Atif looked harsh but he is 200 percent correct. It is not a nation but a unruly crowd.

I felt pain when atif said "Can you give me position?". This is the bitter reality, and in my opinion one of the fundamentel problem of pakistan. 😢

"Can you give me a position" ,and he summarised it all.Period.

Atif love your boldness, bluntness , factual way of thinking, this nation needs this type of surgery.

A big slap by Dr Atif Mian "can you give me a position?" This guy is a real nationalist who wants to do something for his motherland. I am an Indian and do hear Dr Atif's views on multiple forums and it looks like he has something in him to do good for his motherland. But the elephant in the room has some other plans. For elephants, the focus is not the country for sure!

@zaafarmehmood3491

7 ай бұрын

Can u please highlight where he said this… thanks

I have attended this physically. It was amazing

I was lucky enough to physically attend this session. It was amazing. Not many people know that Dr. Christoffe Jaffrelot was there too. I, along the some other young men had a rather detailed discussion about Pakistan in particular and Indo-Pacific region in general. I asked a question at 1:21:58

We need people like him running the country

Great to see Atif Mian at this platform. I want to say, actually this is the real us of social media. Keep on doing. Day will come when efforts will start to pay back.

Pakistan biggest problem is the priority of Islam and religion over other things. Religion doesn’t pay your bills or grows your economy. Science, Math, education leads to learning and enlightenment and eventually economic growth and more.

Always a pleasure hearing Atif Mian

I would request Mr Atif Mian to talk about our population growth. I feel that our fertility rate of 3.3% is our biggest issue. In fact it is the mother of all economic issues we have. India’s fertility rate is 2%. They have restricted their population to 2.5 times since 1972 whereas our population had grown 4 times. This practically means that we have accumulated 80 million extra people to feed and educate. Bangladesh has follwed the Indian model. Mian Atif can throw some professional light on this aspect.

Great debate. Thanks Dr Mian for so passionately presenting his views and replying so gracefully. People like Dr Mian are a global asset which make us all so proud. Thanks Black Hole for providing this opportunity.

Atif Mian is a superstar

I like prof parvez for his revolutionizing ideas about education. It helps India too. No professor in India fascinated me as much he did.

Apparently, Atif Mian is the 2nd most popular Ahmadi muslim from pakistan after Dr. Abdus Salam who was also an Ahmadi muslim. #AhmadiMuslim

An excellent discourse ! Thank you The Blackhole for bringing it to us . Prof Hoodbhoy , no words can define what you are doing for Pakistan in these trying times .

I'm feeling lucky to listen to these two guys.

The fate and conditions of Pakistan is because you guys drove away most progressive and business minded people from Pakistan during partition. The people who migrated to Pakistan were jamindars and nawabs who had no idea how to run and manage businesses, they were simply good how to exploit people under their control that’s what they have been doing for the last 76 years. As simple as that. For Pakistan to grow forward, ban mullas, military, short sighted politicians. Keep religion at home, no hatred to non believers, bring back progressive, talented, visionary Pakistanis and let them run your country till the Pakistani public get civilized.

What he spoke is reality, that we are not thinking about.

Blackhole indeed is a revolutionary platform. Keep up the good work Mr. Hoodbhoy and team!

Thank you Mr.Perez Hoodbouy for your efforts in improving our awareness on issues related to Pakistan .Hearing Mr.Atif Mian ‘s solution ,I think he is not able to speak his mind completely. Before we can make any economic transformation we must first separate the state and government from religious power .Transitioning to a modern democracy involves ensuring that political power is derived from the people through fair and transparent elections .A commitment to a democratic principles includes protecting civil liberties,upholding the rule of law and fostering political pluralism and then strengthening democratic institutions,such as an independent judiciary,free press,and robust civil society for maintaining checks and balances within the system .Then let us focus on Economic transformation Mumtaz

Dr hoodbhoy … you shld do a case study of Amul … which is a farmers owned cooperative … that’s a billion dollar organization competing with global giants like Nestle .. Britannia ..

There is another conversation with Atif Mia on "The Pakistan Experience" podcast and that is a lot better. The host had very well thought out questions in that podcast.

Wow, what a beautiful primer on Economics for the uninitiated! Such people should be cherished. Hope Atif gets an opportunity to do something for his motherland. Best wishes and prayers!

Thanks for Prof. Hoodbhoy and Dr. Atif for this conversations.

Great comment by Atif mian, we are habitual in telling layieing to ourselves

Wonderfull session. My request to the black hole is to have Dr. Hafeez pasha as a guest, discussing economy of Pakistan.

Such talk shows must continue to go on as Pakistanis need more to know the factual analysis.فوج کو پٹہ ڈالنے کی ضرورت ہے۔

Rule of law without any discrimination is game changer. Nothing will happen unless law of the land is respected and feared.

GREAT NICE TO SEE ATIF MIAN PLEASE KEEP ON BRINGING ATIF MIAN FROM TIME TO TIME

Prof. Hoodbhoy asked what should be done first second or third. The answer for the first is very obvious and Mr. Hoodbhoy has been eluding this in indirect way for years. FIRST thing to do is to send ALL the mullahs of the country to the 72 Hoors that they tell every citizen of Pakistan as their ultimate goal in life.

Very informative and knowledgeable program!

Mashallah great analysis of dysfunctional economy of Pakistan.

Similar kinds debates can trigger change. Would love to see such debates in prime-time shows of news channels.

Mashallah Zabardast 🇵🇰🇩🇪

Hopefully the policy makers understand him, without a fundamental shift in policy and mindset Pakistan will not survive

ڈاکٹر صاحب خاکسار گزشتہ ماہ ہی امریکہ پہنچا ہے۔خوش قسمتی سے میں بھی نیوجرسی میں ہوں امید ہے کہیں ملاقات کا موقعہ ضرور ملے گا۔یقینا یہ میرے لیے بڑی خوش قسمتی کی بات ہوگی۔اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکھے۔

It's pleasure to hear from such highly qualified people....In short state should have nothing to do with religion...

Waah.... sincere respect and regards from India.

Great Sir, i always enjoyed and learnt whenever got opprunity to watch ur podcasts

Our problem is that the salary of our guard is more than the people who employ him.

Pakistan doesn't need any advice as they will never change.

It’s a great to hear Dr Atif❤

Excellent explanation, looking forward to such session, good luck to Black Hole.

In Korea the foundation of development was based on the land reform and consequently prosperity in rural areas which lead to expansion of service industry and high literacy rate.

Thoughtful extraordinary expressions.

Thanks a lot for holding this talk, Very interesting and thoughtful, rather fantastic, Hope those at the helm of affairs, heed the message

Very informative program ☺️

Greetings from New Delhi....Atif is extremely competent and his ideas are crystal clear....however its a pity that nothing will ever work for Pakistan till the country exists from radicalism and religious fanatism. Until this happens I doubt if any University Professor from the West would like to be posted in Pakistan.

Dr Sahib Allah bless you with good and healthy life same to Hoodbhai who is doing a brilliant job for Pakistan. I wish if our so called leaders (lootaray) have vision like you guys.

Last but one Q about womens labour participation and its answer is a gem! Kudos!

Zabardast baat ke Hai Atif Mian nay 🇵🇰🇵🇰👍❤️❤️

#Inspiring #Great_Person #Dr_Atif_Mian ❤

Problem with Pakistan is that intellectuals like these two are in the periphery. Decision making is in the hands of the Army, ISI and their appointed political elite. So, whatever you discuss in a room becomes irrelevant in Pakistan. Add to this the huge level of illiteracy, fundamentalism, hatred of India and Hindus and you know why this nation cannot ever rationally decide to bury the hatchet and trade with India even if that is the rational think to do and that is the thing that will save Pakistan's economy.

Worlds best brain Mr Atif mian❤❤❤❤❤

What a man on screen ❤❤❤

An Absolute pleasure listening to him.

Came across this channel yesterday and I am greatly impressed with the content. Admirable!

It is unfortunate that we cannot benefit from people with excellence

Jazak Allah

Thanks a lot, Atif, for making us wiser. However I was very disappointed to note the low level of intellect in the participants and their ability to ask the kind of questions this thought provoking conversation by Atif had created. Pervaiz may like to share the criteria for invitations to such sessions

Thanks for this.

Pakistani army-politicians-jamindaar-elite: "The world is round. If we keep going backward, we will eventually end up in the first spot." Here is another comparison with Bangladesh. The best thing that came out of 1971 was that we got rid of the Pakistani Army, bureaucracy, and zamindar elite politicians. The parasites who are eating your pie right now. We enjoyed a prosperous economic growth from 1977-2006. Then Sheikh Hasina came to power. During her past 15 years of illegitimate rule, she brought back all the bad elements of Pakistan. She replaced the Pakistan army with the police, and made her close allies into billionaire elites. The only difference is that the Pakistani elites and army are huge in numbers and collectively drain the country’s wealth. In Bangladesh, Hasina and her few cronies have hoarded all the wealth and hard-earned dollars from the people. That’s why there are no billionaire Generals or thief brothers in Pakistan. They barely stole $100M. But Hasina’s cronies are all billionaires. One is Aziz Khan from Summit Group, the 41st Billionaire in Singapore. Hasina herself has more than $50B in her stash. All the projects cost 4x more than the normal price. Bangladesh has over $100B foreign debt, and the real number is unknown.

Excellent lecture & discussion. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed has emphasised that one of the chief causes for partition was that the landed gentry of Punjab, were against land reforms (as said by Nehru in his 1936 speech), socialism which then under the garb of religion became the cause for partition. This now remains one of the chief resistance for changes such as taxation. The problem started then and continued.

Awesome and amazing

Excellent discussion.

Atif is a smart person. He clearly is talking about things from a place where these things works which is US. Now coming to Pakistan, one has to not reinvent the wheel, but learn from other countries what has worked and what hasn’t and why. Then adapt those working policies to Pakistan. Who in Pakistan is going to do all of this? Many of these feed into what people call nation building. Building of institutions, processes, bureaucracy and legal systems to deliver on those macro ideas and concepts. This take huge effort and many retries. Sadly, these things take atleast 2 generations for a country that started fresh. Since Pakistan has had 4 generations born since it’s creation, and a country that has systems in place that don’t work, getting Pakistan on the right track personally looks like an impossible feat with the leaders it has. If Pakistan had what India has, then atleast we know the people at the top care about these things and want to fix things and make change. Who is Pakistan’s Modi? Pakistan’s future is bleak. It won’t survive another generation is my assessment.

Good approach sb

I guess one key point which was not discussed during the discussion was to clean our rotten justice system first before asking foreign investors or faculty to come and train us. Hate to say this but they might get blasphemy cases rooted against them through oppositions own personal agendas. This is the bitter truth of today and it’s not just in small cities or towns, it is certainly becoming a part of Pakistani norm now. This shift of religious extremism to normality is the first thing to happen.

Excellent analysis by Atif Mian about Pakistan economy

Awesome & Amazing 🥰🥰🥰🥰

Dr. Atif Sb not only a great intellectual but he has a good sense of humor.

Brilliant and splendid session.

I wish I could understand Urdu. Dr Atif's interview with imf Africa (😂😂 of all people) was very beneficial.

اکنامکس وہ شعبہ ہے جس سے ہم ایک ملک کی معیشت کو سمجھ سکتے ہیں ان بنیادوں پر جن پر نیوٹن نے سیاروں کی گردش سمجھی تھی ۔ Paul Samuelson

Insightful

Marvellous

Every guest has repeated 100 times about education, Army interference etc... is the main reason for Pakistan's condition 😂

Atif Mian is bemoaning 75 years too late! Pakistan was founded on the basis of ideology. Science was never a factor in its creation. Jinnah knew as much about Science as my rear end knows about Mars! At least Nehru, though not a Scientist, encouraged setting up of Scientific institutions in India but not Jinnah. Worse still, always the quintessential British gentleman, Jinnah told, soon after Pakistan was founded, to a bewildered Bengali crowd in Dhaka in his immaculate British accented English, that they would all have to henceforth learn Urdu and not Bengali because that was going to be the national language of Pakistan! Pakistan and Science do not go together and even if some people with good intentions tried result would be a disaster. Case in point Dr Abdus Salam, the only Nobel laureate Pakistan produced. He spent much of his life outside Pk as he was ostracized for being an Ahmediya.

Incentivise to innovate. Spot on

Atif says: problem with nervous system = Military

Very few audiences.. looks like Pakistani youth are more interested in religious matters .

This is all Greek to all of Pakistani establishments

Pakistan ko 1 child policy for the next 5 year karni padegi. Plus women education and women ko workforce me aana padega.Iske results 20 saal me niklenge

@1:01:10 Seriously why can't Prof Atif Mian be the Economic Advisor of Pak PM and FM for a few years? His mastery over economics is not being utilized by Pak govts. All junk is brought to those key posts and ruining the economy.

Awesome sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

33:05 👍Economic policy in India just aimed inflated prices of crude oil , land and gold. Only few people were benefitted. Policy shouldn't be micro economic.

Waht brilliant Analysis and Brilliant Brain ❤❤

Seen.

Pappistani people want to live in 723CE. Imraand will come come and fulfill their desires

Good job

One of biggest law and order issue in pakistan is the decision maker are not held accountable.

Excellent

The question is who will bell the cat? (Military, maulvi)

Zabardast

He has strong professor energy

Parvez Hudbhoi is superb as always. I think, Mr Aatif has some cast problem, hence unacceptable to Political powers. He fears, blasphemy case hence can't speak openly against certain dogmatic things in his loved country. Thankfully, Pakistan Press is much more free compared to India.

عارف میاں نے اسٹبلشمنٹ کا نام نہیں کہ سارے وسائل اور سیاست پر ان کا قبضہ ہے جب تک ملک کے معاملات سیاستدانوں کے پاس نہیں جائیں گے اور کنٹرول سیولین کے پاس نہیں جائیں گے کچھ نہیں بدلے گا اور عاطف میاں نے یہ بھی نہیں بتایا کہ کتنا بجٹ اسٹبلشمنٹ اور اس کے تمام اداروں کے پاس ڈائریکٹ اور ان ڈائریکٹ جا رہا ہے اور سول حکومت صرف ہزار ارب سے چلتی ہے بشمول تنخواہ اور پینشن شامل کر کے ۔

Great minds, Alass faraway, we lost due to our intellectual infertility