Motsoaledi: Police don't need to arrest illegal immigrants
Фильм және анимация
Home Affairs Minister, Aaron Motsoaledi, says police don't need to arrest immigrants or use discriminatory methods to ascertain their status in the country.
Motsoaledi says officers can run checks using the online national register.
He was addressing Parliament on the backlog in permit appeals for asylum seekers and refugees.
Tune into Newzroom Afrika channel 405 for more.
Пікірлер: 194
THIS OLD MAN IS VERY MUCH SOBER AND WE LOVE HIM AND IS OUR OWN!!!
The only Minister who always give 💯 s to his job big up papa 👏 we are watching on side lines , SA must function like other countries like Zimbabwe,Malawi , Mozambique Nigeria , Congo etc within its laws to protect its dignity and sovereignity period.
I like Mr motsoaledi cz he stand for truth
👏👏👏👍✊✊✊ Power bab'uMotswaledi Amen You have spoken akube njalo
MINISTER, THE PROBLEM IS YOU SURROUNDED BY PEOPLE WHO ARE BENEFITING FORM THESE ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES.
@khangezamoyo5151
Жыл бұрын
Money is everything.if you dont want money you are Dom
USA is using the same service n its been working very well,we're behind you minister
@user-um2iw3gk2r
10 ай бұрын
Do we necessarily need to copy what others Do?
While the minister is referring to existing laws, the problem is in their implementation. Police officers see migrants whether legal or illegal as cash cows for their corrupt activities. They will try to intimidate with the intention of soliciting bribes.
@roblucci2366
Жыл бұрын
Sounds like every police force in Africa
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Stay home
@aharaw007rawat3
Жыл бұрын
100 percent
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Fix home for sake of ur future generations
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Tendai u hv some home fixing n housekeeping back in Rhodesia take care of home first then nextdoor
Motsoaledi you are doing your job. No one must tell you how to do it.Those who are not even better ,like to think that others don't know how to work, them themselves are blocked up they don't even know where to start.If you know what you are doing is the wright procedure,then do It and stay very cool ".
Since Europe is generally safe, police job is stop check moslty foreigners and it helps them a lot. I honestly don't mind police checking my Documents. In Europe we getting checked in these streets as foreigners whenever police want and there is nothing wrong with that,they are ensuring their continent remains safe
@dumisanindlovu5766
Жыл бұрын
Which Europe you are referring to has lived in European countries but I have not been stopped to be asked for documents. No to aphathied again
@seantowanda8702
Жыл бұрын
That is because you don't know your rights and you willingly surrender your identity to them as a consentual encounter with the police that is why citizens in Europe have a right to privacy and the only time that they must produce ID to police is when you have committed a crime or during a lawful traffic stop otherwise they will be sued
@seantowanda8702
Жыл бұрын
@@dumisanindlovu5766 only if you have broken the law are you compelled to provide ID you can even say no to the police and they can't force you like here in Africa
Good question Mpho this thing of deport the following day they are back
Dudula let's us go ahead with our job this country is not owned by ANC ,SA belongs to south Africans
@tatendawilson3057
Жыл бұрын
south africa belongs to africans
@jumbo3636
Жыл бұрын
You are uncorrect , no country belongs to nobody , can you go and eat in a restaurant for free or stay in a five star hotel in sandon because you are a South African ,man world belong to hard workers and capable people ,here you are promoting a type of begging and you guys always curse governments or other things because you are lazy .
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Dudula i ANC out of power first
@Bbb-ml4gb
Жыл бұрын
Unapologetic soo
@Bbb-ml4gb
Жыл бұрын
@@zisilemoyi2246 Ulendeni wena
You know your story minister keep pushing we are behibd you.
Why would Motsoaledi tell police what to Do? He must do his job.. Sans don't need the Anc govt will show them in 2024...we all need to register to vote 2023. We need a govt who knows hot to run a counrry cos the Anc has really disappointed black people... Babalaz, hangover go vote...
@jameskillu9171
Жыл бұрын
South Africa is enough for all of us
This old men must go home and sleep!!! They don't understand them selfs!!!;
I feel sorry for this minister because it's obvious he has upset people on high places now they are trying to find any unnecessary faults 😂
@sibusisomosieleng3193
Жыл бұрын
True
He makes some good points.
Sometimes I Just fail to understand why 90% news clips are negative about RSA,If i come to RSA then how will i be identified, one must carry a form of identification, be in a country legally.South Africa has also played a positive pivoting role on this continent, even though all is not well in 2022 it also has positive attributes,it processes the final products from copper plates from DEC and Zambia, Lithium ore, platinum ore, chrome ore from zimbabwe, south african companiea investing in other countries,positive exchange programs etc. RSA in just going through a rough patch and will rise and shine again,why cant we talk about bosch chickens, crops, etc which are drought resistant that have been developed in RSA for other countries,dew harvesting techniques etc. I may be wrong and stand to be corrected but RSA as a whole irrregardless of race or creed has played a positive supportive brotherly or parental role.
@Honeybee897
Жыл бұрын
True Mwisho. Let the truth be told.
@pakisoramatlo5556
Жыл бұрын
No one wants to talk about it, only the negative are been said out loud in order to make RSA look bad.
@faridaally6184
Жыл бұрын
@@jameskillu9171 your government dont treat you good go home
@sibusisomosieleng3193
Жыл бұрын
@@jameskillu9171 you again crocodile rider
@mbowamoi355
Жыл бұрын
The minister says the truth the problem is the way people interpret him. So many times people get detained and a locked up for days when it's just a phone for verification simple.
Mpho I don't like the way you ask your questions
M0rswaled was doing his job accurately the corrupt ANC leader put him in a Big confusion
This will make Johannesburg CBD goes unhappy I heard people don't walk 10 feet without get caught 🤣😂🤣
Well-done saps
Aaron is boss
@sibusisomosieleng3193
Жыл бұрын
Yebo we love him 🥰
If they can't arrest then what's the point
We are tired of these ANC leaders who are reluctant in solving problems as they arise , they are the cause of this illegal foreign national mess instead of fixing it , they open up talk shops ..
Suppose all foreigners leave south africa what will happen may be electricity will be restored 24hours a day? Jobs will be available, cheap water bills and free food door by door, surely RSA you have lost direction Anc have distroyed the country sorry.
We going back to those dark days
The title is misquoting and distorting what the Minister said .
@jameskillu9171
Жыл бұрын
what did the minister say according to you
@pennygooms1539
Жыл бұрын
@@jameskillu9171 You are irrelevant to me. I've seen your various comments concerning South Africans politics and the People. I am not interested in your agenda or thoughts.
@philanimpanza9364
Жыл бұрын
You must always believe journalists at your own risk but don't blame them because they are like actors and they are given script by editors
@yehudahndou77
Жыл бұрын
Click bait
The title of the conversation is different than the argument Mpho are you clear about your job or somebody is doing it for you.
@philanimpanza9364
Жыл бұрын
You must always believe journalists at your own risk but don't blame them because they are like actors they read the script given by editors
Hi like myself I was kept on Wednesday around 12h30 by the police in Germiston, the policeman asked me the papers I showed him the drivers license were my identity number was there he refused and I have to call someone at home to send a picture of my IDENTITY, one said it’s okay one said we😂have to go at Homeaffairs for verification, meanwhile I told someone to bring my iD at Homeaffairs, reaching there they refused to verify it and I told them my relatives are on the way with the iD,they said it’s too late, they issued a letter of detention, and giving me back my drivers license,we go to the police station I was locked up in for 48hours and they took my iD which was delivered by the same office, and I got through Refugies 😢now I to go there for collecting it again instead of giving it back the same day I was been released
@marky5493
Жыл бұрын
then it sounds like its a better place in your old country where they don't do that hey?
It is well.
@Akinnuoyegrace3699
Жыл бұрын
Everything is about foreigner in SA the more we spread hate the more the economy is getting worst. The strength of a broom is on it number. The worst is all eyes and hate is focused on black immigrant as if they are the course of bad economy in SA. Instead of dealing with crime, creating employment, empowering women with skills. In addiction to jealousy and quest for vanity we kept on breaking each other instead of building each in unity and love we range and wage war against each others and we expect progress and God's blessing.
So what should they do after checking them on e system ?
@ToxxicMafia
Жыл бұрын
Simple, arrest them if they are not in the system. General Mawela and his cops do it all the time at the roadblocks
@SonOfTheSoil834
Жыл бұрын
@@ToxxicMafia arrest them until when?and give them food in prisons while packing our prisons 😂😂…take em back to their country with wastage of our resources then they come back same way 🤣🤣
@ToxxicMafia
Жыл бұрын
@@SonOfTheSoil834 how do you take them back without arresting them first?
@ToxxicMafia
Жыл бұрын
@@SonOfTheSoil834 there's a difference between arresting someone and convicting them
@jameskillu9171
Жыл бұрын
treat people well, they are humans, if in system or not. how would you want to be treated
Kindness means kind , a kind person is kind towards everything ,they can't differentiate ,it's they don't differentiate is not correct . Correct sentence in English is a kind person can't differentiate . For example one minister poppy doctor gone against Zimbabwean and claiming herself she is kind to him and unkind to him ,what a biggggggg lie poppy minister what is this . 😀
You are confusing people your statement changes everyday, so just leave these people coz manje asisakwazi ????????
Talk about Zimbabwe not USA old man
I’m
Let them do what ever they do, what makes me not worry about it is both citizens and FOREIGNERS are being arrested daily on different occasions. Yes the song is about FOREIGNERS, but at the END of that song we see Citizens in jail, Now you are happy by seeing FOREIGNERS loaded in Gumbakumbas but be careful the same gumbakumba might load u to jail with your smart card.
Hoy
This police minister and Home affairs minister talking about law but they are not following any of Law. Immigration department are corrupted so today millions of SA public victims by Foreigners and suffering 😢 can't find it any jobs.
Why uhulumeni uhluleka ukusebenzisa imithetho yezwe ukulwa nesimo esikhona kwicountry
😂😂😂🤣🙆🏽♀️🙆🏽♀️🙆🏽♀️🙆🏽♀️🙆🏽♀️
Let them be taken to jail and not be given bail.
@abdullahmia2367
Жыл бұрын
Hi my friend The laws is useless here You can kill someone Rape someone etc Next day you are out my friend What kind of laws is this That call South Africa 🇿🇦 Keep it up
Mxm he was threatened now he is talking trash
Go Dudula everyone at Eskom plz
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Dudula ethnic national invasion from da horn of Africa
This man is old for that position his confused already
@kwazingcobo8551
Жыл бұрын
Go to hell, bloody fool
@hopebuhali3887
Жыл бұрын
We love this man, very good for his position.
@sellomonama7797
Жыл бұрын
You allowed a nonagenarian (president Mugabe) rule Zimbabwe, but now you have the guts to talk about Dr. Motswaledi. Be free to enjoy freedom of speech in Mzanzi cause you won't find it anywhere in Africa.
Everything is about foreigners in this country 🥵
@nomawethumqina3270
Жыл бұрын
Yes until you all go back home
@RINASZ
Жыл бұрын
ubufuna ithini?ons baie moeg vir jou.
@gilvasnyamupingidza768
Жыл бұрын
I'm here till 2030,I'm an African.
@shezwa
Жыл бұрын
@@RINASZ voetsek learn to read, all I'm saying is there is nothing we hearing except foreigners
@Bbb-ml4gb
Жыл бұрын
Yes until they gave us space and go build Africa, it can't be built from SA
Studip idea Mr Minister ,where do u come from yourself . Your great grand parents came from Lesotho long time ago. Check your history Mr Minister . Why talking about Zimbabweans and leaving out the Drug dealers Nigerians who sell drugs and bribe police and home affairs?
Do not mislead the citizens, his meaning is different from your heading.
@sibusisomosieleng3193
Жыл бұрын
News Africa is a problem propaganda channel it has to be closed its high time they replace them now
Many people have been struggling with expire asylum which expire in lockdown it's hard for them
Good has finally overcome evil.
@lebogangmoeketsi1614
Жыл бұрын
Zimbabwean who always focused on south african issues. Mnangwangwa and zanupf are waiting for you.
@lebogangmoeketsi1614
Жыл бұрын
@@jameskillu9171 thank you, south africans need the space to breath
@jameskillu9171
Жыл бұрын
@@lebogangmoeketsi1614 you will get your spaces from boers. when you get courage
@lebogangmoeketsi1614
Жыл бұрын
@@jameskillu9171 we will because black South Africans are fearless. We fear no 1 but we won't use the same method that Zimbabweans used to take their land back because remember black people are not in control of the global systems hence your country is sanctioned today. If we were in control of the global system, we could have took the land by force long time ago. Immediately after 1994 if you don't know. Yours is worse because your are oppressed by black people like you but you come here in SA to preach to south africans pan Africanism and playing smart about SA issues but mnangwangwa is outsmarted Zimbabweans like you.
@WhatdoUwant5419
Жыл бұрын
@@lebogangmoeketsi1614 this James Killu thinks their rabid, vicious, borderline evil ZANU Pf propaganda will work on us. He projects so much hatred and toxicity it’s chilling. Wonder if He even Human or just a Soulless, indoctrinated Zanu bot. He must note: We will never wait hours in the scorching sun just to listen to listen to a president telling us that He shook boris johnson’s Hand.
There are agnets working in Home Aftairs.But when u have a case on they say that they dn't have any agnets woking in the office's.It is only money that talks in this country.
minister is lying .shame. police is adisgrace
This guy he became minister just for foreigners
@bobkenneth2947
Жыл бұрын
Definitely.
This is beyond control we are here stay not going anywhere
Money is involved how much does the united nation's give to the health department because till then maybe dudula will stop thinking like donkeys.
They actually need to be deported.
By the way, the Minister wasn't talking about not arresting illegal immigrants but legal immigrants. Please change the topic, otherwise you are misinforming the public.
@robsrobert7155
Жыл бұрын
Minister we need action because you changed the 12 months of grace period to another 6 months for the Zimbabweans who entered in this country legally . Act now because there are millions of Zimbabweans who are not documented.Are you planning to give them id's so that they must vote for you in 2024? What will happen to police who will be taking bribes? Dudula where are you? We say anybody who entered in this country illegally must be arrested and sent back home.
Its coz they don't get arrested that this country is up to shit
A friend was arrested on good Friday and taken in court on Tuesday then the magistrate sentenced her for 8 months being illegal but she held her permit with her. No one verified a thing my lawyer paid 8000 in fine for nothing and got her out. The other magistrate was so hurt and told the home affairs people they keep on doing this nonsense arresting documented people.
@rosedyantyi3802
Жыл бұрын
We are still going to do it if you are not happy about how we operate feel free to leave 😊
@faraimuchineripi1973
Жыл бұрын
Hi Mbowa, I am a foreign national living in SA, I would like to understand further how the above situation happened? How did the magistrate sentence someone for being an illegal immigrant while they possess a valid permit? why did your lawyer pay a fine for an offence which does not arise? If you are positive the above details are correct, you should appeal the wrongful conviction because your friend would now carry a criminal record wrongfully, secondly I would want you to further engage your lawyer, to explain this thing, otherwise it may require to report this legal practitioner to the Legal Practice Council, that 'fine' given the circumstances sounds very fishy.
@mbowamoi355
Жыл бұрын
@@faraimuchineripi1973 She was there for 2 months I paid the fine myself at newrock the lawyer who got her out took close to 20k in that period. Matter was taken to high court I had to pay sheriff's and spend total I spent more than 40.000 rands in two months. Even after the home affairs verified the documents they still wanted to deport her.
@cubandlovu6227
Жыл бұрын
@@rosedyantyi3802 They'll arrest you too. Remember you are unknown. When police stop anyone they expect bribes
@cubandlovu6227
Жыл бұрын
@@mbowamoi355 you can go to home affairs with your proof of payment and claim your money
Dr Aaron for ANC President
@mosawamorena7707
Жыл бұрын
Lol wena gape!
@zisilemoyi2246
Жыл бұрын
Y
This is stupid idea, why brininging aphathied era again in South Africa. Why people has to carry an ID is it not the time for dompass passes now . Stop this stupid iead for asking people passes and IDS. Please deal with criminals and those who do child traffic. and drug dealers especially the Nigerians. The Nigerians in drugs but they bribe the Law enforcement 😄.
Aron must be taught the definition of illegal, he seems to have forgotten the definition or has never been taught maybe because he's so used to doing illegal things that he can't even differentiate between what's right and wrong.
@machibamaime4095
10 ай бұрын
You are only trying to seem cleverer.
@maburwanemokoena7117
10 ай бұрын
@@machibamaime4095 Your reply doesn't sound too smart, you must reason.
This guy he became minister just for foreigners
@leemabuza387
Жыл бұрын
Lol
@dibongzdibongz7633
Жыл бұрын
This guy is good minister is doing his job proper