"Pie In The Sky Abject Nonsense" | Julia Hartley-Brewer vs Dale Vince
Dale Vince and Julia Hartley-Brewer debate the effectiveness of climate change policies in Scotland, with Vince advocating for target-based approaches and Hartley-Brewer questioning the feasibility of the Scottish government's targets.
They also discuss the viability of renewable energy and nuclear power as backup sources, with Vince emphasizing the potential of renewable energy and Hartley-Brewer highlighting the limitations of renewable sources.
Julia Hartley-Brewer: “You’re quite wrong! Car manufacturers were lobbying the Government saying ‘you’ll have to push the date back because we can’t sell them.'”
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#dalevince #juliahartleybrewer #energy #climatechange #scotland
Пікірлер: 555
dale vince - what a grifter!
@collier8931
Ай бұрын
Spot on
@m.bowyer5045
Ай бұрын
Dale Vince-cult leader
@ZER0--
Ай бұрын
How so?
@collier8931
Ай бұрын
@@ZER0-- Gets the bulk of his money off government subsidies.
@phily8093
Ай бұрын
What a haircut! What a jacket! Climate crisis? Midlife crisis more like.
It must be great to be a champagne socialist, not a care in the world
@uniquevideosUk
Ай бұрын
Exactly 💯 his lifes a breeze off the poorest in the country, what Labour are encouraging.
@stonemarten1400
Ай бұрын
Yeah, imagine living in a terraced house in northern England trying to charge your electric car in the busy street? Totally impractical and unaffordable for poor or working class people. EVs are second cars for virtue-signalling, middle class or wealthy people with detached houses and warmed garages, subsidised by ordinary tax payers. It’s the polar opposite of environmentally friendly.
Dale ……..I have my fingers in my ears and I am not going to listen to the FACTS I am in my little loony climate emergency Bubble.
Middle aged teenage tantrum.
This man makes millions from Government subsidies.
@KINGSLEY-TV
Ай бұрын
Or he’s just a good guy which a good head on his shoulders trying his best who is a self made multi millionaire and people think that’s from subsidies which is utter nonsense.
@KernowFay
Ай бұрын
@@KINGSLEY-TV These companies have lots of subsidies.
@bettyswollocks4255
Ай бұрын
@@KINGSLEY-TV If the UK sunk into the sea tomorrow it would make no difference to the worlds carbon output. The drive to take this country to net zero, stopping all oil based products is going to have such a negative impact on peoples lives especially the poorer in society. I genuinely think people don't understand how bad its going to be, and they will push back. I personally think when that happens so you will see a very different side to this guy and people just like him. He's one of those people who think democracy is great until they don't get their way then it's a bad populist, far right blah, blah, blah process.
@bobsocks7575
Ай бұрын
@@KINGSLEY-TVYou mean it’s not from the £36m the last Labour government gave to Labour donor Dale Vince?
@patriciakeen6687
Ай бұрын
My target is to never listen to anything this man says
He talks BS
@user-xv2kk5fe5b
Ай бұрын
He's an absolute clown. A bit of a non-league joke like his excuse for a football team will soon be. The guy lives in a utopian dreamworld which will never exist.
@jackryder-sw9rk
Ай бұрын
How so? Explain, or are you just spewing BS that Fred down the pub told you?
You will never convince a man who's entire income depends on not being convinced Vince is such a scam artist
@rjones6219
Ай бұрын
Made £100M out of subsidies.
@jhonson7079
Ай бұрын
You will never change a toy government Who earns millions from the oil industry
@jhonson7079
Ай бұрын
You can say the same for the an electric prime minister millions from oil companies
Middle age man wearing a skull and cross bones top, says it all.
@robertadams1054
Ай бұрын
Twit.
@jacquelinethomas4932
Ай бұрын
I bet he’s really good fun at a party 😂…
@Eric-qm5xw
Ай бұрын
Pieces of eight ..😂
@stonemarten1400
Ай бұрын
@@Eric-qm5xwstacking-up his doubloons
@nightowl7459
Ай бұрын
@@robertadams1054I think you have accidentally put a I where there should be an A?
He's so full of crap 🤦
@KINGSLEY-TV
Ай бұрын
He must be doing something right considering he’s a self made multi millionaire and people say that’s from subsidies which is utter bollocks lol.
@evo4ralliart
Ай бұрын
@@KINGSLEY-TV but if you look into it the money is from subsidies sadly
@uniquevideosUk
Ай бұрын
@@KINGSLEY-TV Yeah he's wanting to make money & grow his business! He likes taking holidays on ✈️ to enjoy the wealth he makes of the poorest in the country, you do know ppl are struggling right? Not all are as comfortable as yourself.
@jhonson7079
Ай бұрын
I think you mean she
@jhonson7079
Ай бұрын
I thing you mean she🤔
No, the EV mandate was pushed back because it's not physically possible. This guy is doesn't live on the same planet as those with common sense.
@scatton61
Ай бұрын
When over 50% of the potential car owner sector cannot charge their vehicles from home there's no chance that this will ever succeed.
@therainbowgulag.
Ай бұрын
@@scatton61plus the second hand market is none existent so they'll end making more new cars and this pollution.
@techtipsuk
Ай бұрын
You didn’t need to use the word common in your comment.
Stop this Net Zero madness, it will leave us poorer and impoverished. We little people should not drive or go on holiday!
@stonemarten1400
Ай бұрын
Yes, it will leave the poor and middle-earners poorer and impoverished - the higher earners will sit pretty in their warm detached houses, driving their EVs to the local shops, whilst using their diesel SUVs to cross the channel for skiing holidays on the continent.
Watched 5 mins ,enough shite 😡😡
A 62 y/o dressing like an edgy teenager is peak cringe
@calstonjew
Ай бұрын
He's not wearing a dress and he doesn't have pink hair.
What a silly old man.
Not that the man has a dog in this race. How many millions of our money does he get in grants.
@pommiebears
Ай бұрын
Plenty enough!
Should not have chopped down 16 million trees then . 😡😡😡❤️
Dale Vance is so patronising and deluded
@andyrobinson7071
29 күн бұрын
And she isn’t. She should Check the facts before you host a tv program, and do a proper job and report the facts
Is this man going to be any financially wealthier spouting all this bs, somehow i think so.
He’s the reason most football fans want forest green relegated
@leewetherelt8925
Ай бұрын
They have been.
"That's not true "...without any real argument to follow!! This guy is a flog!!
He’s a business man earning huge amounts of money from the green agenda! So let’s listen to him 🤣🤣
Perhaps somebody in the Net Zero lobby will actually tell us what a "Net Zero target" actually is? "Zero" is zero, nil, zilch, nought, nothing, nowt.. How can there possibly be "net" of nothing when "gross" of nothing is nothing? The whole thing is an egotist nonsense.
@boxfullofneutral8514
Ай бұрын
Err offset?
@heinzmonster
Ай бұрын
They're called trees pal
@uniquevideosUk
Ай бұрын
@@heinzmonster what Dale wants to cut down to help his business.
@dartskipper3170
Ай бұрын
@@boxfullofneutral8514Still doesn't work because there will still be pollution that your offsets are supposed to cancel out of the equation. Doh.....
@andrewscott8950
Ай бұрын
@@dartskipper3170 I didn’t say it would work, but the eejit who posted doesn’t understand simple equations
Could Dale explain HOW we will stop climate change given history and science shows this is the 8th time in 800000 years this has happened???? Does he think we can Stop good old mother nature???
@hudsonbear5038
Ай бұрын
As too his we have back up... eeeeeeeeeeerm yeah thats why the Gov and energy companies keep saying we have at best 5-8% spare capacity.... And we need too build more power stations, which eco nutjobs keep getting blocked... As to the daily 50% of the energy being green a few weeks ago they say it was 87% lol but when you look at the actual data the green energy provides between 3-78% of our daily needs depending on the WEATHER....
@heinzmonster
Ай бұрын
Awful big coincidence that our current sweeping climate change happened around the time of the industrial revolution
@Richard482
Ай бұрын
Because changes in CO2 concentrations is one of the main reasons for those changes in climate over the last 800,000 years.
@hudsonbear5038
Ай бұрын
@@Richard482 yeah so what???
@Richard482
Ай бұрын
@@hudsonbear5038 So the warming effect of CO2 is still the same, regardless of whether it comes from the ocean, a volcano or a powerstation.
If he can't be honest about facts (such as the car industry's reports) how can anyone trust him on anything else he says.
@timkendall4074
Ай бұрын
The car industry has not said it can't sell electric cars. Sales of electric cars are slightly down due to cost but as Vince said they will get cheaper. Also electric cars are not the only solution. When you strip an argument of all nuance and detail to prop up your view have you really achieved anything except cheering from Those that already agree with you. That is 'populist' media.
Dale dressing like a 12 year old and talking like one again 😀😀
Julia was bloody good there, she had him, beat him with facts, and alls he could repeat is ''You don't know what you're talking about''
@danielearley5062
Ай бұрын
That's all he ever says.
About time he was arrested for funding criminal activity !
Dale..."I'll talk over you because what you are saying doesn't fit my narrative!"
Dale thinks he is a member of Spandau Ballet.
@donner101
Ай бұрын
Spandau Ballet think he is a member.
@markullyott9453
Ай бұрын
"We can see a pattern" and "this event hasn't happened before"... one of many of Dippy Daves non sensicle answers. What a Cranium Head
Dale not conVINCE is a narcissistic ponce
I am 70 year old why would I buy solar panel, I could be dead before I pay off the finance.
@M8d9R
Ай бұрын
You'll live well beyond 78 my friend.
@steelearmstrong9616
Ай бұрын
@@M8d9R hmmmmmm
This man is making millions from us the taxpayer, next time you drive past a wind turbine that's not spinning around remember that the company is being paid for it to stand idle and this man is profiting from it...
Dale o Dale. Once all the people see through this scam, you will need to find a proper job...😂
When you're a multi millionaire you do not have to worry about poverty when the cost of bills goes up, he'll still have luxury whilst we live in poverty. One more thing, how can he criticise about Julia's views when he is a Holocaust denier, denying the climate is wrong but denying the Holocaust is okay, strange man.
@heinzmonster
Ай бұрын
Your bills will be a whole lot worse if the climate collapses
Car crash comes to mind !
So he makes money with government subsidies. It’s all a great big con and we are the people who pay
Dale Vince is a 'green energy industrialist' and mult-millionaire. How does he make his money? 🤪🤪🤪
Tesla Laying off workers due to lack of sales!
@michaelheadley2041
Ай бұрын
Seen it
@heinzmonster
Ай бұрын
Due to Chinese competition and poor products, not due to lack of a market
I think Dale is morphing into Eddie Izard
@gedrooney9305
Ай бұрын
That’s Mrs Eddie Izzard to you/them/ me
This man lives in an alternate universe. One that’s strictly between his ears!
I find there is something very dark and almost evil about Dale Vince’s demeanour
The demand for electricity if even half of new cars sold were electric would far outstrip supply.
He's a chancer!!!
Dale is so ‘woke’ he hates you Julia 😂😂😂
@user-vo5bb3du5d
Ай бұрын
yes ,you could see he was up for a fight from his initial attitude when Julia said good afternoon .
Dale Vince & Jim Dale both have the same former and sir name and both talk the same crap!
All this crap will sink like his vegan football club forest green rovers .
When car charging networks stop been so greedy and bring pricing to be competitive, people may think about buying them, too expensive
Where's the silly prats scarf, is he off the Palestine Bus, total bell end and his football team are gash too.
A friend of mine is selling his electric car, it’s too expensive to insure and he hasn’t got the confidence to go on a long journey in it.He uses his wife’s petrol Mini.
What planet is he from?
How many times did he say that’s not true no counter argument whatsoever
Hello Dale can I plant all those avacado stones so global warning gives me a thriving avacado orchard in my garden?
Dale is a climate change nutter
Says we won’t loose electricity but going back last year they were complaining about how much homes were using letting alone millions of car using electric it don’t make sense. Change the narrative when it suits
I have never owned a new car so who is going to find me a second hand EV for 2 grand ??
@deja-view1017
Ай бұрын
Then you'll have to deal with the ridiculous cost of replacing the battery which (they say) last about 10yrs. My car is older than that!
@christinebakewell3475
Ай бұрын
@@deja-view1017 your bang on - these knob jockeys live in the twilight zone - far less sense than money- where do I plug in ? I can’t park within a hundred yards of my home on a normal day - this guy needs to take a long walk off a short pier .
@jimwatson7238
Ай бұрын
That's the whole point they don't want ordinary people driving.
@deja-view1017
Ай бұрын
@@jimwatson7238 Then they'd better provide an alternative. A bus once a day isn't going to cut it.
@johnjc4645
Ай бұрын
@@deja-view1017we haven't had a bus service since the start of COVID they were going to have a trial period before but COVID came now nothing and no sign of them ever starting again
JHB 1 The PONCE 0....a modern day Jimmy Saville with his tracksuit on.
@dlamiss
Ай бұрын
An eco lunatic yep but comparing him to Savile is a bit much
@jamesgibson3598
Ай бұрын
@@dlamiss maybe it was a bit harsh...should not throw the ponce thing around
Jesus christ what a dreamer. Electric car sales are falling Dale. That means people don't want them. Stay off the drugs and get a haircut.
Unusual that a man thinks only businesses such as his can save the world he insists is in grave peril, unless we all spend money on businesses like his.🤔🌎💷💷
He's not very convincing IMO.
It seems very strange to me that a man of dales age grooms himself and dresses like he does , alarm bells are ringing for me , sorry but that’s what I see and I just can’t take him seriously 🤷
@davidwinkle4168
Ай бұрын
I think he is trying to copy Greta!
The logic is like the hairdo: curiously wrong. And I'm not talking about Julia!
@James-mn1ng
Ай бұрын
Power cut in the middle of haircut 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
How can you trust a 50 year guy who dresses like a 16 year skateboarder!
@m.bowyer5045
Ай бұрын
Cult Leader
@calstonjew
Ай бұрын
Tim Pool is nearly 40.
an old man dressing like 12 year old haha what a joker
@stonemarten1400
Ай бұрын
Yeah and his little pirate outfit, with wee shark tooth 😂
@nightowl7459
Ай бұрын
@@stonemarten1400I'm surprised he's not got a XV skateboard tucked under his arm.
@sheilagill8385
Ай бұрын
His barber wants sacking/or good for him,charging him a fortune and giggling all the way home
The average man/woman can bearly afford their bills let alone buying an EV for £18,000 - £30,000 plus paying insurance and not to mention if your lucky to have the space outside your house to charge it. Their not suitable for everyone and we should have a choice as a society not by force as Julia mentioned no one really wants one otherwise they would of been high demand flying out the show rooms and their NOT!
This was like watching a parent arguing with a toddler. Julia you have more patience then me. God help us all
DV is earning a fortune out of this nonsense
How’s the guys football team doing?
@robertadams1054
Ай бұрын
Where did he get his money from, especially as he is a donor for the Labour shower.
Aaaaash the multi millionaire Dale Vince . . .
This men makes a lot of money out of this climate change crap
I lived in Dubai in1970s and 80s. Always heavy rains a few days a year. Sometimes even hail and snow
When’s this global warming coming- it’s mid April and it’s freezin.
Never trust a man who paints his nails!
Never trust a old person who dresses like a fifteen year old.
This guy is proof positive that not only is interstellar travel possible but can be done on a daily basis because he certainly doesn't live on this planet. Julia, you got what is backup, and what is the base load ,the so-called renewables ( these aren't renewable and they are worse for the environment and the poor ever suffering taxpayers). This man is delusional, talk about making up facts.
You are right Juli e. I would not buy an Electric car ever, and I have been driving for 70 years both Commercial and Private.
….they seeded and reaped…now drink and wash.
Of course you do Dale, is there any part of the Trillion Dollar a year climate industry that you don’t believe?
@stonemarten1400
Ай бұрын
Yeah, he cares about the planet so much, I guess he’s reduced his own carbon footprint down to that of the average Mongolian goat herder?
Dale Vince is living in La La land.
These people are deluded
Its all bollox
Has a slightly vested interest. Starting to see his proposition going down the drain.
What planet is this guy from ..? He's a danger to himself ...a fool and his money are soon parted.
Julia Hartley-Brewer is a genius. Honest.
I get really tired of listening to people who would agree with a fact if it smacked them in the face!
There is no point in getting an electric car if the infrastructure is not there.
He’s toxic.
This man is clearly a total ham shank .
Dale wants to grow his own business & this is Labours idea on the UK.
Dubai cloud seeding 😂
This guy is the cleverest climate educator I have ever seen.
It's like dealing with Flat Earthers. The more people who buy electric cars the more fossil fuel generation we will need.
"Thanks for inviting me on your show to hear you scream over me ".
Well that was Kevin where's Perry?
Why is half of his head/hair missing?
@nightowl7459
Ай бұрын
Because half his brain is also missing.
sorry mate forest green got relegated , ' i don't think that's true we are still in the league' vince , probly
Pity they aren't targeting the rich people who are making vast amounts of monies from our utilities
£60,000 for an electric car could you afford that.
I for one wouldn't buy an electric vehicle in a million years.
This guy is a climate grifter .... he makes millions marketing this nonsense to us mugs California recently asked EV owners not to charge their cars as the grid could not cope ......10% of cars in California are EVs
Its almost as if he has a vested interest but I am sure that cant be true. He is right about Nuclear though