Lawyer & Doctor: Debunking Ten Prop 3 Falsehoods
Ойын-сауық
He’s a lawyer. She's a doctor. Meet Attorney, Daniel S. Hilker, and Dr. Joanne Castillo MD, a family medicine physician.
The Diocese of Lansing asked them to assess some the claims being made by the pro-abortion lobby in the current debate over Proposal 3. That's the proposed 323-word “Right to Reproductive Freedom” Amendment to the Constitution of the State of Michigan which will be voted upon November 8.
Here's the top 10 falsehoods as identified and answered by Daniel and Joanne:
00:00 Important Introduction: Don't skip it!
02:18 Claim 1: The Amendment restores women’s rights under Roe. False.
04:39 Claim 2: The Amendment preserves the rights of the next generation. False.
06:27 Claim 3: The Amendment protects a woman’s right to choose. False.
07:45 Claim 4: The Amendment protects “miscarriage care.” False.
08:42 Claim 5: The Amendment allows medical treatment for an ectopic pregnancy. False.
09:54 Claim 6: The Amendment protects health care professionals from going to prison for performing vital fertility, miscarriage, and pregnancy services. False.
10:33 Claim 7: The Amendment prevents prosecution of doctors for performing abortions where the mother’s life is at risk. False.
11:34 Claim 8: This Amendment is needed to prevent “health care professionals” from going to prison for providing abortion care. Mostly False.
12:35 Claim 9: The Amendment protects women. False.
13:18 Claim 10: The Amendment protects the fundamental right of every individual, (man and woman), over their own body, as summarized in “My body, my choice!” False.
As is repeatedly stressed in this video, the full 323-word text of the Proposal 3 Amendment will not be on the ballot paper on November. Only a 95-word summary. Hence:
* To read the full text of the 323-word proposed amendment to the Constitution of the State of Michigan, click here: drop.faithcatholic.com/index....
Note: Also listed in this document by the proposers of the Proposal 3 Constitutional Amendment are the "Provisions of existing constitution altered or abrogated [i.e. repealed] by the proposal if adopted."
In total, the proposers of the Proposal 3 Constitutional Amendment identify eight out of the 12 articles of the Constitution of the State of Michigan that will have to be altered or, in part, repealed if Proposal 3 is approved by voters in November.
These are: Article 1, Declaration of Rights; Article III General Government; Article IV, Legislative Branch; Article V, Executive Branch; Article VI, Judicial Branch; Article VIII, Education; Article IX Finance and Taxation; and Article XI, Public Officers and Employment.
Meanwhile, here is the 95-word summary of Proposal 3 that will appear on the ballot paper in November's election: drop.faithcatholic.com/index....
Пікірлер: 83
Thank you so much! We really appreciate this video. Wish everyone in Michigan would see it before they vote!
When does life begin? If religion is a factor, God told Jeremiah, "before I formed you in the womb I knew you" (Jer 1:5). If science is a factor, the good doctor was right about conception. If your mother would have elected to abort you, she would have killed you. If common sense is a factor, certainly a heartbeat would indicated a life (we are pronounced dead if we don't have one). Keeping with common sense, and the good doctors' point, if dependency is factor of when life begins, it would be fine to kill a child up to what age? The stupidity of even putting this thing on the ballot is beyond comprehension, but the evil of this proposal, and the way it is written, is blatantly apparent.
@realistit4488
Жыл бұрын
kzread.info/dash/bejne/qJplpqmneKmYhNI.html
abortion at any point is murder. Murder is illeagal. I dont get why murder is a politcal argument.
@ferdinanddeguzman3329
Жыл бұрын
absolutely. God bless you.
Thanks for the info!
I knew Dan some years ago. He's an outstanding man. Miss ya buddy.
Excellent video! Thank you, Dr. Joanne Castillo for taking your time to explain this same information in Spanish at our parish.
Thank you for the explanation. Protect our children 🙏 ❤️
@realistit4488
Жыл бұрын
@@Terry-te1ij kzread.info/dash/bejne/qJplpqmneKmYhNI.html
Thanks for your work and time. People need to know what this proposal really is.
This is excellent in helping to understand this Proposal.
If a woman has a misarrange if prop 3 fails, EVERY miscarriage is a potential crime scene... "Did she end the pregnancy? I heard she didn't want to be pregnant". Call the cops.
excellent
Very good but I agree if there was another shorter version with top key points - I know i can't get certain individuals to watch a video longer than 8-10 minutes
@DanHilker
Жыл бұрын
Thanks! There are many other resources out there that are shorter and more digestible. See: kzread.info/dash/bejne/aZNptLqYXZu-iJM.html
@pg3803
Жыл бұрын
I wish someone could tell me where to find the entire law AS WRITTEN! Not the watered down palatable ballot verbiage. Anyone know where we can find it?
@Yousaid77
Жыл бұрын
i didn’t kNOw / Grace Lutheran Church - Coopersville kzread.info/dash/bejne/rGZnmKVqXbzTe5s.html
@Terry-te1ij
Жыл бұрын
@@suzannevainner2845 Is is pro-abortion? Does it favor abortion for any or no reason up to the 9th month with no restrictions whatsoever? Answer me, sugar!
@DanHilker
Жыл бұрын
@@pg3803 See Also: www.micatholic.org/assets/files/advocacy/defeat-proposal-3/proposal-3-explanation.pdf
By far the best video I've seen about proposal on 3 thank you very much much for explaining it and I and I believe staying neutral and stating the facts
THANK YOU!
What I find even more astonishing is your not talking about the life inside the woman.
It passed...pull your kids out of public school.
I think we need to educate woman on how to prevent unwanted pregnancy and ways to abort before nine months please explain why with all the preventive measures on the market they can take why you think they still need an abortion.???
Good but a little late...
May God bless America and Michigan. I pray that these video will be watched by a lot of people in Michigan.
False info - REPORTED
Amen
Please share this video Far and Wide!
Please upload this to Rumble before KZread removes it. Rumble does NOT censor things they don't agree with.
@realistit4488
Жыл бұрын
kzread.info/dash/bejne/qJplpqmneKmYhNI.html
I shared with 10 people and will share with my Catholic friends
Educate women on birth control again.
I wanted to share this, but it's too long and confusing. The people who I think need to see it most won't make it past the first couple of minutes before zoning out.
@DanHilker
Жыл бұрын
Thank you for your feedback! This is intended to be a deeper-dive into the proponent's claims. I invite you to see the very short videos posted by others: e.g. kzread.info/dash/bejne/aZNptLqYXZu-iJM.html
You failed to bring up illegal vbac bans, the fact that obgyns do not follow informed consent today, you failed to bring up obstetrician violence.
OK, FIRST lie at 0:30. The language of the proposal SPECFICALLY PROTECTS THE STATES RIGHT TO REGULATE LATE TERM ABORTIONS.
@samuelsokolowski6170
Жыл бұрын
@jlahuis Seriously, you didn't listen to the whole video where they site the EXACT text on why it doesn't protect States Rights to Regulate Late Term Abortions. That phrase is completely GUTTED by the rest of the text. You also probably didn't read the full amendment text as it was written within the petition for proposal 3. Read and understand the FULL TEXT as it was signed during the petition drive not just the summaries that are going on the ballot. The summary is NOT the amendment. It is just a summary. The amendment is written with extreme bias intended to get people to vote rather than to understand what they are voting for.
@samuelsokolowski6170
Жыл бұрын
Full petition text located here: www.michigan.gov/sos/-/media/Project/Websites/sos/24delrio/Reproductive_Freedom_for_All_747778_7.pdf?rev=a51e8ef7772546bc86058eb68765c97e&hash=96107C919479F71BAC345B4509DA11AD NOTE this is written by Planned Parenthood sooooo.... obviously the text will paint as positive a spin as they possibly can. Even laughably so.
@kmrahe
Жыл бұрын
With such a broad range of exceptions, including for a woman's mental health, the ability to regulate late-term abortions becomes merely a paper tiger.
@KD214_
Жыл бұрын
EXACTLY!! How do they start it with lies! 😂
Great video , we would all be served better if the speakers could cite some sources for their claims. Down in the comment section I'd like to see timestamp links to every claim the Doctor and Lawyer make about the amendment, with a link to the relevant section in the amendment itself (or the propositions webpage since the amendment itself a bit scant on details) I'm not seeing some of these claims on they say the proposal makes. I'm voting "no" but I think we should make it easier on those still on the fence.
@lansingdiocese
Жыл бұрын
Dear Captain, good morning. Great hearing from you. Thank you for your feedback. There are probably two documents that may be helpful in understanding the full impact of the Amendment. One is the 323 words of the Amendment itself: drop.faithcatholic.com/index.php/s/K9EHM7JhehE1JF0#pdfviewer, and then, also, the Michigan Catholic Conference briefing paper that picks ot where you find each of the concerns highlighted within those 323 words: www.micatholic.org/assets/files/advocacy/defeat-proposal-3/proposal-3-focus.pdf . We hope that's something of a help. God bless you.
@Kaptnkrnch
Жыл бұрын
@@lansingdiocese Thank you , that helps out a lot. God Bless you and keep up the good work :)
@jlahuis
Жыл бұрын
They can't site sources, as 90% of the claims they are making are falsehoods.
@jlahuis
Жыл бұрын
@@lansingdiocese Dear Captain. Please do NOT use reference material provided by the Diocese, as it has already been edited to support their agenda. You need to get to the actual language of the bill.
@DanHilker
Жыл бұрын
@@jlahuis In the links above, the Diocese cites to the actual Amendment text. You may be confused about the difference between the "Ballot Language" and the "Amendment Text." The Ballot Language was drafted by the Amendment proponents. It only provides their summary of what will be changed in Michigan's Constitution. You should read the Constitution text for yourself, as only the "summary" will be on the ballot. The Full Amendment Text is here: drop.faithcatholic.com/index.php/s/K9EHM7JhehE1JF0#pdfviewer That link is an exact copy of what was provided as the Amendment text on page 2 of the Petition: www.michigan.gov/sos/-/media/Project/Websites/sos/24delrio/Reproductive_Freedom_for_All_747778_7.pdf?rev=a51e8ef7772546bc86058eb68765c97e&hash=96107C919479F71BAC345B4509DA11AD The Ballot Language is only a Summary: drop.faithcatholic.com/index.php/s/EEJpVfQbKgaenpT
Lies, lies, lies. PEOPLE READ THE PROPOSAL YOURSELF!! These people are misleading. What a shame
Oh people please share
I like the astronaut analogy. If I build a spaceship and someone steals it and takes it up into space, can I ethically activate a remote self-destruct mechanism, ostensibly to, say, prevent someone else from obtaining the technology that went into it? Can I abort that astronaut, because he's using something that belongs to me?
@Terry-te1ij
Жыл бұрын
So kill an astronaut when YOU are not in a life-threatening situation?
@kmrahe
Жыл бұрын
@@Terry-te1ij Yes. That's kind of the logic being used by the pro-aborts: Someone else is using something that belongs to me, without my permission (though that argument really only applies in cases of rape or incest), so I should be able to prevent them from using it, at my own will, at any time, no matter how much they're depending on it, even if it's to sustain their own life.
This is absolutely wrong! these are lies
@KD214_
Жыл бұрын
It’s so sad to see this. What a shame.
@UncleGhoulieTv313
Жыл бұрын
@@KD214_ Did you expect anything less of Christians? Their entire faith is based on lies.
I shared!
Too long of a video. Why didn't the creators and those on the other side do a joint video? Debate it! This proposal will win by a landslide.
@timothycassady52
Жыл бұрын
If a 21 mi ute video is too long for you why do you think a debate would be any shorter? Your post leads me to believe you really want to take the time and do the research. Most people aren't. They prefer to take the word of those who are set to make millions of dollars killing children in the womb.
@Terry-te1ij
Жыл бұрын
SIck if this passes. Voters need to know the following if Proposal 3 passes: It would eliminate parental consent for minors for abortions or hormonal birth control or even sterilizations. It would make it easier for molesters to cover up their crimes because those aiding a young woman getting an abortion cannot be questioned. There could be unregulated abortions by non-doctors. It would deny medical care to premature babies, who with a bit of aid will survive and thrive. It will force tax-payer funding of abortion on demand. Many people who self identify as pro-choice see that Prop 3 is toxic!
@realistit4488
Жыл бұрын
kzread.info/dash/bejne/qJplpqmneKmYhNI.html
Thanks