The Great Plant-Based Con: Food, Health and the Environment - Jayne Buxton
I'm excited to sit down with Jayne Buxton. We talk about the plant-based lifestyle, kids with B12 deficiencies, and much more. Make sure to listen to the full interview to learn more.
Jayne Buxton, born in the UK and having lived across Canada, the US, and the UK, holds an MBA from IMD Business School and a master’s degree in creative writing from Kingston University. She spent fifteen years as a management consultant specializing in business strategy and data analysis before making waves with her debut nonfiction work, "Ending the Mother War," in 1998. This groundbreaking book tackled the complexities faced by women balancing motherhood and careers, earning Jayne recognition as a leading figure in the feminist movement. Following the success of "Ending the Mother War," Jayne transitioned into a prominent spokesperson and writer on work-life issues, founding Flametree, a consultancy for working parents. After Flametree's incorporation into a major consultancy, Jayne dedicated herself fully to writing.
In her latest book, "The Great Plant Based Con," Jayne continues her tradition of challenging mainstream narratives. Through her compelling alternative perspective, she questions prevalent beliefs on important issues, mirroring her commitment to fostering debate and critical thinking. Alongside her writing career, Jayne actively supports organizations such as the Public Health Collaboration and The Real Food Campaign, advocating for healthier lifestyles through the promotion of real food and sustainable practices.
We discuss the following:
0:00 Intro
1:45 All about Jayne Buxton
4:17 Plant-based lifestyle
6:25 Media and WHO funding
14:37 People on a plant-based diet
16:54 Kids with B12 deficiencies
24:43 How to change the dietary recommendations
36:16 Saturated fat studies
38:59 Epidemiological studies
46:21 Meat's environmental impact
58:01 Thoughts on eating insects
1:00:41 Expensive plant-based foods
1:06:05 Where to find Jayne Buxton
_____
RESOURCES
- Website: thegreatplantbasedcon.com/
- Twitter: / jaynereesbuxton
- The Great Plant-Based Con: amzn.to/3IXHEeZ
_____
SIGN UP FOR MY WEEKLY NEWSLETTER: nutritionwithjudy.com/join-nu...
CHECK OUT MY CARNIVORE CURE BOOK: amzn.to/3R4VAXn
THE COMPLETE CARNIVORE DIET FOR BEGINNERS: YOUR PRACTICAL GUIDE TO AN ALL-MEAT LIFESTYLE: amzn.to/3D5lyo5
_____
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:
1) Nutrition with Judy Articles: nutritionwithjudy.com/articles/
2) Nutrition with Judy Resources: nutritionwithjudy.com/resources/
3) Nutrition with Judy Podcast: nutritionwithjudy.buzzsprout....
--------
FIND JUDY CHO:
🌎 Website: www.nutritionwithjudy.com
📺 KZread: / nutritionwithjudy
🏞Instagram: / nutritionwithjudy
👤Facebook: / nutritionwjudy
--------
**DISCLAIMER: I am only here to provide support as a nutritional therapy practitioner and I am not providing medical advice. I always recommend working with a team of holistic practitioners, including your PCP and a certified nutritional therapy practitioner. Do not self-diagnose. Always seek medical guidance when you have a medical condition.
--------
#thegreatplantbasedcon #plantbasedlifestyle #carnivorediet #inflammationreduction #inflammationrelief #autoimmuneprotocol #allmeatdiet #highfatlowcarb #yes2meat #carnivorelife #carbfree #carnivorediet #zerocarb #zerocarbs #worldcarnivoremonth #inflammation #carnivore # #immunehealth #cholesterol #protein #insulinresistance #aminoacids #chronicinflammation #autoimmunewellness #antiinflammatorydiet
Пікірлер: 285
Don't give up, Judy! You make a difference!
@judyjohnson9610
24 күн бұрын
Thanks. There are days that I have to remind myself that the comment section doesn't always represent a fair cross-section of the population.
What drives me mad is that carbon emissions are the only environmental contributer counted - what about pesticide, herbicide, fertilizers, soil depletion, etc.. industrial farming (all kinds) are highly destructive
@ianstuart5660
25 күн бұрын
Excellent points, thanks!
@MichaelHplus
25 күн бұрын
What’s weird is that people like you try to turn the tables by saying, “Plant agriculture is worse,” when animal farming is of course a huge source source of plant agriculture. If you think that crop production is so bad then you should stop eating farmed meat.
@infiniteinfiniteinfi
25 күн бұрын
And global warming is a scam. Those things you mentioned are real.
@LyndaHill
25 күн бұрын
@@MichaelHplusPasture and grass fed. Profits are what drives the terrible farming of animals. They're not supposed to eat corn and grain.
@AnneMB955
24 күн бұрын
Where does that happen specifically?
Root vegetables, grains, beans....food for slaves and during times of starvation. Throughout history, slaves were always fed cheap grains and beans, zero meat and eggs.
@Barbara-oe7yh
20 күн бұрын
So most people in a world are slaves and the little amount is superior and special 😂
@calista1280
20 күн бұрын
@@Barbara-oe7yhActually yes, they want us sick, tired and weak with foggy brains & poor memory... Easier to control the population then! Read the book, THE GREAT RESET, which is being implemented NOW! (2030 target date) or listen to the speeches made in Davos!!! They are evil emperors & in their own minds, they are superior to us peons... The SUGAR & GRAIN INDUSTRIES were behind the Fat is bad motto they imposed on us! They replaced good whole foods with Low Fat & added sugars and filler grains! The same as used to fatten livestock!!! Our whole society became FAT & sick with Metabolic Syndrome & Diabetes!😢 The SAD diet is killing us and the Food Pyramid has been upside down for decades! They don't care about our health, obviously 🙄 look what they did to us during the Covid Plandemic... Restricted our remedies, drs couldnt even talk about it & lied about it being paid for & produced in Wuhan by US, NIH & Fauci funding Gain of Function Research! Obama moved it to China as we made it illegal to do here!The. forced us to take an experimental DNA antagonist when all we needed was a safe dose of Hydroxychloraquine!🤬 Since going Keto/Carnivore I have a lot more energy and much less chronic pain from a bad accident! I actually got my youth and LIFE back! Hallelujah! 🎉😂
@jgfergus
20 күн бұрын
@@Barbara-oe7yh learn a little history Babs!
@asinh1100
19 күн бұрын
Middle class and lower class food was grain tuber beans some milk and egg for centuries .. hardworking and active .. while meat fish eating clergy and elite were plump and lethargic 🍁
@LyndaHill
18 күн бұрын
@@Barbara-oe7yh Yep, slaves to the medical establishment mostly. I haven't been to the doctor in years. Have you?
Will Harris from White Oak Pastures was on Joe Rogan recently. Getting the word out on Regenerative farming.
@NutritionwithJudy
21 күн бұрын
I interviewed Joel Salatin, and he's amazing, too! kzread.info/dash/bejne/pKGl28ivh6yxe9Y.htmlsi=b6zJRakoQ_q05bkd
@Rocketscientist66
17 күн бұрын
Yes yes!! We know what we have to do, we have the studies, the real science, the soil analysis. Biodiversity, regenerative farming practices. But look at our captured and corrupt gov.-agencies throwing Amish-farmers in jail. We are living in a time of great importance. If we do not react, defend our way of life, they will destroy it and destroy humans capacity to thrive and stay healthy, strong. It looks like this is their plan. We must all stand together. We are many, they are few. The power is with the poeple, but hopefully not with those brainwashed into believing the propaganda spewing out of the puppetmaster‘s mouths. Do your research people, the facts are crystal clear.
Judy has the BEST interviews!!! This is so fascinating. I appreciate all the content and great guests.
I bought into it in the 70s, my health declined so that I had to eat meat again in the mid 80s to stay out of the hospital. Yet I STILL believed that saturated fat was bad and that red meat caused cancer. Talk about cognitive dissonance 😵💫
@NutritionwithJudy
25 күн бұрын
It’s been taught to us for so long and most people believe that message, that it’s hard to shake ❤️🩹
@infiniteinfiniteinfi
25 күн бұрын
Their propaganda is very powerful. So we have to be even stronger.
I went to an SDA school in elementary, THE FOOD SUCKED! Damn rice and beans every day!!! I literally starved for years because those are my two most unfavorite foods! It’s a huge vegan cult😅
@pilarskifamily899
21 күн бұрын
Yeah. My parents started going to SDAchurch in retirement when they moved to TN. I love the people, but I am also convinced they are a cult. My parents health has gone down hill since. But I can't convince them of it.
@meatloafhead
21 күн бұрын
@@pilarskifamily899 it was a very nice experience, (except the food) good school and church, but people are generally nice in life altogether, we really don’t need cults brainwashing people anymore than tv and media already does! Lol yet somehow between the SDA and the jehovas witnesses, they are both intertwined in our politics food public health and every other crevice they can seep into! My grandparents got rooked into the SDA church after the Catholics spit on them!!! literally, for being Italians (during ww2) then my father from Croatia got roped into the JW’s all because they came by the house everyday pushing a Croatian bible on him, before we knew it, they took over our normal lives, no more holidays, no birthdays NOTHING! They are creepy, pushy, salesmen & Weirdos…. Sorry, if organized religion comes up now I get a tad bit RATTLED…. As you can see by my rant… lol, see ya around.
Great conversation 👌 and I love that youre acknowledging the propaganda against meat. We need to be aware of it because they want to restrict our access
Spot on.Excellent . Thank you Dr. Judy and Jayne Buxton .. another great , video!!!
Thank you for this. I came from 14 yrs of plant based, and ended up carnivore. That initial feeling good on plant based, was from cutting out junk, I believe. Over the years I got worse and worse. And now, slowly but surely, I am getting better.
@AnneMB955
24 күн бұрын
Good choice. 👍
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
Exactly what happened to me except it took me 30 years to figure it out. 2.5 years carnivore now.
I admit to falling for the con around 8 years ago. I read the China Study, listened to Neil B etc and was convinced because it sounded good and I didn't verify their 'facts'. I thought I felt better for the first few months but I now know it was from eliminating seed oils combined with a placebo effect because I remember my increasing bowel issues, gas and bloating, arthritis, hair loss and brain fog etc. Fast forward to today and I'm now almost 5 years carnivore and absolutely thriving!
@lenaanne9778
21 күн бұрын
I went down the same rabbit hole as you , it took me longer to get to carnivore started in February this year. But its cleared up so many problems I was having which I thought was age related but turned out not. Congratulations on nearly reaching 5 years carnivore.
@Rocketscientist66
17 күн бұрын
Thank you!! Your truth is so important.
A Fantastic video packed with brilliant no nonsense information! Many thanks Judy and Jane🙂🥩⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
8:30 Yes, I also thought plant based was healthiest so when I stopped smoking and ate plants for 2 years, I was very surprised when ended up almost having surgery to fix chronic health problems. Luckily I found carnivore late 2018 and now all of my health problems are gone with no doctors help and I still eat a carnivore diet :)
@suzannepurple
24 күн бұрын
How many times you have BM on a day?
@Meathead-10810
24 күн бұрын
@@suzannepurple Probably 1 or 2 per week with a meat only diet. With plants it was at least 2 per day, shows that the body does not like the plants :)
@Jennieadams1979
24 күн бұрын
@@Meathead-10810exactly! That's one of my favorite things about eating this way! No gas or bloating, and not needing to poop every day!
My husband had a heart calcium score of 75 after less than a year of meaty high fat keto, then carnivore. He was just checked again a year later, it dropped to 25... yeah, it reversed! YES red meat is heart healthy! Heart disease has run in his family. Not any more. :)
@Rocketscientist66
18 күн бұрын
Awesome, congrats! Love hearing these testimonies 🤓
Stopped eating most fruits and vegs. And i ate a lot. Histamine intolarance. I was poisening myself for decades thinking it was healthy. So many symptoms i had. 😂😂 Feel better than ever after two months.
As for SDA saying the only way to Heaven is through eating plants……. Maybe they missed Genesis 9 where The Lord tells Noah from now on in ADDITION to the herbs and plants you are eating you will eat animals for food. Also salvation is ONLY through Jesus period (John 14:6).
@Highdesertqueenie
24 күн бұрын
🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽👍🏽
@sportysbusiness
23 күн бұрын
Or Leviticus 11, where is specifically says "You may eat any animal that has a divided hoof and that chews the cud.". doesn't get any more clear than that...
@Rambert3
23 күн бұрын
Yes God’s word is clear, even Paul says in the latter days(Where we are now) there will be people who tell us to abstain from certain foods and that everything is good when God blesses it and sanctifies it.
@TimothyFreeman-iy8xl
23 күн бұрын
Adventists do you eat meat They do not believe you don’t go to heaven if you do eat meat this is not true. Jesus said you were not defiled by what goes into your mouth, but what comes out of it?
@trishapoland4416
18 күн бұрын
There are many healthy centurion vegetarians. Also, human lives have been shortened, from almost 1000 years before the flood to less than 100 or slightly more since meat was introduced to the diet. Keeping the diet simple, and not eating all the processed food, helps to keep one healthier. But please don’t lump All vegetarians or vegans the same or uninformed. They are not. Oh, and by the way, I have not heard or known “SDAs who believe only vegetarians go to heaven”. One is saved according to his relationship with God.
Excellent discussion. You two make so much sense.
Just recovering from a bad case of food poisoning from little gem lettuce. Not the steak, but the lettuce. My daughter only ate steak she was fine. Her friends and I also ate the salad and we got stomach cramps, diarrhoea, cold sweats, really unwell for a day.
Livestock accounts for about 14.5% of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Meat production also sucks the world dry of copious amounts of fresh water. "The amount of water used for meat production in just 35 hours could provide drinking water for everyone on earth for a year," according to The World Counts. Industrial farming also requires acres upon acres of space. Clearing that land often contributes to deforestation and carbon emissions, making disasters such as forest fires and flooding much more likely.
Jayne Buxton is such a movie star name. Perfect for such a gorgeous lady!
Excellent book!
Thanks for covering so many important issues❤
Congratulations to both, really interesting and informative.
Never once have I craved lettuce or any greens. Even salads, everyone wants the toppings, not the leaves.
@kathleen9456
24 күн бұрын
I actually do crave a salad and mostly the leaves, so it’s hard for me to give it up completely
Why are humans the only living thing on this planet that doesn't know what it should eat. Even the smallest bacteria, protazoe, fungi, and plant doesn't question it. Maybe we should be trying to answer that question.
@ianstuart5660
25 күн бұрын
Definitely. Dr. Berry speaks about it often!
@infiniteinfiniteinfi
25 күн бұрын
Propaganda.
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
Simple...humans have free will and have lost their instinctual knowledge.
I know it makes women feel better that they can say well we're all different, the fact of the matter is, we're the same species and we have a correct diet and a plant based diet is not that. Being able to eat things without getting super sick or dying from it is, different than thriving.
eating an animal based diet is like driving a gas guzzling truck! we are destorying every ecosystem on the planet now- and eating lots of meat is a big part of that. (not to mention the cruelty) domesticated animals like cows, pigs, even farmed fish, etc. are now more numerous that the natural wildlife that form our critical ecosystems we depend upon! we can do fine and adapt over time to a mostly plant based diet.
@joywondering27
15 күн бұрын
But can everyone? Some people will be okay, but as people are saying here after sometime their health declined, and improved after eating meat. Some advocate eating meat once or twice a month. Perhaps it’s the factory farms that need to go and selling meats at fast food places. Hmmmm
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
Wrong
Great interview! Got all my attention!
Excellent thanks very much 😅
@NutritionwithJudy
25 күн бұрын
♥️
Thank you both so much for your work!! I have KZread channel on sustainability and plan to teach the FACT that plant-based is terrible for the environment. I don’t have a lot of time to work on my channel right now so have taken a step back from it but I’m working on it a LOT behind the scenes and will go full force once I retire in about 3 years. I’m sure I’ll post well before that as well but it will not be consistent weekly. We’ve GOT to get the message out and keep talking about it so people will become aware. Also, please look into the benefits of grass-fed ruminants on the ecological health of an ecosystem. It’s wonderful. Just think about it. Before human civilization got so large, we had herds of hooves animals roaming the planet in herds of thousands and millions! Their “farts” did not hurt the environment and neither did their roaming. It is actually beneficial. By comparison you have these massive soy, corn and wheat monocultures using GMOs and glyphosate destroying plant diversity and wildlife in their wake on a MASSIVE SCALE, way more than possible realize. I’m sure that if many of these plant-based people realized how many animals were killed during harvesting of their wheat, corn and soy, they’d think twice about promoting that. I hope Bill Gates gets a clue about this soon. By the way, my degrees are in Marine Biology and Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences.
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
It will be an amazing channel. Having livestock myself and being self sufficient I know how much easier it is to use them for food as opposed to trying to grow cultivated plants to eat. Plants are hard work, especially when Mother Nature isn't playing ball. Growing grass and weeds for our livestock that suit the local soil conditions is no work at all.
I have a friend whose grandson is allergic to dairy, so they feed him pea milk. He’s 2 and it scares me to think what these plant proteins are doing to him. I know every child develops at different rates, but he’s not really talking much. He’s 2 years old.
@orchidmuse
20 күн бұрын
People are adjustable, don't worry. I have a colleague who eats kind of Mediterranean diet (being Italian), and her son can't even smell meat or fish, he won't touch it and he's naturally a vegetarian, but he's a thriving boy who loves football. If issues occur then will see. Not everyone has to be on carnivore to thrive, we choose the diet according to our health issues.
@lynnpoag8173
20 күн бұрын
@@orchidmuse I agree, but my concern is that he’s only 2 and consuming so much pea milk. I worry about his development and that his brain needs a lot of good fats to develop. My husband had gut issues his entire life and now he was diagnosed last year with Parkinson’s Disease.
@orchidmuse
20 күн бұрын
@@lynnpoag8173 Oh that's bad. 😞Stay strong 💫
@commonsense246
19 күн бұрын
@@orchidmuse Don't you mean gullible? The body is very adaptable but the basics of how it works never changes. Long term problems will occur for him. As a two yr old the grandson of OP should be weaned by now anyway. Feed him meat.
This was just awsome! I am so happy to have stumbled on it. ❤❤
Thank you Judy. I always find your interviews and presentations so inspirational, clear and easy to watch/listen to. I am in my hotel and looking forward to hopefully meeting Jayne and Eddie Abbew tomorrow in London at the conference with the Public Health Collaboration that she mentions. There are tickets available for livestream...highly recommend! 👍🙂
Great interview!!!💗💗💗
Excellent info here! Very relevant to my daily health journey. Any advice on studying to be a low carb friendly nutritionist? I have coach / advisor training. Thanks for any info! Love the channel and info shared.
@avaelizabeth4808
25 күн бұрын
Highly recommend checking out health Maria Emmerich . She covers a wider spectrum from carnivore as well as low carb and also has coaching certification program and has helped many reach their health goals.
@NutritionwithJudy
25 күн бұрын
Here’s a good one with trusted practitioners. I haven’t taken their courses specifically but some of the instructors are the best in the low carb space thesmhp.org/
@MichaelBLive
25 күн бұрын
@@NutritionwithJudy Thank you!!!
@Hertz2laugh
25 күн бұрын
@@MichaelBLive Check out Dr. Shawn Baker - he has started up a medical network that specializes in metabolic health and deperscibing medications using low-carb diets (and other things). He could probably point you to good resources since he regularly evaluates medical personnel who apply to work in his network.
A well rounded plant based diet I still the best
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
There is no such thing
Judy, keep dping these interviews! If i could affort your counceling i would take it. Since i can't your newsletter and your interviews are my information geysir
Simply convert all vegetable crops to free-range, grass-fed ruminant animal pastures. 😅
Wow, great conversation! Will be sharing with my plant-based friends when the time seems right 😉
Great interview!!👏👏
Just because someone failed to do the plant based diet the right way, there's no need to trash it. For someone who's been whole food plant based for almost a decade, my only regret that I haven't started it earlier.
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
There is no such thing as a complete plant based diet
@anned6913
15 күн бұрын
@@Jennieadams1979 Why is that ?
@shaynac-rd9iu
3 күн бұрын
You are like 1/100 in 8 billion. Congrats. The rest of us need protein
Thanks Judy for doing this. I've been in Bali for 11 years and have to live in the middle of a vegetarian belief system. It gets incredibly depressing not having people with common sense to talk to. I hope it changes soon.
It's a double whammy for me and probably many others but I am almost used to going against the grain. Not only living and evangelizing to people about the gospel but also telling others about this WOE. It seems as though my the majority of my life I have been met with opposition from the masses but I would not change it for anything. The race is well run and as God being my strength I will endure even if only one life is changed it's worth it.Wishing everyone in the same boat strength and endurance and keep your eye on the prize. It will not be in vain,there are those that will benefit from your help that you offer.
What a great and important interview, Judy. I know some vegans who seem really healthy. Good luck to them. I’ve chosen meat-based that keeps me really healthy. Thank goodness for our ability to choose. Interviews such as this help us choose. 👏
@sportysbusiness
23 күн бұрын
I have a few friends who are vegan. ALL of them have either serious arthritis, skin issues, anxiety and sleep issues or the combo!
@carmenmiller5701
19 күн бұрын
I have a friend who has been vegetarian for 54 years and vegan the past 2 years. He claims to be very healthy at 71 but is having an endoscopy this coming week because of his acid reflux issues! He also has very bad memory retention and suffers from depression. But he believes that being vegan is definitely the healthiest way to eat. I’m mostly carnivore/ketovore occasionally have a salad or small amount of broccoli or cauliflower and at 78 I’m doing very well.
This is quickly becoming one of my favorite podcasts! Listening to this reminded me that one of my vegan friends warned me that you shouldn't be vegan for health. She and her family eventually switched away from vegan due to their health issues.
How about daily requirements for potassium and magnesium? Is it based on vegan experts?
I saw the most health improvements from simply eliminating the processed foods and seed oils even though I was still eating some carbs from potatoes. About 80% carnavore by default. Carbs can offset the negative impact of stored linoleic acid in your fat reserves during its half-Life. The lesser of 2 evils.
Plant-based does not necessarily mean vegan or vegetarian. It can also mean eating primarily plant foods but on occasion including some meat.
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
Most of humanity has been essentially plant based for thousands of years.
@Jennieadams1979
23 күн бұрын
@@jgfergusyou mean meat based
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
@@Jennieadams1979 no...plant based. The development of agriculture, thousands of years ago allowed humans to give up their hunter gatherer lifestyle and settle in one location and build communities and eventually large towns and cities that relied mainly on growing grains, vegetables, beans, tubers, etc. Large scale agriculture was the only means to feed a growing population. It got to the point where a family was fortunate if they had one cow for milk and a few chickens. Meat was the food of the rich primarily. If you examine grocery stores today, 95% of the food (garbage mainly) is made of plants (grains, beans, veg, and fruit). The trade off that humanity experienced in exchange for our population explosion due to agriculture, was that our health began it's decline to where we are today...a sickly, overweight, over stimulated, nutritionally starved species. Many books have been written on this subject.
@commonsense246
19 күн бұрын
@@jgfergus Yep, that's where it all went wrong. Mankind got lazy anad stopped hunting, easier to just water plants and with Lots and Lots of seasonings, made them edible.
QUESTION How does someone such as myself find out or confirm that an article or news story is funded by an organization? You mentioned the Guardian and the animal rights agency funding their article. How do I find that information?
Carnivore changed my life.
The farmers in Canada are also starting to revolt and I'm happy about it.
Please could you share the ultimate book list for meat based and regenerative healing 🤗
Plant based is just another marketing tool along with low fat etc. If it's plant-based I don't eat it.
Raising and slaughtering livestock is a messy business. In order to churn out enough meat to keep up with demand, meat producers slaughter billions of animals every year. Much of this happens in factory farming situations, where scores of animals are crowded into compact spaces to minimize costs and maximize output. Data from the Sentience Institute estimates that 99% of all farmed animals in the U.S. are currently raised this way.
Whenever you have people who are convinced beyond debate on plants. What kind of supplements do we need to give them.
Cattle eating grass vs grain changes gas output dramatically.
@Jennieadams1979
23 күн бұрын
Not really
They both said you both have to pick the right facts. Right facts for what? To suit your own beliefs, purpose?
@itzakpoelzig330
25 күн бұрын
I think they're making the point that many so-called "facts" these days are actually manufactured and paid for by industry, to prop up that industry's profit base. Of course, that's been true for centuries if not millenia. It's always been a buyer-beware kind of system we live in.
@AnneMB955
24 күн бұрын
Who’s ‘they’?
@RBzee112
24 күн бұрын
The vegetarian movement started as a religious belief. When that didn't work, they switched to health, then environmental.
The ultimate cancel culture. I wish people would develop some more critical thinking. I am sure that my ancestors in Europe at some point survived strictly on meat, as hunters and gatherers.
If you read the studies done on the seventh day adventists it is very clear they live longer in better health. As an RN for 37 years most of my patients were sick because of what they ate, drank ( alcohol) and smoked. They were most definitely not on a plant based diet. They ate the standard American diet. I honestly don’t see anyone pushing the plant based diet in our area. I see a lot of Keto diets.
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
The standard American diet IS plant based!
With great respect BUT 44:00 and following regarding ‘animals & even young children know what to eat (instinctively)’ is absolutely incorrect as all 99% of mammals (absolutely including humans) LEARN WHAT TO EAT FROM THEIR MOTHERS. Not only do young mammals learn what to eat & drink from their mothers during their early postnatal association with their mothers, but nutrients in their mothers milk ‘primes’ them to ‘know’ what to eat. Indeed, studies show that the mother’s diet during pregnancy also establishes physiologically the manner in which the new individual will metabolise food.
@AnneMB955
24 күн бұрын
Proof?
@RBzee112
24 күн бұрын
What they're saying is when animals (and people) have a deficiency, they know it instinctively. We can definitely tell when something is 'missing' and we keep eating to meet that need.
@sportysbusiness
23 күн бұрын
Not true, my mother desperately tried to teach me to eat brussel sprouts... Joking aside, children are genetically programmed to crave sugar and reject anything bitter. They are genetically programmed to gnaw on a meaty bone and not want a plate of leafy greens. Historically, our sugar fix was from local fruit or honey a few weeks a year, this is now our achilles heel, we now have access to sugar 24/7 and it's a disaster. It's one of the reasons people love a fruitarian diet, they are actually sugar addicts.
@Mwilke3789
22 күн бұрын
I believe this too. My children love to eat exactly what I ate during my pregnancy with them. I feel endless guilt because my oldest only wants dairy and carbs (creamy pasta and cheese was basically all I ate) he has so many health issues. My middle child I ate non starchy veggies and lean proteins limited carbs. She also loves these foods but has joint issues Im guessing from the high quantity of high oxylate foods. My last I was so nutrient deficient I craved red meat. I craved RAW red meat lol I ate very low carb and almost exclusively meat. He's my steak baby and loves steak and all animal products.
They think it's ok to eat insects because they dont find them cute. Period. It's sentimental, not logical. -Jill
I think a lot of Hindus and Buddhists are vegetarian. India has the most Hindus at around 1 billion…. So the number of vegetarian are probably 500 million in India alone. More like 10% of world pop is vegetarian and 2% vegan
Everything boils down to one thing in the end. MONEY 💰💰$$$€€€£££.
Get ruminate animals back on the land to improve the soil and feed us health giving meat.
I'm down with OPP yeah you know me
Plant-based works for many people I know. Meat work for others as well. So I’m in the middle of it all. Eat plants and steaks without processed, gmo, refined stuff. I’m good. I feel great!
@jayhoggard92
25 күн бұрын
Good for you. I would encourage you to give carnivore a try for 90. You may realize you can feel even better. That was my experience. I'm now 2 yrs carnivore and will never go back to plants.
@Hertz2laugh
25 күн бұрын
@@jayhoggard92Same here. Went from horrible, standard diet to mixed, whole-food diet, and finally to carnivore. I felt better at each stage. Nothing feels as good as when I cut out everything except animal products.
@tallcedars2310
25 күн бұрын
Plant based does work for many people, but children are suffering today and that is very telling. The thing with plants is they are a low dose poison that gradually robs the body of nutrients to the point we start to feel unwell and start going to doctors. Suffering can take decades to rear it's ugly head, and like many old folks, they found no relief over decades, until trying carnivore, or ketovore. What I recommend is that if one eats plants and after some time doesn't feel well, keep the carnivore diet in mind and eat only meat.
@tallcedars2310
25 күн бұрын
@@jayhoggard92 Exactly, we don't know how good it feels to feed our bodies the nutrients it needs to function optimally.💪
@judyjohnson9610
24 күн бұрын
I am so glad to see this. I find that almost all comments in these presentations are at one end of the spectrum or the other. I remain fully middle ground.
Why not get Dr. John McDougall on your show? Dr. Greger, Dr. Campbell or Dr. Neal Bernard. There are hundreds of whole food, plant based doctors who have decades of science standing behind them. I won't hold my breath though.
@rubenperales3173
14 күн бұрын
I don't think she will even have carnivore Dr Paul Saladino on her show because he got sick on the carnivore diet and had to stop following it.
Please watch some of Plant Chompers videos and check out the research he does. Just another point of view
I can understand recommending adding some meat to a plant-based diet to add some vitamin B12 but it makes no sense to me to remove 4 or 5 food groups and replace them with just one food group, meat. That will create more nutrient deficiencies, a very restrictive and non-sustainable diet for most people.
@commonsense246
19 күн бұрын
You have just revealed your lack of nutritional knowledge. Your paradigm of "food groups" is propaganda, nothing more. There is enough proven nutrients in meat for any human. Get educated. Open your mind. Listen to Drs. Berry, Chaffee and Norton. Then make up your mind and good luck to you.
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
There are all kinds of meat. Fish, shellfish, chicken, turkey, pheasant, quail, duck, beef, lamb, pork, goat, bison, venison, the list goes on and depends on where in the world you are, then there are dairy products and eggs. You'd have to be pretty restrictive to suffer from any sort of nutritional deficiency. Humans are carnivores at heart considering we are unable to utilise cellulose which is absolutely essential for herbivores, then there's our stomach acid pH which is more akin to carrion eaters than omnivores. Plants are optional, meat is not.
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
False
Nutritional yeast is loaded with B12, eating sentient beings when there are alternatives baffles me!
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
😂😂😂
I see that our education system is what’s seriously flawed! Focus on the fundamentals of LIFE NOT SUPPRESSION…
When I cook for others and prepare veggies (which I don’t eat) I tell them I cooked plants for them. 😂😂😂. This makes them think a little. If you call them plants they don’t sound so healthy.
What drives me mad is that the pro meat brigade completely ignores the pesticides herbicides, run off of chemicals and the huge amount of land used to grow crops to fatten their meat.
Your comment about Bill Gates owning most of our farm land really rattled me. Where did you hear/read that? I did a search, and came up with something very different. Thank you
Hi Judy! I have to add some corrections. I’m Seventh- Day Adventist. But I do eat mostly meat-based after listening to you and many others in a carnivore space. SDA’s do not believe you HAVE to be plant-based to get to heaven. As a SDA I will admit of our flaws as a faith based group. I will admit that they were trying to sell a product -(Kellogg’s) that’s why they pushed the breakfast is the most important meal of the day in order to do so. But our health message is based on a health acronym called New Start: The Eight Laws of Health is a NEW START! “Pure air, sunlight, abstemiousness, rest, exercise, proper diet, the use of water, trust in divine power (God). This is what Adventist believe. Are there Adventist vegetarians and vegans yes and they also do eat a lot of “Veggie meats” that are terribly high in sodium and Gluten and do encourage people to lean more towards a vegetarian lifestyle it is a blind leading the blind. Many Adventist who do eat meat like myself we follow the “clean vs unclean meats kind of like Kosher meats. But I just had to say we don’t say you’ll go to hell if you don’t eat vegetarian and vegan. I say this as someone who is still Adventist I’m actually the daughter of a pastor. I do think more people do need to look at health truly for themselves and learn based on facts and not be afraid to go against the grain. Pun intended 😉
3:24 ......this is do dangerous, everyone will be deficient and sick etc.
@joywondering27
15 күн бұрын
I’ve grown suspicious but I think they want us sick. Sick people are customers for you know who and hellcare systems
THE BACKGROUND LOOKS LIKE STEPHEN GARDNER's WITH A FEW ITEMS CHANGED...
In 22 years studying the human body on a high level i had all kinds of patients. Carnivore keto plant based vegan etc. i have never seen that level of sick like the carnivore keto etc. The ones that stayed eating that way 0% got better and alot of them are gone. The ones who went plant based about 95% got well. Those are the stats i dint make them up. And knowing what i know about the body that seems about right. Its your choice. This is not a game
@tchicomn
12 күн бұрын
What a load of ......
Thank you for this thought worthy interview. However, I want to point out that everything you are saying about plant-based studies, financing, motivations, and claims apply equally to the meat, poultry, and dairy industries. Furthermore, people on a strictly plant-based diet, as well as on a mixed food diet, can live a healthy life, depending on their overall lifestyle and healthy food choices. I agree that those of us who choose a plant-based lifestyle may dominantly be concerned about animal welfare, sustainability, and environmental factors, but that is not the point I am trying to make here. It would be helpful if you had a small, well-informed panel to discuss the research and who is funding it. Otherwise, we are still being swayed to believe one narrative. Nevertheless, this information is food for thought.
@calista1280
20 күн бұрын
All you have to do is eliminate carbs, sugars and most plants (lectins) to discover the JOY OF FEELING GREAT AGAIN!!! It doesn't take very long either. I am almost completely pain-free and full of energy again ✨️ after decades of chronic pain and fatigue from Fibromyalgia and spinal damage from an accident. As a long time vegetarian I experienced anemia and B12 deficiency...
@commonsense246
19 күн бұрын
You believe whatever, doesn't make it viable. My body and the progress I've made on Meat based with the occasional onion/tomato maybe a berry or two here and there, tells me all I need to know. Plants are fiber, so is wood, I don't eat it. I know that I know that I know. A child may believe their parent when they say that fire can burn you, but until it does, they do not KNOW it does. They learn immediately if they experience it. Same with food. I trust my intelligence and my body to tell me all I need to know. I choose to eat the food the original humans ate thousands of years before they learned they could raise plants to replace the meat they ate that kept them the most successful species on the planet. I'd rather be King of the jungle than a cow, they have the many stomachs to process grass, I don't.
@commonsense246
19 күн бұрын
Yes, but one is wrong the other right!
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
I think you need to dig a little deeper into how much influence the likes of Kelloggs and Seventh Day Aventists have had where food is concerned to understand the depths of the deception. The meat industry doesn't have as much influence as you appear to believe.
i thought eddy has gone carnivore. last time i saw his vid, he mentioned of going carnivore.
Eliminating meat? What the hell is wrong with people? All people need to do is open their eyes to see that the recommendations of eating so many carbs doesn’t work! We’ve never been fatter and sicker in the U.S. and in many other countries, as well. Even if the people aren’t fat, they’re often very sick. Southern Asia is a good example of this. Type 2 is rampant.
@Barbara-oe7yh
13 күн бұрын
Because they eat junk foods,not plant based, people forget to make food at home and they only eat fatty foods and highly processed foods that make them sick
I personally believe it too late and we will not be able to reverse the current attack on meat. Sadly it’s going to get worse.
@NutritionwithJudy
25 күн бұрын
Whatever we believe, is true. I refuse to believe that and will advocate until I can’t. I have two young boys that I have to say later if I tried to make this world a better place. We may not win but we still need to try. And even still, look how many are being helped by carnivore. The movement is growing and that is enough for me to serve and share. Lastly I highly recommend reading this: www.thestarfishchange.org/starfish-tale If we can help even one more starfish, it is worth the fight. ♥️
@candacekerr4139
25 күн бұрын
WELL SAID!
@Rays-ev7bg
25 күн бұрын
Maybe. No one - NO ONE knows what the future holds for humanity on this Earth. But with this attitude the bumblebee wouldn't fly and would have probably gone extinct long ago.
@itzakpoelzig330
25 күн бұрын
As Judy points out around the 4:00 mark, the vegans and vegetarians are HUGELY outnumbered. 2% of people are (temporary) vegans, and 5% are vegetarian. If we, the 98-95% can't figure out how to protect our rights from that tiny (and anemic) cohort, then it could only be for lack of trying. Vote with your dollars. If beef is where the money is, then money-hungry people will start to produce beef. We had beef barons in the 1800s, and we can have them again if that's what the market demands.
@infiniteinfiniteinfi
25 күн бұрын
The sky is the limit!
Great interview! I have been researching on nutrition and making changes to my diet for some years now, mainly to treat diverse health conditions, currently using a ketogenic diet that includes mainly diverse meats, eggs, some vegetables and almost no fruit. Leaving apart all health-related arguments on what the best diet for the human species is, what I can´t come to terms with is the moral aspect of the animal-based, especially the carnivore, diets. We have evolved to be an increasingly conscious species, guided by quite a constant set of moral values, that mostly condemns violence in all its forms. Most of us are moved by animal abuse, and we have increasingly developed emotional ties with animals. Therefore, it sounds like an evolutionary contradiction that the “proper” diet for humans is one that depends on us going against those moral tendencies, and that requires the killing of sentient beings (more or less violent depending on the way of production, but always violent), most especially in the case of mammals. This is something I struggle with, and I believe is the only real argument in favor of a plant-based (vegan/vegetarian) diet.
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
Do some research into the number of animals killed to grow plants commercially (many cute, fluffy ones too). You will be utterly horrified. That's where the real animal abuse is. Not in good, pasture based livestock farming.
The noise isn't just from vegans and vegetarians. The Blue Zones where people live the longest are mostly plant based. As more and more research studies show the benefits of plant based diets healthcare professionals are recommending Mediterranean diets and Dash diets which are also plant based but easier to follow.
@dianatrans1804
21 күн бұрын
Excellent point! Believe me, I enjoyed eating meats and their products back when I did so, but since I have not consumed any of this for about a year now, I couldn’t imagine returning to that way of eating. There’s just no need for it, (secondhand protein that an animal has gotten from eating plants). I will just eat the plants myself. And when I think about the abuse that our precious animals, that God gave us as a gift to enjoy and treat with love and kindness. It makes me sick and sad to consume their DNA in such an abusive manner, as humans are doing today. This is not at all what God had intended for humankind. And yet I’m not saying it’s 100% wrong to consume animals and their products or God would’ve never allowed it to begin with. I just know the way it’s being done today is 100% wrong. And if we were back to a perfect state of God’s original purpose for the earth, which will be accomplished very soon. We will most likely go back to enjoying the earth and having our precious animals have NO fear us. Psalms 37
@lifechoices7869
21 күн бұрын
@@dianatrans1804have you ever asked why God himself wanted the fatty parts for himself and the priests in the temple sacrifice?
@MsRoustine
21 күн бұрын
Have you been to a mediteraean country? I live there. My vegetarian friends who visited could not find a non red meat restaurant. Red meat is very much in the centre, but the plant based academics announced that it was not a meat, butter and cream diet.
@crystalprovance3423
19 күн бұрын
Actually they are not plant based.
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
The Blue Zones have been thoroughly debunked many times over by the scientific community. Even if they eat mostly plant based foods they are eating a lot of animals fats. It's animal fats that contribute the most calories to their diet and that's why they are healthy. It certainly isn't the plants.
U can get all your needed nutrients from a vegetarian diet , so I've heard , 💝🚴♀️
@proudchristian77
7 күн бұрын
I've been on mine for like about 11 yrs thereabouts, but I eat once a day & it's all I'm hungry for, so mine is & has been if I can eat enough, but I exercise, 💝🚴♀️
How do you deal with the constipation issues on a carnivore diet which contains no fiber? Fiber also feeds the healthy gut bacteria which then produce health benefits. This is a big issue that was not discussed.
@tchicomn
25 күн бұрын
Because everything you just said is complete BS
@floatingmoon5778
25 күн бұрын
There isn’t a constipation issue. For some people, fiber CAUSES constipation… this is why GI doctors often recommend a very low or no fiber diet for those who have IBS. Your information is very lopsided.
@australiainfelix7307
25 күн бұрын
I'm carnivore and don't suffer from constipation. It's not the issue you think it is.
@lf7065
25 күн бұрын
I had some constipation initially, but it resolved in a couple of weeks of strict carnivore with lots of fat, like butter and fatty meats. Eat more fat, it helps so much during transition. The gut bugs adjust. 🙂
@LyndaHill
25 күн бұрын
I've been on carnivore for four years. I never get constipation. I'm also no longer depressed. And all my IBS disappeared.
I understand the "vegan honeymoon", but can anyone truly "thrive" on a vegan diet?
@angelamalejczuk8456
17 күн бұрын
For me, yes. Vegan since 2017. Low thyroid (Hashimoto's) reversed. Raynaud's reversed. Allergies gone. Runny nose gone. Better mobility (less stiff), weight control. I always had low iron, that's gone now too. Now I eat no junk food, only whole unprocessed plant foods. Lots and lots of dark leafy greens. Flax for plant based omega 3. No oil. I have never felt better. It is not always easy because I have to eat out of my own kitchen, but it has changed my life for the better. I would never go back. When I was eating meat and eggs and cheese it was local and organic and I was getting sicker and sicker. I do what works.
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
No
@Jennieadams1979
15 күн бұрын
angelamalejczuk8456 I'm suspicious
107 year Oldest Tattoo Artist's 6 Secrets of Longevity Youth Apo Whang Od May 15, 2023 #longevity #health #diet Apo Whang Od, born in 1917, is 107 years old! She is the World's Oldest Tattooist and Vogue's Oldest Cover Model ever in the World! Enter into the enchanting world of the timeless Apo Whang Ode! At an astonishing 106 years old, in the year 2023, she has just made history by gracing the cover of Vogue - the oldest person to ever do so! Her artistic talents have mesmerized countless people from all corners of the globe, as she continues to welcome visitors with her warm smile and unwavering passion. Her extraordinary life story is a true inspiration to us all. But the question remains - what are the secrets to her unparalleled energy and longevity? Get ready to unveil the Top 6 ways she stays vibrant and healthy, as we explore the mystical world of Apo Whang Ode! kzread.info/dash/bejne/ma6E0ZSIYpbZeLQ.html
ahah jayne is clueless about the vitamin A con... and judy nods going along with it, don't tell garrett hey ... ;)
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
You are the one that is clueless. Plants have no vitamin A. They have beta carotene which is not the same. Get your facts straight before displaying your ignorance.
@Jennieadams1979
23 күн бұрын
Enlighten us
95% of the world is not plant based? What? I think you misspoke. Most of the world IS plant based. All the foods people eat and drink come from plants! Only a small amount of people are meat based, namely those who eat the carnivore way. 🙂
@LyndaHill
25 күн бұрын
I think you missed the point. They mean exclusively plant based.
@lf7065
25 күн бұрын
@@LyndaHill That'd be vegan.
@LyndaHill
24 күн бұрын
@@lf7065 Yep. Vegetarian or vegan. One just has to think, really.
@AnneMB955
24 күн бұрын
88 million Vegans in the world. 3/4 are females in India. In UK, 2.5 million (4.7%) are Vegan. The US, 13.4 million. 1-2% of the world is Vegan.
@sportysbusiness
23 күн бұрын
@@lf7065 I think you need to look up what 'plant based' means. It means eating only plants. Vegan is an ethical choice to eat only plants, so all vegans are plant based, but not all plant based eaters are vegan.
Been vegetarian largely vegan for 45 years. Always avoided the refined ultra processed food industry suggestions for the most part I’m 63 now I have no diseases and my blood work is remarkably good. A1c 5.4 The plant based foods are healing in many ways. But so many vegetarians year in crazy ways ! Studies show repeatedly one after the next that a plant based artery can revert arteriosclerosis. The big cohort studies of Adventists have shown that people on a vegetarian diet are more protected against cancer and live longer. I respect the criticism but this is just talk. Studies actually are not discussed This presentation is devoid of science and of heart data. You should conduct studies first and show the plant based is not protective before you come up with your ideas and suppositions. Just talk will lead you nowhere. I enjoy most of the presentations by this nutriiionist. This one left me baffled. And I am a professor and read the literature assiduously. I’ve also been a health educator and naturopath for decades. I’ve seen the power of adequate nutrition and amazing recoveries. The narrative that fills this presentation is incomprehensible to me and lamentably biased
@GordonPavilion
23 күн бұрын
Agree
@jgfergus
23 күн бұрын
The only comparison study that would be valid is comparing long term 100% plant based eater to 100% meat eaters. Not the typical misleading studies that compare vegans to eaters of the standard American diet who eat some meat but lots of processed garbage. And as you think yourself so intelligent, you obviously know that a vegan diet is deficient in many important nutrients. But you may not grasp these things as 45 years of veganism has resulted in inferior brain development. And I bet you are a skinny frail elderly man with little muscle mass. But you eat what you want, just don't dictate to me what I should be eating.
@pamelakrumvieda3153
23 күн бұрын
Interestingly she just mentioned studies that were done but blocked from publishing for decades because they didn't support the plant based Ansel Keys mantra. There is a giant problem with science not having integrity when funded by corporations and governments with an agenda. We like to think our science in uncorruptible, but that's just not the case.
@lifechoices7869
21 күн бұрын
It appears that you might be biased as well
@wiltonpt1
21 күн бұрын
@@lifechoices7869 bias has to do with preferences perceptions and opinions. Facts trumps all that. You cannot deny facts. But you cannot turn a blind eye to all the research demonstrating over and over what happens when people change to plant based diets both prospective and retrospective studies. I cannot deny what I have seen in my patients either. Reality is what it is not what we fancy it to be. This talk was just talk it provided no substantiation from the scientific literature. It was the worst demonstration I’ve seen in a long time of trying to raise s vacuous argument.
What expertise does this woman have on food ? Zero. This is the pendulum swinging the other way to scare folks. Don’t be fooled by such interviews people. She isn’t qualified to give any knowledge on it.
@sportysbusiness
23 күн бұрын
Who's more qualified? A doctor taught a few hours of propaganda at medical school, or a writer who researched studies and conducted interviews with experts for years in order to write a book?
@Jennieadams1979
23 күн бұрын
@sportysbusiness well said
@eslom1489
21 күн бұрын
I completely agree! As a nurse, all the patients I see with high blood pressure, diabetes, and high cholesterol are meat eaters. So many people have 2 to 3 of these conditions. Now, I see lots of ulcerative colitis and Crohns. Be smart folks. You need fruits and veggies, and perhaps a little meat. I do eat seafood about 2 days a week for the past 35 years. I feel great with zero illness. DON'T EAT LOTS OF MEAT as the moderator ended with.
@jg5755
19 күн бұрын
@@eslom1489 You are seeing a lot of sick people. That's your job. But they don't represent what is normal. They are sick. Those diseases are metabolic diseases. I cured the horrendous perimenopausal symptoms I was experiencing by avoiding plant foods and greatly increasing my intake of animal fats. I was in a bad state but am now back to my normal self. Grains are the worst for my hormones. Was I just supposed to suffer? I'm not the only woman to discover this either.