If you could explain why building 7 went down JUST LIKE the towers without ever being hit by anything but debris then we could close the case.

@robertw2930

9 жыл бұрын

Harry Johnson Maybe, compression waves from the tower falling and instability from underground fires that created resonance within the structure.

@SandmanTrials

9 жыл бұрын

Harry Johnson If there is a smoking gun, it's the fact that building 7 did go down the way it did! Building 7 was battered by two humongous buildings and took all day to collapse. The twin towers were hit by planes, but they collapsed in mere hours. If there's a smoking gun, it's that the entire world saw how long and how much force it should take to actually collapse a steel frame building right next to an example of something that has never happened before. But I'm no physicist, or architect, or even a scientist. I was just a dumb kid who was told he was smart, so now thinks he can ascertain whether or not a building collapse was a premeditated, internal conspiracy or an act of retribution by a an angry group of men from the Middle East. I cannot, because I am no expert. What I can do is realize the consequences of such grandiosity and greed, and know that America needs to change. I know that we need to get out of the Middle East and do away with our incomprehensible arrogance. "I know".

@SandmanTrials

9 жыл бұрын

Thomas Paine Scientists have spent years specializing in their specific fields. The good one gets cited and published. It's those scientists that remain utilized by INTERNATIONAL entities worldwide. If even one of them found something suspicious, there would be an INTERNATIONAL revolt against America. Not a slow and steady one, but a quick and, well, revolting one. The only "scientists" proclaiming their "vast" knowledge of physics regarding the attacks of September 11th as some sort of vague, logically fallacious appeal to authority, are the ones whom never get cited by other, credible scientists; they're the ones who have no credible income, so they must resort to the cockamamie, imagined schemes. The worst part is many of them believe it, as they lack a real understanding of physics. Hence, their delusional beliefs. You will now experience an incredible amount of anxiety and perhaps anger if you read what I wrote. This is normal. It is referred to as cognitive dissonance, but really, you're brain is telling you to ignore that which interferes with your reality. Our brains are stupid. Ignore them. Embrace the real reality, and you may let go of fear. And trust me, there's plenty to be pissed off about without having to resort to wild conspiracies. Take a breath. Join in a cause. Fight to end corruption. Support a candidate you truly believe in. I don't just mean a candidate who's running for President, but any and all candidates running for public office. We have to take our country back. We can do this peacefully. Our battles are waged a very different way in the modern world. All we must do is take action. Do something.

@jonnekorvamaki4775

9 жыл бұрын

Joshua Sanders , "Scientists have spent years specializing in their specific fields. The good one gets cited and published." In Ideal world this would be the truth due to basic principles of science. On the other hand, by embracing the real reality one has to realize that scientifical research and science community overall are influenced by the entities who fund them. Unfortunately science is not completely funded by itself so external power structures always coincide with scientifical reasearch. Going back to late 2001, how many universities even considered publishing anything that would contradict with the official story if doing so would have labelled them as "antigovermental"? By asking this purely speculative question I`m just trying to show that science community is facing a more complex reality than science as a methotology is. You encourage people to "fight to end corruption" yet it seems to me you let yourself to naively believe that whatever is said in the holy name of science can not be corrupted. In my opinion you are not in a position to suggest anything about those scientists and experts who disagree with the official story. It is possible some of them are delusional and simply wrong but you have no grounds to claim that many one of them are delusional unless you groundlessly assume that science is independent of the power structure of society, especially independent of interests of those who fund it. Instead of psychologizing those who might no see eye to eye with you, I warmly recommend you to question your own belief system. Then you do not need to ignore reality anymore and you can let go of your fear.

@BigGreezyJake

8 жыл бұрын

Jonne Korvamäki all that one has to do is look at history, it has a tendency to repeat itself, and as a cannabis smoker (oh no, he must be a crazy conspiracy theorist) who has done extensive research, it is obvious that yes, the science is so often tainted by the entities that fund them. the US and Britain have been responsible for many more atrocious acts, why this seems to be such a stretch for Noam saddens me!

Marking the decade since this video

He even talks about PROPAGANDA and FAKE STORIES in Manufactured Consent. And now he is saying it doesn't happen ? He is contradicting HIMSELF ! And he keeps saying ,"someone would have talked". So people list all the Top Secret and Black Project and SEAL MISSIONS you know about since everyone already knows about them anyway. And start with the space based weapons systems called Star Wars that was never released.

enlighten me to building 7

@muskduh

4 жыл бұрын

Amy was there and is covering up

I agree with you, actually. Thanks for the comment.

there is only one thing that looks like a perfect demolition . That is a perfect demolition

@throwerofturds

9 жыл бұрын

Thomas Paine the official government story is that the beams of the building were weakened by heat from the fires and then the buildings came down in a perfect demolition pattern . . if you believe that your not very bright even if you are educated in some way . if you want to see heat search "skyscraper fire , bejing ,feb 2009" . .that is heat and not just a little bit of smoke like the three wtc towers but a 45 story torch that burned super hot for six hours . please compare the two . if it doesn't convince you you are either stupid or crooked . since you are arguing this line in the first place you some kind of dumb if you cant tell a perfect demolition from anything else . while your at it check out "demolition fails " there are examples of pancaking there and they don't look like the chopped up dust that were the towers as they came down

@throwerofturds

8 жыл бұрын

Thomas Paine a couple of points Thomas That was a perfect demo job . The building came straight down . there were no big twisted beams because something chopped those beams up . That building came down perfectly Also that was not a fire . that was just a bunch of smoke and could not weaken any beams . and if you think that smoke could weaken beams then your a horses ass and not worth talking to . I suggest a good coke habit or something . that might help .

@throwerofturds

8 жыл бұрын

Thomas Paine well Thomas im a welder and a self taught physics guy and I don't see any mention in your comment about you bein g a civil engineer .Physics and electrical training do not a civil engineer make . You say the walls buckled out ? That fall was a lot closer to perfect demolition than anything iv seen . Go and check out "Demolition Fails " here on youtube . there is a huge diference between a building that comes down wrong and one that comes down right . You are a horses ass to not know the diference ,electrical engineering aside . Also ...what happened to poor old building seven ...Did it catch the falling disease to ? horses ass Thomas !

@barthill9578

8 жыл бұрын

Thomas Paine Any body with common sense and half a brain can tell the buildings were demolished and when you get into the details of how strong those buildings were forget about it, crash plane after plane and turn the building into swiss cheese and it still would of been standing.

@nemome5837

8 жыл бұрын

+Geof B We don't need to believe any "story" about 9/11 because the world saw what happened live on TV on that day. Everything else, including your drivel about other incidents, is idle fantasy.

Anyone ever heard of a guy named Norman Minetta? How about Peter Michael Ketcham of NIST? This is a good start for anyone interested in learning more about the truth of 9ll

"Who cares?" ~ Noam Chomsky

holy shit these comments. i thought the dislikes are people feeling attacked by being critcised that the "they hate our freedom" is nonsense. however its conspiracy theorists nonsense

How could he be so right on about so many things, and so wrong about the 'official' nonsense story about what happened that day.

@chrisbova9686

3 жыл бұрын

Kinda makes you wonder if he's been full of it the whole time.

@cliffgaither

3 жыл бұрын

@@chrisbova9686 •••• Chomsky isn't perfect. Several mistakes doesn't negate his decades-long political research. He just quoted Pentagon Documentation ( substantiating everything he has written about The State ) that was told to that imbecile in The White House at the time.

@GMAV3RICK

2 жыл бұрын

@@cliffgaither You’re exactly correct.

Is it possible that you do not see what many intellectuals Do? If not how can you not? Perfect demolitions you call attack? Have you forgotten the first rule, who is benefiting?

Let's just agree to disagree on those issues. I'll only quote Siegmund Freud when he famously observed: "Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar".

Sticks and stones will break my bones, but names will never hurt me.

Heres a CLUE from wikipedia Avram Noam Chomsky was born on December 7, 1928, in the East Oak Lane neighborhood of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. His father was William "Zev" Chomsky, an Ashkenazi Jew originally from Ukraine who had fled to the United States in 1913.

How many times does Chomsky blink a minute?

@muskduh

4 жыл бұрын

as many times as needed to make a lie sound good

I am speechless that a supposedly intelligent man accepts the absurdest story ever told by a government.

@rossathome

4 жыл бұрын

I agree. ,For example its so bizzare how Compsky totally rejected that 911 was very likely an inside job, when so many firefighter video testimonials say internal BOMBS went off and that obviously suggested it was an inside job. There is so much glaring evidence .Almost no wreckage from any planes , one small turbine found on Pentagon area that is the size of a guided missile , no dents where the engines would be ( the strongest part of a plane), over 400 pilots for justice claim a regular passenger plane cannot even steer at 500mph let alone penetrate a steel building, unless it was heavily ranforced ( by military titanium ) and has a giant specialized explosive bolted underneath ,which has been shown in many close up photos. Plus it was witnessed by so many as being grey and looking like a military plane. I used to be impressed by Chompsky but he must well know that IF JFK could be assassinated , then his brother assassinated , then its also quite realistic 40 years on that the technology and control mechanisms in the shadow government would find it quite effortless to do 911. Corona virus while it is real it is very likely part of yet another creeping domination of the psychopathic leaders and shadow Government , that they are no better than the Mafia /MOB. If I was to guess , they are just the same Mafia MOB that has parasitically penetrated all government around the world. They no longer look like classic bugsy Malone bad guy characters portrayed in the movies, but now they wear suits and run the world. How else could any group Terrorise so many nations without having any guilt unless they are psychopathic.

@hornyconvict

3 жыл бұрын

This has been thoroughly debunked. It wasn't an inside job you fucking dolt.

@chrisbova9686

3 жыл бұрын

@@hornyconvict yeah it was, OBVIOUSLY.

@cliffgaither

3 жыл бұрын

@@rossathome :: I haven't watched the video yet ; like a lot of people, I go to the comments -- first ! to prepare me for any bs in the video. Chomsky is politically brilliant. I can't wait to hear his reasoning, in spite of your counter-arguments. As you, Chomsky had equated the United States' Foreign-Policy to The Mafia. As you commented, they ( The Mafia Magicians ) have changed their wardrobe into suits & ties as The Klan Members have removed their sheets that hid their darkness, for the Brooks Brothers' Suits of daylight on Wall-Street. ( If Chomsky is wrong, it could be he's afraid of being identified as a conspiracy theorist & conspiracy theorists are from the "mob". )

@hornyconvict

3 жыл бұрын

@chantu mantu yes it was. Source: me. I did 9/11

I do not understand when people have the "controlled demolition" thought process. I saw, certainly did not hear, evidence of controlled demolition. No bursting of explosives throughout any of the buildings, no almost deafening "popping" sounds. FBI, CIA, NTSB, ATF, Fire professionals, all were there at the sites. They saw no evidence of explosives. They are trained in those kinds of events, they would have noticed any evidence of explosives. The towers certainly fell longer than 9 or 10 seconds. These debris and dust cloud from the towers fell quicker. I can see it in every video and pic. The towers began to collapse from the area where each tower buckled, I can see that. Building 7 burned all day long. Building 7 had a huge gash in it. The fire professionals knew that 7 was going to fall, they said so, hours before it did fall. The penthouse on top of building 7 collapses inward a full 7 or 8 seconds before the rest of the building comes down. The windows begin to break when the penthouse collapses. The old man Lucky Larry screwed the pooch because he did not get a pay out to cover the cost of rebuilding. I've found nowhere that the term "pull" is a demolition term except in the case of "pulling" with cables. And wouldn't it be expected to require terrorism insurance on a building that has been attacked by terrorist before? Fire Chief Daniel Nigro: "The biggest decision we had to make on the first day was to clear the area and create a collapse zone around the severely damaged 7 World Trade Center, a 47-story building heavily involved in fire. A number of fire officers and companies assessed the damage to the building. The appraisals indicated that the building's integrity was in serious doubt. I issued the orders to pull back the firefighters and define the collapse zone. It was a critical decision; we could not lose any more firefighters. It took a lot of time to pull everyone out, given the emotionalism of the day, communications difficulties, and the collapse terrain" Firefighter Marcel Klaes: "All morning I was watching 7 World Trade burn." FDNY Lieutenant Robert Larocco - "We walked over by number Seven World Trade Center as it was burning and saw this 40-plus story building with fire on nearly all floors." Firefighter Vincent Massa - "At this point, Seven Wold Trade was going heavy and they weren't letting anybody get too close. Everybody was expecting that to come down." J

@kenbrucegonemad8979

6 жыл бұрын

J Law What about how no other steel framed building has collapsed due to fire but three that day. What about no evidence of a plane hitting the pentagon. 47 cameras or something around the pentagon but none saw a plane. Lol.

@harlow743

10 ай бұрын

All kinds of evidence 3,000 Architechs and Engineers say your wrong

Chompsky you know it was an inside job yet you lie, how much did they pay you?

@sullivansongz

8 жыл бұрын

dope

@johnculpepper5336

8 жыл бұрын

Chumpsky was paid well for his Zionist disinformation.

@friedcash9815

5 жыл бұрын

gate keeper

@ozricaurora6943

5 жыл бұрын

It wasn't an inside job

@ozricaurora6943

4 жыл бұрын

@Gregory F. Murray so chomsky got money for 911?

That's nice.

wow I just saw a comment disappear...

Oh my

11 minutes are not an hour.

Check out the document: Rebuilding America's defenses and the think tank: Project for a New American Century.

@flyingpants Yes I have. He had no arguments whatsoever, other than to say that even controlled scientific experiments often leave unexplainable phenomena.Great, thanks for that contribution. Oh, and that someone would have leaked the plot. He finished by saying "even if it is true, who cares?" I do not believe he has even looked into this seriously, compared to David Ray Griffin on this matter, he comes over as simply ignorant.

I was only saying I disagreed with you on the 9/11 conspiracy. This spot is too small to discuss it. The Freud quote was not meant as a "general answer" obviously, only a small reflection that real life does not follow preconceived ideas.

Really NOAM CHOMSKY !!! Your still spewing disproven government and propagandist lies!....is the money that good,or...have they really duped a man I always looked up to.check your research Noam!

I don't collect autographs (I have 2 in 52 years). But I want his. I imagine if I asked him for his autograph, he would reject me. And I would be delighted. He's free thinking and free spirited, who I would guess has 0 autographs. And think 3 less than I about autographs.

@throwerofturds

2 жыл бұрын

Lol right years have gone by since your comment do you still believe what you wrote ?

THEY ASK HIM QUIETLY ....DO YOU WANT LIVE?

I think it is.

Hey man...upon further reflection, I agree with you that my comment was too extreme. I'm removing it out of respect for you and the youtube community and because I did not intend to offend anyone directly. Peace.

Chomsky is a "gate keeper". He knows what he can and can't say. He keeps his mouth shut and he gets a nice big check.

@throwerofturds

2 жыл бұрын

I'd describe him as a disinformation not . He talks about the US like they were responsible for the ills of the world when in fact it is the globalists who control the US and all else

@drugmoney4996

2 жыл бұрын

@@throwerofturds Absolutely

@DjWellDressedMan

7 ай бұрын

YOU have no idea of Chomsky's thoughts and your pathetic comment shows it in spades, nice try at trying to think.

@miloshp7399

5 ай бұрын

Muricans cant handle the truth that someone attacked them on their soil. Sorry guys but a bunch of Arabs flied a plane into your city.

@realistblue-_-136

4 ай бұрын

@@throwerofturdsdude what the hell are are you talking about we are the neoliberal globalist lmaoo

@artinmey His arguement is that he is not capable of making a judgement on the sciene. He doesn't have the backround or the expertise to judge if thermite meand something or not. This is what he has said, so he can't make the call. What makes you think you know better than a legitimate genius?

@Uncle99B i get it now. ;) must be me german heritage that made me emphasize this point unvoluntarily. maybe i just wanted to appeal to the american psyche, too. but your point is valid, although i still think it completely misses my point.

Sorry, if you think a little glitch in the unsustainable economy is big news, then we have no chance of surviving a real problem.

That figure represents a mere sliver against all the professionals who accept the findings of the NIST report. This is what conspiracy theorists must acknowledge: that the vast majority simply reject the truther claims, and with solid scientific grounds.

@rodneygiovanatti5425

6 жыл бұрын

what solid scientific grounds are you referring to? NIST would not even release their work for public scrutiny for "fear it would jeopardize public safety"... Shyam Sundar initially stated that the buildings could not have fallen at freefall because that would mean "there would be no supporting structure". Years later NIST concedes that WTC 7 did in fact fall at freefall for 10 stories. That should have been front page news yet it does not get talked about in the main stream press.

no P in Chomsky driving me nuts hearing her

@Uncle99B dont know where your reading problems come from. you are completely missing my point. all i said is that comparing osama bin laden to hitler is like comparing george w with stalin.

@artinmey Have you bothered to listen to his refutation of the conspiracy nonsense?

too much questions / evidence not being answered on , he avoid talking about this after 10 years , but he is a critic of the response i give a credit for that but believe was not an inside job or does not want to made public his depth opinion. for me is a ?

bit strong isn't it?

I do not know what happened. I do know what did not happen, the official story. It just surprises me that Chomsky doesnt seem to care either way. I understand that either way USA foreign policy involves mass murder with or without 9.11 but there are other considerations, eg, how the American people would see their relationship to Israel, if any involvement were to be proven, not to mention the whole political process. This has to be of concern to a commentator like Chomsky.

@stephenpayne9120

Жыл бұрын

You nailed it: "Chomsky doesn't seem to care either way." No, he never does.

Mr. Chomsky has lost his credibility. Maybe Israel got to him.

@madeleine8977

8 жыл бұрын

And you presumably are the more rational? In your own mind, perhaps.

@johnculpepper5336

8 жыл бұрын

Chumpsky is choking on Israel dick.

@johnculpepper5336

8 жыл бұрын

Sorts however rational disagree thinking. Eat shit Paula!

@olorinmithrandir8536

6 жыл бұрын

You're just an anti semite pig. Shame on you. Shame on you.

@mck1972

5 жыл бұрын

To say that, ' Chomsky has lost his credibility ', presumes that he ever actually HAD ANY credibility to begin with! -He Didn't!

Bought and paid for

@abdullahalghamsan8929

4 жыл бұрын

@mariocrivera1000 bro I made this comment 5 years ago. Omg :P

@abdullahalghamsan8929

4 жыл бұрын

@mariocrivera1000 How you doing during this depressing time?

He looks a bit grumpy...

Good ol’ gate keeper

You are such a supernumerary. Why do we need your comment when we have JREF?

the living legend

@youngbuck189 You then have to listen to others WITH the expertise, use your own reasoning & common sense, verify all that is possible ............ If your conclusion is different to a "legitimate" genius (as you call him ) incapable of making a judgement, It could be a very valid conclusion you arrive at !

He is a Real American Hero!

Well following my instincts, I wouldn't buy a second hand car from this man, that is for sure

i never understand the "they hate our freedoms" bullshit. why would you go thousands of km to a country because you dont like their style of living? why would you even bother? i also dont go to kongo or saudi arabia because i dont like there atrocities and way of living. it makes absolutely no sense. and even if you are extreme you would only do it if there are no other big problems when you can bother about other peoples way of life which doesnt affect you at all

pass

No thermite, salafism paid another visit as it did in 1993.

No.

You think he is wise? Wow, you must be smarter than him if you can judge his wisdom. How com i've never heard of you??

If you agree so much with Chomsky, your post doesn't make sense. If it was a inside job that means that people may rebel, ok? If it was a bunch of terrorist that get in the hi-tech US security with a plastic knife, to admit it would be a shame and dangerous, ok? Since he works for the US army he choses the best option for the government and it is simply not talk about that, deal with that as irrelevant such as he calls the JFK murder...

@youngbuck189 ... much like Bigfoot

Keep sitting on the Dock of the Bay Noam....😪

because they get paid not to,they have bills to pay,they probably don"t want to be assassinated,or imprisoned for life.I hope this helps answer your question,I would recommend drinking more floride tainted water so your more passive,and don't ask questions. "the truth shall sit you in prison,or dead' .

Christ, I had no idea Amy Goodman was so...HARD looking.

@Kuwaiti1990

4 жыл бұрын

Seas of Bronze 😳😅

Anyone can clearly see that a missile hit pentagon... not a Plane

would mr chomsky survive 1 day in...iran, russia, china, saudi arabia?

sure, the official story is suspect and i don't believe it, but i'm not going to jump to conclusions. let's start with just demanding the case be reinvestigated... i'm sure noam wouldn't be against that.

This is the sad reality that titans of intellect are still subject to the years. His mind cracked.

Chomsky should be on Totalitarian Now! instead. haha This guy is as nutty as Alex Jones.

I like this feller. He's SPOT ON!

As usual Chomsky is overly simplistic. Of course the question that is not asked is why do the Arabs and or Muslims not attack Russia? In the last few decades the Russians have supported the Serbs against the Muslims of Kosovo, the Russians had made war in Afghanistan, they had also committed horrible atrocities in Chechnya. Today they support the brutal Assad regime in Syria. Following Chomsky's line of thought, 9/11 should have been carried out in Moscow not New York. What America does represent in the Arab and or Muslim world is gay rights, women's rights and human rights, all rights that do not go down well in the misogynist, homophobic and despotic thinking of the Muslim Brotherhood and their offshoot Al Qeda. Be well.

@GabrielRevan

10 жыл бұрын

Well said.

@Wawi633

10 жыл бұрын

Thanks.

please stop shouting...

I agree and I love Noam Chomsky.

Aren't we so lucky to have Noam Chomsky to judge the US response to 9/11? After all, who could possibly be better qualified on such an important topic, than a career Linguistics Professor, with ZERO Real World Experience in Government, Military, International Affairs, Foreign Policy, or National Security, and whose criticisms all have the great luxury of exploiting 20/20 Hindsight? This makes perfect sense-Right??? UGH-It is a tragedy that anyone takes this ridiculous old man seriously! SMH

@dikranovichk5889

5 жыл бұрын

@M CK, it's funny because nutters strut around claiming to have a petition with 3000 whole signatures from professional architects and engineers around the world. Well, I think most of the signatures are from professionals. But here's the thing, in the USA alone, there are one million architects and engineers. M ck, do you know what percentage of 1 million, 3 thousand is? I'll give you a clue. 10 thousand, that would be one percent of the total engineers and architects, just in the USA.

@dikranovichk5889

5 жыл бұрын

Chomsky didn't sign the list of the architects and engineers group, started by Richard gage, did he?

He's lost all credibility with me now. Am intelligent man but he's backing out.... I'm bitterly disgusted.

Chomsky has reserved his place in hell