It should be titled "Subscription-free GPU accelerated VDI", because we already have subscription free VDI

@Level1Techs

4 ай бұрын

Good call! ~Editor Autumn

@brazghost

4 ай бұрын

@@Level1Techs I swore it was "Intel introduces Subscription GPU"

@gork42

4 ай бұрын

It's also been supported on Intel iGPUs for a very long time. One of the things that isn't discussed so much wrt the topic of GPU virtualization is that the amount of effort that NVidia puts into their driver in their attempt to keep this type of thing locked down on their consumer cards (even though they are capable) is actually the root cause for why doing things like PCIe passthrough of NVidia GPU is such an absolute pain in the ass. NVidia are the most two-faced assholes that ever walked the planet. More of this, Intel, PLEASE

@dgo4490

4 ай бұрын

"for now" tm

@Deytookourjurrrs

4 ай бұрын

Hey what are some free VD I can use?

"life changing" is an understatement, I thought we would see this back in 2010. Absolutely insane it has taken this long to make it happen. I had to jump through so many hoops to make Proxmox do Virtual GPUs on my GTX 1060 6GB. Perhaps this will force Nvidia to rethink their policy on VGPUs in a few more years.

@niks660097

4 ай бұрын

rethink? they'll probably increase subscription fee, IT admins don't have power to spend money, its the management, and they'll only pick what their analysts say, and those analysts don't care about a rounding error in their budget but big names like nvidia cloud native.

@GeorgeWashingtonLaserMusket

4 ай бұрын

Intel is for more well known.

@joelv4495

4 ай бұрын

TrueNAS Scale has GPU passthrough to VMs in the GUI! I'm a recent convert from Proxmox, and I'm gonna start playing with GPU passthrough soon.

@hycron1234

4 ай бұрын

@@joelv4495- You may or may not know this.. but GPU passthrough is fine if you only want one graphics card powering one virtual machine. Virtual GPUs are when you split up a single graphics card and assign parts of it to different virtual machines.

@joelv4495

4 ай бұрын

@@hycron1234 oh gotcha. Makes sense that a totally different process is required.

YAAAAAY!!!!!

@marcogenovesi8570

4 ай бұрын

time to make another episode in the long lived "we have vdi at home" series, i guess

@Collin0

4 ай бұрын

I was thinking about your project watching this, lol. I tried doing virtual desktops at home with 2 S7150x2s I got for cheap a couple years ago hoping for better luck but couldn't solve the same problems you did and accepted it was over. Now I'm just wondering which of those A770s will work

@AIC_onyt

4 ай бұрын

a770 gpu gaming incoming?

I can't believe the title reads "subscription free" and we're all excited about it. DARKEST TIMELINE CONFIRMED.

Bonus points for epic sax guy. -the guy who worked with you on Nvidia GRID some 5+ years back

I'd love to see Intel handle the odd use cases like AMD handles ECC RAM on consumer Ryzen platforms - Enabled, but not certified. Let people mess with it if they want as long as they know it hasn't been given rigorous testing.

@Daniel15au

4 ай бұрын

Intel do support ECC on consumer CPUs... I'm using ECC RAM with an i5-13500. They've just chosen to artifically limit it to workstation (W680) and server motherboard chipsets. This is purely to make more money... The memory controller is on the CPU so it really shouldn't matter which motherboard chipset you're using.

@eldibs

4 ай бұрын

@@Daniel15au Just to be clear, first of all, it sounds like we agree, and that's why I 'liked' your response. Second of all, I said "platforms," not "CPUs."

@Daniel15au

4 ай бұрын

@@eldibs sorry, I misread "platforms" as "CPUs" in your comment!

@eldibs

4 ай бұрын

@@Daniel15au My good bromigo, it's okay, an honest mistake. Also, your extra info was interesting.

@boukeelsinghorst4848

4 ай бұрын

I believe ecc is deliberately disabled on Intel cpu's, so they can ask for a premium to have it enabled. AMD leaves it enabled

Get this to consumers! Maybe not 32 vdi but allow to have like 5, and AV1 encoding for cheap and it will be amazing

@Waitwhat469

4 ай бұрын

Stream to 5 separate gpu accelerated clients around my house and support AV1 encode/decode for media server support? This is like a dream case for the tech dad/mom house build. Also, possibly a very powerful streamer house setup...

@wayland7150

4 ай бұрын

Alternatively fit several discreet GPUs and pass them through.

@eDoc2020

4 ай бұрын

@@wayland7150 It's hard to find a consumer platform with 2 x16 slots. The best you can hope for is 2 slots in x8 mode and you won't have any slots left for I/O. 1 slot powering 4 VMs is much more useful.

@jungl3ist

3 ай бұрын

They will fight this to the teeth. The moment intel or nvidia enables this on a consumer grade a big chunk of the market will save money on this…. We can dream tho

The moment I can buy a consumer GPU with SR-IOV, I'm in.

@kelownatechkid

4 ай бұрын

Yes please. I have a spare slot just waiting in my server...

@porklaser

4 ай бұрын

I dream of the day I can dynamically partition my system and GPU and boot linux/windows simultaneously with 1% performance hit. No hal, no paravirt. VMs talk to the hardware. We don't have to put up with latency in 202X

@hugevibez

4 ай бұрын

So you're buying an A770?

@KiraSlith

4 ай бұрын

@@hugevibez Pretty sure that's not officially supported at this point. Intel and Nvidia both teased the option, but that obviously didn't pan out. :-/

@drewlarson65

4 ай бұрын

They know that, and want you spending enterprise monies instead :/

Wow this is a real game changer we will get one for our internal proxmox server. Thanks for this information. 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿

this is 100% one of my lofty dreams for my homelab i've been working towards for years but has always been next to impossible or working with jank workarounds. One day i'll have my desktops and gaming centralized in my rack

This is kind of what I want for a whole house gaming setup. I want a big PC rack mounted in my comm closet and then every TV/monitor is just a thin station. Even if I couldn't slice one GPU up but had to dedicate a GPU to each VD. I haven't figured out how to make a setup that's acceptable for gaming. Local is still always better by a long shot.

@lyserberg

4 ай бұрын

You could never do it for gaming anyway. You'd fail every bit integrity check straight out the door by even the lousiest of anti-cheat systems.

@mattjax16

4 ай бұрын

@@lyserbergthat was my question is how do you plan to circumvent anti virtualization measures taken by anti cheats

@manitoba-op4jx

4 ай бұрын

@@lyserbergjoke's on you, all my favorite games don't need anti-cheat

@steaksoldier

4 ай бұрын

@@lyserberg You are aware that a vast majority of games don't use anti cheat right? Your entire point falls flat on it's face if someone just doesn't play zoomer shooters lol

@gh975223

4 ай бұрын

i never had an issue playing games in visualised environment! even ubisoft games work (there just funny about getting too many cpu!) @@lyserberg

Man Wendell i can't tell you how thankful i am for your videos, your info, and everyone at the L1 forums! A million thank yous!!

Its been so many years! Please Intel release a consumer card with enabled SR-IOV. You don’t need to support it. Just put a warning in the driver (like overclocking on motherboards) and let us tinker to our heart’s content!!

This is dynamite! Thanks for this Wendell!

Your channel is awesome. I have been looking for a solution like this for years.

This is what everyone should have. Basically a home server that you could split up between multiple users in a home. In that way each endpoint only needs to be as powerful as a cellphone. Personally I am using truenas scale right now but I hope they can flush out their virtualization capabilities but I am really excited that proxmox is getting these capabilities.

@supdawg7811

4 ай бұрын

I would love to have this to separate my gaming and machine learning environments, but any sort of virtualization vs anti-cheat is a no-go. I don't want to do some weird Frankenstein's monster of Windows as host and hope that GPU passthrough to Linux works, and I don't want to deal with WSL because eventually I'll run into some issue.

@supdawg7811

4 ай бұрын

In order for this to become popular, hardware manufacturers need to start making guarantees to virtual machines about whether they can access guest memory, and then you have to get the developers on board and to trust it, as well as the OS vendors, etc.

@supdawg7811

4 ай бұрын

You're basically looking at extensive use of TPM, maybe per-guest encrypted memory, etc.

@chaosfenix

4 ай бұрын

@@supdawg7811I need to try running some more anti-cheat games on my system. Currently I have only tried the master chief collection but I don't really like playing on the internet with random people. Just not the kind of games I like. Currently my main "desktop" though is a windows 10 system I have passed a 4070 super through to and it works pretty well.

@chaosfenix

4 ай бұрын

@@supdawg7811Yeah I do think that the software ecosystem needs to evolve a bit because currently getting a performant virtualized systems up an running can be a bit of a pain. Previously I was running a system like you said with a windows server based system but when I tried upgrading my GPU from a 1060 to a 6800 AMDs installer told me that they didn't like that I was using their GPU on windows server. I used windows server because it was also serving as my file server and I got the license for free from school. I then decided to Install truenas scale, since the primary purpose here was a file server, and pass the 6800 to the VM but I still couldn't get the AMD drivers to install properly. I tried switching to Proxmox which allowed me to try with windows 10 and 11 but had the same issue on both. Tested passing my old 1060 to a VM and found that it worked with Nvidia GPUs so switched back to truenas scale, bought a new 4070 super, and have been using that for a couple of months now. I love it but the software restrictions AMD had in place have really pissed me off.

Our server admins in the other department will never admit this to be true... Because Linux hypervisor environments are "cobbled together". And their great Citrix VDI Test machine based on VMware and ancient Nvidia Quadro GPUs was a grandiose failure because... You guessed it... Subscription fees!!!

god damn it MAKE THE ARC VIDEO!!! i've watched this video SO MANY TIMES!! I CANNNOT WAITTTTTTT!!!

I purchased a mini-PC with an N100 CPU to run a Jellyfin server in Proxmox. I spent hours and hours trying to get the iGPU pass through working. I was about to give up & try Docker instead. I’m so grateful that this video was made & setup guides were linked in the description. I’ll work through them later, but I can tell at a glance that there were steps I missed because they were not in Jellyfin or Proxmox documentation.

@__Ben

2 ай бұрын

Did you end up getting SR-IOV working with the N100 iGPU?

This is great stuff especially regarding Proxmox! Excelling content. Thanks for making it happen!

Sometimes I'm busy during the day and I see a niche video like this that Wendell has posted. I think, "Man, I don't think this will be of any interest or use to me. I don't think I'm going to watch it...." But then I always do watch it and I'm blown away about how awesome these videos are. This info may help me to architect some great solutions for clients in the future.

Wendel is a god of nerds, such a beast

Wendell is that you? You're the whole reason my business took off, you taught me so much

Fantastic video! Proxmox for the win!

Ha! We are literally looking at deploying a new VDI solution. Glad I remembered you uploaded this video.

As a Horizon admin that had to give up his K1 and K2 Grid cards this warms my cold heart.

I've been waiting for video like this

Absolutely loved the new intro. Excellent video, the future of vdi is looking accelerated!

Oh my god this is GOOD news! Thanks for unraveling this awesome development Wendell

Want! After spending a weekend of driver and licencing hell getting vGPU up on a Tesla P4 I would happily pay to never have to deal with licencing servers and the ability to use drivers from my distros package repository.

Please keep us updated on this, extremely interested in testing.

the best part of the video was the datacenter ASMR... it brings back so many memories...

So what your saying is I should buy the "correct" a770 for my proxmox cluster....very well I shall visit the forums for the "one".😅

@ionstorm66

4 ай бұрын

I've never been able to find the actual files to flash for it.

@CTWilliams89

4 ай бұрын

@@ionstorm66 well damn lol

@TomMorris1

4 ай бұрын

I wonder if this could work on cheaper cards like the a380 as well?

@CTWilliams89

4 ай бұрын

@@TomMorris1 I happen to have a a380 in one of my nodes now. 🤔

@pauljones9150

4 ай бұрын

​@@TomMorris1I think the 380 is nearly as strong for this type of task?

I am looking to buy a used card since I am working on getting my certifications for OpenShift/VMware/Citrix given that I am or have worked and maybe be deployed again at clients that use it. This is awesome for learning at home and getting actual hands-on use and learning with this technology. I never bothered with buying a used NVIDIA or AMD card for licensing reasons or in the case of AMD, general support on Citrix or VMware Horizon for example. Anyway, many thanks for this video Wendell, you gave us a sneak peak of this on the L1 Linux channel but to see this is full form is just amazing!

Been looking into VDI for a few years now to potentially cut power costs, more specifically the number of running systems. Really glad this has got some attention as it may make it a more viable system letting companies know there are a casual use cases for these cards.

I read and reread the title like 3-4 times and read “subscription fee” every time. ADHD for the win.

@shineymcshine

4 ай бұрын

It needs a dash. I'm a heavy dash-user 😄

@skunkwerx9674

4 ай бұрын

ADHD? What?

@marcogenovesi8570

4 ай бұрын

@@skunkwerx9674 attention deficit with hyperactivity disorder. I don't remember the actual acronym

Oh thank god I am not the only one nerding out over this.

This is exciting!

Insanely cool 👍 Dream come true

wow & thank you

Thanks Wendell!

8:02 wow what a shot! 🤣

Love the jump scare, reminds me of that old classroom vid

We're buying at least $10M in Dell this year without alot of that being 2u VSAN ready nodes for Vmware with GPU slots standard. Haven't purchased many GPUs but the few I've seen have been Nvidia a40 (I think?) data center GPUs. We have some old VDI on ancient Vblocks so may need an upgrade here soon. Would be interested in what my Dell rep has or our VAR.

@krj15489

4 ай бұрын

I've got a buddy at another VAR says they have the Flex 140 in their catalogue, on backorder and not shipping but eventually available for about $2400.

Eyes open for one for my home lab VMware Horizon implementation. Already have a Tesla P4 passed through to a Plex server, time to give my virtual desktops some love.

My lord, I'm actually exited about getting back into server hardware again. This would make something like an active display wall possible where you could interact with it on 100's of displays at an event.

The Flex 170 is a bit too expensive for my hobbyist needs, but I would love an A770 I could split into 4 (8 would be amazing).

Genuinely started looking for a flex 140. The second I hear I can make this work on a a770 or flash it with the intel flex Bios. I'm instant going to buy one

we're doing testing with the flex gpus on VxRail currently in the 16G Dells.

i like the subtle soundtrack

Every Intel project I've invested in or bought components for in the past 3+ years was canceled by Intel. From FPGA's to RISCV platforms. I laughed so hard last week when I found out that Altera is now a standalone company again, really Intel? Intel is like the koolaid man that smashes through your walls and shouts "Guess Who's Back!"

@edc1569

4 ай бұрын

Remember that really innovative camera thing they built and then scrapped while everyone in industry was getting their heads around it, realsense.

@vincei4252

4 ай бұрын

@@edc1569 At least they had excuse that there was no killer app back then. I wonder how much the industry shrugs when Intel launches a new product because everyone knows that within a couple years they will take a hammer to it. You can't even escape this in shipping products. I had an order for FPGA's that I'd ordered from mouser. 3 months later I got an email saying all my orders were canceled as Intel is shipping the darn things to the DOD. They weren't even the high end parts.

@vincei4252

4 ай бұрын

@@edc1569 My response was censored by the Google/KZread overlords. I despair this place.

@Pacho18

4 ай бұрын

​@@edc1569lidar?

Sounds good. Now I want a Minisforum MS-01 for the iGPU SRIOV use in a Jellyfin VM.

Man the Gandalf thing is a proper throwback, I remember that meme from the early days haha Nice to see these intel gpu capabilities though, interesting, I'll be keeping an eye on that next time we go through our refresh, see if I can't procure something like this for testing in the meantime

Simple homelab setup here with no accelerated stuff at all. No plans to upgrade just yet but if this works with a standard ARC card or the flex cards are reasonably priced then wow I may have to look into adding this in to my current setup.

@vikingcat794

2 ай бұрын

flex cards are not reasonably priced for consumers.

Ooooo! So exciting!

LOL. Thanks for that intro. Gunna have that Eurovision song in my head for another week. HAHAHA!

HYPE HYPE HYPE HYPE (IM EXCITED)

Had to check my phone post intro, as the epic saxman is my phones ringtone XD

"... we didn't account for this use case..." that brought back some tears in my eyes...

This is super cool technology.

I'm using SR-IOV on my Unraid home server with i5-14500 (UHD 770 iGPU) - it is a plugin (in beta) and it works great so far, I just set how many "VFs" I want (0-7) and I can pass it to any VM. I didn't even need to do anything in CLI, just downloaded a plugin from CA apps - imagine that, using a GUI for things on Linux, half of the Truenas forum would be so mad.

@stuffwhy3501

4 ай бұрын

Which plug in?

@Bayonet1809

4 ай бұрын

Yes, any more info on this you could provide would be helpful.

@pauljones9150

4 ай бұрын

Dude half the comment sections was asking "770 sr-iov when". You gotta spill the sauce

@Level1Techs

4 ай бұрын

If you follow the how to on the forum it works same for minisforum and uhd 770 as shown here. Video on l1 linux soon

@Quettesh

4 ай бұрын

@@pauljones9150 not Arc 770, but UHD 770 - integrated GPU on i5-14500. In CA apps it is called "Intel i915 SR-IOV" from giganode.

If there was a hall of IT Wendel should be in it!

Very cool!

The moment Wendell, is Geeked all the way out! They finally caught-up, Wendell.

Intel coming to save the day. Absurdity at it's finest. We live in weird times.

@ehenningsen

4 ай бұрын

Their gaming GPUs are also the best for price to performance and are much closer to NVIDIA features than AMD. Their new fabs are monsters too. Intel is about to go big again, i think.

@bosstowndynamics5488

4 ай бұрын

Intel have been fairly good about software support for many years, the issue has always been gating hardware, and that's still very much their MO when you look at how much a Flex 170 costs compared to a more or less identical a770 from a raw silicon perspective

Just one of these would solve half my virtual machine needs…pretty nice. Hopefully we get to see it in more affordable (for the consumer) someone.

Thanks Wendel. Do you know how we can get hold of such a card? Have you had the chance to look into the Radeon Pro v620, on paper it says that it is for VDI and cloud gaming but not sure if software is available only to cloud vendors?

Subscription free…………………………for now. I see the strat!

I would love to see a video demonstrating alder lakes igpu SR-IOV capabilities and setup process, maybe a cubesOS like functionality with hardware accelerated vga on the cheap would be possible with this?

It will make a big difference down the road when people upgrade the districts computer systems. Pushing 30 desktops 3D is amazing. I am hoping for a arc will enable this feature in the future on desktops.

Yes but how do we get the Flex 170s? I went to the Supermicro site but it just shows the server and config but no option for Flex 170s? What gives?

I really hope that the market is hot again with 3 competitors instead of just one company monopoly market

I'm intrigued by the accidental 30 virtual functions on A770. Any news on that?

Kudos to Intel on this. I'm solidly red team for compute and red or green team for GPU, but I appreciate anything thing that is performant and cost effective.

Love the Gandalf reference.

But does it do AV1? 😅 Even if it doesn't... If I understand correctly it allows to encode 32*1080p streams or 8*4K streams? The ability to stream to basically all the platforms you'd want to stream (YT, Twitch, FB, TikTok, Vimeo, Twitter, Instagram, DLive, Trovo, Kick, LinkedIn 🤣) AT THE SAME TIME and with DIFFERENT SETTINGS EACH is wild.

@Level1Techs

4 ай бұрын

It was infact first hardware to do av1..in2022. Just unobtanium

@KingLarbear

4 ай бұрын

​@@Level1Techs yikes

Where can I find a flex 170? Or 4 or 8 of them?

I recently set up a new x99 dual cpu homelab server with 2 e5-2699v3 CPUs, running the latest proxmox. This was for my and my son's use for learning and to support home servers. I bought a used Nvidia K80 to try vgpu vdi, but haven't attempted setting it up yet. Would a flex 140 be easier? Also, do you know if the folks at Proxmox are working on adding vgpu support to the base (and the GUI) so admins don't have to kludge together changes in the background that get wiped out after the next set of updates?

Thank you for continued great content. Just a bad prosumer here….but I have made a career in IT just based on videos from the likes of you and Linus, etc. high five 🖐️ from Kansas City!

It is genuinely amazing that the VDI industry has been so ridiculous that $400/seat for just the virtual part (no thin client, no peripherals) is a steal.

does anyone know the cost or some kind of MSRP? hard to really compare without that. Would love to see more VDI tho

Can it be use on Hyper-V with the guest VMs?

Does Intel's GPU partitioning work just with lower performance, with Intel's desktop eg 770 GPUs? My impression is that it doesn't, but I don't recall seeing that mentioned.

17:33 - 😂 Epic Sax Gandalf School - I think it’s a VDI demo 😅

Impressive, people like to hate on intel but I'm really excited about their GPUs for workflows in video and 3D. Go team blue! 🔵

If Citrix qualified this, how will XCP-Ng work?

I am prosumer and I have been looking for a flex 170 on eba recently, but it seems to be to new and unpopular for good deals to appear on ebay.... at least within the EU without crazy import fees

Now thinking much more about the future, with this technology we can access high processing power from anywhere, and going further, we can have our own open source AI.

curious if this can support 3d content creation on vm? with nvidia being dominant in that domain.

I'm really looking forward for the video about SR-IOV with desktop GPUs! Unfortunately Intel Flex is quite out of reach for the projects im working on 😅 There is also the VirGL GPU type in Proxmox which, as I understand it, enables sharing of GPU resources without explicit GPU support. I never got it working with a significant performance increase. Can someone tell me if it even works?

@Pacho18

4 ай бұрын

VirGL only works with linux guests.

@witzbereit

4 ай бұрын

@@Pacho18 wow thanks 😂 that's something I got to myself. I have a test machine with a GPU and Linux guests that use VirGL, but I'm not that deep into how "rendering" works so that I can confirm that it is really using the GPU. Maybe I should also try it again in PVE 8.1.

Can I use the accelerated desktop inside libvirt for kvm?😊

Wait, OpenShift? What are those solutions like? For the end user that is.

Wow, you have been wanting this for awhile. Its Intel.

Where can we buy one of those cards? Are there any plans to sell them to us mortals?

This is great news

lmao, I was _JUST_ about to put ol' Saxophone Gandalf up to keep me company and somehow this is the video I watch

Problem with SR-IOV is that it can't be used alongside Nested Virt. At least bypassing the CPU exact model. And if you don't SR-IOV driver gives error 43. Someone can verify this? Maybe i'm dumb enough or i am just making things wrong.

Epic sax man !

most of the time do not have a clue, but learning...slowly

it'd be really neat if this could ever get back supported to consumer amd cards. could see some nerdy home networks that would love this