Damned if Nadu, damned if Nadon't.

@TheSpiritombsableye

20 күн бұрын

Finally someone made this type of joke.

@christiansmith49

19 күн бұрын

But do you Nadu the dew?

@lostalone9320

19 күн бұрын

Oh well played sir

@masterthnag105

19 күн бұрын

Joy

@commanderpower99

19 күн бұрын

@@TheSpiritombsableye I think they made it during coverage

WotC when Oko was printed: "Wait, we can target our opponent's things?" WotC when Nadu was printed: "Wait, we can target our own things?"

@laytonjr6601

19 күн бұрын

More like: wait, equipments target?

@drokhalis3338

17 күн бұрын

And it ducks draw hate from Bowmasters, Narset, Sheoldred, etc. whoever designed the card should be fired nearly every line of text on the card is worded to break the card as much as it can.

I like how the thumbnail makes it look like Nadu is replacing crim. Crim has been powercrept out of the mtggoldfish podcast

“ I understand you can’t probably test the thousands of cards you print each year for every format” What a fantastic argument in favor of product fatigue

@crisgon9552

20 күн бұрын

A face value read of Nadu anyone can see it is busted. It's a 3/4 can't bolted.

@lostalone9320

19 күн бұрын

As a player I look at Nadu and think "Huh, what about those old cephalid things with 0 cost abilities? Wonder if I can find something like that..."

Ban Window: Everything is fine 4 days later: Nadu

@brningpyre

19 күн бұрын

The ban timing itself is a problem, too. What is the point of a B&R announcement explicitly timed so that you can't ban anything?

1993: Bolt the bird 2024: Ban the bird

@_Ve_98

19 күн бұрын

The power creep has gotten so high that removing a creature from the board is not enough, you need to remove it from the format.

@lexmtaylor

19 күн бұрын

Can’t Bolt that Bird.

57:05 - Bingo! We've stopped designing cards for paper. They're only designing cards for Arena which is great for Arena but some of these cards seem borderline impossible to track in paper.

Who would have guessed one simic legend would have been a mistake.... oh wait, everyone in the magic community, immediately once the bird was spoiled

@pablopandolfo8446

20 күн бұрын

Simic OP or shit. No in-betweens.

@Shimatzu95

19 күн бұрын

​@@pablopandolfo8446also almost always just boring value design

@_Ve_98

19 күн бұрын

​@@Shimatzu95I think we should just ban them from putting ramp and card draw in simic to force them to do something else. It has stopped being part of the guild's identity and become just a bad crutch.

@Botanick13

19 күн бұрын

Tbh If WOTC should ban everything Mtg community thinks is broken during spoiler season we would be still playing with Ironclaw orcs. I think the 1st issue is the testing, both Oko and Nadu was clearly problematic from start and we know for 100% that Wotc did not test those cards in 60 card format at all. Other problem is releasing sets into big tournatments... This was what 2 weeks before PT? Last year we got Wilds of Eldrain 1 week before World? If wotc is lazy to test it themself, they should not release it so close to the big events

@LedPESRule

19 күн бұрын

Everyone except Richard, he said it was trash

when talking about Nadu win rate, remember that the most played deck (in case of nadu, almost 27% between its variants) will have a LOT of mirror matches, and mirror matches will make up a lot of its losses.

@zackestin1368

20 күн бұрын

although what is richard smoking with "modern is for cards after they rotate out of standard" which standard cards since like, deaths shadow? has came out as a modern all star post standard rotation? way more often is fatal push is $7 in standard, sheoldred is over 50, teferi is over 50, etc for the multi format staples, and go way down in price post standard rotation, the closest youll get is buying the deck now you think will be the best after Nadu gets weakened/banned, surely. Like they explicitly designed pioneer for that niche instead, only he seems to have the idea that 2015 jund is still supposed to be top tier, insane hes asking for a card to be banned and in the same breath complaining about not being safe investing in decks, people are just trying new decks because theyre new, yawg is still good, living end is even better since nadu will take up so much sideboard slots, even in the time from recording to snapshots theyre completely different.

@JulioDRai

19 күн бұрын

@@zackestin1368 He also mentioned that Modern is an entirely new format and pretty much all the decks form pre-MH3 are gone while we are seeing the metagame snapshot on screen of the last month and 5 of the top 8 decks are all pre-MH3 decks (Living End, Rakdos Scam, Amulet Titan, Tron and Yawgmoth) and they will probably go back up after everything settles and Nadu gets the ban hammer, of the new decks (not counting Nadu) the only ones that seem to compete with the pre-MH3 decks are Ruby Storm and Mardu/Boros Energy the rest all seem like a tier bellow for now.

@jamesesdad

19 күн бұрын

@@zackestin1368 Richard is so full of shit, its honestly embarrassing how clueless he is considering he owns mtg goldfish. He explicitly states he wants modern to be what pioneer is (a place for rotated standard cards), but then goes off on a tangent about how he refuses to learn or play pioneer (his problem). Furthermore, him constantly lamenting the fact that tarmogoyf is currently unplayable in modern, despite the fact that its been unplayable for the last 4 years, shows how completely out of touch he is.

@helloyou5549

19 күн бұрын

@@zackestin1368 just admit you have no idea what he meant

@zackestin1368

19 күн бұрын

@@helloyou5549 no, i've listened to every podcast for years, I know exactly what he means, like when he called phlage unplayable trash because its 3 mana and what deck wants it, to calling sheoldred basically an uncommon that will see no play and why is she mythic, to calling the one ring "way too slow and nobody will be casting this and not instantly dying" he just has the worst takes ever when it comes to card analysis, there is nothing else to get. hes the old man yelling at clouds constantly.

My theory on Nadu is that Nadu was originally supposed to only trigger off of "spells" versus "spells or abilities" like Venerated Rotpriest; Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief; or Zada, Hedron Grinder. I think the last time Wizards printed a card that triggered off of a "spell or ability" you controlled that targeted your own permanents was Cephalid Illusionist. Presumably they haven't printed a card like that until Nadu because they learned that lesson.

@rodrigo1720

20 күн бұрын

Haha. The most interessing thing where wizards creates another simic nonsense is "what it was supposed to be before after testing team aproves"?

@rodrigo1720

20 күн бұрын

If nadu was a 3/1 and has "draw" on th text, the deck would be ok. Any red/black/ wreen would limit the deck

@lichdust

20 күн бұрын

the whole per creature i think was the unintended part. I think they wont ban they will just errata to "only twice across all creatures"

@lVideoWatcherl

20 күн бұрын

@@lichdust When have they errata'd a printed card, outside of cards actually just not working as intended rules-wise? This card works, and there is no rules confusion. Have WotC ever errata'd a card ever in such a case? If anything, it will be nerfed in Alchemy, but in paper, the only solution _is_ a ban. You cannot change the printing of rules text on a card willy-nilly.

@pablopandolfo8446

20 күн бұрын

Kira, great glass spinner was spells or ability, but it's a protection and opens no way to combos. It was totally intentional, they need to push cards so ppl keep buying pack/cards.

The first, second, third, fourth, and fifth time I read Nadu, my brain automatically corrected the text to read " *Whenever a creature you control* becomes the target of a spell or ability, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land card, put it into the battlefield *tapped* . Otherwise put it into your hand. This ability only triggers twice each turn." The card is so broken that it's like an Eldritch horror and my brain would rather perceive it as what it should be than what it actually is.

@dickkickem4238

19 күн бұрын

same

@laytonjr6601

19 күн бұрын

Even if the lands came into play untapped, a correct twice per turn restriction would be a weird Uro (strong but I don't know if deserving of a ban)

I hate Modern Horizons becoming Modern, or even Legacy, rotation. You voiced the same concern I have held for years now: buying a $1000 deck that last for years is a very different calculation from buying a deck at that price that will only last a year or two. WotC seem to want the high prices for cards that don't retain their value. It's not sustainable.

It's clearly Shuko that's the overpowered card. I don't know how it was able to slip under the radar for so long!

@banditkeithkingofduelmonsters

20 күн бұрын

It's the upstart goblin of mtg.

@BriceBeNic3

20 күн бұрын

this has to be an eye roll. even with grieves the bird does stupid stuff.

@BoltTheEmolga

19 күн бұрын

@@BriceBeNic3I think they’re more predicting what WotC is going to say in their banlist

@000Converse000

19 күн бұрын

@@BoltTheEmolga absolutely. shuko is an equipment that gives +1/0, you basically can't get a weaker equipment than that. In isolation, there is no way a sane person would deem it ban-worthy.

Seth correctly guessed most of the top meta cards from MH3 so to keep the karmic balance, his Bloomburrow predictions are probably going to all be Circle of Loyalty level 😂

@Crusina

19 күн бұрын

Also why is the wanderer so pretty 😢❤

Love love love the podcasts!!! I look forward to this and the commander ones each week ❤❤

@MTGGoldfishPodcast

19 күн бұрын

Thanks!

"What do you play if Nadu isn't banned?" Elden Ring

The last time I remember a deck being this dominant wasn't really that long ago, it was Izzet Epiphany in the Innistrad Championship, which was 40% of the metagame, 6/8 top 8 slots, and a 59% winrate.

Foundations being announced right as MH3 hits is incredibly ridiculous timing. "Our non-rotating format has become a psuedo-rotating format due to regular powercreep, and our rotating format is going to become a pseudo nonrotating format due to permanently legal staples."

@Shimatzu95

19 күн бұрын

I said it before, standard is now extended(the old format, before modern was a thing). Just change the name already and re-introduce NORMAL standard.

@ammonaustin9081

19 күн бұрын

WotC's greed is trying to kill standard, modern, and EDH all at once

@robertk1834

19 күн бұрын

@@ammonaustin9081 it's definitely killed EDH for me, I rarely engage with it any more

@JonReid01

19 күн бұрын

​@@Shimatzu95 what would normal standard be in that context? Not trolling just don't know what you mean

@Shimatzu95

18 күн бұрын

@@JonReid01 the regular 2 ish years it was before, potentially shorter as we get more sets faster now compared to the early days. Edit: Given that we now have more non standard sets, i think 2 yeats is still fine.

Modern feels like opening a bank account and putting $1,200 in it. Then, when you check your account a week later, there's only $350 in there.

@MTGGoldfishPodcast

19 күн бұрын

So it's the "I decided to invest in random shitcoin" format.

@bonidc6732

19 күн бұрын

Why you see a game as an investment??

@brningpyre

19 күн бұрын

@@bonidc6732 Because cards are expensive. If you wanna just burn money, then go ahead. But for the rest of us, we gotta buy and sell cards as we move between decks and formats.

@AndrewS-vu4ji

19 күн бұрын

​@@bonidc6732 It justifies the large purchase. Not a lot of regular people will pay $1000 for a deck of magic cards, so being able to sell it for pretty much the same price takes away the sting of spending that much.

@Tomovanlaanen

18 күн бұрын

@@bonidc6732 Nobody here is suggesting it's an investment. We don't want the cards to increase in value - we're just hoping that if we want to sell out, we recoup most of the costs. You know, like Modern used to be.

I started building yawg in modern a little over a year ago. It seemed like every time I almost had the deck finished, some new super expensive piece for the deck came out. There was sheoldred, then orcish bow masters, then soul cauldron. Now that I finally got all the pieces like 2 months ago, the entire meta has shifted, most of the cards I've invested in aren't even being used in the deck anymore. I originally thought I was just going to wait for the meta to settle from mh3 and then update the deck, but at this point I'll probably just take it apart and put the cards in random commander decks

@JulioDRai

19 күн бұрын

I wouldnt worry too much if I were you, right now Yawg players are trying out all the cards to see if anything is worth adding but so far I havent seen anything that has made the deck that much better so its very likely that once the meta settles Yawg looks almost the exact same as it did pre-MH3, its also smart to wait for the Nadu ban before buying anything for modern.

@6ixpool520

19 күн бұрын

@@JulioDRai Yeah, yawg will regain its place as the best creature based combo deck in modern once WOTC finally gets around to banning Nadu

@Stefanish

19 күн бұрын

Yeah, you cant buy a deck over time anymore. You have to buy the whole deck while it's hot to ensure at least a few months of play, before it rotates and destroys all the money invested. At 1000$ per deck, I said goodbye to modern long time ago

I'm looking forward to the explanation in the B&R of how this card got printed. someone getting thrown under the bus.

@xiaohe6407

20 күн бұрын

They will try to tell you how shouko is a mistake like bridge from below.

@SurlyDuff814

20 күн бұрын

"We didn't playtest Nadu because we don't give a crap about non-Commander formats."

@holstenmason

19 күн бұрын

@@SurlyDuff814 in fairness it had an even more dominant showing in its first cedh tournament

@florinalinmarginean1135

19 күн бұрын

@@SurlyDuff814 They don't give a shit about Commander either: that broken mess of Dockside Extortionist was first printed in a Commander precon. And Nadu is probably even more broken than in Modern, since you get him in your command zone. Hopefully he gets banned there too; I'm tired of people sitting down at a table with an absolute design mistake complaining when I focus them and beat them down

YES RICHARD! THANK YOU! Modern horizons was so problematic for the role modern served as a format. Standard was the format to play when you wanted quick metagame turnover. Modern was the format where you could feel confident spending premium prices on a deck that they will be able to play for a long time. Now modern rotates at the same rate as standard (which isn't really in paper anymore) and you have to spend $1000+ every two years.

@martijndenboon9534

19 күн бұрын

I really only play commander now mainly because of this reason when I used to buy 60 card decks for GPs and fun more competitive games

@robertk1834

19 күн бұрын

@@martijndenboon9534 Commander is rotating lockstep with Modern as there are hundreds of new cards being injected annually.

Richard gave the correct answer about Nadu: it wasn't tested for Modern, only Commander, where it's harder to go infinite with just one shuko in the deck (and even so it's egregious). They don't test for any format whatsoever outside Commander, it's the only thing that matters for R&D.

I still watch MTGGoldfish videos, yet I stopped playing Modern and MTG altogether about 5 years ago. That tells you everything you need to know about a game that has become a complete parody of its former self...

@Leuber

19 күн бұрын

I have used my old modern cards (you know, the cards that have become unplayable draft chaff nowadays) to make a modern 2018 battlebox. Hollow One, Affinity, Dredge, Lantern, Death’s Shadow, Valakut, EldraTron, etc. I still really like these decks and IMHO that was some of the best modern we ever had.

If I recall, Wizards straight up said, "We didn't see the Saheeli/Felidar combo." In my opinion, which is purely mine, Wizards doesn't play test. WoTC waits for the community to play test at a Pro Tour and save them the cost of payroll.

I used to think Llanowar elves was a busted card, but for the current Bo1 standard, I'm not even sure it would be that good. Green struggles against Red aggro and Boros Convoke because it doesn't have proper removal, and Llanowar Elves is going to randomly get got by Lockdowns and Path of peril. That's not to mention, Depopulate and Sunfall, which is going to get the Elves and whatever they ramped into. Wrath of god is technically an upgrade over Depopulate, but I'm not sure it's better than Sunfall. I'm guessing decks that want wraths will split and play both.

@MTGGoldfishPodcast

19 күн бұрын

I actually think that in the current format Llanowar is probably a good addition. Green needs help and it dies to all the powerful, popular cheap removal and Green will still have issues with getting hit by a wrath. Whether it will look that way 5 years from now, who knows?

Please found the format "Horizonless Modern" without MHx or universes beyond. The pushed cards that are printed into Standard will make their way into Horizonless Modern

11:28 - Thank you for saying this. I was getting tired of being gaslit that this card had an intense playtesting process. It did not.

@josephwodarczyk977

14 күн бұрын

That's not what gaslighting is. You weren't there when it went untested, so there's no memory for people to dispute.

@ReyaadawnMTG

14 күн бұрын

@@josephwodarczyk977 a very loud portion of the online community continually told us that “it was playtested vigorously” despite the fact that it was clearly not. Sure, that may not be clinically defined gaslighting in terms of an abusive relationship but that sure is a form of it in a smaller scale

Seth Nadu is obnoxious in commander and draft too. People completely change the draft archetype if they get passed Nadu.

28:44 Yes, play Pioneer. It’s the power level of early 2010s Modern.

@verververververver

20 күн бұрын

Pioneer is stale af right now too.

@Xoulrath_

20 күн бұрын

​@@verververververver there's room to build. People just don't. Same as Modern.

@as95ms98

19 күн бұрын

​@@ververververververPioneer is fucking awesome right now! Nothing's stopping you from making a brew, and there's a lot of stuff you can do.

@Leuber

19 күн бұрын

I am now very hesitant (read: unwilling) to invest in Pioneer for fear of Pioneer Horizons once WotC figures out that they need to ruin that format now.

Overlord of the Hauntwoods giving you a token of something that doesn’t “exist” sounds a lot like the paper version of conjuring cards from mtga.

The community creates an eternal format to play their older cards. Wizards prints directly into the format to capitalize on the popularity of the new format. Non-rotating format now is rotating.

I think its awesome seeing the fastest man in America playing MtG. That's a lot bigger sign of the health of the game than its getting credit for.

I would never build or buy a modern deck. Honestly, MH3 went from cards I was excited about for my commander decks to the realization that WotC is insistent on soft rotating, apparently every format, at an untenable pace. It’s just making me appreciate what I have and drastically limit my exposure to new cards.

I legitimately think whoever greenlit Nadu assumed the twice per turn limit somehow applied to all of the creatures combined or something. If you understand the rules of the game you can clearly see why this ability is broken, why it is also super hard to understand and why it is so unintuitive.

@enmanuelrondon9700

19 күн бұрын

There's no way it was an accident, it's pushed from every single angle you look it it from.

I peaced out of Modern with MH1. The writing was on the wall then that Wizards was all in on dollar signs and didn't care about the game at all. It has just accelerated with each MH release.

54:30 Impending triggers on end step, not upkeep. This knocks a turn off the clock, but it also means that your opponent gets a turn of it being a creature to answer it before it can attack.

Can't wait for the inevitable Rhystic Studies video on Nadu down the line

I still can't believe they templated the card as "creatures you control have," instead of "whenever a creature you control." It would still be REALLY good if it could only trigger twice per turn, but it would be more excusably good.

@bigfhtagn

19 күн бұрын

That's definitely the most important change they could/should have made but they had so many other chances to hit the breaks. The extra lands could come in tapped, does it need to fly and does it need those stats? The cost could be more color intensive? There's a lot of levers that could have been pulled but, man they really let this go past 11

@PaulSzkibik

19 күн бұрын

@@bigfhtagn I feel like the devs just misread the cards and thought "it only triggers twice per turn" and thought "oh, that's cute in edh, where you aphetto alchemist can draw up to 9 cards in a turn cycle but it's fine in modern."

@_Ve_98

19 күн бұрын

They probably did it to stop tidebinder from completely disabling it. Still, just use an emblem with that ability that's only active while nadu is in the field

@robertk1834

19 күн бұрын

Even with this, a 3/4 flyer for 1UG is still egregious.

can say confidently that Wotc printed this card, because "crunch" both not enough time to design these cards with extremely extended list of pros and people who work in magic all ushered to both design and playtest. Even rosewater has admitted on podcasts that sometimes cards have errors because of when they are submitted during the sets design cycle(which can mean set closes tomorrow we need 10 rares, hey guys heres 10 rares on the final day). Wheel was printed in a way that straight up doesnt work as a physical card, and nadu was allowed to release in this state. This is a crunch issue. Nadu wasnt a chase rare and was very quickly brewed at first glance by people on twitter when doomwake previewd it.

Remember when Richard said Nadu decks wouldn't be that good because you'll be playing so many bad cards that can't win you the game. Or that Assassin's Creed will sell well. Richard, tell us which stocks will tank!

@cutebuttzlolz

19 күн бұрын

Yeah and him saying you’d have to have two brain cells in this video to see that nadu is broken 😂

@jamesesdad

19 күн бұрын

he's completely clueless, and often has terrible takes. Complaining about goyf being unplayable in the format, even though its basically seen no real competitive play in the last 4 years.

@helloyou5549

19 күн бұрын

@@jamesesdad i find he often has the best takes

@baconsir1159

19 күн бұрын

Not to mention his take on Phlage, lol

The One Ring is for Modern what Brainstorm is to Legacy. If it wasn't so expensive, the fact that it's a glue that binds every deck together might be a positive for the format instead of a negative.

I like cards that make "land tokens" because you don't have to go through your library and shuffle afterwards. Similar to treasures really, but just a different flavor. Obviously, a card could just tap for mana, but if powerful enough, these cards can go into landfall decks and shorten the time to shuffle. Edit: Ah, I paused the video when I wrote this. 10 seconds later they're mentioned the no-shuffling benefit. 😅

This is probably the best takes on how wizards has taken the game I've ever heard. Thank you for highlighting some of these concerns. Great video guys!

11:41 Nadu is also miserable in commander.

Been playing annuls as a clean answer for the Ring and other things for months now, been working pretty well for me.

Re: Noah Lyles: For what it's worth, there's also been clips of him also bringing/showing the old school yugioh cards too (e.g. exodia/blue eyes)

The conversation about rotation now existing in both Modern and Commander was… sad. 😔 it was very accurate, but sad. I have no interest in Duskmourn as a set, but I do have a samurai based EDH deck so another usable samurai in the form of The Wanderer is a card I’ll definitely be interested in.

Our old cards were bought didn't cut it anymore in the arms race so we started just printing our own and house banned the problems

I agree with Richard about the lower power the better, it's the same in racing games too. My favourites are the lower categories where you're racing around in underpowered crapboxes and have to use actual technique when racing as opposed to the higher categories where everyone is just ramming into each other in their 1000 horsepower rocket ships.

56:50 Richard not knowing about infinitokens is the wildest of the wild even for him

Great pod, really enjoyed it

Nadu feels like it would appear in a card design textbook, followed by an essay prompt to analyze the card design in 500 words and explain why the design is terrible.

Unfortunately, the analysis of the modern "investment problem" is spot on. I bought a bunch of stuff for paper 2 years ago to get back into the tournament scene. Now I don't dare to calculate the current value of my collection due to the huge inflation caused by powercreep and MH-X sets. Probably will focus more an Arena and Timless for the upcoming months as I get to play the new cards but a fraction of the cost.

oh boy, here we go!

Duskmourn’s style is awesome. I’m excited for it

Been playing magic for 15 years and now i pretty much strictly play limited. From an economic standpoint i think its actually cheaper over time considering every format is rotational at this point. I just miss limited GPs....

@Xoulrath_

20 күн бұрын

Technically, it should be cheaper, IF you're selling the money cards.

@6ixpool520

19 күн бұрын

@@Xoulrath_ Or just playing them in your commander decks lol

@Xoulrath_

19 күн бұрын

@@6ixpool520 I don't play Commander.

I would wholeheartedly recommend Pauper. Most decks in the format cost $50 to $100, games are grindy and interactive, and you can use a wide variety of cards from throughout Magic's history. There was just recently a major tournament that had seven different decks in the top eight, and most decks have anywhere from a 4% to 10% metagame share. It's also a format where even jank brews can steal wins against meta decks. Goblins and elves, neither of which are significant metagame players made it to the semi-finals of the card market best pauper deck ever challenge

@TravisOsborn

19 күн бұрын

Doesn’t the Horizons sets still come in and shake this format up a ton? I guess it’s not as expensive of a rotation but it’s still kind of a hassle.

@johnjessop9456

19 күн бұрын

Horizons sets don't so much rotate pauper as they add new tools to old archetypes. The number of cards that break into pauper in a big way is minimal. Just about the only new archetype that came out of the latest set is sadistic lizard, which is a Creature-Based combo deck that plays very similarly to goblin combo. Just about every other deck just happened to pick up one or two new cards.

Printing cards directly into older formats was a mistake. Modern is just a more expensive Standard now.

What i like about mtggoldfish is how critical they are to wotc and dont shy away to tell the how they feel about the game

Regarding Modern, I haven't played it in paper since 2017. The reasoning being mostly because of the issues Richard described; many staples were no longer seeing play, and I bought into Legacy instead. I saw the writing on the wall in the first Modern Horizons set, that the format would simply be too volatile to have any deck remain relevant for a long period of time. Legacy actually has a better shot; the "staples" last longer, and certainly ebb and flow, because the answers are better. Decks are rarely invalidated forever, and receive tools that allow them to update and compete. Your skill matters far more in Legacy, because mistakes generally lose the entire game, so the pace of the game is slower, and the answers are so good it generally devolves quite quickly into "limited style gameplay" as Richard describes. There are exceptions to this, such as cards that are borderline unanswerable in certain shells even with almost all the cards in Magic's history, notably the sequencing of Grief+Reanimate in Daze shells (wait for a ban on this one before investigating). Exceptions aside, there is generally good enough interaction in Legacy to make just about whatever you want playable, even through high power level fluctuations and new inclusions, because of the skill ceiling being astronomically high. It's almost more economically efficient to buy a Reserved List mana base (or proxy it, the community is incredibly proxy friendly) and a few staples and to cycle through a couple Legacy decks with the mana base you have than it is to spend money on a rotating modern format. That's what I did in 2017, and I never, ever looked back. Just don't pick a Lands/Mox Diamond shell unless you are very, very stable financially.

The funniest thing to me about land tokens is just how much more you could potentially ramp with token doubling effects, I could see a lower powered commander game where a player's token land stack is approaching library size, especially in Selesnya colors. At least populate doesn't make more of them, unless you turn one or more into a creature.

Really good episode. Very insightful.

My Nadu theory is that it was a once per turn 3/3 and that intern tested that version and was happy with it. Then an exec came in two days before sending it to print and said "this is only once per turn? so weak! make it at least twice per turn!". "But its once per turn per creature" says the interm, but the exect, not understanding what that means just doubled down "Twice per turn I say, and also make it live bolt for good measure!"

As a commander only player for the past decade, i didnt even have to know the current meta in other formats.Yet, the moment nadus abilities spoiled, my jaw dropped and i knew I'd hear that name in my damn dreams.

MH3 got me back into Magic after a 10-year hiatus. It’s an amazing limited experience and has tons of incredibly-flavorful cards and call-backs for us older players. That being said, I started buying cards for Boros Energy during release week, got most of the deck, and then just stopped after the Pro Tour. I don’t think I’ll be playing Modern; just Commander and limited.

Nadu looked insane from the get go, no way they couldn’t have known how good it would be. Please slow the power creep, especially in the most powerful format to begin with.

I love how Richard's response to "Nowhere to Run" is that it doesn't have targets; as if Virtue of Persistence hasn't been been killing important things in Standard since it's release in September of 2023. And that it doesn't kill Nadu; as if this unreleased card for Standard is meant to be the answer for a card that doesn't even exist in Standard or have Ward or Hexproof. Mostly I love how Richard doesn't even pretend to know what's going on in Standard and everything is good or bad based on whether it ruins his Goyf experience in Modern.

I didn't even watch the top 8 when I saw 5 Nadu decks made it lol.

Overlord is amazing in any commander enchantress deck. Its an enchantment that ramps and makes a threat.

It's actually really clear how Nadu happenned imo. - Nadu is given to testers without the twice a turn restriction. - Testers give feedback that it's broken and that you need to limit gate the ability. - Design go 'ok, please retest it with it only triggering twice a turn'. - Testers test it actually triggering twice a turn, give feedback that it's now fine. - Design send it to print, forgetting to change the templating to just be an ability on Nadu, not giving it to every creature. - All formats where nadu is legal are immediately ruined. The reality is that mtg testers dont test with real cards, they test with playtest wordings on playtest cards and this it the unfortunate result. I really don't think this was a 'to sell packs' thing because it would have been a mythic if that was the case.

@PoYi-fi1zt

19 күн бұрын

Maybe it was just once per turn and then … the test team say it was too weak… so they print twice a turn😅

@zztzgza

19 күн бұрын

The playtest team has old mtg pros on it, they can't really miss this ruling workaround for nadu which is flicker and blink, bant colors, unless they just don't test these cards at all. Whomever designed Nadu is also at fault because their restriction on Nadu's ability is a suggestion and not a hard limit.

@TJMiton

19 күн бұрын

@@zztzgza that's exactly the point i was making; they do not test with actual cards. obviously it's a design issue, the card should just have the ability that triggers twice (worded similarly to leovold ect), not give it to every creature.

@keagancollins3243

19 күн бұрын

As soon as I read the card my first reaction was “someone misplaced a quotation mark”

@Bubblenuts13

19 күн бұрын

As I’ve followed mtg, I consistently feel like Wizard’s methods for handling card design and testing need to be improved upon. It feels like there are very often little mistakes and moments where something is changed at the last minute that only happen because they have too many steps in the process. There really shouldn’t be a possibility for the pros to play with unfinished versions of cards but that’s what happens because of time constraints.

I learned how to play Magic via Modern about 10 years ago. It’s hard to find shops that promote 60 card formats in general. I will always love the format but it is not meant for the average player. I am heavily invested in it and can speak from experience trying to teach it to new players.

49:10 at the very least, Duskmourne has a lot of supernatural elements. No shortage of magic

The foundations idea comes from RND not wanting to have to redesign the same set every year when the core sets were basically reprint farms. This solves 2 problems

Could they ever “restrict” The One Ring?? They’ve never restricted before in modern but this card seems like a good fit for it.

this might be a controversial opinion but i think wizards knew what they were doing when printing nadu

@BickSnarf

19 күн бұрын

I think they did test it and knew it was broken. from a company that has been doing this for essentially my whole life im almost assured they released this card to generate discourse around the game

The best match to watch at the pro tour was the boros energy mirror. It was the closest to watching a traditional midrange mirror. But with way more efficient cards. And Phlage although it didn’t show up in top 8 looks like it might be oppressive if it takes over.

Overlord seems insane in a blink deck. Play it for three, flickerwisp it, get another land and a 6/5. Or flash in Phelia on t2, play overlord on three, Phelia blinks it, get more ramp and a 6/5.

Since you asked Seth, I proxy modern cards and it’s super fun so I don’t mind the power creep

Im someone wo listens to this everyweek and i was wondering which helps you guys more if i listen on goldfish article or youtube?

I do believe this may be planned. Was the set really good if no cards have to get banned? As y'all said the broken card helps push sales too

I'd look forward to a conversation from you guys about doomwakes modern or horizonless modern. Mtg is a board game and we can choose how to use these cards, so why not play traditional modern without horizons

I use modern horizons for EDH and my cube. Modern horizon power creeps old cards out of edh as well.

The problems with Modern Horizons sets as I see it is that with MH2 people complained a lot that there were too many generically powerful cards that could fit a bunch of places, and the format rotated. So now with MH3 they made a lot of narrow powerful cards that all work with each other, and the format rotated. I think the solution should be, no more MH sets. Both approaches failed, and I don’t see a third

20:00 I do think the "flavor win" of every deck wanting the One Ring could be followed up by a flavorful solution: *_restricting_* the card in every format. There is only _One_ Ring, after all! And I'm only _mostly_ joking. I mean, obviously introducing a single-card restricted list to Modern would be pretty silly. But you'd get rid of the "Ring draws the next Ring" play pattern, limiting the protection ability and making it less trivially easy to reset your burden counters and stabilize your life total. And from a card availability perspective, the number of playsets of the card in existence would basically quadruple!

was so excited for the weekend of games but holy moly you're right, nadu bored me to tears

Tbf, Modern only rotates every other year. Standard shuffles along four times a year

I play paper modern, and I still have a great time with it. I played golgari rock and did well with it, and for mh3 I built Boros Boom (thanks spike) and had an amazing time with it. In terms of price, my golgari was way more expensive than my Boros deck, the only real expensive card being phlage. I want to say I saw a lot of people complaining about facing Yawg, titan, tron and the like before MH3 because those were the best decks and in our 20+ people FnM modern tournaments you would always see them, but now there are a bunch of new decks to face and it’s refreshing. I don’t think all the old decks are dead, there is still time for decks to change and adapt to at least be able to compete. To say the entirety of modern is the top 5 decks is not right, random rouge decks can still smash them as their sideboards are not prepared as I did with $100 12 shadow against all the MH2 meta decks, and same goes for the older decks pre MH3.

+1 for a green blue legendary manadork for a single blue/green hybrid cost and taps for green or blue. color shifting is power creep too :)

My LGS Basicly baned Nadu for Modern.

Lorcana seems pretty great - picked it up the other day.

To answer Seth's q at about 35 min: Cube is my modern, has been since covid. If I want balance I can't rely on wotc, so I do the best I can for my playgroup.

Cephalid breakfast existed (maybe still exists? I dont play attention to legacy anymore). Idk how they missed nadu when you consider cephalid breakfast functions similarly

@cpthavoc5571

19 күн бұрын

Cephalid Breakfast is still around in legacy and several builds of it have added in Nadu to add to the midrange backup of the deck seeing as they already have the combo pieces for it in there with Nomads en Kor and Shuko. The builds that go all in on the main combo don't bother with Nadu though.

my theory re: how nadu happened is that it only triggered on spells until the last minute, when someone realised it needed to also trigger on fury and solitude.

Pioneer, you're describing Pioneer!!!

Great video, Seth. Please make the Gruul Prowess deck before Nadu gets banned! Swiftspear the bird!

surprised you guys didnt quickly talk about kai budde, really sad news but nice from wizards to honour him this way, hope he can beat cancer still

I remember a few years ago I noticed that simply by drafting and playing magic I was like 5 cards away from a full Eldrazi Tron deck so I bought the missing cards and completed it for like 30$ and it was great. There is no way to do that today, even though I was lucky to open 4 rings, no way I'm building new decks. Only commander

the biggest problem I feel is not a single card but rather a critical mass of ones that pretty much end the game on the spot. you cannot wait for your turn and need to either instantly remove their threat or counter it, otherwise it's too late to come back. sure, emrakul and combo decks do exist but now it's almost every deck and they are less and less interactable

WOTC won’t ban because they can make a cereal cross over with Toucan Sam! 😂

@jud6ment

20 күн бұрын

Its already in the works (i don't actually know, but probably)

@Xoulrath_

20 күн бұрын

That would make way more sense for BoP. Also, I WOULD buy it. Don't judge me. 😂