The Hedge Knight read-through Part 2 - Dunk and Egg
Ойын-сауық
Featuring@GreyWasteTim ! The second part (2 of 3) of the Hedge Knight brings us the tourney at Ashford meadow, which becomes the trial by 7 at Ashford Meadow! Dunk vs Aerion Brightflame! Triple morningstar long night meteor symbolism! It's all here!
🜏 One-time donation to support: www.paypal.me/mythicalastronomy
🜏 Join our Patreon: / davidlightbringer
🜏 All things Mythical Astronomy: lucifermeanslightbringer.com/
🜏 Teeshirts & Merch: lucifer-means-lightbringer.cr...
🜏 NEW mythology YT Channel: / mythicconcepts
🜏 NEW sci-fi & more YT Channel: / @moonmediacollective
Twitter: @thedragonLML | Instagram: @davidlightbringer
Grey Waste Tim's channel: @GreyWasteTim
title image uses "Dunk and Egg by Hector Arzate"
Пікірлер: 143
A sacrifice to the algorithm
@theseviolentdelightz
Жыл бұрын
To the old algorithms and the new
@davidwilkinson8836
7 ай бұрын
😂
A user leaves a comment.
@davturley3950
2 ай бұрын
There is only one god. A user knows his name.
Imagine reading a series of books and thinking that the author never use metaphors and symbolism to express themselves, the characters, the world within it. Couldn't be me. Please don't ever stop what your doing, I love these deep dives so much and I know that majority of people here do too. ❤ Also one of my favorite lines is the "dusk seeping into the room" and the lines similar to this throughout ASoIaF because it shows the light and shadow are very much alive.
@sierrabird3817
Жыл бұрын
“Dusk seeping” also makes me thing of the oily black stone drinking the light and Stannis’ shadow coming to kill Renly
@TheRyssaRave
Жыл бұрын
@@sierrabird3817 oh yes, that's fantastic.
@kingmessiahisaac6404
Жыл бұрын
😅Lee gq
Dunk is the most relatable protagonist to someone "thick as a castle wall." If only I were also that badass.
I'm a simple man. I have to have others break down symbolism and I leave comments when asked nicely. Thx, once again, for a fantastic live stream Mr LML and Mr GWT. Bless the green teas, Garth the green and all of our pets + squirrels (Children of the Forest). Until next week! ❤
I'm LOVING these duo read through streams guys, you both rock dudes. ❤🔥✌️
You know that it would be untrue You know that I would be a liar If I was to say to you Girl you have to ride that pyre C’mon ride me in the pyre C’mon ride me in the pyre Gotta light that sword on fiiiirrrrrreeee!
@laurenl3474
Жыл бұрын
You know that it would be untrue You know I’d be a liar If I were to say to you, “Don’t ride me in the pyre” Girl, ride me in the pyre Cmon, ride me in the pyre “Cmon girl,” I’d say to you, “Light my sword on fire!” Lol cute, city slacker
I am grateful for the Monday escape from the mundane work I do. Thanks LML
Re-watching these live streams always makes my monday a little easier ❤
im so excited its finally spring again, i found your channel last year when i started gardening (real not author style lol) and i would just put on your vids and work out in my flowerbeds and let me just say ive been waiting so patiently to return to this little ritual it brings me so much joy thank you david and tim! i appreciate your content so much!!
Oooh ma'goodness 😂...Ya'll tickle me to bits 🤣 😅🫠😆 Truly. So pleasant, fun, enjoyable YET insightful, thorough, sharp, funny, goofy and charming. Gold stars all around guys ✨️🌠🌟
High quality entertainment as always. Thank you guys.
I don’t mind the pauses for symbolism. That’s what I come to LML for anyways 🤷♂️
Thank you. Your channel has helped remind me that good stories work on multiple levels. Praise Garth!
The people that think your over analysing are the same people bitchin constantly that George hasn’t delivered Winds yet, not knowing how deep this story goes and therefore not knowing how difficult an undertaking it’s going to be finish this off
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
i tend to think that's right
These dunk and egg streams have been a blast btw, Tim thank you for everything you bring to the read alongs, and as always great job David!
I really love your back ground David it’s pretty awesome
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
ITS A CASTLE WALL GET IT
@melissamoore5223
Жыл бұрын
@@DavidLightbringer yes! I got it lol 😂 this is why you are the best, you crack me up
rewatching these glorious streams cuz they are incredible
Thanks for the great stream! Loving the D&E content, guys!
Comment for the comment gods, engagement for the engagement throne
Say “Weirwood Net” three times to have green dreams 🧑🏼🎤😴☠️
Great times! Had to catch a quick rewatch at work.
Thank you both of this! Each of you reminds me of friends from long ago
Quite the fun stream! Always great to go back and hear the tales of Ser Duncan
These read throughs are really fun. The plot hints in D&E are even more clear on re read than those in the main books. It just reminds us to keep hunting for clues
Wow i love so much this dunk and egg streams. As always great chemistry!
Ser Robin Rhysling vs Leo Longthorn Tyrell, is like a Grey King figure fighting a green king. So summer king vs winter king symbolism. A lance to the heart, is like being killed. But he rises again... Splinters flying, a one-eyed dude rising from the dead. It reminds me of the prologue...
@jonhauge-evaldsson783
Жыл бұрын
Rhysling sigil is, a door in a black wall, and just as you guys said, it reminds us of the black gate. The face in the door reminds us of the Grey King.
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
you're right, the splinters are a good parallel to the Waymar prologue for sure!
Dunk believes Eggs lies about his identity, because he sees himself in him. Dunk projects his feelings towards the boy he once was, giving him the love Arlan gave him, when he was all alone in a horrible world. 💔 😢❤
Great stream, perhaps you should have used the Nimble Dick voice for Steely Pete.
I love these streams. They're always so fun!
Your analysis always make the whole thing so much richer than when I read it by myself. I don't have the patience to think about all this and try to find the metaphors. I didn't expect this many in dunk and egg tbh since it's an 'easier' read than asoiaf.
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
hahah i know right??
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
as far as it being surprising that Dunk and Egg has so much
Always love the hedge knight stories
I didn't catch this live, but damn good stream. I love the compact story telling in dunk and egg and David and Tim's commentary are very enjoyable on top. I'll definitely try to catch the rest of these.
Great stream yall! Thanks 👍
Another great read. Stoked for part 3. Mel is not only from Hardhome, she mended Mance’s cloak. 😜
Mythhead checking in! I hadn't read the Dunk and Egg books but it's very cool to do it real time with your analysis and see what I catch on first blush. I'm really excited to do that as I read TWoW.
LML & Tim Thank You Guys for that top notch stream! What a good team you make!💪🏼💪🏼👌🏻👌🏻💘💘🙋🏼♀️🇨🇦
I'm over a week late, but here's what stands out to me. If the tourney is symbolism for the battle against the Bloodstone Emperor that happened on the Battle Isle and what happened between Rhaegar and Lyanna, it's so curious that the whole time Dunk was keeping his eye on Valarr and watching him intently. Especially during this entire time, Dunk kept thinking that he had to "unhorse" Valarr. And when someone is unhorsed in a jousting tourney, that person is brought down/brought back to earth. You've mentioned how riding a horse could mean being on the astral plane or inside the weirwood. So, we have Dunk and Egg (mostly Dunk) watching Valarr while thinking that they must "unhorse" him, which gives me the idea of someone in the current story (maybe Bran, maybe Euron) looking through the weirwood net, observing figures from the past like Rhaegar, Azor Ahai, or the Bloodstone Emperor, and trying to "unhorse" them from the astral plane or the weirwood net, bringing them back to earth or to the real world. The word "unhorse" stood out to me specifically.
Hi David and Tim!Sorry to miss you. Glad I 😊can rewatch. Cheers gents @
02:00:30 - 02:02:00 this is why your the goat of ASOIAF symbolism
This stream was awesome!
Awesome as always. I look forward to this every week.
Came for the symbolism, staying for the hot pyre sex 🔥 Great stream!
Great stream as always, look forward to this every week. Looking forward to Jon Snow's resurrection video 2.0 pyre sex edition
I personally don't mind going into the weeds drawing parallels and symbolism
Tim looking fresh! Js! Nice to see him glowing & growing!
You two are the best!
2:42:11 I would recommend: Bran as Merlin, Bloodraven as the wizard who taught Merlin, Jon as ?Uthur? Pendragon( Arthur’s father), Jon’s daughter as Arthur.
If I were in charge at HBO, I'd have learnt my lesson from season 8 of GoT (George is the irreplaceable one with the talent & substitutes are a waste of money & a hit to reputation) and insisted George was in the writing room as much as he was willing. The news about the 2 seasons greenlit & hands-on GRRM sounds very positive to me.
I hadn't heard the news about HotD since I live under a rock, but I think anyone who isn't excited about it is crazy, heh heh
1:50:02 - Hey Dave, just wanted to say that Aerion and his men's behavior here isn't just petty - it is far, far worse. These puppets are *this family's livelihood!!!* It takes a moment to destroy but weeks and possibly months to create!! As an artist I'm especially horrified of the breaking of her fingers 😣😫🤬 the nimbleness of these fingers, their connection to the brain and eyes is what puts food on the table. It is so painful to read. I love Dunk for standing up for what's right without a second thought. The insane privilege of a prince destroying the livelihood of those much much below him is infuriating.
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
great point.. they were specifically crippling their ability to make a living. and they were never compensated, only grateful to escape at all
Another great stream! Happy we are doing the Hedge Knight. I can't wait to hear what you have to say about the recruiting and battle.
Sorry I missed this live. Still juicy several days later! 😂
Another awesome stream boys, can’t wait for the conclusion and looking forward to the rest of the stories hope you guys keep it rolling!
I love this!!!!
Awesome stream. Appreciate it :)
loved the stream cant wait for the next one
Great job fellas!
This stream was awesome! Hope youtube sees this comment and recommends it to more people
Gotta get this man to 100k subs already
I have nothing witty to add.... so for the algorithm God's
comment.
I can't wait for the next part!
Dope!
Great stream!
David always looks sweaty 😂
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
actually, I’m one of those people who basically never sweats
Yay a part 3!
Best damn channel in existence
Stoking the Flames of Algorithm
Bloodraven and Jon have daily contact. Because Bloodraven is in Mormont's Raven.
Thanks
1:28:12 I’m always excited to hear GRRM is creating anything! 1:58:23 So Dunk, the representation of a true night, had a cup of wine (blood/weirwood paste), went through the wall of watchers (North of the wall), to save a woman to save a woman from a dragon (Frozen Azor Ahai). As the prince’s guard (the others) close in on Dunk (the last hero), Egg (an unknown dragon) steps in and commands the guards (others) to stop their attack… Am I reading into this too much?
Brilliant.
Can you figure out witch houses at this tourney were Blackfire suppoters? Loyalists? Neutral?
I liked dreamcatcher too tim!! 😅
Tim doesn't See the other when the Horns are tooting. He hast to Go to the David Lightbringer school For children who can't do symbolism very well.
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
🤣🤣🤣
Great stream! Can't wait for part 3!
I'm certain I'm not the first to observe this, but it just dawned on me that there have been 4 Aegons, and Egg is the fourth son of a fourth son
In the previous stream, there was a part that was explaining the rules of the tourney and there was a sentence somewhere along the lines of "... the others were left to be challengers". So could it be that you got it the other way around and the champions are the heroes defending the weirwood net and the realms of men from the others and the night king? Prince Valarr, who doesn't fit with the symbolism of the other champions, as you said, could be the last hero, implying that he had dragon blood.
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
i couldn’t sort it out. it seems like Others and last hero’s on both sides. it’s really confusing on that sense. the action between Dunk and Aerion is easy to interpret, but the teams, idk
If Rhysling means wine it could be symbolism for blood. The way grrm worded it sounds like the nissa nissa story. A lance to the chest. splinters are a comet shard that took out one of his eyes aka one of the moons. His name and sigil symbolizing a blood and a door(blood sacrifice that opens a door) maybe
Great stream poor Dunk.😢
Asha pregnant blows my mind makes so much sense. How did I not see it???
Quaith's mask is Magneto's helmet!
@mistermaestersirthomas9164
Жыл бұрын
Probably, but are you familiar with the “masks hide eye color” trope?
This read alongs man ❤
In all seriousness about Blood Raven/ Shara Seastar/ Mel, I have no doubt in my mind, if Blood Raven had the slightest inkling of Mel serving the greater good by being enslaved, he would have been on board with that. He's not a "good" guy. He's a force of nature. Impartial and implacable.
How do you interpret the symbolism of Maekar killing Baelor? Cain and Able? Is it the same as Stannis and Renly? Or is it The Night's King Azor Ahai (who maybe was a Stark a proto-Stark) and Brandon the Breaker, Last Hero maybe his brother or maybe his son, if Bael the Bard is Night's King?
Love these book reads
Who do you guys think it was that killed Baelor Breakspear? And why? I don't think it was Maekar. Or how do you explain the memory loss? Magic? No, I think it was someone else. Either on purpous or by accident. On his own accord or working for somebody.
@jonhauge-evaldsson783
Жыл бұрын
Motives: Lots!
Fab stream!
Surprised you guys missed them drinking prince blood 😮
@DavidLightbringer
Жыл бұрын
oh prince of the blood was that what was going on
@ACPritchard
Жыл бұрын
Tried to find it in my graphic novel but it’s not there!! So I have returned to point it out directly, just for you my friend 💪🔥 1:40:45 I believe the subtext of this conversation symbolizes two figures sharing a cup of special blood together, ser. Prince’s blood. *kings* blood. I believe it was David Lightbringer once said in his nimble dick voice, “any time George mentions wine you need to think of blood” Or something. Words are wind, right? 😊 Have a great day my dude
@ACPritchard
Жыл бұрын
“They took his horse” Like Odin’s horse?
@ACPritchard
Жыл бұрын
“He handed dunk a wine cup” *the next line: “prince baelor is an honorable man” Lmao
@ACPritchard
Жыл бұрын
Raymond drained his cup and set it aside. “Poor maekar” Lmfao. Witness me, David. I got the eye now 👁
Great stream as always! Just want to build on all the points you found pointing to potential pyre sex...We know how GRRM likes to take his previously written ideas/themes and build on them/incorporate them into A Song of Ice and Fire. Well, I've only read the very beginning of this novelette (a while ago)...but isn't GRRM's Meathouse Man (and apologies for bringing up this disturbing story) about a corpse-handler that reanimates corpses to perform manual labour...and then visits corpse brothels where the sex workers are reanimated corpses? I dont know about you... but feels like GRRM incorporating these ideas into a Jon Snow pyre sex/resurrection vibes to me! Sorry again lol.
Wine is associated with blood. Versus a barred door , I.e to the weirwood net
@Slechy_Lesh
Жыл бұрын
(Rysling)
Just catching this now! God I absolutely love when y'all are both in a video together! FANTASTIC stream my dudes!
Lair of the White Worm…😊 1980’s movie
Do you think George might be a member of team ADHD? His creative process (complete with long breaks) reminds me a lot of my own
Maybe it was Aeiron, not Maekar who killed Baelor, in a vain hope to make his father proud.
Thicc as a castle wall 😮
Thanks for this. Great video. The web is dark and full of algorithms.
This new hair is so sexy!
I think the political conflict here is between Maekar and Baelor. Aeiron is not just an evil kid, he is pushed by his father. I think Maekar is a mix of Tywin and Randyll Tarley. He is pushing Daeron to be a knight even though he doesn't want to. I think he sent Aemon away to be a master because he was to bad at fighting. More as a way to hide him. As Raymunn Fosseway, says, to this toxisic masculine warriors, to be a maester is a discrase. I also think the trail by seven was Makar's idea not Aeron's. I think when Maekar in the end agrees to let Egg become Dunk's squire, it is not to be nice to any of them. He wants to make a man out of him.
@jonhauge-evaldsson783
Жыл бұрын
Now I read that it was King Daeron II who sent Aemon to the citadel, because he thought there were to many princes. Maekar protested and saw it as an insult.