You could have mentioned the fact that Ashkenazi and Sephardim also come from the same ancestral lines as the Mizrahim. We're Judean first, and should not be defined by where we were forced to form our shtetls.

@jeanbrown6117

3 жыл бұрын

Numbers 12:1 NIV

@SigalDa

3 жыл бұрын

@Bob De Baviaan again the khqzar myth?

@SigalDa

3 жыл бұрын

@Bob De Baviaan yes what evidence? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@xoxlove6101

3 жыл бұрын

@Bob De Baviaan so a made up bullshit, all antisemites are the same

@ran52475

3 жыл бұрын

@Bob De Baviaan yeah and German academia also provided plenty of evidence for their Nazism, just jump to explaining our Satanic blood already

there are 2 million arab citizens in Israel. not one million.

@nonebusiness2023

3 жыл бұрын

They're really bad with their research they screwed up on that and by claiming that Arab attacks on you started in 1920 when there were multiple massacres in the 1800s in places like Hebron

@Nicolay406

3 жыл бұрын

@@nonebusiness2023 there were anti semitic attack since the Jewish diaspora but that's not the case right now.

@johns22

3 жыл бұрын

@@nonebusiness2023 Can you provide the specific year and specifics of the Herbron massacre in the 1800s?

@nonebusiness2023

3 жыл бұрын

@@johns22 1773 or 1775 blood libel dozens of jews killed The 1834 Hebron massacre occurred in early August 1834 12-40 jews killed (depends on sources) theres an other smaller one that happened before 1929 one cant find happened somewere between around 1800s further in 1700-1800 multiple recorded murders in Hebron of jews also further .

@johns22

3 жыл бұрын

@@nonebusiness2023 "The 1834 Hebron massacre occurred in early August 1834 12-40 jews killed (depends on sources) " Who was the aggressor? Was it the Palestinians? Who were the main target of aggression? Were they the Jews? Who suffered the overwhelming share of the casualties? Were they the Jews? While we are still on the topic, who were the majority inhabitants of Hebron by far at that time? Were they the Jews? What was the origin of the Jews of Hebron in the 18th century? Were they descendants of the ancient Jews who never left Hebron?

@4:43 - When was the last time the Palestinians held an election?

@betsyboomstein5393

3 жыл бұрын

A long time lmao

@iDarkBladei2

3 жыл бұрын

More importantly, why didn't they have an election for so long? Mainly because of internal political disagreements. Don't forget that hamas, a recognised terrorist org., is also very much a part of all this.

@saberh2981

3 жыл бұрын

I wonder y let’s see maybe israel occupation legit last week israel tried to make Abbas cancel them an occupation shouldn’t have a right on it’s opressed elections

@topmog

3 жыл бұрын

@@petarjovanovic1481 Where on Earth do you get that? Arab Israelis DO vote in Israeli elections, they have voted in previous Palestinian elections AND they will vote in the upcoming Palestinian elections, just google up "Jerusalem Arabs to participate in Palestinian elections".

@iDarkBladei2

3 жыл бұрын

Not knowing is ok, but not willing to know, that's stupidity, and it's dangerous. There have always been Arab parties and Arab Knesset members. Granted, it's not enough just to be able to get elected, because there have never been an Arab party in the government, but at least Israel is truly democratic, and the elections are held properly, which gives the Arab population a chance to be represented and so on...

Wasn't it President Jimmy Carter who introduced the concept of apartheid as it applies to Israel? I remember hearing that he said that the title of his book "Peace, not Apartheid" wasn't meant literally, but was only meant to be provocative. The concept caught on like wildfire, however, around the world.

@gerberjoanne266

2 жыл бұрын

@Tarna Motato Did you mean "biased"? If so, I agree with you.

@gerberjoanne266

2 жыл бұрын

@Tarna Motato Easier said than done, as there is a lot of blame to go around, not only to the Israelis, but also to the Palestinian leaders who lie to their public and divert foreign aid to weapons and Swiss bank accounts.

@SafetySpooon

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I was disgusted with him & will never forgive him, especially since,when he was called on it, he never took it back.

@gusgrow9768

2 жыл бұрын

No it wasn’t it was first used by Hendrik Verwoerd the architect of South Africa apartheid. There also has been numerous Israeli PMs that have said that Israel would become a an Apartheid state long before Carters book.

@gusgrow9768

2 жыл бұрын

No you are wrong multiple Israeli PMs said that Israel was heading towards apartheid long before Jimmy Carter wrote that book. Nelson Mandela famous aparttide anti-apartheid Activist from South Africa called it apartheid before him. I believe it was a white South African president in the 70s that was the first person to call Israel an apartheid state.

This video makes it out as though Israel's presence in the West Bank is simply for security reasons . . . what about the settlements?? Obviously the situation is nowhere near as bad as in South Africa, but it seems pretty clear that in the West Bank (and East Jerusalem), your ethnicity determines what rights you have. Israel-with the strongest military in the region and the US by its side-has effective security control of the entire area between the Mediterranean and the Jordan. Within this territory, all Jews have the right to vote, move freely, etc., while most Arabs do not. "Apartheid" is a legal term and does not only apply to South Africa.

@josephloiselle7016

Жыл бұрын

Yes. It's especially obvious if you look at the fact that Palestinians have to constantly go through checkpoints just to move around within the West Bank. The Palestinian areas in the West Bank are essentially Bantustans. If Israel doesn't want to be an Apartheid state then they have to grant citizenship and voting rights to all Palestinians in the West Bank, but they won't do that because then there wouldn't be a Jewish majority.

@alexvisser4542

Жыл бұрын

'To equate what is going on in Israel today with South Africa when South Africa was under Apartheid laws is a gift to Israel' Noam Chomski

@drdonna4915

Жыл бұрын

Read up on what happened to land ownership and occupancy in Judea and Samaria. Under Jordanian control, Jews were forced out of their generational homes. While they still owned their property, they couldn't live there and had to rent their property (that's what the fuss was a couple of years ago - nonpayment of rent). Jews purchased land and became the owners. If Muslims can live in Israel, Jews should be able to live in the territories.

@theoshouse8215

Жыл бұрын

@@drdonna4915 I guess ideally everyone could live everywhere. The issue is that Jews have the right to vote for the government that occupies and controls the West Bank (Israel), and Palestinians lack this right due to their ethnicity. And it’s not like the settlers are peaceful cohabitants. The Jordanians’ injustice doesn’t justify the Israeli occupation.

@shainazion4073

9 ай бұрын

The only state/country that has any claim to the West Bank is Israel under International Law. The law of *Uti Possidetis Juris* is the way new states are created. There has Never been a Palestinian State or country in all of History. The Jewish state was approved by Unanimous vote of the League of Nations in 1922 when the Mandate of Palestine was created to *_"reconstitute the Jewish homeland in the Area of Palestine"_*

Will the human right watch acusse islamic countries of appartheid against their non muslim minorities which is actually true apartheid....

@Anne-zt2dz

3 жыл бұрын

The difference is religious oppression and ethnic cleansing. Both horrible but the second one is what makes it apartheid.

@NortheastIndiaindetails

3 жыл бұрын

@@Anne-zt2dz what happened to Kurds, yazidis?

@DogesBasement

3 жыл бұрын

@@Anne-zt2dz Where do you see ethnic cleaning? And what's the difference between religious cleaning?

@blackmamba6253

2 жыл бұрын

@Mujtaba Gillani Every single islamic country as per their sharial law non muslim minorities are considered second class citisens and dont have the same rights like the muslims do ,second proof for apartheid in islamic countries is treatment of women who are segregated and oppressed....

@blackmamba6253

2 жыл бұрын

​@Mujtaba Gillani I lived in a islamic country....And visited few others....Segregation of women ,persecutuion of non muslim minorities i witnessed it all ....

The examples this video gives connected to apartheid are a problem in Israel proper. Intermarriage: Since religious government authorities control marriages, Jews cannot marry non Jews without one of them converting or going abroad. If a Jew tries to convert, the religious government authority makes it difficult and these people are often contacted by "anti-assimilation" groups. Jobs: Since Palestinians with Israeli citizenship don't get drafted, they are barred from jobs that require high government clearance like being pilots for example. Different land: The Israeli government gives preference to Jewish farmers who have more access to land despite Palestinians with Israeli citizenship being more likely to live in rural areas. The government is also less likely to approve building permits for them. Besides this, Israel is very clear that it will profile people for security checks so even in Israel proper Arab citizens are more scrutinized by security.

@GeoffSh4rt

2 жыл бұрын

"If a Jew tries to convert, the religious government authority makes it difficult and these people are often contacted by "anti-assimilation" groups." Name a single israeli Jew who's been contacted by an "anti-assimilation group".

@stevenv6463

2 жыл бұрын

@@GeoffSh4rt I searched online and found an article in two seconds about Lehava. They contact people's families if someone is dating a Palestinian. They mentioned Matan Amichai sending people's information to the group. They also mentioned a police officer who was contacted.

@stevenv6463

2 жыл бұрын

@@GeoffSh4rtSaying Israel is not apartheid because of SA is like saying the Armenian genocide was not a thing because of what Germany did. Lehava is not a government authority but many government officials contact them. I know of someone whose teacher told Lehava about something to their parent and it caused a lot of issues for her. They don't just talk to girls. They also contact their families and get them into physical harm. Palestinians don't often volunteer for the army and when they do, they are often denied. Look at the percentage of farmers by race and who has more land. One of the stated goals of the Israeli land authority is to give more land to Jews.

@GeoffSh4rt

2 жыл бұрын

@@stevenv6463 You seem to think that ANY form of discrimination against a minority group warrants the epithet 'apartheid'. In that case you must think that the UK is an apartheid state because it certainly discriminates against Jews and other non-Anglicans. The national flag, for example, has a ruddy great cross; it doesn't have a star of David. High ranking members of the Anglican clergy have an automatic entitlement to sit in the legislature. The same right is not accorded to Jews. Christian festivals are national holidays; Jewish fewstivals aren't. Is that aprtheid? If not, why not? Name a government official who contacted Lehava - and by 'government official' I mean someone in a position of power, able to influence government policy. And the official Lehava website makes clear that they only contact girls. Israeli Arabs, I repeat, are enlisting in ever increasing numbers - and they're reaching very high positions. Check out this statement. Apartheid is all about legally enforced discrimination. If Jews have more land, what is the legal basis? Is it conceivable that they have more land simply because they're richer? And I copied this from Wikipedia. Israel Land Authority’s functions According to the Amendment 7 (2009) of the Israel Land Administration Law (1960), ILA’s functions are as follows. Allocation of land for housing, affordable housing, public housing, employment, open space allotments and for other purposes in locations and amounts required for the needs of economy, society and environment, including future needs; Land acquisition and land expropriation for the state according to the law, primarily for environmental purposes; Protection of rights of land owners in Israel; Promotion of registration of real estate rights in the Land books of Israel; Provision of services to the landholders in Israel as required for management and implementation of their rights; Publication of information about Israeli lands, including details on agreements made by the Authority regarding lands it manages, and data on the availability of planned Israeli lands for development and maintenance of open space territory; Any other function related to the Israel land management imposed upon it by law or by any governmental decision. Where, outside of your Israel-hating imagination, can you find "one of the stated goals of the Israeli land authority is to give more land to Jews."

@stevenv6463

2 жыл бұрын

@@GeoffSh4rt First you say any Israeli Jew who was contacted and now you say any government official. What will you say next? It is only apartheid if Netanyahu called them. Why does every single Israeli argue this way? Also I don't care what is on your flag or anyone else's.

One million arab citizens ?? Try 2 million... and I am a pround one of them. Proud of both. Being an Israeli and being a distinctly levantene arab.

@UNPACKED

3 жыл бұрын

You are correct! This was an error on our part that we missed during the review process for all our videos.

@Nehmi

3 жыл бұрын

1.6 million or so

@mjohn5921

3 жыл бұрын

@@Nehmi no. 2 million.

@coreyslater2801

3 жыл бұрын

do u think that your ancestors, were once jews who converted centuries ago?

@mjohn5921

3 жыл бұрын

@@coreyslater2801 Ancestry is an opposite tree. It gets more complex as you go further back. Yes it's possible.

Actually the security wall is only 5 percent of the border , the border is a fence

@seanpermann5570

2 жыл бұрын

The border is nothing more than a demarcation of two different societies as well

@idokonak451

2 жыл бұрын

@@seanpermann5570 And Palestinians can go checkpoints freely as long as they don't carry something to attack with

Calling an Apartheid a necessity doesnt makes It less than a Apartheid, And ignoring the settlements problems with internacional law And how the campaign for them was made in israel makes me question the intention of this video

@Anne-zt2dz

3 жыл бұрын

Right! No one claims that it is the exact same situation but it has a similar ethnic oppression.

@1060Pearl

3 жыл бұрын

This is pure propaganda. Not even trying to show two sides. It glosses over the fact Israel has the worlds 4th largest army and has nukes...yet they fear for their protection? Hmmm. Call it what it is. Colonialism. It’s a big mess on both sides and neither side is particularly good. As a US citizen I don’t want my tax money funding any sort of oppression. That should be my right as a tax payer. We got plenty of our own stuff to deal with.

@missLunatic7

3 жыл бұрын

@@1060Pearl to say israel doesn't have to be afraid is nonsense . When you have terrorist blowing up buses and places or trying to stab people , i bet you will be afraid . When hamas is shooting rockets into your country , sending fire kites or bomb balloons, will you be okay with that? Yes israel is strong but it's because we are afraid for our own safety. By the way i am an israeli . Ps. About your tax money , you are right . If you don't want that money to go to other countries that's totally acceptable .

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

@@Anne-zt2dz Haas is getting money from China.

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

Fine, let's call Apartheid a necessity. They want all Boers dead.

2.1 million Arabs in israel not 1 million

a lot of missing missing reasons in this video

as a South African of colour and a student of our Apartheid history and yours, I must say that if you (disingenuously) simplify Apartheid to your description here, you will never be able to understand the comparison. Apartheid does not simply mean one state, one government, with unequal laws for its citizens. The foundational bedrock of Apartheid were the Bantustans and the Pass Laws. The Bantustans were semi autonomous regions, similar to Area B in the West Bank). All black South Africans were deemed to be citizens of the Bantustans. They did not have citizenship of South Africa proper. Apartheid rendered South Africa into a federation of regions under the supreme power of White South Africa. Black people could only enter and reside in White South Africa with a pass. In reality the Bantustan governments had no power at all. Brown South Africans however were allowed to live in White South Africa, but as very much disenfranchised second class citizens. The UN (of course) never recognised the Bantustans, but SA continued with the ridiculous charade. SA took over Namibia after defeating the German colonists there in WW1. When SA became an Apartheid state in 1948 they implemented the Bantustan policy there as well. They held on to Namibia until 1989, ostensibly for security reasons, much as Israel does with the Occupied Territories. The West Bank and Gaza are Bantustans, in everything but name. Apartheid is intricate, both in SA and Israel. So when you reject your opponents challenge of Apartheid, it is because YOU do not understand the intricacies, not them. Study the intricacy of SA Apartheid and your situation in Israel will be illuminated to you .If you actually want equality for all Palestinians (as your videos often claim), and this even possibly in one state with regional powers. Well, that one state already exists, de facto if not de jure. It is already a federation of semi autonomous regions under the supreme control of Israel. Start by recognising the massive discrimination Palestinians live under in that one de facto state, both in the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem Banstustans, and even within Israel proper. And when a member of our delegation at the ICJ stated that Palestinians live under a worse form of Apartheid than we ever did, it's true. Separate roads for Palestinians and Jews?! Even in our darkest days we never had such a thing!

@sh3ryn

Ай бұрын

Separation wouldn't have happened if your darling Palestinians weren't suicide, murdering, graping, kidnapping and bombing Jews. Dividing West bank came after jordan withdrawal from judea and samaria those so called Palestinians in West bank are jordanians Israel is even merciful and patients to those terrorists who want to kill them any time they get. Israel citizens in West bank use different routes for protection and fire of being murdered, Palestinians are allowed to enter Israel for work, visits, and using Israel airports but Israel Jews can't go to Palestine part for fear of being murder, Israel provide food, health care, jobs, security, water, electricity to Palestinians but they are still ungrateful it's not Israel fault that they love their people so much they will do anything to protect them even if it means to bulid a big wall. And for gaza Israel is not their and doesn't govern their it's hamas if we are to go by your explanation of apartheid it Palestinians doing aparthied against Israelis not the other way around. And anyone who has ever read southafrica history knows the condition black southafricans went through is no way near what Palestinians put themselves into. Bye the way am African and we were taught history of southafrica as a subject of it's own so I know very well what southafrica was stop this bs.

As a black South African, the division between Arabs and Israelis hurts my heart. It may not be the exact same circumstances that black, Indian and mixed race South Africans had to endure, but the discrimination and judgement based on ethnicity produces the same result. Division. “Apart-hood”. Any sect or group that is discriminated against based on ethnicity is a form of apartheid. Don’t minimize Apartheid by picking on detail of ethnicity rather than race. Discrimination is discrimination.

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

So "Kill the Boer" therefore "Kill the Jew?"

@VajrahahaShunyata

3 жыл бұрын

The Jews were originally buying what was considered the least desirable land. At ridiculous prices making the Arab landowners extremely rich. In the Middle to late 1800´s this land was devoid of people. Mark Twain and many other people who visited wrote about it. Including the Arabs living in the Levant. All the towns and places of old having crumbled to dust was the exact phrase the ottoman ruler of the time said. After ww1 this Ottoman Empire was crumbling and the ruler sent two populations from around 🇹🇷 To populate the area. This was a reaction to the British n French dickheaded colonial meddling into the levant.(I use this neutral old name for the area as it has national ambiguity). He wanted to Arabize the region to combat the influx of Jews escaping persecution in Europe. Arab pride was already stinging from their loss of Empire status after ww1 and there was a rise of militias and infighting for the power vacuum. This plus Britian promises the land to at least 4 different peoples. There is a crazy sheik who leads several attempts to drive the Jews out of land that the bought. They did not steal anything at this point. Britain is unable to squash this uprising of Arabs. In the beginning it was Arab Aggression. They ask the newly formed UN to step in. They do. They decide to create a 2 state system with the Arab population getting 75% of the land and the Jews getting a small and mostly barren 25%. The Arabs get practically all the good land. Everything green and fertile other than a few places in the desert that were being slowly turned green by Jewish hard work and ingenuity. The Arabs said no. They don’t want peace. The entire Arab population said no. They started to kill and persecute Jews in Arab lands all around the Arab nations. The Jews were escaping persecution in Europe and suddenly had to escape persecution in 90% of Islamic lands with a small few notable exceptions. This created another mass immigration to The levant. The Arab nations said that they were going to wipe out the Jews. Many Arabs were told to leave their homes because it was all out war. The Jews at the time often pleaded with their neighbors to stay. The dictates of Jihad do not allow Muslims freedom of thought though do they? If you quit it’s a death Sentence, this it truth. Apostates are to be killed. The Arab forces lost. The areas that supported the Arab attempt to kill all Jews were subdued and those are the areas that had the population pushed out. Strategic importance places. It’s survival at this point and an absolute miracle that the Jews are still alive. They declare independence. The un brokers a new deal. The Arabs say no. This time 8 Arab nations get involved to wipe Israel off the map. Miracle again. Israel wins. This time they take the Gotland heights because it is strategically necessary and the Sinai because Egypt was a little bitch. The cries for death to Israel have never stopped. They teach it to their toddlers. They never stopped attacking Jews. They still talk of slitting the throats of their children. Have you even seen their pro martyrs propaganda on tv and in their music? Over the years in this horrible situation the people of Israel have given land back as a move towards reconciliation. Every time the Arab population uses it as a launching pad for the next jihad. This portofrei responsibility is almost never mentioned in western media. If you don’t research deeply you would never know. The Palestinians have been horribly used by the other Arab nations. They were never granted any form of citizenship by any Arab nations. They are used as human shields. They are sacrificial lambs in the name of Islamic pride. The works tries to help and has givin billions in aid to help our Palestinian brothers and sisters and the money is always diverted to more military and terrorist activities while the Palestinians live in squalor. A martyr assembly belt churning out bodies in a suicidal infantile rage against a lost cause based upon false narratives. I know for a fact that Israel would have let you live in peace if you stopped killing their children. That was decades ago. Now you are pushing them into no longer wanting to give you another chance. And the truth? Why should they? You want to destroy them. You don’t want them as neighbors. And you are willing to die to prove it. You will even get honored because your culture loves martyrs above peacemakers. I have read the entire Koran several times. It’s a book of peace. Until the end. And the end is war. And the end supersedes. That is why the Palestinians are committing suicide for the tell-lie-vision. Look at us😭 Victim 😥 Never any accountability.. It’s not even on the Radar of your culture. You are immune to empathy as a whole. Not everyone. I know peaceful beautiful Muslims. But as a whole. You are war. Until we are all under the yoke, right? It’s definitely in your book.

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

@@VajrahahaShunyata When Grand Sheriff Hussain called a jihad on the Ottomans, what Palestinian came as Jews from though out the Middle East to join Sheriff Faisel 's army? Palestinians are Turks. Maybe Israel should recognise Kurdistan.

@evanriley74

3 жыл бұрын

The Jew isn’t even supposed to have a country till their messiah comes. So no it isn’t truth.

@bambabomba1407

3 жыл бұрын

@@VajrahahaShunyata The moment that you don’t mention the Balfour declaration and the saix pico accord, it means you have no idea what your talking about.

I'm new to the Palestinian/Israel topic, as an American that previously didn't pay attention to it because it seemed too neverending snd complicated. But now I am looking for fair and factual information. I just saw a recent video about "apartheid in Israel" and now I'm watching this one which seeks to dispute the claims. I have some questions and comments:

@ec6621

3 жыл бұрын

1) this video insinuates in the graphic that the origin of attacks were largely from West Bank and the places of attack were largely towards the cities along the shore thus the wall is justified, for security reasons. But... that doesn't make sense to me because missiles can fly over walls; people do not. So it makes more sense to me that the wall is meant to separate (or isolate) people first and foremost.

@ec6621

3 жыл бұрын

2) Israelis are accused of land grabs and Palestinian displacement. So if Area C (blue), which you've said is Israeli led administration and security, is the *_majority of land_* in West Bank, then why does the fact that 90% of Palestinians are within Area A (red) & B (yellow) combined, matter with regards to the accusation of land grabbing? The map just tells me the vast majority of West Bank land is under Israeli control and Palestinians are crammed into smaller red areas. Red areas that aren't even contiguous. So unless they're Israeli citizens (which most Arabs aren't) their mobility is negatively affected and their rights reduced the moment they leave one red area (enter a yellow or blue area) just to travel to another red area. I don't know, guys... this map doesn't help in disputing accusations of apartheid. It... kinda confirms it.

@ec6621

3 жыл бұрын

@DKGames 1) Thanks for responding. Hmm, I have many more questions now. (Sorry if my questions are amateur). So the wall is for the purpose of Israelis controlling which non-Israeli Arabs can leave West Bank and enter Israel? Ok. 1a) Do those restrictions apply only to non-Israeli Arabs or non-israeli people in general (regardless of race or ethnicity)? I'm wondering if discrimination is based on ethnicity or nationality. 1b) Ok, if West Bank is considered eastern Israel and those non-Israeli Arabs have lived there for generations or their whole life, why are they not Israeli citizens? They're not Palestinian citizens. They're not Jordanian citizens. They're not Israeli citizens. It sounds like they're stateless. 1c) Since West Bank is just eastern part of Isreal, are *_no restrictions_* placed on Israeli citizens in West bank? For example, are Israelis allowed to live/work/travel anywhere in Israel including West Bank? And if non-Israeli Arabs aren't Israeli citizens, does that mean they're *_not allowed_* to work/live/travel anywhere? If so, how is this not apartheid??

@ec6621

3 жыл бұрын

@DKGames 2) Ok, so you're saying Palestinians weren't pushed into the red Area A's over time, they simply were living there the whole time. And the blue Area C's were free for the taking. So the Israelis claimed that land. 2a) But what about the spaces in between the red areas? If the Israelis took over those spaces, that's restricting access they previously had to each other in different red areas, since they're not contiguous. 2b) They previously had free access to the Mediterranean Sea, too, including Gaza strip. Now that's limited. 2c) It sounds like the Israeli rationale is "the land where your home is not built on is not privately owned by you". So the vast blue Area C which was previously shared public space is no longer public nor shared. This does sound like land-grabbing. 2d) There are over 2 million Palestinian Arabs living in West Bank, but 90% of them live in the small areas A and B. Yet the video says there's about 300,000 Jews living in the larger blue area C. This means for majority of Palestinians there's a little land for a lot of people but for Jews, there's a lot of land for few people. Sorry, I know it's a lot of questions.

@ec6621

3 жыл бұрын

@DKGames 1a) Ok, so restrictions into/out of West Bank are applied on basis of nationality; or should I say... on the basis of NON-nationality, non-Israeli nationality. So are non-Israeli Jews ever restricted? Do we find the vast majority of those restricted non-Israeli's are Arab? By "these specific areas" do you mean *_all_* of West Bank; or just parts of it, like red and yellow Areas A and B. 1b) Well that's good if the Palestinians have the option to become Israeli citizens. That would at least give them a nationality/citizenship as opposed to being stateless. But why aren't they automatically Israeli citizens by virtue of having been born in that land, which is now part of Israel. As in: they were Jordanian citizens, and now they're Israeli citizens with full Israeli rights. 1c) By "these areas" do you mean only Areas A, within West Bank? Because the video showed that Israelis do indeed live in West Bank; Especially in Area C, where they outnumber the Palestinians. Ok, Palestinians can go in and out of Area A, but can they go in and out of West Bank to work, live & build, and travel? Even though Israeli's can't go in and out of Area A, they can go in and out of West Bank to work/live/travel, right?

The video omits a lot of facts. Just like the fact that separate type of IDs are issues for Jewish Israelis and non Jewish Israelis. These ids determines what rights you will have. Another fact, half the population in Jerusalem are denied citizenship because they’re not Jews. Israel is the controlling authority over the whole territory, but in territories where majority are not Jews, you have segregated roads and separate legal system. One of the population that perceives itself as the superior race, the other for the race treated as inferior.

@user-jn6rw3hf8u

2 жыл бұрын

So how 2 million Arabs get citzneship in Israel? 1.2 million of them stay in Israel after 48 war. How therr are Arabs representatives in the parliament of Israel? How they can be above jews and make laws for jews? How Arabs can be commander and boss of jews? The pa you talk about Israel offer them in 1948 israeli id they refuse it but still Israel give them residents rights they can travel, work, get and even give medical care to jews (my family doctor she is Palestinian) and they get social care and insurance from israel. There id is belong to country name Palestine it was created in 1967 qfter Israel was free Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria fro. Jordan in war. You really don't know what you talk about. Israel need to care about he own citznes Palestinian in west Bank and gaza are Palestinians citznes!! In aprtahid no Arabs can be above jewa, Palestinian are just Arabs that take a new identity in 1967. And still by the peace accords in 1995 Israel let them work, travel and get medical care in israel, israrl and Palestine is 2 states 2 Counties on the same land. If we talk about aprtahid why jews can't live in ramhalla, beit lehem, janin, nablus ecs, not to live not travel and don't work?? Its aprtahid right? NO CAUSE THIS IS COUTNRY NAME PALESTINE AND ISRAEL IS A DIFFERENT COUNTRY

@okyes5671

2 жыл бұрын

Wrong. There are no separate ids for non Jews in Israel. If there where why would there be Arab parties in the Israeli parliament? Where there black parties in the South African parliament? The people in Jerusalem are not “denied” citizenship. They refused citizenship offered many times by Israeli government. Israeli checkpoints and walls are not separation there boundaries between Isreal and the pa. Just like checkpoints along any other border in the world. Have you ever been to Israel? I suggest you go there and ask the people no one in Israel considers themselves “above” the Palestinians

@deborahfreedman333

Жыл бұрын

That's like saying the fact US citizens have a US passport, and Canadian citizens have a Canadian passport proves apartheid. Of course, those under PA control, have a PA justice system, and PA IDs.

@graceg3250

9 ай бұрын

@@okyes5671 I suggest YOU go to Israel and see how in some areas Palestinians are not allowed to even walk down certain streets, where foreigners and Jews can. How is it that a Palestinian born in Jerusalem is denied the right to visit from abroad while someone who’s Jewish (not even ethnically Hebrew…as the vast majority aren’t or even a practicing Jew) can easily show up to Israel and be given citizenship? You should see the petty harassment and contempt Palestinians face at the hands of Jews. Right now, many Jews are even calling for a “final solution” for Gaza. At least, there are some decent Jews who speak up against Israel.

Black South Africans weren't citizens of South Africa but of their respective Bantustan. Maybe try something different.

@amerikiwi8343

3 жыл бұрын

And only one country in the world actually gave legitimacy to those bantustans by recognising them as independent countries and letting them establish embassies. That country was Israel. The video forgets they were Apartheid South Africa's closest ally.

@theklorg305

3 жыл бұрын

Thats simply not true.

@solid7468

3 жыл бұрын

@@theklorg305 Maybe a little education.

@zaper2904

2 жыл бұрын

You do realize that by calling the west bank a Bantustan you're implicitly saying that its rightful Israeli land right? it can't be both a Bantustan who's "citizens" are actually the citizens of the country to which the land belongs to and its own independent organization. This isn't even bringing up how the PLO is widely recognized by the international community unlike the Bantustan governments and how as the video points out this agreement was reached in cooperation with the Palestinians.

@solid7468

2 жыл бұрын

@@amerikiwi8343 Good point.

Saludos chicos 🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡

But the question is why Israel has occupied so much land of Palestine?

@mugivamv3396

3 жыл бұрын

You mean all the West Bank part? Israel took it in the six days war from Jordan(Israel wasn't the one attacking first); it was a countermeasure. Each time Israel withdrew a little from some parts, they got dozens and hundreds of suicide bombers. Look at Gaza; Israel has nothing to do with it. There Isn't a single jew in there. Yet, Israel still get missiles flying at it.

@xyan819

3 жыл бұрын

@@mugivamv3396 I mean right from 1948 what was Israel's size and what's now. Am a neutral though

@mugivamv3396

3 жыл бұрын

@@xyan819 So...? Israel hasn't started any of its wars. Whether its territory increased or not - what does it have to do with anything? Perhaps you expect the attacked side to say, "Ah, here my friend, your territories back. Let's just forget you wanted to destroy." Plus, Israel has given some territories back for peace agreements - Jordan and Egypt for example.

@neozyykun

3 жыл бұрын

@@xyan819 the jewish state and arab state territories were described in 1947. The jews agreed to the un's two state solution establishing israel in 1948, the arabs rejected that offer and instead started a war. Right after the establishment of Israel, syria jordan egypt and others invaded israel seeking its destruction but lost the war Israel gained territory due to that war. In 1967 another war took place, this time Israelis were sure they're gonna lose but the idf successfully invaded egypt and managed to triple its size. after that another war took place in 1973 place against egypt and others and in the end Israel returned the entire sinai peninsula that's 3 times bigger than its actual size for peace with egypt. Long story short every time Israel has gained territory, it was because of wars and Israel has never started a war unless it had to. Its not israels fault that the arabs keep on losing wars

@dovidell

3 жыл бұрын

Jordan controlled Judea , Samaria and Eastern Jerusalem for 19 years , why didn't they " return " some of the " occupied land" to " its rightful owners" ?

Didnt you guys institute a nation state law or something? Enough with this BS

@midwestinyomouth

3 жыл бұрын

what are you talking about?

@TheCaniblcat

3 жыл бұрын

@@midwestinyomouth I think he may mean a law a while back that Israel in principle is a Jewish Democratic state. The law has no teeth, it was more an official declaration. Much like the UK's "official" religion is the Church of England, it's a declaration, not an enforceable law that requires conversion or expulsion.

@ItayAI

3 жыл бұрын

the first law ever established in the Palestinian authority claiming Palestine is a nation state their flag represents Islam and pan Arabism, most flags in the world represent the nation, most countries in the world are nation states, but they can still be democracies and respect all human rights as Sweden, Denmark and Finland are all nation states but when its about Jews it makes them crazy because they lived for years as the strong oppressors and the Quran promotes them to control the lives of the Jews.

@TheCaniblcat

3 жыл бұрын

@@ItayAI Well IIRC there is a law, I'm not sure if it's the Quran or just general Muslim law under the old caliphate that a. all land that, once owned by Muslims, is forever Muslim and cannot ever be ceded to a non-Muslim and b. all other religions are inferior to Islam and must declare subservience. In the old caliphate, Jews and Christian shad to pay a fealty tax that Muslims did not. The Jews were given a yellow start to show they had paid that tax. This is from where the Nazi's got their yellow Juden stars idea. Christians also had a symbol to show they'd paid the tax, but IDR what it was. The giving up land thing is still very much part of Palestinians law. In Area B, Muslims are by PA law NOT allowed to sell land to Jews. The penalty is up to and including death, though I don't believe the death penalty had ever been applied in such a case, but Muslims selling land to Jews is severely punished.

@jonlenihan4798

2 жыл бұрын

Doesn't affect birth citizenship. It's a statement of opposition to those who want to flood Israel with foreign Arabs.

Didn't Nelson Mandela say Israel is an apartheid state

@jeanmeeran1732

4 ай бұрын

Yes indeed, he said South Africa will never fully be free until the Palestiniansare free

@Wind-oh-Wishp

2 ай бұрын

No, he did not.

@ryanmoore2447

2 ай бұрын

@@Wind-oh-Wishp yes him and Desmond tutu both said it

@ryanmoore2447

2 ай бұрын

@@Wind-oh-Wishp and Israel were best buds with the apartheid south africa

Absolutely! Why ask questions you know the answers to?

Fishy to ask... Why Israel also gave full military support to apartheid South Africa those time? I mean look at every, some, South African equipment in which they are Israeli origin as well the blueprint design. Does it look so fishy if 'non Apartheid' Israel gave a lot of support to a extreme racist South Africa at the time?

@Summercamp1sland

Жыл бұрын

It also supports post apartheid South Africa

I’ve stopped listening to and responding to anyone who accuses Israel of apartheid.

@dovidell

3 жыл бұрын

@FREE MILO , you mean like the Syrians, Jordanians and Lebanese ? - what do you mean you've never heard of black September ? , you were do so well until now !!!! ( NOT )

@sumeyyeozdemir8135

3 жыл бұрын

@Eli C Israel is a terrorist country let alone being an apartheid one. Long live hell for the cruels!!!

Let me explain to you what they said in this video, I ‘m just going to change the names as ISRAEL= Russia , PALESTINE = Ukraine , in this current war russia wanted to annexate parts of ukrain as they said it was belongs to them , ukranian ppl reject this idea but Russia used the army and weapon to reach their goal , who will you sympathies with? Even the palestenian can’t live freely in their parts of the country , Britain is the one who gave the jews”nation” afterWW2 when Ottoman Empire falls, Palestine was always among its arab neighbourhood, Nothing called israel

@Mohammedsalo

Жыл бұрын

The sound of the truth

@sapphicwriter

4 ай бұрын

Notice how none of the people trying to justify apartheid and the dehumanization of Palestinians responded to this.

Bringing a South African to validate the legtitimacy of this video doesn't make it objective. Let's call it segregation of Palestinians instead of apartheid. Does it make it better?

@mosando

3 жыл бұрын

Then they are gonna bring an old school American Segregationist saying it's not true segregation

@mikihay

3 жыл бұрын

How is it segragation . Prove ur claim

@israarayya2358

3 жыл бұрын

@@mikihay Roads built only for use of the Jewish settlers, maintaining a 60/40 Jewish majority in Jerusalem, even Human Rights Watch called it an apartheid so please educate yourself through reliable sources before talking, because i can keep on talking about the segregation

@yali2926

3 жыл бұрын

It makes it less of an anti Israeli propaganda so yes. Anyways, I don't know where you're from but I doubt your country will let terrorists move freely within it's borders. If they're so innocent, why wouldn't their Egyptian brothers and sisters let them in through their shared border with Gaza? Or maybe Jordan? Same reason we don't.

@israarayya2358

3 жыл бұрын

@@yali2926 Fun fact: The IDF was founded on militia groups that were trained by the British mandate, but then these groups turned on them and started "resisting" the British mandate by performing terrorist acts to kill both British soldiers and Palestinians (The Hagana, Ergon dunno how it's spelled sorry). If the foundation of a whole army is based on militia terrorists, then I doubt your argument still stands.

There are actually 2 million Arabs and Arabs currently hold 20 seats in the 120 seat Kneset.

@ThiccPhoenix

Жыл бұрын

There should be ~24 but 20 is pretty close

Thanks for this video!

It's 2 million Arabs

I m ex-black muslim from Norway and pro Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱❤

@AbdulHamid-gx4dv

3 жыл бұрын

you can be ex-black in Norway?

@edimarkovich168

3 жыл бұрын

The world keep silence of arabs still owning black slaves.. also arabs were the slaves traders for centuriess

@thestruggleisallthatmatter8833

Жыл бұрын

@@AbdulHamid-gx4dv he’s a troll

I'm confused on one thing, though. Is B'Tselem being included in the reference to "extreme" critics? From what I can tell, that doesn't seem to be their reputation except among those who can hardly be considered neutral parties on the matter, I I'm certain that they're goal isn't the delegitimization of Israel. I also don't understand why relevant facts about the recent election in Israel weren't brought up. No small number of politicians can be a reflection on the state or the people at large, but you can't claim to have a representative government and deny that certain politicians represent a large enough portion of the population to have earned a seat in the representative body.

@sunshine6522

3 жыл бұрын

B'Tselem is in fact an extreme critic of Israel with the intention of delegitimizing it.

@OldMansWar

3 жыл бұрын

@@sunshine6522 So, you're saying it's an organization of anti-Israel Israelis? From what I can tell, the organization is trying to help Israel push closer to the ideal version of itself by reporting on the less savory aspects of it's actions and policies. In my view, that is a greater form of patriotism than ignoring the bad and focusing on, and exaggerating, the good; something which my fellow Americans do as easily as breathing.

@sunshine6522

3 жыл бұрын

@@OldMansWar Many Americans hate America and are calling it a racist country, haven't you seen the clips of BLM protestors chanting "death to America"? the same thing is happening in Israel, some Israelis hate Israel and are willing to collaborate with its enemies. constructive criticism is one thing- but working side by side with Israel's enemies is a completely different story.

@OldMansWar

3 жыл бұрын

@@sunshine6522 If we select the worst representatives of any group to represent the group as a whole, every group is literally awful. And given some of the new members of the Knesset, who promote hate and war crimes as well as turning Israel into a theocratic republic... Those kinds of criticisms, the sort you made of BLM and Americans with strong criticisms of their own country, are what ACTUAL attempts at delegitimization look like.

@sunshine6522

3 жыл бұрын

@@OldMansWar So you agree that there are some awful representatives in every group. what I'm saying is that B'Tselem is the worst representative of the Israeli society. nothing is worse than being a traitor to your own country and collaborating with those who are seeking Israel's destruction. it would be objective criticism if they focused on speaking to Israelis- instead of running around the entire world to smear Israel's reputation.

This is ridiculous and painful to watch, protecting its citizens? Can you tell me how many thousands have died since 2000?

@ItayAI

3 жыл бұрын

terrorists? some of them exploded themselves as a suicide bombers? this is not my problem

South Africa used also tried to justify it's system of apartheid....

This is pure propaganda with the narrator reinforcing the point ".. so this isn't apartheid" several times 🙄 no ones believing it anymore

@LuisDiuk

3 жыл бұрын

I hope you get sued for a defamation crime and hate speech, Israel gives full right to all its citizens, you just write "propaganda, no one believes" and you dont give any argumentation

@islammaynul9322

3 жыл бұрын

@@LuisDiuk FACTS

@LuisDiuk

3 жыл бұрын

@@islammaynul9322 LIES

@islammaynul9322

3 жыл бұрын

@@LuisDiuk so you’re telling me your comment is a lie, ok

@LuisDiuk

3 жыл бұрын

@@islammaynul9322 You prove yourself to be a narcissist manipulating the verbal linguistics. First comment says "this is propaganda", then I comment to this denouncing it because it just calls the video propaganda without actually providing any argument. And then you come and say "facts" to which I answer you "lies". You expose yourself as defamator, narcissist and manipulator

How can you call Israel an "apartheid state" when it is plainly not? Arabs are not forced to live by themselves, but they PREFER to live by themselves. They prefer to send their children to Arabic speaking schools, whereas Jews send their children to Hebrew speaking schools. Arabs prefer speaking their own language, Arabic, whereas Jews converse in Hebrew. Arabs choose to pray in mosques, not because they are forced to do so, but because Islam dictates to them where they should pray. Jews pray in synagogues. However, in other things we are all the same. We ride the same buses; we are cared for in the same hospitals, and we purchase goods in the same stores and supermarkets. We also work together in many of the same offices and institutions.

Do u even believe your own propaganda?

@theklorg305

3 жыл бұрын

lol, imagine honestly attacking such a fair source as being propagandistic just because it disagrees with your agenda. Thats like calling Belgium an apartheid state because it doesn't treat Dutch as Belgian citizens, its absolutely insane. And of course, if you say something so crazy people will assume you're anti-Belgian.

@milangielen

3 жыл бұрын

@@theklorg305 but Belgium does…

@roeeparienty7365

2 жыл бұрын

What is the problem?your lies are getting exposed 😂😂

@gabriele4740

2 жыл бұрын

These guys don't seem to even realize how ridiculous this Israeli propaganda sounds

@Evantrop

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabriele4740 Facts or duck off

hey can you guys make a video of moroccan jews ? ps. love your video's ❤❤

This propaganda conveniently forgots the part that area C covers 60% of the WB and only 18% of the WB has partial autonomy of Palestinianian governance.

@SigalDa

3 жыл бұрын

and in area c their is no paliestnians they are in area a+b

@christianriiselaursen3605

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah but basically No one lives in the "c" area

@zaper2904

2 жыл бұрын

only it does by pointing out that something like 95% of the Palestinians live in areas A and B why do you care who rules a mostly empty land?

@carlitosmexican7469

2 жыл бұрын

@@zaper2904 bc it has resources

I'm an American, I have lots of European Jewish friends, i honestly don't know very many Palestenians....i have always supported jewish people.... i am against the Nazis and KkK and other anti jewish groups. HOWEVER, it seems like Israel has become an aparthied state.... reminds me of south africa and the displacement of native americans on to reservations.......I can not continue to stand i solidarity with these EVIL acts of oppression and genocide!!!

@nhpkm1

2 жыл бұрын

I'm curious if you did basic research to arrive to your claims . Without googling : By what percent (% ) did the Palestinian population shrink (get smaller) since the formation of Israel (1948) . Formula : ("population at 1948" - "current population" )/ "population at 1948" %

4:43 No apartheid cus they govern themselves... Exept when there are also Jewish people who don’t feel safe. So you agree? You agree that Jewish people in Israel have an ethnic superiority by law... Like apartheid.

@solid7468

3 жыл бұрын

Bantustans also governed themselves in South Africa.

@alvarez6487

3 жыл бұрын

Yet, Israel still manages all aspects of their lives and like Apartheid South Africa they split and close the freedom of movement of the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza.

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

@@alvarez6487 killed a Boer.

@DogesBasement

3 жыл бұрын

What superiority? Tell me,or you're lying.

@SafetySpooon

2 жыл бұрын

@@alvarez6487 Bullshit. Why should Israel be the ONLY country who has to NOT have a secure border? Is Canada "apartheid" for not letting Americans in & out of the border at will? It's HAMAS who *manage every aspect of their lives* - get a fucking clue!

Thank you for this. I just shared in the comments of an UN* video which I saw about Israel being an apartheid state without no real sources to proof it... It's crystal clear you can't compare what's happened in South Africa with the situation of Israel.

@TheBigThinker944

3 жыл бұрын

So a man from gaza can freely walk into tel aviv as freely as an Israeli citezens from tel aviv can move around?

@mayanlogos92

3 жыл бұрын

@@TheBigThinker944 as long as he isn't a danger for *the people living there * I think yes. Oh, also... isn't there a board crossing? like for example I'm from Moldova & we have a board crossing between Moldova & Transnistria which is a separatist zone... it declares itself being autonomous (we also have such an autonomus territory in the south of the country called UTAG where Gagausians live that has it's own leader called a Bashcan) isn't kinda like the same in Gaza & West Bank? Idk... For example I was once in Transnistria, people from there have their own kind of passport, kinda like Soviet kind, currency and when we pass there is a check for strangers coming in, it's pretty strict getting in there... ik nothing about the other Autonomus Region which as I said is on south but they're pretty much checked from inside, from them.. I think I can't really compare between countries cs autonomus might mean for a part a thing and for another sth else, or imply some other things too, like additionally, as to their rules laws or even just customs

@scorest8601

3 жыл бұрын

That's why you won't work in the UN, you're dumb that's it. It's crystal clear that palestinians are under an apartheid rule, even the lacking morals girl in this video implicitly admitted it, she just said that they were just 10% who were under apartheid and so because it isn't 100% she doesn't consider it apartheid. You're hearing what you want to hear not the truth, if you honestly wanted the truth the last thing you would do is to check on it in an israëli youTube channel.

@octillionZ

2 жыл бұрын

@Saleh Nimer so were the scots who killed the english when they occupied scotland terrorists? How about the Americans before the war of 1776? The irgun and palmach were resistance fighters. Terrorists kill and destroy because they are hateful (ie hamas and islamic jihad) freedom fighters destroy and rarely kill to gain the independence (ie, palamach, scots, Americans, the koreans.)

@deep8049

2 жыл бұрын

. The Authors of the Amnesty International report have responded to this claim in their report: The report does not set out to compare Israel with South Africa under apartheid or to determine whether Israel is an “apartheid state”-a concept that is not defined in international law. Rather, the report assesses whether specific acts and policies carried out by Israeli authorities today amount in particular areas to the crimes of apartheid and persecution as defined under international law. Have you even READ the apart?

7 questions to ask a Pro Palestinian: 1 / Explain to me why you consider that it is Israel which took the land from the Palestinians, while it is Jordan which occupies 80% of Palestine? 2 / Explain to me why you consider it logical that Palestine should belong to the Palestinians, when it never occurred to you that Judea could belong to the Jews? 3 / Explain to me why, while an Arab can walk quietly in Tel Aviv and Haifa while a Jew who gets lost in Ramallah or Shehem (Nablus) is the object of a lynching, c is Israel you accuse of apartheid? 4 / Explain to me why you find it normal that there are Arabs living in Israel but it is unthinkable that a single Jew could live in a Palestinian state? 5 / Explain to me why it was only after Israel took Gaza from Egypt and Judea and Samaria from Jordan that you started calling them "the Palestinian territories"? 6 / Explain to me why the Palestinians never sought to create a state in these famous territories while they were under Arab rule? 7 / Finally explain to me why you disdain to answer these questions for fear of understanding that your unwavering support for the Palestinian cause against Israel is nothing other than the humanist expression of your disguised anti-Semitism? 🤔

@timelesshour8701

2 жыл бұрын

My answer: your god promised that land thousands years ago-how do we know? Well you guys wrote down--

@patriotsforisrael3610

2 жыл бұрын

@@timelesshour8701 The *Jewish people* are *indigenous* to *Judea* - Land of Israel. After over 2 millennia of forced exile, persecution, and genocide, the *(re)establishment* of Jewish sovereignty in our *ancestral homeland* is a remarkable story of *national liberation.* Jewish claims to the land are far more than biblical accounts. Our *religion, language, culture, holidays, rituals, liturgy, history,* and even the words Jew and Jewish are all inseparable from *historical Judea* and our collective longing to return to the Land of Israel. The land of Israel is where Jews became a people and the oldest monotheistic faith. It is where Jews achieved *sovereignty* before losing it and regaining it several times until much of the *indigenous Jewish population* was either killed or forced into exile following the *Roman Empire’s* brutal suppression of the heroic *Jewish revolt* in the second century of the Common Era. Though the Romans subsequently renamed the land *Syria Palaestina,* the Jewish people never left our homeland physically or spiritually. *Archaeological evidence* of Jewish life can be found in more than *30,000 sites* in Israel with antiquities dating back centuries. Even when we were massacred and persecuted by Christian Crusaders, Arab and Ottoman invaders, the British-led Jordanian Arab Legion, or more recently Hamas suicide bombers and rockets, our attachment never wavered. It is in this same land where Jews miraculously *revitalized* the Hebrew language, *rebuilt* the institutions necessary for independence, *re-engaged* in rituals that are uniquely observed in the land of Israel, redeveloped the land and the economy so that by several magnitudes the Jewish and non-Jewish populations grew, and offered refuge not just to the remnant which survived the Holocaust, but also millions of Jews fleeing persecution from the Muslim Middle East, Ethiopia, and the former Soviet Union. Today, Israel is a rich tapestry of *diverse* citizens, including over half of Jewish Israelis (who identify as Jews of color) and 20% of whom are Arab citizens.

@timelesshour8701

2 жыл бұрын

@@patriotsforisrael3610 My contention is that YOUR people claim ownership of Palestine through a book written by Jewish hands, claiming a super natural being told them of the promised land, this doesn't work with secular law. Also, your lost control of PALESTINE over 2,000 years ago to Greeks, the Romans and than to the Arabs. Plus, its in the bible (if its true) that "god" told Joshua to destroy the walls of JERICO, why is there walls? that means the Israelite STOLED the land from the natives of Palestine, the Canaanites? Israelites not natives, but the Canaanites are. Joshua 6 1-27

@patriotsforisrael3610

2 жыл бұрын

@@timelesshour8701 Syria Palaestina (later, Palestine) was a name given to the Jewish province of *Judea* in 135 CE by the Roman Emperor Hadrian who wanted to erase the Jewish connection to the land. Btw, The Romans also changed the name of Jerusalem to *Aelia Capitolina.* And no one uses that name today. Jerusalem will always remain JERUSALEM. And Judea will always remain JUDEA. Like it or not. Am Yisrael Chai! 🕎

@blueliar

2 жыл бұрын

If we go as per ur narrative that God Promised Land of Israel to Abhrambic doesn't that includes Arabs also.... As they are descendant of Abraham... Let's make it clear... U don't want anything but falsehood and narrative that fits u... And feeds ur ego ...u can have a thousand justification for the crimes u commits... No wonder God expelled u from the Promised Land and made u in Exile .... Or have the God Spoken again and took back the Exile And Honestly i don't care from whom that land belong to Jews or for the Arabs.. all i wish is there for a peace and harmony.. and for all communities to live peacefully.....

Facts

Spoiler Hell no israel is the only democracy in the middle east! U shoude come see yourself

So why then do you have football teams like Beitar Jerusalem, where an Arab has never been allowed to play? Israel hasn't even had the equivalent of Jackie Robinson.

@ItayAI

3 жыл бұрын

its a private club and their own choice the captain of the Israeli football team is Muslim so you cant claim there is a segregation

Amnesty international called out Israel for being an apartheid state. That’s all what needs to be said

@Mouse01011

8 ай бұрын

And they are wrong. checkpoints and walls had to be built to protect Israelis from constant bombardment coming from Palestinians and their allies who do not want Jews anywhere near them and who call for Jews to be exterminated. Don’t be fooled by Hamas propaganda and left wing propagandists. I am a die hard liberal and supporter of Israel.

@egodeosum

6 ай бұрын

@@Mouse01011 The invasion and hostage taking in October by Hamas was an act of terrorism. What is telling is Israeli leaders describing it as their 9/11, their pearl harbor, as an attack out of nowhere and a clear break from normal. Normal for Israeli's is living in a developed first-world democracy, with one of the worlds most advanced militaries and missile defense systems . It sells itself as a holiday destination. It was a break with normal them. Normal is the West Bank facing the indignity of occupation and the piecemeal theft of land. Normal is Gaza being one of the largest concentrations of people becoming increasingly nonviable as a independent state as it is blocked from developing, whose terrorised population did indeed turn to a violent and antidemocratic organisation. Normal is ineffectual rocket fire being met with bombardment; suicidal terrorism with regular terrorism. Normal is thousands of Palestinian men, women, and children under administrative detention. Israeli's dying at rates normally reserved for Palestinians is indeed a tragedy. There doesn't seem to be an acceptable response for the Palestinians other than to get with the programme and give up their land or die already. I would ideally point out to Palestinians that Israel is doing this to them and not Jews in general, but can you really fault them for accepting Israel's own rhetoric which equates the two, or that dismisses criticism of Israel as antisemitism? Isn't it the slightest bit gross to say "these people want to exterminate us" as you bomb Gaza once again to rubble? Some of Hamas' rhetoric and stated aspirations are vile , as vile as what Israel is practicing. Palestinians are an inconvenient people, who live in land earmarked for the Jewish homeland. Arabs paying for the sins of Europe. However pressing the need for a Jewish homeland, whoever was the initial aggressor, Israel decisively won this war a long time ago. It is like a person standing on the neck of another still ineffectually flailing at their legs with a knife, insisting they have no choice because if they get off obviously they'd attack them. Instead picking they pockets, and taking the flare up in hostility in response to this as further evidence of their unreasonableness. At some point you can either cease your hostility and indeed comprise your commitment to your security in the hope of peace, or just commit and crush their windpipe.

No mention at all of the occupation/blockade of Gaza??

@UNPACKED

3 ай бұрын

You can learn more all about that here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/gpt1049yj5e4qtY.html

respectfully, the overall thesis of this seems to be that because 'settler colonialism' and 'apartheid' are imperfect categorizations, they are necessarily invalid and that seems to be a bit of a smokescreen in and of itself....appreciate the thoughtfulness of some of the content on this channel though.

@UNPACKED

6 ай бұрын

Appreciate the respectful feedback. As you can see in our content, we don’t think everything is fine or that Israel is blameless or that there’s a simple solution. Sure it’s simple for people to throw around those terms, but they erase complexity, vilify Israel, and don’t work to address real underlying issues. That misconception is what we try and unpack on our channel.

6:05 Considering themselves 'God's chosen people' in the Bible isn't superiority over the Arabs?

@MP-lv5vk

3 жыл бұрын

It's a pact with God. But, you literally - according to the Torah - don't need to be Jewish to be good and virtuous. You could, in practice, simply follow Noah's 7 commandments without converting. Being 'chosen' isn't inherently a favorable position.

@Qualex14

3 жыл бұрын

Deuteronomy book 7 has the Abrahamic God clearly placing the people of Israel over all the other nationalities in the region, don't tell me they're not considered to be in a favorable position relative to other nationalities: Deuteronomy 7:1 'When the Lord, your God, brings you into the land to which you are coming to possess it, He will cast away many nations from before you: the Hittites, the Girgashites, the Amorites, the Canaanites, the Perizzites, the Hivvites, and the Jebusites, seven nations more numerous and powerful than you.' Deuteronomy 7:6 'For you are a holy people to the Lord, your God: the Lord your God has chosen you to be His treasured people, out of all the peoples upon the face of the earth.' Just to note, I'm an atheist that believes this is all superstitious bullshit, but am more than happy to live and let live so long as you don't try to enforce your beliefs on other people.

3 жыл бұрын

@@Qualex14 You are just repeating a medieval anti-Semitic slander. Disgusting.

@xoxlove6101

3 жыл бұрын

Chosen to uphold the bible and the laws God wrote in it, no other nation needed to do so, that is all we were chosen for. no one said anything about being superior- that is on you gentiles feeling inferior and stealing our religion

@xoxlove6101

3 жыл бұрын

@joshua c because of the transltion of the 70

I’m Jewish Israeli, and I love my Arab and Palestinian neighbors 🇮🇱🤝🇵🇸

@linoyc3479

7 ай бұрын

Well, they don’t love us too unfortunately. Full of hate to Jews

@twmax6525

3 ай бұрын

Does your government? 😂

@stormtrain11

3 ай бұрын

@@twmax6525 Why did you bring the government? I disagree with the government. I’m not the government

@twmax6525

3 ай бұрын

@@stormtrain11 Because it doesn’t matter what individual citizens believe or support at this point. The conversation is about government policies and how they affect the population. And it’s a fact that Palestinians have been persecuted for decades by your government and there is plenty of ample evidence for it. This video is misleading, and it’s a non sequitur bringing up who you love. There are also Israelis who hate their Palestinian and Arab neighbors.

@twmax6525

3 ай бұрын

@@stormtrain11 I’m just real pissed since my government in my name as a taxpayer (I’m an American) is now continuing to send your country billions in aid to continue what it’s doing. It’s not about who people hate and love, this is now just about right and wrong and holding the powerful accountable so that this is change. There will never be peace as things are now.

only haters will judge Israel immediately without the FACTS..shalom hatikva

@islammaynul9322

3 жыл бұрын

FACTS bro,

@basilkhalili9312

2 жыл бұрын

Try the book ethnic cleansing of Palestine by one of the most prestigious Israeli historians Ilan Pappe as a fact. Try the book Gaza by the son of holocaust survivors and one of the most fearless Jewish American professors in the US Norman Finkelstein as a fact. Try the thousands of reports and investigations that were issued by highly respected human rights organisation on the crimes committed by israhell like HRW as a fact. Why don't you go read a book instead of washing your brain with rubbish videos like this as a fact.

Palestinians need permits to move around. Are Palestinians allowed to live in Jewish Settlements? Palestinian athletes have difficulties securing travel documents.

@SocialSchism

3 жыл бұрын

You know there’s Palestinians living and working in Israel right?

@sunshine6522

3 жыл бұрын

Palestinians need a permit to enter Israel just as Canadians need a permit to enter Japan, its two different countries.

@kingbradley6000

3 жыл бұрын

@@sunshine6522 we're talking about israeli settlements in palestinian land, settler invaders can go into a palestinian home and just claim it as his own and the idf will look the other way and even encourage it.

@sunshine6522

3 жыл бұрын

@@kingbradley6000 That's simply not how it works... settlements are built on empty land- there's no such thing as going in and stealing a Palestinian home.

Yes there are two sets of laws and therefore Israel is an apartheid state. Of course it's not like South Africa in every way. Complete strawman.

Well, Nelson Mandela saw it as an apartheid, but I guess he is no expert on what an apartheid looks like so we will just ignore him.

@mrclass9083

3 жыл бұрын

your a legend

@roeebn5809

3 жыл бұрын

He is no expert on what Israel/ Palestine looks like, so yeah

@sardar388

3 жыл бұрын

@@roeebn5809 He's an expert on what it means to be the victim of an oppressor state, and that is why he could relate to the people of the State of Palestine who are being oppressed by the zionists.

@ItayAI

3 жыл бұрын

source: trust me bro

@roeebn5809

3 жыл бұрын

@@sardar388 still not valid because he has such small grasp on the actuallity of things here lol. I can send send you quotes from fighters against racism that mean nothing too. For example, Martin Luther king said "Peace for Israel means security and that security must be a reality". What is security for Israel? The wall that protects Israeli civilians and was built after the second intifada. The checkpoints between the borders of Judea and Samaria or the blockade of Gaza that aims to limit transference of arms to hamas.

The music makes this propaganda so much worse and unbearable.

Sounds like an apartheid lover defending an apartheid state. No justification necessary.

They're not only Apartheid they are also occupation.

I can't take this video serious because it is so biased and the fact that Israelis are so sensitive to criticism really doesn't help to have an honest dialogue.

Yes

yes

I am from South Africa and apartheid is Afrikaans for separation. It's a word, not a term or definition. It was just used by the western world to describe the segregation of races that happened under the National Party. And what's happening in Isreal is not Apartheid. It's the type of discrimination that is happening in Japan with relation to foreign workers and in the USA with black/African people.

@mansoor7571

3 жыл бұрын

U are on drugs a word carries meaning and it is the meaning that defines the word and U who has no element of understanding the history or fact or what is happening , in palistine it is quite ignorant to make a judgement , wake up dude we live in KZread world not in candle light era... I am sure press a button and knock and U shall receive and seek and shall find.... What is happening in palistine is worst than what happened in Africa , this is ethnic cleansing of a nation in the name of ante-cimitism..here people are killed if they do not accept tyrancy

@euanhamilton3471

2 жыл бұрын

@@mansoor7571 It is terrible but it is no apartheid. Apartheid was about the separation of races whereas, in Palestine, the Palestinians have many rights removed and are treated terribly, but Israelis are allowed by Israel to move to Palestinian areas, which is not segregation, rather a human rights violation). Also, it is very hard to compare the two because the treatment of black people in SA was different (and by many considered worse) than in occupied Palestine.

@yurichtube1162

2 жыл бұрын

@@mansoor7571 it's not worse. It's the arabs who created this issue. The jews are no longer weak and inferior. You are just shocked that Allah has chosen the jews over the arabs, that Mohammad might had been a liar and that you are in so much pain following islam.

@elisabethdakak878

2 жыл бұрын

What are you talking about? In the USA, all the local terrorists (BLM) are not jailed for the mayhem and chaos that they created. They destroyed stores completely based on the fact that their owners will be compensated by insurance. There is freedom in the USA, we need to live decently, and not destroy. There is a great number of mixt marriages in the USA, the schools are not segregated.

@user-jn6rw3hf8u

2 жыл бұрын

@@mansoor7571 how Israel is aprtahid? If Palestinians can work with the jews get medical care in the same place and even shop and eat in the same places with the jewz! This is exactly they problem you see edit videos and not the real life and you think its the true! And now to the Israeli arbas- the get represented on the parliament even i coalition, most of the doctors nurses (medications) and nurse in Israel are Arabs (however my own family doctor she is from east Jerusalem and I am jewish) , Arabs can work with jew, eat in the same restaurants, live on th same buildings, 81% of them serve in idf this no. Is bigger than than the jews (only 70%). And I can keep going! You never see on your social the kids that throw blocks and injured and even kill many innocent israelis, they even throw fire bottles,shoot and stab. When they throw blocks they get arrested for few hours! If hamas or PLO wand to figth israel they need to that by there own and not using kids and not to shoot and try to murder israelis. When hamas launch rockets its from citznes area in Gaza and directly to Israeli citznes area to kill us! Israel don't want go back to second intifada back than thousands explode and die even Arabs. However Palestinians and israeli Arabs can sit in the same bus /train with jews! Its not a crime israel protect her citznes Arabs and jews! 1.8 million Arabs live here and thousands of other minorities! I never saw idf hurt someone innocent and I live here not like you see only social

I admit some criticisms of Israel may be true (but I don't know enough), but claiming Israel runs "Aparteid" or "terroism" is definately "lying for the sake of a cause" - what we call "propaganda". Some people have an INCREDIBLY one-sided, impractical & hyper-partisan view on the Isael/Palestinian issue. Putting nationalism, rage or pity of oneself or others above all else, all practical realities - that is not a virtue imo, but creates far more suffering.

@gabriele4740

2 жыл бұрын

if you admit you "don't know enough", it implies you don't know enough to tell whether the accusation of apartheid is true or not, and you shall admit you may not be able to judge if others are "lying" or "incredibly" one-sided

@pebblepod30

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabriele4740 No it doesn't necessarily. It is (unlike you comment?) has some humility rather than rage & the arrogance that anyone who disagrees is evil or lying. Here is why i said that: (1) Most ppl are INCREADIBLY one sided on this and will accuse israel or palestians of anything. Do thus an accusation by itself means absolutely nothing, what else do you expect? (2) Apartheid is about race or religion, and restriction based purely on that, not for security. But Arabs do live in Israel and are let into the same places, correct? Sure they may get treated the same way by some ppl as Jews get treated in london or elsewhere by arabs. But apartheid? What is the evidence? (3) The wall and security measures are extreme to prevent terrorist attacks on civilians & also attacks on military. What is the alternative? Commit suicide for the sake of those whose hoal is thr destruction of Israeli?

@pebblepod30

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabriele4740 Your comment sounds insincere & like cheap shot by someone very polarized on the issue in who is all good and all evil. But i will Give you the benefit of the doubt, sp explain if you like, and how you know what you know. I may take a while to answer coz i go through msgs not that often. Thank you 😉🙏🙏

@abdillin

2 жыл бұрын

It's 100% apartheid dude

@pebblepod30

2 жыл бұрын

@@gabriele4740 i notice you didnt answer

And I have Dreams !!!!! The Peace in Middle East and in the World !!!!! And I have a Dream !!!! Two States Israel and Palestinia And I have a Dream !!!!! To see Palestinian official Army and Police working with Israelian Army and Police against terrorism coming from some palestinians and some israelians. And I have a Dream !!!!! To see the three religions of Abraham Judaïsme Christianisme Islam United for the Peace in the Middle East for the Peace in All the World !!!!!! Grand Bien nous Fasse pour cela !!!!! S'il plaît à Dieu !!!!! Amen Amine !!!!

@shainazion4073

Жыл бұрын

Your medication is making you hallucinate!

כל כך הרבה עובדות בסרטון אחד

"I am shocked by the claim that the free, diverse, democratic state of Israel practices apartheid. This ridiculous accusation trivialises the word apartheid, minimising and belittling the racism and suffering endured by South Africans of color." Rev. Dr. Kenneth Meshoe, Member of the South African Parliament. Claiming that Israel is an apartheid state is, therefore, a grave injustice to those who actually lived under an apartheid regime.

@ThiccPhoenix

Жыл бұрын

Yes I agree 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

@RC-qf3mp

9 ай бұрын

Too bad for you that Nelson Mandela loudly criticized Israel for being an Apartheid state, perhaps Mandela knows more about that than you do,

4:40 _"As a result of the Oslo Accords, Palestinians largely govern themselves, and vote to elect leaders of the Palestinian Authority government."_ The premise of Apartheid was to create a separation of the races. An _"apart-hood"_ where each ethnic group would be separated from greater South Africa, and be confined in areas or lands specifically designated for that ethnic group. These lands or "ethnic designations" were called _"Bantustans"_ and in these areas, Black people were told that these were their homelands, and they were allowed to (as you said), _"...govern themselves, and vote to elect leaders..."_ . Let me continue... 4:50 _"Israeli laws don't actually apply to much if the West Bank, except for certain areas with greater security risks or higher Jewish populations"_ In these *_Bantustans_* some had the priveleges like *_"Area C"_* in Israel had -they were self-governing. But the majority were *_"Area As and Bs"_* in that the Apartheid government had some control over them. Aside from this, there were areas once more designated for Black South Africans, called _"Townships"_ . These areas were the _"...areas of greater security risks..."_ that you mentioned, and were thus in the complete control of the South African government, and their inhabitants were subject to various restrictions and even curfews. One of the most hated of those controls was that inhabitants of these townships were not allowed to leave these areas with a _"pass"_ , which Black people had to have them at all times otherwise they would be imprisoned. They were also denied any access to live any else in South Africa except for the areas that they were forced to live in. All this echoes the same restrictions that Israel imposes on the Palestinians in the West Bank, thus making Israel's current enforcement of this system, an Apartheid one. You can try to justify your actions in the Occupied West Bank, but you CANNOT deny that Israel has enforced Apartheid in order to deal with your perceived problems in that region. in conclusion, Israel is an Apartheid state. In its entirety.

@xoxlove6101

3 жыл бұрын

You do know it's the Arab muslims who want a ethnic religious state- Palestine, and not Israel who has equal rights for its non Jewish citizens? You are so beyond biased your antisemitism is showing

@ytbgamer9380

3 жыл бұрын

@@xoxlove6101 israel does not have equal rights for non jews. In its laws it says it is the state of the jews. Also palestinians who live in parts of israel that are not occupied have less rights and can not move free or vote

@lu881

3 жыл бұрын

@@xoxlove6101 You do realise that Israel is an ethno-religious state too right? When you have OFFICIAL LEGAL policy saying that in Jerusalem, they want 60% Jews and 40% non-Jews. Your Zionism is showing. And don't equate my criticism of an Jewish Apartheid regime with hatred towards Jewish people. I have never hated Jewish people in my entire life. But I have always hated ethno-nationalists like the Zionists who run Israel.

@The___Gambit894

3 жыл бұрын

Are A and B are not Bantustans because they are independent and not part of Israel. They world wiews them as The State of Palestine. While "Bantustans" in South Africa were self governt but they were controled and were part of South Africa. And in South Africa blacks wanted to coexist with whites in the country as a hole while palestinians wanted to live in a country separated from Israel. Palestinians in West Bank and Gaza don't even wannna be part of Israel.

@yali2926

3 жыл бұрын

@@ytbgamer9380 Does Palestine has equal rights for Jews? If Palestine was a country would it allow Jews to vote? Why does it seem so obvious to people that Israel has to be a bi ethnic state and Palestine will be a Muslim state?

Israeli telling a Palestinian; “if I don’t steal your house someone else will”. This guy certainly knew that the laws were in his favour, so that 1 min video debunk your entire video

@germsage6726

3 жыл бұрын

He's not Israeli.

@ItayAI

3 жыл бұрын

fake al Jazeera propaganda the Jews in sheikh jarrah owned their houses in the 19th century the Palestinians stole it during the Jordanian occupation

unbelievably one sided this tactic ............... tragic the lack of humanity....................

@jesusislord3592

3 жыл бұрын

Imran your one sided view gets busted by facts. You obviously can't deal with it

@jesusislord3592

2 жыл бұрын

@Cric Tube Thank you 😊

I hear that “it’s complicated” but if you are trying to be balanced about your approach to these issues you should have some Palestinian youth speakers instead of only kids with Israeli flags in the background speaking if you want to be fair about this complicated problem that has gone on for far too long. Also you harken back to the Six Day War as why it all has to be this way in most of the videos. Does it though? Most of not everyone who fought in that war are long gone? Why does it still bind your hands from doing something? Finally the word Apartheid doesn’t belong to South Africa or any other country for that matter. It’s definition is a policy or system of segregation or discrimination on grounds of race. If that definition fits then the word can be used by anyone. You can’t culturally appropriate an English word. Also the speaker in this videos points out that South Africa was unjust to its own citizens while Israel is clearly being unjust to people they are militarily occupying who aren’t part of Isreal!? 😆 Seriously? Making a vid quibbling about stealing a word from another country may have been the wrong direction.

Im sure Israel treats the Palestinians very fairly and never does anything wrong

The young people who can accuse Israel of apartheid or deny the accusation are the neutrals, not the people who are biased towards Israel, like this woman who supports Israeli policies.

like from me

The answer: Yes but no

@xtelora8652

2 жыл бұрын

Yes but yes

@ozyurowitz2815

2 жыл бұрын

@@xtelora8652 no, but no

@deborahfreedman333

Жыл бұрын

Yes, only in those areas arabs control.

There is no such netionality as palestinian, palestine is a name of area , roman name that given to the area of Israel in 96, and the target of this was to erase the jewish history and to erase any evidence to the existence of jewish nation, Don't be stupid, this name given to JEWISH land, so technically the jews are palestinians, not arabs, tye arabs came there only in 636, and CONQUERED thhe land

Myanmar, former leader part did litte

Stop playing war games on pelestian's land and soil by Jew Israel will not recognise in pelestine country and middle East all pelestine country only for pelestian people not for Israel Why UN give two nations State in pelestine From today all news media does not discuss as a issue for Israel and discuss for pelestine country

@shainazion4073

Жыл бұрын

Please explain how the Ottoman Turk former Lands or the British Mandate lands, or the illegally annexed Jordanian lands ever were the Palestinian's lands. The British did a Land Survey in 1945, the Palestinian farmers owned 3.3% of the land. How does that make it Palestinian land??

@shainazion4073

Жыл бұрын

The UN gave nothing. It offered an idea to split the land, the Arabs said NO!! Therefore there was never a Palestine.

basically, if one's judging whether israel is an apartheid state or not based on what's seen on the most superficial level (as the video claimed, with "no context") then the result may seem like an apartheid state. In reality, occupying territories due to real secuirity risks is the moral thing to do. In fact, NOT occupying and patrolling those areas is immoral towards ALL of the Israel citizens (arabs and jews).

@_ee75

2 жыл бұрын

You mean the illegal Israeli settlements lol?

@yonatan3001

2 жыл бұрын

@@_ee75 Illegal by who's definition?

@_ee75

2 жыл бұрын

@@yonatan3001 fucking international court of justice and united nations lol

@yonatan3001

2 жыл бұрын

@@_ee75 what is their definition of illegal settlements?

@deborahfreedman333

Жыл бұрын

Since the only occupation of Yudah and Shomron, is by the ar abs, who invaded in 1948, and ethnically cleansed the place, only those areas controlled by the PA and Hamas are truly apartheid. The native people cannot live, or even travel there safely.

No it's not, this is their land. Long live Israel ❤❤❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇨🇦

I’m an atheist. I enjoy Christmas calling it purely a christian celebration is naive. And the same applies to Easter.

Short awnser no. Long awnser nooooooooooooooo.

this is pure bs

@slickrick2420

3 жыл бұрын

Why?

Thank you for articulating the situation so well. It helps give words where I, and am sure many others, have struggled to articulate our confusion and frustration when trying to clear this misappropriation/misunderstanding up when asked about it.

@saberh2981

3 жыл бұрын

You mean white washing the topic. And calling illegal settlers building more houses for them and settler colonialism as “security”?

@tamaralexander9379

3 жыл бұрын

@@saberh2981 NOt illegal at all as Israel didnt occupy a Palestinian state.

@saberh2981

3 жыл бұрын

@@tamaralexander9379 yes it is illegal coming taking over someone’s house and life and exiling them is ILLEGAL.

@tamaralexander9379

3 жыл бұрын

@@saberh2981 Yes indeed Jordan doing that to the Jews in 1948 was illegal.

@saberh2981

3 жыл бұрын

@@tamaralexander9379 but it’s ok for israel to do it palis GREAT TO KNOWW GOOD TO KNOW u not human. Inhuman

So your calling human rights extremes

the video doesn't explain that mizrahim moved here because the Arabs kicked them off their land, depriving them and their families of their historical roots just for being Jewish, now why should they feel sorry for the same Arabs here?

@saveUyghurs

3 жыл бұрын

There’s a little something called international laws now

You have done a very important and high-quality job here. Thanks for these important videos. I sincerely hope that young people around the world will watch them

@overvault

Жыл бұрын

watch what? The LIES? Just have to see your profile and subscriptions to know how an israeli, pro pisrael you are...

Does Israel Act as an Apartheid State? -- NO !!.

@dovidell

3 жыл бұрын

@jack rodgers So you've been to South Africa , have you ? , tell me about your visit to Soweto , then tell me about how in Israel , there are two lines for toilets , petrol and voting in Israel , one for the Jews , and the other for " infidels " - you CAN'T because apartheid DOESN'T exist in Israel

Please the music is distracting. For those who want to tear up the US constitution this is what it looks like. Chaos!

How do you then describe demolitions of Palestinian houses not only in east Jerusalem but also in the west bank while illegal Israeli settlements in the west bank aren't being subjected to the same? How do you describe those well constructed roads leading to settlements in the west bank, that the Israeli settlers can use freely but Palestinians have to go through poor roads laden with Israeli checkpoints, where they have to endure humiliation as the seek to be let through? This list can go on and on and on.........

@shainazion4073

Жыл бұрын

You obviously do not know enough avout the situation to comment if you ask these questions. The only "Palestinian" houses that are demolished are either illegally built or are owned by terrorists and their families. Israel has legal housing laws with permits and building laws, if you just build a house and ignore all the housing laws, the house gets demolished whether owned by Jew or Arab. Please explain how Israel building in Israel is illegal. Area C is fully under Israeli control, both by government and security. They can build up infustructure where they want. If the Palestinian Authority does not spend their money on roads, it is not Israels position to interfere. Checkpoints were established after terror campaigns. They were not there from the beginning. They stopped the terror by over 90%. Please, give more uneducated comments.....

@wambgujohn4074

Жыл бұрын

@@shainazion4073 I will still freely exercise my freedom of expression regardless of how it makes you feel. Given that nobody ever had the chance to choose their parents or even their place of birth, how would you feel if you were a Palestinian?

I am a Zionist but I cannot accept the evils happening to the Afrikaner in modern South Africa.

@dovidell

3 жыл бұрын

I visited the RSA , and the " locals" believe what you and I call " revenge" ( with government help - where else who farm attackers get military grade cell-phone jammers etc? ) , they call karma - like drowning innocent kids in baths full of boiling water is karma

@hashira3031

3 жыл бұрын

Go to south africa and stop getting your news on KZread

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

@jack rodgers supports murdet

@hashira3031

3 жыл бұрын

@@dovidell I'm a local and I call this bullshit, it's pointless arguing with someone obsessed about race but peace be to you...

@dovidell

3 жыл бұрын

@@hashira3031 I visited the RSA 20 years ago , and as beautiful as it was , I would never return , it's just too dangerous with the ANC in power

I ask the beloved lord the merciful the powerful the peaceful the beautiful the creator the healer the glorified the witness the hearer the viewer the owner of everything the wisdom the one who shall be glorified the one who accounts for everything even lesser than atom the unseen by humans unless in the day of judgment when he give the one who has given us the eyes and ears to hold us responsible the believers the right to look at him to punish those who demolish the accommodation of children and women’s and to do his justice I ask you Allah who knows the need of everyone I ask you not to make us like those of harmed their prophet Moses I ask you because you hear this call I ask him who protect Joseph in his prison the one who will return to Amen

@WHU63

3 жыл бұрын

The God who spoke to Moses in the desert said his name was YAHWEH. He also said in Exodus 3 that he was the God of Abraham, Issac and Jacob. Jacob became known as Israel because his twelve sons became the tribes of Israel. And from the tribe of Judah comes the Messiah, Jesus Christ. Christ is the word of God, the second person of the Trinity. His death on the cross was the final sin sacrifice and salvation is through Christ alone. Those who follow Allah deny Christ's divinity, or that he died for our sins. Allah is not God, nor was Mohammed a prophet.

@ashtondolce4446

3 жыл бұрын

Lol are you guys serious? Apartheid over some religion. RIP Humanity

@azaztoto8676

3 жыл бұрын

@@WHU63 first of all prophet Moses asked the lord to see him. Then the lord said to him look at the mountain and if the mountain stand unchanged Moses will see him. The mountain has been compacted to the ground and Moses has immediately prostrate. However, this story is discussed clearly in the holy Quran. The lord has said that all nice names and meanings is for him. ﴿هُوَ اللَّهُ الخالِقُ البارِئُ المُصَوِّرُ لَهُ الأَسماءُ الحُسنى يُسَبِّحُ لَهُ ما فِي السَّماواتِ وَالأَرضِ وَهُوَ العَزيزُ الحَكيمُ﴾ [Al-Ḥashr: 24] (24) He is Allāh, the Creator,[1666] the Producer,[1667] the Fashioner;[1668] to Him belong the best names.[1669] Whatever is in the heavens and earth is exalting Him. And He is the Exalted in Might, the Wise.[1670] [1666]- i.e., He who destined existence for His creation. [1667]- i.e., He who brings His creation into existence. [1668]- i.e., He who gives every creation its particular form. [1669]- Refer to the final paragraphs of the "Introduction" for a brief discussion of these attributes. [1670]- Refer to footnote in 6:18. - English Meanings Nevertheless, the messiah who was sent to Jews was Jesus the son of Mary ( he was with no father while Adam was with no father nor mother (All said in Quran). Jews has cheated prophet Jesus. However, they are awaiting the false messiah. In Quran Allah said that Messiah was not killed and he was raised to the skies, while another man was shaped like him and was Christ. Quran says that Jesus will return back before the end of the life. What you need to know is that Jews has cheated and killed many prophets. Prophet Mohammed is from the stream of Ismail the elder son of Abraham. Quran said did you hear the instructions of Jacob to his son to believe in the one lord ( the lord of Abraham, Ismail, Issac and Jacob).

@WHU63

3 жыл бұрын

@@azaztoto8676 You speak of what the Quran says about Moses. The Quran is the work of Mohamed who lived 2000 years after Moses. Moses himself wrote the first 5 Torah books, guided by God. Why don't you read them? These are the words of Moses himself. In Exodus 3 God told Moses that his name was YAHWEH. Why is this name never used in the Quran? You will also find the covenant line of Abraham, Issac and Jacob. In Genesis 17 God clearly states that Ishmael isn't a covenant son. Issac was the covenant son of Abraham and Issac's son Jacob became known as Israel. Israel became God's covenant people. Mohammed also lived 600 years after Christ. Christ clearly said in each gospel that wicked men would kill him and that he would be raised to life after three days. Those who wrote the gospels were those who lived and walked with Jesus. Matthew and John were disciples, John Mark wrote Peters gospel (gospel of Mark). Luke was a medical doctor and apostle who didn't meet Jesus, but who worked with the disciples and apostles including Paul. Why then would the Quran say Jesus wasn't crucified and raised. Even Bart Ehrman's a former Christian and now author says Christ was crucified. The Torah and gospels are much closer and more accurate sources than the Quran. I suggest you read them and find the truth which Jesus taught.

@azaztoto8676

3 жыл бұрын

@@WHU63 you know that when prophet Moses 40 nights appointment has completed the lord said to him that his tribe has worshipped the calf. He put what he wrote on the ground and he went to his brother haroun to punish him. He said to Moses that he has feared those who has deviated. Some of What prophet Moses wrote and what was sent to Jesus has been rewritten for sake of money. However, Quran is unchanged and was promised from the lord to save him. I hope Allah ( means the only one to be worshipped)will guide you and all of us to him.

לא

All my life I have seen images of Israelis living in a developed first world nation sold as both a world class hub of research and development and a holiday destination. At the same time I've seen images of Palestinians being corralled and barred from developing by occupation. One population exists in a constant state of privation in the name of security for another population . Whole Israeli cities exist in the west bank now as well as numerous other settlements. The west bank faces the indignity of occupation and piecemeal theft of useful land, while Gaza is one of the largest concentrations of people in the world and is routinely bombed by one of the most advanced military in the world. You make a place unfit for humans, don't be surprised when it produces monsters. Hamas' violent response to Israel is suicidal terrorism, which is met by the IDF with regular terrorism. There doesn't seem to be an acceptable response for the Palestinians other than get with the programme and either give up and leave or die already. Zionism is the project of establishing a Jewish homeland by having Jews move there from Europe and elsewhere. This is a colonial population as much as the Afrikaners are in South Africa. This is not assert anything about the justification of that project or to argue that it shouldn't exist, simply to point out a similarity. In both cases, these colonial states found an inconvenient population within their claimed territory, and there existed a near constant state of conflict with the surrounding countries. There exists apartheid rhetoric that claims the Afrikaners found an empty land and only later did the Bantu population move in, similar to the Zionist rhetoric that dismisses the historical claim of the Palestinians . Just as the apartheid regime existed with the support of the US and western allies, so to is Israel one of us. This isn't something happening on China's or Russia's watch, or whatever authoritarian regime you care to name, it is happening on ours. An ally, a first world developed democracy is committing a slow genocide of an inconvenient population living at its mercy and by its rules. Of course there are difference. Race relations in Israel are hardly as rosey or simple as presented in this video, but yes the apartheid that exists in Israel and Palestine isn't racial in the way it was in South Africa. To label Israel an apartheid state is to say that the two situations are substantively similar, not identical.

This is our land , Why do we have to submit , LMAO

@mrdaykurutakuchannel

3 жыл бұрын

No. Zionists stole them like Tuyuls steal money.

@deborahfreedman333

Жыл бұрын

It never was your land.

Boers support Isreal.🇿🇦🇮🇱

@thefatcontroller7721

3 жыл бұрын

Nelson Mandela was against Israeli apartheid

@JohnTheStun

3 жыл бұрын

@@thefatcontroller7721 So he would like actual Israel?

@myselfazania7771

3 жыл бұрын

Ofcourse they do

@matthewmorrisdon6906

3 жыл бұрын

@@JohnTheStun Mandela shoved burning tires on Board necks.

@Anne-zt2dz

3 жыл бұрын

of course, fascist solidarity

Who should i believe: Amnesty International, a world renowned human rights organization, or a clearly biased propaganda channel? Amnesty International tells me it is apartheid and you tell me its not

@UNPACKED

7 ай бұрын

You should look at the facts, not just the name on the label. Here’s another video I think you would appreciate: kzread.info/dash/bejne/Z5is2MGIm9nAiLQ.html

I grew up in South Africa so I understand apartheid and what I see in Isreal is not apartheid. The views that I hear of apartheid in South Africa are also quite distorted. It wasn't created because whites viewed themselves as superior, it was because they believed everybody should be separate, that’s why people were classified as Indian, Black etc. This was the reason that the homelands were created. Most people see the release of Nelson Mandela as the watershed moment, it wasn't, apartheid was mostly over long before the 1990s but the laws were still in place. I studied with both Blacks and Indians in the 1980s, who ironically qualified before me because I was required to do two years national service whereas they weren't. Apartheid wasn't right and that's why most of South Africa voted for change. It is important to report the truth because in so many cases the narrative is wrong but it's used effectively as a weapon. This is the case for Israel, there is no apartheid in Israel, but this word is so powerful and it's being used against the Israelis. Why is "from the river to the sea" not being seen as both genocide and apartheid, but Israel's actions in defending themselves are? Let's not forget that the slogan implies complete annihilation of the Jews - genocide, and a piece of land where there will be no Jews - apartheid.

This is so damn biased, it's sickening.

3 жыл бұрын

Anti-Jewish racists don't like facts. Nothing new.

@JaimeNoro

3 жыл бұрын

@ the old anti-semite victim card. I'm not even talking about jewish people, you idiot. I'm talking about Israel's policies. If you consider yourself entitled to evict a palestinian from their house and settle there; if you think you desrve more rights as a citizen than a palestinian; if you agree with blockading their land, expand yours, annex what's is not your land, you are the racist one. Psychological projection won't be enough.

@redstream1237

3 жыл бұрын

@ Most of the religious Jews don't even recognise Israel

@jaller23rus

3 жыл бұрын

@@redstream1237 If you are talking about Neturei Karta guys, they are surely not "most of the religious Jews". Their numbers are really small.

@practicalhabit

3 жыл бұрын

@ boo. Say that to yourself. Don't call other people racist when you're the one that racist.

Israel is several times more oppressive than South Africa under apartheid. I like how you say the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, apartheid development is way more complicated than how South Africa developed. Not hardly, the Dutch and British built South Africa and when it was done, Africans came in droves, unlike the formation of Israel, where the people were already there in droves, God's chosen people, in their mind, had only one options, systematically exterminated them.

@alexvisser4542

Жыл бұрын

'To equate what is going on in Israel today with South Africa when South Africa was under Apartheid laws is a gift to Israel' Noam Chomski

@snoopcelev1590

Жыл бұрын

If it's so bad here they can leave

@shainazion4073

9 ай бұрын

That's really sad as you show how ignorant you are. The early Jewish leaders appealed to the Arabs to stay in their houses and help them create a country together. There have been less than 100,000 "Palestinians" killed in the last 100 years. There was never a time that Israel started Any of the fighting. Five Arab armies attacked the one day old country of Israel. From the 1880s, the Arabs attacked the Jews on lands they bought. You really need to educate yourself. *Buy a book! Google is free!*

"Israel is not an apartheid state" The apartheid state

At 5:22, this lady needs to go and look at the map they showed again and correct her statement that is clearly biased towards...well the while video is but...nvm 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@beyakhad

3 жыл бұрын

It's a great video :)

@rajosaddex-swayzemitzimo1363

3 жыл бұрын

@@beyakhad 🤣🤣🤣👌🏽 it is!

@PratipGhoshDastidardhurr

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly the point! Show one thing and tell another.. 🤷🏻‍♂️