RUSH-LEAVE THAT THING ALONE- REACTION

Музыка

#rush #music #bass

Пікірлер: 279

  • @squamishfish
    @squamishfish3 ай бұрын

    YYZ is the bands most popular instrumental, Try YYZ Live in Rio, see 60 thousand fans singing to the instrumental

  • @traumaturgist

    @traumaturgist

    2 ай бұрын

    Yeah everyone says this but, audience novelty aside, this is NOT their best performance (you can see Geddy's face when he flubs a note). I wish everyone would stop saying this is such a great performance just because of the crowd

  • @traumaturgist

    @traumaturgist

    2 ай бұрын

    @@SA-cn4jc Awwww, a widdle twiggered aren't we widdle boy?

  • @traumaturgist

    @traumaturgist

    2 ай бұрын

    @@SA-cn4jc LOL where in fact did I diss Rush? I said that this wasn't their best performance. I'd refer anyone to the YYZ off Different Stages as a far superior performance (or the live version off the Moving Pictures 40th Anniversary album). Nowhere was I criticising Rush as a band. That was obvious and you missed it, which makes you sound like a feeble little fanboy more than anything else.

  • @shahabodinrahnama2397

    @shahabodinrahnama2397

    Ай бұрын

    ngl it gave me goosebumps

  • @kidkong637

    @kidkong637

    19 күн бұрын

    In my 70 years I’ve never seen a crowd rock like that.

  • @Mondaydark2o12
    @Mondaydark2o123 ай бұрын

    Geddy Lee is so good. That dude makes music happen. Rush is just amazing its kinda sad that they are just now being more noticed mainstream. Rush is a music lovers band.

  • @gj7aj
    @gj7aj3 ай бұрын

    YYZ live in Rio is another great instrumental by Rush.

  • @peterf4552

    @peterf4552

    3 ай бұрын

    An instrumental sing-along.

  • @kentgreer1079
    @kentgreer10793 ай бұрын

    Ah, the chickens. In the early days, both Geddy and Alex had the mandatory stack of amps behind them, either side of Neil's drum kit. But eventually, Geddy decided to run his bass directly through the PA system. So no stack of amps on Geddy's side of the stage. And this look unbalanced. So, as a joke, they first added clothes dryers, the kind you find at a laundromat. this also gave the a place to put t-shirts that Geddy and Alex could throw into the audience. As time went on, the stuff behind Geddy changed. Vending machines, popcorn machines, and rotisserie chicken ovens. There are other live shows where a guy in a chicken suit came out to baste the chickens in the rotisseries. On this tour, when they had a 'machine' theme, the rubber chickens were being thrown into a vat. Rush really enjoyed a good joke. You should watch their acceptance speeches when the were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame after many years of being ignored. Alex's speech is hilarious, although Geddy and Neil pretend to club him with their trophies they just received.

  • @greenehorn
    @greenehornАй бұрын

    We’re so happy to have you with us in the Rush community. Your appreciation is noted. I saw them live on ten tours over 35 years and it changed my life.

  • @scotttolson8179
    @scotttolson81793 ай бұрын

    I saw other commenters say to check out the live version of "Where's my thing/Here it is". Lots of great Bass work by Geddy, and includes a Neil Peart drum solo as well.

  • @juliebrockett3471
    @juliebrockett34713 ай бұрын

    Great reaction Church Boy! This was great! A lot of people are requesting, “Where’s my Thing”! That’s great , but another one is “Malignant Narcisissn”(live snakes and arrows tour) Geddy rocks a Jaco Pastorius bass! And it has a really cool drum solo at the end!! Be well and God bless… from Texas!!

  • @darrenobayashi6528
    @darrenobayashi65283 ай бұрын

    Rush was always focused on being a live act. Whenever possible it is always better live. They play their stuff almost exactly as they record it on their albums, on the rare occasion they change something, it becomes even better... ;)

  • @Steve_Blackwood

    @Steve_Blackwood

    3 ай бұрын

    Yeah, this has always been my take. I have all their studio albums, and wore them out, but getting to see them actually make the magic just takes it to the next level.

  • @RaymondBCrisp
    @RaymondBCrisp3 ай бұрын

    When you said you needed more bass, I knew you'd like this one. I feel that after this song, you realize that their live versions are the way to go. They are, bar none, the tightest rock band I've seen live. And I've seen some really great groups like Pink Floyd, Yes, and Genesis, all prog rock groups themselves, with their own sound and odd time signature songs too, but great, great acts. As tight as their sound was, I don't think they were quite as in-sync as Rush. You play music, so you know what I'm talking about. It's not when a group is playing notes together that sets great musicians apart, it's when they all rest together, and you have that perfect moment with the absence of sound (ghost notes, I believe some call them), to me that defines truly tight musicians. I don't think I've seen anyone else that quite replicates that as well live as these guys do. They are just machines, their musicianship is so good. So, you've not heard a song with words. I will offer you this one, from 1981, so a classic. Xanadu, Live from Exit Stage Left - kzread.info/dash/bejne/Y5en08aoctbAj6g.html

  • @djlaino
    @djlaino3 ай бұрын

    I love how Geddy broke Church Boy's mind at the end of the song. Rush are musicians' musicians. Three virtuosos with a synergy universally recognized by others, yet with a humbleness and dedication to the music so appreciated by their fans. We are so lucky they were able to stay together for so long and generate so much good music. I am glad they are still making fans of new listeners. And I thank them every time I hear them.

  • @kimbarry4674
    @kimbarry46743 ай бұрын

    If you don't mind the Professor with a solo in the middle of the song MALIGNANT NARCISSIM live is a great 1 too ❤🇨🇦

  • @Matty0923

    @Matty0923

    3 ай бұрын

    ...and who in their right mind would mind a Neil Peart drum solo?

  • @rickthestiks9240

    @rickthestiks9240

    3 ай бұрын

    yeah, another good one,,,👍

  • @freewill8218

    @freewill8218

    3 ай бұрын

    Usually a case of malignant narcissism brought on during childhood.

  • @vicenteraira
    @vicenteraira3 ай бұрын

    Yes! Down with the RushRabbitHole! Please do Spirit of Radio or Natural Science next.

  • @smellytheclam5812

    @smellytheclam5812

    3 ай бұрын

    Natural Science is the song that hooked me on Rush 30 years ago. A must listen!!!

  • @dalemerrifield8308

    @dalemerrifield8308

    3 ай бұрын

    If you do Natural Science, do the live one. Great energy

  • @greggmyers7505
    @greggmyers75053 ай бұрын

    8:35 "they have a kinship", you are correct sir!

  • @DanLaTour12
    @DanLaTour123 ай бұрын

    One thing RUSH does is perfection. So much so that when MTV approached them to go unplugged, they declined the invitation. So whether they are live or not isn’t an issue. Going live only gives you the addition of the crowd, which is priceless in my opinion. So no matter which way you go you will always get that RUSH.

  • @Matty0923
    @Matty09233 ай бұрын

    You would also love Malignant Narcissism and Where's my thing/here it is live, both awesome

  • @spiffymick7073
    @spiffymick70733 ай бұрын

    Love your Rush reactions. It's refreshing to have somebody with a musical background see what's going on. Geddy's finest playing as often running free under one of Alex's solos. Please check out Freewill, the studio version, the lyrics might 'poke' at you a bit, but listen to the bassline of Geddy going nutso under the guitar solo.

  • @dalemerrifield8308

    @dalemerrifield8308

    3 ай бұрын

    All three of them enter the realm of absolute lunacy during that solo. If you ever listen to the isolated drums during that song it will just floor you.

  • @michaelwhalen7154
    @michaelwhalen71543 ай бұрын

    Rush is best appreciated live. You might like Working Man live in Cleveland. Love your insightful reactions!

  • @user-xu1jo4yb8r

    @user-xu1jo4yb8r

    2 ай бұрын

    As long as it's a good recording, you are right. There are some bad mixes out there. Even R40. So so clean. But I found a few that were muddy

  • @juliewensel4468
    @juliewensel44683 ай бұрын

    Awesome storytelling, no need to apologize. I can still watch you watch Rush all day,. I look forward to our journey.

  • @benredmond6636
    @benredmond66363 ай бұрын

    I get excited when I see you doing a RUSH reaction

  • @chriskangeter8993
    @chriskangeter89933 ай бұрын

    Geddy and the band refer to their instrumentals as "band solo's". They are all going off at the same time.

  • @ector6187
    @ector61873 ай бұрын

    Just for exceptional soloing by both bass and guitar, and some drums, you have to check out Working Man - Live in Cleveland. The visuals of their interplay is amazing.

  • @matthewhoag2609
    @matthewhoag26093 ай бұрын

    The thing about a guitar solo in Rush is it’s usually more of a 3-way instrumental explosion, lol. Some of the work Geddy does under Alex’s solos is amazing. Try the song Freewill (studio) for a great example. Working Man live in Cleveland is another great one with all three of them shredding in the instrumental sections.

  • @debbieplato5107
    @debbieplato51073 ай бұрын

    I would always suggest doing a live version when it comes to Rush. Malignant Narcissism from the Snakes and Arrows tour Where's my thing, /Here it is live in Dallas Cheers

  • @rickthestiks9240
    @rickthestiks92403 ай бұрын

    👍 up to the peoples who suggest that one,, whit geddy;s skills... legend ,, right there,,,🎸🤘🤘🤘

  • @user-vl5sm9wu1s
    @user-vl5sm9wu1s3 ай бұрын

    Rush is a rare band that their live music is very close to the studio releases

  • @brilof2112
    @brilof21123 ай бұрын

    Beautiful story about your brother. Music is so powerful and universal. Loved your commentary about RUSH's timing, definitely brothers from different mothers.😀

  • @toronto57
    @toronto573 ай бұрын

    With rush live is always better..

  • @stevenmonte7397
    @stevenmonte73973 ай бұрын

    Phenomenal!!!!!!

  • @ActualFactualMagic
    @ActualFactualMagic3 ай бұрын

    Geddy plays his bass almost like a Spanish guitar. If you watch close he will strum through strings in both directions. Almost like he's picking but using his fingers as the picks. When he is playing a simple line he plays like most bass players. But when he runs a fast riff he will often strum through the strings with his fingers. Incredible.

  • @garysteinert8040
    @garysteinert80403 ай бұрын

    Live version if released by RUSH. Chickens, Laundry, vending machines, they never took themselves to serious.

  • @frederickstamm-rr1qj
    @frederickstamm-rr1qj3 ай бұрын

    It’s amazing how music can touch the heart , no matter what listen to it, it’s something that heals us , both inside and outside.

  • @sms667
    @sms6673 ай бұрын

    Leave That Thing Alone never gets no love. Thank you.

  • @Babyseal2002
    @Babyseal20023 ай бұрын

    Your question: studio v live..? Now that you're down the rabbit-hole - both!! Studio first to hear what they dealt was the absolute best they could do, at that point in time. And then a live version to appreciate just how good they are live. Rush Army will provide plenty of recommendations. Mine, again, is check StickHits channel for remastered live performances. And this includes Xanadu live in Montreal 1981. Well worth re-reacting....

  • @crazydale1000
    @crazydale1000Ай бұрын

    I saw Rush 5 times. Every show was so good it's hard to describe. I am very fortunate to have seen these great players

  • @clockworkangel4026
    @clockworkangel40263 ай бұрын

    It's always great to add new members to the Rush family. (Your adoption paperwork should arrive shortly. 😁😉) If you want something atmospheric I recommend Jacobs Ladder (studio). It's an amazing deep cut I think you'll love. I'm also going to suggest Nobody's Hero. (Have the lyrics pulled up for this one.) I think you'll appreciate the message it conveys.

  • @powellpatterson4928
    @powellpatterson49283 ай бұрын

    The beauty of instrumentals ( especially RUSH's) is that the music transcends language barriers and all people get the same joy. My love of RUSH can not be overstated.

  • @jerrypilarz3076
    @jerrypilarz30763 ай бұрын

    On the chickens...as stage tech and sound got better over the years, eventually Geddy stopped using a back line of amps and started sending the bass straight to the PA. He filled in the space where the amps used to be with his sense of humor.

  • @Eldrave20
    @Eldrave203 ай бұрын

    So many good songs to recommend to you from Rush. It does my heart good to see a musician appreciate music I fell in love with 45 years ago. The full 2112 with all its parts tells a story reminiscent of opera, but rock and roll flavored. It's hard say which is more important to that story, the lyrics, or the music, but in my mind, one is diminished by the exclusion of the other. There is a video set to it that's animated which enhances that story.

  • @matthewhoag2609
    @matthewhoag26093 ай бұрын

    Thanks for sharing the stories of your brother. That lesson he taught you was one of these guys definitely knew. They are all masters on their respective instruments, but every note they play supports the song. There are no egos among these guys, no competition for the spotlight, and they all get a chance to shine. I remember an interview with another musician (which I could remember who) saying Alex would be the standout musician in any other band, but being in Rush he is the most underrated guitarist because “he serves the song, he doesn’t step all over it.” Cheers!

  • @jenniferandrews1917
    @jenniferandrews19173 ай бұрын

    This is what you call a deep track! Love it! ❤️

  • @toddashton9696
    @toddashton96963 ай бұрын

    Thanks for taking our suggestion to react to this often overlooked instrumental. I was very excited to see your reaction. Great reaction. Geddy really digs in when he picks on the bass. Its part of what gives his sound a unique feel. He has on occasion broken strings by digging in so hard. One of the most famous Bass / Drum tracks by Rush is YYZ. You can't go wrong with the studio track, but their Performance of YYZ in Rio is so incredible, it is a must see. This one should be near the top of your list of Rush reactions.

  • @EchoesDaBear
    @EchoesDaBear3 ай бұрын

    Great reaction Church Boy!! I've been waiting on seeing this from you - pretty much guaranteed that you'd dig this one - as bass is what you seek!! It's long been one of my favourite Rush pieces, esp. instrumentals, for a LONG time! I remember when I got this album in 1993 - I think I repeated this song several times - jaw on the floor, just in awe!! This was an amazing version to react to (particularly that end!). I've seen this one live a few times, and it's always a treat! Alex's soaring guitar lines, Geddy's basslines & of course, Neil's steady, intricate grooves! Perfection!! Related? Only that they're 3 good ole Canadian boys - 2 from Willowdale area of Toronto (Geddy & Alex), one from the close city of St. Catharines (Neil - RIP). Where they ARE related is in their love of progressive, hard rocking music - where they think/act as one mind! Keep up the Rush journey! Cheers.

  • @scottlogsdon5607
    @scottlogsdon5607Ай бұрын

    Geddy tells the story that when he stopped using his amps on stage he had a big open space behind him so they left it open to the stage crew to find something to go there. Since the entire band has such a deep sense of humor the crew went with washers, dryers, and food machines. They then included the crew in the show by taking care of the items on stage switching food, doing the laundry, rotating chicken, even offering chicken to Neal in one video making him laugh which you don't often see because he is so intense. The Barbies in front of Alex is his favorite fans and he has a thing for dinosaurs so the crew finds dinosaurs and puts them on his stacks just to maintain the bands deep rooted humor that keeps them such close friends before being an amazing band. As far as school, Alex and Neil have a strong background of jazz lessons. That being said you can hear a lot of jazz in their songs.

  • @markjohnson4217
    @markjohnson42173 ай бұрын

    Thanks for your story! As a seasoned singer/drummer/ and part-time bullshit guitarist, I have found over the years that the capacity to listen has taught me way more about musicianship than the actual playing. Playing tbe instrument, especially as a drummer, has always felt as though there is an irresistable force compelling me and driving me forward at times, or gently entangling me at others. It is not just about becoming one with the instrument, it is about you youself becoming an instrument of the music. The best group I have ever been a part of was a trio and we were friends since our late teens and became very close. By the third year of playing together, we were able to crank out 40 min long improvisations, filled with dynamic changes, time signature shifts, thematic recapitulations, it was ALL there. We became essentially telepathic when we played, and decided tbat we would press record as soon as we sat down and plugged in because it never failed, the first thing we played was always golden and trying to replicate it later was never quite tbe same. I have hours and hours of tbese recordings that sound like finished epic pieces of music. That was the only band I have ever played with that had tbat chemistry. Three guys... Who were friends since their teens... Who played original music together for years... Coincidence? Or is this actually the best formula for that 'next level' phenomenon that Rush have achieved? I am inclined to believe so.

  • @krgreenwood
    @krgreenwood3 ай бұрын

    Happy Monday…yay Look forward to all your reactions❤

  • @drakeswarchannel2530
    @drakeswarchannel25303 ай бұрын

    Thank you for your effort in producing these reflections! Black Sabbath - Falling off the Edge of the World.

  • @aspackblaze3583
    @aspackblaze35833 ай бұрын

    Loved your anecdote about you and your brother. Good stuff! Man, you GET Rush. I'm with you... there are a lot of great musicians, but not all of them can make music that's listenable (most Prog Rock, imo). Watch Rush "Marathon" live to see great bass WHILE singing👍👍👍

  • @byrd4mgt
    @byrd4mgt3 ай бұрын

    Love the story about your brother teaching you those two lessons. You taught me one lesson today, that I'm not the only one to play until I cry.

  • @bbr8174
    @bbr81742 ай бұрын

    Ged picked up the Flamenco plucking from Les Claypool … it changed his approach to the instrument just as Alex came back from Victor refreshed and more aggressive and Neil had displayed his new found timing and chops after Gruber. You will also notice the floating thumb! The latter years of Rush was the MOST proficient version of the band as the individuals had transcended their own virtuosity. The collective experience was just beyond comprehension. So appreciate your honesty and integrity to the music! Blessings and admiration!!!

  • @timgelinas-drummer7802
    @timgelinas-drummer78023 ай бұрын

    You’re exactly right about creating an atmosphere. I play drums and try to do the same thing in worship at my church. It’s a great responsibility to lay that foundation and create that atmosphere. Great job!

  • @R777-RLM
    @R777-RLM3 ай бұрын

    It's always fun sharing the band we love, but few are musicians, so you can teach learned some guitar and synth from my brother, who's an excellent six string bassist of Progressive Rock.

  • @melpetricko3932
    @melpetricko39322 ай бұрын

    Their goofy stage decor and gags are so pure. I love it!

  • @matthewhoag2609
    @matthewhoag26093 ай бұрын

    I know you’ll check out the instrumental YYZ soon. YYZ is the airport code for Toronto Pearson International. The piece is truly about the hustle and bustle of travel, but when you listen to it, think video games. This song makes the baddest boss fight music you will ever hear, lol.

  • @scottbaxtrom4324
    @scottbaxtrom43243 ай бұрын

    Rush song Where's My Thing, Here It Is.Must listen too.Luv your reactions.Enjoy the ride.

  • @stephenwalton8507
    @stephenwalton85073 ай бұрын

    You have great sound quality on your channel, easy on the ears when listening with headgear.

  • @Stevedrums741
    @Stevedrums7412 ай бұрын

    Alex & Geddy have been best friends since they were 12 years old. They are closer than brothers. I was lucky enough to have seen these guys 49 times on every tour from 1982-2015. They seem to be one of the only bands I can think of where the friendships remained off the stage as well as on (Genesis and U2 come to mind). They are the only band where I can say it was a true privilege to have seen them. They never not brought the best they had on the night and even when they'd hit a bum note here and there, it was charming because you think "These guys are human, after all". I sure do miss them.

  • @jimtatro6550
    @jimtatro65503 ай бұрын

    As a fan of Rush for over 45 years, I must say I am loving your rush journey. Keep going my friend the rabbit hole just gets deeper as you go.

  • @chicagojon1972
    @chicagojon19723 ай бұрын

    Thanks for sharing stories about your brother. I would have loved to hear him play the piano! The members of Rush always cared about each other like brothers and it shows. RIP Neil.

  • @garnold16
    @garnold1617 күн бұрын

    Studio vs Live. The answer is Both. The Studio gifts us the songs. Live shows us the love of music these brothers share. We're with you on this journey.

  • @philstone3859
    @philstone38592 ай бұрын

    Watching and hearing this live video reminds me of their in concert, cavernous, open, sound. This is the closest sound of the live experience that I’ve heard so far. It really captures that actual live sound of the band if that makes any sense. I guess it’s the live sound engineering and the big hall/arena, echo type sound that I’m used to that this captures so well. Especially with a super clean, live band like RUSH. You can really hear the venue acoustics. Now, just do it extremely LOUDLY. Some of the very best concerts.

  • @user-ji4ex2tn2o
    @user-ji4ex2tn2o3 ай бұрын

    If you have not checked out rush working man live in Cleveland, you are missing out. The performance is the end of the show. It's like they all cut loose and go nuts in perfectly controlled manor. That's where you will see you tremendous chemistry if they actually do possess. Pretty special

  • @markstromberg1148
    @markstromberg11483 ай бұрын

    I love that you're diving headlong into Rush's music; it is enjoyable to see how you react as you hear it for the first time. Although I stand by my recommendation that you work your way through the catalogue chronologically, I also think it would be interesting to see a musician's reaction to the gracefully-orchestrated time signature changes in "Freewill" from the 1979 album "Permanent Waves." Go get 'em!

  • @bboyshotty
    @bboyshotty3 ай бұрын

    damn..ive never seen this. What.A.GROOVE!

  • @TylerLL2112
    @TylerLL21123 ай бұрын

    I love this song. But I also absolutely loved the story about your brother. Thanks for sharing.

  • @camshaftishh
    @camshaftishh2 ай бұрын

    I'm so glad someone recommended this exact version of this song since you're a bassist. I'm a little late to the party but I'm loving the Rush reactions. Watching Rush live is usually the way to go, they're just as good live, if not better.

  • @markandersen5187
    @markandersen51873 ай бұрын

    #2 instrumental only behind LA Villa! Incredible that it was captured live...your reaction gave me goosebumps 🤘

  • @XDarkSyntaXOriginal
    @XDarkSyntaXOriginal3 ай бұрын

    As a bassist of over 50 years here's a few tracks that will get your wheels turning. Studio Version (Cruise Control) by the Dixie Dreggs from the Free Fall album. Live Album (Egocentric Molecules) by Jean Luc Ponty Live from 1979 Studio version (Donna Lee) by Jaco Pastorious from the album Jaco Pastorious. Studio version (Head for Backstage Pass) by Jeff Beck from the Wired album Studio version (Zap) by Eric Johnson from Tones album. Enjoy.

  • @blitzdough
    @blitzdough4 күн бұрын

    I appreciate your story about your brother. To your point about not overdoing the riffs..... I remember a quote from Geddy where he said ( paraphrased ) "It sure helps to have great chops and play real well, but in the end its the song that's that matters".

  • @lindaward5376
    @lindaward53763 ай бұрын

    Another song from Rush that you may like is Limelight, where Geddy's bassline helps Alex to shine in one of his best solos ever; my favourite live version is from the Exit Stage Left video, but I recommend starting with the studio version so you can understand Neil's lyrics, which are an important component here. Cheers from Toronto! 🎤 🎹 🎸 🥁 🎸 🐐 🐐 🐐

  • @kimbarry4674
    @kimbarry46743 ай бұрын

    Please do MALIGNANT NARCISSIM Geddy uses a fretless bass such amazing sound and this instrumental was also nominated for a GRAMMY ❤🇨🇦

  • @ChrisTexan
    @ChrisTexan3 ай бұрын

    Rush live are incomparable honestly, the way they make their studio versions, by their own admissions, they literally just come in with ideas, sometimes they'll collaborate in pairs or altogether, but basically they get a "great mix" done, and on some songs in particular, the studio versions are epic... but some, when you hear it live (even a short time later) it's clear they left something on the table due to recording pressures or whatever, and they really find the groove and the missing bits that they then add in live. La Villa Strangiato (LVS) is one of those (I'll have to watch your vid on that one next, this was the first I ran across from you, I see a couple others in the suggestions now)... the album recording was incredible, one thing to note, if you watch the "official video" version of LVS, that is NOT the studio recording, that's a "played live for video" version, which actually has a slightly different vibe than the original studio version (good, but different)... the album version is a bit cleaner yet also darker (especially with headphones at night), you can almost get the creeps listening to it.... Fast forward to the version they play in concert over the years (In particular the "A SHow of Hands" concert version) and it's literally faster, more notes, more intricacy, and yet also more flowing and powerful... and they do all that LIVE. A Rush concert is (was, sadly) an epic experience "Precision Thunder" was how our Dallas newspaper wrote up one of their concerts here back around 1990 (Presto tour)... the studio releases are literally just the starting point, then they make it better on the road. Also, sometimes they just get goofy, like the reggae version (first 2 verses) of "Working Man" that they played on one of their later tours (their original "big break" song that was a hard rocker originally). Anyhow, so the BEST thing to do is both, hear the studio, then the live. THe crazy thing is the live versions are easily "perfectly matched" to the studio releases most of the time, just with "more" somehow in them, but if you memorized the album versions, you could sing right along, and hum right along with any part of it and it'd match the live version, just instead of 1/8th note high-hats on the studio drums, there now are triplets mixed in, the bass has a few extra notes where there weren't before, yet the original notes are all there, and the guitar, well, Alex finds ways to make it make sounds it never did on the album but perfectly (in most cases, LOL) in sync with the original melody (I'd say he makes more mistakes (still very rare though) than the other 2, but he's also a bit more free-wheeling which certainly keeps it interesting! LOL).

  • @pablozee6359
    @pablozee63593 ай бұрын

    I think what you’re taking about with Rush is about serving the song. They’re all indeed master players and one with their instruments. As dazzling as their technical prowess may be, they generally tried to make it about the song and not themselves. There are exceptions to that, and they’re usually intentional and funny. Take La Villa Strangiato, for example. It is subtitled, “An exercise in self indulgence.” Neil Peart once said that when it came to composing drum parts, he had a teacher that said to use the K.I.S.S. model - Keep It Simple, Stupid. Neil chose to make up his own model - M.U.S.I.C - Make Up Something Interesting & Complimentary. Great band and great people.

  • @davewelch377
    @davewelch3773 ай бұрын

    Great reaction!! Always go with the live versions from Rush. The best trio in Rock.

  • @mpkelley20
    @mpkelley203 ай бұрын

    Great story about playing soft your brother. My son plays bass in a church band. Started last year at 16 and plays with all older guys who have been playing for 20+ years. They are very helpful at helping him understand when it’s time to play the song and when it’s ok to let loose. He’s matured so much in a year and it’s translated well to his school jazz band and the theater pit he plays in. Never turn down advice from people in music. There is always something to learn and it will make you better. Love your reactions. Keep it up! Would love to see some video of you and your brother playing some music if you have any.

  • @freedomfalcon3352
    @freedomfalcon33523 ай бұрын

    Studio first, then live, brother! God bless.

  • @AnthonyPeterson-bh1ex
    @AnthonyPeterson-bh1ex3 ай бұрын

    Rush is just amazing. My favorite band by far. I appreciate your points of view. Well done.

  • @SwolllenGoat
    @SwolllenGoat3 ай бұрын

    always live with RUSH

  • @scottlogsdon5607
    @scottlogsdon56072 ай бұрын

    Live shows from Cleveland and Germany are amazing live shows where they turn it way up from the albums. Keep doing your amazing reactions. It's cool that you and The Daily Doug make the effort to play your instruments during the reactions to actually get into what is being played!! You are awesome 😎

  • @ObnoxiousNox
    @ObnoxiousNox3 ай бұрын

    Rush did time signatures that doesn’t exist

  • @Mike80528
    @Mike805283 ай бұрын

    Malignant Narcissism is another instrumental you might enjoy. Their instrumentals generally developed out of jam sessions...

  • @wiseonelol25
    @wiseonelol253 ай бұрын

    This band consists of the most humble of musicians, and they like being goofs and having laughs! To that end, they always like to inject little bits of comedy throughout their shows - the chef loading chickens, a gorrilla coming on to steal popcorn, cartoon videos, both created by their South Park creator buddies and others - and using the fact that Geddy switched from onstage amps to sending his signal through the PA, and wanted to balance the stage since Alex still used his stacks, so they used popcorn makers, chicken rotisseries, and even washing machines!!! World Class musicians, and world class goof offs!

  • @scottallen6160
    @scottallen61603 ай бұрын

    Music is a conduit for sharing the Spirit within us with others. When we embrace the Spirit we just ‘know’ how to share emotions in song. ✌️😉💕

  • @byronness7385
    @byronness73853 ай бұрын

    Welcome too the quirkiest band, their friendship transcends time… An quite likely why they we’re so tight on stage You never know what you will see on stage, from stacks of dryers drying clothes to rotisserie chickens to gorillas wondering around Check out the documentary beyond the lighted stage in ur spare time, will give you a deeper understanding of the band Love ur reactions, your a real fan of music

  • @apctest8359
    @apctest83593 ай бұрын

    I vote for live versions whenever possible

  • @smellytheclam5812
    @smellytheclam58123 ай бұрын

    Natural Science. Just do it!!

  • @oliver-yg6qr
    @oliver-yg6qr3 ай бұрын

    I love your knowledge of music and your faith. much respect!

  • @user-ny3rs9eo1g
    @user-ny3rs9eo1g3 ай бұрын

    What a great reaction! Hopefully Geddy's solo brings you more happiness than La Villa. lol They are the perfect balance between "serving the song" and serving their own ambitions as players to challenge themselves and become better musicians. Re: studio vs live - the studio versions are generally more recommended for a 1st time listening bc a lot of the nuances of the song get lost in the live versions (crowd noise, etc). Studio version to fully hear and appreciate the composition and the nuances of their musicianship as individuals and as a group. And the lyrics. Live versions for the energy, added improv moments (like Geddy's solo) and their incredibly TIGHT musicianship as a group. It was actually a joy to watch them mess up. NOT bc it made them human, but bc watching them was superhuman. I hope you continue to explore them. They will never cease to surprise you and be a source of inspiration.

  • @MrLedotson
    @MrLedotson3 ай бұрын

    You can always do the live versions. Rush never disappoints live.

  • @Progene01
    @Progene013 ай бұрын

    RUSH Live in Rio is another one you have to see and some GREAT BASS in it!!!

  • @Particulator
    @Particulator3 ай бұрын

    They have perfect timing simply because they've played together for some 40 years when this was recorded.

  • @josedevarona4376
    @josedevarona43763 ай бұрын

    Your awesome.. love your commentary and stories.. lots of blessings

  • @Eldrave20
    @Eldrave203 ай бұрын

    I watched your reaction to Xanadu, and one of the others, in addition to this one. I have so much to say. To add to what you said about the power of music, music is life--as it has the power to provoke liberating revelation! Music is art, and the object of art, is to give shape--life. Without getting political, or religious, i would absolutely love to see you react to "Witch hunt". I'd be interested in your take on the lyrics in addition to the music. I think the message is an important one.

  • @user-nm9ex5je4u
    @user-nm9ex5je4u3 ай бұрын

    That is some nasty bass on that song, loved your reaction, just subscribed...Rush can make you cry also... check out the live version of The Garden. It is an emotional journey and a goodby of sorts by Neil. The stage, lighting, lyrics, strings and of course, the music. This was the last track on the last studio album Rush made. They would tour a few more times and end things in 2015 , ultimately with Neils untimely passing in early 2020. Knowing all that and seeing it live brings tears and chills at the same time. Im a hard working 60+ general contractor in Canada, home of these guys btw, and this live version reduces me to a blubbering mess every time, its Rush at their mature best...thank me later...

  • @ericdudemanofthedudes
    @ericdudemanofthedudes3 ай бұрын

    Stoked to see another rush reaction pop up the day I discovered your channel! Studio version of Spirit of Radio is a must listen in terms of a phenomenal Rush song. Thanks for the thoughtful reactions dude!

  • @davehooper6481
    @davehooper64813 ай бұрын

    For more than 30 years, my favorite two bands have been Rush and Steely Dan. I’m glad to see you’re discovering them and I’ll watch all your videos. Like many others, I’ll make a suggestion to you. The musicianship is superior, of course, but some of the lyrics are as well. From the farewell to Kings album, and the hemispheres album, you’ll find a continuing story there that is compelling to read, as well as listen to. It’s about the duality of man’s mind. Be prepared for lots of Rickenbacker

  • @Mike80528
    @Mike805283 ай бұрын

    Geddy's hero was Chris Squire and early on he worked to create the same/similar sound. He didn't realize Chris used a pick, and he developed a plucking technique that is rather unique...he still loves Chris and forgives him for having used a pick...and played bass for Yes in their hall of fame introduction performance, filling in for Chris who had passed beforehand.

  • @paulcaruana4090
    @paulcaruana40903 ай бұрын

    My favorite Peart fill after the solo. That 2 bar break is sweet as fuck

  • @adamwhite7895
    @adamwhite78953 ай бұрын

    Time machine tour - the guy with the chickens was 'fueling' the time machine. On the Snakes and Arrows tour, they had a guy basting rotisserie chickens behind Geddy Lee (a play on 'Henhouse' brand amps) which were then fed to the stage crew after each concert. Many tours had some crazy antics going on during maestro level play... quite constrasting. I saw the time machine concert twice over the 2 year tour. Some of their best stuff (working man - live in cleveland) on that tour. Absolute magicians. Got me to pick up the bass. Slappa da bass maaan.

  • @marcralston2501
    @marcralston250128 күн бұрын

    When it comes to Rush. ALWAYS LIVE BRO! ALWAYS!

  • @michaelkeller6223
    @michaelkeller62233 ай бұрын

    Being a 3!piece is part of what makes them so special. Each takes turns filling in the space that would be taken up by additional band members and it allows them to be ‘busy’ without sounding like they are ‘overplaying’

Келесі