It is incorrect to say the US Supreme Court will hear this case once it has been appealed through the Federal courts. The convicted murderer's attorneys can petition the Supreme Court for a hearing, but they grant very few cases each term so his chances of a Supreme Court hearing are vanishingly tiny.

Alex Murdererugh's SNOT getting appeal

@iidentifyasAmerican

Жыл бұрын

All things being equal, I think he should get an appeal based on his attorneys failure to assist or put forth a defense.

@LucyLennon20

Жыл бұрын

@@iidentifyasAmerican I was joking. I heard what you said about an appeal based on poor representation; but will it fly?

@msnatty3277

Жыл бұрын

@@iidentifyasAmerican they did the best they could. They couldn’t really put up too much of a fight with the phone data, snap chat, 911 call, the video evidence, on star, etc it goes on with his inconsistencies to his story. He lied because he was there and did the crime. He didn’t count on them getting into Paul’s phone.

Hope his appeal is rejected he is so guilty

@sophieallen5613

Жыл бұрын

I honestly cannot see how you can be so sure.

I'm from south africa, i clearly remember watching on the news about Maggie and Paul's murder. And I thought oh that's such a shame then bits a pieces started coming out then hearing about Alex dads death, and his so called assassination...iv been following ever since.

@paulkenneally789

Жыл бұрын

Bloke is as guilty as Pistorius.

His lawyers were terrible. He shouldn't have taken the stand, the Prosecutor didn't have a good case for murder. Without AM on the stand, a senerio with reasonable doubt, not allowing the prosecutor to go way outside the scope of the case, and challenging some sketchy evidence that was entered, he could've gotten off. Nobody placed him at the murder scene. I agree his counsel did nothing to assist him, they harmed by letting him testify trying to recall during a devastating event. They allowed him to incriminate himself. Murdaugh was convicted on speculation, issues that prejudiced the case, circumstantial evidence and self incrimination. He should be retried with real attorneys.

@glendasuttle7054

Жыл бұрын

Thank God he didn’t get off. He is SO guilty. Paul’s phone you can clearly hear Alex, Maggie and Paul. He is a cheat, a thief and a murderer. I hope he stays in prison for the rest of his life. Hopefully he will realize all the damage he has done to so many.

@lastonegal6533

Жыл бұрын

Alex was so stubborn about himself taking the stand! Dick Harpo said, "MY client takes the fifth!" Then smart Alex says,"I knew I stole from EVERYBODY! But I must repeat! I did NOT kill my Mags and Pawpaw!" What an idiot! That kennel video? Was nothing! He should have shut up! And if the State only hung onto that video? Then all Alex could say? Was the video was from hours earlier? Or that it was NOT at the time of when the disgusting senseless murders took his Mags & Pawpaw? Reasonable doubt! But Alex wanted to show all that he could win? All the time?!? The only way that he could ever get off? Would be having a BFF in the Supreme Court!?!? But? After 6 long weeks? Alex? Can dream on! He's in for good! He kept yapping and yapping and loved to hear the sound of his own voice! LE, SLED, The State! Knew AM would be yapping his way into prison! What an idiot! Never ever take the stand! No matter who you think you are!

@msnatty3277

Жыл бұрын

@@lastonegal6533 He couldn’t say the video was from earlier. They have the phone data showing the exact time the video was recorded. They analyzed that phone there’s no getting around it he was there. He felt he had no choice but try and salvage and recover from the lie he told that he was not there minutes before they were murdered. He did it.

@lastonegal6533

Жыл бұрын

@Ms Natty I was making a tongue and cheek comment? However? If Alex Murder never took the stand? I think the defense only needed one juror? And I'm sure Harpo? May have went on a lam? And said how dumb it was for the phone records couldn't never have been that time of exact killings? And now that he took the stand? He has a 1% of having a chance? Yet? It will take 4 to 6 years from now? I think Alex will just die in the heat in that prison? No more Vinne Vine shirts? Or cool showers? I think he will find God? Or in the heat? He has to go to Mallory Beach case in Aug. And the jailers will make him wake up at 2 or 3 am and he will have to wait? In that hot van? I think Alex will confess? Or beg someone to kill him? I am so happy that he took that stand! All that time! Paul's video sealed his murder from the grave! Alex,"Are they dead yet?"

This is the crappiest news ever! Mr waters did the job already 💯

His eyes are terrifying! 0:47

Judge...Why are you appealing Mr Murdaugh? Alex...I didn't like the verdict.

@jameskellinger8314

Жыл бұрын

Too bad you nothing about how the system works

Will the officer be charged for lying to the grand jury? If that were you or I, we'd already be in prison.

@jutru8782

Жыл бұрын

Can you refer what was said? I never heard this story.

Character not motive? Oh please. AM is Madoff meets Scot Peterson.

He has no chance of winning an appeal or being free ever again.

I wonder if Buster really believes his dad is innocent.

@DRBR-2020

Жыл бұрын

Doubtful, but he can't publicly admit it.

Alex is supposedly broke how's he going to afford new layers

Well, who killed them?

@sophieallen5613

Жыл бұрын

Maybe there was someone else there. Coincidences do happen..

@roxieolemeda3196

Жыл бұрын

5'2 vigilantes didn't you catch that

@piedpiper5886

Жыл бұрын

Are you serious? Of course it was Alex. He was the only other person there.

The killer(s) footprints were at the murder scene. Did they document them?

@piedpiper5886

Жыл бұрын

Alex’s footprint?

@jameskellinger8314

Жыл бұрын

@@piedpiper5886 They never identified Alex's footprint. The photos did not include a scale, so you cannot tell what size the shoes in the photo.

Corruption belongs behind bars

if he appeals could the death penalty be introduced ?

@iidentifyasAmerican

Жыл бұрын

Why would it be? They don't have the type of proof needed to get a death penalty conviction.

@tedbhoy1

Жыл бұрын

@@iidentifyasAmerican personally i believe the death penalty is barbaric , my point was if it was introduced i doubt he would appeal

@rickreallylikedthevideobut7899

Жыл бұрын

@@iidentifyasAmerican Apparently you are wrong, because the jury said GUILTY!

@jutru8782

Жыл бұрын

No. The prosecution set the penalty at life. It’s easier to try a case without the death penalty, as the jury is unlikely to agree on that as punishment. He won’t win an appeal. It’s his right to do so, but not likely to win.

@roxieolemeda3196

Жыл бұрын

That'd be great 🤜 👊 the judge said that he qualified for the death penalty

A couple of “random vigilantes” will come and admit did they were stealing dogs…

@jongmod9440

Жыл бұрын

PERFECT timing for "random killer,s" huh? OR, or, those upset about the boat incident FINALLY decided to get Karma? Yeahhhhh, sure!

@piedpiper5886

Жыл бұрын

Is this a joke?

Well the fact that he lied about being down by the kennels where Maggie and Paul were. His whole world was falling apart and the plan was in place to do away with the two problems that were muddying the waters. The fact that the investigation around his appeal is going to be done by another SLED office is good. But I think it took longer to get back to the house to not hear the gunshots if he was not there. This depends on what route was taken and how the truck was faced. Backing up and turning in the road to head for the house would take more time.

Motive was not an element of the crime, but the judge allowed prior bad acts evidence to prove motive. If that is not plain error, nothing is.

@piedpiper5886

Жыл бұрын

The defense was at fault. They brought it up so the judge had to allow it in

SC criminal appeals fly about 8% of the time.

Yeah well good luck with that.

He did it. Police should not have let all those people in crime scene or in the house. I hope they had a supeona for that video in the kennel and did a voice analysis on the audio. They didn't check the hair in Maggie's hands or do an xray on Paul's brain. Other than that I don't see any other issues

@jutru8782

Жыл бұрын

The video is solid on its own. It’s in forensic evidence. Not necessary to do voice analysis. AM admitted it was his voice. The hair in Maggie’s hand was determined to be her own. It was released from the shot to her head. Very sad.

@roxieolemeda3196

Жыл бұрын

The officer 1st in the scene said that there wasn't anyone there to contaminate the crime scene

@piedpiper5886

Жыл бұрын

@@roxieolemeda3196 That is true, but Alex made phone calls to have as many people there as possible.