Is Islam in Line With the Faith of the Prophets? - Rabbi Answers

Rabbi Pinchas Taylor answers whether the Islamic faith is compatible with that of the Prophets and whether Muslims are idolaters for praying in the direction of Kaaba.

Пікірлер: 31

  • @safiul1930
    @safiul19306 ай бұрын

    Islam was preached by every prophets. Whorship God alone and follow your prophet. That is Islam.

  • @Gambitheart
    @Gambitheart2 ай бұрын

    Rambam is burning in deepest hellfire now.

  • @makalo
    @makalo6 ай бұрын

    I just wish Jews one day could read Genesis 28 and then look up in ancient maps where Haran actually is located. It would change everything for you... I promise.

  • @amf5637

    @amf5637

    5 ай бұрын

    I am Jewish and have been thinking about and have been contemplating your comment for the last couple days. I don't usually leave comments but I'm curious enough to ask a follow up. Haran is located in modern day Turkey and people were going back and forth between there and Ur, as Avraham did. Are you implying that that's not where Haran was actually located? Which maps should I look at? And yes, in Genesis 28 he liked the people in that area (like those from Aram, the Arameans) more than the Canaanites for his son to marry. I'm not sure what conclusion you want me to draw about that. So what's supposed to be different for me? I think I'm missing the point. I like to discover new truths that will change everything for me but I may need it a little more spelled out. Could you elaborate?

  • @copkhan007
    @copkhan0077 ай бұрын

    There is no such thing as Ismailalite. Abraham, Ismail and all the Prophets were Muslims.

  • @cryptoKnightsea

    @cryptoKnightsea

    6 ай бұрын

    Ishamilaties means Arabs

  • @MakeItInterestingNow

    @MakeItInterestingNow

    6 ай бұрын

    The history is - Judaism, Christianity, Islam so there is no way the prophets were Muslims. They were all Jewish and Muhammad and Quran which came a few thousand years later embraced them. Even the Quran says so, that the Jews were blessed by God and by all the prophets he gave them.

  • @cryptoKnightsea

    @cryptoKnightsea

    6 ай бұрын

    @@MakeItInterestingNow maybe you are from usa or other western country, most of people there don't know that jews and arabs are blood cousins, and jews are children of israel and arabs are children of ismail. and Muslim is arabic word means. person who submits his/her will to true God. that's the definition of Muslim. every prophets submitted their will to god. that's why they were muslims. and arabs jews are semetic people,. God in hebrew it's Ello'im . God in Arabic it's Allah, God in Aramic is Elah, which is the language of Jesus.

  • @cryptoKnightsea

    @cryptoKnightsea

    6 ай бұрын

    they are worship the same god. ask any jews.

  • @charananekibalijaun8837

    @charananekibalijaun8837

    5 ай бұрын

    They were Jews 😂

  • @zainabhussein8142
    @zainabhussein81425 ай бұрын

    As Muslim believe jesus mot don't believe jesus

  • @shanewoody4232

    @shanewoody4232

    5 ай бұрын

    Muslims believe Jesus is a prophet there's nothing wrong with that. Unfortunately Paul as well as the Greeks and Romans corrupted his word.

  • @NAZionist666
    @NAZionist6665 ай бұрын

    🕌☪️🤝✡️🕍 Strictly montheist, Abrahamic 😊

  • @horusksa1983

    @horusksa1983

    10 күн бұрын

    Add Unitarian Christians too

  • @samiqala6543
    @samiqala65436 ай бұрын

    Islam yes, Judaism no they are so not

  • @andanandan6061
    @andanandan60615 ай бұрын

    Well the Jews is not fully Monotheistic. They have divine assembly and lesser Gods below supreme God (EL) similar to Pagan Meccan with Allah and his lesser deity (Al-lat, Al-Manat and Al-Uzza). That why Jesus was sent to the Jew and Muhammad was sent to the Pagan Arab.

  • @zainabhussein8142

    @zainabhussein8142

    5 ай бұрын

    Exactly jews don't believe jesus

  • @yasminee52

    @yasminee52

    4 ай бұрын

    No why are you lying about Them ? They believe in God just like us

  • @Gphilly819

    @Gphilly819

    4 ай бұрын

    False im a Jewish man and and went to Jewish school And learned the Torah We learn that we worship one God

  • @andanandan6061

    @andanandan6061

    4 ай бұрын

    @@yasminee52 Yahweh is described as one of the sons of El in Deuteronomy 32:8-9, but this was removed by a later emendation to the text. (Wikipedia) Just google it. Yahweh and EL, two Gods of Israel there is some twisted stuff I wonder why God sent messanger to this people if they "were" already Monotheistic.

  • @user-xu1hn3ic6b
    @user-xu1hn3ic6b20 күн бұрын

    Secondly the truth is based on Tanakh Outside that we enter lies. The Quran presents a messiah who is short of the one in Tanakh. Gods covenant with Abraham is fulfilled in messiah. Who is high Siitted at Gods right hand Comes to be given a kingdom of David to reign with all people's on earth serving him. Islam and Quran fall short of that. Not the complete truth.

  • @karimmezghiche9921

    @karimmezghiche9921

    4 күн бұрын

    Why should we trust the Tanakh? Is it from God? No The Qur'an is from God