Opening the book by just having "Jon" thinking about dragons and Daenerys without context is such a troll move XD

@shortstuff780

Жыл бұрын

But, it's very on point with something George would do

@Luciana_McC_99

Жыл бұрын

Yeah I'm literally just starting this and that's what I was wondering, this is supposed to be after dance of the dragons right ?

@nicholsonfile

Жыл бұрын

@@Luciana_McC_99 The books are not exactly chronological: early Feast for Crows chapters happen before the end of Storm of Swords.

@GT-xw7qy

6 ай бұрын

As soon as I heard this I knew it was going to be good.

How he'd earned a bronze link was itself a higher mystery Sick burn

This was a brilliant balance between lore and restraint. Even if I had never heard of any ASoIaF, if I browsed this prologue in a bookstore, I would buy this book.

That settles it then: If GRRM doesn’t finish ASoIaF, the fans will. This was fantastic!

@martinfiedler4317

2 жыл бұрын

When Preston announced his endeavor, I hat a glimpse of a hope it may push GRRM to go back to work. Now I start to hope he doesn't, so that this version can stand alone!

@TraciPeteyforlife

2 жыл бұрын

@@martinfiedler4317 You have a very nice change of that happening

@Mofi357

9 ай бұрын

Its like riding two trainwrecks at once and I just bought a ticket for the second train?

The Lemons, the Wires. Why do I think Glass-Candles require electricity to work ... I like it.

@purpleblah2

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah I thought of potato batteries

@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin

2 жыл бұрын

@@purpleblah2 It an early draft, they were carrots. Then I read that lemons have a ton more energy because they have more acid. It was too perfect. (But of course it is ambiguous what actually turned the candle on. Was it the lemons or Jon's telepathy?)

@mistermaestersirthomas9164

2 жыл бұрын

@@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin glass candles sit on a natural gas spot like Delphi, only a spark is needed. Magic lanterns, gas powered for gas lighting; it’s why a con artist Marwyn is the one to tell us, who looks like Avatar from Wizards(1977) sorta.

@Ancor_Vantian

Жыл бұрын

@@mistermaestersirthomas9164 perhaps a dumb question. Although your idea is very interesting; How would that work given that The Citadel's Glass Candles were _brought_ from Valyria? There are not native to Oldtown. I guess we could say the Obsidian itself is 'flammable', but it doesn't burn away like wax; if that makes sense(?)

@mistermaestersirthomas9164

Жыл бұрын

@@Ancor_Vantian the candle is hollow, the gas comes up from the ground and burns inside. That’s why it doesn’t move in the breeze, like gas lamp the flame is contained. They can be moved off the base, but unless it is fixed on to a gas deposit it would do nothing. Oldtown having visions (like the Oracle of Delphi) has such a deposit.

The raven screaming "Jon" and "Beware" was so creepy. I loved it. Great chapter as always!

@musculusiv4172

2 жыл бұрын

I wonder who was wise enough to know about the assassination and how to teach the raven to speak but not wise enough to make him deliver a meaningful message like "Assassin coming!" instead of "Jon beware!"

@bennett420316

2 жыл бұрын

BloodRaven strikes again

@blubblubwhat

2 жыл бұрын

the sphinx wasnt king of all the animals at the end was she? one sneaked away to bite jon..

@alanpennie8013

2 жыл бұрын

@@musculusiv4172 You have to follow the Rule of Cryptic.

My god, this character is absolutely good enough to read a whole book about. Best chapter yet. But I fricken knew it would end the way it did, too cruel.

@ThereIsNoLord

2 жыл бұрын

I am so sorry.

@Holypikemanz

2 жыл бұрын

"my god" its not good

@teddycaliendo6744

2 жыл бұрын

@@Holypikemanz the fuck u on about

@1handedtyper

2 жыл бұрын

Him being q prologue POV character, I knew he had been living on borrowed time, but a Sorrowful Man? Didn't see that coming.😲 Someone had to hire him, and shortage of people pissed off at them. And what's the deal with the 3 Quarteen?

@musculusiv4172

2 жыл бұрын

I was so relieved that he was able to send the letter with his discovery before he died lol I was convinced he would make a discovery and then die before he could tell anyone

When you try to tell your fellow Maesters about the seasons but they just give you that sweetsleep stare.

This is the most I’ve ever cared about a prologue character. I’m with the other commenters who would happily read a whole book about Maester Jon! Huge well done to everyone who made this.

I really dug Jon as a character. It was an interesting perspective.

I was skeptical when you said you wanted the prologue to be about another Maester, but congrats to the writers for making John so compelling in such a short time. This chapter did an excellent job bringing things about the world to the audience's mind they've likely been taking for granted.

@Radiotomb

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed. This was reeeeally good!

Encouraging article on GRRM: "After acknowledging that his process 'sounds mad, I know,' Martin observed this about his writing: 'What I have noticed more and more of late, however, is my gardening is taking me further and further away from the television series.'"

@alanpennie8013

2 жыл бұрын

Certainly a lot more positive than his previous update. I like The Dragon Demands' theory that Bran and Sansa will swap places at the end.

Great job to everyone involved! Highlights for me were definitely QUEEN Jeyne's characterization and Preston's raven voice 10/10!

@kristinaporter2629

2 жыл бұрын

The raven was full Roy Dotrice

Incredible chapter once again. There's so much variety in this project so far, it's pretty unreal. I love love love how it uses so much of the same flavour and texture that GRRM does in ASOIAF. In the last chapter we saw the fixation with history, of characters looking at the legends and stories of the past, tinged with nostalgia and wonder at the events and figures of worlds that once existed. And in this one we see something similar, but different, in how nature and the physical world works. Thinking of the fantastical mundanities of flora and fauna, the mysteries of scientific discovering and the passion of deepening our understanding. The details about the Wall and the Citadel, particularly the ancient tree root, going hand in hand with the emotional story-telling of our present characters. Jon's empathetic and very human struggles supporting and being seemlessly interwoven with the political story of the larger work, and the magical story beyond that. And again the detail of the prose continues to amaze me. How even the layout of the first page makes you think about the rest of the story, by seeing key words like Jon, Daenarys, wings, and dragons, which stand out when you're just looking at a first glance and make you connect the story you're reading in this chapter with all of the things we've experienced in the previous books, and before you're given the specific context of who the point of view character is here and where we find ourselves. This is written like a prologue of a long series. Everything just feels right. Even the way Jon thinks about Alleras over and over, with a little too much detail in a way that makes him seem a bit too passionate and obsessed, still rings emotionally true and connects him as a character in the same story as Tyrion, Jaime, Jorah, and so many others of a type that GRRM likes to write. This whole project continues to remain brilliantly authentic. Never thought I'd see fan-fiction of this quality, that could connect with me like this in a way that feels indistinguishable from the novel series I came to love a decade ago.

@classicdansmith

2 жыл бұрын

The start of this chapter felt surreal. After hearing the name Jon and imagery of dragons and Daenerys I was thinking “wait, huh? The prologue is supposed to be in the Riverlands with Jeyne Westerling!”

This is spectacular. Everyone involved deserves praise.

@zacrusk5274

2 жыл бұрын

Nope, just Preston. He’s the greatest that ever was, dude!

@martinfiedler4317

2 жыл бұрын

Indeed. Heartfelt thanks to everyone. My namesake could not have done it better!

@anguswaterhouse9255

Жыл бұрын

The little references they sneak in are so great. The ship that Jon says takes him north is the same one that takes Theon back to Pyke, and they mention "The captain's daughter's, son" which is probably Theons bastard that he said he likely got her pregnant with in ACOK!

I love the "thinks he's gay but. Surprise! Not gay" very GRRM

Please don’t stop doing these, I know they don’t get as many views as the theory’s, but people will notice at some point. This fells much more like a passion project anyways, but please don’t get bored. We who watch couldn’t handle another abandoned book. Love

@akiramado9198

2 жыл бұрын

You know the guy david reads asoiaf? We should drop a few links in some comments and get the word out about it.

@cosmiccomedy7394

Жыл бұрын

@@akiramado9198 I absolutely love David's reading of asoiaf. Best narration I've come across.

@ludovicus-Wyndham

9 ай бұрын

​@@cosmiccomedy7394David's Renly is a marvel. Everyone who's familiar with the books should pay homage.

' "fruitless" attempt to lit the glass candles' Really preston... really?? XD Absolutely loved it. I have a bit of a more fantasy take on ASOIAF, don't think it's all pure sci-fi as you propose, but I enjoy your take immensely. Good idea setting up a makeshift battery to turn on the Dragonglass candle!

@santiagogarza8121

2 жыл бұрын

It's very FMA

@rvestalmd

2 жыл бұрын

I didn’t even catch that until reading this comment…

@jaredbrady5566

2 жыл бұрын

This was cool, I really hope this method is how it ends working in canon. I don't recall Preston mentioning it before, so I'm assuming it's a theory from one of the contributors. So awesome.

@DrJReefer

Жыл бұрын

I've heard far worse mistakes in Audible productions. Like the Saxon Story narrator who uses the name RANGAR over and over again for an entire book.

@Vmac1394

7 ай бұрын

Sci-Fi IS fantasy, only with a different setting. Star Trek is as plausible as Tolkien.

I definitely need a line by line analysis of this chapter.

@sagebias2251

2 жыл бұрын

Amen

@sunkist1309

2 жыл бұрын

Same man I loved this one but I want to know what jons revelation was. And who hired the assassins. And why did Jon need to die?

@db7213

2 жыл бұрын

That's the drawback of this project: Who is going to analyze and theorize about it? We'd need to clone Preston and have one of the clones not be involved in the writing process!

@Jord73

2 жыл бұрын

@@db7213 Maybe we can ask George?

@db7213

2 жыл бұрын

​@@Jord73 Lol. Yeah, I'd love to see that.

Beautifully written chapter. Congrats to all involved. All three TWoW chapters have been brilliant.

Just now noticing the last line of the chapter reveals the assassin is one of the Sorrowful Men of Qarth. I wonder where Preston is going with that, especially considering Sybille’s family likely came from Qarth’s Guild of Spicers

"A river flowing into itself"... Beautiful metaphor. Also that's 2 chapters with lemons. Feel like someone should keep a count ;-)

@gianmarcozoffoli9891

2 жыл бұрын

what does it mean?

@danielbroome5690

2 жыл бұрын

@@gianmarcozoffoli9891 Not sure if that's a serious question, but the answer is that GRRM has noted lemons and their climate at least 2-3 times in the story so far, and Preston and many other readers picked up on the fact that they cannot grow in Bravos or any similar latitude like kings landing etc. Primarily this is significant because it totally de-legitimizes Dany's entire backstory because she remembers a lemontree at the house with the red door which she thinks is in braavos. This is shown to be impossible by the contextual clues including the mentions of lemons here.

@mo_exel

2 жыл бұрын

@@danielbroome5690 I think they meant the "river flowing into itself" part. I am also a bit confused about that. Does it mean an electric current?

@jaredbrady5566

2 жыл бұрын

@@mo_exel I'm thinking something like the dragon eating it's tail metaphor we get in the books, so time repeating.

@SophiaLilithUwU

Жыл бұрын

@@mo_exel An electric current needs to be closed, or "flowing into itself" in a more flowery way of putting it. "Current" is also a synonym for "river" The ingredients used in the chapter are copper wire, lemons and calamine? which is zink i believe? which you can use to make a lemon battery, which generates an eletric current that light glass candles once the current is closed, which dont use fire to be lit, but electric power. It's also an allusion to ouroboros, a symbol in alchemy of dragon or snake biting its own tail, representing infinity and time.

I really liked the notion I got at 42:42. That Jon had, in his mind with his great discovery promoted himself to Archmaester of Astronomy. Kinda let down when I read the PDF and saw it was a flub.

@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin

2 жыл бұрын

Ha ha! I was so upset when I realized I misspoke after the upload. I guess is kind of works both ways.

@Seelenverheizer

4 ай бұрын

yeah it makes it much better, our boi already sees himself as archmeaster.

Man I'm gonna have trouble separating this all from cannon..Really great work!!(I Would love to read something completely original from him) Honestly How sad would it be if this not only got finished first but also ends up being better then what we get from GRRM..

@KrishnaSharma-nx9dy

2 жыл бұрын

I don't think they can top grrm. They might look better as it can include popular theories but grrms storytelling is just unmatched.

@CanalLass

2 жыл бұрын

This may be the only cannon we get.

@croatiawarior

2 жыл бұрын

@@KrishnaSharma-nx9dy they can, they will actually finish it.

@akiramado9198

2 жыл бұрын

@@KrishnaSharma-nx9dy ofc. That's why this is a fan project. Look at it for what it is and be greatful these hard working people are willing to entertain us.

@andrewlynch4126

2 жыл бұрын

@@KrishnaSharma-nx9dy grrm would actually have to finish writing for his to be better, which he won’t which is fine I’d stop working if I were him but I’d at least be honest about it

keep up the good work Preston! you carry this community on your shoulders!

You have no idea how much I needed this today Preston. Thank you.

So what do we think is Preston's plan for Jeyne? I presume she's not getting manticored... is she just going to stay at the Crag with her lordly brother, is her brother Raynald going to reemerge and she'll end up reunited with him, will she get married off to her (probably kinslaying) ship captain cousin after he totally definitely doesn't kill Rollam, is she going to get wrapped up in the messy succession crisis that will eventually unfold at Winterfell? In a world where some people can use glass candles, ravens, dreams, weirwoods, etc. to mess with people's mental state, i would've thought someone would be interested in making it look like Jeyne is pregnant (by killing her maester and getting her to run away super suspiciously - something like that) to sow chaos in the Riverlands and North.

A whole prolog? And you managed this in less than 10 years not locked in a cabin? What sorcery is this?

@dinazwitscher9872

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe taiwan is the trick? Someone tell george

@mycattypedthis2827

2 жыл бұрын

collaborative work 😄

@e22ddie46

2 жыл бұрын

Dude has a young kid too. One I assume his wife expects him to occasionally help out with ;)

@ScamallDorcha

2 жыл бұрын

To be fair, Presto was just editing, maybe adding a bit of hiw own writing. Editing is a lot easier than writing from scratch.

@joeyrozic1100

2 жыл бұрын

Preston has energy to spare

Beautiful. Perfect timing for me to listen to. I am excited for what's to come. I would love for other KZread channels very familiar with _A Song of Ice and Fire_ like Quinn's Ideas to analyze these chapters once we are quite far into the writing of the book. This could become something big within the _Ice and Fire_ community, the writers might appreciate that.

@OwenTheLegend

2 жыл бұрын

Unrelated but your cosplays are awesome!

@ClaireYunFarronXIII

2 жыл бұрын

@@OwenTheLegend Thank you!

@brenttrotter88

2 жыл бұрын

Ha I was just thinking "wouldn't it great if Preston did a chapter analysis on this?" He could end it with "but I'm probably wrong about half of this" haha

This chapter is so good... gotta appreciate that THIS is how you continue a story. is it likely that GRRM's prologue will involve a Sorrowful Man? no. but should we include it anyways? absolutely, because there has to be SOMETHING - if you're reluctant to add new plot points, then you end up with the emptiness of the show's later seasons which sucks.

I was so excited for the ravens (Preston) to start screaming "CORN CORN CORN CORN", lemons being the answer to everything, going back to the tavern with Pate and the other acolytes, this really feels like the perfect prologue.

@postpunk6947

2 жыл бұрын

And Theon's child!

ok Preston. the first 2 chapters were pretty good, though there were parts that were a little clumsy. This chapter was just... amazing. Hats off to you and your editors!!!

@Radiotomb

2 жыл бұрын

Fantastic chapter, for sure

@zacrusk5274

2 жыл бұрын

Nope, fist two were gold, Preston is perfect.

@Radiotomb

2 жыл бұрын

@@zacrusk5274 Nope. First one was really cool. Hota was great. Prologue is absolutely perfect.

@zacrusk5274

2 жыл бұрын

@@Radiotomb NOPE! hota perfect, Danny perfect, John perfect, Preston perfect, chad summerchild PERFECT!!!!

This is fantastic. It feels almost like the ACOK prologue in reverse. And love Jon, super engaging character.

These keep getting better. When Winds finally comes I think it'll be hard to separate this from what's actually happening. I've already absorbed all of this into my headcanon.

Nice cameo by Theon's son. "Lemons are the answer", that part reminded me of the science class experience where we produced electricity with lemons ;)

Everyone is theorizing about the chapter on the Discord. Awesome!

Well done. Even with that pace of publishing Preston will finish the books much earlier then GRRM!

In the middle of a gripping story of a compelling character whose heart is in conflict you just throw in a frickin' heir to the iron isles casually. I have so many more questions but at this rate compared to GRRM's, I can wait. Thank you to everyone involved.

This one seems to be the best written one so far. I love the content, keep them coming.

"Jon had read of the maesters' 'fruitless' attempts..." Jon's attempt is 'fruitful because he uses lemons which are a fruit.

@SophiaLilithUwU

Жыл бұрын

It's also fruitful because Jon is fruity which means gay. :P

Amazing, hats off to everyone that contributed! My favorite chapter so far Little sad that Jon died though, bro just wanted to do science and kiss his crush. That's a lot more wholesome than most ASoIaF characters. Guess we have to keep with tradition though XD

@aslanevrim4348

2 жыл бұрын

Jon has already become one of the most tragic characters of a series that has Ned and Rob Stark, Micah the butcher's boy and the atrocities of the Mountain's men

@Dragon.um5tz

11 ай бұрын

Did they resurrect him

Must be hard for such a great writer like Gurm to see fans taking action into their own hands and essentially crowd-sourcing and finishing his magnum opus for him . These fan-fic chapter samples are dead-on in tone and pacing.

@princememphis7726

28 күн бұрын

Yeah he hated fan fic

Nice touch with Theon's baby!

@catscratch2020

2 жыл бұрын

Its Theons for sure !

@LB-ec9lx

2 жыл бұрын

Been scrolling all the way down to see if anyone spotted it

@karentargaryen7959

2 жыл бұрын

@@LB-ec9lx me too. That one stood out to me right away.

Well done! Loved the part where time travelling bran tells maester jon about the rock cycle in a telepathic message 😉

It sounds like the explanation for the seasons has something to do with a combination of plate tectonics (buoyancy of fluids, dragonglass being forced to the surface somehow, possibly iron from the planet's core?) and electromagnetism (lemons, copper, and a zinc ore making a battery of some sort, and the endless river representing a circuit). Like the sun of Planetos (Solos?) emits an electromagnetic field that causes the entire planet to have an erratic axial wobble or something.

@taylorkahl301

2 жыл бұрын

I'm for the wobbly spin axis theory. even Earth has a spin axis that gradually shifts over time due to natural phenomena e.g., shifting of land masses and ice/water across the globe

@CptnCardboard

2 жыл бұрын

I'm kind of thinking it has to do with an ancient impact event, since the comet is mentioned here this may be the operating theory.

@dicknijmegen

2 жыл бұрын

Not sure the battery for the glass candle relates to the seasons.

@IngTomT

2 жыл бұрын

@@taylorkahl301 It's mostly due to gravitational forces from the moon and the sun and other planets

@ksolesky2

2 жыл бұрын

Don't the dorthraki have a legend about planetos once having a second moon that cracked open and dragons came out? I think Planetos had a second moon that was hit by a comet/meteor and the debris, which would appear as shooting stars, was interpreted by ancient humans as dragons being born. This is probably what caused long night, as a form of nuclear winter, and the lack of a second moon gives planetos and irregular rotation and irregular seasons

“The gaze of man made crooked by his sin”😂😂😂😂 faith of the 7 for ya

You’re a man of action Preston! Nothing but respect for you and this undertaking. since the winds has been delayed and delayed I’m glad we have someone like you to take charge

Goddamn it, now we have to theorize over the fan fic! Who sent the Sorrowful man?!

I thought the Daenerys chapter was ok, but I loved Hotah and this one, can't wait for the next!

The problem with setting up cool mysteries like this is you're going to have to spoil them when you do the outline for a relevant chapter like Cersei I. Might need to start prefacing the outline videos as spoilers for the fan fiction project. Lol. Great job pulling it all together, Preston

Holy Sphinxes this is INCREDIBLE!! When Preston described his ideas for the chapter, I admit, I had serious doubts. It was way out of left field, and sounded all over the place. But this ended up being the finest chapter of all!!! Everyone who participated deserves the utmost praise. It's better than GRRM, I'm not afraid to say! And through this character and setting you manage to touch upon... Possibly *every single* domain in the story! 🤯👏👏👏👏👏

This was amazing, something I hate about most medieval/medieval inspired media is that they often present the characters as clueless and have never thought about anything deeper than their immediate future or worse idiots, you have brilliantly shown that these are not stupid character and they do think things bigger than themselves i.e. you'd never see someone in this inspired period to understand evaporation only wish this nuance came to more media 10/10

PJ IS BACK FOMOS

Preston, been following the channel for a long time but never felt the need to comment before: this is so good and the writers are talented.

Amazing chapter, really feels like a GrrM prologue imo. One correction, and it's really insignificant, but the ingredients given for the lemon battery shouldn't work. Calamine isn't metallic zink, so the reaction that produces electricity (metallic zink oxidizing and the formation of hydrogen gas) can't happen. Calamine, like most metal ores, is the oxidized form of zink, ZnCO3 or zink silicate.

Last chapter was definitely great, but this one was phenomenal! The exploration into the uneven seasons and the the big weirwood stump were perfect ideas, I loved the characters, loved the political implications, loved the Alleras cameo. As soon as the pale qartheen got off the ship I knew how it would end. My favourite part though, was the tease with the telescope. Great job fellas.

I’m heartbroken, I love this character so much!

Poor Jon. So much pain and trauma can be felt through the line. The metaphores used to describe his abuse are heart renching

The suspense of waiting for this next chapter has been killing me this past month. I'm beginning to understand what it's been like for fans waiting since 2011 for Winds. This chapter was well worth the wait thou

I just listened to the previous two chapters yesterday, and this one coming out was a pleasant surprise. Really can't wrap my head around the amount of effort that went into this project. I mean, it really does read like GRRRRM, it's really nuanced, and the atmosphere is very thick. Massive respect to everyone involved. Keep it up!

This is so good it's almost unbelievable that it's a fanfic. Of course, the Prologue POV character is always doomed to die, but this was so cruel yet so satisfying. And, it certainly, has the re-readable quality matching Martin's fiction.

Such a labour of love. Many thanks for everyone involved. I love the Jon Beware stuff. All the Jons really have to beware in this story...

@brigidscott4373

Жыл бұрын

Lol True

Another awesome chapter and beautifully read… thank you so so much for all the thought and work that goes into this project ❤️❤️❤️

Seeing this new update has brightened my whole day. Thank you all!

My Vacation just started, perfect timing for releasing this. Thank you Preston and everyone else involved.

Awesome stuff!! Loved the throwaway line about the Mallisters bitchin about the Iron born. Just an Easter egg that adds to Preston's theory that they had Balon killed.

@ksolesky2

2 жыл бұрын

If that's true they majorly fucked up. Euron seems more likely to attack seaguard than Balon.

The ending of this chapter was so good! Actually gasped even though I knew it was coming!

Thank you and everyone involved , it brought me so much joy

“Forgiven is not forgotten.”

Huge kudos to everyone involved in this wonderful project. Your writing and creativity is absolutely on par with George. From a dedicated fan, thank you for giving me the ending I always wanted!

👏👏👏 - the cohesiveness of your writing is improving at a significant rate. Much praise to all contributors for this undertaking. I along with thousands others are very grateful.

I've checked everyday for this. I can't wait.

Another wonderful chapter. Everyone involved deserves all the praise they are getting and more.

Damn this was fantastic!! Kept my interest from the first word to the last and had me wanting it to keep going. Thank you to everyone who submitted. This was excellently done.

I cannot thank enough Preston and everyone involved in this project. It is sooo good; I am always happy when I see a new chapter has been uploaded.

I’ve been waiting here for days. Start the damn chapter before I piss myself.

I have 3 laundry baskets, but I don't think that's enough for all the Easter Eggs! Thanks Preston and Team Sweet Robin!

I think listening to this makes me realize I want an official PJ narration of the books.

Amazing! Preston this chapter's writing is next-level. I would totally read a standalone book about this character. Keep it up!

PJ PLANNED IT ALL

You managed to make us care for a character in less than a chapter and take his life and hopes away. Why must prologues be so!

I laughed at first… but then… I realized how gd good it is

This was so good!!! I'm not sure if any of the stuff I wrote actually worked its way in.... but I don't care, because the result is a beautiful chapter. Thank you Preston for taking the time to put together this project.

Wow, the best one yet PJ! You and the writers are absolutely killing it.

Do the people who are deeper into the PJ theories know what Jon discovered and wrote to Marwin? Or is this a newly invented mystery?

@alanpennie8013

2 жыл бұрын

I believe it's newly invented. Jon has found a pattern linking The Moon to the seasons.

Weird. I didn't get a notification for this one. It also didn't appear on the subscriptions list thing. Instead, by complete chance, I manually searched Preston's playlists to find another video to sleep to and there it was. Anyway, great job as always. This is definitely the best chapter so far

@keirangrant1607

2 жыл бұрын

It just popped up 1-minute ago for me and its 0926 for me

@manband20

2 жыл бұрын

Apparently it was unlisted in the playlist for a few hours and only went public in the past few minutes. You're one of the lucky ones!

@janicel.6971

2 жыл бұрын

I'm glad I'm not that only one that listens to Preston's videos to sleep haha.

@dicknijmegen

2 жыл бұрын

For me it was also complete chance. I certaintly haven't been checking if it was out every day for the past 2 weeks ;)

You are above even The Author. I hereby award you the title of Big Author. You are a true writer.

By the Seven! This is the best chapter so far!! Amazing work, all those who contributed.

wow, honestly this was incredible work. i feel like, even independent of the series its so well woven into, this would be a fascinating chapter to read/hear. wonderful!

Every timer I see or hear the word “corn” I hear it in the voice of Roy Dotrice.

Great job to everyone who contributed! You keep outdoing yourselves and I can’t wait to see what comes next.

Poor maester Jon! My favorite chapter so far this really was amazing and the twist at the end!

HOW DID I WAIT 2 DAYS TO READ THIS! Seriously, Preston and his channel have saved me from many many long dark nights of the soul.

Yooooooo, this can serve as a short story by itself and win a prize

I prefer the zombie-werewolf-fetus ending of my submission, but this works too. Nice work, Preston!

Just writing in to say this is my fourth listen to the chapter, and I can't wait for the ensuing discussion 🦂

The set up of Jon wanting to go home and about to go home, then in GRRM fashion it was subverted with a pinch to the ankle.

😭 I’M SO HAPPY I WAITED A FEW MONTHS TO CHECK IT’S SUCH A BEAUTIFUL EUPHORIC SURPRISE TO SEE ANOTHER CHAPTER Once again, a million and one thanks to all contributors and Preston himself

Truly an engaging chapter. I honestly think it's my favorite. It gave me chills, at the end, and I regret that I waited until 4 in the morning to listen to it.

These are beyond excellent. Preston, I implore you to gather these writers and pen an original fantasy/scifi piece. It would be an outstanding work.