Yes, this was a brilliant conversation. I thought the chapter where Ivan is visited by the "Devil" was quite disturbing, too.

@di9645

2 жыл бұрын

What Ami1649 is discussing here from the book about the 6 years old girl being in a cellar not knowing what she did to deserve the life she had and the recent discovery of unmarked graves of over a thousand children in Catholic schools in Canada.

@gilliofrancesa

Жыл бұрын

I just read that chapter. I thought it was brilliant!!

@yuanmona

10 ай бұрын

agree! and the actor in the movie is intellectually lively

@aliceentayyab452

6 күн бұрын

I literally felt sick to a point where i thought someone was sitting in the corner of my room far from me yet breathing heavily behind my ear. I came to a point of almost sleep paralysis like state and afterwards felt very dizzy.

The themes of fatherhood are so complex and interesting. Ivan and Alyosha are philosophical rivals, and that rivalry shows in the teaching by example they do: Alyosha tries to prepare the future generation through the kids at the end of the book, while Ivan's teachings led to murder. Also, its very interesting how Ivan talks about loving children, yet Alyosha is the only one who seems to be around them.

If you were to ask randoms in the street nobody would know what yourre talking about.

@tww1671

3 жыл бұрын

It's an unfortunate truth

@DaTryHardCamper

3 жыл бұрын

Ahahah truth I have just gotten past this chapter but really wanted another's views on this just about to start the poem

@robertimmanuel577

2 жыл бұрын

@@tww1671 nothing unfortunate about it. Just different interests.

@tww1671

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertimmanuel577 Good point. I agree :)

@lukasmiller486

2 жыл бұрын

I read the book twice (not for college but enjoyment) so I knew right away what you were referring to in the title.

The next chapter after Rebellion, The Grand Inquisitor, is the best chapter of all time imo.

@thebenevolentsun6575

10 ай бұрын

Overrated

I always really liked how Ivan cut the Bullshit when they were sitting together and said that they both knew what they really wanted to talk about: "The Eternal Questions"

I know it’s not this black and white, but what I got from this chapter and the grand inquisitor is that Ivan believes in God, but can’t accept him because of the horrors he allows to happen on earth?

I like that though Dostoyevsky ADORES Alyosha, he still allows him to love Ivan. And Ivan.. Ivan is a split personality. Hes torn in 2. Figure Rodya in Crime and Punishment

I'm almost done with the book. I will really miss it. I'll cherish the remaining 200 pages I haven't yet read.

@ami1649

2 жыл бұрын

Enjoy!

“Too high a price is asked for harmony.”

I had Alyosha’s outlook when I was younger. Then at 18 I became a first responder. It was only for a year, but I had 3 bad cases, one involving an infant. Now at 28, I have more of Ivan’s outlook. I don’t know what to believe as far as a higher power goes, but if there is one, I would have some hard questions about those events. This chapter made me feel understood in a way.

@brigs369

4 ай бұрын

do you believe in free will? because suffering becomes pretty obvious if you do now the unobvious, and unanswerable, is why suffering is a conduit to existence and/or God. The best answer one can give is that our only hope is that those who suffer find eternal peace in the afterlife

In describing Ivan, the author says he wrote newspaper articles on theology and Christians and Atheists alike believed his words supported their views. Dostoevsky does the same with this novel. Be wary in implying he has definitively supported your viewpoint. I’d argue that Ivan’s ways led to perdition and Alyosha was the only consistent beacon of light throughout the book. Alyosha answered all of his questions, not with words but how he lived. Ivan had all the words but his life amounted to an odorous vapor.

@guy_gardner4098

28 күн бұрын

Dostoyevsky is very obviously pro-orthodox church, like ffs please, it's written all over his books.

In Ortodox Christianity self inspection and repentance of sin is the key to the door we knock on for Jesus .The Truth. By Acknowledging our own wrong we start to feel love and compassion for others who do wrong while blind and ignorant as we are, but also to recognize Lie that is trying to manipulate us. In repentance, Holly Spirit presence manifest, starts to teach us....to be wise as serpent and harmless as dove.

Excellent video. I’m a Roman Catholic and when Jesus was born Herod had all the first born males slaughtered. I think they are the first martyrs of the Church. But they were also “old testament “ Jews now having their sons slain absurdly in search of Herod’s fear of a new king having been born. This is the story of mankind’s fallen nature. And it has brought blood lust into the world for as long as it lasts. God created angels before man with free will. Yes we want freedom no matter how far it degrades us. We have free will. The Holy Innocents that were slaughtered the night Jesus was born were immediately in glory. But still as believers we are commanded to give our lives to come to the aid of the suffering and that itself is not absurd.

Yet Doestoevski was a very sincere Christian. He had the depth and honesty to present the strongest possible challenges to faith in Christ imaginable. It would have been interesting to hear more of the younger brother and his perspective.

@za4310

7 ай бұрын

I somewhat doubt the standardness of Dostoyevskys stated beliefs, to the point where I think he might have been more of atheist despite claiming otherwise. I think he considers himself at worst an Ivan who has gone mad from the truth and at best a zosima who acknowledges the truth but persists. I think he considers the talk of immortal souls and heaven to comfort grieving mothers to be an opposite side of the coin or the grand Inquisitor. Lies to control and supposedly help humanity. He seems to believe it's okay to comfort individuals but to mechanically control human society and lock up people like zosima/jesus is wrong. Zosima doesn't want to establish a church-state relationship either, and it's basically because he already understands the meaning of Ivan's poem without having heard it. He knows that the state mechanically loves "humanity" yet ignores individuals. Any great state, church or not, is somewhat like the girl in the wheelchair. She claims to love humanity but has no love for individuals. So I think Dostoevsky believes religion is pragmatically true for individuals but he doesn't believe it literally. He sees it as a form of madness that could either comfort your in your grieving or haunt you with apparitions of the devil. This is reinforced especially by his constant references to holy fools. He sees a falseness in some of them, but those qualities of taking on strange beliefs and behaviors in order to help others is essentially what he feels about religion. He considers the will to care for others and show love as a measure of the truth.

Историята на българина предадена чрез Иван е абсолютно вярна и аргумента за създаването на дявола от хората е логичната връзка. Което означава, че тази връзка поражда и необходимостта от Бог. Страхотно видео.

I like your analysis of that chapter, well done! There is more to the chapter, but this might be a great start for people trying to understand more about it

While short, the chapter “A Little Demon” hit me super hard. The imagery is similar to Rebellion in how it details horrible acts being done to children, yet Lise talks about it in a way completely different way. She’s depressed, numb, and revels in the idea of hurting herself or others as some kind of escape, smiling as she describes violent atrocities. And the way the chapter ends with her slamming the door on her finger, with it being described as black and oozing. Lise looks at what she did to herself, about to cry, thinking how even that wasn’t enough. It’s so short but it was such a poignant depiction of depression

@kyutifer

2 жыл бұрын

This part hurt. The loss of innocence really gets to me, and the worst part is that it makes sense.

@Foushee217

2 жыл бұрын

I was so confused after reading the Little Demon chapter, but now i think i understand it's because I've never really suffered from depression. The previous chapter about Lise was so sweet and hopeful, and then she is completely lost. My wife, who has had depression, said it made sense to her. But it broke my heart, and never really gets resolved!

@user-rr9to2ul6n

Жыл бұрын

omg i wrote a poem about this section because it was so resounding to me when i first read this book

@ghostfriendly6474

Жыл бұрын

Most disturbing sentence of the book, absolutely "I don't know'. The virtuous and sincere monk is unable to deny an anti-Semitic blood libel

@ghostfriendly6474

Жыл бұрын

@@Foushee217 Not a full resolution but she sent flowers to the small boy's funeral at the end

Nicely presented young man. You are a natural born teacher.

It still baffles me that essentially the book states children are abused simply because the delectable defenselessness is too tantalizing to pass up. Or disgusts me, anyway. Excellent video.

You look like you are on the verge of crying: Great video by the way. I am currently on page 452

I found the opposite tone reading this chapter. I didn’t get a sense of Ivan being sad and weary of the idea that everyone can be forgiven and that there being harmony but rather I felt this undercurrent of resentfulness from Ivan. To me it seemed more that Ivan was ridiculing this vision and wilfully torturing his brother with them while masquerading as a melancholic benevolent figure

@fakeemail4005

2 жыл бұрын

I got the same impression too. I though Ivan was full of energy and angry even, while he was talking to Alyosha, who he knew had pretty much the opposite beliefs as him

@kelpower1

Жыл бұрын

I know this is a year old, but I just finished reading the chapter myself & I absolutely agree. I always envision these kinds of long monologues as if I were acting them out on stage to really feel the character or what I would think they feel & it was very frantic & desperate like a search for an answer he knows he’ll never receive & if he ever did, it wouldn’t suffice to calm him.

@caseyharrington4947

Жыл бұрын

@@kelpower1 Out of curiosity, when you get to it, please tell is what you think of chapter 9

@kelpower1

Жыл бұрын

@@caseyharrington4947 can you name the chapter? My copy is from 1950 & it’s broken up differently. Are you referring to “The Preliminary Investigation”?

@caseyharrington4947

Жыл бұрын

@@kelpower1 "The Devil"

Hysterical opening to the video! Great content!

Astonishing! Absolutely astonishing. Thank you so much for this.

This is great; thank you so much for sharing.

just finished book today, this was a great way to start 're-reading' it, thanks for the brilliant overview !

@ami1649

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks!

Reading The Rebel from Camus I'm at the chapter where he makes reference to Ivan Karamazov. It sill need to read The Brothers Karamazov and so your video helped give context to Camus' thoughts. Thanks !

Found your channel through reddit and wow, brilliant video!!!! Excited to go through all of your channel. Ivan Karamazov is one of my all time favorite characters and I cherish every chapter he's in in Karamazov brothers greatly, he's so interesting.

@ami1649

2 жыл бұрын

💯🙏

Great content, thank you! I'm about to start reading the book

In the middle of the Rebellion chapter right now, can't wait to be stopped on the street to be asked what the most disturbing chapter of Brothers is

I went out onto the street and asked random people “what is the most disturbing chapter in The Brothers Karamazov?” No one knew what I was talking about.

@SearchingTheArchives

Жыл бұрын

I chuckled

When I saw the heading title of your video, I remembered that chapter in all its horror, and wholly agree with you. Even the axe murder scene in Crime and Punishment pales in comparison.

@sonyafirefly3879

3 жыл бұрын

The only one that's harder to read in his work is the chapter in Demons that the publishers refused to leave in (but which explains the book's ending).

@burntt999

2 жыл бұрын

@@sonyafirefly3879 oh damn im about to read demons next.. how’d you find out about missing chapters? And im assuming they are online somewhere?

@sonyafirefly3879

2 жыл бұрын

@@burntt999 It's at the end of the Pevear and Volokhonsky translation. Makes the ending of the book make a heck of a lot more sense, but it will make you feel angry and sick (seriously, thinking about it just now made me cry). I don't know exactly where Dostoevsky meant it to be in the book.

I've recently finished this novel. Thanks for the video

Great video! The Brothers Karamazov is one of my favorite books I have read. Rebellion is disturbing for sure.

This was an amazing passage from the book. I recently finished reading it! I agree with Ivan.

@dannyperez1604

3 жыл бұрын

If you finished reading it then you know Dostoevsky responds by what happens to Ivan at the end of the book. The argument he correctly makes is that when "God is dead" and religion ceases to exist, men would have to create their own values but they are incapable of doing so. It is a theme in many of his books that man must have some form of a God in order to keep order in the world, otherwise everything is permissible. In other words, even atheists act like a God exists. Dostoevsky correctly predicted what Communism would become in the absence of religious structure.

@thetinmaamfromozthemagicdragon

3 жыл бұрын

Probs why the next chapter grand inquisitor juxtaposes this one so poignantly

The rivalry, the battle is obvious through out the whole book. It’s clear, that those were fighting in Dostoevsky as well, but he finds the way out through the God, without a clear win for any side. The line in the beginning is also quite fascinating, where Fjodor Pavlovich talks to Alyosha, and he almost cries, calling Alyosha such a good boy. And then he adds : Fyodor was sentimental. Sentimental AND ANGRY. So even at this moment Devil is not leaving him. He is angry to himself, but Alyosha makes him fight the evil. It’s so many senses and sidelines in this book, that it really gives you no chance, then to agree to Jordan Peterson, that it’s probably the greatest book ever written.

I love this video, I think you nailed it

Brilliant analysis

I just finished reading this chapter. Preparing myself for The Grand Inquisitor. I admire how Ivan lets reality hit him. He does not turn his eyes away from it, no matter how painful it may be. I wonder if this has anything to do with some sort of self-laceration on his side.

@NART211

Жыл бұрын

I would say it's because he'd rather see the truth for what it is. He's a realist. From Dostoevsky's Notes From The Underground: "Which is better - cheap happiness or exalted sufferings?" Rather than cheap lies, Ivan is choosing exalted suffering - exalted because it is the truth. In the same conversation between Alyosha and Ivan, Ivan asks if he should stop and if he's making Alyosha suffer. Alyosha responds with something like: "Oh, I want to suffer." I believe Ivan sees how people turn a blind eye to those sufferings and chooses to look at them directly. This takes courage to do. I remember at the meeting with Father Zossima, Ivan was a passive listener, not intervening even when the priests discussed his articles (my memory might not be accurate here). This could be because he thought people were living a lie, especially that of Christianity, and hence refused to involve himself in their lies and stuck to his knowledge and lofty suffering. Alyosha, however, is able to take that burden of suffering and maintain his faith in humanity. I believe this is one of the reasons why Dostoevsky wrote him as the hero. In the words of Viktor Frankl: "For tears bore witness that a man had the greatest of courage, the courage to suffer." I believe this is the type of courage encompassesd by Dostoevsky and the Karamazov. Hurrah for Karamazov!

@dalejames486

Жыл бұрын

@@NART211 "..'I'm a realist,' I'll say, 'not a materialist,' heh, heh!" -The Devil in Ivan's nightmare

@NART211

Жыл бұрын

@@dalejames486 It's always worthwhile speaking to a clever man.

'It isn't God I don't accept, Alyosha, it's just his ticket that I most respectfully return to him.' Most badass line ever written!🙌

@CatholicWisdom

7 ай бұрын

Very similar to the lines by Capaneus, one of the main characters in Dante’s Inferno.

Great review, cheers

I’m reading the McDuff translation, and it’s called “Mutiny” instead of Rebellion. Don’t know if it’s a better translation or not but it’s interesting!

Thank you!

Zosima was not the part of monastery brethren. He is a hermit type of monk.

I've only just completed my first read. I would love to be a part of this conversation but I think I shoulf only do so when I re read it

Looks like this book blew your mind, Einstein loved Dostoyevsky, and many great novelist admired his work. Read MuMu by Dostoyevsky, short book and great read. Bulgakov is another spectacular writer, Master and Margarita is a masterpiece I think.

@thetinmaamfromozthemagicdragon

3 жыл бұрын

Read Einstein’s dreams by Alan Lightman!!! From what you’re saying, I’m sure you’d love it Unless you already have, which I think is more probable

@thesenseii9479

3 жыл бұрын

My friend also recommended the Master and Margarita! I’m definitely gonna read it now. thanks for that

I read this book 25 yes ago and was deeply moved. I’ve just re read it and it’s still if not more disturbing. I don’t know how to place this passage and the others of equal emotional charge given what happened in the 20th century and even today in Ukraine. I feel the search for universal values is a dead end pursuit. Perhaps we need a definition of human nature and of an “ideal” man to help us fix an anchor in this world where “god is dead”. I’d be interested to know your thoughts. ??

Thank you so much for this review. I just finished the book and so many ideas and emotions were clashing in my head but your "review' of this chapter was so educational in my attempt to understand Ivan's character and his ideas about God. Question: Why did Smerdyakov commit suicide, and Ivan feel guilt for his perceived role in his father's murder, if they both didn't believe in God and "everything is permitted"?

@CatholicWisdom

9 ай бұрын

The guilt they both felt is because God is real. S. was too weak to bear it. Ivan was stronger.

@kathrynstiles3509

7 ай бұрын

exactly @@CatholicWisdom

@fuiscklam4087

6 ай бұрын

Ivan was never the kind of atheist, that don't believe in God. As he says it himself: "I just humbly return the ticket"

I loved the chapter where Grushenka & Katerina meet for the first time!

Great video!

@ami1649

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you!

Alyosha is the one who actually follows the suffering servant. I believe you might be mistaken.

Obviously the “Rebellion” chapter is emotionally disturbing to the vlogger, as to almost all who read it, including myself. One of the most disturbing for me was Katerina Ivanovna’s revelation during Dimitri’s hearing about her mental and psychological sufferings.

@ami1649

3 жыл бұрын

Nice! I'll have to revisit that section. Thanks!

@mightstealyourvinyl3378

7 ай бұрын

Such a fatally good answer

Ivan was just applying what he was learning in law school 😅

It is really difficult to read it, I really do not know how I could move my eyes along the pages.

The Grand Inquisitor is the most disturbing chapter so far to me. A poem that not so called poem because it is tremendously long. Ivan such a weirdo. I agree his belief that he trusts the god existence but he don't trust the teachings that forgive every people who have sinned on you as in the chapter Rebellion. He has a point on this statement. He uses kids as his motive explaining his belief that gives me grief and sympathy for those kids. Dostoevsky has ability to hide himself in the character as representative. The author was the mind, the characters is the speaker of the mind.

@tyronemidzi2457

2 жыл бұрын

In my opinion the grand inquisitor abs rebellion are on the same level.

The father acts irrationally for the sake of it.

@acropolisnow9466

3 жыл бұрын

He enjoys it.

Inhuman suffering

Most random people in the street would have probably never even read the book. Sadly, I have only ever met one person who has that I know of. It’s a shame because it’s one of the greatest books in world literature. As for Ivan, he was the world’s first poe! 😂 He tried to act as if he didn’t believe in a God, but he did really. That’s why he told Alyosha that he ‘returns the ticket’ (rejects the offer of salvation.) He had a view of God, sitting on a cloud, not intervening to help when his people suffered. Edit: some of the story about the Turks was later rehashed to be the Germans in World War One, such as the bayoneting of babies. The Germans never did that in the First World War, even though under Hitler unspeakable atrocities were committed.

@fuiscklam4087

6 ай бұрын

Yet the story of the Turks is factually true.

@oleggorky906

6 ай бұрын

@@fuiscklam4087 I didn’t say it wasn’t. It wasn’t true with regard to Germany is what I was pointing out. I don’t know much about the Turks. But they have certainly committed atrocities against the Armenians, Greeks, Arabs and others.

@ElonMuskrat-my8jy

3 ай бұрын

​@@oleggorky906I doubt they did the bayonetting in WWII. But the Soviets certainly did it.

@oleggorky906

3 ай бұрын

@@ElonMuskrat-my8jy I meant the First World War. But yes, the Soviets committed some terrible atrocities at the end of the Second World War. It’s widely believed that over two million German women were raped; the civilian population weren’t even allowed to lock their doors at night, allowing the Russians to walk in to any house at will and take any woman whom they so desired by force. Many of the victims were raped multiple times by multiple men. It got so bad that with the trauma of all that, untold thousands of women just gave up and committed suicide. Many weren’t even women as such, just children. It was pure revenge for what Hitler did, the difference being that no Soviet soldier was going to be prosecuted for a war crime. The biggest tragedy of the Second World War is that the vast majority of the dead weren’t combatants. Untold millions of civilians were murdered by several governments. Just imagine the horrors that could be perpetrated now with drones carrying biological weapons and toxins capable even of distinguishing between races. If another World War comes, I hope that I don’t live to see it. The consequences are going to be unimaginably brutal.

Thanks for your thoughts on said chapter. Dostoevsky is the best.

I am so glad this guy is good looking…I’d have a hard time paying attention. Thank you.

sorry but I can't stop thinking ab the 1st statement you made 'if you were to go out in the street and ask any person...' I'm either deeply confused ab the ordinary person one may come across day to day OR I live in an extemly sheltered and obtuse environment because....

I honestly found ivans arguments to be very superficial. Everyone always talks about him like hes such a genius so i expected more when i read the book but it wasnt very impressive to me

I think the grand inquisitor and rebellion are just one chapter !!

Every monk knows that all mankind deserves death but that's why Jesus is so crucial. That evil that alyoshas brother describes is within the heart of every single man. If it were not for Christ we would all be worthy of death.

The Grand Inquisitor is my favorite

Actually It's towards the end of first third of the text.

The grand inquisitor chapter

Same

What do you think of Nikolai Berdyaev?

@ami1649

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not familiar. Do you recommend him?

@jamessheffield4173

2 жыл бұрын

@@ami1649 Nikolai Alexandrovich Berdyaev was a Russian political and Christian religious philosopher who emphasized the existential spiritual significance of human freedom and the human person.

@jamessheffield4173

2 жыл бұрын

@@ami1649 I think Berdyaev's philosophy is close to Dostoyevsky's.

@JaxBespoked

Жыл бұрын

@@ami1649 He wrote a book/collection of essays on Dostoevsky that I highly recommend. In this early 20th century work, he was one of the first thinkers to seriously compare and contrast Dostoevsky and Nietzsche.

The entire purpose of this video is to distract you from another chapter that is far more disturbing.

Rebellion is good!

Gold mines?

Also from the Christian Perspective even Children Are Not Innocent. Grace comes through Christ Alone. It is a free gift, not one that Is earned, and not one that is lost.

Ivan sounds like ee-von, not like I-vën. Why do English speakers englishify everything?

@ZenityStudios

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe because they’re English……………………

While talk, please look at the camera. Its anoying

@ami1649

3 жыл бұрын

I'll try my best!

@shankarthiyagaraajan1147

3 жыл бұрын

@@ami1649 🌼🌼🌼👍🏼

@uggggggghhhhh

3 жыл бұрын

it isnt annoying at all

@elb1914

3 жыл бұрын

It really isn’t

@vickielberfeld2014

7 ай бұрын

Unless a person is reading off cue cards or has memorized in advance what he‘ll say, gazing at the camera 100% is impossible. I much appreciate and prefer this speaker‘s more natural approach.