I always assumed the spiritcaller snails were just regular snake-snails that ate a lot of glovewort, and could summon whatever spirits of bodies the glovewort grew on

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

I reached that same conclusion in a different video! Great minds think alike

@tyhussein

8 ай бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmaskwhich video? Would love to watch!

"Tanith is guarded by Gug, who is in deep pain." I wasn't expecting a max0r reference out of nowhere, that made me laugh.

@cheatcode436

Жыл бұрын

“Aren’t we all?”

The spirit caller snails also summon wolves and samurai. It could be that they're just mimicking something they've seen. The wolves that naturally once inhabited the mountaintops, the blood mad samurai from the Land of Reeds, and the godskin apostles, and perhaps their queen, whose regalia still reside in the cave.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

That's the best alternative explanation for the snail I've come across! Though I have my own alternative theory for why the Inaba are there involving the Shinto Land of Reeds.

@Xandros999

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask Thanks. To be fair I don't remember much about the Inaba other than they're somehow associated with Okina, so when I bunch them together as blood-mad I'm frankly just memeing. I kind of suspected the snails were more strongly associated with Godskins because they're all basically serpentine albinos. Maybe that's just Fromsoft muddying the waters on purpose as they like to do.

I have a whole conspiracy that attempts to bring much of this together and it starts with an item called “The Beast Eye” which we receive from Gurranq, aka Maliketh the Black Blade. I believe this eye belonged to the Gloam Eyed Queen aka Marika the Eternal. The short version is that judging from Iji and Ranni’s dialogue, we know that when each Empyrean are chosen by their Two Fingers, they are given a shadow that will turn into a horrid curse should they ever betray the Greater Will. How do they know this? They must’ve seen it happen. The only other recorded Empyrean with a shadow in history is Marika and when she began to plot against the Greater Will(Enia mentioning her trespass), I believe Maliketh activated his kill switch and used Destined Death against her and explaining her fate when we finally meet her. It would also explain why her corpse is missing her left eye, why the eye has a claw mark, and is surrounded by Marika’s stony flesh. Another question I asked myself is just how Maliketh was able to possess or lock away the Rune of Death if he’s just a shadowbound and not a demigod? The Rune of Death had to have a host originally and I believe Maliketh sealed that host in his Black Blade, Marika herself or maybe Melina? This eye could very well have been passed down to some of her children as well, particularly the Empyreans. The Three Sisters: -Melina(Smoldering Butterfly) - she reveals to have the same eye, on the same side of her face as Marika would have in the lord of frenzy ending. Her previously Golden Eye loses its color because the Golden Order is no more and Grace is gone. Also interesting to note is that her Blade of Calling has the same shotel like design similar to the Godskin Peeler. -Malenia(Aeonion Butterfly)- obviously this is pure speculation but I think the rot that covers her eyes was an intentional creative decision to hide this very secret. -Miquella(Nascent Butterfly) - I’ll get to that.. -Ranni? - It’s hard to tie Ranni with being a daughter to Marika but her spirit form keeps the same eye closed as Melina. I believe Ranni’s pupil color that she never opens is Gloam and that’s basing it from Melina. I believe they keep them shut to hide their identities as Empyreans. So how does it all connect? This is where my conspiracy really starts. Judging from Turtle Pope’s dialogue, we know that Radagon left Rennala to become second Elden Lord after his union with Queen Marika but before he left, he bequeathed the Amber Egg that she is found cradling when we meet her in-game. Miriel claims she was left heartbroken because of his departure, but what if there is more to the story? What if instead of heartbroken, she’s actually bewitched? Let’s look at some details on the Amber egg: We are given dialogue from Gideon that the egg contains a Great Rune, and further progression into the game reveals it to be the The Rune of the Unborn. The rune is not revealed to be associated with any god in particular, much like the Rune of Death, but there are some interesting implications on it. Mohgs Great rune reads - “Mohg and Morgott are twin brothers, and their Great Runes are naturally similar.” Judging from that item description, the Rune with the most similarity to it is Malenia’s, who was Miquella’s twin. If this egg does contain the Great Rune of Miquella, possibly his soul too, then an explanation for the shape of the rune could be his curse - the “eternal childhood” - and possibly why the juveniles are imperfected and stuck as children. This brings me to my theory. Rennala is overly attached to it, calling it her little “culver”. We know from the Bewitching Branch that Miquella had the ability to compel love and affection and if we look close, we can see traces of it inside the egg, particularly the white buds before they hatch. We know anything that’s mixed with the blood or essence of Miquella tends to stay in a premature “infant” form, hence the Haligtree being stuck as a baby version of the Erdtree and now the buds inside the egg. If Rennala encountered the moon on the mountaintops and used it to “bewitch” the academy, what prevented her from becoming bewitched herself? Another thing to point out is the empty bird cages found all over the Raya Academy. I always wondered what the purpose of these were but then it dawned on me, there is an item in the game called “The Slumbering Egg” and it’s a crafting material needed to create items in the game that alleviate sleep. This makes me think the members of the Academy were trying to awaken Rennala from her “deep slumber” as Ranni says and at the same time, explain why the Knights of the Cuckoo marched against the Carian manor since they must’ve found out what Ranni is doing. So why would Ranni keep Rennala in her current state and attempt to possibly reincarnate Miquella? One theory is it’s because Miquella was in fact Ranni’s secret mentor, the Snowy Crone, and Torrent is the key to prove it, specifically his Whistle. The spectral steed whistle is made of a delicate “goldwork”, not just gold, mirroring the Item Description on the Unalloyed Needle. I didn’t think much of it at first but after seeing the flame of frenzy ending, I’ve speculated that the material is Unalloyed Gold. This is backed by the fact that the whistle is still intact after the flame of frenzy is unleashed. Gold only reacts to heat by melting and the fact that it’s burning in the ending is bizarre and means it could be rejecting the flame. We know that Miquella’s needle is made from the same stock and has the properties to ward away the effects of the flame of frenzy and rot, which both originate from outer gods. Torrent is also partial to the Frozen Raisins which are made exclusively from the Mountaintops with his mane being pale blonde like Miquella’s but that could just be a coincidence since Radahn’s horse has red hair. Or if you really want to go unhinged, Ranni may in fact be Miquella reincarnated. Miquella is thought to have an alter ego named St.Trina who’s gender is open to interpretation(The double helix can be seen in Miquella’s needle which depicts the symbol for mercury(Roman God), who represents intersex people). In fact, the item description in the Sword of St. Trina states that he could’ve been a boy or girl. St. Trina is heavily tied to sleep and it can’t be a coincidence that Ranni enters a deep slumber at the same time as Rogier after you get close to retrieving her curse mark. During her first appearance in the Church of Elleh, the merchant and the donkey are also both asleep and the fog that covers the area can be seen on the Trina Lily and envelops all of Liurnia. Also, the juveniles in Rennala’s fight sing about sleep and they mention “mother’s umbra” which refers to the shadow of the moon cast by an eclipse aka the Dark Moon. Also St. Trina’s torch portrays the figure with one eye (Ranni always keeps one eye open). Something interesting about Blaidd is that his breastplate portrays two twins with a tree between, possibly being Miquella, Malenia and the Haligtree, and the double helix from Miquella’s needle can be seen in his Royal Greatsword. Blaidd could very well solve the mystery of their Shadow since they were born at the same time, being twins. His breastplate also tells us he always hated the cold but it never snows in Liurnia? I think the fact that Ranni discarded her flesh is the reason Blaidd has been able to help Ranni wage war against the Greater Will, right up to the point where Ranni murders her Two Fingers, going mad at the end of the questline because Ranni(Miquella) is in our pocket as a miniature doll. Speaking of Unalloyed Gold, the Mask of Confidence in particular could hint towards this secret. The gold threads could be unalloyed to hide Miquella’s(Ranni) secret from the Greater Will. This would also explain Malenia’s confrontation with Radahn. In her ending, She embraces Marika(her true mother) and vows to finish what they started which is to not be influenced by the Greater Will/Outer Gods anymore before creating a massive waygate into the Dark Moon(also explains why all the way gates smaller than our tarnished, since they were created by Miquella, a child). Finally, Ranni does sound like a child and she looks exactly like her doll which I believe is fashioned after Miquella. If you look at the statues of Miquella, he’s always depicted with his head much larger than his body which is a trait babies have, and explaining why the “Greathood” and the Snowy Crone Hat is meant for someone with a larger head which is also a recurring theme with the Glinstone Crowns. Also, It only snows inside of Miquella’s husk in all of the Haligtree, further associating Miquella with the cold. I know there’s Miquella’s “body” in Mohg’s palace but I believe the it’s nothing but a husk since we don’t get a Great Rune. It’s likely he bewitched Mohg, Rennala, Seluvis, Gideon, Malenia etc. Even the player(why else would our character give her a wedding ring that clearly states “don’t give this to me”). “Oh? A dogged fellow aren’t we? Or is it thy habit to merely talk to dolls?” (Thank you for your time if you read all of this, and sorry but it was the only way to explain the snail since they’re also found in Miquella’s Haligtree and he’s eluded to be a spirit summoner from the bell we recieve from Ranni.)

@alexgeerts6404

Жыл бұрын

Woooooow this is great one of the first theory/ideas I’ve seen that take character motivations into play.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for sharing and writing this all up! It's definitely one of the more creative theories I've come across and it focuses on details a lot of lore hunters overlook (I never noticed all the empty bird cages at the Academy or the fact that the Masks of Confidence have golden thread!) I especially love any theory/unhinged speculation about the Amber Egg, which is one of the most bewitching items in the game, both in-game and for lore hunters. One theory I came across (first from T-L-G-T-W) that could dovetail quite nicely with what you wrote above is the idea that Ranni was born from the Amber Egg and raised by Rennala as a form of brood parasitism.

@inserisciunnome

Жыл бұрын

My lord, that was quite the Read. Every time i feel like i figured something out about the lore, i find a comment like this that trows me COMPLETELY Off balance. Impressive Theory nonetheless!

@HavocHounds1988

Жыл бұрын

The Blade of Calling is more similar to the Black Knife that the Black Knife Assassins use. Melina even uses their moveset. Even the Ash of War on the weapon is pretty much a direct copy of the Black Knife, just the Blade of Calling uses a holy projectile instead of Destined Death. The Haligtree I believe is not fully formed because Miquella was pulled from it before he was ready. He was using his own essence to grow the tree, and to also grow himself into a true God. I believe the bird cages were for cuckoos. Marika is a sort of mother to Ranni because Radagon is Marika.

@arkbg22

Жыл бұрын

TL;DR

The code might be calling them Fathers in the religious sense, as a synonym to apostle

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Good point!

@lilmusky2772

11 ай бұрын

Has anyone bothered to check whether it's an ambiguity originating from japenese to english translation

Now that I think about it, both the apostles and nobles do have some kind of slug like features, both in looks and abilities. The apostle can stretch, and the noble has snakelike features, and those two bulging yellow eyes on his hood just seem so... Snaily. Also, he looks like he has a shell with all the fat he carries around. This theory kinda makes sense, perhaps in a more thematic rather than lore way, but maybe the dlc will give us more snail stuff

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Great points! Plus, all of Rennala's juvenile scholars do move like slugs...

Also, thank you for putting forth a new idea for the GEQ! I've always thought Melina was a bit too on the nose of a theory. I like the Spirit Caller snail idea for her, and it makes a lot of sense. My out there theory, however, is that its actually St Trina >:3

@DeoSiege

Жыл бұрын

I think Saint Trina Melania brother can't spell his name lol

I think it is father as you would call a priest "father", the Godskin look like they wear religious regalia

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Good point! Of course, since George R.R. Martin was involved, it could always be both

Imo it’s still most likely (to me at least) that Melina was a child between Radagon and Marika. Children always seem to come in sets of three. Between Godfrey and Marika we have Godwyn, Morgott, and Mohg. Between Radagon and Rennala we have Ranni, Rykard, and Radahn. And between Marika and Radagon we have Melina, Malenia, and Miquella. A trio per relationship. Melina rebelled against the Erdtree as the gloam-eyed queen and was killed for it (at least her body was). Her gloam eye is the only gloam eye she has left, because the other is the quivering beast eye taken by maliketh. In fact I think her body was turned into the Godslayer Greatsword, which is pretty close to where Maliketh is in Caelid, who holds her eye. Im sure there are plenty of holes I can’t think of but to me it seems almost guaranteed that Melina is or was a gloam eyed queen

When in doubt, always listen to the snail in your ear, for it knows the way.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Praise the Snail!

Renalla not only references gravestones, she also turn the sweetings INTO graveatones during the attack where she lifts them into the air. Beyond that, Renallas staff has runes that are very similar to those on the Spirit Caller bell, and the top part is similar to the iconography on the Resurrection Totems.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Ahh, I knew I was missing something about the gravestones--thank you for pointing that out! And I didn't realize that about the runes--my current theory is that Renna crafted the Spiritcalling Bell so that all definitely tracks!

@PerusingPanda

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask Just curious, but do you also think Renna is the Snowy Crone?

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Yep! Though who knows if Renna has any other secret identities...

@PerusingPanda

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask That does make physical sense as to why she would know so much about the moons. But if Ranni is the only Princess of Caria left, how was Renna still around to teach/warn her of the occultic Dark Moon? That would make them half sisters, and Renna should be heir to the Carian line. I wonder also if you lend any credance to the theory that Radagon was rebirthing the old earthbound Gods, using the Amber Egg. Tangentially, I think that's related.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

I've actually been under the assumption that Renna and Rennala (and Sellen!) were the Three Sisters of Caria. (Selene was the Greek goddess of the moon and there's a portrait of her at Raya Lucaria. Plus Sellen and Rennala look similar.) But since all 3 have vastly different views on magic, they had a falling out. (Renna likes the occult and the dark moon, while Sellen is fascinated by the Primeval Current.) That would explain why Renna was Ranni's secret mentor despite being Carian and why there aren't any other Carian princesses. And I hadn't heard that theory before! Do tell. In the Rig Veda, the universe was created out of a golden egg (Hiranyagarbha) so it could be an allusion to that!

Never saw that snail attack animation! And perfect placement of the Oblivion intro, great video!!

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

I love that your content acknowledges assumptions made in other theories. Obvs I don't have all the answers but it's nice to finally see someone avoiding assumptions

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

I like the theory that Marika was the Gloam Eyed Queen, and it makes some sense if she was, considering how Melina appears to become the GEQ in the Frenzied Flame ending, and Melina is somehow a daughter of Marika according to her name in the code which reads MarikaOfDaughter. The theory is that Marika was originally from what is now one of the Eternal Cities (probably Noxstella), and because of what the Greater Will did to her city she decided to work her way to become the vessel for the Elden Ring, and to then slowly destroy the Golden Order from within. And there are things in game that sort of corroborate this thought. Rogier says that the Black Knife Assassins are Scions of the Eternal City, and the Black Knife set mentions how the Black Knife Assassins are all Numen women with close ties to Marika. So this makes it seem that one if not all the Eternal Cities were once known as Numen, and were at some point banished beneath the earth. And another piece of evidence that Marika might be connected with the Godskins is that in Farum Azula, in the room where Maliketh is fought there is a statue of what looks like a women with three wolves around her. Empyreans have half wolf shadows to guard and if needed kill their Empyrean. Though why it's three, then again Ranni has 3 wolves outside her tower as well, so the connection is still there.

Unrelated to the main video, but I read a comment talking about the "three sisters" towers and wanted to respond to that - I think it may be a reference to the triune goddess Hecate, which represents the aspects of waxing/full/waning, or maiden, mother, and crone. Hecate is also associated with witchcraft, the moon, sorcery, necromancy, graves, night, and ghosts. In Elden Ring, I feel like this ties in heavily with Ranni (maiden), Rennala (mother), and Rennala (crone). If you look at depictions of Hecate, you may see a similarity to how Glintstone crowns appear in game, in that she is often depicted with multiple faces/heads. Hecate was associated with dogs, as she was depicted with them and some were sacrificed to her, echoing Ranni's relationship with Blaidd. Hecate was often equated/conflated with Selene, another moon goddess, who others have tied to Sellen. I don't know what this means as far as lore goes, or if this has any bearing on interpreting the Carian family tree, just thought it was an interesting set of references.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

I actually had a whole discussion on the tripartite goddess in an earlier draft of the script!! Though I had Renna as the crone and Melina as the maiden, since they're called that in the game.

@tropezando

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask oh yeah, sorry it autocompleted a second Rennala where I meant to put Renna for crone lol!

The Godskin being called father is probably not literal and meant to mean a high ranking priest

I wonder how the dusk-eye queen's order (or a ending that has to do with her) would be

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Great question! If I had to guess, I'd assume it would look the most similar to the Age of the Duskborn with Fia, since they share a similar favorable outlook towards creating new life amid death. And that ending, along with the Erdleaf Flower, are the only mentions of dusk/dusky in the game. It's also fascinating that no matter the ending you choose, you accomplish a lot of the Gloam-Eyed Queen's objectives: The Rune of Death is released and restored and anywhere between 3-7 demigods are killed.

@DungEnjoyerr

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask a skeleTON of demigods felled (duskborn ending joke)

3:33 Best joke ever

haha, at 3:30 I thought "George did write lots of the lore" then his pic immediately pops on screen.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Great minds think alike!

Coming back to this, with the SOTE trailer released, I'm quite confident the gloam-eyed queen is who Marika takes the strands of hair/rune from in the trailer (after maliketh defeats her, and just before creating the erdtree).. it's definitely a godskin cloth she pulls it from. And that event - her defeat - was what led to the creation. I almost wonder if she was her sister. And if Melina is either marked with a gloam eye in honor of her, or IS her - somehow brought back in spirit (because her body was burned) to undo Marika's rule

Miquella was probably an Ancient Tomb, since that's where you find The Golden Epitaph.

Another long shot candidate could be the spirit tuner that hewg once knew, given the recurring connection to spirit summoning and the decidedly dusky hue of spirits. hewg does specifically mention eye color. I also strongly doubt that marika would have spread the rumor thag the GEQ was an empyrean. the mere fact that there could even _be_ an empyrean that wasn't born of her line is a threat to her power

@garrulousgoldmask

11 ай бұрын

Good points! Personally I think Renna may have been the spirit tuner Hewg once knew since her body (which Ranni is in a copy of) does seem to have very similar eyes to Roderika.

My head canon is that there is only one apostle and one noble who are just running around looking for the runes of death and to release destined death

If being the Gloam-Eyed Queen is a title (big if) then Melina could be related to Ranni after all, given the oft noted facial similarities, both being bodiless, and their relationship with Torrent. Perhaps she was a piece of her that was loyal to the Golden Order that was cast off during or after the Night of Black Knives so Ranni could pursue her goals.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Very true! There are just so many connections between Ranni and Melina. It's also important to note that Miriel says Rennala is involved with reincarnation, which has very different connotations than rebirth (and leads to a lot more possibilities for theory crafting!)

@armandaneshjoo

Жыл бұрын

yup. Ranni is a piece of Melina... kinda. In GRRM's mythos, Melina was the main character. she was the empyrean black knife trained by her aunt Mari. Marika conspired with Melina to burn the Erdtree by sacrificing Godwyn and herself. The purpose Marika gave her was to become the next queen. With our help, she did. In Myazaki's lore, Melina's story was given to Ranni, and aunt Mari's story was given to aunt Renna. Melina became the kindling maiden, and Mari became the gloam-eyed queen. yup. gloam-eyed queen is a description, not a title. Abzu and Marika were golden-eye Mari and Melina were gloam-eyed

Big, if true.

6:26 is hilarious 😂

A dusky yellow flower starting to fade that eats erdtree leaves. I recently found out the leaves only fall when a shard bearer is killed or someone becomes elden lord, but I wonder if this is a reference to godwyns death. Im sure leaves fell for him in the past. Just an opinion, but i like to think it's marika after the death of godwyn. I think her eyes dimmed just like the flower.

The eye color of the spirit calling snail might be close to Roderika's eyes in color and Hewg mentions eye color being a feature of spirit tuners. Granted spirit tuners are different than spirit callers but probably not too different. Maybe The gloam eyed queen is the person to whom Hewg owed a great debt.

There are 3 wolves in front of Ranni's Rise, on the steps 👀

Very cool, definitely a different focus on things that are being neglected by other analysis

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Thank you! I was pleasantly surprised that even a figure like the GEQ still had a ton of unexplored lore a year after the game came out.

@SocraTetris

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask You also knocked onto something that has bothered me, which is how people casually said, "the color of gloam," like gloam wasn't a time of day/state of the sky with various colors. Lol, no one before Elden Ring was looking for the "Gloam" colored crayon. But most of all i liked the focus on the themes of motherhood, which were central to bloodborne as well

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Right? I definitely wanted to set the record straight on that since FromSoft left the color of "gloam" to be evocative and ambiguous... And I'm growing more and more convinced that not only is Elden Ring Dark Souls 2 (2), it's also Bloodborne 2.

Damn I just found that channel and saw 3 theory videos. What a banger. On top of the GEQ being an empyrean and her sword, one NPC with the Bloodwolf armor (sorry idk the english name) that can be encountered thorugh the volcano manor questline inside the real roundtable hold, has the GEQ sword. And his armor states he wanted to become a shadow for an empyrean. My guess is empyrean get shadows that are manufactured thorugh heroes wishing to become a shadow

@garrulousgoldmask

5 күн бұрын

Yep! I actually talked about the Bloody Wolf Vargram in my theory video on why Leda could be Miquella’s Shadow.

Small point that I never double check, Rennala’s eyes are different before you fight and after.

@kreadapelu8813

Жыл бұрын

Oh also… Rennala uhhh. Go to the tower where you get Terra Magika. Do it in the day. Look south, look up. What is that?

V. II Snail from armored core 6 makes a lot more sense after watching this🐌

Ok, hear me out, what if the snail is the shadow of the shadow of the Gloam Eyed Queen. I don't think its the case nor is there any evidence to it but it made me chuckle so I thought I'd mention it.

Thanks for the shout-out! ^^

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

And thank you for stopping by! ^^ Your videos are easily some of the best in the community and offer so many perspectives I never even considered!

A year late, but the Rennala we fight is actually Ranni doing an illusion

I know this is probably not the case, but what if 'gloam eyed' isn't about her eye colour but rather her ambition? She seeks to bring about The Gloaming in the same way Ranni seeks to bring about the night.

When you connect the real-world Roman mythology to its corresponding in-game characters and events, it leads us to identify: Empyreans = Muses/Fates From this, we identify Melina as the Muse named ‘Memory’ Remember the Memory of Grace item? Melina and her ties to grace seem to be intrinsically tied to the MEMORY of the past, in some metaphysical sense. The roundtable hold/the modern, golden, phantom erdtree/possibly the phantom flagposts and stuff around the outskirts of Leyndell - all MEMORIES. So, if we just follow the Roman mythology’s family tree of Muses/Fates, this should directly correlate to the family tree of the Empyreans, right? Well, the first generation was named Calliope. Calliope was the original Muse. In Roman mythology, she herself represents the conjoining of the Earth, Moon, and Sun. Her mythology (of her riding Pegasus up to the sun and being scorched by its heat) is a clear analogy for the creation of the Philosopher’s stone via mixing and burning the Tria Prima. This generation is represented in-game by: Earth = Marika = alchemical Salt Moon = Rennala = alchemical Mercury Sun = Radagon = alchemical Sulfur CUTTING TO THE CHASE: The modern in-game story revolving around Marika, Radagon, Rennala, their family trees, and ALL their conflicts, is ALL based directly on real-world mythology, including their family trees. This basic principle leads you to clear real-world inspirations for many of the story’s “unanswered” questions- Who is the Gloam-Eyed Queen and where is she? Who is the Prince of Death and where is he? Why does the Sun seem to play a background role to the story - highly important in context, often depicted, but seldom talked about in detail? What is the Helphen and the red grace seen by those who met their death in battle? Who are those who live in death, and why are they doing what they do? What is the Primeval Current? (This one has a direct translation, in Latin, which explains why Lusat and Azur turned themselves to crystal) Who were/are the Outer Gods? What were their names in Roman mythology, and from that, their family trees, associations, principles, and actions? What was the intended purpose of the Haligtree? Who is the womanly form we see grown from the roots? WHO is the real-world Roman mythology inspiration for Miquella? And from that, the inspiration for Unalloyed Gold needles and their opposite counterpart, St Trina’s arrows? Why did St Trina suddenly disappear without a trace? Why did she always cover her face? This one’s hard - why did St Trina sing the merchants a lullaby to soothe their frenzy? WHO taught her the lullaby? From these points, we then see the damning evidence that PROVES the logical soundness of this theory: Why did Mohg kidnap Miquella and set him on the giant pelvis? This is impossible to understand without understanding the inspirations for the characters and plotline. “In Greek mythology, Eros (UK: /ˈɪərɒs, ˈɛrɒs/, US: /ˈɛrɒs, ˈɛroʊs/;[4] Ancient Greek: Ἔρως, romanized: Érōs, lit. 'Love, Desire') is the Greek god of love and sex. His Roman counterpart was Cupid ("desire").[5] In the earliest account, he is a primordial god, while in later accounts he is described as one of the children of Aphrodite and Ares and, with some of his siblings, was one of the Erotes, a group of winged love gods.” Starting to notice connections between Eros and Cupid? Between the Formless Mother and Miquella? The understanding of modern in-game events also hinges on the understanding of the real-world story The Golden Ass. I could go into more detail, but it was the inspiration for: Godrick getting Grafted Hoarah Loux’s death in the Badlands, and inspiration for having Serosh hang off his neck/back/head Malenia being infected with the Scarlet Rot at her birth (intentionally by her parents) Miquella putting the Unalloyed Gold Needle in Malenia, prompting her to suddenly become obsessed with fighting Radahn (for no clear reason, right? Well, duh - she had a golden Cupid’s arrow stuck into her flesh) Malenia going to fight Radahn, specifically sparing the life of Godrick along the way Malenia unleashing the Rot SPECIFICALLY AT THE VERY MOMENT RIGHT AFTER BREAKING THE UNALLOYED GOLD NEEDLE, and her falling into a deep slumber immediately afterwards, having to be carried back to the Haligtree by Findlay So on and so forth… read the Golden Ass to help you understand the plot of the game

Hah, never noticed that Rennala summoned 4 wolfs. For followers of the golden order 3 is considered a bad omen. I often got the feeling 3 is used purposely to signify something that is not a part of that belief without any good explanation, I mean even "A lonely wolf" comes in a pack of 3. Ironically, beasts are the only place I have found hearts tutched by gold that will never decay. Something not even heroes of the golden order seemingly was able to achieve.

@garrulousgoldmask

11 ай бұрын

Oh I didn't make the connection between the number 3 being a symbol of bad luck to wolf packs--good eye! It's also interesting because the four-toed fowl foot is a symbol of great luck.

And the Snail do have a snakes head

@garrulousgoldmask

11 ай бұрын

Yep! All of them are called SnakeSnails in the game files and there's even a cut snail that's part cobra.

That the GEQ is associated with motherhood and birth is not strange at all, because that's literally the definition of all Empyreans i.e. they have the power to give birth and it's also the reason why Ranni refused to be an Empyrean. Hence all Empyreans except Miquella are female (though with Miquella given he has a female alter ego, this is also something which can be questioned to some extent). I also think that the word "father" for the godskin nobles and apostles does not necessarily mean the father of a literal child, but is far more likely to be in a religious context, because they are usually found in places of worship (churches, temples, worshipped as a leader figure in Dominula Windmill village and so on). If you're going to point out to any actual weird instance of incest in the game, then Mohg explicitly being shown to lay with Miquella (we find them doing just that in Mohgwyn Palace) is a far more obvious example. I also think you place too much meaning on the spiritcaller snails since they have shown no other affinity with the GEQ i.e. wielding godflame. The spiritcaller snails are more likely connected with the ancestrals or the deathrite birds, since they are the ones connected with the spirit world and the general death of all things. It is also notable that the player receives the summoning bell from Ranni, not Melina, and that Melina was gifted Torrent's ring to give to the chosen Tarnished which now people theorize could be Miquella due to the new DLC poster. So whoever left the items in the Spiritcaller Cave knows about GEQ and has power or knowledge of the spirits, and that person is likely Ranni or someone associated with Ranni. That the spiritcaller snail can summon godskin apostles and nobles is consistent with that all living beings in Lands Between exist both in spirit and flesh. Godwyn died in spirit but not in flesh, and Ranni died in flesh but not in spirit. So these nobles and apostles died at some point, and since they were hunted down by Marika, that makes sense. And after that the snail could summon them just like the snail summons all other forms of spirits such as the crucible knights.

Well I just learned that the snail has a grab attack.

Maybe the glow eyed Queen is like shibiri.

I'm pretty sure it's stated that Maliketh defeated the Gloam Eyed Queen and not Marika. Though I guess it could be interpreted that he did it on behalf of his half-sister. Is it possible the color of Rennala's eyes in that phase 2 cutscene aren't accurate? Considering it is implied that whole phase is just a creation of Ranni and not really Rennala. I don't think a Shadow can truly be killed. I believe that Blaidd actually mentions this if you try killing him where he is found howling. So the GEQ turning her shadow into a blade is probably not something that could have been done, but maybe.

YEEEES NEW VIDEO

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

I love the enthusiasm!!

Melina is the ultimate souls mommy gf

Its dragon rider (archer) obviously

Father = priest.....

Two things to add, Rennala's second form is a mirage and not actually Rennala thus eye color and summoning wolves isn't canonically valid. Second thing is Melina always says "she is not a maiden", maybe she did give birth at some point in the past.

What if the gloam eyed queen ascended to godhood and no one knew which could explain her will manifesting in the snails and melina

Funnily enough, if the whole "gloam eyed queen mating with her kids" thing is true, she's not the only one. Some people in who theory crafted came to believe Marika did it with Godwyn to have the Omen twins

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Oh interesting! I hadn't heard of that theory before though I can see the logic behind it. I've also been delving deeper into alchemy and there is way more incest imagery than I was expecting (mainly mother-son and brother-sister). And that could have all kinds of implications for Elden Ring.

Marika did something (the betrayal) to Melina because Apostles could kill gods to protect her new god-self (similar to how she eliminated the giants for their fire in protection of the Erdtree.) Somehow I feel you (the player) are the "wolf" shadow for Melina trying to kill the gods once more. She leads you all the way to the giant's flame and burns the Erdtree (symbolically Marika.) Idk

I think you're overthinking too much the word "father", father is also used to describe a religious preacher from the Catholic churches (orthodox and romanic)

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

That's fair! Though this is George RR Martin so it could always be both

@nox_cadit

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask facts

Being named Apostles I assumed the term "Father" was the biblical and not relating to them being daddies.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

That could be the case! Though since GRRM was involved, it could always be both.

@ApplePi3.

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask *nods that is true haha

"Father" can simply mean leaders of the faith.

The connections between Rennala and the Gloam-Eyed Queen actually has implications for Ranni, given how Ranni's spirit face is almost identical to Melina's Face, the fact that Ranni of all people is the one who gives the Tarnished the Spirit Summoning Bell, the fact that only Ranni and Melina know about Torrent, and how whenever Melina appears to talk to the Tarnished she appears and disappears with the same blue light particles that Torrent and Ranni have (When you first meet Ranni and she hands over the Spirit Summoning Bell she disappears with blue particles, and Torrent appears and disappears in the same way), the fact that both Ranni and Melina don't have their own physical form and are just spirits, both Ranni's and Melina's connection to the Black Knife Assassins (Melina literally has their moveset when you summon her against Morgott), if the theory that Melina and Ranni are the same person is true (In much the same way as Marika and Radagon), then Rennala's connection to the Gloam-Eyed Queen could imply that Ranni/Melina are in fact the Gloam-Eyed Queen as people have been speculating, Melina is seemingly implied to be the Gloam-Eyed Queen in the Frenzied Flame Ending One thing that might support this is actually the Sword of Night and Flame, which is found inside Caria Manor, it deals Magic and Fire damage that scales off of Int and Faith respectively, Ranni obviously uses Sorcery so the Magic part makes sense, but Melina is capable of controlling the Flames in the Forge of the Giants and she definitely uses Incantations as seen when you summon her to fight Morgott...

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Those are some great insights! The Ranni-Melina theory was one of the very first Elden Ring lore theories I came across, so I'm glad you put that in a whole new light. I also hadn't thought of connecting the Sword of Night and Flame to Ranni/Melina.

@jaydenlobbe7911

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask There is more to it, such as how Melina’s eye in the Frenzied Flame Ending is Purple, which is the colour you get if you mix Blue and Red, blue for Ranni and red for Melina (Fire is typically orange and yellow, Melina’s hair is pink, both Orange and Pink are a mix between Red and another colour, the colour red specifically isn’t associated with Melina but it’s indirectly associated with her through red adjacent colours)

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Good point! It's also interesting that in alchemy, the color purple was derived from gold, which could have some fascinating parallels to Melina.

9:25 dont u think this is miquella ? I mean, the dlc will confirm if hes the real torrent owner, if so, yes

I believe the gloam eyed queen is Ranni or renalla

Father is also a religious title

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

True! Though Elden Ring was co-written by George RR Martin so it could always be both

Pretty sure they’re “Father” like a priest, not an actual father

@garrulousgoldmask

11 ай бұрын

Fair point! Though this was co-written by George RR Martin, so it could always be both...

@Quader417

11 ай бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask yes still a possibility 😂 i just hope not

came here from timdiggity's video :D

Marika being the GEQ was the only logical conclusion for me. The connection to the nox via the clothing details is so subtle but evident.

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

I had seen theories for Marika being the GEQ, but I hasn't heard about the Nox clothing connection! What's going on there?

@Win_Condition

Жыл бұрын

@@garrulousgoldmask i haven’t done as much research into this but it’s something that piqued my interest. The Nox armors are eerily reminiscent of the Godskin armor, especially being one of the few cultures in the Lands Between to have hoods integrated into their armors along w/ the white color scheme💯

Yup. Gloam eyed queen is a title. Ever since the Numen arrived and took down the Nox there have been four queens ruling over the lands between: 1. Abzu (golden eye), wife to Placidusax, queen during great tree era, chosen by Manus Celes 2. Mari (gloam-eyed), wife to stormlord Grandsax, queen during the second crucible era, chosen by the three fingers. leader of the god hunt. 3. Marika (Golden eye), wife to Godfrey, queen during Erdtree era. chosen by the two fingers. 4. Melina (gloam-eyed), abandoned her purpose to become the next queen, as instructed by Marika (her mother in the erdtree). Melina was Marika's daughter. Mari and Marika were daughters of Placidusax and Abzu.

I’m the 666th sub!

I simply believe Gloam Eyed Queen was marika the eternal.

I think the connections are just too flimsy as of now.

For the amount of subscribers u have bro this is great keep it up an you'll get noticed for sure

@garrulousgoldmask

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!

@user-eb6gr1ux6w

Жыл бұрын

@Garrulous Goldmask I didn't mean it rude either I just re read it so just making sure I meant like usually the production an edits an stuff ppl do usually shows why they aren't popular and yours vid shows u should have a million followers