Outside of gameplay, are there any specific topics related to the channel or EDH / cEDH that you would be interested in listening to us discuss? As the season comes to a close we're looking into trying out a podcast-style video before the start of Season 2 and would love to know what you guys would be interested in hearing us talk about!

@TheYakVortex

4 жыл бұрын

Pod cast 🤔 interesting, watch i must

@patrickmchugh4616

4 жыл бұрын

I would be interested in hearing you guys discuss an EDH or possibly cEDH-only banlist. Myself and others in my playgroup find a lot of the cards on the commander banlist to be unworthy and probably wouldn't hurt the game to be unbanned. Great content as always!

@TheBlackdragon936

4 жыл бұрын

Casually Competitive MTG MVP was the right choice but Necro was LVP (Least Valuable player) he drew the same amount of cards in the end without it with the skipper draws and the loss of life got him killed.

@argonnas2

4 жыл бұрын

discussing how you come up with a deck that is fun and competitive. like opus thief and grixis ping control.

@austin19950618

4 жыл бұрын

Please release them on Spotify too

I think that showing the misplays isn't a bad thing because we get to learn the correct rulings alongside you guys.

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

While we don't like showcasing large misplays, we also see the value is showing and explaining the misplays for the sake of both learning ourselves and showing others some maybe not common interactions. The only super strict rule we have internally is that if the misplay drastically affects gameplay we will most likely pull the game, but other than that we are okay with keeping things a bit more 'realistic.' We are still working on a way to possibly incorporate a judge, but until then those are our general guidelines internally

@TheRealVFox

4 жыл бұрын

@@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG What was the free counterspell that was available if Adam still had the mental misstep? If it was Force of Will, Bill might have lost because of that -1 life,or at least not have gone off.

@Winterhe4rt

4 жыл бұрын

I dont mind an occasional misplay. especially not if you guys catch it and not the´comment section. ^^ With so many players and cards involved its a normal thing that happens all the time on probably every Commander table. So you guys finding them and pointing them out is a great way.

Cindervine MVP jesus that's a lot of damage

That combo.... How are people so smart? This is great content. I love owning up to misplays. Thanks for the game!

The competitive meter is kinda hard to extract information from since most of the decks are like 80%, 90% on it. I would suggest a number out of 10 at the end so that we know where the deck lies. Also one number or meter doesn't always tell the whole story so I would love some more meters rating the deck on metrics such as the amount of interaction, combo/win speed or value options it has.

Probably my new favorite edh youtube channel, keep em coming guys.

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

Thank you so much!

@jamesmayle3787

2 жыл бұрын

Jesus Christ is lord. Please read at least three books of the Bible. The first book of each testament and one you chose yourself. As you do practice forgiveness. It is important. Please

Seriously, best format out of all the c/edh youtubers currently - very watchable

Wait a second....I think I see a hard counter to some competitive combo decks...might me making Ruric Thar soon

@magerehenk7579

4 жыл бұрын

a 6 mana card will never be a hard counter to competitive decks, it's just too slow and expensive.

@MK-13337

4 жыл бұрын

The "Hard counter" just got bounced and killed and it costs a boatload of mana.

@14:54 there’s a missed upkeep trigger with mana vault which would result in Nate losing if he paid 2 life into necropotence

@markgrassia8354

2 жыл бұрын

yep and then missed again on the next turn. damnation would never have happened

@tonyc5356

8 ай бұрын

The damage from mana vault goes on the stack at draw step but necropotence skips the draw step.

I'm loving these videos. I really enjoyed the walking through the stack and even the misplay. I completely missed it until you point it out. Learned alot from this. Keep up the great work

Your videos are fantastic y’all And I really appreciate you owning up to your mistakes And explaining the combos and how you give us the graphics of the stack Really enjoy your content and am looking forward to more videos :D

Thank you, thank you for playing K'rrik ! I love this commander and there is not enough content/game play with him.

Just found your channel. Loving these videos. Easy to follow and I really enjoy the quick deck explanation before the match so I can learn new decks. Keep up the great work

Everytime I see an Inalla deck played, it's always different but always looks like so much fun! Great video!

Never clicked on a notification faster!

The grasp of fate information was new to me. I had to look it up and now I’ll have to explain it to my group. Also enjoyed the misplay explanation. Great to help better inform us less competitive players! Keep it up!

Bill's playmat is DOPE!!!! That's some serious nostalgia right there! And the game was superb, btw :-P

It's so interesting to a new player like me to see massive combos. Thanks for the great content.

I really appreciate showing how many cards each player has in their hand. It really makes a big difference to interpreting the plays made and frankly I don't know why so few EDH channels do this.

That combo is y i love this format. People deciding I want to see how far this one thing can go and pushing it beyond any expected limit is amazing.

Watching these has gotten me and my friends into Cedh, keep it coming and bring back Uro soon!

Spoilers ahead That combo took longer than some Modern matches

I love the little bar at the bottom of the screen during the beginning! Idk if it’s all your videos, but that’s soo cool!

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

It got added a few videos ago, I figured if I got annoyed / bored listening to myself shill out our Patreon then others might as well. A timer seemed like a good way for people to skip over it if they wanted without being too intrusive.

I'm so happy to finally see my favorite mono black boy on the channel. Thank you guys, cant wait to see this episode play out.

@RobMedellin

4 жыл бұрын

It didn't go well for our boy. I play 3HG commander, so we have 70 Life and I eat it all up, yum yum yum. But I play a lot of things and more often than not win, unless it's vs 3 mono blue in which case we never win.

Loved all these decks

That stained glass sliver playmat. Man of absolute taste.

Love me sone gruul especially, but i always look forward to your uploads

Some awesome playmats there

GRUUL SMASH! Ruric Thar keeping everyone on their toes. Also the death of a thousand cuts from Cindervines & Fate Unraveler was a beautiful thing to watch.

I look forward to your new videos coming soon you guys have been missed honestly

top-notch content. keep it up

Brago is my favorite deck in all of magic. I think that a hard stax build with Brago gets out of hand quickly.

6:17 the life doesn’t change but the smoke goes through

Rooting for Nate this time through. Reservoir is always fun to watch

Love it!

Recently built deck in the style of Ruric Thar but as Klothys, very effective and good. Great vid

Best edh channel easily

That was a craaaaazy combo

Surprised to see Ruric Thar here! He was my first Commander, so it was great to see the damage-based stax basically pound everyone half to death.

I run ruric thar stax it's really good. I love the deck 😍❤️ thanks for showing the deck.

Props to bill for popping off, bonus props to bill for wearing what I think is the ahegao hoodie, that’s a power move right there

I do want to see more krrik though! Honestly why I watched this video in particular.

Geez what a loop. 12 page essay is an understatement lol

Love the videos! I have learned so much from this channel. I have never played an interaction like grasp of fate in our playgroup. Could someone explain that a bit more and other cards that work that way?

That Inalla combo was really cool. At first I thought thats its A LOT of dead cards involved. But I guess if you can use the sac Rituals and the Reanimation spells effectively before the combo turn then its potentially a great package.

Im a simple man. I sees a notification from Casually Competitive, I clicks like

I'm at 07:00 and I'm rooting for Brago. I totally have a Brago deck, too!🤩

Wow! I had no idea that Grasp of Fate (and similar effects) work that way. My commander is frequently exiled by Palace Jailer so this a an important interaction for me :)

@Halinn

4 жыл бұрын

I had to pause the video there to look up the specific rules as well. Anything that doesn't say to return the exiled card (like o-ring does), works this way, where you can bring it from the CZ. Won't work if it's moved from the CZ afterwards tho, because then it's a new game object

@xChikyx

4 жыл бұрын

This is completely new to me, i thought it was a misplay

@kaszael

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I had no idea either. Now my question is: does MtGO know?

@xChikyx

4 жыл бұрын

@@kaszael do judges even know?

@CrypticBore

4 жыл бұрын

@@kaszael pretty sure xmage doesnt know which means ill have to do a bug report but i dont play white.

That DBZ mat is amazing

That's a sweet Inalla Edh

10/10 I'll come back for stupidly convoluted combos again

Interesting take on Krrick I personally like the life gain version with infinite’s but this was near to watch. -Jack N

I think cindervines is always good just because it's also interaction at the minimum. It's also not something someone counters early so if you drop it it's a near uncounterable removal spell while putting some solid damage along the way. I've always liked little threat cards like this or using mystical tutor for a force of will because then people KNOW its there and might just not play their stuff out of fear. Had that dampining sphere gone off this might of been a very different game.

Chain of Vapor, the bounced permanents controller can sac a land, not chain of vapors caster. Love the content just wanted to point out :)

Why didn't Bill have to discard down to 7 in each of his end-steps after the Necropotence trigger? Did he have an effect on the battlefield that gave him unlimited hand-size? Love the content guys, this channel single-handedly got me into cEDH. Keep up the great work!

I LOVE THE MISPLAY EXPLANATION I hope you correct old games you’ve taken down especially for odd rulings. I know it changes the outcome but even a “blooper reel” with explanation may be great

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

There is currently only 1 video that we've ever produced and then pulled down due to misplays and I plan to re-record some of the audio with clear explanation and hopefully get that uploaded as maybe a bonus video sometime in the somewhat near future

@ryansalmon6507

4 жыл бұрын

You guys rule! Ty

Unnecessary complicated Wincon... I like it

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

Have you seen the Elsha win a few videos ago? We're all about overcomplicating things here

@HeyHeyHeyJoJoJo

4 жыл бұрын

Yes that one was nice too😁 Yesterday i played Siona and Won with Earthcraft /1 enchanted forest /whip silk /siona / and a enchantress. This drew half my deck and i could win with altar of dementia. This fellt really unnecessary long but my shielded by faith got countered 2 times.

@HeyHeyHeyJoJoJo

4 жыл бұрын

I have to say that i had to kill my own enchantress because i would have milled myself before i could mill my oponents

I use Scholar of Ages in a ton loops. She's a really strong combo piece!

Am I missing something? Shouldn't the Damping Sphere have completely stopped Inalla from going off? Did something happen to it that I forgot? o.O

@ungulatemanalpha

4 жыл бұрын

It's still exiled by Delay for another turn.

@kurtgrgelwrx8376

4 жыл бұрын

@@ungulatemanalpha ahhh yes thank you haha

Nate forgot to take damage from mana vault at turn 6 hehehe, awesome vídeo anyways

He revealed windfall at 16min mark, and didn't cast it even with narset in play. He really liked his hand it seems

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

He had just tutored up a Spellseeker, didn't want to let that go

Yes, Inalla wins! I play combo Inalla but I play the more common lines like prophets, dualcaster/ghostly flicker, apprentice necromancer/Ashnod's altar

Finding a Windfall off of a Narset activation has got to be the best feeling. (or the worst feeling for your opponents).

Question around 10:34 lake of the dead is played. Now my understanding is it only has 1 printing and it's quite old. So what is that?

Niv-Mizzet, Parun!!!!!!!

Great video! Just a question though, shouldn't have mana vault killed Nate? It was tapped and he had 1 life 😂

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

He had a Necropotence on the battlefield causing him to skip his draw step which is when Mana Vault deals damage

@rlujan1999

4 жыл бұрын

Allow me to differ Casually Competitive MTG. Mana Vault deals damage during the upkeep... are Untap/Upkeep/Draw ALL included in the "Draw step" that's been skipped by Necropotence? (This is a legit question, I'm not sure now lol)

@rlujan1999

4 жыл бұрын

I mean, he died anyway a turn later, so eitherway this is not that important😆😂

@RobMedellin

4 жыл бұрын

@@rlujan1999 I also thought it was in the upkeep, but no, it's actually until the draw step

@rlujan1999

4 жыл бұрын

@@RobMedellin huh, I just checked, and it changes depending on the version of the card. The old version says that it is during the upkeep, while the new one (from Ultimate Masters) does it during the draw step. I've never noticed this detail before. So interesting!

I had a question about the interaction with grasp of fate and exiling a commander with it. How does that rules interaction work so that u can still get your commander back if grasp of fate leaves the battle field.

As a bit of feedback, I would love it if, whenever someone has to discard a few cards, you were to maybe show which cards where discarded, maybe with a small icon next to their graveyard? I know it's extra work, especially if someone dumps like 13 cards because they drew twenty plus cards with a Necropotence, but it would greatly enhance the viewing pleasure! You don't have to narrate those cards either, but you could if there were any super important / relevant cards discarded.

@tibx2617

2 жыл бұрын

They get exiled with necropotence

I think the card in the middle should be larger so it's easier to read, but that's just a personal preference. Everything else was cool to watch.

Don’t know if since at it was instant speed so it didn’t do anything but wouldn’t damping sphere effect the combo?

@jackpabich763

4 жыл бұрын

Yes. Which is why it wasn't on the battlefield.

That Mindblade Render seemed like an odd inclusion in Bill's deck. Any particular reason for it?

I see everyone asking about the mana vault trigger. But at 17:17 Nate puts Necro cards to hand and doesn’t discard down to hand size? I know it didn’t seem to affect the game but I’m pretty sure that’s how Necropotence works right? The cards in hand counter says he has 8 when passing the turn

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

This is a visual mistake. He does discard down to 7, I just missed fixing this in editing

Would love to see a competitive sliver deck.

@orsettomorbido

4 жыл бұрын

Sliver as in The First Sliver or as in the tribe?

At 18:47, why doesn't Bill take 7 dmg for the essence flux cast from ruric thar and cindervines?

Any chance you'd play a Marwyn deck on this channel?

Man, that damping sphere was just ignored. Pretty wild.

@Customerbuilder

4 жыл бұрын

I thought so too, but it was under Delay the entire game.

@simpleb645

4 жыл бұрын

@@Customerbuilder Ahh you're so right

where did they get the black and white playmat

Is the background music from Plague, Inc?

A bit of an issue…you can’t change the mode of pyroblast with imp’s mischief because once it’s mode has been chosen it can’t change…see ruling on 10/4/2004 on the gatherer.

After watching the video and hearing you say that when a mistake affects the outcome of the game you might not publish the video I have this to say, you should publish the video and just make it clear in the title that there was a misplay. Because maybe it did affect the game but we might also make these mistakes so it's a great way to learn from them.

@robwormuth7838

4 жыл бұрын

There’s a spike feeders video from a while ago featuring Tatyova and an egregious misreading of “Horn of Greed”. I think that’s more of the type of situation where the video should’ve alluded to it in the title. However, I personally feel like it’s relatively easy to use hindsight to judge wether or not something ended up affecting the outcome.

Where is that lake of the dead art from? I thought the only one was from alliances. Is it a proxy?

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

It is a proxy. For ease of use we tend to proxy cards we have in other decks so we don't have to constantly swap cards, and I accidentally pulled the online version of that card for the proxy

@pedrobronze

4 жыл бұрын

I was also wandering about that

Super simple combo lOI

1:20 no description given in the link

I've always found the interaction between commanders and effects like grasp of fate to be counterintuitive rules wise. If you return your commander to the command zone and the grasp of fate is removed it returns to play. I presume, but would like to know for sure, that would not be the case if you put the commander in the command zone from grasp of fate recast it and then put it in the command zone from a non-grasp of fate effect and then grasp of fate was removed

@blinky101

4 жыл бұрын

that is correct, it would be seen by the game as a different object. Same reason that flickering a creature with epheramate and the like counters removal pointed at that creature

wow, today I realized that you're playing with proxies since the lake of dead is the MTGO version... All this time I was thinking that you guys are rich AF lol

nate doesn't seem to take damage from his mana vault for several turns

Ruric thar is secretly great

Im curious, why did Bill's combo work if Joseph had a damping sphere out? wouldnt Bill have run out of mana because of it?

Maybe i am a little bit late, but isn't there a dampening sphere on the side of ruric thar? casting those spells would be impossible.

I'm an inalla player too, just curious about the reason to play infinite token combo with more than five cards involved.

@TheRealLap

4 жыл бұрын

It isn't, at least 3 of them got tutored up by Spellseeker which is part of the combo in the first place, this line costs less mana than prophet's dance and hence should be included. It also enables Razaketh line which is another line that's cheaper than prophet. Given that reanimation package is already there, I think it's a very good fit.

I’d enjoy another urza build as one of the options???

How was the Inalla player able to cast his combo with the Damping Sphere on board?

Grasp of Fate being destroyed returns the Commander even when it's not in exile? Didn't know that, the same should work for Banishing Light/Banisher Priest since they're worded in the same way, what about Oblivion Ring/Fiend Hunter?

@CasuallyCompetitiveMTG

4 жыл бұрын

Cards like Oblivion Ring will not work if you put your commander back into the command zone since it specific says 'Return the exiled card...' and after replacing the removal effect it is no longer exiled. If it doesn't specify that the exiled card returns or that the card has to return from exile then the replacement effect shouldn't stop the re-entering

K'rrick missed a manavault burn trigger after the abolisher cast, vault was underneath darksteel for this turn until untap and moving straight to combat. Idk but it seems kinda strange, so close to lethal

That lake of the dead version, what is that? Alliance was only printing, looks like MTGO art

wasn't dampening sphere in play during the wizard combo??

@billkakke6050

4 жыл бұрын

It's was delayed

nate can we mabye get a deck tech on your storm deck? @Casually Competitive MTG

I have a question to see if anyone could answer for me, if I sacrifice a creature does it count as the creature dying

Wait what that's how grasp of fate

How does Nate have a Lake of the Dead with the Vintage Masters printing and WOTC stamp on the card? I really want to know lol. The card has only been printed in Alliances in paper and online in Vintage Masters.

@Repairgenius

4 жыл бұрын

Its a proxy, Nate has the alliance version, but its a huge time sink to keep switching out double sleeved cards to play in a new deck in the videos.

@Vhaanzeit

4 жыл бұрын

@@Repairgenius Where can you get proxies for cards like that? I prefer the Vintage Masters artfor quite a few cards versus the OG ones I have. Cheers for responding quickly.

@Repairgenius

4 жыл бұрын

Vhaanzeit so what we use is MTG press just for paper and then we use a basic land backing, you can get any card from any set printed. I personally use CustomizedMTG for my true to size proxies/alters.

@Vhaanzeit

4 жыл бұрын

@@Repairgenius Really appreciate the info! Thanks a lot.