Imagine if Joel wore the Shrek skin again for this episode. It'd be funny but he'd get called out so quickly for sure xD

@lilypainter666

5 ай бұрын

Yeah lol

@pixiepinkgamer

5 ай бұрын

Todily

@Mizu_ow

5 ай бұрын

Why’d a yellow callout a yellow?

@Lahzing

5 ай бұрын

​@@Mizu_owwhy not?

@Mizu_ow

5 ай бұрын

@@Lahzing because they’re on the same team

Last episode: "Etho I know you're obsessed with me. You put me in the thumbnail of your first episode." This episode: Joel puts Etho in his thumbnail

@-lilyy.anaa-

5 ай бұрын

Its a love-hate relationship

@holssvsp

5 ай бұрын

next session: ‘okay joel i saw YOUR** thumbnail calm down’

@basilbat273

5 ай бұрын

​@@holssvspyour*

@knulllord654

5 ай бұрын

​YOUR*

That task fits too perfectly with Joel, it's too eerie. It's as if it's not a coincidence xD

@lilypainter666

5 ай бұрын

Yeah lol

@imperfectimp

5 ай бұрын

Yeah, i feel like they're not entirely random. They seem to be getting harder over time too. But imo it's fine if the mods are just finding interesting pairings. Makes the content better than some truly wild randomization.

@cl-jp3uv

5 ай бұрын

@@imperfectimpI find it hard to believe if they are random. First the cult task and now this

@gemsngold

5 ай бұрын

@@imperfectimpmy theory is that since the book is marked “(name)’s Secret Task”, they have a pool of thematically fitting tasks for each player, and randomly pick from that pool.

@grondhero

5 ай бұрын

Yeah, seems like the tasks are tailor suited for people (seriously, Mumbo not allowing Scar to take 3 hearts damage?). Hopefully there's multiple tasks that each person could have and the game chooses a random one from that suite of tasks.

Joel: ‘If you were a colour, what would you be? Pearl: RED! DEFINITELY RED

@yangland2692

5 ай бұрын

She said that way too quickly 😂😂

@liamr4117

5 ай бұрын

Scarlet Pearl lives on

@_PTUBE101_

5 ай бұрын

@@liamr4117yerp

@BramLastname

5 ай бұрын

It does suit her

@Hope_blade_edits

2 ай бұрын

That’s how you know she’s slowly but surely becoming 5 am pearl

Joel’s 4 lines for his task: 3:49 “I ain’t the sharpest tool in the shed” 11:42 “My world’s on fire, how about yours?” 13:17 “so much to do, so much to see” 15:45 “I could use a little fuel myself”

@user-ry5pz8vq8h

5 ай бұрын

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

As soon as I heard Joel saying "I ain't the sharpest tool in the shed" in pearl's episode I immediately realized what his task was. 🤣🤣

@TheOne_6

5 ай бұрын

as soon as i heard 'my world's on fire, how about yours?' on grians i also immediately knew what his task was

@danieldavid3766

5 ай бұрын

@@TheOne_6I thought it was just a joke because he just “caught” Grian singing

@leamysage

5 ай бұрын

@@TheOne_6same

@wheleck

5 ай бұрын

same i heard one of the lyrics in someone elses video and immediately knew what it was

@TheOne_6

5 ай бұрын

episode 5 is out@@wheleck

22:03 Etho slowly looking and turning at Joel will never not be funny

I feel like this was such a calm episode compared to last time and it's like a good lil breather. Thank you for not making us feel stressed Joel xD

@KitsukiiPlays

5 ай бұрын

Calm for Joel only, I guess. Considering we have 2 reds now, lol

@iloveowls90

5 ай бұрын

@@KitsukiiPlaysThat was their fault though not Joel’s

@-lilyy.anaa-

5 ай бұрын

We needed it after Jimmys and Martyns shenanigans

@dbseamz

5 ай бұрын

I think being away from Grian has helped Joel calm down. First two episodes were more hinged than I ever remember Joel acting in Life Series, then week 3 was more of the old chaos--while Grian was with him.

@grookeymon

5 ай бұрын

BRO YOU GOT THREE COMMENTS IN MY TOP 4 RECOMMENDED COMMENTS

Hard Task suggestion: Give BDubs a clock, and convince him to give it back.

Task idea: You can't speak to "random username" for 30 minutes of the session, but you have to be around them sometimes under the 30 minutes

@BramLastname

5 ай бұрын

You could start the timer whenever you hear them speak.

@fennekin1750

3 ай бұрын

Like, you have to communicate to them in anyway that is NOT talking or speaking to them in any way at all? If so, that sounds funny & hard! Like, you'd have to do something like flip a trapdoor or point (or try to point in MC) or something just to communicate, but you have to be muted the whole time? Literally muted or just not talk at all while being unmuted.

Joel last session: Etho I know you're obsessed with me you put me in your thumbnail Also Joel this session: ETHO BOAT BOYS THUMBNAIL LETS GO

Task Idea: “Act like you think you’re muted and do or reveal something embarrassing. Another player must hear but awkwardly ignore it. If addressed, does not count.”

@SamBorgman

5 ай бұрын

This would be fun. I'd be screaming at my mom like I'm the devil child lol No one would stick around and they would even decide to cut that out of their videos

@Gladiva19

5 ай бұрын

@@SamBorgmanScreaming at your parents, who gave you everything, is so cringy and ungrateful 🤢🤮 But maybe they deserve it for raising such a useless child and putting them in society for others to deal with.

@SamBorgman

5 ай бұрын

@@Gladiva19 lol wut

@LRM12o8

5 ай бұрын

@Gladiva19 some children have terrible parents that deserve to be screamed at way more than one child can do. Just like some people don't understand jokes, but are quick to harshly judge others and call them useless... 👀

@ihateyoukeagan

5 ай бұрын

@@Gladiva19respectfully shut up

Task idea 1: Throw a party for a past life series team (BEST, flower husbands, Ranchers, bad boys etc.) Task idea 2: Get all Secret life members to throw you an item. Any item. Task idea 3: Get 5 people in a row NOT to give you a heart when you ask them. If someone gives it to you, you need to restart

@nfandi

5 ай бұрын

tbh they would probably run out of people before completing the third one, they're so generous

@glitch3dgh0st15

5 ай бұрын

@@nfandibut if you waited until the end of the session it’d be way too easy because everyone gave them away because of your point, they’re too generous

@lcyJ

5 ай бұрын

third one is way too easy

@cassievibes1253

5 ай бұрын

These are so good tho

@dbseamz

5 ай бұрын

@@glitch3dgh0st15 yeah, ask all three of the Heart Foundation after they do their random giveaway and you're set.

I can just imagine Joel looking at Lizzie and going "You know, you're the second best wife I've ever had" and Lizzie just be like "But I'm the only wife you've had" followed by just a small moment of awkward silence.

The cult is literally hilarious because everyone just discovers it and it so funny!

22:13 I know Joel said that the fandom's gonna go crazy, and he is so right because OMG MY BOAT BOYSSSSS 😍😍 It's been too long 😭

I saw Grian's pov, and as soon as I saw the title of this video I immediately guessed what Joel's task was by the very well placed "My world's on fire, how bout yours?" he used in his reaction.

After "This is where relationship ends by Etho I'm sure his task is to bring back every life series reference

@luminemo

3 ай бұрын

I love that Etho had actually already finished his task by then! So boating with Joel was just a bonus

this has been the most peaceful secret life ep yet thank you for considering my blood pressure this time

@blueaeus

5 ай бұрын

ur so real for that im always stress watching these guys😭

Joel and Etho are making me go MAD over these boat boy crumbs 😭‼️

Task idea: Use the wrong series name in at least 5 conversations. Only rule is that it has to be a life series. If someone calls you out on the task or corrects you, that conversation does not count. Example: Accidentally call secret life Last Life

@charlottesocool

5 ай бұрын

THQATS SO GOOD

@Pogitoed

5 ай бұрын

maybe to make it a bit harder have it be 4 times but u have to do each season, like you have to accidentally say 3rd life, last life, double life, and limited life, the latter 2 would prob be much harder

@JustMy0pinion

5 ай бұрын

Lame task

@eclipse4507

5 ай бұрын

People misspeak and say that all the time. Way too easy

@cam_5577

5 ай бұрын

@@eclipse4507 yeah thats why I tried adding the fact that if they are pointed out or corrected it doesnt count. It was just an idea :/

Task idea: tell Bigb, "Where's Bdubs?" everytime you meet him, you must at least do this 5 times during the session. If Bigb asks if this is your task, you fail.

im like 100% sure ethos task was to make people relive the past life series or smtn similar

Task idea: Stalker Be (player’s) secret stalker. Leave hints and messages that they’re being watched. If you get caught, you fail.

As much as I love the chaotic version of Joel, this episode where you were taking it easy was great, especially in contrast to everybody else going to the End lol

the mere fact that a red can just walk up to someone with a axe and take chunks of health away is terrifying

@lisahenry20

5 ай бұрын

Haven't finished this video yet, but i think at the end of Martyn's, Grian talks about how the red lives will work

@asmi__

5 ай бұрын

Hey I see you in the comment section of so many videos! It's crazy how many similar youtubers we watch :D

@thedeltastrat

5 ай бұрын

as lisa says, reds can't damage ppl whenever like in the past. Instead their tasks involve damaging people, and they can only damage ppl via their task. However they once they complete a task they get another one lol

@zeerabbit8895

5 ай бұрын

​@@thedeltastratwho is Lisa?? :D

@shidoulover48

5 ай бұрын

@@zeerabbit8895person who replied earlier

The fact that joels favourite color is green and then he just remembers that he is not green anymore😭😭 this is called fomo :_)

challenge Idea: you are now terrified of the words "task" and "secret" and whenever any of them are said you have to scream and run away in fear.

Task idea: leave everyone a potted plant without getting caught.

I love how proud he is of the fact they’re married 😭 he couldn’t stop saying it ❤️

Considering you are married, I think it would be a good task to go around and propose to each other in front of at least 4 people. And it has to seem like a random coincidence, like one of you was there and the other just happened to come along.

Task idea: be Jimmy’s bodyguard. You can let him in on the secret and he can NOT tell anyone. (Jimmy you heard me)

A MUCH better episode for Joel this week! NOICE job with the lyrics sprinkled in (as well as the Annoyed expressions & giggles!) throughout an episode 😁. @24:10 Scar & his Exasperated "Sheeesh he's back again for God's sake!" just slayed me! He's sooo worried about following his task rules, plus constantly & INSTANTLY getting told by Joel to take it off is PRICELESS. 😆

task ideas: 1st: get a group of at least three other people to do a cult style chant around someone’s base without being called out by the person who owns the base. the chant must include something that rhymes. it must also be either made up on the spot, or related to the base/ person who’s base it is. 2nd: go around the server and change all the signs you can find ever so slightly 3rd: be a vegan/ vegetarian for the WHOLE session. :)

@Epicc345

5 ай бұрын

2nd one is cool

@tillytiger5041

5 ай бұрын

peace love and plants!

@bananagaming7612

5 ай бұрын

@@tillytiger5041shut up eat meat

@Galaxy-im5rz

5 ай бұрын

Peace, love, and no pants

@ratxentherat

5 ай бұрын

@@Galaxy-im5rzwhat 😨

I remember watching other people's episodes and hearing "so much to do, so much to see" without even considering that it might be a task.

Joel’s little scream when a mob comes by is the funniest thing ever 😂😂😂

Was literally looking for something to watch thinking “could really go for a secret life video” AND HERE WE ARE!

Task/Secret Suggestion: "Come out" to someone by telling them a big (made up) secret about yourself. If three people think it's weird then you succeed.

The thumbnail is just giving reminders to the Boat Boys in Double Life

wow, you genuinely slipped them all in perfectly naturally! :D Especially that fuel-line. Congrats!

I've been enjoying watching the different perspectives, but the best thing in this episode was how sweet the interactions were between Joel and Lizzy at 5:50. The other nice touch was the crickets when Joel found Grian, and Joel stumbling onto Etho riding in a land boat at 22:05. That whole Mumbo horse interaction was hilarious.

You see a lot of comments about how when someone uploads it makes your day, but nothing genuinely makes my day like seeing a new Secret Life episode in my recommended

I remember watching grians pov and laughing historically at the smash mouth lyric. Didn’t even realize where it was from 😂

9:16 I love the delay when Joel is talking to Grian, then Grian suddenly just zips away

It’s always a good day when Joel posts even when it’s been a bad day if he posts it’s a good day

Task Idea: Make sure Tim isn’t eliminated First (no this isn’t a joke)

@ranboozled_

5 ай бұрын

That would be a mission lol

@libertybridger

11 күн бұрын

**spoiler alert** It happened. No task needed

Task Idea: Congratulation, you have passed your task! But... You can't press success until end of session, and unless at least 8 people make an guess or assumption of what your task is, then next week you need to change to a hard task immediately.

Task Idea: Make people believe you are on less hearts than you actually are, you win if someone gifts you a heart without asking for one

Hard task: Follow Scott for thirty minutes without him noticing. Normal task: Use book / movie quotes as many times possible.

Joel Etho moment was so cute 🥰 , i am so into them and Joel Grian interaction was so so funny 🤣 i love them . Scar running from Joel is funniest thing 🤣... And lastly Joel and lizzie is always so wholesome ❤❤❤❤❤

@asmi__

5 ай бұрын

Definitely named all the best parts of the video :D

Task idea: you have to make 3 vine references in 3 different conversions and don’t get called out

I immediately left Grian's video to watch Joel's as soon as I guessed his task (heard him say "My world's on fire"... ) best task ever lol!

Task Idea: You have to start every sentence you say (in front of other people) with a certain letter of the alphabet going in alphabetical order. So the first peron you talk to you have to start your sentence with the letter A then the next sentence with B and so on so forward. You have to get to the end of the alphabet by the end of the session. If you mess up you have to start over.

what a relaxing episode after all the chaos and struggles last episode! Next session it is gonna be great to see Joel back up to 30 hearts hopefully!

I watched both Jimmy and Grian's videos before this and in both I picked up on the all star "my world's on fire, how about yours" but didn't actually question it to be Joel's secret

Joel completely forgot about the spawner he found when he needed levels lol

Secret Task: become Solidarity’s Hunting dog for this session and do whatever violent thing he asks

Task : Convince at least 3 players to guess your task while your task is not what they tought they are

Task idea: be the counsellor of the server for the entire session

Task suggestion: when other players lose hearts, appologize. Do this 3 times without getting called out, if you get called out, you have to restart.

This whole episode was hilarious, but just…. Etho being an absolute gremlin in the background was something else xD And those references were SEAMLESS, I wouldn’t have picked up on them either if I didn’t know, and I genuinely love smash mouth!

Task Idea: Convince a player you have a rare item without telling them, if they ask to see this rare item you must show rotten flesh to them

Task idea: Create a survey of 5 questions and get the answers for that survey from everyone before you're called out.

Task idea: have unbroken eye contact with 3 people for 10 seconds then run away, if the other person looks away before time is up find someone else

19:44 Yeah, underwater caving is risky as all hell, even when you have regen, but SO WORTH IT! So much materials but with only a strong risk of drowning damage. Hell, I don't think I've ever seen a Drowned spawn while doing that.

22:11 Etho in his boat: "Get in loser we're going shopping!" XD

potential secrets;; avoid a player for an entire session, if they come within 5 blocks of you, you fail. convince any player to change for a harder task. pretend to be a physic and read 3 players futures. say furthermore twice to at-least 5 players without being commented on. speak with an Australian accent the entire session. convince someone to go to the nether and get them lost. switch every players bed to another’s without directly being accused. give everyone a cake

Task: Someone has to wear a jack-o-lantern and get asked, "wait you can wear jack-o-lanterns."

My brain has been rotten away by the Internet. I watched a different POV first, and I noticed Joel using the lyrics straight away. :D The "I could use a little fuel myself" was a great mix-in into the conversation though!

Task idea: Plan a wedding and become a priest, Minimum of 6 people need to attend to the wedding.

This was so fun to watch... I really enjoyed, and you're a great environmental storyteller. Also unreasonably excited to see your nice, safe precautions with your base. Best of luck!! Can't wait to see what's next!

Task1: Don’t let the person trying to find you find you Task2: try find the person you are required to find

10:34 I hadn't heard this A-ha from Etho yet, still making my way through SL4s. "You think you got it figured a-haout?" LOL that's pretty good, Etho. xD

Task Idea : Don't mute for the entire session. Yellow Task Idea : Successfully spy on 5 people and call out atleast one of them of their task correctly. Red Task Idea : 'Accidentally' push someone off a cliff without punching. They must take atleast 5 hearts of damage.

Task idea: convince people that its your pets birthday and have atleast 3 people say happy birthday (if you dont have a pet also convince them that you do)

Hard Task idea: get all the yellow to ask what your task is

mounders bounded by profound love

The fairground on the mound is iconic and no one can change my mind ❤️

Task idea for red names: You're are it in a game of tag. Punch someone else who hasn't completed their task to tag them. Once you tag them, give them this book and it is now their task Whoever is it at the end of the session fails

Task idea: You are not allowed to go outside the bounds of a quarter of the map (NW, NE, SW, or SE). You may pick which quarter.

dude i live for these uploads !! i have no idea how your still so enthusiastic !!!

Task idea: successfully “sell” another player an entire chest/barrel (shulker box?) of the same mundane block (dirt, stone, etc) It must be sold for payment, not just freely given.

"my world's on fire, how about yours?" was used so seamlessly! i really loved that line when i watched other povs, thought you had such a way with words lol

Man, I just love Joel's Task in this episode! Its super funny & fits Joel SOO well!! I think he did a great job working the lyrics he chose, into conversations! When I watched Grian's, I thought he was just annoyed abt the whole situation & was just being funny & referencing All Star by saying "My world's on fire, how 'bout yours?" lol! & He used "I could use a little fuel myself" really well!

Idea for a task: Get at least 3 other players to recreate an historical event or battle from another series like the battle of red desert or bdubs pool party

Task ideas: 1. Hard task: Repeat everything someone says every time they talk to you, if they tell you to stop, you fail. You can re try this 3 times. 2. Easy task: Follow Etho around everywhere silently. Don’t say anything. If he tells you to go away, you fail. 3. Possibly hard?: Give someone on the sever a trash gift. If they genuinely like it, you completed your task. If they don’t, you fail. One attempt only.

task idea: speak in only noises to people for 30 minutes, this could be squeaks, grunts etc. if you say one word, you fail

Task idea: for 15 minutes, keep doing water bucket clutch jumps from 1-3 block jumps while interacting with others

Task Idea: try singing a song, but get another person to finish the song, without getting called out, if you do you cant do that song or that person again

HARD task idea: Become the boogeyman. A green or yellow would have to kill another green or yellow

6:10 “You know what? You are.. you are amazing.” Even though I’m sure that was Joel trying to think of an All Star lyric, that was still adorable 😂

Task idea: You are now BigB. Confuse the living daylights out of people, particularly Grian. If someone guesses that your task is to be as confusing as possible, then you fail.

@oxybrightdark8765

5 ай бұрын

Imagine if B got this

Task concept: What If we had a task like this but the song depends on who gets it. For Example, if Lizzie gets it, it could be a song from Empires: The Musical. Or Joel could have another Shrek song. Scott could have Deal with Destiny. You get the idea. For guessing, the player only has to guess what that they have to mix parts of their song in sentences for it to count (guessing what the book said would be impossible). It might be too wild of an idea but thought I'd pitch it anyway.

okay, the “my world’s on fire, how about yours” line in griba’s pov suddenly makes sense 😂

Task idea: Change all of 4 people's water sources in their farms to lava! Obviously, don't get caught, if you do, you have to start over

Congrats on completing your task. Take good care of your hearts! 💜💜💜

Task idea: Throughout the session film 5 reality tv confessionals if you are caught you fail

The round mound astound!!!

Perfect timing, I’ve just finished watching the first 3 episodes

Task: No man, no matter if its true or not you must say no to, or deny everything. They must proclaim you must say no to everything.