the real question is: Did Alyson really take Seren up on her invitation to milkshakes?

The software did not fail. It did figure out which card was missing from the deck hence the “we did it for real”. When the “error” occurs and a bunch of cards are displayed the first and last cards are significant. Everything else on the display is distraction. The suit in the first card matches the missing card. Add the value of the first and last card to get the value of the missing card. An ace on the screen would likely always indicate a 1 so that every card in the deck can be represented by two cards on the screen. In this case the 4 of spades was the first card which establishes that Penn’s card is a spade. The last card is a three of clubs. Ignore the suit and add 3 to 4 to get 7 so Penn’s card is the 7 of spades. Not so sure how he got Allison’s card.

I love this so much, as a Dad and a magician. Great to see years of preparation pay off! And the time spent together is priceless. Wonderful job.

That was a hard build to a mediocre ending

Wow that was painful to watch.

she literally told Penn 'i dont respect you" lol not very smart...

And ladies don’t let your dad cut your hair!

Great performance. Nice to see how well Seren held her own on stage... not easy to have that confidence for a teenager to do so in this situation. That level of confidence speaks of a very bright future... whether in magic or doing something else. Impressive.

Great trick. Great use of software and technology. ...and by that I mean fooling the viewer into thinking this is in front of a live audience. Yeah... there's nobody there. Seats are empty. which is why there's a scene behind Penn and Teller. A few audience tracks are used and voila... totally fooled.

ngl this is one of the most confusing and unengaging routines I have ever seen on this show.

"I had to bring a Star with me" at

I'm 29, and if I was on a stage like that, I would crumble into dust. Many props to Seren for performing so well. What a wholesome trick. You fooled me even if I caught a bit of Penn's double-talk. Fantastic job.

I think this is the first time I've seen a father daughter pair on the show and it's super sweet, Seren is just adorable

I can’t tell if Penn’s clues confirm or deny it, but my suspicion is that someone is extraordinarily observant, and both of you communicate like only a father and daughter can. ❤

Great trick & performance. Whether fooling the pros or not, it looked like you both enjoyed your time and it looked seamless. The fact that you made it on tape, should give you confidence that you are in the elite group of magicians now, congratulations. Keep pushing forward.

Jeez. How freaking wholesome is that? Good on both of you!

A lot of fun!

Delightful! I've now subscribed and can't wait to watch more of this magical duo. Brava/Bravo!

that was so much fun! want to see more of you guys

Good stuff! Enjoyed your routine. Keep up the good work! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼