This is by a very long margin by far the best compilation I have ever come across. Not just in respect of Chomsky but of anybody or anything. I don't think I've ever learned as much in a 4 plus hour period, whilst enjoying myself at the same time, in my life. I can't thank you enough for putting the time and effort into preparing it. Chomsky is brilliant, the compilation is brilliant, what else can I say.

@Anarchist0707

Жыл бұрын

Chomsky is the most sincere and honest intellectual of the century, he is Gallelio.

@JavierBonillaC

8 ай бұрын

I have said somewhere else that if aliens asked us to “send us your best”, and I was in charge of the decision, I’d send them Chomsky. If they said send us your worst I’d send 45 or else the President of Mexico (my president).

@johnhelm6231

7 ай бұрын

Good job five stars 😅😮🎉

@fabiengerard8142

2 ай бұрын

🙏🏻🙏🏽🙏

@regaliaretailfashionmerch4314

22 күн бұрын

Natural history and Evolutionary Anthropology, related fields should be of much interest to you then in case you want to look deeper into deep time and dawn of humanity, also their study is positively liberating Good luck

Thank you for posting Noam's genius.

Another great time paying attention to Noam Chomsky trying to understand the miracle of our thoughts and how we express ourselves in words that reach concepts.

Gives one a lot to think about, it's cool to have so much of Noman's presentations from over many years in one place, sort of like a library!!! Good Job

I love Chomsky..." If you take a look at..." We all had better take a look at. Then, " take a simple example..." We'd all better be puzzled enough to look for examples before we believe in any ole' thing. And then, " Just ask yourself..."

Thank you for compiling these fantastic excerpts, really appreciate it, really good for meditation or mental subliminal relaxation. 🌹♥️🌹 Luv Shan 🌹♥️🌹

Thank you so, so much for uploading this

This is an awesome compilation, thankyou so much for taking the time to create it 🙏

Thank you for compiling this post

Thank you for this compilation. Love it.

“the actual rules of language, which certainly are not taught in school because nobody even knows them…” That was an insight that I didn’t have

Noam is like Mr. Spock and the rest of us like Captain Kirk. We simply cannot argue with Mr. Spock's Vulcan logic just marvel as its brilliance. lol

It's so simple you look right past it. His whole philosophy is we are biological creatures with a weird adaptation that allows "thought".

@tommytwobrews

Ай бұрын

i disagree

@tommytwobrews

Ай бұрын

Hey, I said i disagree!

@tommytwobrews

Ай бұрын

Give your head a shake, I'm disagreeing with you over here!

great compilation

Chomsky looks scary in the first video lol. But amazing! Thank you for posting!

@OngoGablogian185

Жыл бұрын

Beauty is a short-lived tyranny! Getting old sucks.

@fabiengerard8142

Жыл бұрын

Scary?!? 😮 What do you mean exactly?

thank you this is so good

I love his patience with the second interviewer- "so, you mean that languages other than english also allow for creative thought?" lmao

Blessings To All Worthy Of Being Blessed

@fabiengerard8142

Жыл бұрын

👌🏻👌🏽👌

It would be nice if the interviewer in the first long clip would shut up and let Noam talk.

He thinks normally what I think when I’m high.

I talk to myself because few listen to me .. yes a very human condition as we scream into the void we are trained to perceive .. The true human paradox of self delusion .. The powers that be spend a lot of effort to reprogram a natural human being. All about power over others

His biggest mistake is when he says that our thoughts and linguistic expressions are not caused by stimuli, either external or internal. By the laws. of physics they must be.

Studying animal and insect in itself is a complex challenge, the more we study one species the more we understand its connection with its world. If we are determined enough we end up studying the whole super structure. Ofcourse this study entails years and years of information gathering, yet no one study is conclusive, a new researchers always and always finds out something significant that enhances the understanding, alter firmly held assumption. Human beings are big complex than animal, he creates environments, his ability to do this makes it an multi faceted study, there is atleast a 20 to 25 spheres that are creating the human mind and human world. And we keep identifying newer keys all the time that reveal an hidden physiological activity or a deeper motivation that encourage us to keep investigating. A process that took millions years can not be revealed in one book or one study, it gets exhsustive enough for you to give up or often can lead to a mental emotional fatigue, we keep at it nevertheless. Our mystery is very much the mystery of the universe/multiverse.

According to The Urantia Book there are several stages involved in evolutionary conscious mind development that are applicable only to living organisms, which also explains how the human race evolved from simple organised plasms of micro-organisms, established in the shallow briney seas of long ago, during the Proterozoic era. This began firstly with the evolutionary conscious development of -Intuition-, which involves the intuitive urge to grow, develop and evolve, from simple to complex micro-oganisms to primitive marine vegetation, then evolving into a more prolific complexed advanced marine vegetation. Then by evolutionary mutation evolved into simple primitive marine animal organisms, during the beginning of the Paleozoic era. During this era evolutionary consciousness was to make further advances in -Understanding- and -Courage- with the appearance of early primative marine-life evolutionary mind. By the end of this era the marine-life was very prolific, the fishes and The Frogs had evolved, and the vegetation was now spreading across the land bringing in the Mesozoic era. To cut an even longer story short; the frog brought forth the dinosaurs, the dinosaur brought forth the animals, the an animal brought forth the mammals and the primates, which brought about the evolutionary conscious mind development of -Knowledge- and -Council-, which is demonstrated by the various groupings in the animal kingdom of the schools, flocks and herds. So the human race, The Twins; a boy and a girl, sprang-up, mutated from an evolved pair of lemurs, some three times removed, which were all wiped out by each succeeding generation, just north of India (not in Africa) around a million years ago. So, what I'm getting at, is that all the animal kingdom, marine land and air, have developed some type of form of communication, even if it is only sounds, signs and expressions they did communicate with each other. The Twins found it very difficult to communicate with or even advance their family to use words and symbols, having already developed a primitive alphabet. So one day when they were only about 12 years old, after their mother and most of their band had been killed off by a raiding party of Gibbons, while the males were out hunting. The Twins decided to leave home and make their own way in the world. By making this supreme free will choice The Twins advanced their evolutionary conscious mind development to the levels of -Worship- and -Wisdom-, raising them above the animal kingdom, and our world was then registered as having attained -Will Creature Status-, from which stage of development of personality is bestowed, this usually occurs around 3 years of age in modern day humans. Also, further to this the Homo-Sapiens, the colored races appeared, (again in India not Africa) around 500,000 years ago. So in conclusion, I reckon that Professor Noam Chomsky has hit the evolutionary mind development nail of mandkind right on the head, in more ways than one. What a mind that man has evolved, awesome!!... To find out a whole lot more check out The Urantia Book..... (you can read it online)

@fabiengerard8142

Жыл бұрын

* …human SPECIES, not ‘’race’’. 👌🏻👌🏽👌

@stevenhines5550

Ай бұрын

Yes. Let me get right on that. After all it was written by extraterrestrials. I'm very interested to learn what they think about our evolution.

The only thing that bugs me is the reference to the freudian unconscious as, in principle, being accessible to the conscious. That is a common but gross error. Freud clearly and sharply differentiates between the descriptive unconscious (accessible to the conscious, but part of rhe pre-conscious system) and the unsconscious system, completly innaccessible to the conscious. Freud's theory of these 3 systems appears to be very similar to Chomsky's views, and in my opinion, still relevant today.

@fabiengerard8142

Жыл бұрын

OK, but what about the subconscious, then?

The human world has one-side-effect The collaborative process of creating a question. A Biosphereical adaptive Hemispheric helix dawned vertical creature essential. ...Methodological a missing link... Deprivation itself questions this space ...Brainstorming survival ...Basically a living sundial question is itself reasoning. ...Souls of hunger quench of thirst cry stories of once birth. Our reflections remain of the first generation. ...The original question is seperation possible? ...Freedom has a returning value (Communication) another set of questions of our need around the world. .........Location earth.

We are all the same - straight out of Africa 60k years ago. Nevermind those new articles about evidence of significant mixing with other human species outside of Africa, that's irrelevant even though it coincides geographically and chronologically with the "relatively recent mutation" chomsky labeled the Great Leap Forward of modern humans.

Note

2:49:04

What asteroid?

@Anarchist0707

Жыл бұрын

That which wiped Dinosaurs and gave a chance to human species.

"we can't stop giving bankers massive bonuses, because they go elsewhere" Good. Let them. We'll do the job for everyone, not just ourselves. Learn about the authentic Spanish Revolution movement. The CNT. Anarcho-syndicalism. When the bosses and owners absconded when the people rightly, got sick of them, the everyday people chipped in with the work. Each to their own passion. Both rural and urban, it ran very well. Money didn't always have to come into it. these are all jobs we do ANYWAY. But we're free to fit in where we fit in best. So successful an experiment was it, that before too long, the Nazis, facists, socialists, communists, and capitalists all sabotaged it, and buried the chances of most of s knowing any of this.

@deejannemeiurffnicht1791

Жыл бұрын

Damnit! Forgot to add, that much of the waffle above gave background to this and the other stuff Noam goes on about. He's fortunate enough to be able to express stuff we're all waking up to. But he's able to get it across in plain talk. It's naturally very clear to him. So it's easy to take it in from him.

What would be the size of human grammar?

@stevenhines5550

Ай бұрын

4

@mithrandir2006

Ай бұрын

@@stevenhines5550 4 what? Depends on the unit 😆

@stevenhines5550

Ай бұрын

@@mithrandir2006 grammarinos

@mithrandir2006

Ай бұрын

@stevenhines5550 the human grammar is probably gigantic.

@stevenhines5550

Ай бұрын

Four grammarinos

My #guru of 20 years professor Chomsky is not always right. Newborn pays attention to human voice, because it heard it for a few months. It is impossible to hunt without a group of people, with who you need to communicate! who will be throwing the spear first, and who will be the second, and who will be scaring the animal from the opposite side. There was a spoken #language at least 2 million years ago. And this is not my opinion. But Mr. Chomsky is convinced there was no language 200,000 years ago. Professor #Chomsky probably is not familiar with #Toba #supervolcano explosion 74,000 years ago and so cold mind’s #revolution “ after this #extinction event (turned out to be a #geneticbottleneck ). #IamBogoslowsky🦁🤴 ,

@stevenhines5550

Ай бұрын

Language is distinct from communication. Orcas hunt in groups but don't use language.

These are all atheist arguments, Islam rejects many of these humanist assumptions.

@joebob4579

Жыл бұрын

You say that as if Islamic arguments are worth talking about, funny

@hassanmirza2392

Жыл бұрын

@@joebob4579 A quarter of humanity will disagree with a pagan like you, we don't care what idol worshipers like you think. Humanism is cultural Christianity and not nothing else. You are a Euro-centric pagan.

@Raydensheraj

Жыл бұрын

What should be rejected are lies & fables like Islam with it's pedophile prophet that rides a flying horse to the moon in order to cut it in half with a sword....djinns and a preferred version of invisible supernatural superbeeing without an inch of evidence but one idiotic dark age book. Like all religions, Islam should be rejected.

Don't think I failed English class . I think English class failed me .... It was too rigid not flexible as humans naturally are ... Some good at one thing or another but not as flexible as to absorb a little of many subjects and inter weaving ideas that create solutions to problems . Solutions that can't happen if you don't have some knowledge of the other subject job or process . 😮

What s with the waving hands.distractive.cognostigive.go on noam c