The Double-Edged Sword of One Piece Live Action

Ойын-сауық

Netflix's One Piece Live Action looks true to the source material... maybe a little too true?
Join our Discord! / discord
Twitter: / phenomsage
MyAnimeList: myanimelist.net/profile/Pheno...
00:00 - One Piece Live Action Trailer Is Here
02:09 - Can A One Piece Live Action Even Work?
04:18 - Can You Be TOO Faithful To The Source?
06:17 - The Cast
07:27 - Luffy
08:57 - The Visuals
10:27 - What Will Decide The Fate Of This Series
Thanks for watching!

Пікірлер: 229

  • @GASA1997
    @GASA199711 ай бұрын

    Arlong park is going to be the make it or break it moment for the live action series.

  • @SomeFactsYouMightNotKnow

    @SomeFactsYouMightNotKnow

    11 ай бұрын

    Cant wait for cgi chopper 😂😂😂

  • @griddycheese

    @griddycheese

    11 ай бұрын

    @@SomeFactsYouMightNotKnow prob gon be close to rocket from GOG

  • @GiRR007

    @GiRR007

    11 ай бұрын

    @@griddycheese Or even just have chopper be played by a little kid even except for when he tranforms into a deer or hybrid.

  • @piratekingluffy376

    @piratekingluffy376

    11 ай бұрын

    @@SomeFactsYouMightNotKnowforget chopper, cgi hachi

  • @SomeFactsYouMightNotKnow

    @SomeFactsYouMightNotKnow

    11 ай бұрын

    @@piratekingluffy376 fo real 😭😭😂😂😂

  • @Erif-
    @Erif-11 ай бұрын

    Please be good. Please be good. Please be good. Please be good. Please be good. Please be good. Please be good. Please be good.

  • @finallycanchangethenamenot359

    @finallycanchangethenamenot359

    11 ай бұрын

    The people who saw the scenes in anime ax(?) Said that it looks amazing

  • @jeremiahbennett3004
    @jeremiahbennett300411 ай бұрын

    One thing i think even haters of the trailer can admit is that the practical sets look very impressive, like the fact they didn't cgi the boats and decided to build them all is really impressive, and i'm super happy with how they look.

  • @mrkaji8913

    @mrkaji8913

    11 ай бұрын

    Better than marvel

  • @tobiaswedin

    @tobiaswedin

    11 ай бұрын

    Did you even see Garp's ship in the trailer? 100% CGI disaster.

  • @tylergraham1670

    @tylergraham1670

    11 ай бұрын

    @@tobiaswedinas long as the fights and emotional scenes and story are on point then cgi should be the least of our worries lol

  • @warrenharshaw7677

    @warrenharshaw7677

    11 ай бұрын

    Yet, when they decided to design the going merry, they went with that design instead of the original, which would have been simpler to design and better.

  • @jeremiahbennett3004

    @jeremiahbennett3004

    11 ай бұрын

    @@tobiaswedin actually, they built that practically as well, the one shot of it we saw just happened to be cgi

  • @software-namibia
    @software-namibia11 ай бұрын

    I know a girl who worked as a sound technician on the show and she said that practically everyone in the studio broke down in tears when they filmed the help me scene. I think its safe to assume they did it justice

  • @unicornhuntercg

    @unicornhuntercg

    11 ай бұрын

    cap

  • @XxMonsterOpsxX

    @XxMonsterOpsxX

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Preetzole i will help you. Ill bring the bat, you bring the crowbar

  • @jorgearria5973

    @jorgearria5973

    11 ай бұрын

    If you are correct. I'm only going to you for the reliable info

  • @dontworryaboutit5490

    @dontworryaboutit5490

    11 ай бұрын

    I think it’s safe to say that that doesn’t actually mean anything, and that it isn’t safe to say they did it Justice.

  • @hellbunniez3

    @hellbunniez3

    11 ай бұрын

    at least show us your receipts bro 😤

  • @462n
    @462n11 ай бұрын

    One thing to keep in mind (especially with visuals like the scene where Nami's wig stands out), this was just a teaser trailer, and even actual trailers frequently have scenes that either don't make it into the final version or are slightly different. So basically, let's just wait and see if it still looks odd in the final product, and remember that teaser trailers are more about showing the vibe.

  • @voorlees9368

    @voorlees9368

    11 ай бұрын

    wellthe vibe i got was "Dogshit characterization of beloved characters" only one that seems alright is zoro and even then its only because hes doing zoros bullshit stoicisim he got after being beat by mihawk, so even thats fucked, we didnt even hear from usopp or sanji and seeing as how those two are the only ones to get major character changes (eyebrows and nose) i have far less hope for it, i dont give a fuck, the eyebros are a key detail to sanji. I can live without the nose, but i refuse to change on the brows. its gonna be dogshit and i genuinly hope this sinks netflix.

  • @Vainglory100

    @Vainglory100

    11 ай бұрын

    Yeah like the live action sonics trailer. It looked horrible but came out much better

  • @YSleepish

    @YSleepish

    11 ай бұрын

    @@voorlees9368 calm down lol u havent seen it yet

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    @@voorlees9368then leave and don’t make a positive comment negative.

  • @angelcordova3709
    @angelcordova370911 ай бұрын

    At this point idc if it would turn out good or bad. i'd still watch it with passion and marvel at how perfect the cast is

  • @gmmq654

    @gmmq654

    11 ай бұрын

    whitewashed cast, creazy how perfect that is to you lmfao.

  • @huggylul

    @huggylul

    11 ай бұрын

    @@gmmq654 bro what.... all of them more or less adhere to the nationalities set by Oda and even then if it was japanese ur point would be even worse. Not even good bait.

  • @angelcordova3709

    @angelcordova3709

    11 ай бұрын

    @@gmmq654 This is by far the worse comment I've read abt the live action 💀💀

  • @gmmq654

    @gmmq654

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@huggylul You are blind as shit. The entire cast not just the strawhats is 99% white. How the fuck is Koushiro, Kuro or Mihawk white? Koushiro should be obviously Japanese, Kuro should've been Korean and Mihawk should've been either Asian or Hispanic. Yet they're certified whiteboys. Even who they cast as Kuina isn't full Asian if shes even Asian at all. Even besides all of that, you know the fact that its a japanese show with obvious Asian characters that they turned white, how can you look at Sanji and think that is in any shape or form accurate? Bro looks like Eminem. You really think the entire One Piece universe goes like this Fishmen and Usopps family = Black, Zoro and Wano characters = Japanese not even Asian in general but Japanese and then everyone else is White?!? How?!?!? There should be way more Asian characters than currently present. Even just for pure aesthetic purposes, most of these characters that they made White don't look white at all as i previously mentioned.

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    @@gmmq654bros jealous with this being better then other live actions.

  • @zactheweebgod
    @zactheweebgod11 ай бұрын

    I feel like every one is forgetting that this is a TEASER trailer. That means we’ll get another one twice the length, it’ll probably show kuro Krieg maybe fish men and also I’m hoping for a small Mihawk tease

  • @OperationRebirth314

    @OperationRebirth314

    11 ай бұрын

    I think we already get a tease of the Mihawk-Zoro fight

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    Just happened lol

  • @WellDoneOnTheInternetEverybody
    @WellDoneOnTheInternetEverybody11 ай бұрын

    The moment Luffy put the straw hat on Nami was the scene that locked me into the 1000-episode long journey. You're so true in that how they handle it in the live action will determine how far the series goes.

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    Zoros introduction locked me in lol-

  • @BlazeMakesGames
    @BlazeMakesGames11 ай бұрын

    I feel like the issue of adaptation to live action is that with one piece it'll only get harder and harder to adapt as time goes on. Like you said One Piece is an incredibly cartoony series and that makes it really hard to translate to live action. And the issue is that it only gets more and more cartoony as time goes on. I'll admit that East Blue might be the easiest to adapt and this show could be great for all I know. But with every island that they travel to in the grand line, things only get weirder and crazier. Like I feel like it's going to be hard to have main characters in the cast like Chopper and Brook and Franky with their insane proportions and just everything about them and have them not look horrible in live action.

  • @kenzoog8349
    @kenzoog834911 ай бұрын

    just today, the people that watch a clip in anime expo and is good so far

  • @dustymingus2599
    @dustymingus259911 ай бұрын

    The cast chemistry is off the charts... all the interviews i've seen end up giving me the biggest stupid grin and i don't even notice it happening... I didn't like the trailer at first but it grew on me big time.

  • @MasterMarciTV
    @MasterMarciTV11 ай бұрын

    It is confirmed that the original voice actors voice the live action in japanese. With the known voices it feels so much natural

  • @diekerydock
    @diekerydock11 ай бұрын

    Good or bad. One piece fans will double in size, especially from new generations. Oda approved it, so do i. I love the anime more than 20 years. I will definitely watch it with open mind.

  • @XxMonsterOpsxX
    @XxMonsterOpsxX11 ай бұрын

    there are 3 things that make one piece amazing for me, 1 the story telling is amazing, the world building is amazing, the character development is amazing.

  • @codernakul
    @codernakul11 ай бұрын

    We want mushoku tensei weekly reviews 🎉

  • @gamingparadise3390
    @gamingparadise339011 ай бұрын

    teaser not trailer

  • @maximum2931
    @maximum293111 ай бұрын

    I wonder who’s gonna play Mihawk

  • @ONEPEAKFRFR
    @ONEPEAKFRFR11 ай бұрын

    What im scared about is if it succeeds and gets green lit for a season 2 aka the alabasta arc then that'd where were run into trouble especially sense there are a lot more devil fruit users and more moments and creatures that will be very cgi heavy

  • @GucciPucciMIH

    @GucciPucciMIH

    11 ай бұрын

    If they nail Smoker I'm confident they'll do fine with Crocodile

  • @TheYodelingViking

    @TheYodelingViking

    11 ай бұрын

    How will Chopper look if we get season 2? Especially since he has 7 transformations which will all appear numerous times and need to look great both for One Piece and for live action so can't be an exact replica nor too realistic (Though since it isn't Disney I'm slightly less worried on that part).

  • @cartoonishidealism582

    @cartoonishidealism582

    11 ай бұрын

    Mother's Basement recommended getting the Jim Henson company to do Age of Resistance-style puppets, costumes and animatronics and honestly I can't really see a better way without absolutely destroying their CGI budget.

  • @Merione

    @Merione

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@GucciPucciMIH Well, if Marvel could do Sandman in the Spider-Man 3 movie way back in 2007, I don't see any reason to worry about Crocodile

  • @Fanimei

    @Fanimei

    11 ай бұрын

    I think everything pre-timeskip is doable. It’s when you get past the timeskip where it gets way too bizarre.

  • @DL-idk
    @DL-idk11 ай бұрын

    I think they add the filter so the esthetic would be easier to handle in live action form. With too many color being too saturated, it could be tricky to make the scene look legit (aka everything work harmoniously together and very at home) and not some cheap, over the top fan cosplays where everything clashes with everything else.

  • @Svnkgaming_
    @Svnkgaming_11 ай бұрын

    Best video I’ve seen so far on the matter

  • @TheYodelingViking
    @TheYodelingViking11 ай бұрын

    My guess with Nami based on the trailer is there is only 1 boat to escape with after Alvida so Nami reluctantly goes with Luffy and Coby and has seen more of who he is before deciding to join which helps make her decision to save Luffy from Buggy make more sense in a live action setting since putting her life along with her village on the line for a man she met only 5 minutes ago wouldn't make too much sense. It isn't that different from the anime which had her see Luffy when escaping from Alvida which wasn't in the manga.

  • @frankpetrone
    @frankpetrone11 ай бұрын

    I new a guy who worked with Oda and apparently when he saw the final cut he pissed all over it and then said it was amazing

  • @jordan1thegame
    @jordan1thegame11 ай бұрын

    Just imagine gear 5 in live action

  • @arahcozy
    @arahcozy11 ай бұрын

    No matter what the people in the internet say…One Piece true fans will be happy to watch this it might weird a little but I will never hating it. I’m just happy my Fav Anime since I was kid is getting so popular. I don’t care what hater gonna say… I’m freaking love One Piece. They make my life full and happy.

  • @DeBean970

    @DeBean970

    11 ай бұрын

    That's dumb. A true fan can like what they like.

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    @@DeBean970huh- I’m confused, are you with her/him or not-?

  • @mochhhhee
    @mochhhhee11 ай бұрын

    Iñaki GOAT! Honestly. I think he is able to pull it off in no small part because he’s Mexican. We genuinely talk like that and it’s not exaggerated or “cringe” so it comes off as sincere

  • @astralblast6627
    @astralblast662711 ай бұрын

    One Piece is a fun anime. It always portrays as a fun, bizarre/absurd silly-goofy show...all in all it's fun to watch. Just don't put too much comparison with the live action film and the Anime & manga. One Piece has always been a light-hearted action adventure anime, it never tried to depict deep intense stories...so I hope the writers will keep that in mind. Luffy's crew is a fun bunch, the best thing of the anime, pls portray that in the movie. I am actually excited for the movie.

  • @Mf_CHIP
    @Mf_CHIP11 ай бұрын

    No live action adaptasion will ever top Speed Racer

  • @thomasffrench3639

    @thomasffrench3639

    11 ай бұрын

    Eh, Speed Racer isn’t really a Speed Racer adaptation tho. I would say it’s terrible as an adaptation. Also Ruroni Kenshin is better.

  • @ONEPEAKFRFR

    @ONEPEAKFRFR

    11 ай бұрын

    Facts! that movie was fun as hell!

  • @superdrifter-1773

    @superdrifter-1773

    11 ай бұрын

    @@thomasffrench3639speed racer is the only anime live adaptation that has the quirks of anime and still works. Other adaptations haven’t got that special charm that speed racer has

  • @zulkifli4201

    @zulkifli4201

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@ONEPEAKFRFRit was mid There is still alot good Anime LA out there

  • @zulkifli4201

    @zulkifli4201

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@superdrifter-1773not really though

  • @murphy2013
    @murphy201310 ай бұрын

    After weeks of just getting more and more information and scenes from the show leading up to the release, I think I’m glad they didn’t make Sanji’s eyebrows curly or Usopp’s nose. Not only would it be harder to deal with when it comes to fight choreography, especially the nose, but I feel like the more you look at stuff like that on your screen the more you realize it looks really fake or stands out. Idk that’s just me

  • @dudenamedchris3325
    @dudenamedchris332511 ай бұрын

    Why did you use a one blade sword on the thumbnail, when your title is "The Double Edged Sword"?

  • @draggo69
    @draggo6911 ай бұрын

    Nice!

  • @level1life79
    @level1life7911 ай бұрын

    The thing is if they pull this off it has the potential to actually be the greatest TV show of all time

  • @voorlees9368

    @voorlees9368

    11 ай бұрын

    Breaking bad: *Laughs* also bruh, FUCK NO. if its the greatest tv show then it has to beat the original anime, aND YOU CAHAHAHAHAHAHA FU*CK ME THAT TO FUCKIN FUNNY HAHAHAHAHHAHAALMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOO AND YOU ACTUALLY BELIEVE THAT? LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @lilyfields3748

    @lilyfields3748

    11 ай бұрын

    Greatest la. I mean, I’ll think it’s the best tv show, but others will def disagree with you.

  • @tobiaswedin
    @tobiaswedin11 ай бұрын

    My biggest problem with the live action is that they're playing it too safe (in their minds). They have removed everything "too wacky", which is a fundamental core of what makes One Piece what it is, and swapped out Oda's unique sense of humor with standard Marvel banter. They should have gone all out giving Usopp his long nose, the Merry more cutesey, Sanji having his twirl brow, Luffy's portrayal more source correct as a boy of few (but blunt and stupid) words and all the characters more goofy gag type reactions. Those who'd argue that it doesn't work are just not suitable to make it in technical terms or have enough faith in Oda's humor for it to go well outside Japan (even though the manga and anime being such a hit says otherwise), go find someone that is confident and creative enough about being able to. And the "for a wider audience" argument is BS as One Piece already has one of the biggest audiences on the planet, no need to expand for it to make serious bank.

  • @piratekingluffy376

    @piratekingluffy376

    11 ай бұрын

    Honestly agree with you, this show has zero chance. They showed zero scenes from fishman island. No fishmen so either arlong Park isn’t in season 1 or the fishman cgi is that bad, idk I have this feeling they are gonna use the fight with zoro and mihawk as the finale of sorts, maybe use nami leaving the crew as a cliffhanger. But if not then arlong Park is gonna be a visual horror show. I have little faith in cgi hachi and cgi arlong

  • @Spork2

    @Spork2

    11 ай бұрын

    @@piratekingluffy376Arlong Park is confirmed to be in the show, they just haven’t shown it in the first trailer

  • @piratekingluffy376

    @piratekingluffy376

    11 ай бұрын

    @@Spork2 I don’t think one piece is meant for live action. It’s too whacky and creative, the designs that we love from the show won’t be adapted well. I think a lot of it is gonna feel either bizarre or underwhelming

  • @flavioalbatrozz2557
    @flavioalbatrozz255711 ай бұрын

    One piece is like the live action of Flintstones, GRINCH or Adam's Family. Basically will be a little "kinder campy". You should watch this like an "alice in wonderland" or "wizard of oz" type of movie.

  • @ar14237
    @ar1423711 ай бұрын

    Not saying arlong park is not a great ark. But it was barratie that hooked me personally the fact that it captured how cooks act in a Kitchen or at least every kitchen I have work in

  • @DeBean970

    @DeBean970

    11 ай бұрын

    Same. Except it was Sanji's original characterisation that got me hooked

  • @sabelotoda2
    @sabelotoda211 ай бұрын

    The color that they decided to give the live action is brilliant and perfect in my opinion and I have seen other people saying that they don't like it but it seems that they do not understand the thematic decision behind the color palette, if you look closely the color is medium yellow like the dawn and the first arc of the manga is the romance dawn , luffy represents the sun and he and his crew represent the dawn of a new era and the end of the darknes perpetuated by the world government that is why i love the color palette It is thematically perfect, especially for this first season.

  • @pedro6720

    @pedro6720

    11 ай бұрын

    Is just a filter, is not that deep

  • @Bigmiquimby

    @Bigmiquimby

    11 ай бұрын

    ​@@pedro6720it's One Piece. It's probably THAT deep if they're trying to do it justice.

  • @sabelotoda2

    @sabelotoda2

    11 ай бұрын

    @@pedro6720 although obviously I don't know why they chose that color I am a film producer and I can assure you that what I said is not far from the possibility, all the great filmmakers think in that way and deeply about things that a normal person who watches a movie thinks that It is "easy and not so deep" so believe me that the color they are using they thought about before deciding why and surely they considered the type of things that I mentioned.

  • @mrs.sugawara9184
    @mrs.sugawara918411 ай бұрын

    I can finally show my mom what one piece is! She doesn't want to watch the anime cuz it's anime😅

  • @Soguwe
    @Soguwe11 ай бұрын

    The manga doesn't go anywhere Neither does the anime We only gain another interpretation of a thing we love deeply I for one am happy to see Luffy and gang in yet another light, be it a slightly less cartoony one

  • @drbarryva
    @drbarryva11 ай бұрын

    A part of me feels like thisbis it, this is the deciding factor thatll either save netflix, or finally put it to the ground

  • @tximinoman
    @tximinoman11 ай бұрын

    I didn't hate the trailer, which is the biggest praise I can give, given that I never expected to like the Netflix adaptation to begin with. This story is way too important for me (I've been reading/watching One Piece since I was like 11 or 12 and I just recently turned 34, I've known the Strawhats for longer than I've known most of my friends at this point) so since they first announced this project I already knew that regardless of what they did, it was going to rub me the wrong way, regardless of it's quality. BUT that being said, I can't deny it looks more promising than I expected. As you say in your video, the heart of One Piece has always been the Strawhats and they seem to have find the right actors for the job (I agree Iñaki looks unexpectedly promising as Luffy), so, you know, better than expected already. And I agree with your fear for this series because that's also my biggest complaint with the trailer, they seem to have grounded the background while still commiting to faithfulness in the costume designs and it just looks a bit off. I personally think the backgrounds look great (even if less colorful than the manga), they seem to have hitted the sweet-spot between realism and cartoony in my opinion and they seem to have gone for their own personal take on the OP world, which is great... but then Nami looks like someone cosplaying as her, and the Strawhat looks too clean and too... cheap? I don't know. They don't seem to have adapted the costumes so they don't seem to fit well and everything ends up looking kind of off and kind of weird IMO. But that being said, I'll definitely watch the first season when it drops. Because I think this project deserves a chance even if is something I don't expect to like very much (because that's mostly my problem) and I know how important those early views are for Netflix. And I just hope it's as good as it can be, and if it helps bring more attention to my favourite story then that's a win.

  • @rasdan1192
    @rasdan119211 ай бұрын

    I was actually wonder whose idea bringing One Piece to Live Action?

  • @Gojo___Satoru___
    @Gojo___Satoru___11 ай бұрын

    I Wonder how the three powerful men such as Gol D roger , Edward Newgate , Kozuki Oden look like in live action

  • @whoopsie321
    @whoopsie32111 ай бұрын

    I expect some characters aint gonna be making it into the show like Gaimon especially since the show is only 8 episodes. And I don't think Alvida will make it to Loguetown cus they would have to either change the actress or just completely CGI it which would look weird.

  • @srensen9948sander
    @srensen9948sander11 ай бұрын

    Great video, fair opinions. Are you watching jujustu Kaisen season 2

  • @radityapoerwanto7018
    @radityapoerwanto701811 ай бұрын

    Honestly, I prefer if the budget spent for live action used for another animated movie. No matter how good it is, Netflix live action adaptation won't ever match up to the animation/manga.

  • @mrkaji8913
    @mrkaji891311 ай бұрын

    2:24 I lived Netflix bebop and bleach

  • @MarkFilipAnthony
    @MarkFilipAnthony11 ай бұрын

    I disagree that it can't be done in Live action. I feel the argument is that OP is too cartoony, but I disagree. The cartoony part isn't what makes OP special. While it is that on the surface, it's actually very grounded and raw. One just have to take the series seriously

  • @DRCx_
    @DRCx_11 ай бұрын

    The thumbnail is a single edged sword and that's hilarious to me

  • @level1life79
    @level1life7911 ай бұрын

    Im so excited for this show i just bought a toooon of One Piece clothes on Light in the Box

  • @piratekingluffy376
    @piratekingluffy37611 ай бұрын

    I’m a just say, there is a reason we didn’t see any fishmen in that trailer, either they are gonna hold on arlong park til a season 2 or that fishman cgi was not good for the trailer

  • @NotAWhaleAtAll
    @NotAWhaleAtAll11 ай бұрын

    Only clocked on it because one-edged sword in the thumbnail is hilarious

  • @AngellMessiah
    @AngellMessiah11 ай бұрын

    I do believe you can make a live-action cartoon, because it's been done. Scott pilgrim is one example.

  • @enshongmiranda
    @enshongmiranda11 ай бұрын

    The lack of color is just jarring.

  • @markblackburn7563
    @markblackburn756311 ай бұрын

    I’m excited for it, but part of that is because I’ve always wanted to get my family’s into One Piece, but they don’t wanna watch anime.

  • @tvMage
    @tvMage11 ай бұрын

    if you thought they needed to catch everything perfectly but the darkness of it makes it more real they cant do straight up cartoon copy

  • @diarrhea6344
    @diarrhea634410 ай бұрын

    Will you ever continue reviewing the chapters of Houseki no Kuni manga?

  • @Juju_Miner
    @Juju_Miner11 ай бұрын

    What has me feeling optimistic is it feels like they got the “spirit” right. Hard to explain it other than that.

  • @makodoesstuff
    @makodoesstuff11 ай бұрын

    One of my biggest hopes is that they have the actor for live action Luffy (or at least someone who sounds similar) sing we are

  • @mrkaji8913
    @mrkaji891311 ай бұрын

    There are already good ones: alita, detective pikachu, sonic, edge of tomorrow, and even cowboy bebop

  • @jamessizemore7103
    @jamessizemore710311 ай бұрын

    I’m excited to give it a try. If they get the characters and charisma right, I’ll forgive lousy effects. Because let’s face it, TV CG has never been that great but we still loved shows like supernatural and Star Trek because the actors go all out and bring the worlds to life

  • @chadgrimwell8380
    @chadgrimwell838011 ай бұрын

    Look promising actually. Now I don't know if I would subscribe to Netflix just for this.

  • @_sogeking
    @_sogeking11 ай бұрын

    10:03 actually I think they said that that is Emily Rudd's hair

  • @Mercyswaifu
    @Mercyswaifu11 ай бұрын

    Still can’t get over how live action luffy sounds like he suffered brain damage

  • @Beabubop
    @Beabubop11 ай бұрын

    im gonna be looking for the goofiness of the characters between arcs its gonna be hard for them since most of pre timeskip is pure goofiness, but if they capture that goofiness im good

  • @user-qn4qu4ow8p
    @user-qn4qu4ow8p11 ай бұрын

    I'm sorry, but all my hopes went down the drain after hearing Luffy drop a MCU one-liner.

  • @jordantompkins9112
    @jordantompkins911211 ай бұрын

    YO why didn't they get the people who made the Speed Racer movie to do this? That movie was incredible at how it conveyed anime vibes and expressions on a live action screen. The color and effects where poppin' and it just played like an anime

  • @fumomofumosarum5893
    @fumomofumosarum589311 ай бұрын

    Yeah that "Mexican Western" filter is a bit grading... not really sure whose decision that was. It's completely unnecessary. And the Flying Lamb figurehead. Yikes. But still, this will be a wild ride. I'm sure twitter will blow up...

  • @leonishikino6873
    @leonishikino687311 ай бұрын

    My big take away for live action adaptations is if the spirit of the source material is able to shine through, that's a big draw for me and I don't mind departures from the source as long as it's done in respect. It's a huge part of why I really love Hideaki Anno's Cutie Honey movie rather than Cutie Honey: Tears which premiered years later despite both being LA adapts that took liberties with their source. Anno's adapt kept the spirit and even went back to his Tokusatsu loving roots with the characters esp loved how cheesy everything seemed to be in contrast to how serious the script had been. In terms of American adapts tho, im very cautious as Alita and Speed Racer are what I feel were the best done by an overseas director/s. In all honesty, One Piece's adapt could be very good if they remember to keep the spirit of the source in tact and keep the whimsical outfits I've seen from a lot of characters. Like not everything needs to be down in the dumps and serious so I might give this a watch as I'm reading the source.

  • @kaizerapa1814
    @kaizerapa181411 ай бұрын

    Think the washed out filter tone might actually work in it's favour when the tone gets serious, wich is what I'm hoping for and not just be for kids only.

  • @ArmaHipHopTV

    @ArmaHipHopTV

    11 ай бұрын

    It's apparently MA rated so you might be in luck.

  • @kaizerapa1814

    @kaizerapa1814

    11 ай бұрын

    @@ArmaHipHopTV is that for real? 😲😳

  • @mechajay3358
    @mechajay335811 ай бұрын

    I waiting until the show actually comes out to see if its worth giving a chance. Especially since Netflix's track record of Live Action shows based of popular Anime/Manga, I still have aot of skepticisms about it.

  • @GyulaHorvathGarijin
    @GyulaHorvathGarijin11 ай бұрын

    I find it funny how rare it is mentioned, but for me it all comes down to how fast can I get used to the non-japanese voices. The rest of the pie I can swallow, regardless of the filling.

  • @jordanarogeti2444
    @jordanarogeti244411 ай бұрын

    Where can we read that article you showed of oda saying emily’s help me scene was perfect??

  • @mckillalaberry

    @mckillalaberry

    11 ай бұрын

    People been saying this since the release of the trailer 😄💔It's cap

  • @Yuurkk
    @Yuurkk11 ай бұрын

    I feel like op live action should be watched in a different logical mindset than in anime non logic mindset that don’t follow reality

  • @digital-underworld
    @digital-underworld11 ай бұрын

    I have a lot of issues with the netflix live-action adaptation of one piece. Some of the things just look off and don't translate well as a live-action show. I've made my peace that some things just aren't possible considering the source material and world it's set in, but at the same time I think there is so much that the trailers got right and did well. I really hope that my issues with the adaptation will fade away while watching the actual show.

  • @AsuraOkami
    @AsuraOkami11 ай бұрын

    I am ambivalent about the show going into it when I watch it. Some parts about the trailer I liked and others I disliked. One major dislike I can't stand is the way the Inaki said gum gum pistol, it just feels so off.

  • @heroborgswe5418
    @heroborgswe541811 ай бұрын

    Who will be brook?

  • @LathropLdST
    @LathropLdST11 ай бұрын

    A certain Eichiiro Oda is in production. Not sure if you are aware.

  • @R3TR0J4N
    @R3TR0J4N2 ай бұрын

    casting is great it grew on me. i miss a pridefull Zoro, or just his lines doesnt live up w/ the grounded take theshow is going for tahts why

  • @thesis-and-nieces6722
    @thesis-and-nieces672211 ай бұрын

    This looks great and a competition for Pirates of Caribbean. I just hope there is no bait and switch midway, where they put agenda driven narratives

  • @dragonleo_lemon7184
    @dragonleo_lemon718411 ай бұрын

    the sword on the thumbnail is NOT double edged. no hate tho, this is a nice video

  • @rinlewis9383
    @rinlewis938311 ай бұрын

    Bruh, they're not wearing wigs, their actual hair has been styled. I've seen pics of Nami's actress hair that has been styled. They don't wanna look like cosplayers. Well yeah, some background characters wore wig, at least who are required to.

  • @Treblebeatgames
    @Treblebeatgames11 ай бұрын

    I love the idea of the thumb nail but am here to nitpick that katanas are single edge swords. Have a good day

  • @GiRR007
    @GiRR00711 ай бұрын

    When it comes to adaptation you cant take every thing that's silly about one piece and implement it into live action, it just wouldn't make sense. Live action is a different medium and is for different people. It has different strengths and weaknesses compared to animation and thus should play into those strengths.

  • @joshuaflask3091
    @joshuaflask309111 ай бұрын

    Well when you have 150M budget but you really need like a 200M budget and need to increase it every season

  • @infinitygauntlet101
    @infinitygauntlet10111 ай бұрын

    I kinda dont like Zoro on this. He was already broody eventhough he hasnt met Mihawk yet.

  • @that_dude_over_there
    @that_dude_over_there11 ай бұрын

    Here’s the thing, people just want it to be good. It shouldn’t aim to be an alternative for the original, just to be good enough to stand on its own two feet

  • @Strav24
    @Strav2411 ай бұрын

    I always say if you don't like one piece by the end of along park them its not for you. So it truly is the best test for if they will be able to capture the essence of this show

  • @logangant7732
    @logangant773211 ай бұрын

    here’s the question? is it a thousand episodes

  • @Blaze-fo9mo
    @Blaze-fo9mo11 ай бұрын

    They removed usoap long nose 😭 Edit: pica and chopper in the live action 💀

  • @KIDZMONDAY
    @KIDZMONDAY11 ай бұрын

    So choppr is there or not?

  • @TarunOG
    @TarunOG11 ай бұрын

    switch tah bb vs luffy meme wtf

  • @nfa_copium2479
    @nfa_copium247911 ай бұрын

    To be honest. I hope they adapt at least until alabasta

  • @The_True_Warrior
    @The_True_Warrior11 ай бұрын

    Better nail the baritea

  • @whathappenswhenimbored
    @whathappenswhenimbored11 ай бұрын

    I hope it's more stage-play and less live-action remake. It seems stage-play like based on the character acting and the costume design, but the ugly coloring and "cinematic" camera shots scream live-action remake.

  • @robis9364
    @robis936411 ай бұрын

    Would minks be real animals or people will be dressed as animals?

  • @BaldorfBreakdowns
    @BaldorfBreakdowns11 ай бұрын

    I feel like all the dialogue is waay too restrained, the facial expressions too. Everyone looks and sounds too serious. They need to go all in, but it doesn't seem like they are going to.

  • @joshuaflask3091
    @joshuaflask309111 ай бұрын

    I just am like how far will they go in the One Piece seriece I mean East Blue sure but like some archs like whole cake island, dressrossorosa, water seven, and more I don't seee how they can do it

  • @BrotherhoodsCreed

    @BrotherhoodsCreed

    11 ай бұрын

    I dont think theres anyway theyd be able to without huge timejumps cutting out tons of content as the actors will age considerably between seasons. By season 3 or 4 they will be like 6 or 7 years older. If by some chance they get to new world arcs, the actors would be 10 plus years older and no longer look like young adults.

  • @piratekingluffy376

    @piratekingluffy376

    11 ай бұрын

    @@BrotherhoodsCreedthe show is gonna flop, imma just say this, there is a reason we didn’t see any fishmen in that trailer. People are forgetting about, hachi arlong and the,other fishmen, forget cgi raccoon dog. CGI octopus man

  • @gensischosen251
    @gensischosen25110 ай бұрын

    It could potentially best Anime live action adaptation ever and Netflix really made a come back from having that awful death note live action.

  • @angelopellicci179
    @angelopellicci17911 ай бұрын

    The issue I have with the existence of this show has less to do with it specifically, but more so with an issue I’ve had with entertainment in general in recent years. WHAT IS THE OBSESSION WITH MAKING THINGS LIVE ACTION??? I really don’t get it. Everything is live action adaptations now and it really doesn’t make any sense. What’s the point of animation even existing if you’re going to try to make it live action? Why not have animated adaptations of live action movies and shows? Animation and live action lend themselves to different forms of visual storytelling that’s unique unto them, so it makes no sense why so why so much effort is being put into making a series about an already existing series that isn’t only insanely popular, but is still currently going on. Not only that, but the series is so cartoonish that in order to make it live action certain changes r needed so it doesn’t look so weird. So as a result the story loses part of what made it special and what it makes it it. So it’ll just be a shell if what it already is. And for what? For the sake of making it in live action! Cuz that’s the new craze, and it allows for these properties to be milked to death with how much money they can make.

  • @user-AADZ
    @user-AADZ11 ай бұрын

    Tldr: netflix *could* suck

  • @strawbunnyramune7742
    @strawbunnyramune774211 ай бұрын

    for the little things they are doing i hope they don't try to make the acting on the expression too cartony and instead any shenanigans the cast get into together be more focused on the fact that they are are technically still teenagers, a good example some of the interaction and reactions are exaggerated in the anime for comedy where as here I hope they take more realistic approach or as realistic as they can get , in the anime zoro and sanji fight over little things and amp it up to 10 with the cartony way of bickering, where as here i hope they tone it down and just translate it to them having realistic yet petty fights and getting on each others nerves but not going so goofy " you see them into be covered by a dust cloud as they fight and wrestle and you can hear them call each other childish nicknames", or like with nami she has over expressive angry reactions played up for when the rest of the crew is kind of acting goofy and just down right stupid, and again I hope in the show I hope they just play off some of that anger as her being ticked off and kind of struggling to keep the peace in a crew with mostly guys, also I know everyone might not like the pacing of the series but I do hope they take certain route when making some of the other charters join luffy and don't make it to unrealistic since they don't have that many episodes to show of their dynamic and how they work well together , zoro nami and luffy are shown to not fully accept or agree on the idea of becoming a crew unlike the different pacing in the anime, what im hoping for is that they take the time in the series to show even in jut little aspect or moments, how the characters can grow to trust and look after one another and even become friends and in the end some what respect luffy as their captain,as a one piece fan I agree that the show wont be everyone's cup of tea, but when the full trailer comes out I think that will realy be the last nail on the coffin or a beacon of hope depending whether you are a die hard fan, and average watcher of the anime, or just a person that has never watched or read anything one piece related

  • @piratekingluffy376

    @piratekingluffy376

    11 ай бұрын

    This is the issue because the goofiness is an integral function in the one piece universe, the show will not have the same charm. Just think about all the different whacky character designs there are, all the whack df attacks, I just don’t see this show living up to the hype

  • @strawbunnyramune7742

    @strawbunnyramune7742

    11 ай бұрын

    @@piratekingluffy376 I know that the goofiness is a integral part and it shall be missed I just really really really hope they don't make it weird or uncanny if that makes sense, it obviously wont live up to the hype, that is clear to me but for all the hard work they put into the show I hope some parts can be note worthy and pleasing to some fans, I guess what im trying to say is that I hope it finds a nice home right down the middle you know? not so amazing that everyone's like " this is even better than the original!!! :0" ( because lets be honest I don't see that happening) but not so bad everyone's like " this is straight up garbage and cringe!!!! I hate one piece now!!! and the actors suck!!!!" , but then again all we can do is wait and see

Келесі