I saw Renaissance In the 1970's at Robin Hood Dell West, an outdoor venue outside of Philadelphia. When Annie starts singing her voice puts a spell on you! All you want to do is hear more from her! What is amazing is that the group still performs today in 2023. Annie settled in Bucks County Pennsylvania, another suburb of Philadelphia, and has lived there since the 1990's.

A voice in a million backed by masters of their instruments. They don't make music like this anymore. I'm blown away every time I listen.

Annie has an amazing voice. Underrated. She and Renaissance one day might see the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Worthy of it.

This is so good. Just love Annie's voice and the Rick sound of Jon Camp! What a band!!!❤

I saw them at Carnagie Hall in the 70's but don't remember the year. But the show I was at that absolutely blew me away was when they played Red Rocks in 76 or 77. I had my camera and telephoto and got some great picks from about the 12th row.

Renaissance Live at Carnegie Hall is one of the greatest live albums l ever heard l never got to see them in the 70’s but many years later they played a small venue in Orlando Florida Annie Haslam loves her fans because they cancelled the show because Annie had back surgery but the venue told me to hang onto my ticket because they are rescheduling the show and she came back and performed the show some artist’s would have blown off the show and would have done other dates but not Annie she didn’t want to let the fans down you have to give her a lot of respect for doing that she also e-mail a fan thanking him for his praise for her music she is one of a kind a class act through and through Sadly Michael Dunsford passed on before this show came up we will all miss Michael very much RIP Michael

@sanityassassin8161

12 күн бұрын

And Jon Tout. Requiescat in Pace. ✝️

The Carnegie Hall Show wasn’t filmed. This is the Sight and Sound broadcast film from 1977 combined with the audio from Carnegie Hall in 1975. I wish Carnegie Hall had been filmed . Any Renaissance fan does!

@DavidNWalker

2 жыл бұрын

That's Correct. The Carnegie Hall Album is one of the great live albums.

@ACooke108

Жыл бұрын

I knew something was wrong with this. Simply, I don't see the orchestra. Shame on you Cal Vid.

@jimryan5479

Жыл бұрын

I was at one of the three Carnegie Hall shows and it’s amazing to me that not one bootleg tape was made during those three performances or that the band itself didn’t document the show(s) either!

@paulquintin3607

Жыл бұрын

Video of the Carnegie Hall concerts would be a great thing to see, sorry it doesn’t exist! This is one of my all time favorite pieces of vinyl that I own, and one of my favorite finds during my College Radio days….

@userphlglvc

10 ай бұрын

I don't know Renaissance intellectual and cool band about another band! because important band for me. this stop! see you again next day# this is 森川/Japan thank you# over-

I saw them several times back in the 70's. Annie has one of the most amazing voices ever, and the band was so far ahead of its time bringing so many young rockers into progressive classical rock. Absolute perfection!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I hadn't ever seen this band. I live in Russia. But I love that music and those musicians. I like to call it art rock. And Renaissance is undoubtedly one of the most beloved bands. Their music and Annie's voice make me cry with happiness.

@GregiiFlieger

11 ай бұрын

This band is uniquely talented.

In 1991, I bought a Renaissance original sound track. I have an LP in my hand right now, but I don't have a turntable. So I'm listening on KZread. Even listening to KZread, the beautiful melody and overwhelming impressions still remain.

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

Very cool!

I saw them several times with this lineup, and this music. Very talented group, nice people too. RIP John Tout and Michael Dunford

This was the only group I ever saw at Carnegie Hall. I'm so glad I had the privilege of seeing them there & with dead center 4th row seats. Perfect sound was a total treat .

Running Hard off of Carnegie Hall is so delightful! Listening to this song again brings magic back into my life.

Oh, to be able to sing like her. Beautiful , beautiful voice.

I’ve seen Renaissance twice in the past 10 years or so; would’ve loved to see them back in their prime, and with Jon Camp. Annie… beautiful voice, beautiful woman. There should’ve been more Prog bands with female vocalists; it works so well.

@Eleventhearlofmars

11 ай бұрын

Yeah, shadow of the heirophant stands out for me as a fantastic prog tune with female vocals.

Highly creative music by hyper talented musicians

Such a beautiful pure voice...backed up by extremely talented professionals.

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more!

Her voice and stage presence is just mesmerising. Wow !!

We are lucky to have this video material. This music and talent is once in eternity.

How could anyone NOT love this music??!!

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

Right? They're the best!

Renaissance was/is one of my fave progressive bands.

if they came out now, they'd be huge

Nice job syncing the BBC performance footage with the audio from the Live at Carnegie Hall album. It really works quite well. Thank you!

Saw them in an ice skating rink in Phoenix in the early 80"s. No more than 400 in attendance. Yes, Annie has voice that besides her can only be heard in heaven.

The dynamic musical break starting at about 15:00 is actual melodies from Maurice Jarre's score from the film Doctor Zhivago. I am certain they had permission because it was never challenged and it is incorporated so well into their music. Chillingly beautiful. Jarre would be proud.

I’ve had the pleasure of seeing this band many times over the years. Always calming and enchanting. Plus having an angel singing always added to the brilliance .

Wow! Video of a track I've seen only in my head since 1977.

Gold in the voice- magic and all of it live- magic

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

Annie is simply wonderful!

Just love Renaissance music. Annie Haslam is wonderful!

@Realbillball

3 жыл бұрын

Oh, isn't she just ?

@thomaszadorozny451

3 жыл бұрын

Amen! Truly wonderful! Ethereal, and soul stirring! God bless her!

@elizabeththompson6644

2 жыл бұрын

Angelic voice

I can not believe how this video/audio was synced....OUTSTANDING and so very much appreciated...makes the viewing so much more enjoyable....THANK YOU

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

Wow, thank you!

Saw them three times in Philadelphia. Just absolutely mesmerizing. Annie just love her. She lives outside Philadelphia in Bucks County. She moved there because it reminded her of her home land in England.

@Realbillball

3 жыл бұрын

What? I thought she was from Bolton? ;)

@Realbillball

3 жыл бұрын

@Xen Bucks County looks like Bolton? My oh my....

@kevinandrews9111

3 жыл бұрын

Saw them at the Tower a few times. Twice with Al Stewart. Both had huge following in Philadelphia in the 70s.

@lisellesloan3191

3 жыл бұрын

Wow! That's good to know. I saw them in Philly, too, where I used to live. I never would have guessed that she had chosen my old home town to live in. That's interesting to know it's like in England in Bucks, as I've never been there before, alas.

@Nymphya

2 жыл бұрын

I also saw them in Philly at the Tower theater; and am from there, as well. So interesting to see how many others here saw them in Philly. They are simply superb.

Very nice job on syncing a video from one live performance with the audio from another live performance. I saw Renaissance in the mid 70s while they toured with Yes. Phenomenal event. Became a lifelong fan of both bands because of that show.

Saw them live on Penn's landing in 1976 I'll never forget that voice and that beautiful ballroom gown

@csacsa8117

Жыл бұрын

i was there!

@markschultz7582

Жыл бұрын

She's the most ALLURING Lady I've ever heard!!! Simply Beautiful and Lovely!!!!

Absolutely loved Renaissance back in the day! Thank you.

Such a grand band🌷🕊🎶

So good to hear and see Annie again ❤️

Great band, Annie had the voice of an angel. Once saw them many years ago in a small club on LBI.

IN MY OPINION...ANNIE HASLAM IS THE GREATEST FEMALE LEAD VOCALIST TO EVER WALK THE PLANET...HER VOICE...HER RANGE...HER BEAUTY...

@malcolmharing3744

Жыл бұрын

And she is still beautiful.

Adoro esta banda. Prog rock é lindo. Gentle giant, jethro tull, emerson..., genesis, rush...

0:00 Carpet of The Sun 3:30 Mother Russia 13:23 Running Hard

This song, Carpet of the Sun, is so special to me. I had some try out to play on acoustic guitar and sing the song at same time. My voice does not reach the Soprano level Annie's does.

It's not surprising I once heard in a long interview with Jon Anderson (YES, etc...) say his favourite singer is Annie. And it's reciprocal, as évidenced by her stunning solo cover of "Turn of the Century" :)

It's so nice to watch Carnegie Hall Live after only listening to the album all these years!

A quiet and very precious moment. Love from Switzerland.

fantastic voice! unique vocal gymnastics.

I am with the IALAHV movement - I Absolutely Love Annie Haslam's Voice.

@tomkarlen3776

3 жыл бұрын

Whats that?

That is absurdly beautiful.

Thanks for posting this. Awesome set and wow can't say enough about the band's talent and Annie's voice. Mother Russia is totally captivating.

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

You're very welcome

"Mother Russia" is so apropos to our time!

Renaissance. Beautiful. Annie's voice. I was at this concert. Thank you.

@dariobarisic3461

2 жыл бұрын

Gratulation☆

@Eleventhearlofmars

11 ай бұрын

The sight and sound concert or Carnegie hall? 😂

Saw the band on tour in Toronto a couple of times in Toronto - Massey Hall and Convocation Hall - University of Toronto campus- brilliant

So peaceful.

Banda Maravilhosa! O melhor vocal de todos os tempos!!

Annie Haslam was the height of 1970s British Babedom…

Went to that show with a bunch of friends from the old Fort Wadsworth.

Was at this concert. Still love them .

@CalVid

4 жыл бұрын

You're so fortunate to have been there.

@thomaszadorozny451

3 жыл бұрын

Saw them back in 1978, at the Uptown Theatre! What an awesome performance! Jon Camp's bass solo during Ashes are Burning, was worth the price of admission! God bless Mz. Annie Haslam!

@allisonrich5061

2 жыл бұрын

Oh how we envy you!

Very beautiful❇

é lindo demais, me faz chorar de emoção, felicidade...pôr do sol, lua cheia

@bispomanoelangelo8783

3 жыл бұрын

Concordo com vc que bela voz.

This is just wonderful.

I saw them at Massey Hall in Toronto and they were magnificent. I was a huge prog rock fan and the big 3 were my faves ELP, Genesis and Yes, but Renaissance, Camel and Strawbs were right up there with them.

Absolutely stunning ❤️❤️

@CalVid

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you! Cheers!

@jeff6899

3 жыл бұрын

@@CalVid One of my alltime fav English bands, along with Strawbs. Thank You for the tribute !

Questa musica è una boccata d ossigeno in questi tempi difficili.pura poesia,altro che trap/rap jax,baby k e cazzatine varie

_Mother Russia_ is a fenomenal song!

Thanks for the very enjoyable file! Peace!

Que bela voz!

Thank you.

@CalVid

3 жыл бұрын

You're welcome!

great footage and beautiful morning

@CalVid

4 жыл бұрын

Many thanks

Nice 💅

I always tell people that Annie is absolute precision in tempo, pitch, resonance, and meter. When you can synch video from one concert, with audio from another? Ipso-Facto!

@sumtymzwhy

6 ай бұрын

I noticed at around 2 minutes in she stops holding the note on video, but in the audio. she continues to hold it longer.

Buenísimo !!!

Vocal phrasing on first tune reminds me of Liz Fraser.

Baam :) fascinating work you have here

Excellent job Cal. Fantastic. Congrats from Brazil.

nice!💝

I special like Renaissance performance on live. Renaissance classic rock sound were precious! at last I'm Japanese myEnglish please tolerate! this is 森川/Japan thank you# over-

NOT VERY OFTEN YOU SEE A BASS GUITAR AS THE LEAD GUITAR....ANIE HASLAM IS PERHAPS THE GREATEST FEMALE LEAD VOCALISTS OF ALL TIME...SHE HAS TREMENDOUS RANGE...JOHN CAMP IS AWSOME ON BASS GUITAR AND SINGS WELL...THE REST OF THE GROUP ARE SKILLED PROFESSIONALS.....IV SEEN RENAISSANCE TWICE IN PHOENIX ARIZONA BACK IN THE LATE 70s...MONEY WELL SPENT...

Dream your dream !!

Video💙Wow

The actual footage is from their concert at the BBC in 1977, not the Carnegie Hall where it feature orchestral accompaniment. A real shame, since I thought there would be an actual filming of the famous concerts they gave there and which resulted in their famous double live album.

@marlachristensen2076

3 жыл бұрын

huh?

@marlachristensen2076

3 жыл бұрын

Well, while I am not currently in possession of my 'Live at Carnegie Hall' album, the stage playing seems to match the music off of this album - as I remember it.

@marlachristensen2076

3 жыл бұрын

I suppose the real tale would be in 'Ashes are Burning' though.

@marlachristensen2076

3 жыл бұрын

And, yeah, one sees no orchestra here.

@johnmorris8799

Жыл бұрын

If you had bothered to read the credits at the end .. it is a montage of 2 separate gigs with some audio trickery and tempo bending. Never mind, Annie’s singing is indescribably beautiful and that is all that matters.

I did my best attempt at playing this on guitar (wishfully thinking it was an Ovation Guitar though it was only an Alverez) and singing at the same time.

Love them. Is this video really from the Carnegie Hall concert? Annie herself has said she regrets there was no video taken of it.

EAR CANDY

Take that A.I.!

¿Algún mexicano que adore esta música tanto como yo?

@yeirebeirut369

2 жыл бұрын

Yo soy Judío- Norteamericano y adoro la Bella Música Igual que Tu Joshep

@Daniel87.

Жыл бұрын

✌️ desde Leon,Gto, Mexico. Long live Prog Rock

@verissimodenise

Жыл бұрын

I am braziliam and I lovr Renaissance since the 70's.

Thanks Cal Vid - but this is from Live at BBC Sight & Sound - Golders Green Hippodrome 1977

@Ianpetermills

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah, but read the title. The audio is from Carnegie Hall.

@patrickkelly9178

3 жыл бұрын

Yes you are correct and far too small a stage I suspect for Carnegie. I saw the sight and sound show back in the day myself. I had forgotten they used an orchestra for this gig too.

@davidreding8813

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, just a teeny bit out of synch in a couple of places. Still an amazing vid!

My only objection to this video is that the intro to Running Hard got cut.

Maybe video/audio editors meshed live with studio because some parts do seem live but others are clearly not.

how hard is it to sing with the timings going on

Popular music was so much better before over-production and auto-tune ruined it.

Not liking Mother Russia at the moment..., though the song is amazing.

@marcofonseca2897

Жыл бұрын

unintelligent people try to boycott everything related to Russia, including its universal culture🇷🇺

@BufordP

Жыл бұрын

Are you not aware the song is about Solzhenitsyn?

@Eleventhearlofmars

11 ай бұрын

Jeez 😂

Misrepresents the Renaissance period...

Mother Russia. This song is so special to me. Thank you Vlademir Putin.

@clintmaffett2570

2 жыл бұрын

What does Putin have to do with this song? Or I trying to be funny?

@dianequick3127

Жыл бұрын

@@clintmaffett2570 This is a reasonable question. The administrations in Russia are very careful about which bands they allow to perform in their Country. It is not in distaste to the music though. I can see why Mother Russia is probably one of which has to wait. It is rather difficult to explain. Though, to make you aware, the first band allowed to perform in Russia, Red Square to be exact, was none other than the Beatles and the Russians LOVED the performance. This was under Putin's Administration.

I'm a huge Renaissance fan, listen to their music frequently, but this sounds like the studio versions of the songs to me (which I am very familiar with) and not a live performance. Plus, the video is out-of-sync at several points if you watch carefully the piano and drum performances. Plus, near the end of Mother Russia, Annie's lip sync is obviously off near the last couple of notes. I wish whoever posts videos would be honest and not make people believe they are watching an actual live performance when it is live video playing along with the studio recordings.

@BlueSandLive

3 жыл бұрын

There is no deception. The video and description clearly state the video and audio are different. Naturally, there are some out-of-sync sections where Annie and the band didn't play those two performances exactly the same.

@paulvincent6191

3 жыл бұрын

@@BlueSandLive My apologies to the posters of this video-I did not read the description (usually just listen)-but I've seen many "live" videos posted that have no such disclaimers. Real live videos are gold to see how good the artists really are without all the fixing/editing done in the studio production process.

@tomkarlen3776

3 жыл бұрын

What r u saying?

8 people are fucking deaf

Annie is the best female vocalist of all time