P Chidambaram on what he would do if he was Jaitley | Devender Sharma on solving farmer crisis
Ойын-сауық
P Chidambaram and Devinder Sharma talk about the Indian economy under the NDA government and the current state of the country’s agricultural sector with Shoma Chaudhury at Algebra, The Arts & Ideas Club, Gurgaon on 26 November 2016.
Former union finance minister, Mr.P Chidambaram, talks about demonetisation, its effects on the Indian economy and whether it was worth it. He explains that income that ought to taxed has escaped taxation. He says that in order to end the shadow economy, all income should be taxed; and, the devised taxation machinery should be effective.
Devinder Sharma, a renowned agricultural economist, argues about how the government’s policies devised to allegedly generate employment are skewed policies. He says the government understands employment generation as pushing people from the rural to the urban areas; as a consequence of which, most people work as daily wage labourers. Furthermore, he proposes that if the government would actually concentrate on improving the agricultural sector and increases the MSP, it would boost the country’s GDP while simultaneously solving the issue of growing farmer crisis and their suicide.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe To "Algebra Club" Channel HERE: goo.gl/Y9TB76
For more content from "Algebra Club", click HERE: goo.gl/24X5NH
Like "Algebra Club" on Facebook HERE: goo.gl/B66ZA6
Follow "Algebra Club" on Twitter HERE: goo.gl/JWLpTj
---
Algebra takes the idea of a club - a universe of the likeminded - and expands it to new paradigms. The key idea behind Algebra is to bring together a fellowship of people who believe great cities are built not just on infrastructure but a life of the mind; who understand robust and liberal societies need the oxygen of great conversation and nuanced thinking. At a time when we are increasingly surrounded by rage and noise, Algebra is that unique live and continuous space where people could go for a genuine exchange of ideas and exposure to issues; where new seeds could be sparked, fresh perspectives formed, and intelligent connections made.
Algebra - the Arts and Ideas Club is designed to host over 60 conversations over the year with topline thinkers and practitioners from almost every discipline that impacts human affairs: politics, economy, environment, spirituality, cinema, medicine, science, technology, music, media, literature, the arts, sports, people’s movements, et al. In a line, Algebra is a space where one can meet an exciting, cutting-edge spectrum of people shaping the world in different ways. Where one can test one’s ideas, challenge one’s perspectives, and build friendships. A sort of fellowship of the curious and engaged.
Membership to Algebra is by invitation or referral. If you know an Algebra member, ask them to put you in touch with us.
For more, click HERE:
www.algebratheclub.com/members...
Пікірлер: 83
all butchery is not surgery. Surgery is a precise activity. Chidambaram is right.
@sathyanathanmenon7778
6 жыл бұрын
I wonder why did you not implement all these wonderful ideas when you were in power? All that we heard was news about scam after scam which booted out your party from power.
How intelligent is he. Some feels proud to listen his every points. Well thought and put forward.
nice and clear explanation....
Chidambaram very interesting person
@rajanramaswami2911
5 жыл бұрын
He is an ace crook.
It is surprising> Mr Devender sharma, you have really enlightened us with the real problems of the farmers and its solutions. If the schemes of subsidy in huge volumes as in foreign countries to farmers, then perhaps that wont reach the actual farmers, but the politicians and their spouses, who actually show farm production on records and get away with subsidies. there should be some other novel way, where actual farmer community should flourish and prosper, which in turn drives the growth of other sectors of economy and push the GDP to double digit as well. You deserve to be in Govt. as an advisor in Agricultural ministry
Very good articulation of points sir!
I cannot really say if Chidambaram is corrupt or not or if his son is corrupt or not. If they are then the judicial needs to take charge. However will say this that this man has a far better understanding of the economics and finance as compared to Jaitley and NDA Government leaders. Demonetisation has devastated a well running economy. One would then think that the government learnt the lesson as far as the implementation part is concerned but no. They repeated the same mistake with how they introduced GST. Lack of clarity and ridiculous taxation slabs with little help available. And what is the deal with 49 returns in a year. How does one expect small businesses to comply. Poor governance.
@johnvarghese2120
5 жыл бұрын
with his "far better" understanding of economy what did chidambaram do during the 10 years? he was the finance minister even in 1990's too. while china has rocketed to world super power since 1990, india is still considered third world. the only person benefitted were chidambaram, his family and congis whose wealth have skyrocketed. GST had to be brought some day and it takes time to implement it in a huge nation like india, where building a flyover takes years. someone had to swallow the bitter pill even it came at political cost. congress sat on GST for decades fearing loss of votes. if it were implemented before, we would have a much better economy today. economies are not made by one person taking decisions. agreed that the current govt is inexperienced but we are atleast on the right path today
One more request to the Programme Convener of Algebra; the slides which you are displaying behind the speech; few of them are not relevant to the discussion. Say for example when there was a discussion went on pertinent to the Agri Sector along with Sharma Ji, there was a slide depicting demonetization and the comment of some experts. Display a slide which is relevant to the discussion or topic of the discussion will be more suitable.
he gave the percentage of shadow economy for both China and US and missed the percentage for India because the percentage is over 40%! He is one of the architects of that and he doesn't accept it. This is available at 6:00
@imsayraj
6 жыл бұрын
Where did you get 40 percent? Was it in your dream?
Condition of indian economy is like Jaitley
How does it matter whether make in India is for India or for the world?
Very intelligent to went into the bar.
The problem started with congress govt allowing corruption by its allies with no checks on them and than people voted BJP without realising BJP has no able individuals to run a country. Now Modi self servingly made this foolish decision to fulfil his rhetoric without realising how blunderess the decision would be cos he has all spineless psycophants around him who wouldn't dare to question his foolish ideas.
👍👍👍👍👍👍
A jail sentence would bring out truths about some undesirable politicians like the person Ex minister Chidambaram.
Normally the moderator is unbiased but I notice mostly all your speakers as well as you Ms.Shoma vehemently disgrace current government
Superb ! Half Chaddhi Gaye full Chaddhi bane, langoti bankar lauti. 😂😂😂
*land ceiling act
Sharma is a great men
MR. Goody Goody Singh and Mr. M.M. Singh wasted ten years and now the new lot has complicated the situation.The corporate sector is real winner to grab 60 percent share of the economy.
Chidambram GDP = Madagascar GDP + Ghana GDP + Cypress GDP
big thievies chidambaram Arun Jetly
with his "far better" understanding of economy what did chidambaram do during the 10 years? he was the finance minister even in 1990's too. while china has rocketed to world super power since 1990, india is still considered third world. the only person benefitted were chidambaram, his family and congis whose wealth have skyrocketed. GST had to be brought some day and it takes time to implement it in a huge nation like india, where building a flyover takes years. someone had to swallow the bitter pill even it came at political cost. congress sat on GST for decades fearing loss of votes. if it were implemented before, we would have a much better economy today. economies are not made by one person taking decisions. agreed that the current govt is inexperienced but we are atleast on the right path today
Mr P. Chidambaram just grilled the opposition on a barbecue whereas Mr Devendra rightly broke the agony and plight of the backbones of the country.
She starts asking an important question and then she says I won't get into it right now! Why do you even raise the question when you are not interested to persue It? But apart from this this is a great forum I am a big fan of Shoma and Algebra. Great platform good constructive and balanced discussions. Thanks a lot.
Anchor is hell bent in proving that BJP is corrupt... Shame on her...
Eligible to teach economy in uni, not to be finance minister.
I mean politicians in this country own major chunks of lands in their names Benaamis. There should proper land ceiling and one cannot own more than few acres and there should be ban in land conversion from agricultural to commercial especially where water canals are in place
Hindi channels also have to do such kind of discussion rather than wasting time in stupid religious discussion...
Neither am I a dynasty slave nor a Bhakt, just a common citizen. Shoma kept mentioning again & again about NDA regime not creating enough jobs but Mr.Nitin Gadkari has gone on record to claim that as per an IIT study, for every 1000 crore invested one lakh direct or indirect employment is created. By this logic, he claims that infact NDA has created more jobs than what they have promised in their manifesto. Now either IITians are insane (which is hard to digest) or Nitin Gadkari has his facts incorrect. Why don't you call him in this show and literally grill him on what is the truth? Let him substantiate his claims by evidence and figures. More than anything all citizens have the right to know if election manifestos are delivered or not?
@tanjukhurana
5 жыл бұрын
Ashutosh Deshpande algebra only invites anti-bjp.
Heard an information long time before that Mr.Chidambaram has sold the old machines to Pakistan, which is used in Nashik for Printing the Rupee notes. More no. of counterfeit Indian Rupees been manufactured in Pakistan and it is coming back to India through Kashmir. This is one of the reason for Demonitisation that the type and colour including the GSM of the Rupee paper has been changed. Of course our people have faced huge trouble, but when it comes to the discussion that PC is also one among the reason a furious cause for this action is giving little pain in me. Because I respect him a lot for his intellect and the way that he handled the questions from any interviewer. But it is really hurt me that he has utilised his intelligence and authority for selfish purpose rather than for the nation.
@Gangakinartheke
3 жыл бұрын
Do you think that can be a reliable info? I mean its a common sense no gov will give another country their security features so that they can counterfeit and smuggle back their currency. Let alone pakistan. Selling machine does not mean they sold all the secret prints also. Pakistan themselves developed the technology to counterfeit indian currency as north korea does with US dollar.
Mr PC talks about Ethics and Morality and anchor doesn't contest?! He embodies the height of corruption, plunder and nepotism
Chidambaram shame of you. What is your position right now.
Spineless Chidambaram didn't had the guts to face Mr Sharma Questions because he knows successive goverments have been succumbing to WTO & world bank pressures in terms of agriculture issues .
Sir ! When are they sending you to Tihar ?
why don't you be fair and invite someone from bjp also. all this while you propogate only one side of the story
Mr. Sharma ?
What did he do when he was in power? The farmers issue had been there for several decades. When they are spring in the opposition they are wiser !!!!? Whole in power may be they are busy making money for themselves
Idea club ivanydam eppady kollay adykka mudyndhadhu endru kethiradha
i
What abovut pvt co employs proper epf pension from service 1970 to 1998 yrs last month salary ₹4500/ m I get my epf pension ₹ 220 , 500, 800/ m last 20 yrs at now my. Age 75 yrs in govt same level emplos getting pension ₹35000/ m the froud unqulified pa sy thirudan all pvt co employs pala kody epf moneyay loot out syudhu thirudy vittan rtd pvt co employs pattyny pottu paavam panny vittan pvt co employs saabam dhaan Ivan kamby ennynan Ivan kollay adytha panathay avan vamsam anubavikkadhu mody ji iydam peasy. Min ₹5000/ m vaangy koduthal pavan vimosanam kidaykkalam thozhylalargalin thurogy indha low class kasadan indhyraindhyrany mugargy dhosha kuttayil kulithu vidhyay veenakkyavan employs saabam palykkiradhu
BJP might get a failure in new implementations, at least they are trying to change the country even though no one supporting. If this guy becomes Finance minister again they simply eating peoples money and they talk about dalith, minority every day just to get some sympathy votes.
@a1t168
3 жыл бұрын
Haa haa gobag andbhakt tabhi iss desh ki economy -24% giri
He was finance minister for 10 years could do nothing what he will do now bloody corrupts.
Maadhar "chor"
We miss you so much sir, chai wala and his kaitely has fucked the economy
I'm at 5 secs in this video and i can tell you what chidbum would do.....he'll give all the money to his idly overdosed son karthi. Waste of time and space of this video in youtube.
This guy is so demented...he was in jaitley's place for so long and drove the economy to the abyss... what do you have to say about yourself and Karti... corrupt to the core... I hate his smug all intelligent appearance
Here is indias most prolific money launder via participatory notes lecturing us on black money....wow.
He would take lots of bribe which Jaitely is not doing.
just watch the body language of the host vs one with bjp guests. Algebra is another match fixing media game sponsored by congress. the host has clearly received the blessings of manu singhvi ;)
@ravindraharsoor3460
6 жыл бұрын
Prasad Ligade If it is true, then it is disappointing to see such talented and intelligent anchor wasting her talent on corrupt and wrong end.