's not possible, yet there it is.
Is its body a PC case? XD
The difference is budget....
Brother ate the devil fruit
You guys forgot to put the hockey stick at the background.
That's kinda of the point, isn't it? Its the more efficient/easy way for the robot to get up compared to how a human would do it.
Человек все еще круче, человек может вставать прыжком отталкиваясь руками из за головы))
@@user-fr7yt8xe2w IDK, this contortion stuff is pretty cool aswell, tho that might just be for its novelty.
its NOT difficult, you are right. but its how eerily smooth the movements are that make it so popular
honestly, that is the point of the new Atlas, making state of the art use of OFF THE SHELF parts❤❤, also NVIDIA is going to make bi-pedal bot building in garage trivial, as same as it happened with drones, from helicopter models barely flying with help of human intuition... to pretty much any flight characteristics drones made out of boredom, literally build out of junk, flying on open source model.
Don't think anyone claimed that it's difficult. It's just that other companies haven't done it before.
please add more imperfection to your texture
Everyone knows Niel Armstrong first man on the moon. And nobody know who been there after him
ok?
Its the fact u didnt think of it first
No it isn't.
@@johnsmithe4656 yep.
早送りしてるでしょう。動きが遅いです。